#and invalidates criticism of Jason's behaviour based on ethical arguments wrt this specific list | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

glitter-stained · 8 days ago

Text

Some Bruce & Batfam fans Jason antis will be like "emotions and affect shouldn't cloud your judgement killing is wrong!" and then rank Jason beating Tim up or kidnapping Mia higher in their list of his worse offences than the duffle bag of doom

#not to be a hater but omg #like i get it #killing an unnamed goon is killing an unnamed goon #i'm not shedding any tear over them either #but you can't both let your attachment to those characters alter your evaluation of Jason's ethics #and claim that Jason is wrong for believing affect and attachment should have an impact on moral judgement #it doesn't make sense #dc #jason todd #dc comics #anti bruce wayne #anti batman #< i think would be the most useful for filtering in that case #can't exactly tag “anti jason antis”#“he blew up her school!” he blew up a gym with no one in it. he blew up a car with people in it. not to mention a building.#why is the gym a worse offense to you. why do you think.#and before you argue that attachment doesn't have the same level as real life emotions because it exists on a meta level #the sheer fact your meta attachment is being taken into account in the making of that ranking #makes the definition of what counts as *worst* offenses completely obsolete from an ethical standpoint #and invalidates criticism of Jason's behaviour based on ethical arguments wrt this specific list

131 notes · View notes