ten years later...
[Česká Verze]
This has been kicking around my head as of late, I have a dear new friend who doesn’t speak much English, and I’ve wanted to tell him about this weird, terrible moment in my life that fundamentally changed who I am and how I will forever interact with the world (both in good ways and bad). But I don’t know how to. So I am writing it all down, which is something I have never done. And then I will leave it here, and of course, once a year I will remember and shake my fist at the world for myself and all the other victims of violent men, and then I will put my fist down, and get back to living my life. It’s that time of year, though...
I’ve been thinking about this a lot. It comes unbidden in the middle of the night. When someone is walking too quickly toward me. When someone says something inappropriate online or in person. When too many of the boxes, of that pattern of violence I have permanently etched in my head, get ticked… I think:
“Ten years ago someone tried to kill you... maybe you should run.”
(Obvious content warnings apply, readers: Violence.)
Ten years is so long. I have adapted. I have moved past it. But the parts of that night, those horrific hours in the morning… 4am. 5am. In the ER by 6am… the parts that are left, I feel are going to stay with me forever.
They don’t haunt, so much. They are just there. In the corners. They keep me aware. So in some ways, they keep me safe.
Daniel Rhinehardt was my housemate. (How do I refer to him? There is nothing colloquial about him at all, but since this is going up online, as a statement of public record, as a possible search result for Google, that might warn some poor woman who doesn’t know… Daniel Rhinehardt is his name, and I will refer to him as such.) We did lots of things together, because I am the type, I have discovered, who likes housemates as community. I have had many successful versions of communal housemates, who cooked together, or went on mundane errands, that sort of thing. With no hidden agenda, no sense of obligation… healthy relationships between people. This was not one of them. But I was too young and naive to figure that out in time.
I won’t go into too many details, but this man became obsessed with me. I remember being on tour for a month, bills paid in advance, and I received harassing phone calls from him because I hadn’t called him, or some nonsense like that. We did our first Dragon Con (major convention in Atlanta, that I performed at or now do puppetry at) that year, and he came with us to sell merch. I woke up one morning in my band’s hotel room to find him in bed next to me, which unnerved me (I had specifically requested my female friend sleep with me, to keep this weird toxicity I was starting to pick up on away). I was looking for apartments in September of 2008. I was looking. I hadn’t said anything, but I knew I had to leave, but I just didn’t pull it all together fast enough.
On September 20th, 2008, at my friend David’s birthday, Rhinehardt got drunk. At the time I did not drink and was babysitting friend of mine on the roof. They were a bit touchy feely as they were on some other substances, but I didn’t mind. I trusted them and I knew I was in control of my situation. When we decided it was time for me to go to bed, we all cuddled a bit and they each kissed me goodnight. They were a married couple, and there was nothing untoward with silly friendly kisses, but it set Rhinehardt off. He started yelling nonsense and threw a chair off the roof (it was caught by a lower tier, and did not fall to the street). He stormed off screaming garbled obscenities and was gone. The night was thrown into disarray. We tried to call him because we were all concerned. But I was also starting to panic. I took a hit of my inhaler and we went back downstairs into David’s apartment. I sat on her bed while some friends talked me down and told me I really needed to move out. I agreed and told them how I had been looking, but couldn’t find anything at the time. I don’t know how long we were there in the apartment when Rhinehardt came back in, yelling nonsense, walked straight in at me and stabbed me in the side.
I would like to take a brief moment to mention a memory that I can never shake. One day, apropos of nothing, Daniel Rhinehardt told me that if he was ever going to stab someone he would make sure to swing in from the side. That is where all the organs are, defenseless. It was so much more work to stab from the front or the back because of the ribcage. He *told* me that once. Well before, I think, he had any designs of stabbing me… but he told me that. He thought it was impressive. This vast knowledge of violence.
“...stabbed me in the side.” It looks so small to read it back. Such a small action. How does it reverberate even now?
Thankfully I had enough reactionary sense to move as much as I could, being seated on a bed, and turned myself away so that his fist, no, knife… both... hit my hip and lodged there 3 inches, (8cm or so), instead of my side. My organs were spared, and while the scar tissue presses against it, my sciatic nerve and artery were both missed.
I screamed. He pulled the knife back and tried to stab me again, but was pulled off by someone else. Matt McCorkle, David Forbes, and Luke Withrow all had a hand in saving my life that night. Sometimes I wonder what would have happened if they weren’t there, if I had gone home. Best not to think about it, not now or ever. It would not have been good. As fucked as I was, I was still somehow, always, lucky.
