MHA Chapter 423 spoilers translations
This week’s initial tentative super rough/literal translations under the cut.
tagline 1
ねじ込んだ一撃ーー‼︎
ねじこんだいちげきーー‼︎
nejikonda ichigeki--!!
A single, exacting blow--!!
tagline 2
No.423 OFA vs AFO 堀越耕平
ナンバー423 ワン・フォー・オールバーサスオール・フォー・ワン ほりこしこうへい
NANBAA 423 WAN FOO OORU vs OORU FOO WAN Horikoshi Kouhei
No. 423 One for All vs All for One Kouhei Horikoshi
1
何故気付けなかった
なぜきづけなかった
naze kidzukenakatta
Why didn't I notice?
2
この窶れた"身体"に「超再生」が適用されない違和感
このやつれた"からだ"に「ちょうさいせい」がてきようされないいわかん
kono yatsureta "karada" ni 「chousaisei」 ga tekiyou sarenai iwakan
[This] sense of discomfort that Super Regeneration no longer applies to this worn-out body.
3
こいつだ…いやーーー
koitsu da...iya---
It's this guy...no---
4
こいつらがーー‼︎
koitsura ga--!!
All of these [people]--!!
5
謀ったのだ
はかったのだ
hakatta no da
They conspired.
1
それ単体では
それたんたいでは
sore tantai de wa
By itself
2
あまりに脆弱な"敵意"
あまりにぜいじゃくな"てきい"
amari ni zeijaku na "tekii"
[each one's] enmity was too frail,
3
しかし撚り集まって
しかしよりあつまって
shikashi yori atsumatte
but when they gathered together,
4
いつしか僕を覆い感受を鈍らせていたのだ
いつしかぼくをおおいかんじゅをにぶらせていたのだ
itsu shika boku wo ooi kanju wo niburasete ita no da
before I knew it, they enshrouded me and dulled my sensitivity.
(Note: He means his ability to sense one person via Danger Sense became dulled because there were too many people with enmity gathered together in one place.)
5
与一と継承者どもを打ち込まれたあの時にもう精神のみならず
よいちとけいしょうしゃどもをうちこまれたあのときにもうせいしんのみならず
Yoichi to keishousha-domo wo uchikomareta ano toki ni mou seishin no minarazu
Yoichi and all the successors were cast [into me]. At that time, not only my spirit but
6
身体も…‼︎
からだも…‼︎
karada mo...!!
my body, too...!!
7
生半可な"身体"では
なまはんかな"からだ"では
namahanka na "karada" de wa
(literal) A half-baked body
(official) Your limp-noodle body isn't ready for it.
8
受け取り切れず四肢が爆散してしまうんだ!
うけとりきれずししがばくさんしてしまうんだ!
uketori kirezu shishi ga bakusan shite shimaunda!
(literal) can't receive it. Your limbs would explode!
(official) Your limbs would pop right off!!
(Note: This frame is from chapter 2.)
9
たった2年…!8代目より少し上乗せされた…
たった2ねん…!8だいめよりすこしうわのせされた…
tatta 2nen...! 8daime yori sukoshi uwanosesareta...
"Only 2 years...! I only added a little more to [what it was with] 8th..."
(Note: He means he only added 2 years' worth of power to OFA, a tiny amount after what it was when All Might passed it off.)
10
9人分の力の結晶だ
9にんぶんのちからのけっしょうだ
9ninbun no chikara no kesshou da
"It's the crystallization of power in proportion to nine people."
1
既に"身体"も
すでに"からだ"も
sude ni karada mo
This body also has already
2
砕かれていた事に
くだかれていたことに
kudakarete ita koto ni
been broken, unfortunately.
3
"個性"が崩れてく…
"こせい"がくずれてく…
"kosei" ga kuzureteku...
"His quirks are crumbling..."
(Note: This is a word often used to describe the effects of Tomura's Decay.)
4
やったのか緑谷…!
