S6 parallels in s12 again (some thoughts on 12.10)
I had a slightly unnerving thought while I was re-watching 12.10 that I havenât seen anyone talk about. Maybe Iâm just seeing things. Maybe my memory is being terrible again.
Remember how s12 is a parallel to s6?Â
Well... I think I found at least part of the âwall breakâ parallel. The weird part is, I donât think it ends here.
There be super spoilers of 12.10 ahead, so Iâll stick the rest of this long post in the Below Place.
Jeez, this episode is dense *rubs eyes*
So from the Midpoint, we learn that Lilyâs daughter was human and that Ishim used the garrison to enact his twisted jealousy revenge as opposed to carrying out a nephilum kill as Cas was lead to believe it was.
From Lilyâs flashback we also learn the following about Lilyâs relationship with Ishim:
Lily found a way to summon an angel
Lily put the angel (Ishim) on a pedestal and saw him as perfect
But he was really a âmonsterâ
Ishim shared angel magic and secrets with Lily for her own purposes
At some point Ishim betrayed Lilyâs trust and she asked Akibel to protect her
Ishim assigns love as his feeling towards Lily
She assigns obsession
Ishim believes Lily betrayed him with Akibel and kills him
Ishim doesnât kill Lily for her âbetrayalâ but instead kills her daughter to break her heart as he believes she broke his.
Sound familiar?
Dean found a way to summon an angel
Dean put that angel (Cas) on a pedestal
Dean learns Cas is not perfect. Heâs a powerful supernatural being with flaws and ambitions. Heâs also been called âmonsterâ in the show. Specifically by Claire.
Cas teaches Dean and Sam the ways of angels and warding for their purposes
Cas betrays Dean and Samâs loyalty by going behind their back with Crowley
Cas may have felt he was feeling love or maybe not. Itâs hard to tell back then but it may have been more akin to obsession with Dean. Thatâs kind of whatâs implied here, anyway.
Cas believes Dean betrayed him by not helping him with Raphael
Their confrontation even kind of looks like and sounds like some of the confrontations Dean and Cas had in s6.
Cas doesnât kill Dean and Sam for their betrayal, but he does break Samâs(closest thing weâve got to Deanâs kid) wall to break Dean and slow their progress.
So in this, I have a few thoughts:
Who is Akibel represented as and will his mirror play some part later? Was he just an illustration of a âso called betrayalâ that was easy to produce on screen and didnât require much buildup? Probably.
Why this specific mirror? I think theyâre trying to highlight the difference between past Cas and current Cas. âWhen did you become so gooey?â Ishim throws around a lot of words that imply Cas used to be more like him throughout the episode. It also further highlights that Cas has always been a bit different. He didnât kill Sam, he did something terrible to him, but he didnât kill him. This whole bit also highlights the relationship between Cas and Dean and Cas and Sam being different, especially back then. He specifically targeted Sam to get to Dean and not the other way around.
Lily losing her soul also draws attention to that arc in season 6. Whether it was intended as a setup, a mirror for Sam or just as a reminder to the arc, Iâm not completely sure.Â
A lot of this episode is about Casâ decisions and how he makes them as well as how Dean reacts to them as opposed to how he used to. At the end of the episode they both sort of learn a lesson. A lesson theyâve kind of learned before but is drawn attention to here. At the beginning of the episode and also in S6, Cas believes that some sacrifices must be made for the greater good. At the end of the episode, he says that some of his decisions need questioning and highlights this at the BM scene by saying that before, he wouldât have hesitated to kill Kelly, but now instead decides to drink and try and find a better way. Iâm guessing his decision to kill Billy is gonna be a pretty hefty weight but I donât think it will lead to Casâ death. A lot of this show is about literally flipping the script, so no walking into a pool of death this time, I hope. Dean learns to use his words more, something that was harder for him to do before considering the circumstances.
Main characters who change for the better tend to live in shows because the opposite speaks ill of the audience unless itâs the last episode(depending on setup). âYou know all that effort you put into becoming a better person? Whelp, it killed youâ Yeah, that doesnât usually fly in TV shows unless it was setup all along(Which it hasnât been in SPN since S7). Movies can get away with it, but it requires a specific setup and usually involves a character that was perceived as a villain. Itâs called âredemption equals deathâ and I hate it. Itâs generally used when a characterâs purpose in the story was to be an antagonist, so when theyâre redeemed, the story has no where for them to go, so they die. Cas is not framed this way. Cas is framed as one of the heroes even if he doesnât always act like one. Itâs the nature of heroes to be hypocritical anyway. Dean and Sam donât exactly have a stellar track record but we follow them around and cheer them on anyway. Because they are literally our humanity surrogates. This is also why if they end the show in death for TFW, I may hate them a little. As Iâve said before: âSPN, you are allowed to be sad, you are not allowed to be pointless.â
A couple of other things:
Casâ 1901 vessel said that ânephilim grow into their powersâ and was followed up with âworlds dieâ Uh... on what other worlds are their nephilim? New headcanon: All other habitable worlds in the universe are basically just tests for Earth or were created afterward as wherever Chuck goes to. This would at least kind of explain why the universe gives so much of a shit about what people on a tiny spec do.
Ishim says to Cas that heâs gonna cut out his humanity the same way he cut out his by killing Dean. Which sounds awesome if youâre a destiel shipper like me, but then I realized that Ishim didnât kill Lily. He killed her daughter and Akibel. How was he cutting out his humanity? Did he have a connection to May? Wouldnât that make Sam his humanity if we wanna be all mirrory? I must be missing something.Â
With this in an episode like this, it makes me wonder how theyâll bring back the rest of the âBreaks Samâs wallâ bit. What will happen in Samâs head? What will be Samâs head? In s6, his headspace is a deciduous forest as it usually is. Kind of like Purgatory really. What will Sam have to accept? What will be our metaphor for hell this time? What will be broken?
29 notes
¡
View notes