Text
Always Forever
[Chapter 1]
———————
Your shift was just about over, fatigue clung to you like some kind of shadow, the consequence of a sleepless night. The day had been just as uneventful as every other day, only the occasional appearance of people stopping in for gas or a quick snack.
You were so lost in your thoughts, completely ignoring the man in front of you as if he didn't exist—Not registering his presence at all until he was standing directly in front of you, clearing his throat to draw your attention away from whatever you had been preoccupied with. Startled, you looked up and met his gaze, giving him an apologetic smile as he sat down a bag of chips and a bottle of Pepsi.
The man appeared to be in his late forties, with a neatly trimmed gray beard and a demeanor as serious as his stern expression. You quickly scanned his items, the familiar beeps of the register breaking the silence. Before you could tell him the total, you were interrupted.
"Can I get a pack of Marlboro?" His voice low and gravelly, carrying a kind of rough authority.
You nodded, grabbing the red pack of cigarettes and setting them on the counter. "These?" You asked to confirm.
He nodded and handed his ID over. Samuel Gardiner, born 1976. Looked about right. After double-checking you passed the ID back to him.
Just as you did, the chime of the door signaled someone else entering. You caught a glimpse of a blue hoodie heading toward the drinks coolers but didn't pay much attention. You were focused finishing up with Samuel.
"Have a good day," he said, gathering his items—Pepsi and chips in one hand, cigarettes in the other as he trudged out the door.
The door swung shut with a soft thud, leaving you alone with the new customer. He approached the counter softly, placing a can of Red Bull down with deliberate movements. He was slightly taller than average, with messy dark brown hair that hung over his forehead, though grooming wasn't a priority.
There was something about the way he moved—unhurried, almost purposeful—that caught your attention. When his eyes met yours, dark and nearly black, they seemed to linger for just a moment too long, studying you. The intensity unsettled you, and for a moment, you wondered if you imagined it.
You picked up the Red Bull and scanned it, offering him a polite smile. "Three dollars," you said, keeping your tone light. He didn't speak, merely nodded as he fished a few crumpled bills from his pocket and handed it to you in silence.
"Would you like a receipt?" You asked, opening the cash register. He shook his head, his silence stretching on. Something felt... off. Maybe he wasn't the talkative type. Or perhaps he simply didn't like engaging with strangers. For a moment, you even considered the possibility that he might be mute.
"Alright then, have a good day!" You said automatically, the words tumbling out before you realized how ridiculous they sounded. It wasn't day anymore—it was nearly midnight. Smooth Y/n. Real smooth.
He took the Red Bull, his steps almost soundless as he moved toward the door. Just as he reached it, he hesitated, and you caught the faintest murmur, almost a whisper come from him. "Y-you too."
So, he wasn't mute after all.
#creepypasta#ticci toby#toby rogers creepypasta#ticci toby creepypasta#ticci toby x reader#ticcy toby#tobias erin rogers#toby rogers#creepypasta x reader#always forever series#creepypasta ticci toby#toby x reader#toby creepypasta#tobias rogers#“ticci” toby rogers#toby rodgers x reader#toby rogers x you#toby rogers x reader#creepy pasta#creepypasta toby
59 notes
·
View notes
Text
Always Forever
[Prologue]
———————
Beep, Beep...
you sighed putting the two items into a bag
"You look rough," A middle-aged woman said as she bounced a child in her arms that seemed to be around 2-3 years old while another kid who looked slightly older clung to her shirt.
You smiled and spoke while grabbing a candy bar off the table. "Long day."
She scoffed "I can relate." She gushed as she side-eyed the kid in her hands. There was an awkward silence between the two of you after her comment.
"Your total will be 25.75," you said, finally breaking the silence as she rolled her eyes groaning.
"I can't believe it cost this much for only a few things." she groaned as she sat her child down and started roaming through her purse, "there it is" she sighed in relief—pulling out a leather clutch wallet. "I thought I was gonna have to make a run for it." you both chuckled at her joke as she paid for her stuff and then put her card back in her wallet. "Have a good day, honey" she sighed, giving you a small smile before walking away.
