#i remember one case in his last year when alito was trying to pose a question and the advocate kept fighting the hypo and alito | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

mourning-again-in-america · 1 year

Text

justice kavanaugh is surprisingly good at explicitly highlighting cruxes, namely, hypotheticals not very distant from our own reality in which under the advocate's own argument, said advocate must lose. i wish i saw more of that!

#the current supreme court lineup is *really* good at producing interesting questions #hell jackson would be a straightforward improvement on breyer if she didn't share the sotomayor/alito thing of trying to skewer the #opposition when she thinks she can; she lacks former justice breyer's warm-heartedness and merriment #i remember one case in his last year when alito was trying to pose a question and the advocate kept fighting the hypo and alito #really kept going at it; after a few minutes breyer stepped in and concocted one of his elaborate nonsensical questions and asked #alito if this captured his point; and alito choking back laughter said yes and even the advocate thought it was pretty funny #the current court is too aggro but i don't mind it as much; i just wish jackson would cut down on the length of her questions if she's not #going to be making everyone's lives so much better like breyer did; novel-length questions they may have been

2 notes · View notes