Then came the insanity that was bleeding all over my friend’s bed and floor. Rhinehardt was pushed out of the apartment, the door was locked. Every time someone knocked on that door I lost my shit, completely terrified. But at the same time I was in shock and trying to sort out how I could avoid going to the hospital, one seemingly completely logical thought was: Matt’s dad was a vet… so we had access to medical supplies? My health insurance did not start for another TEN DAYS. (Thank you for absolutely nothing, America.) 911 was called, because of course it was. I had been stabbed right in front of a group of friends and party-goers. I was left, lying on the floor, while Luke and Danielle held towels against my hip and thigh to try to stop the bleeding.
That’s how it went for 20 minutes? 2 hours? I could not tell (of course it couldn’t have been 2 hours, but I lost all track fo time). Eventually paramedics arrived, cut my pants off, staunch the bleeding as best they could (my inhaler I took during the panic attack was working as a blood thinner, so that was miserable) and whisked me away.
Shock is a wonderful feeling. I mean, it’s horrible, but it does keep you calm. I “made friends” with them, they were very excited about their new sealing product for puncture wounds. They whisked me into an ER. Where I was photographed, documented, scrubbed, sutured, stapled, and asked a million questions I didn’t know how to answer.
Meanwhile everyone was sort of detained at the apartment -now crime scene- to give statements. More photographs were taken. I’m told they are available somewhere, public record, but I’ve never seen them. I’ve asked once, but was unable to track them down.
I was told by the detective on my case, no, *the* case (it would become very apparent that this was not MY case, rather I was the VICTIM in the STATE’s case) that I could not go home. It was not safe. Did I have anywhere to go? Anyone I could stay with? I didn’t know. I had friends… but I knew Matt, Amanda, David, Luke, Danielle… but I didn’t know anyone’s last names, didn’t know how to contact anyone… I am not sure if I even had my phone, no… now that I think of it,I think my phone and my bag were left behind on the floor of the apartment. I was given crutches, scrubs (again, my pants had been cut off), and my shoes, and a voucher for a taxi, and discharged around 9am.
I was given back my shoes. Little beat up black ballet flats. I just stared at them. They were splattered with blood. I stood there in what must be one of the most cinematic scenes of my life, a mess, leaning on crutches, completely alone in a hospital lobby, as the sun crested the mountain and poured over me. A man offered me a wheelchair, but due to the location of my wound, I was unable to sit down. I hobbled to the sidewalk… I had no bag, no belongings, just my shoes in my hands, and as the cab driver came over to me I saw Luke and Danielle turn the corner. They had come to find me, and subsequently adopt me. We went back to Matt and Amanda’s apartment, which was in the same building as mine. Rhinehardt was still in jail at the time, so we went through my apartment and grabbed some essentials. Some clothes, my laptop, The Invention of Hugo Cabret (a book I had been meaning to read), Agatha (the cat I had been cat sitting) and some other items I forget. We sat around Matt and Amanda’s apartment for a bit, then, exhausted, back to Luke and Danielle’s where I would live for the next few weeks. Daniel Rhinehardt would be released on bail that night, and he would never go back to jail for this crime. Because that is how the system works in North Carolina.
When I made it back to Luke and Danielle’s house I remember calling my parents.
Calling my friend Tom in the wee hours of the morning, because of the time zone, and leaving a message saying something like “you should call me back as soon as you get this.”
I called work and asked to not come in for a bit. I tried to explain.
These mundane exercises.
I needed to inform my people.
I started using Facebook for only that reason. To tell my people from Charlotte, my hometown (no, I don’t claim that often) that I would be back for a short stay, couldn’t drive, needed help. Needed people around me… I don’t know. I do know that Erich Moffitt, an ex -but I thought friend- never returned my call. Just left me out there, drifting in the darkest void I’ve ever drifted in. So... yeah, a polite fuck you, dude.
Everything went from bad to worse as I tried to recover, but there were still wonderful highlights to cling to. My friend Tom created a paypal donation site for me, as I was uninsured and would need help covering the medical bills (though in the end Victim’s Compensation would cover them, but not before they went into default and cruel creditors would harass me and call the incident of someone stabbing me an “accident”), I was caught by an incredible network of friends in Asheville, who I am forever overjoyed to see, who I can rely on to this day, and I love dearly. My birthday, 2 days later on Sept 23rd, I spent in Charlotte, my parents collected me and took me to their home a few hours away for a few days following which made sense. It was during a gas crisis, but I didn’t know. My friend Mike Walker and his wife Mary came to my parent’s house, collected me in the back of their car, and drove me out for Ethiopian food on my birthday. It was truly special.