--------------------------
You glanced at the clock,
11:51
Ugh... You huffed, looking around the bland gas station before your eyes met the ground as you continued to wait for your shift to be over so that you could finally go home and sleep in peace. You looked at the clock again.
11:52
Why can't it just be 12 already... I just want to leave... You looked around the store to see if anyone was there but from what you could see the store seemed empty except for you. You decided to pass the last 8 minutes by buying yourself an energy drink and scrolling through your phone. Before you knew it, it was already midnight. You looked up as the bell rang on the door and someone walked in.
--------------------------
Eat, sleep, wake up, then go to work. Those things basically described your life. All you did was work then come back home just to have to work again a few hours later. You stopped talking to all your friends and family for the most part, not being able to have enough time to give them a call or a message unless it was a happy birthday or a congratulations. You needed to find a better job, so you weren't known as a cashier working at a shitty gas station that gets robbed twice a month. You still lived in a decent house that you could at least thank your job for. It had two stories and 1 bedroom with two bathrooms. You were able to move out a while ago soon after you turned 18, saying goodbye to friends and moving to a more secluded area right outside of Denver.
--------------------------
You opened your front door, quickly sliding your shoes off, and making your way to your bedroom. You were completely exhausted from work as usual and just wanted to get home and lay in your bed. As you made your way into your bedroom you placed down your belongings and didn't bother changing as you slid under the covers, drifting off to sleep...
#creepypasta#ticci toby#toby rogers creepypasta#ticci toby creepypasta#ticci toby headcanons#ticci toby x reader#creepypasta x reader#always forever series#creepypasta ticci toby#ticcy toby#toby x reader#toby creepypasta#tobias erin rogers#toby rogers#toby erin rogers#creepy pasta#creepypasta toby#creepypasta series#tobias rogers#“ticci” toby rogers#toby rogers x you#toby rogers x reader#creepypasta fandom
57 notes
·
View notes
Text
Im sorry everyone i lowk haven’t opened tumblr in months bc i don’t have that much time with work n everything going on😭 but I’m gonna try to start being active again
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ticci Toby headcanons⁉️
A/n: Back and writing for my childhood crush?? Yes, yes I am.
Warnings: Mentions of sex (kinda)



🪓☆ Bro LOVES animals and insects, especially the ones that most people dislike
🪓☆ Such as centipedes, millipedes, possums, raccoons, snakes, beetles (especially weevils omg) and spiders + many many more
🪓☆ MIDWESTERN EMO BOY!! Guys PLEASE just look at him it makes sense
🪓☆ He has a few freckles and moles :33
🪓☆ The type of person who’s kinda quiet until you get to know him, grows more comfortable with you over time :P
🪓☆ He can be kind of a sarcastic jerk sometimes though ngl 😭
🪓☆ NOT a morning person
🪓☆ Hypersexual
🪓☆ Plus due to his CIPA it’s one of the few things he actually can feel.
🪓☆ Likes to go on walks. And I’m talking HOURRR LONG ONES
🪓☆ Toby’s love language is for sure either quality time or physical touch 💯💯
🪓☆ Besties with Jeff and Jane and is like an annoying little brother to Masky
🪓☆ He’s pansexual !! If there’s a hole there’s a goal 🙏
🪓☆ Tried to pierce his ears by himself once… Yeaaahh they got infected the next day
🪓☆ Absolute LOSER but I love him dearly so it’s alright <3
🪓☆ Waffle jokes and whatever aside, he enjoys both waffles and pancakes equally, not really much of a preference there.
4K notes
·
View notes
Text
Pride Month is upon us again and so it is time to repost my little guy, Hue! I’m wishing everyone a safe, supportive, positive, and enlightening Pride, whether you’re all the way “out” or not!
57K notes
·
View notes
Text
Today, I would like to commemorate an event which has laid a very profound impact on the internet.
Ten years ago on this day (06/08/09), a forum website called SomethingAwful held a photoshop contest titled “create paranormal images”. The contest would require participants to edit ordinary photographs into creepy-looking images, and then try to pass them off as authentic photos on other paranormal forums.
