#GIVEUSMOREROSE2K17

[smokysteventheories-blog]

Rose in the Room, Real or Fake?

This question has plagued me ever since the episode Storm in the Room aired. It seems the answer should be simple enough. No, that Rose was merely a creation of the room, the Crewniverse have stated multiple times before that Rose is not coming back. I know that. I believe that.

Yet again, something in Rose’s final lines, before she disappears, seems so raw, so real. The Rose we see in the rest of the episode is a stark contrast to the Rose seen previously. Her facial expressions before have an artificial feel to them, the audience can clearly tell that this Rose is a product of the room.

Yet, at the line, “Steven, you know that isn't true. In the tape I left you, I told you I how much I wanted to have you and let you exist. Do you think what I said to you in the tape was a lie?”, she seems much more raw and real. Sure, I’m willing to accept that the room was telling Steven what he wanted to hear, but the possibility of Rose being able to communicate with Steven through the room doesn’t seem too farfetched.

This is especially considering Steven says next, “I get it. I know you didn't want me to deal with your problems. You're a part of me now. I have to deal with what you left behind.” 

Rose is a part of Steven. What better place to communicate than inside the one room that literally comes into being because of Rose's gem?.

That, and I really want more Rose. It’s kind of a problem.