I bonded so much with Agatha, the cat, who I was cat sitting, in Luke and Danielle’s little guest room. She was my constant companion as I recovered. I read The Invention of Hugo Cabret. It is one of my favourite books to this day. It is easy, beautiful, densely illustrated, and I would get lost in it. I would read it over and over, or just open it and look at it. It’s still a comfort that I can’t quite describe. Calm, dark, stable. An adventure, but a safe one. (Fun fact, I buy copies of that book whenever I see them in second hand shops, to give to friends. I have one now that was just unknowingly claimed by someone.)
I was wearing my punk rock jacket, covered in patches and badges, when I was stabbed, but thought nothing of it. When I was in the courthouse, filing for a temporary restraining order, I put some coins in my pocket and they fell out onto the floor. The knife had gone straight through. I later stitched it back shut in red, and then silver thread over where the staples had gone. The punkest punk rock jacket. I still have it, but I don’t wear it anymore.
I came back to Asheville too soon, to do a Hellblinki show. I was incredibly out of it. I remember Ian (who I would date for 5 years, much later) visiting that show and hugging me and having no earthly idea what I had been through. (It should have been a warning, really, I think now, but from a place of happiness, love, and sarcasm.) I passed out on the couch at the venue. The bar staff and owner knew what was up and looked out for me, and told me if I ever needed anything, ANYTHING, just come to them. Just go to The Rocket Club and they would sort it. The Rocket Club is gone now, but I think to think that the offer still stands with Ken.
I recovered physically. I used a cane for a while, but eventually, now, I am 99%. That 1% shows up now and again, excruciating pain if getting a massage, or just weird weather patterns and scar tissue.
Emotionally and mentally I am okay. I have PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder), but that’s not surprising. If and when I run into Daniel Rhinehardt, and I have the unbelievable misfortune of doing so now and again, I sort of “blackout”. I go into this incredible fight or flight response moment, and I always choose flight. It’s not an option. It is done for me. I “come to” as I am running down a street, hiding in a bathroom, or driving away (it’s terrifying to sort of “wake up” in your own body and find you’ve been driving a car.) These blackouts aren’t black, but I become much more a passenger and my lizard-brain takes over. I’m mostly aware of what is happening, but I am not the one in control.
Daniel Rhinehardt received no jail time. He was given probation, required counseling, and is a convicted felon. It’s not much. It’s not much, but at least it is not nothing. He does have a record. And he’s added to it since me. That’s the main reason I am writing this. Because he attacked women after me.
I would later have several women come tell me how he had abused them or been violent, but they were always too afraid to go to the police. This breaks my heart and makes me incredibly angry. I would have never been put in this danger if there was some record, if people warned each other about violent men. Thankfully we as a culture are better about that now, ten years later. The sentencing hearing at court would be laughable if it wasn’t so goddamn tragic. Rhinehardt's lawyer claimed he only drank that night because he didn’t want to be rude to his host, then asserting that his drunkenness somehow means his violence wasn’t actually him. David grabbed my hand. I could tell she was furious. I was in a weird state of disbelief and also just acceptance that the NC Court System did not and does not give a fuck about me.
After the court hearing I was dazed. But I remember we walked out into the gray February day, and got coffees. What else can you do? I had gotten knocked about so much over those 5 months that nothing shocked me. I just accepted it as best I could. And had coffee.
I got a restraining order, but every year when I went back to renew it some judge behind a desk made me feel like I didn’t deserve it, because if it had not been violated, why did I need it? One of them, the last one (before I stopped going, not needing to expose myself to that trauma over and over) called me “Miss Rhinehardt”, just truly horrible people who absolutely did not care about me. Again, North Carolina, I am looking at you with so much contempt for how you treat women.
All of my legal work was handled pro bono by Pisgah Legal, and I am thankful to them forever. I was terrified I would not qualify or I would have to prove this happened, or I don’t know what, but no, I was firmly supported and told that the 911 call and the photos were terrible, but also incredibly damning in my favor. An odd benefit, I guess. Also, since my attack is technically domestic violence, I had access to counseling through Helpmate and OurVoice, who are both fantastic resources.
