Eventually this will be a tournament between Doctor Who stories of all kinds, for now we produce a ranking to use for seeding, one poll posted a week, polls will be open for two weeks, with results announced after they close
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Text
Series 15 Roundup:
Episode Rankings:
By original score:
The Story and the Engine
The Well
Lux
The Interstellar Song Contest
The Robot Revolution
Wish World
Lucky Day
The Reality War
By week on score:
The Story and the Engine
The Well
Lux
The Robot Revolution
Lucky Day
The Interstellar Song Contest
Wish World
The Reality War
Overall Maximums, Minimums and Averages
highest original rating: The Story and the Engine, 8.34
highest week on rating: The Story and the Engine, 8.4
lowest original rating: The Reality War, 3.47
lowest week on rating: The Reality War, 2.96
average original rating: 6.91 (7.48 excluding the final two episodes)
average week on score: 6.46 (7.19 excluding the final two episodes)
series rating: 5.86
How does this stack up with the rest of the era?
[yikes, does that make things look bad]
Episode Rankings:
By original score:
The Star Beast
Wild Blue Yonder
Rogue
The Story and the Engine
Boom
The Well
The Legend of Ruby Sunday
Lux
73 Yards
Dot and Bubble
The Giggle
The Devil's Chord
The Church on Ruby Road
The Interstellar Song Contest
The Robot Revolution
Wish World
Empire of Death
Joy to the World
Space Babies
Lucky Day
The Reality War
By week on score (note, the christmas specials were not polled):
Wild Blue Yonder
The Story and the Engine
Rogue
Boom
73 Yards
The Well
Dot and Bubble
The Star Beast
Lux
The Giggle
The Legend of Ruby Sunday
The Devil's Chord
The Robot Revolution
Lucky Day
The Interstellar Song Contest
Empire of Death
Space Babies
Wish World
The Reality War
Averages:
60th Specials: Original - 8.44, Week on - 8.07
Series 14: Original - 7.61, Week on - 7.34, Overall - 6.98
Series 15: Original - 6.91, Week on - 6.46, Overall - 5.86
My thoughts:
Series 15 is clearly by far the weakest, however it is safe to assume these results are skewed by the abysmal finale, excluding the polls for the final two episodes the results are much closer to, though still below those of series 14
I would like to specifically point out the results of The Reality War, no other story, across the whole era, recieved a score of less than 6 the first go around, and only two (Wish World and Space Babies, and even then just barely) scored less than a 6 the second time around, The Reality War managed half of that. Additionally, the lowest previous mode of 6 belonged to Space Babies on only its follow up poll, The Reality War has a mode of 1, and the second highest levels of agreement across any previously conducted. Aside from Wild Blue Yonder, the most popular options on any given poll fall between 20 and 35%, The Reality War was scored a 1 by around 40% of people. The dislike for the episode cannot be understated
Episode Breakdown
The Robot Revolution (Original) mean: 6.93, mode: 7 (31%)
The Robot Revolution (Week on) mean: 6.75, mode: 7 (30.5%)
Lux (Original) mean: 7.88, mode: 8 (31.9%)
Lux (Week on) mean: 7.48, mode: 8 (30.6%)
The Well (Original) mean: 8.26, mode: 9 (30.6%)
The Well (Week on) mean: 7.90, mode: 8 (33.6%)
Lucky Day (Original) mean: 6.43, mode: 7 (23%)
Lucky Day (Week on) mean: 6.30, mode: 7 (33.7%)
The Story and the Engine (Original) mean: 8.34, mode: 9 (27.3%)
The Story and the Engine (Week on) mean: 8.40, mode: 8 (28.1%)
The Interstellar Song Contest (Original) mean: 7.00, mode: 8 (22.2%)
The Interstellar Song Contest (Week on) mean: 6.28, mode: 8 (20.7%)
Wish World (Original) mean: 6.93, mode: 9 (19.8%)
Wish World (Week on) mean: 5.62, mode: 7 (22.1%)
The Reality War (Original) mean: 3.47, mode: 1 (39.4%)
The Reality War (Week on) mean: 2.96, mode: 1 (39.8%)
series as a whole mean: 5.86, mode: 7 (26.8%)
63 notes
·
View notes
Text
heres a preview of the updated results
the dropoff is practically vertical
MASTERPOST
104 notes
·
View notes