Two days later, on June 10th, a user by the name Victor Surge would find this thread, and become inspired. He submitted the two pictures above, featuring a tall, faceless monster which would stalk children, who would then disappear. He called his monster “the Slender Man”. After this initial post, Surge and others would expand on the character and the story, creating one of the internet’s most famous monsters. The Slender Man proved to be popular enough to spread to other websites, with 4chan, Deviantart, and TV Tropes all having their own Slender-Mania. On June 20th of that same year, another user on the SomethingAwful forums found the Slender Man, and also wanted to contribute. Noticing nobody had made any videos yet of the monster, he sat down with some of his friends and planned out a video webseries involving a former college film student discovering and unravelling the mysteries surrounding Slender Man; this would become Marble Hornets, one of the first horror-themed ARG’s of the internet.
That all happened ten years ago. Ten years of haunting the darkest corners of the internet, and Slender Man has built up a surprisingly dense resume, for a fictional monster. Several popular webseries, a couple hit games, at least two movies, even inspiring other characters in seperate series like the Silence in Dr Who and the Enderman in Minecraft. And all this within a ten-year period.
I think this just attests to how much humans can be inspired by an idea. From a small handful of edited photographs, we collectively constructed a new monster which lurks in our nightmares, and now it almost seems as natural as the horror mythos he was based on. For better or worse, the Slender Man seems to be here to stay. Happy Birthday, Slendy! Here’s to hoping you continue to be both terrifying and terrific!
94K notes
·
View notes
Note
What are some silly headcanons you have for Toby? Just general stuff
Hi! I’m glad I finally got to this😭 I just made a post about it! I hope you like it! LThe link is here >☺️
1 note
·
View note
Text
Summary :: regular hcs for Ticci Toby
Notes :: hahaha😝 Ikik I'm finally back!!
Warnings :: none that I know of
Readers gender :: no reader in this(?)
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
This hoe is crazy asf man good luck😭 because you're gonna need it if you come across this guy... especially older him
Even if he doesn't remember a lot of stuff from his past the trauma he went through stuck with him through everything and a lot of people still use that against him.
ok... so ik that canonically he doesn't know Masky or Hoodie but... I'm going against that for these head canons and even go against my personal head canons as well because... Idk
Masky tends to bring up his past a lot on purpose just to get this reaction out of him because he's and asshole and even goes out of his way to call him “Mr. Rogers”, “Toby Rogers”, or “Ticci Toby”
Toby(for obvious reasons) has ditched his last name and everything else that connects him to his past, the only thing that he carried into his new life is his first name and no. HE DOES NOT GO BY TICCI TOBY! He hates being called that because that's what he was called by a kid by his bullies... which bullied him so bad he had to be homeschooled
I can’t really see Toby making friends with people in the manor either but instead being more of acquaintances with everyone while also being very passive aggressive towards every being he interacts with.
When Toby first joined the manor though, he did have an on and off relationship with Natalie which left him even more messed up than before and now he has relationship issues as well
Toby tends to have a lot of stuff in his hair all the time (blood, leaves, etc.) and if we’re being honest, he probably doesn’t shower- jkjk he showers every time he gets the chance, though that's only really when he's at a victim's house and has time to spare.
He also doesn’t eat much due to being out in the woods all the time for Slenderman so the best thing he gets is also stuff he takes from his victim's house...
After killing someone they kind of just make themselves at home and catch up on everything they need to while taking some stuff with them to go.
Also, he's a STALKER. Not even intentionally at times but it's something he's taken with him from his very... unusual job...
He's got a midwestern style going on and has probably tried to pierce his ears and a bunch of other things before but it ended up getting infected.
He actually tries to take care of the cuts he gets on missions and his gash because when he was younger, his mom used to freak out about the littlest of things and when he'd get a cut or anything his mom would say if he didn't take care of it, it would get infected and fall off. And now he takes that to heart even if he didn't when he was younger and getting hurt all the time.