やったのかみどりや…!
yatta no ka Midoriya...!
"Did you do it, Midoriya...!"
1
まだだ‼︎
mada da!!
Not yet!!
2
"個性"で無理矢理
"こせい"でむりやり
"kosei" de muriyari
With his quirks, he forcibly
3
つなぎ止めた!
つなぎとめた!
tsunagitometa!
tied himself together!
(Note: This word also means "to save someone's life." In this case AFO is forcibly preserving his own life by using his quirks to keep himself from falling apart.)
4
まだ何も為していない
まだなにもなしていない
mada nani mo nashite inai
"I haven't achieved anything yet."
5
誰にも奪わせはしない…‼︎
だれにもうばわせはしない…‼︎
dare ni mo ubawase wa shinai...!!
"I won't let anyone steal it away...!!"
6
僕だけが夢を為す
ぼくだけがゆめをなす
boku dake ga yume wo nasu
"Only I will achieve my dream."
7
誰にも…!継がぬ…紡がぬ‼︎
だれにも…!つがぬ…つむがぬ‼︎
dare ni mo...! tsuganu...tsumuganu!!
"No one...! [They] won't inherit it... [They] won't spin the tale*!!"
(*Note: The word used here means "to spin (thread), to make up a story, to assemble, to put together.")
8
魔王は常に唯一‼︎
まおうはつねにゆいいつ‼︎
maou wa tsune ni yuiitsu!!
"The Demon King is always the only one!!"
9
そうだとも繰り返せばいい…
そうだともくりかえせばいい…
sou da tomo kurikaeseba ii...
Even if that's true, I can just do it over again...
10
愚かな弔にそうしたように‼︎
おろかなとむらにそうしたように‼︎
oroka na Tomura ni sou shita you ni!!
Just like how I did to foolish Tomura!!
11
OFA無��今緑谷でも…!誰でも‼︎
ワン・フォー・オールなきいまみどりやでも…!だれでも‼︎
WAN FOO OORU naki ima Midoriya demo...! dare demo!!
Even Midoriya, now that he doesn't have One For All...! Anyone!!
12
"個性"を「与え」奪えばいい‼︎
"ぼく自身"を「あたえ」うばえばいい‼︎
"boku jishin (kanji: kosei)" wo 「atae」 ubaeba ii!!
I can give and take away "myself" (read as: my quirk)!!
1
器を!!!
うつわを!!!
utsuwa wo!!!
"[I'll make] a vessel!!!"
2
もうやめろAFO
もうやめろオール・フォー・ワン
mou yamero OORU FOO WAN
"Give it a rest, All For One."
3
緑谷‼︎
みどりや‼︎
Midoriya!!
"Midoriya!!"
4
白雲…⁉︎
しらくも…⁉︎
Shirakumo...!?
"Shirakumo...!?"
5
消…太
しょう…た
Shou...ta
"Shou...ta"
6
山…田…
やま…だ…
Yama...da...
"Yama...da..."
7
ゴメン…ナ……
GOMEN...NA......
"I'm...sorry......"
8
行かなくては…私はーーーーー
いかなくては…わたしはーーーーー
ikanakute wa...watashi wa-----
Have to go...I-----
1
死柄木弔を守らなくては
しがらきとむらをまもらなくては
Shigaraki Tomura wo mamoranakute wa
I have to protect Tomura Shigaraki
2
Xあ‼︎X生‼︎
Xあ‼︎Xしょう‼︎
XA!! Xshou!!
(Note: This speech bubble is partially cut off.)
3
やっぱり…‼︎どこまでも…
yappari...!! doko made mo...
"As expected...!! No matter what..."
4
手ぇ差し伸べちまうんだよあいつは‼︎
てぇさしのべちまうんだよあいつは‼︎
tee sashinobechimaunda yo aitsu wa!!
"he's that guy who'll hold out his hand [for someone]!!"
5
A…FO…
オール…フォー・ワン…
OORU...FOO WAN...
