donnatheshort

[donnatheshort]

The Rosewood police sucks but the doctors are fucking miracle workers!

[donnatheshort]

You don't care how it hurts Until you lose the one you wanted Cause you're taking her for granted And everything you had got destroyed But you're just a boy

[donnatheshort]

Sometimes I feel like nothing is ever going to be okay ever again.

[donnatheshort]

When both your period and finals are coming to ruin your life

[donnatheshort]

Solitaire

I still remember how much I used to need you. Tried so hard to please you, but you didn't need me. You knew I loved you; knew I always would be there. You just did what you wanted; you didn't care. All the cards were held by you. There was nothin' I could do. All those nights I sat alone starin' at the telephone wonderin' were you ever comin' home. Solitaire, it got so lonely. Solitaire, no one to hold me. Where were you when I played solitaire? It took some time but I stopped thinkin' about you; started livin' without you, now look who's back here. You've had a change of heart, well, mine just couldn't wait. You found out you loved me just a little too late. Once the cards were held by you. Now there's nothin' you can do. All those nights you sit alone, starin' at the telephone wonderin' if I'm ever comin' home. Solitaire, see what it's like now. Solitaire, to cry all night now. Solitaire, see how it feels to bear. Solitaire, it gets so lonely. Solitaire, you wanna hold me. Don't wait up, 'cos babe, I won't be there. ---Laura Branigan---

[donnatheshort]

I think when it’s all over it just comes back in flashes, you know? It’s like a kaleidoscope of memories which all comes back… but he never does.

I think a part of me knew the second i saw him that this would happen. It’s not really anything he said or anything he did. It was the feeling that came along with it, and crazy thing I don’t know if I’m ever going to feel that way again, but I dunno if i should.

I knew his world moved too fast and burned to bright, but I just thought “how could the devil be pulling you toward someone who looks so much like an angel when he smiles at you?” Maybe he knew that when he saw me. I guess I just lost my balance.

I think the worst part of it all wasn’t losing him…it was losing me.

[donnatheshort]

Could Mona be Redcoat?

I know it sounds impossible but let’s look at this potential story:

We know that Cece went to visit Mona at Radley. Wren gave Cece authorization, according to him because Melissa thought that she’d be a good role model for Mona due to their mutual hatred of Ali. We also know that Cece and Ali both wore the red coat so that Ali could visit town and Cece could distract anyone from Ali by being her doppelganger.

The first time red coat visits Mona is right after Mona’s reveal, when she’s brought to Radley. Mona sees someone in a red coat and says that she did exactly what they told her to do. We now know that Mona thought she was speaking to Alison, because she then hallucinated seeing Alison in a red coat in Radley while Hanna was visiting her. 

What did Ali tell Mona to do last time they spoke? She taught Mona how to be popular. This was the night that Ali disappeared at the Lost Woods Motel. Mona did what Ali suggested and she became a queen bee. She became the new Alison DiLaurentis.

Once Mona was brought to Radley, she could no longer be that beautiful it girl. She was tarnished. So she had to become a new version of Ali. When she saw Cece in the red coat, she thought it was Ali and decided that she would become like her. And so evil red coat was born.

Charles got into Radley, probably because he knew his way in and out as a former patient. He taught Mona how to get in and out and they started playing the game together. She told him that Ali came to visit her, so together they dug up Ali’s grave to see whether or not her body was inside. 

Emily remembers seeing someone in a black hoodie, who was doing the digging, and someone else in a red coat. That’s all she remembers. Mona claims that she was there too and that she saw red coat. That is a lie. Mona was the one in the red coat. Charles was the one digging the grave. Only two bad guys were there that night.

We know it’s pretty likely that red coat is a brunette. Why do we think this? First of all, we saw the blonde wig in A’s lair. If red coat was naturally blonde, they wouldn’t need a wig, would they? Also, in Wren’s drawing of a woman in a red coat in front of a barn, red coat was a brunette. 