But his habits just don't let his gash heal properly and he continues to chew at it, never giving it time to heal.
But, speaking of getting hurt. He used to get hurt A LOT when he was younger but now, he doesn't. Because after coming back from missions hurt almost every time due to him being reckless everyone started refusing to help patch him up... So now he knows how to be more careful and take care of wounds!
But yeah... that's the end of these head canons lol I might make some more for this silly guy later on though
#creepypasta#ticci toby#toby rogers creepypasta#ticci toby creepypasta#ticci toby headcanons#ticcy toby#tobias erin rogers#toby rogers#toby erin rogers#tobias rogers#“ticci” toby rogers#toby creepypasta#creepypasta toby#creepypasta headcanon#ticci toby hc#toby rogers headcanons#ticci toby x reader#creepy pasta#creepypasta x reader#creepypasta ticci toby
80 notes
·
View notes
Note
Hi! First time requester here I was wondering do you have any headcannons on reader and highschool Toby losing their virginity to each other I totally understand if you’re not comfortable with that.
Summary :: reader and Toby losing their virginity to eachother
Notes :: Hi!😁 This is the first nsfw request I've got so I'm sorry if it's written poorly😭 I've been wondering when I'd finally get one but I'm totally comfortable with it I js can't take myself seriously while writing it but I still hope you enjoy!
Warnings :: nsfw, cursing
Readers gender :: gender neutral, afab
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Toby literally has no experience whatsoever because before you no one ever even really talked to him other than bullies.
He is super nervous about the whole thing but the horny teenager in him has been secretly wanting to do this with you ever since you both got together.
He may have no experience at all but he knows the basics at least and even though he isn't the most romantic person he wants this to be the best experience for the both of you.
He's insecure about his body and overall general appearance so he'd probably want to have his first few times in the dark.
Ik for sure this mans a switch, but his preference is your preference so if you want to top then he's more than happy to
holds your hand the whole time, gently caressing the back of your hand with his thumb as he leaves a hot trail of kisses down your neck to your collarbone
PRAISES you so much as he waits for you to adjust around his cock as he peppers your shoulder with light kisses
Definitely doesn't take his hateful attitude to bed, especially not when it's the both of yours first time
He'll go down on you, asking if he's doing good while he holds your hips and eats you out like it's his last fucking meal
He doesn't want to hurt you at all he'll be asking over and over if he's doing good and making sure you feel as good as he does!
Though, due to his CIPA he doesn't really know how much it hurts to lose your virginity so you're going to have to tell him though he still doesn't realize😭
He's good wit it just very rough soo... it's definitely not the best first experience... but pls he's trying his best
#creepypasta#ticci toby#ticci toby x reader#toby rogers creepypasta#ticci toby creepypasta#ticci toby headcanons#ticcy toby#creepypasta x reader#ticci toby x you#ticci toby x y/n#toby x reader#creepy pasta#creepypasta toby#creepypasta x y/n#creepypasta ticci toby#tobias erin rogers#toby rogers#toby erin rogers#toby rogers x you#toby rogers x reader#toby rogers x y/n#toby rogers headcanons
505 notes
·
View notes
Text
I love these hcs 🫶🫶
Long live Lyra!!😝 She’s the goat
‘‘Ticci’’ Toby, modern high school AU
Summary: YES, the proxy concept still exists. Toby doesn’t get his position as a proxy til LATER. Basically me just messily writing about the AU a bit at like 1 am 😭 I’ll write a fic version later. . . Slice of life? Sorta.
To note: Toby’s vocal tics are in cursive (I’m basing him off a friend irl with tourettes) tics are written: - like this - and he tics in a way that sometimes affects his speech: speaks ‘’luh’- tic - like this.’’ Lyra, Toby’s sister is still alive (SHE’S GOATED AND YES DON’T DISMISS HER AS A SIDE CHARACTER.). Toby and Lyra are non-identical twins. You’re all about 18 years old. So not proof-read I wrote this at night. Sorta long. . .
Warnings: Mentions of abuse/disordered behaviour.
Pairing: Not romantic yet, Toby’s just clingy n stuff. FEM READER. <3
◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢◤◢
How did you meet?
