bensonfiles

[bensonfiles]

JEMILY x YOU MASTERLIST

SWEET SURRENDER

PREMISE: JJ and Emily have been gently falling in love with you for a while and when they find out you’ve never been with anyone before, they take their time showing you what it means to be touched, loved, and cherished. It’s soft, overwhelming, and full of praise. Just pure, beautiful first-time sex — the kind that ruins you for anyone else.

[bensonfiles]

OLIVIA BENSON MASTERLIST

TASTE OF APOLOGY

PREMISE: An argument between you and Olivia finally cracks open everything you’ve both been too afraid to say. The fight turns physical, then filthy, as anger melts into desperate, possessive sex across the apartment — where bruises, sweat, and breathless apologies tangle together in the aftermath.

WARDROBE THEFT

PREMISE: Olivia comes home after a long day to find you wearing her old academy shirt, and the simple sight of you wrapped in her clothes reminds her just how much you belong — sparking a quiet, tender moment of possessive love and cozy domestic warmth.

[bensonfiles]

EMILY PRENTISS MASTERLIST || pornstar au

AVN AWARDS

PREMISE: You both win at the AVN Awards — you for Best New Performer, Emily for Lifetime Achievement. Emily corners you in the women’s bathroom between speeches, still in her floor-length silk dress, one hand around your throat, the other under your dress, teasing your pussy while whispering how she’s wanted to ruin you since your first scene went viral.

[bensonfiles]

RITA CALHOUN MASTERLIST

THE SPARE ROOM

PREMISE: You’re renting a spare room from Rita Calhoun, a sharp, confident woman who’s as intimidating as she is irresistible. When mock trial week forces you to prepare together, distractions quickly turn into something much more charged — and complicated. With unspoken tension simmering beneath every glance and touch, the lines between mentorship and desire blur in ways neither of you expect.

[bensonfiles]

AARON HOTCHNER MASTERLIST || pornstar au

RAW FOOTAGE

PREMISE: When you land an audition for one of the industry’s top adult films, you know exactly who you’re hoping to impress: Aaron Hotchner — porn legend, known to everyone else as “Hotch.” But when the lights go up and the director gives the nod, it’s not just an audition anymore. You take control, tease the untouchable star, and turn a routine scene into something no one on set will forget.

LIVE STREAM

PREMISE: You’re doing a live-streamed cam session for fans. Aaron surprises the audience by joining. You try to maintain composure as he takes control slowly, his hand between your thighs as he murmurs, “Let them watch what’s mine.”

DATE NIGHT

PREMISE: Aaron finally asks you out on a proper date — no cameras, no sets, just the two of you. Dinner’s good, conversation’s better, but neither of you makes it back to your place. You end up in the backseat of his sleek black car, your panties shoved to the side, his hand around your throat, and his cock buried deep while the windows fog up around you.

[bensonfiles]

EMILY PRENTISS MASTERLIST

HANDLING EMILY

PREMISE: You’ve always teased Emily Prentiss about being older. About how you could handle a woman like her—experienced, commanding, devastating. But when she finally calls your bluff and takes you home, you learn exactly what it means to be at her mercy.

JEALOUS HEAT

PREMISE: She wanted your attention—so she let someone else flirt with her. Smiled too wide. Laughed too loud. She knew exactly what she was doing. Now she’s face-down on the couch, dress bunched at her waist, your cock buried deep as you fuck the jealousy out of your system—and the smugness out of her voice.

DIRTY MOUTHS, SOFT HANDS

PREMISE: Emily fucks you stupid on her couch, makes you clean up your mess, eats you out like it’s the last thing she’ll ever do, and then scrubs you clean in the shower with sleepy kisses and giggles before curling up in bed like the world’s softest menace.

HER PLUG, HER PLAYTHING, HER PRIZE

PREMISE: "Your job is to be available. I’ll take care of the rest." You wear a plug and a vibrator to one of her fundraisers, discreetly controlled from her phone. When you get home, she doesn’t even let you speak before bending you over the kitchen counter and finishing what she started in public.

FIRE AND ICE

PREMISE: What started as a teasing dare between you and Emily in the soft glow of her townhouse turned into one of the most intimate, filthy nights you’d ever shared. Curled up together with old records playing and cheap wine loosening your tongue, you challenged Emily’s predictable dominance in bed, baiting her with a smug little grin and the accusation that she wouldn’t know what to do if you asked for something different. Emily, every inch the silver-haired, sharp-eyed, effortlessly in-control woman she was, accepted without hesitation, demanding you tell her what you wanted.

DRAWN TO YOU

PREMISE: You, a younger artist, surprise your older girlfriend Emily Prentiss with a secret portrait you’ve spent weeks creating, capturing her as you truly see her — tender, strong, and completely loved. The vulnerability in that moment leads to a deep, intimate confession of feelings between you both. The emotional high turns physical, with Emily taking you to bed.

[bensonfiles]

CASEY NOVAK MASTERLIST

A NIGHT AT CASEY'S

PREMISE: You always crash at Casey’s place after nights out — but this time, drunk and giggly, you accidentally walk in on her jerking off in her bedroom. Instead of leaving, you close the door behind you, lean against it, and ask, “Why didn’t you ever tell me you were packing that?” The look she gives you changes everything.

FORGIVE ME, FATHER

PREMISE: You took a vow of purity. A sacred life, untouched, unsullied — until Casey Novak walked into your church at midnight and made the altar her bed. She taunts your restraint with every look, every touch, and when you break, you break hard — bent over scripture, moaning her name, tasting sin like it’s salvation.

FILTHY TEXTS

PREMISE: You spend your afternoon sending Casey Novak filthy photos and videos of your aching cock while she’s trapped in court, slowly unravelling her composure. By the time she gets home, you’re already a desperate mess — and she’s about to ruin you for it.

DESK DUTY

PREMISE: Casey Novak works late. You show up in leather, cocky and soaked in road heat, just to distract her like the menace of a girlfriend you are.

LEAVE YOUR MARKS

PREMISE: You never expected a simple afternoon with Casey to leave you aching in ways you’d crave again and again. Between teasing glances, stolen touches, and the kind of warmth only she can give, you find yourself tangled in her orbit — marked, claimed, and cared for. It’s rough in all the ways you need, and soft where it counts.

BABY FEVER

PREMISE: You and Casey are lying in bed after dinner, half-watching a documentary about childbirth — and you can’t stop stealing glances at her. When Casey catches you staring, she smirks knowingly. “You’ve got that look again,” she teases, one hand lazily cupping your thigh. You admit you can’t stop thinking about it — about what it would feel like to be full of her, to be carrying her baby.

[bensonfiles]

MASTERLISTS

❝ criminal minds masterlist ❞ ❝ svu masterlist ❞ ❝ jemily masterlist ❞

[bensonfiles]

ALEX CABOT MASTERLIST

PRECISION IN HEELS

PREMISE: You’re just trying to drop off the new kitchen plans and get the hell out. Alex Cabot, your most infuriatingly high-maintenance client, has other ideas — ones that end with you fucking her senseless on her marble countertop.

CRY FOR ME

PREMISE: You’re Alex Cabot’s favourite brat — all sass, defiance, and filthy mouth. In the privacy of your bedroom, she reminds you exactly who’s in charge. Lace panties, stinging handprints, and breathless begging turn into relentless edging, spitplay, and tear-streaked orgasms until you finally give in for her.

MISMATCHED SOCKS

PREMISE: A quiet evening takes a chaotic turn when dinner doesn't go as planned, but love, laughter, and a little improvisation turn it into something far better than perfect.