#its not supposed to be a 1:1 retelling but you know. a sort of thematic reference
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Am I insane or are Joker and Akechi low-key equivalent to Adam and Eve in the 3rd semester
- Maruki's palace has some heavy "Garden of Eden" themes, with it essentially being a paradise where people live free of suffering and strife but also in a kind of blissful ignorance of themselves. The highest structure is LITERALLY named Eden, with a garden and an apple tree with a snake and everything. Maruki oversees everything as God, one who gave this wonderful place and unburdened lives to people.
- 3rd semester Akechi was born out of Joker's cognition thanks to Maruki, just like how Eve was born out of Adam's rib; There's also the fact that Joker wanted Akechi alive again so that they might try starting their relationship over and due to his regret over how their relationship ended up- which parellels Adam's desire for a companion. Joker and Akechi are the only two people in Maruki's reality who feel that something's not right (at least at first), making them truly uniquely cognicient beings, kind of like how Adam and Eve were uniquely intelligent among all the other life in Eden (given that they could talk and were chosen to be the caretakers of all other creation).
- In the bible, it was Eve who convinced Adam to eat the apple and gain awareness; In the game, it's Akechi who manages to convince Joker about the truth of what's actually going on around them.
- Once Adam eats the apple, he and Eve are banished from Eden by God, forcing them and all the other humans in the future to live on Earth, where they have to suffer from hunger, illness, pain, and all the other things they never felt while in Heaven. Joker and Akechi go after Maruki with all the other phantom thieves- their consciousness allowed them to disobey their "God" and destroy his reality, causing them and all humanity to return to the original world, where they have to suffer from heartache and other emotions they were free of in his "Paradise". Not to mention that they themselves will suffer too- Joker will have to live without Akechi, mourning the relationship they could have, while Akechi will literally stop existing. If they obeyed, they could still both exist together (even if it would be in a way they don't want).
- Adam and Eve are, of course, positioned as a "pair of opposites", given that Abrahamic religions see men and women as opposite "forces". Almost every aspect of Joker and Akechi mirrors eachother, from designs through personalities to places they occupy in their lives. There's also the fact that Adam and Eve were sort of destined for eachother, made for eachother by God, just like how Joker and Akechi were destined by gods to be rivals and opposites.
- "Rebellion" in general is one of the main themes of the game, and Adam and Eve can be seen as humanity's first rebels by going against their creator (or at least that's one possible interpretation). Joker and Akechi are P5's protagonist and deuteragonist, the two main thematic characters of the game; Them being united together AS A DUO (unlike during the Shido situation, where they had the same goal but mostly worked separately) against a shared God-like opponent who is trying to take away their free will is kind of like if God wanted to take Adam and Eve back and wipe their minds, and Adam and Eve fought together like hell to stay free.
- This is really minor, but there is a Mementos dialogue about Akechi eating a single apple for lunch every day... 👀
#persona#persona 5#p5#p5r#goro akechi#ren amamiya#shuake#hatter blathers#sorry if this had been talked about before. i looked it up online and couldnt find anything#maybe i missed something?#i am a SUCKERRR for a good garden of eden/adam and eve motif.........#not sure how sumire fits in.... kain and abel in one person? lol /jk /lh#im sorry if i got something wrong about the game lol i feel like theres so many details and information you can easily overlook by accident#i hope im not delusional lol this came to me as i was falling asleep and the more i thought about it the more it made sense to me#its not supposed to be a 1:1 retelling but you know. a sort of thematic reference#sorry for any mistakes or anything like that#im kinda sleep deprived lmao
201 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ok wait
So, the parallels with the story of Oma and Shu and the color coding of the characters being brilliant foreshadowing for Zutara has always been legend in the fandom and its been analyzed and analyzed and analyzes again. Yes, that's great. I piss myself off about it literally every day. But on THIS DAY, on THIS DAILY ITERATION OF BEING BITTER ABOUT ZUTARA, I just kinda. . .noticed something else about the Oma and Shu story and parallel and the color coding and the animation that's probably already been thought of or pointed out before but it was my first time noticing it and I'm even more mad now. Maybe it’s just me! I am probably reaching. I don’t actually think the animators had this in mind when creating the series, but the coincidence is still like “hhmmmmhhhMMM oK” Anyway my blog name is Zutara Secret Tunnel and I’m a big fan of the Oma and Shu parallel theory within the Zutara fandom so I’m strapping on my tin foil hat HERE I GO I WARNED YOU:
SO
We know the theory that red and blue was supposed to be coded for Zuko and Katara cause we know the animators of the show understand colors and symbolism and aren't babies. We also know that they were in the exact same positions as Zuko and Katara in the catacombs under Ba Sing Se (which has rightfully been pointed out as the dumbest jail to put them in if not for this type of foreshadowing??? There was a real jail RIGHT THERE?? I digress).
