#There's a gut instinct to avoid using the term Jews that I have that I've been told is typical of activists
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
us specific post incoming, but: in the wake of the inauguration I've seen a couple of versions floating around tumblr at this point, and they're all well-meaning so I don't want to put this on the posts themselves, but:
if you find yourself compelled to make or spread versions/interpretations of the "first they came for" poem, just take a second to double check whether or not Jews are included.
The original version is very culturally specific to Germany and to German guilt/reconciliation post-WWII, and while the sentiments (of standing up for others before atrocities occur) are important and universal, the original intention and message are still important, especially as antisemitism rises in spaces across the political spectrum.
If we do not include Jewish people in our advocacy, we will be repeating the exact same conditions the original poem criticizes. It would be ironic in a very serious and unfunny way to be silent on the suffering of Jews while quoting a poem reckoning with the suffering Jewish people endured because of bystanders' silence.
#cw antisemitism#pipie rants#couple of things: i'm Christian so if you're Jewish and hate my language I'm very sorry#There's a gut instinct to avoid using the term Jews that I have that I've been told is typical of activists#but that ultimately avoiding the term just feeds into the idea that Jews is a bad term which it isn't#also this is not about *sreal and I am not using coded language#many leftist/liberal activists need to disentangle their rhetoric from antisemitic tropes#it is self defeating and cruel to advocate for humanity of one group by recycling bigoted tropes against another
9 notes
·
View notes