Conrad Fisher girlies are also Nathan Scott girlies are also Jess Mariano girlies are also Seth Cohen girlies are also Logan Echolls girlies are also Pacey Witter girlies.
He can't bring himself to respond directly to the question about Marlene, knowing how much it would upset Ellie and that, of course, he's responsible.
The use of "us" and "home". What a journey from "Oh, it's "we" now"? and "I'm not family"? "No, you're cargo."
Ellie turning her back and Joel immediately noticing. What he did is already having consequences.
And yet a look of resignation, of acceptance, comes over him. He'll take those consequences if it means she's alive and with him, right now, upset or not. His "I'm sorry" is quiet, and when Ellie's already checked out of the conversation so who knows if she heard him. Anyway, he's only sorry for what she's been through and how she's now feeling. He'll never be sorry for his decision.
I've always thought Joel's face after Sarah tells him she fixed his watch because she knows he wouldn't fix it himself was really interesting.
We see Sarah take care of Joel almost as much as he takes of her (Giving him Vitamin C, making breakfast, knowing general knowledge he doesn't, telling him his shirt is inside out, insisting he has some kind of birthday celebration). But her acknowledging that obviously hurts him a bit. Even before the apocalypse, he was a Dad clearly trying his best but not always able to do everything he wanted.
When he can't save Sarah it just confirms his absolute worst fears - that he will never be able to do enough and that it's his daughter who suffers.
Then he meets Ellie, begins to take on a parental role, and it feels like it's happening again. He can't always protect her. She has to figure a lot out on her own.
His conversation with Tommy about failing "her" is about Ellie but it goes all the way back to Sarah, of course.
Even when Ellie tells him she'll him follow him anywhere once they've seen if she's the cure, his face falls again.
Once again, one of his girls is taking on the responsibility. She's reassuring *him* that everything will be fine, that she still sees a future together even though she's the one that is going to have to make sacrifices and it should probably be the other way round.
It's also why he is so still and sure in the hospital. He knows how he can help his daughter this time, and he sure as hell isn't going to let that opportunity go by.
I'm not sure I will ever emotionally recover from the fact that after all the horror and chaos he has caused, Joel still takes a moment to hold Ellie. To give himself a second to appreciate that he has her, this girl that has become the centre of his universe, alive and in his arms. It's been 20 years since he's got to have the feeling.
When Ellie asks Joel if she can ask him a serious question, he responds so quickly. Literally doesn't hesitate to say yes and give her his full attention.
I like to think it's a leftover instinct from raising Sarah. Joel seems like the kind of parent who treated Sarah as an equal, who would be honest with her about everything. Nothing was off the table as they chatted over breakfast or curled up together on the sofa after a long day. Eventually, she overtook him and knew all the answers already, but he liked to think that just meant he was doing his job as a Dad.