I applied for a passport. Just seemed the right thing to do. I wanted to leave the country. I wanted to leave it all behind for just a bit. The passport came in the mail, but on the same day, a check from Victim’s Compensation reimbursing me, finally, for all the medical bills I had been forced to cover, arrived. I put the two together and a few months later left the country to go do a festival with band family in London and Whitby, and visit my dear friend Xavi Quero in Barcelona, Catalonia.
There’s more mess afterward as well... I can never quite write it all, and maybe what is left out will just fade away into obscurity. But this is enough. Except it is worth saying: a couple years later a woman reached out to me on Facebook because she was dating Daniel Rhinehardt and he was scaring her. She heard about me and wanted to know if “it was all true”. He had told her that he had a record, but said that I had cheated on him or some other nonsense, which is ridiculous for several reasons (we were not dating, gross, and if ever we were- HOW DOES THAT JUSTIFY ATTACKING A WOMAN!?) lots of red flags on that one, but this woman didn’t see them until too late. I did warn her, and she got away, or so I was told. But a few months later he was arrested for assault on a female, and she had a broken jaw. I don’t know if they are the same, but I’ve got decent powers of deduction.
He was arrested another time as well, as I was informed via mugshot (I don’t ever need to see that face again, thank you, but there it was) for another assault on a female. I don’t know the story, I don’t want to know… and I probably already know. It’s a pattern. I recognize patterns.
I mentioned that I’ve run into him. That’s god-awful. I have another friend who looks vaguely like him, which leads to a cute comedy of errors, that still involves a PTSD meltdown for me. I am getting better about it, and this friend knows what I am really asking if I say “Are you at Restaurant X? Or Hey, are you downtown?” because I am giving myself a precious few seconds hoping for a “yes, that’s me!” and then relief… though usually it ends up with me hyperventilating somewhere else, after having run off, literally without thinking.
But, Valerie! You’re usually so positive about things! What is the silver lining of all this?
No. I’m not there yet, but I am getting there. There is something horrible about having someone try to kill you. Someone you trusted. Something that breaks inside you and will never be the same. It’s strange to have a moment when someone else decided they wanted to control your fate, your life, and by control I mean try to fuck it up horrifically, or just… end it. Someone tried to end me. Me. That damaged my psyche for a long time… maybe permanently, though I have put my own spin on it.
There is something about this incident that left me feeling like less of a person, I was to another human being (no matter how terrible a person): dispensable. I will always struggle with that, copying it over to other relationships with decent enough people, this disposability. I don’t have inherently low self esteem or anything, but as I mentioned before, something, some trust in human decency… broke. And I’ve never been able to put it back together right.
I worry that I give this incident too much weight, but I swear to you, fereverently, it weighs only as much as it does. But that fluctuates. Am I digging up the past to make drama? No. I am trying to explain how I got here, how I became the person I am. I am always trying to accept this. Accept the reactions of the people around me. (The local paper referred to me, anonymously, as having been “stabbed in the buttocks”. This led to a weird sort of dark comedy, because how silly it all sounded. Some people would latch onto that, I would sometimes try to laugh about it too, a forced laugh. It was really horrific to have some friends very close to me miss the seriousness of my situation because of one shitty line of reporting. I laughed along, but I was really, really broken about that for a while.)
Trying to explain to a beautiful new friend that I am fine now, but I was not always fine, and that I fought like hell to be the shining happy blueberry girl that I get to be today. But I, like any woman who has ever stepped forward and said: “Hold on, this man did X to me”, I feel like I am fighting a world that will not believe me, despite as my lawyer mentioned, the overwhelming amount of proof, evidence, the fact that this did happen, is documented, and yet people still turn a blind eye, or make excuses. It is maddening. It is soul destroying.
I have people I meet who inadvertently overstep. (I have a creepy neighbour who was following that pattern of violence I mentioned, and I am completely terrified of him.) I still have trouble dealing with them. Almost always men. Men who want to get too close, who miss social cues, who are creepy, who seem to want something from me. I am working on accepting that a man who is interested in me, when I am not interested in him, is not necessarily a threat. They are not all threats. They are not going to try to murder you just because you turn them down. But I am not there yet. I am still working on that. It’s a work in progress...
