Tumgik
#{yeah nO WONDER MOFFAT THOUGHT GIRL IN THE FIREPLACE WAS A GOOD IDEA. YALL FED HIS EGO}
egyptroyal · 2 years
Text
sorry i gotta say
i promise im not a rose anti because rose antis get mad at her simply existing and i get specifically mad at the choices rose made during turn left after Buckingham Place that physically and psychologically fucked around with Donna like Ten did to Mickey and then later to Martha and her family simply to be summed up at 'i was trying to come back... to you' and he respond at the end 'does it need saying?'
because girl what did you expect from doctordonna!donna saying 'i got the best bit of the doctor: his mind' and KNOWING THAT TEN CAN NOW SENSE DONNA TELEPATHICALLY (nine even said: i would feel it [taps temple] in here) you thought he wouldnt see all that from turn left????
rose: 'i dont know, it just sounded like something he would say. [giggling]
donna: [rightfully furious, knowing that rose just lured her the whole time into a suicide mission the second rose was told by donna that the doctor died under the thames via racnoss; roars] YOU LIAR!
rose: [smile wiped, slight flinch because its remincent of both 9's anger towards the daleks (and cassandra) as well as Ten's anger towards Mr Connolly, now being directed towards herself.]
later rose states very clearly to donna: 'i thought it was just the doctor we needed but, its the both of you. The Doctor And Donna Noble, together
like thats gotta be a right smack to rose because she is SO USED TO HEARING, SO USED TO BEING TOLD, SO USED TO BEING REMINDED OF 'the doctor and rose tyler in the tardis as it should be' and THE WHOLE UNIVERSES THAT SHE HAS TRAVELED TO WHERE THE STARS - GALAXIES - UNIVERSES UPON UNIVERSES INCLUDING turn left OUTRIGHT TELL HER NOPE ITS THE DOCTORDONNA - THE DOCTOR AND DONNA NOBLE IN THE TARDIS AS IT IS FORETOLD, AS IT SHOULD BE like baby im sorry but as soon as he called her his friend just like how he refers the master as an old friend - you aint stood a chance in staying with him as soon as he refered to tentoo as his ninth self before he met rose.
AND YOU EXPECTED HIM TO STILL SAY I L-- GIRL GIRL GIRL NOOO
like even in both scenes (deleted and televised) like doctordonna herself via the 'let me break this down for you' nine/ten's speech pattern of - just just
Tenth Doctor: [to Rose and DoctorDonna!Ten/Handy/Tentoo Tyler] The Doctor in the Tardis, with Rose Tyler as it should be
Rose: but what about you?
Tenth Doctor: [lying to make it easier, nods to Donna] Oh, I'm fine, I got madam! (possibly 'madame' after he love his french phrases)
DoctorDonna!Donna: [nine ref where in the comic he shared a mind briefly with rose, hence her still forlorn expression during the convo] A human with a time lord brain: perfect combination! [ten ref to rose and ten forever convo] We can travel the universe forever. Best friends! [ten and donna exclaiming] And equals. [ten's 'well' shrug saying this] Just what skinny boy needs: an equal. [donna breaking it down herself, literally backing up to what he just said]
if you look at his expression while she speaks, you can tell that this is all ten saying this through donna - him chuckling when she calls him skinny boy because thats when she steps in - before actually keeping that same expression at the word 'equal' being repeated and him nodding along while doing so.
HE TOLD HER THAT HIMSELF, its just that donna gives it a compassionate tone that the doctor would lack
and then they continue what we see later on tv and I FIND THAT WILD THAT THEY HAD THIS CONVO AND THEN SHE ASKED THE 'what were you going to say? On that beach' scene like girl girl girl omg godddd.
like you don't deserve him because he told you via his own friend telling you that you dont deserve him but he didnt deserve you either girl, get that tentoo babes like wooooo
And then the very thing after waters of mars is go full time lord victorious IE HIS FULL GENOCIDAL RUN FOR DONNA, BURNING THE UNIVERSE, KILLING DEATH, FULL BADWOLF!DOCTOR TO WHERE HIS NINTH AND EIGHTH SELFHAD TO STOP HIM LIKE ALL THAT FOR DONNA BUT crickets. crumbs. sand particles. constant abandonment on his end. questioning where u at instead of straight up running until you find her and have her by your side. rose girl you wasnt just disrespected in not getting an answer that you tore through universe to get but also that the choices and attitude you made and expressed that is nos part of donna's mind, memories - that whole episode of turn left - ended up being the final nail in the coffin for him just leaving you behind with the memory of the love you and him will never have and never will own without you becoming the weapon he would discard and him becoming yet another man you just settled for.
oof love the doctorrose ship but also god what a shish kabob of crumbs if this is what yall still want to settle for 'hetero romance'
no wonder billie doing so many of her own and other projeespecially if its the one ship that was only around for the respect of the memory of a dead regeneration like oof like damn shit this hurtscts so she doesn't go to the 60th anniversary except in archival footage
especially if its the one ship that was only around for the respect of the memory of a dead regeneration like oof like damn shit this hurts
no wonder the tenth doctor adventures with rose is bland as hell - its like listening to a divorced couple trying and failing to get that spark but its just embarrassing for both parties because the last two (4 technically) other yt men she was with died via invasion scenarios or hubris at the wrong time and place and a poc significant other left her because of HER NEGLIGENCE AND TREATING HIM LESSER (i see where ten got that quirk from while using 'mourning rose absence' as a crutch but yeah not all of rose's quirks were good and lovey dovey because he also picked up her casanova quirk (rose with jack and adam and ten with poisson and cleo, funny how ppl hate those episodes but isnt really admitting the REAL reason why and giving excuses or blaming the writers for not catering to their self yt insert fantasies. THE JOAN REDFERN ARC IS VERY CLEARLY BANGING YOU ON THE HEAD ABOUT THIS BETWEEN FOBWATCHED TEN AND JOAN MIRRORING AN 1800S VERSION OF TEN AND ROSE TREATMENT TOWARDS MICKEY AND MARTHA AND THE FACT YALL PRETEND NOT TO SEE IT IS THE VERY REASON THAT LIKE JOAN AND ROSE, YOU WILL BE LEFT IMMEDIATELY BEHIND LIKE ROSE AND JOAN REGARDLESS OR NOT IF YOU HAVE A HAPPY LIFE OR NOT. THAT IS THE MERCY OF THE DOCTOR TO CATER TO YOUR mainly yt...EGO) bland. af.
meanwhile [blasts the donna theme] DOCTOR SAID I ONLY LOVE 'platonical romantically' DONNA AND THATS WHO I AM IMPRESSING LOOK AT MY NEW HANNIBAL LECTER PLAID SUIT MY 8TH DOCTOR AUDIO BLUE COAT PRE-TIME WAR BUT FRESH OFF TLV. YOU GOT A KID NAME ROSE? NEAT LETS DO A WHOLE FAMILY REUNION LETS GO EVERYBODY INCLUDING YOU SYLVIA LETS GO why is wilf my new dad in a wheelchair? how long have i been gone? EVERYONE LETS GO. healthy hetero relationship using gallifrey's version of friendship is a balanced romance while romance is considered less or not equal (see what they and i did there) to friendship. fuck yeah!
6 notes · View notes