In the finale, Mona wears a red cape to prom, dressed as little red riding hood. Why would the writers choose to do that? This could be a huge hint. 

[donnatheshort]

Tell me why...

Why? That's all I seem to be asking myself the past few days. Why me? Why does he feel that way? Why can't I get over this? Why am I not good enough? Why am I not strong enough? Why isn't he in love with me? When someone you love decides maybe they don't love you as much as you thought they did, your mind starts to fill with all of these why's. The sad thing is, you most likely won't be getting an answer any time soon to any of these questions. The process is that you start to blame yourself. Often when we can't find answers for something causing us pain, blaming ourselves becomes the most natural option. But why (yeah...here's another one) should I be blaming myself for what someone else is doing to me? In all honesty, if he doesn't love me anymore, it's not really his fault. Is it? Well...maybe it is. And there's the next step. You go from feeling like crap and blaming yourself to trying to make yourself feel better by blaming the other person. Maybe it is their fault because they didn't try hard enough. Maybe they're just making up excuses when really something else is going on. Maybe if they had been honest with you all along, this could have been prevented. So many questions. So many hypothetical situations. But really, no one knows the truth. No one knows "why". And that's quite possibly the hardest thing to accept.

[donnatheshort]

I had the same thought lmao

Who is this monster?

[donnatheshort]

Sara is Bethany

I’ve been going back and rewatching recent episodes to find some clues.. and I’ve stumbled across many proving that SARA IS BETHANY.

Let’s start with the dollhouse.

This is the room we saw Sara in.. doesn’t it look familiar?

This was when Aria was in Rhonda’s room in Radley.. take a look at the bed. They look exactly the same. That is definitely a Radley bed in Sara’s room.

When Mona was pretending to be Alison, this is what she said when the girls started calling her Mona.

This is what Sara said when she was found by the cop and the cop asked her name:

Sara. Sara Harvey… Alison. Alison DiLaurentis. She said it exactly like Mona did when she was pretending to be someone else.

This was Emily, Emily’s mom, and Sara’s conversation during this scene:

Sara: “Yeah, I ran away.”

Emily’s mom: “Why?”

Sara: “Just couldn’t do it anymore.”

Emily: “Do what?”

Sara: “Pretend to be happy. Pretend everything was gonna be okay. Pretend my dad would come back and he’d be different if he did.”

This was a HUGE clue. Why did Bethany hate Mrs. DiLaurentis so much? BECAUSE SHE HAD AN AFFAIR WITH BETHANY’S FATHER!

Oh and doesn’t the way she looked in the mirror in that scene remind you of anything?……..

BETHANY’S DRAWING!

In 6x04, Emily returned home and her mother was very worried about Sara.

This was her and Emily’s conversation:

Emily’s mom: “I looked for Sara everywhere, and I finally found her… on our roof.”

Emily: “What was she doing on the roof?”

Emily’s mom: “I was afraid she was going to jump, but she was just staring up at the sky. Said she wanted to watch the sunset.”

Sara was on the roof? Wasn’t there said to have been another fragile patient at Radley with Marion Cavanaugh on the roof? WAS IT BETHANY?!

Another thing I got out of their conversation was that she wanted to watch the sunset..

We all know that Bethany was an artist.. And she was drawing what she wanted to do.

The next morning, Emily woke up to find that Sara was gone.

She found out she escaped through the window.. If I remember correctly, while Spencer was in Radley, she found out how Mona used to escape.. and it was through the window. Mona once said “I made a deal with the devil and she gave me a way in and out of that place.” Who else would know Radley better than its own patient like BETHANY? Was Sara/Bethany doing Charles’ dirty work so the girls would think A was really a girl? That’s exactly what it looks like…

In 6x06, Sara had her first day at work for Caleb.

Sara asked Caleb an interesting question..

“What do you know about Alison DiLaurentis? I wouldn’t ask but, when you’re forced to answer to someone else’s name and wear their clothes, you become curious about her.”