"All...For One..."
6
死柄…木弔を…オ返シ…下サイ
しがら…きとむらを…オかえシ…くだサイ
Shigara...ki Tomura wo...OkaSHI...kudaSAI
"Tomura Shigara...ki...Please give...him back."
7
オッおォッ
OoO
"Ooo"
1
オ友達が待っテイルんデす
オともだちがまっテイルんデす
Otomodachi ga matTE IRUnDEsu
"His friends are waiting."
1
爆豪⁉︎
ばくごう⁉︎
Bakugou!?
"Bakugou!?"
2
病院にって…‼︎うっそだろあいつ!
びょういんにって…‼︎うっそだろあいつ!
byouin ni tte...!! usso daro aitsu!
"They said [you were heading to] the hospital...!! That guy's unbelievable!"
3
「爆破」で一人で来やがった‼︎
「ばくは」でひとりできやがった‼︎
「bakuha」 de hitori de kiyagatta!!
"He went and came over alone using Explosion!!"
4
轟の"ジャンプ台"貸りたけどよォ〜〜〜〜〜
とどろきの"ジャンプだい"かりたけどよォ〜〜〜〜〜
Todoroki no "JANPU dai" karita kedo yoO~~~~~
"I borrowed Todoroki's jump platform, but~~~~~"
5
俺に追い越されてンなよ出久‼︎
おれにおいこされてンなよいずく‼︎
ore ni oikosareteN na yo Izuku!!
"don't let me overtake you, Izuku!!"
6
AFO…‼︎おまえを許しはしない
オール・フォー・ワン…‼︎おまえをゆるしはしない
OORU FOO WAN...!! omae wo yurushi wa shinai
"All For One...!! I won't forgive you."
1
けれど理解できない化物だとも思わない
けれどりかいできないばけものだともおもわない
keredo rikai dekinai bakemono da to mo omowanai
"But I don't think you're an incomprehensible monster."
2
…やめろ
...yamero
"...Stop."
3
おまえは魔王なんかじゃない
おまえはまおうなんかじゃない
omae wa maou nanka ja nai
"You are not actually a Demon King."
4
見るな
みるな
miruna
"Don't look [at me]."
5
おまえはただの
omae wa tada no
"You're just"
6
寂しがりな人間だ‼︎
さみしがりなにんげんだ‼︎
samishigari na ningen da!!
"a lonely person!!"
1
与一…⁉︎
よいち…⁉︎
Yoichi...!?
"Yoichi...!?"
2
緑谷くんは
みどりやくんは
Midoriya-kun wa
"Midoriya-kun"
3
限り限りのラインでカケラが残るよう
ぎりぎりのラインでカケラがのこるよう
girigiri no RAIN de KAKERA ga nokoru you
"seems to have a fragment remain for as long as possible."
4
ぶつける力を調整したんだね……
ぶつけるちからをちょうせいしたんだね……
butsukeru chikara wo chousei shitanda ne......
"I guess he adjusted the force of his hit......"
5
そして 残り火による"感応"で叩き起こしたんだ
そして のこりびによる"かんのう"でたたきおこしたんだ
soshite nokoribi ni yoru "kannou" de tataki okoshitanda
Then, I was roused awake in response to his embers.
6
僅かな残滓となった僕を
わずかなざんしとなったぼくを
wazuka na zanshi to natta boku wo
I, who became mere dregs,
7
ワン・フォー・オールを
WAN FOO OORU wo
One For All.
8
正しく完遂させる為に
ただしくかんすいさせるために
tadashiku kansui saseru tame ni
In order to properly follow [things] through.
(Note: The order of the lines here makes this confusing. He's saying that, in response to Izuku's final attack with his embers, the barest dregs of Yoichi's vestige was roused. This one last piece of his vestige remained likely because Izuku held back on his attack using Yoichi's vestige. Now that he, the base One For All quirk, has awoken, he will carry out the mission of One For All.)
