Tumgik
#you think im gonna respect the artistic decision of people who killed one cat off a bunch of times in different books because they forgot he
tasmanianstripes · 3 years
Text
Redesigning characters is FINE. It's FUN. You need to fucking calm down if you think otherwise.
There's nothing wrong with that as long as it's not done to somebody's oc (without consent) or they don't imply it's "fixing" the characters.
Some artists like to see themselves as characters they love, so they'll change their skin colour or body type or ethnicity or something else about them. It's FINE, it's just done for fun, as long as it's not done for clout chasing (often done by people who, for example, are skinny but redesign characters to be fat just to seem progressive) and the artist doesn't say they're "fixing" them it's FINE.
Some media, like animation, are limited in the designs they can portray. Artists don't have the same limitations as animation or movies have, so it's fun to draw characters with more detailed designs! For example, MLP characters partly so simplistic in their design so it'd be easier to animate them, but when you don't have to draw them 25+ times just to make a second of animation then it's fine and FUN to make their designs a little more complex! Sometimes the designs that are intentionally simplistic for animation look boring or flat in drawing because it's a different medium, so artists might want to redesign them slightly so they look better for that specific medium!
HELL, sometimes artists just like having artistic freedom and like to redesign characters because they prefer that type of design choice. Sometimes, like in book series designs, artists like to be more original with their depictions of certain characters. I'm gonna draw Mapleshade as a white cat with black and ginger freckles instead of a mostly black calico, who the fuck cares!
IT'S NOT A BAD THING.
#thylacines can talk#'if i cant recognise the character in your artwork that means youre a bad designer' honey i very often dont recognise characters in art#because warrior cats has like one million grey cats with each artist having a slightly different interpretation of them. if i cant recognise#grey cat nr. 29463737 do yoh really think id care if it took me a few seconds to recognise that this ginger cat is actually bluestar?#also your designs have the same damn body type copy pasted with just different coat colours how about you better your designs before you#start preaching to us mx same face syndrome.#fucking hell unless i get any kind of context clues i already confuse brindleface ashfur and ferncloud in fanart frequently and as a child i#thought ravenpaw greystripe firestar and hollyleaf jayfesther lionblaze were all the same group of cats because i couldnt speak english and#they looked so similar in fanart. do you really think warrior cats has amazing original designs or do you just hate artists having fun and#artistic freedom? or are you just jealous because you're physically unable to draw two distinctly different cats unless you colour them?#also some cats have distinct features most artists keep so its not THAT hard to recognise them. like if its a twink with a spiked collar#theres a 99% chance its scourge regardless of if hes pure black or calico or fucking ginger and white#also i value artist's freedom over 'respecting' erin hunter's decisions when these idiots cant even seem to agree how their characters look#like who theyre related to or even how old they are or if they fucking died or not#you think im gonna respect the artistic decision of people who killed one cat off a bunch of times in different books because they forgot he#died or who changed a character's gender mid story because they forgot he was a she-cat or who lead to an entire fucking twitter discourse#because they cant remember what eye colour their god damn character has? huh??? you think im gonna listen to erin 'longtail is silver tabby#no hes beige no hes grey no hes-' hunter? that erin 'dovewing has 3 different eye colours' hunter? THAT erin hunter?#HA. no.
33 notes · View notes