Back in middle school.
Toby and Lyra were known as the German exchange students. They were placed in your class about halfway through your first semester. The twins ended up living in Colorado after their dad had some business to finish in the u.s. He’s a business man who’s wife relies on him to keep her job. By the way did I mention that he sucks? Your parents don’t, so congrats! <3
All of your parents are financially rich? Sorta? Rich enough to place you in the same private boarding school a few years later.
Connie, their mom, loves you like her daughter. Absolute sweetheart. Would kill for u trust.
You clicked with Lyra on the basis of being queer (she’s lesbian), Toby because he was a package deal and you were acting normal with him (he’s not used to that sorta treatment!)
Toby stuck to Lyra like GLUE. He’d follow her everywhere. One time you saw him pulling at her shirt when she tried to leave to see her friend. She had to bring him with her.
To be honest, Toby looked pretty weak and malnourished when you first met, he was also EXTREMELY hesitant to get involved with you outside of Lyra’s interactions with you. The moment you had laughed ((instead of getting mad. . )) after his tic made him pull at your hair, I swear he fell in love with u /hj
Genuinely he is so quick to get out of his shell and follow you like a lost puppy. It’s like a, ‘’do I follow Lyra, or (name)??? Shit shit who’’ situation when you two decide to split.
You realised he was pretty reserved at first because of his time back in Germany. Elementary kids were RUTHLESS with him, and he had to be homeschooled. Lyra and Toby were separated, and he was worried something would happen to him or her now that they were. Luckily for him, his dad had already planned for them to move to the u.s (not out of kindness for Toby, like I said guy’s a business man).
Both were fluent in English, but Toby was comfortable placing a few German words here and there throughout his speech.
He eats junk for lunch. You started bringing him lunch. He’s eager to reach into your lunchbox if you have something he wants. Lyra smacks his hand and tells him to behave. You usually end up giving him what he had wanted. Toby wants u sooo bad after that.
Does he have a crush on you? Maybe. He can’t figure it out if he does. He sure acts like a boyfriend.
Lyra and you are ying and yang. You don’t deal with anyone’s bullshit in your time in middle school, and actively protect Toby from any stares or aggressive advances.
Toby is SHOOOOORT!!! OMG. He’s so short like at least to your nose. Lyra’s a bit taller, she’s your height.
Despite Toby’s shortness he treats you as if you were the one smaller and needed his constant protection (by being physically affectionate). If you ask him about it, he tells you that you’re clearly in need of his aid (bro himself is gonna get blown away by the wind?? what protection is he talking about)
Toby has a mix of bipolar/BPD, therapists weren’t able to set the exact diagnosis. You’re (un)fortunately his FP. Yeah, good luck with that??
You were mindblown when you’d accidentally spilled his cup of hot chocolate on him and he didn’t even flinch. ‘’Yeah, he can’t feel that’’ Lyra just drops the lore bomb on you. Toby just complains about his pants being ruined. You’re just there like ??? Sorry but also what
You made Lyra tell you about all his conditions. You spent about an entire night studying what made him unique. Toby was staring at you when you had told him about it (he wanted to lock you in his room, and never let u leave after you admitted it).
How about high school?
WEELCOME TO YOUR HIGH SCHOOL ERA.
You’re all in the same main class, but you have certain classes which separate you.
It’s a private school so any bullying towards Toby is less common, but he has an entire group basically against him being in the school (they find him really annoying and not worthy of attending their school)
Lyra and Toby are taller than you now. About a head taller. Yup, a COMPLETE switch up from middle school. They tease you about this, ESPECIALLY Toby.
‘’Why are you so short, hu-huh??’’ And he’s grinning like a maniac. Hit him and he’ll laugh.
He’s much bigger now since he was quick to get himself involved with the gym on his campus and a LOT of outdoor activities. It helps him vent out his anger and frustrations. Did I mention he does a lot of wood chopping? He’s fascinated by hatchets. . . Wow! Wonder how that’s gonna affect him in the future.