9
どうでもいい‼︎
dou demo ii!!
"I don't care!!"
10
どうでもいい‼︎
dou demo ii!!
"I don't care!!"
11
消えるな‼︎顔を見せろ!
きえるな‼︎かおをみせろ!
kieruna!! kao wo misero!
"Don't disappear!! Show your face!"
12
無理だよ
むりだよ
muri da yo
"That's impossible."
13
消える
きえる
kieru
"I'll disappear."
14
駄目だ
だめだ
dame da
"You can't!"
15
僕のモノだ‼︎僕を見ていろ‼︎目を見せろ‼︎
ぼくのモノだ‼︎ぼくをみていろ‼︎めをみせろ‼︎
boku no MONO da!! boku wo mite iro!! me wo misero!!
"You're mine!! Look at me!! Show [me] your eyes!!"
16
兄さん
にいさん
niisan
"[Older] Brother,"
17
貴方を導けなかった
あなたをみちびけなかった
anata wo michibikenakatta
"I couldn't guide you."
18
これは緑谷くんが見出してくれた
これはみどりやくんがみいだしてくれた
kore wa Midoriya-kun ga miidashite kureta
"Midoriya-kun discovered this for me."
19
僕らへの最期の救済だ
ぼくらへのさいごのきゅうさいだ
bokura e no saigo no kyuusai da
"It's our final* salvation."
(*Note: The word used for "final" here means "one's last moment at their time of death.")
1
駄目だ‼︎許可しない‼︎大好きだ!
だめだ‼︎きょかしない‼︎だいすきだ!
dame da!! kyoka shinai!! daisuki da!
"You can't!! I won't allow it!! I love you!"
2
大好きなんだ!!!おまえがいないと僕は駄目なんだ!!!
だいすきなんだ!!!おまえがいないとぼくはだめなんだ!!!
daisuki nanda!!! omae ga inai to boku wa dame nanda!!!
"I love you!!! If you're gone I have no purpose*!!!"
(*Note: The word used here, dame, means many things depending on context. It means "bad, no good, useless, broken, hopeless, wasted, in vain, purposeless.")
3
そうやって
sou yatte
"In that way,"
4
全てを己が為に利用してきた代償を払う時だ
すべてをおのがためにりようしてきたツケをはらうときだ
subete wo ono ga tame ni riyou shite kita TSUKE (kanji: daishou) wo harau toki da
"it's time to pay reparations for taking advantage of everything for your own sake."
5-6
彼が起こしたのは僕だけじゃない
かれがおこしたのはぼくだけじゃない
kare ga okoshita no wa boku dake ja nai
"I was not the only one he awoke."
1
先生に喰われて消滅したと思ったんだけどな…
せんせいにくわれてしょうめつしたとおもったんだけどな…
sensei ni kuwarete shoumetsu shita to omottanda kedo na...
I thought I had been devoured by Master and disappeared, but...
2
あんたが俺を
あんたがおれを
anta ga ore wo
were you
3
消えないように繋ぎ止めてたのか
きえないようにつなぎとめてたのか
kienai you ni tsunagi tometeta no ka
tying* me down so I wouldn't disappear?
(*Note: Again, this word also means "to save someone's life.")
4
おばあちゃん
obaachan
Grandma,
5
黒霧……………
くろぎり……………
Kurogiri...............
Kurogiri...............
6
先生から身体を奪い返しただけで
せんせいからからだをうばいかえしただけで
sensei kara karada wo ubai kaeshita dake de
I only stole my body back from Master, and
7
何も壊せやしなかった
なにもこわせやしなかった
nani mo kowase ya shinakatta
I didn't destroy anything.
8
結局俺はおまえの言った通り…泣いてるガキだったって事か
けっきょくおれはおまえのいったとおり…ないてるガキだったってことか
kekkyoku ore wa omae no itta toori...naiteru GAKI datta tte koto ka
"In the end, I was just as you said... A crying kid, huh?"
