#but if the gist of it is based on sherlock holmes I'd be happy

[misguidedandperplexed]

Someone smarter than me should write a frum!Sherlock Holmes story.

I'd love to read about Srulik Holman, who uses his top-notch analytical skills (born out of learning gemara; he's completed shas 3 times already, naturally) to solve crimes and mysteries as a consulting detective. And his roommate Jon Weinstein, a ba'al teshuva who became frum after sustaining an injury in the military (who knows so little compared to Srulik but Srulik is working on his middos and trying to be patient).

Best part is, it doesn't even need to be fanfiction because Sherlock Holmes is in the public domain.