haruka-branding - Tumblr blog

[haruka-branding]

Perspectives on Burberry's Presence in Japan

When I asked ChatGPT 4.0 regarding which luxury brand is least likely to suffer from counterfeits, it suggested Hermes as the brand least susceptible to counterfeit damage. This is based on Hermes' emphasis on craftsmanship, limited production runs, discreet branding with no specific logo, rich heritage, and premium pricing.

I agree with the view that Hermes is the least likely to be negatively impacted by counterfeiting. Recently, I watched a YouTube video showcasing the artisanal process behind Hermes bags at its leather atelier in Paris (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7LJrU4443Q). The video highlighted how Hermes draws inspiration from its equestrian heritage for its contemporary bag designs and emphasized that each bag is meticulously handcrafted by skilled French artisans, with a single picnic bag requiring 19 hours of labor. I admire Hermes' commitment to artisanal craftsmanship, timeless aesthetic, and restricted production. These attributes align with the critical success factors outlined in the case study, namely mystique, allure, scarcity, sophistication, craftsmanship, and exclusivity.

Conversely, Burberry, while possessing a reputation for its mystique, allure, and sophistication, which come from its timeless design and British heritage, lacks the same emphasis on craftsmanship and exclusivity, based on my experience and observation.

Growing up in Japan, I observed Burberry's collaboration with its licensee, a company called Mitsui, over an extended period, as detailed in the case study. Mitsui sublicensed the Burberry brand to Sanyo Shokai, a Japanese apparel manufacturer, which also developed its own Burberry-affiliated lines, "Burberry Blue Label" and "Black Label," targeting younger demographics. Sanyo Shokai also manufactures a range of products, including school uniforms, which have become associated not only with Burberry but also with other brands. These ventures diluted the perception of Burberry's craftsmanship and exclusivity in Japan. I remember my mother often said to me, "Burberry products made by Sanyo Shokai, while of decent quality, do not embody the true essence of Burberry, and thus, I would not purchase them in Japan."

In conclusion, while Burberry enjoys a heritage of timeless design and British mystique, I believe it could enhance its brand legacy, particularly in Japan, by placing a greater emphasis on craftsmanship and exclusivity.

[haruka-branding]

The parallels between predicting product diffusion and valuing companies for IPO

When I read the article "Four Products: Predicting Diffusion," I couldn't help but reflect on my prior experience in investment banking, particularly in executing IPOs and pricing company valuations within the technology, media, and telecommunications sectors.

The article resonated with me as it illuminated a common challenge faced in investment banking: determining the optimal valuation for a company going public, especially when the company introduces a completely new concept or product to the market. In my role, accurately pricing an IPO was crucial for satisfying institutional clients and ensuring a successful market debut. However, valuing a company with a groundbreaking product posed unique challenges akin to predicting demand for a new brand or product. Much like the article's discussion on new-to-the-world products, such companies lacked direct comparables or benchmarks in the market, making traditional valuation methods less applicable.

To address this challenge, my team and I employed various strategies, which involved analyzing companies across different sectors and regions to identify similarities in business models or structures. This analysis helped us gauge market sentiment and potential demand for the company's innovative business. However, despite our efforts, accurately forecasting demand for these pioneering companies remained a daunting task. One of the risks we faced was the tendency for companies to overestimate demand, leading to an inflated IPO price. This optimistic valuation could initially attract investors but often resulted in a post-IPO stock price decline as investors realized the discrepancy between the perceived and actual value of the company. This scenario mirrored the article's cautionary points of product managers misjudging consumer acceptance, resulting in significant market misfires.

The comparison between predicting product diffusion and valuing companies for IPO underscores the inherent uncertainty and complexity of introducing novel concepts to the market. Both necessitate a deep hypothesis regarding consumer behavior and market dynamics, as well as the capacity to discern potential roadblocks to adoption.

[haruka-branding]

The Power of Storytelling in the World of Wine: A memorable trip to a winery in Japan

As I immersed myself in the Concha y Toro case, memories of a special trip to a Japanese winery came flooding back. The journey began with a simple question from my father: "My friend, who worked in the finance industry for almost 30 years, suddenly quit his job and started a winery. Should we visit him?" We embarked on a two-hour drive from Tokyo to Nagano prefecture.

It was a very hot day in July. The owner greeted us with a big, warm smile. He showed us around the huge vineyard, with rows and rows of grapevines as far as we could see. As we walked, he shared stories of his daily routine, waking up at 4 a.m. to tend to the vines, which were all grown organically without pesticides. Organic practices, meticulous care, and a deep reverence for nature were at the heart of his winemaking philosophy. From inspecting each branch for pests to strategically positioning pillars to harness sunlight, every action spoke volumes about his dedication to quality. He also talked about the challenges of winemaking, like dealing with unpredictable weather that can affect grape production. Despite the hurdles, his passion for winemaking was unwavering.

Tasting the wine, I understood that it wasn't just about the flavor; It was about the stories behind it that truly captivated me. The decision to leave behind a stable career in finance for the uncertainty of winemaking underscored the transformative power of pursuing one's passion.

Since that memorable visit, my father has made it a nightly ritual to savor a glass of wine that the owner makes. Yet, it's not just about the taste—it's about feeling connected to his friend's journey, one that embodies courage, passion, and unwavering support.

This experience taught me that while quality is undoubtedly important, storytelling truly sets wine apart. Whether it's the rich history of Concha y Toro or the vibrant narrative of Chilean wines, compelling stories have the power to shape brand perception and foster a global community of enthusiasts. In a world with plentiful choices, it is the stories we tell that leave a lasting impression, transcending geographical boundaries and forging bonds that endure beyond the last sip.