Lyra’s the popular girl! But she’s kind and awesome,and she makes sure to bring you to every party she has access to. You two party a LOT. If Toby joins, it’s to be you and Lyra’s body guard. He doesn’t know what to do at parties and sorta just stands there beside you waiting for suggestions. Eventually he’ll loosen a bit up.
Lyra’s a cheerleader and you’re her biggest fan. You shout the loudest from the crowd during her performances, ‘’that’s MY girl!’’ And shit everyone thinks you’re dating now??
She had to clarify that you weren’t dating on her twitter. People were both surprised (and disappointed). Toby spammed L to those who said homophobic shit. He gets into arguments on twitter a LOT.
Speaking about arguments, Toby gets more physical as years pass. It’s not uncommon to be wrestled by the guy. He loves asserting any and all power over you. Why? Cause he’s a jerk and he craves your full attention at times. YOU’LL NEVER WIN SORRY THAT GUY IS INHUMANELY STRONG. Never does it to Lyra though. She can smack him and he won’t raise a finger.
Toby’s still reserved but more confidently now. He’s not reserved in the way that, ‘look at that guy, what a loner!’’ It’s more, ‘’yeah I’m not gonna mess with that guy he’s kinda weird’’. He likes it that way. Toby wants only to be around you and Lyra, anyway.
YOU HAVE A LOT OF FRIENDS THOUGH. (Toby’s secretly tweaking at that). You spend a lot of time with them but make sure to fill in on Toby’s needs. Your main is Lyra and Toby though.
How are you in class?
Lyra and you, to your parent’s delight, are the golden students. You excel in every subject, except German. It’s so difficult??
Toby corrects you during german class. He turns around on his chair to face you. ‘’It’s ich not ish. Wow, since when was I - don’t throw! - so smart?’’
He says that because he sucks in basically every other subject (except p.e, which is optional). He targets the hell out of you if you join p.e. You’re backed into a wall and he’s standing in front of you with a ball in his hand. ‘’Run, come on! Want to see how you’d -wow!- escape this.’’ Anyway back to German class. Toby will tell you to say certain phrases.
‘’Say ich liebe dich’’ . You stare at him and raise your eyebrow questioning him with the look on your face. ‘’Come on, juh-just do it!’’ He’d roll his eyes at your stubbornness. After you do it, he smiles. He makes. A heart with his hands and winks at you. ‘’Ich liebe dich auch.’’
After you found out what he meant through studying in class, you were like ????? Lyra giggled.
NGL you two are in a situationship. None of you are adressing the tension. When Lyra asks Toby about it he’s like, ‘’can’t a guy tuh-tease his - My girl! Woo, She’s my girl!- … Shut up! Damn.’’ He was saying that to his tourettes more than Lyra. His ears were RED.
Tbh she’s curious about how far your relationship would go.
she genuinely wonders if you have the hots for her brother. She asks you about it and even if you deny her accusation she’ll teasingly be like, ‘’that’s sooo weird he’s my brother. . .! Anyway so when’s the marriage.’’ And you’d throw a pillow at her shortly after.
#ticci toby#toby rogers creepypasta#ticcy toby#tobias erin rogers#toby rogers#creepypasta x reader#creepypasta#ticci toby creepypasta#ticci toby headcanons#lyra rogers creepypasta#lyra rogers#lyra creepypasta#ticci toby x reader#toby x reader#creepypasta ticci toby#toby creepypasta#toby rogers headcanons#“ticci” toby rogers#toby rogers x reader#toby rogers x you#tobias rogers#toby erin rogers#creepypasta fandom#creepypasta headcanon#creepy pasta
16 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ahh I'm glad I inspired you! If you ever wanted to post your own high school AU I'd LOVE to read itt. And I agree with them both being kissable😌
I want to say thank you to everyone supporting the Honesty series, it means a lot to me and I'm happy that you guys enjoy it! to celebrate here are some little extra things going on with characters you've met and some you haven't! 🤭





53 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm glad you like them! I'm def not crushing on the sister either... 🤫
I want to say thank you to everyone supporting the Honesty series, it means a lot to me and I'm happy that you guys enjoy it! to celebrate here are some little extra things going on with characters you've met and some you haven't! 🤭





53 notes
·
View notes
Text
✄ - - - - - - - -
Always Forever Masterlist
Parts: [Prologue]
Look up ‘Character Status’ to figure out what characters are up to behind scenes.💟💟💟
Spotify playlist: 🎧
Cast Extras: none
Hcs & Side stories: none
Extras do not contain spoilers unless said in warnings.
