Tumgik
#but at this point in their life kate doesn't know HOW to be sisterly without the mother-overtones slipping through
alicuntisms · 2 years
Text
the way so many people talk about edwina in the show as the diamond basically reducing her to an object to be won is disheartening. 
#i guess this is my edwina sharma rewatch#we're on off to the races my dudes#and it just hammers home how anthony is edwina's rebellion against kate#and considering the parentification of kate i think the idea that anthony is in part edwina's teenage rebellion makes sense#and yet again i think the fandom just forgot about the conversation that kate and edwina have while waiting for the queen#like you can see even then that she's falling for anthony's performance#that while the little subterfuge with dorset was rude#she also buys anthony's line about how he just wanted to spend time with edwina#kate is the one who thinks that it's anthony trying to make her look stupid#edwina does not#and thus we see the beginning of the cracks in their relationship#i think coming to england really make edwina want SISTERLY advice from kate verus s the mom advice she's probably used to getting from kate#but at this point in their life kate doesn't know HOW to be sisterly without the mother-overtones slipping through#and like i know people are like 'they're sisters! a man shouldn't come between them!'#which is fair#but shit like this happens all the time#both in fiction and the real world#so it's not cray-cray that it's happening here#and like at the end of the day#even though the sharmas are messy as fuck#they just come off a much more interesting/real for me personally#than their book counterparts#there is literally nothing wrong with adding strife to a family dynamic#especially one as slightly complicated as the sharmas are considering their history#i will admit that this didn't come across very well in the show but i personally think it's there#if y'all could just put your biases aside of course#i think focusing on edwina's struggles throughout the series makes sense from a narrative standpoint#the sharmas and the bridgertons are the main families for s2 after all#literally the only sideplot i cannot get behind and resent is the featheringtons#like the way all of that should have been saved for season three will never stop pissing me off
6 notes · View notes
lenfaz · 2 years
Text
Bridgerton S2, E3
Well, that was a rollercoaster and in almost the best way possible!
After episode 2 I was a little hesitant, but I have to say that this is still going as semi-expected. I have not ranted at the screen (that much)
- Aubrey Hall is every bit as beautiful and enchanting as I imagined it, and I loved how Kate is so taken by it while Edwina is... the Edwina we all know and love
- Newton's apperarances gave me life
- The flashbacks! OMG the flashbacks, I can't even with the amazing work both actors brought to show the heartwrenching moment that it was losing Edmund. We know from the books *why* Anthony doesn't want to fall in love and I was wondering how they were going to tell us/show us that. And I think they did a fantastic job translating those words into the flashbacks we see. I think the addition of seeing Violet going through grief and depression is so powerful. We don't want to think of that, bc is Violet and we know she loves her children and we know she'll be there for them, but this is a very plausible outcome of her grieving and having post partum depression and I think showing Anthony dealing with that at such young age is a great way to show why he doesn't want to fall in love. The scene between Anthony and Violet is just so beautiful and so on point. I cried. I did
- PALL MALL! ok, this was not how my mind ever imagined Pall Mall... (it was a lot more ruthless and rusticating in my view) but I loved every minute of it. It's much too short, MUCH TOO SHORT, but it does a great job to show them being *them* and how much he really enjoys her company without him even knowing it. I loved the heart to heart they had and how he starts to really see her. And how much she's starting to realize she wants him for herself. It's subtle, but you can see it in Simone's performance and it's A-class acting.
- I'm not crazy about Edwina crying over Anthony not proposing, but it's clear that while they tried to hide the truth from her, she knows she needs to marry well to ensure her family's future. That is why she's working so hard to please Anthony and it's so sad when he doesn't propose. It's not because she has feelings for him. That is my story and I'm sticking to it.
- I loved how they managed to weave in the "Kate likes strong tea" into the story. It's a small thing, but it does tie well with this version of Kate and I really like that they have it there.
- I loved that they included the tidbit that Anthony doesn't read at all while Edwina loves books. I'm going to pretend that was a friendly brotherly/sisterly conversation, Lady Danbury and Violet be damned.
- Daphne knows. DAPHNE KNOWS and it's so amazing that she went directly to Kate thinking that was the person her brother chose. Because you know, Anthony couldn't spend more than 2 minutes with Edwina before he needed to find Kate.
- Benedict is a fuckboy, Colin is ... Colin and Eloise whining is getting on my nerves. Also, sorry but Eloise never cared about being compared to Daphne
- WHY IS COLIN NOT EATING IN ANY OF THESE EPISODES?
- I'm not sure I'm liking this Penelope thing, but it is true that she had someone helping her in the books, so I'll accept it for now. I'm bumped that we clearly won't see Anthony going to her rescue and that sucks because I loved that scene so much.
- The bee scene, OMG THE BEE SCENE I CANNOT BREATHE PEOPLE. His angst, his absolute terror that he's going to lose her, you see in his eyes that he's terrified and the way she tries to calm him, and comfort him and the panting and the heavy breathing and omg. It was perfection, perfection, except for... WHY THE FUCK DID YOU NOT KISS THE WOMAN ANTHONY? But omg, that pent up frustration, once they finally let go... THINGS WILL BE COMBUSTING.
and this is the ranting part: I'm now even more pissed that I was last season that they stole the "I burn for you" line from this book. Not only because it's Anthony's line, but because they stole it from Kate, who needed that line, that love, that devotion, a lot more than Daphne. Daphne was well regarded by all, and praised by her beauty, whereas Kate was the ugly spinster sister of the Incomparable and we know how much she felt that to the core. So to have Anthony telling her that he burned just for her, was such a powerful moment. They better bring me something on this or I'll be mad
- As usual, the Featheringtons continue to be the most delightful thing in this show. Prudence is the best. The best. I cannot believe they didn't give us Felicity, because I would have loved to have the drawing room scene in its full glory in Colin and Pen's book. Also, if coursin Featherington wants Cressida, by all means he can have that wrecked harpy. We all know Portia can rise to that challenge.
6 notes · View notes