Yes she was wearing the same clothes as Alison was the night she went missing in the dollhouse, but BETHANY WAS WEARING THE SAME CLOTHES THAT NIGHT ALSO.

And she said she was forced to answer to her name? Then why did Charles need Mona and why was her room in the dollhouse designed after a Radley room? Why wasn’t she put in the hole after Mona got there like Mona was when Alison was supposed to replace her? INTERESTING.

In 6x06, after the girls broke in to Leslie’s office, they had a conversation with Mona about Charles and how he faked his death and why was Leslie looking so suspicious.

Charles was only distracting the girls with Leslie because he’s planning something big. He wanted it to look like Leslie was A..

Later that night, Sara came to Emily’s after she was “hit by a car”

Emily showed her a picture of Leslie’s car, and Sara said that was the one that hit her. It seems to me like she’s also trying to distract the girls with Leslie being A. Later that night when Emily went to check if she was chipped, she kissed her. Seems to me like she didn’t want Emily to know she doesn’t have one. She‘s definitely hiding something.

I’ve been suspicious of her since the beginning, and now I definitely do believe she is Bethany.

[donnatheshort]

This makes so much sense. Could also leave doors open for people we know existed before "that night" because Charles could have been living as a new identity pretending to be normal all that time.

Charles escaped Radley the same time Bethany did, according to Mona. Assuming he has been in there since he was admitted, wouldn't that eliminate any characters shown to be present previous to the night he escaped as Charles?

Yes.

That would eliminate Toby since we know he was out and about and allegedly peeping into Alison’s windows prior to That Night. It would eliminate Lucas and Noel since they were obviously around in the Halloween flashbacks. Ian and Wilden too.

It also puts a damper on the Wren theory, because if he escaped Radley on That Night, that only affords him a year to create a whole new identity, forge all the necessary credentials and references to position himself as a fake doctor, adopt a British accent and a whole backstory, and possibly undergo plastic surgery to mask his identity in order to re-enter Radley. Not impossible, especially if he had been planning it for a decade, but it’s still pushing into soap opera territory.

But I’m hesitant to take Mona’s word as gospel, especially via Lesli. Unreliable sources abound.

And here’s evidence to the contrary:

There’s still the issue of Bethany’s picture with the (teenage) boy being taken away by the demon. To me, it suggests Charles was pulled out of Radley at some point.

In my opinion, if Bethany and Charles had escaped together, this picture would not exist.

So maybe Charles did not escape with Bethany. Maybe Charles was already out, but he came back to get Bethany and run away with her. And it ended in tragedy.

[donnatheshort]

This is really well thought out.  It could also really work. On thing I would want explained more is why CeCe would involve the liars in all of this.  

Why will we feel sorry for Cece? ***Warning, you may want tissues around while reading this***