✄ - - - - - - - -
0 notes
Text
I think im js gonna delete my honesty series and start a new one😭 so im gonna js do a poll for this
4 notes
·
View notes
Note
hi!! First of all happy belated birthday no idea when you’ll see this but 🥳 I just wanted to see if you could just do some general kinda fluff for Toby and any other of your choosing during like the crush stage
also you are an amazing writer and incredibly creative whoever the douchebag who stood you up is doesn’t deserve you so get yourself a better man bc if anyone deserves it it’s you<3
so yeah that’s the end of my little rant and feel free to just ignore this ask, put yourself first!
-A ❤️
Summary :: Toby during the crush stage
Notes :: thank you so much!🤭 You are too sweet! btw I didn't know which Toby you wanted so I js did High school Toby but I can always change it if you want and make another one for him💟 I'm prob going to add Jeff later but I js wanted to get this out as soon as possible
Warnings :: none that I can think of except for the usual cursing
Readers gender :: None assigned, gender neutral
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
This guy is so fucking mean for no reason but hates whenever anyone else is mean to you
He bullies you because he doesn't know how to respond to his own emotions and he has absolutely 0 experience. Plus, he thinks you're only talking to him to mess with him at first
I can see him falling for someone because they were nice to him or because he found them physically attractive as bad as it may sound to some people. But, he does know when someone is only being nice because they feel bad or they are just trying to mess with his feelings he just wants to be treated like a normal human being not get made fun of or have people be overly nice to him because of his disorders but we can get more into those emotions another time.
Even though he can most of the time tell the difference between genuine kindness and people feeling bad, sometimes he may think that people are messing with him when they actually are being genuinely nice because he overthinks everything and lets his bad thoughts take over a lot of the time.
Would definitely zone out while staring at you as he bites his nails and hands... Gets so many side eyes and weird stares because of it too
thinks about you 24/7 to the point it affects his daily life and his mother and sister get worried
He would probably mistake his romantic feelings for platonic at first but when he realizes the only thing that changes is how mean he is to you and I don't mean he gets nicer 😃 your #1 hater and #1 supporter
He's honestly confusing, one minute he'll be thinking you hate him and he doesn't have a chance to thinking he does have a chance and that you have the same feelings for him as he does for you.
Meaning that there's like a 30% he will make a first move on you because you have to catch him in the right mood, at the right time, on the right day which is pretty hard because you'll never know what mood he'll be in and he
He literally just acts like he hates you and if you asked him out or made a move he'd turn it down but then out of no where months later he will ask you out
he's honestly such an attention whore and he only craves your attention now so good luck
the only time he can really talk to you in person outside of school is if you happen to be friends with his sister or you guys meet up somewhere like a park or a cafe which isn't that often because of his parents so he makes up for it by texting you all day
Reminder though that he isn't some soft and shy bundle of joy who is just hurt, he is crazy and is slowly going under the control of Slenderman. He can have major mood swings and will most likely make you end up not liking him for the way he treats you at first, he doesn't mean it tho he's just a lil delulu 😊
Overall, your experience is gonna be a rough 5/10 unless you don't mind his harsh words then it'd be like a 6.5 - 7.5
#creepypasta#ticci toby#ticci toby x reader#toby rogers creepypasta#ticci toby creepypasta#highschool Toby Rogers#ticcy toby#creepypasta toby#toby x reader#toby rogers x reader#ticci toby headcanons#toby rogers#ticci toby x you#toby rogers x you#tobias erin rogers#toby erin rogers#tobias rogers
209 notes
·
View notes