9
この手をX壊せなかったX
このてをXこわせなかったX
kono te wo X kowasenakatta X
"This hand X couldn't break X"."
(Note: Some of this speech bubble is cut off. It could say something like "I couldn't break these hands of yours.")
10
…やった事を許せはしないだから戦った
…やったことをゆるせはしないだからたたかった
...yatta koto wo yuruse wa shinai da kara tatakatta
"...I can't forgive the things you've done; that's why I fought."
1
止めたかったし…止まってほしかったんだ
とめたかったし…とまってほしかったんだ
tometakatta shi...tomatte hoshikattanda
"I wanted to stop [you]... I wanted [you] to stop,"
2
悲しみが紡がれないように
かなしみがつむがれないように
kanashimi ga tsumugarenai you ni
"so that the sadness wouldn't [keep] spin[ning]*."
(*Note: This is back to that word that means "to spin yarn, to spin tales, etc." Izuku is saying he didn't want the sadness to beget more sadness. He wants the chain of sadness to stop.)
3
ハッ
HA
"Ha."
(Note: This is an exhalation that could mean any number of things, like shock, laughter, realization, etc.)
4
緑谷出久
みどりやいずく
Midoriya Izuku
"Izuku Midoriya,"
5
スピナーが生きてたら伝えてくれよ
スピナーがいきてたらつたえてくれよ
SUPINAA ga ikitetara tsutaete kure yo
"if Spinner is alive, please tell him [something]."
6
"死柄木弔"は最期まで壊す為に戦ったって
"しがらきとむら"はさいごまでこわすためにたたかったって
"Shigaraki Tomura" wa saigo made kowasu tame ni tatakatta tte
"Tomura Shigaraki fought until the very end* in order to destroy."
(*Note: Again, this is that "finale" word that means "one's last moment at their time of death.")
7
もう…壊したよ
もう…こわしたよ
mou...kowashita yo
"You already...destroyed [it]."
tagline
決着‼︎永きにわたる因縁が晴れ上がるーー‼︎
けっちゃく‼︎ながきにわたるいんねんがはれあがるーー‼︎
kecchaku!! nagaki ni wataru innen ga hareagaru--!!
Settled!! The chain of cause and effect that spans a long time is cleared up--!!
304 notes
·
View notes
What do u think Kiran is
How do u think the order sees kiran
*slowly sits up in my chair*
I think Kiran is a very normal person. This is someone you and I have met before. Be that from the other side of grocery store cashier, waiting in the same elevator, or walking by on a crosswalk. Kiran is a civilian from our world trying to roll with the punches of being warped somewhere completely alien. And you can see it in how they conduct themselves.
I always have a lot of fun writing Kiran’s dialogue because their casual modern speech almost feels like a dialect in comparison to the more formal fantasy tone everyone else speaks with. An “ain’t” will never exit Alfonse’s mouth, you know? And there’s a difference in “Do you have gold?” vs “You got gold?” To me, this gives Kiran an air of unfamiliarity to anyone they interact with. Let’s use Grima as an example, because it doesn’t sound like this grammatical change would make much of difference until Kiran has the audacity to hit Grima with a bro mid sentence. But that’s just how they talk. And as sweet and friendly as they are, there’s always moments like that to remind that no one has the cultural context to fully understand Kiran. Except for the audience, who can realize that Kiran let the customer service voice drop to talk to Grima like he’s an actual person.
And that’s just about how they talk! This view is only emphasized by every other thing about them! They’re a lovable goof, which is normal chill person behavior in the audience’s eyes but feels REALLY ODD to the characters of FE’s medieval fantasy war setting. There is this air of unknown about them that the more socially perceptive will pick up on and will try to come to a conclusion about. Example, I imagine Soren would interpret a lot of this as a dangerous and deeply annoying lack of intelligence from someone he has the displeasure of sharing a tactics table with. Or looping back to the Grima example, he would totally think Kiran has greedy ulterior motives behind that pleasant facade. It takes a lot of work for those types to realize that the discrepancy present isn’t really any of those things. But I also wouldn’t be too surprised if Kiran doesn’t try to directly prove any of those assumptions wrong unless they have to.