So, I’ve been seeing lately that after people read my Cece theories, they wonder why would they feel sorry for Cece. I’ve thought about it long and hard and I think I may have finally realized where they’re going with Cece and Charles’ story line. Here’s what I think has happened and what will happen, causing us to cry ourselves to sleep after the finale: A few times over the course of the past couple years, Marlene has said “Chuck and Blair forever”, now to people who have watched Gossip Girl- we know she’s referring to Chuck Bass and Blair Waldorf. Chuck (Charles) and Blair is arguably one of the best (and messed up) relationships on GG, they grew up together from birth and eventually fell in love and had a child together. As I have said in previous theories, Charles and Cece met in Radley at an extremely young age, the two grew close. Now, in 6x04 it was revealed that Charles had died at the age of 16, meaning he had been in Radley for well over a decade. Assuming Cece had been put in Radley around the time she stabbed her sister (6ish?) the two were nearly the same age. There, they fell in love, growing up together in their own prison- they were inseparable. In an interview with Keegan Allen, he described the story as a “Romantic Tragedy” and from all of the Shakespeare references that have been circling around lately… I think PLL may throw us a Romeo and Juliet type story with them. If you know about Romeo and Juliet, Juliet is to be married to Paris- though she doesn’t love him. She then goes to the priest saying she would rather die, that she loves Romeo. The priest gives her a drug that makes her seem totally dead, thus leaving her to be buried in a tomb. Romeo, in mourning, goes to Juliet’s tomb, thinking she was really dead he drinks poison to kill himself… In 6x04, I think it may have been Spencer or Kenneth that said Charles death was caused by sedatives and that he was then cremated. There’s no other way I can say this… I think Cece and Charles planned to escape Radley and run off together, when they found Charles- they thought he was dead. He was cremated before he could wake up to escape with Cece. As I’m writing this, I can feel a lump in my throat and I’m trying to hold back tears. After the tragic death of Charles, Cece took over for his life, she took his identity and started living the life she knew he wanted. She became the older sibling for Alison that Charles always wanted to be. She became the prom queen and tried to recreate the prom so that Charles could be prom king. She taught Alison how to perfect a lie. She loved Alison as the younger sibling Charles would’ve wanted, she hated Alison for getting Charles into Radley. She became everything Charles wanted to be, everything that he had told her in Radley. She became Charles.

Cece will die in the finale, that’s just how it has to end.

“A glooming peace this morning with it brings. The sun, for sorrow, will not show his head. Go hence, to have more talk of these sad things. Some shall be pardoned, and some punishèd. For never was a story of more woe Than this of Juliet and her Romeo.”

[donnatheshort]

I know this out there, but...

What if all of the liars have a history with mental illness? 

Imagine this: Spencer, Hanna, Aria, and Emily were all in Radley as children. We’re trusting them but we know that they can be unreliable narrators, as Spencer kept the drug secret from everyone for many, many seasons. 

Background:

The first clue was Spencer dreaming of that room in Radley that she hadn’t been to when she was older. She remembered the slippers with Charles’ name on them and she remembers a little girl. She said the little girl looked like Ali. It’s possible that the little girl was Ali, but it’s doubtful that her parents would’ve sent her to Radley at the same time as Charles. It could be Spencer or one of the other liars (more likely Hanna than the other two) or it could be Bethany. 

We know that all of the liars have secrets. Marlene once said that there’s stuff we don’t know about all of them, just like Spencer.

Maybe Aria had a relapse after Ali died. When her family was in “Iceland” she was really at Radley for a year, which is how Eddie Lamb recognized her and freaked her out. 

Haven’t you ever wondered why Ali picked these girls to be her friends? Maybe they’re more connected than we ever knew. In Spencer’s dream at Radley (back when she was first admitted), she saw Ali. Spencer mentioned that they didn’t know each other in sixth grade and Ali said “you didn’t even know me when you knew me”, which can mean many things, but maybe it’s a hint that the beginning of their friendship was a lie.

When Ali visited Aria when she was sick (when Ali was supposed to be dead still), the last thing she said to Aria was “you know why I chose you, right?”

Ali was a popular girl and she assembled a clique of “losers” to be her friends. Spencer was a nerd. Hanna was “hefty Hanna”. Emily was a passive girl and an athlete but definitely not popular. And Aria was alternative, the kind of girl who never hung out with cool kids. So why them? Maybe she wanted something from them. 

So this brings me to their connection to Charles. I know this is getting long but hang in there with me please. 

Connection to Charles:

The liars knew Charles as children when they were at Radley. They were very young, around 9 years old. He was 16. Maybe he bullied them at Radley and pushed them around. I’d bet that with Mrs. D on the board, they’d probably seen Ali a few times. Maybe they were jealous of her. Maybe Emily was in love with her without even realizing it. And they knew that Charles had tried to drown Ali as a baby. So together they drowned Charles (which is why Hanna and Spencer freaked out at the bathtub in Radley’s basement). 