Ok so we see that the one in red (Oma) is in Zuko's position and the one in blue (Shu) is in Katara's position, cleverly gender swapped. We've all seen the still of how Zuko is in basically this EXACT SAME SITTING POSITION when he tumbles down into the catacombs, with Katara standing over him. (Also not in red, but in earth tones, which Oma is ALSO shown to be in during the story while I don’t think Shu’s coloring changes BUT THAT’S BESIDE THE POINT).
(I couldn’t find the exact still I wanted but ya’ll KNOW WHAT I’M TALKING ABOUT)
Ok, but as the story of Oma and Shu continues we find that Shu was killed in the war. We see Oma mourn him and then we see her anger, and her lashing out. When she's described as unleashing her powerful earthbending to end the war and create the new city of Omashu, this is how she's shown:
Huh looks familiar from a time when we saw a paralleled also red-coded character do something similar.
Wow so it turns out that Zuko just really likes doing things similarly to this red-coded character in a great love story with a blue-coded character. Even right up to the finale of the show!! What a cool bending move Zuko. REALLY COOL. And especially when he’s fighting for peace alongside Katara, our lovely blue-coded gender-swapped Shu, and right before he nearly sacrifices HIS OWN LIFE to SAVE HERS.
And how quaint that the blue-coded character, Katara, is there to heal the character she's tied to in this parallel, thus changing the story from one of loss to one of triumph!
And I know what you might say, one of the great themes of A:tLA is that of destiny being open to change based on an individual's decisions (although the deus ex rockina might be a divergence from that, but I digress again!!!1), especially due to the conclusion of The Fortuneteller. But think about it. This isn’t destiny. This isn’t a reincarnation or a retelling. They may be thematically tied to this story, but how did they change it based on their own choices in their own lives and scenarios? In this scenario, Zuko chooses to fight to end the war with Katara, rather than making the mistake that Oma did and waiting to act until it was too late and she had already lost Shu.
So it's not destiny, just a parallel, and an even further example of how we can learn from history and legend to shape our own destinies, and how these scenarios often repeat themselves but the outcomes of them can be changed based on what individuals do in the times that they are experiencing them.
And honestly it was Oma's actions in bringing peace (whoa like a certain Fire Lord whattttt) that created the great city of Omashu. Wouldn't it have been rad to see a union between Zuko and Katara bring about a project like, oh gee idk, Republic City? Things we coulda had, my dudes. Things we coulda had.
(Also if you think I didn’t notice that Oma is in white when she unleashes her anger, a fire nation mourning color but also potentially a way to show her not tied to any one nation sort of like a certain fire prince who was technically a “traitor” to his nation and learned to appreciate things from all different nations YOU ARE WRONG I NOTICED THAT TOO)
Anyway I hate this show and myself so I'm gonna go now. Don’t @ me.
#zutara#oma and shu#dumb theories i have#thinking and reaching#look i just wish as a writer that I had half a mind to create these awesome parallels and then for what? For a badly developed endgame ship#and some terribly OOC comics???#and no I didn't watch korra don't even ask me#I also don't actually hate this show I'm just FOREVER BITTER#I know its been a thousand years but ill be bitter on my DEATH BED#Go ahead and call me a toothbrush cause i know this is a REACH#BUT STILL#this is not an argument about intent in canon but more about potential in canon#but then again#what zutara related rant isnt#we coulda had it allll#maybe even a statue of KATARA WHO KNOWS????#ok crawlin back to muh fanfiction bye
87 notes
·
View notes
Photo
[Image description: graphic titled “Adriana Reviews...” followed by four books with their titles, authors, and release date (discussed below), superimposed over a gradient mosaic of pinks and purples]
Hi, everyone! I’ve been busy moving and with personal family business, but in between I’ve been reading, so this post is intended as a review-dump of all the books I read during that time. That’s right, I’m not talking about just one book reviewed, I’m talking about FOUR books being reviewed. In ONE post! Hold on to your reading devices, ‘cause it’s about to go down… (Spoilers and Long Post Ahead!!!)
I’ll start with the one I read during my finals week (I know, procrastination got the best of me):
Future Leaders of Nowhere by Emily O’Beirne (March 14th, 2017)
Set in Australia, we follow along as Finn and Willa end up at a camp for “Future Leaders” thanks to their performance in their respective schools. Pitted against each other as captains of their respective teams, these teenage girls must find common ground in order to survive the wrath of an entitled straight white boy who’s drunk with power (or a semblance of power).