Why? Well now it’s time for the implications! Oh how we love the implications.
Because the Summoner is a different story. No one has any fucking clue what that is.
I can tell you what Kiran has pieced together so far. Summoning people from across time and space is apparently not easy. It’s not some school of magical study that some mage could pull off with enough time and research. Trust, Eitri tried. It’s a lot of complex moving parts. For example, the contracts. The contracts Kiran automatically binds their summoned to don’t even compare to the ones Veronica used in book 1. They are far more intense and infinitely harder to break. The only way out of them is if Kiran wills it so. Not even death is an option, because Kiran can come in for the revive. If they had to guess, it’s an older, more completed version of the art. Something lost to time. But no matter the case, Kiran has the ability to take full control of whoever they manage to summon. From a lowly farmer to the divine. And their power only grows.
In a similar vein, if there was any character to canonically see the hud, I think it would be Kiran. It’s genuinely part of their power set. I have previously described Kiran as the party mage until Veronica shows up to be the actual mage, but it would be way more accurate to call them a mystic/seer. They see the map, everyone’s stats, and is doing a fast amount of math to give the combat forecast. Then, upon processing all this information their enemies couldn’t dream of having at their disposal, Kiran can telepathically communicate any change in plans to anyone under contract. Kiran is not inherently some great tactician the moment they touch ground in Askr; they simply can do things no one else can. They’re learning the actual tactics part on the fly. This makes them simultaneously the largest ace up the Order’s sleeve and potentially its biggest liability. If they fall, it could cause a whole system cascade. By that same token, some of the biggest threats the Order has faced are the ones who do their research and rightfully target Kiran.
Now. Thinking critically about all that. That’s downright terrifying. A ridiculous amount of power has been dropped callously into Kiran’s lap and they have to work extremely hard to be moral with it. It’s terrifyingly easy not to be. It would actively take less effort to ‘take the reins’ as it were. But in order to be able to sleep at night ever again, they go the extra mile to not invalidate the will of their summoned. To take over like that. To make a colony of worker bees out of people. Because oh dear god they just summoned a child and the fact that they could easily force them to fight and die for them, only to be revived and do it all over again, is HAUNTING. No. No the Order has an in house orphanage now. This kid is getting adopted and cared for god damnit or Kiran might just pop a blood vessel. And sure that child is going to be a child and there will never be a world where they get along with everyone else, but that’s just going to need be a problem they address when they get there and not an excuse to use Hubris; the power set. Now replace the word child with everyone they ever summoned and you have the wider philosophy they apply to the entire Order.
They’re hyper aware of the power imbalance. They hate it with every bone in their body. They work really hard to correct it in whatever way they can.
So Kiran might not jump on the opportunity to correct those who think lesser of them. It’s… oddly comforting to know someone is keeping a critical eye on them. Holding them accountable. Especially since so much of the order just thinks of them as this quirky yet well meaning host. And, really, what can they even do about that? They have gone over the contract with every hero they summon and despite that they still choose to stay. So, what, do they try to inspire more mistrust? The problem with that they would have to actually do acts that intentionally inspire mistrust. And even if that was successful they can’t just waste the extra man power because every other month there’s some new divine asshole who wants them all dead. And if they fail that means they have to start their life from square one and god they can’t do that again so—
Just breathe Kiran.
It’s fine. You’re fine. Just breathe.
You have work to do.
71 notes
·
View notes
It's really disheartening that Rick Riordan stance on the war I understand that he wants to be neutral on this stance but in my opinion by becoming neutral he only worsening the issue as many Palestines are dying that are mostly children, how the majority of Israeli are supporting the Genocide of Palestine, and how the government is trying so hard (but miserably failing) to justified the genocide. I will hold him accountable for what he said on this issue as during this period the choice is basically "you are with us or against us."