The Cover-up:

Radley has a history with covering up crimes. They covered up Marion’s murder by ruling it a suicide. WIlden was paid off to alter the files so that nobody would find out. So maybe they did it that time too. When the girls murdered Charles, Radley wanted to protect them because they were young and it would be bad press for the institution if unsupervised 9 year old girls murdered a 16 year old boy. So they faked some documents about organ donation and ruled it a suicide. Mrs. D, like Mr. D, wanted Charles gone. He was a problem for the family. And she didn’t want the drama, so she helped with the cover-up. Only one other person knew the truth about what happened… Bethany. 

Bethany blackmailed Mrs. D into getting things because of what she knew. But what she really wanted was for the truth to come out. Mrs. D would give her things and take her out at Bethany’s request. She bought her a horse. However, when at Radley, Marion Cavanaugh saw Bethany blackmailing Mrs. D and she figured out what had happened all those years ago. Mrs. D couldn’t allow her secret to come out. So Mrs. D pushed Marion off of the roof, and to be sure not to get caught, she blamed it on Bethany and had it ruled as a suicide. Bethany knew that this had been done before, and she was furious. Mrs. D took her back to the horse farm and tried to make nice, telling Bethany to call her Aunt Jessie, and Bethany totally lost it. Soon, Bethany ran away from Radley. Mrs. D got the call that night and was worried because she knew Bethany hated her. 

That Night:

Everything gets foggy at this point. Too many people are at play to really speculate, but all I can say is that the liars were awake that night even though Ali drugged them and they killed someone else that night: Bethany. They were so drugged up that they didn’t bury her. Spencer was left to finish the job but she left Bethany’s body there. The NAT club seemed to think that Spencer killed Ali that night, which is why Garrett said he was protecting her and Melissa buried Bethany to protect her. Emily and Spencer have both had murky flashbacks of killing a blonde in a yellow top. It was Bethany.

One other person was out there that night: Bethany’s twin. C’mon, you know they’re going to throw the twin theory in at some point. She visited Bethany at Radley and when she visited her, she fell in love with Charles. She found out what the liars did, both to her love and to her sister, and for that she’s getting revenge. Who is Bethany’s twin? My first choice suspect is Cece. She is Big A and black widow and red coat.

[donnatheshort]

Kind of weird how the A and the M are capitalized. I understand why the A usually is, but why the M? Is this a clue? Aria Montgomery Ashley Marin Andrew M.... (Maybe his real last name)

[donnatheshort]

When Ezra told Aria “What do you wanna know?” about Andrew, I really thought he was gonna pick the notes he took while stalking everybody and use them as an encyclopedia.

[donnatheshort]

I decided to look up details on Patsy Cline and her life instead of focusing on the songs. It turns out she was involved in a bad car accident that resulted in a huge scar on her forehead that she had to hide the rest of her career. Maybe Marlene is alluding towards the fact that this is similar to Charles in that he wears masks to hide a scar from a bad accident. And then maybe she wants us to figure out what accident (perhaps the "Jenna thing").

Marlene's most recent Twitter was captioned HUGE PLL CLUE

And it was about a song with the lyrics: “I’m crazy for feeling so lonely”.

SO FAR, EVERY PIECE OF INFORMATION WE HAVE ABOUT SEASON 6 IS WORKING IN FAVOUR OF MY THEORY.

[donnatheshort]

Wow

Have you googled Walking After Midnight farms? Someone on another board found it. It is a farm in Tennessee owned by a couple named Melissa and Dr. Charles. It is also formerly named Black Widow farms. They specialize in horses. If this isn't a complete coincidence, I believe this totally points to Wren and Melissa. Especially since Marlene recently posted that Walking after Midnight is still a clue.

Not gonna lie, I thought this message was a troll. I was about to reply and say ‘nice try I’m not easy to fool’ but then I googled it for myself and oh my gosh this is true. What the hell! Surely this isn’t a coincidence, Marlene tweeted that ‘Walking After Midnight’ is a clue!Here’s the link: http://www.walking-after-midnight.com