I really liked the plot and characters of this book! At first I was apprehensive about the thematic and was sort of confused about what the camp entailed, as well as the fact that a month-long camp where they basically mixed a roleplay “Settlers of Catan” with scavenger hunts didn’t seem like something I would be interested in. However, it was the characters which drew me in. I loved Finn and Willa, both separately and together. Finn was a silent-but-deadly kind of leader that left me doing chinhands because DAMN I love girls who don’t take any shit. The same went for Willa, since I kept repeating “I wanna be like you when I grow up” as I saw her take charge of her Amazonian group of girls. Their relationship was organic; gotta love that friends-to-lovers trope. I adored their tenderness, how genuine their respect for each other was, and how realistic these aspects were because these were teen girls! Willa and Finn were insecure, they had family and identity issues, and yet they still managed to be there for each other. Of course, they had issues, but that’s a part of teenage angst and author-made drama.
The author was also able to include so much representation that made me so giddy! On the page, Finn was bisexual (I loved her explanation in Ch. 63: “Listen, I’m perfectly happy to help you out with difficult concepts. Like that time that I explained anaerobic respiration to you, but I do not have the time or the energy to explain really basic stuff. Especially when the meaning is in the actual word. Bisexuality. Hear that? Bi.” Even though that definition is very binary, it was important to see that word written out), Willa was gay and of mixed Indian descent, and there was a whole cast of side-characters with varied identities.
With all that said, I also had issues with some parts of the book. The characterization of Willa was at times inconsistent, and there was an islamophobic act depicted (a character tried to take off a Muslim girl’s hijab) that wasn’t really dealt with beyond the anger of some characters and it ended up seemingly brushed aside by the MC. The shifting POV worked most of the time, but there were times where the POV of that character didn’t feel all that necessary.
All in all, the book reminded me of the styles of E. Lockhart and Becky Albertalli. It was a fun, breezy read if you’re a fan of teenage hijinks at a sleepaway camp. Thanks to the publisher for allowing me access to review this book through NetGalley.
Rating: 3/5 Stars
Goodreads // Amazon
After reading that last book, I read Joyride during the flight home, which made it easy for me to delve into its world…
Joyride Vol. 1 by Jackson Lanzing and Colin Kelly (September 21st, 2016)
Joyride was a fascinating read for me. I don’t usually read graphic novels (probably because I’m incredibly picky about them and devour them so fast), but Joyride was just fun to devour. The writing kept me engaged and I genuinely was interested in the development of the characters and their adventures in space. I’m a fan of science-fiction and space adventures, especially when the team is comprised of found-families in the face of adversity.
Though they kept me engaged for the duration of my flight, I felt they were forgettable characters for some reason. I loved them, but I felt like they weren’t developed enough. Perhaps in Vol. 2 there was more character development, but in this installment it was difficult to discern between characterizations and that got in the way of the storytelling. In the future, I would like to see the relationships between the female characters explored some more as well as the dynamics with the brothers. The book left me with so many questions, mostly centered around the plot and its characters: what type of government were they under at the base? Was the alien sidekick necessary to the plot besides to make snide and unhelpful comments? Was Catrin gay? Is there going to be a love triangle around Uma? If so, I would read the next installment.
In terms of the art, I felt like the colors were vibrant and it appeared neat. I’m not that knowledgeable of art and drawing, I find myself lacking in that department, but I really liked them because they kept drawing me in; it was the type of aesthetic I like in my science fiction media. I did find the depictions of the characters inconsistent at times as well, but I didn’t really mind that.
In any case, on a scale from 0 to 5, where 0 is Jupiter Ascending-ridiculous and 5 is Star Wars: The Force Awakens- glorious, Joyride falls in a solid 3 level sff (so, maybe like a Star Trek Beyond). Thanks to BOOM! Studios for allowing me to read this through NetGalley.
Rating: 3/5 Stars
Goodreads // Amazon
After reading this graphic novel, I knew I wanted to delve into a more light-hearted, highly anticipated read…
Always and Forever, Lara Jean by Jenny Han (Release date: May 2nd, 2017)
I want to start by giving thanks to our lord and savior Jenny Han for being so generous as to give us meek readers a third and final look into Lara Jean Song-Covey’s life. Her writing is always full of life and colors. I have to say that when I read, I become a very mentally-visual person, so when I tell you that a book and its words remind me of certain colors, it’s good. Always and Forever reminded me of a muted blue, the blue of melancholy, of looking back through old pictures, of taking the last step out of your high school. It is a blue that looks at the future and says it’s okay to not have your shit together as long as you have people around you supporting you and cheering you on to your next great adventure.