Part of me wishes he will realize what he said was wrong and understand the bigger issue that plays at hand. I will criticism for his actions as how can a man who promotes LGBTQIA and representation of minorities and disabilities in his books turn a blind eyes to Genocide of people. However we can only wait and see on his next move.
One last thing about your previous you said you don't group Riordan with other authors where do you would group him with? Also this is more on an opinion base answer but many people are boycotting companies that support Israel there as been another post on Twitter on boycotting authors. Rick Riordan happens to be one of them. Do you believed that he should be boycotted with other authors or he should be properly educated and apologized for his previous statement? If you believed he should be boycotted what do tou have to say to those who might have the mentality of "separate the art from the artist"
thank you for this ask, and i completely agree with you! it is extremely hypocritical of him considering what he preaches for in his books. i think he’s convinced he has properly addressed the apartheid by using very vague language that can be applied to anything, and in doing so, he’s addressed nothing really.
your first question on who i would group him with— probably other authors who are doing the exact same as him in their virtue signalling. i always like to link my other blogs to each other, so i don’t think it’s a secret that i have a red queen account and i’m pretty passionate about that. unfortunately, victoria aveyard is another fantasy author who has literally wrote a whole four-book series on the uprising against oppression but is now playing neutral in her address of the apartheid. rebecca yarros is in the same boat, although i haven’t read ‘fourth wing,’ fans have said there are large themes of oppression within the book. so if i had to group riordan it would probably be in the ‘i-like-to-write-about-it-for-profit-and-praise-only’ group.
in terms of boycotting, i think that’s a great idea! i would also like to remind everyone that the percy jackson tv show is coming out in a little over a month, but disney is a huge industry financially supporting israel as well ($2 million in funding), which is obviously far more damning than a poorly written address by one person. there is a boycott happening for disney as well— and the pjo show will be released on disney + . i implore everyone to not watch it on that platform!! personally i will be pirating it online (idk if i’ll get into trouble saying that here but lol oh well), because im pretty sure the boycott is only for withdrawing financial support, not simply consuming media.
i feel like separating art from the artist only works if that artist is… like, dead, and you’re using that art and its values as a historical insight to how the world was during its time. you can still like a piece of work that has a problematic artist, you can engage with the work (to an extent). but separating art from the artist barely works because either:
to engage with the art is to support the artist in some way, so that artist is making money based on your interaction with that (particularly in the case for singers and streaming of songs)
that artists’ views and values are so rancid that it’s literally embedded within the text itself. to ignore it is harmful.
harry potter is my all-time favourite example to use, because jkr is the scum of the earth, and her views are entrenched in her work. a lesser known example is sarah j maas and her books (she’s also not as dogshit as jkr, but then again, its not hard to be a better person than her). i’m not going to bag on these people for liking things by problematic people (would be hypocritical of me), i just think it’s cowardly not to address it when you come across it, or at least admit to it. to simply write things off as ‘separate to the artist’ is like purposefully turning off your critical thinking skills.
on whether boycotting or an apology is enough— if riordan did apologise and used specific language and not the nonsense he had in that blog, expressed his remorse for his ignorance and then actually did or said something to support the people of palestine then, yeah. that’s fine and that’s how we learn ig. but he should educate himself, too many activists, people from the arab community and especially palestinians are expected to be all-knowing and to educate everyone else on an already draining and personal tragedy. it’s been exhausting for me, i can’t imagine what they’re going through. if riordan (or anyone) needs to be educated, he should do it himself, and (at least in my opinion) i don’t think the info is very hard to find now. it’s just about weeding out the misinformation.
i think boycotting is a good idea as of now. it can serve to be a catalyst for self reflection for many people. also, as much as i hate most online discourses, talking about it online needs to happen. i don’t want these authors to forget, for a moment, about the ignorance they posted online during a time of international crisis.
190 notes
·
View notes