116 notes
·
View notes
“Historical Accuracy” in Fantasy
noneexpectations reblogged your post:
Historical accuracy in a fictional setting ������
That particular nonsense happens constantly. Game of Thrones, Lord of the Rings, Disney cartoons, Harry Potter (especially regarding the House Founders), Discworld, from books to video games, you name it, white fans have used that argument to try and silence fans of color who wish for more and better representation.
The concept that ubiquitous whiteness is somehow “historically accurate” when applied to these settings, or that the creators of SFF media are limited to this “accuracy” when it comes to diverse representation (but somehow not when it comes to magic and dragons!) is overwhelmingly present in fandom.
And its also compounded by the idea that this obligation towards “accuracy” absolves creators of having any responsibility to the diversity of their audience is especially infuriating. Racism in SFF will continue to be perpetuated unless we interrupt this cycle, and actively (and enthusiastically!) engage with the media we love…but that sometimes does not seem to love us in return.
MPoC in some ways boils down to “Even if we pretend you have a point, you’re still wrong.” The problem is compounded when people seem to believe that fantasy is history. If I can do anything to try and clarify the issue and show people the tools for informed research, I’m beyond gratified.
513 notes
·
View notes