Always and Forever was the best goodbye to Lara Jean I could’ve hoped for. It was full of twists and drama and it was so realistic I had to check if the story wasn’t actually about me. I could relate to Lara Jean’s anxiety around college and the process of getting accepted or denied to the universities you love. When I was going through that process, my dream schools were University of Wisconsin-Madison and Penn State, and though I got accepted, I had to go through the heartbreak of declining their offers because it was too much money. I felt Lara Jean’s disappointment as if I had declined those offers right then and not four years ago.
I also felt Lara Jean’s uncertainty around the relationships you keep or give up on after high school. There are some that are forever, like your family. Her family, as always, showed up for her time and time again, and their love for her shone through in this book. I loved Kitty so much, especially with her feelings towards her second older sister leaving their house. On the other hand, Lara Jean felt conflicted over her relationship with her boyfriend, Peter. Though I graduated without a significant other (much like Lara’s mother advised them to do), I found myself a tad angry at Peter and even Lara. I don’t know why I kept finding it selfish for them to want to go to the same university and just keep doing what they’re doing because it works instead of challenging themselves. Maybe it was the cynic in me talking over the idealistic voice that permeates Young Adult Contemporary Romance, but by the end of the book I was glad to squish that so-called voice of reason; who needs that when you could be salivating over Lara Jean’s wardrobe/cooking/everything. I had one question, which I may have missed over the course of the series, but I needed to know what was Lara Jean’s major, as that may have been key to her characterization.
In the end, I was glad for Jenny Han’s basically coming full-circle with this book. This novel was the best tight, pretty bow this series needed.
Rating: 4/5 Stars
Goodreads // Amazon
Last but not least, a monster of a book that took me an entire week to get through while tending to my dad at the hospital…
Girls Made of Snow and Glass by Melissa Bashardoust (Release date: September 5th, 2017)
First off, I want to declare that I was dubious about this book. I first heard of it through a friend, who sent me an article that dubbed it as “a feminist retelling of Snow White”. I’m always cringing when someone calls a book a feminist-anything, but I was willing to give it a try. When i saw that NetGalley had it in advance, I requested it, not really thinking I’d get approved. To my surprise, my inbox was telling me that Flatiron Books had approved my request and I was really excited (thanks Flatiron Books!). I delved into Bashardoust’s world without much background besides the fact that it was supposed to be feminist and a retelling of Snow White (which I may or may not have forgotten when I started reading it because I was tired).
I think it was essential for me to dive into this one without reading what it was about, because it led to me wanting to process everything written at face value. Girls Made of Snow and Glass was a magical tale of putting oneself first, as the opposite would allow for men’s greed and ignorance to burrow itself into women’s lives.
In this tale, the patriarchal notions of duty to a man in a position of authority and notions of how a woman should exist in public and private spheres are challenged by the main characters: Mina and Lynet. Lynet was a normal fifteen-year old girl in a fictional royal family; she wishes to be more than what she was born into, wanted to run away from her circumstances and, above all, be herself. This sounds pretty cliché, except for the fact that it’s GAY! Yes, you read right, G A Y. I won’t go into details, but it’s a very nuanced and mellow pairing that felt like ocean waves on a stroll by the beach. On the other hand, Mina was set up to be the wicked stepmother, except the narrative framed her more as a woman who’d been forced to assimilate into a patriarchal monarchy that didn’t appreciate her prowess as a tactician and desire to help those in need. Mina’s circumstances were constricted by her father’s ambition and her own intellect, which in itself is deemed as valuable by the author but not by people surrounding her, much as is the case with many powerful and influential women.
I really liked the characterization work the author put into the story, each character was fleshed out and I wanted to know more about each of them. I did think the author maintained the races of the characters vague, which was a problem for me, since it’s being marketed as a feminist fantasy book and there’s not a lot of visible racial representation. The plot I felt was slightly predictable, but I was delighted by the way the author threaded these characters reacting to each other. I felt the reveals came too early, that the reader was just given the characters’ secrets readily, rather than it being a slow reveal. I liked the author’s writing, I think it was really nice and had a beautiful poetic flow.
Girls Made of Snow and Glass was a wonderful read about the influence women have and, in summary, to never underestimate the power that their words and actions hold. At its center, it’s a story about two women coming together from two very different points in their lives and learning from and loving one another. Bashardoust’s story was intricate and a bit of what we needed in the realm of fantasy.
Rating: 4/5 stars
Goodreads // Amazon
#mine#future leaders of nowhere#girls made of snow and glass#joyride#always and forever lara jean#adriana reviews#adriana recs#long post
7 notes
·
View notes