My positive spin? Pragmatism. I have a deeply ingrained understanding that tomorrow is promised to no one. So now, while I do so responsibly, I am pretty good about going after what I want, in good ways. It took me awhile to work back to this, but I have found a healthy balance of being responsible, and chasing after whimsy because who knows, the world could end tomorrow. My friend, who I mentioned at the top, told me once that I was brave, having caught up to him on a random adventure by myself on the other side of the world. Bravery never occurred to me. It was a factor, sure, I’m brave, but it was really: “No, I want to see this friend. And I could die next week.” I don’t think like that… not really, that I might die next week, month, year… but at the same time I do, but with different wording. I just think “I want this experience in my life, and now might be the only chance I get, so I am going to make it happen to the best of my ability.”
Also, I adventure. I do incredible things, and my life has been pretty spectacular so far. I am proud of the work I have done, the art I have made, and I treasure the friendships I’ve found and the experiences I’ve had. That is my revenge. Daniel Rhinehardt tried to end me. Tried to irreversibly ruin my life, and he failed. And, while it took some time to pull my parts back together, I have done more than just survive him, I have thrived.
A friend mentioned that to me after I had a particularly good day recently (I played puppets with my art hero and fairygodfather, who I will not mention here for the same google search result reasons), she said something along the lines of “You’re doing a lot more than just surviving.” It caught me off guard, I forgot she even knew about my whole getting-stabbed incident… I don’t mind people knowing, it is a part of who I am now. I thought about it, and said “yes.” It’s true. That’s my goal. That’s what I am doing. And I’m okay with that.
I have mentioned a few times that one of the impetus of this tirade of tragedy is this new friend of mine, who is learning English, so I wanted to have this written down, messy as it may be, so that I am not dumping a bunch of English words on him with a context that is not easily understood with new words, (and made up words as I try to describe messy feelings not found in a textbook)… but also for my English speaking friends, because I’ve never really unloaded the whole story, or even this much of the story to anyone… I am open to sharing it, but really, sharing it is exhausting. I get a weird surge of adrenaline when I explain it, but that adrenaline is coming from fear, mistrust, vulnerability… and it just vibrates through my system with no outlet until I realize I don’t want it. I don’t need it. I’m just wiped out.
But this friend. I am going to visit him and others in a different location, still on the other side of the world, in a few months. We met in Japan, so why not continue meeting in far off countries where I have a clumsy or nearly nonexistent grasp of the language? What could possibly go wrong? I was explaining this to my mother a week or so ago, my trip plans, dates I’m looking at, etc, and she asked me (supportively) a very motherly question: “Do you trust this person?”
And I answered without even thinking, or maybe I did think, but it was reactionary: “Yes. Implicitly.” I told her. And he’s not the first stranger-turned-friend that I have trusted implicitly, there have been several over the past few years. Like-minded individuals who I am introduced to, or who I stumble upon and I get them, they get me, and I trust them inherently, implicitly, and with all my heart. This has been years in the works, to get back to this point, where I can just accept a person who is good, who will look out for me, who cares for me without wanting anything in return. A mutual trust and vulnerability. I am lucky to have this back.
I am in a good place now. I have been in a good place for a while. This series of terrible moments from ten years ago left a mark, and changed who I am, but also changed me into who I am today. And I am happy with the person I ended up as. I’m not thanking any horrific person for trying to kill me, goodness no. He’s a terrible human being, and every woman should stay well away from him.
I guess there is one thing undeniably positive thing I have taken away from this horrific series of events. I’ve been through some rough times in my life since then, but nothing ever like that. And to all of it I have been able to say: “I’ve survived worse than this.”
And it’s gotten me through a lot.
It has sort of changed my perspective, it can sometimes be a comfort or a place of strength.
Also, I quietly know that I would win every argument of “worst housemate ever”.
That’s it, really. No overarching summary or call to action… maybe “be kind.” Try being a good person to each other, and if you see someone leaning towards violence, stop it. Call the cops, I don’t like cops either, but you shut that down when you see it. Put it on their record. Give them a record. They’ve earned it. Make them show up in that cursory google search.
Give the next woman a fighting chance.
afterward, another reason why I wrote this, as I explained in my letter to my aforementioned friend:
...and I remember thinking to myself: "oh, scars..." and looking at you and wishing this information was already in your head, but no, I would have to put it there.
So I said something like: "there is not enough time" and I left it there.
But I hope you also know, from having met me, that I'm alright now. I wasn't for a while. But I am now.
I hope you all understand.
18 notes
·
View notes