#Correspondent Ramita Navai | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

xtruss · 8 months

Text

Ramita Navai on Reporting From the West Bank 🇵🇸 as “The Bastard Child of the US 🇺🇸 and the West 🇪🇺 Isra-hell—Freedom Fighters Hamas Against Illegal Occupation” War Rages in Gaza

— January 23, 2024 | By Inci Sayki | Frontline

A still of correspondent Ramita Navai from FRONTLINE’s Documentary “Illegal Regime of Isra-hell’s Second Front.”

Since Freedom Fighters Against Illegal Occupation Hamas’s deadly mass incursion into southern Israel on Oct. 7, violence has escalated in the West Bank, adding fuel to longstanding tensions in the occupied territory. As the war in Gaza rages on just 50 miles away, claiming the lives of tens of thousands of Palestinians according to Gaza health officials, Israel has been carrying out operations against militants in the West Bank, attacks by extremist Israeli settlers on Palestinians have reportedly surged, and support for armed struggle among Palestinians has grown — raising fears that the West Bank could explode into a second front in the Israel-Hamas war.

For her latest FRONTLINE documentary, Israel’s Second Front, correspondent Ramita Navai (Afghanistan Undercover, Syria Undercover, Iraq Uncovered, UN Sex Abuse Scandal) traveled to the West Bank in the weeks following Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack to understand the effects of Israel’s ongoing military campaign in Gaza on Palestinians in the West Bank, increased support for militant groups, and the implications for a region on the edge amid concerns of a widening conflict in the Middle East. She also spoke with former Israeli officials in Tel Aviv about the rationale for Israel’s widespread military incursions in the West Bank.

Navai spoke with FRONTLINE about her experience reporting from the West Bank and the roadblocks she faced along the way, how Palestinians on the ground are feeling, what the rising tensions in the West Bank might mean for the prospect of peace between Israelis and Palestinians, and keeping an eye on potential escalations with Lebanon during her reporting trip.

This interview has been edited for clarity and length.

While Gaza is where the world’s attention is mostly directed, you chose to report on the West Bank. Can you tell me why that was an important undertaking for you?

Ramita: All eyes are on Gaza as they should be. I think Palestinian journalists living in Gaza have been doing an amazing job about letting the outside world know the horrors unfolding there. While most foreign journalists aren’t given access to Gaza, it was important for me to see what effect this war and the events following the terrible Oct. 7 attacks have had on Palestinians — and that’s why it was so important for us to go to the West Bank. Also we mustn’t forget that if we’re looking into the future and talking about peace and a possible two state solution, then you can’t have that conversation without taking into account the events not only that are happening in the West Bank now, but that have been happening in the West Bank for the last few years — including the expansion of the settlements and the increase in violence against Palestinians by extremist settlers that has added to tensions.

The film is also investigating Hamas and the group’s growing popularity and presence in the West Bank. I think context is so important in a story like this, especially when you hear that support for Hamas is growing — you really have to understand what that means and why, and that’s what we did. We were told that support for Hamas does not necessarily mean support for the brutal atrocities they carried out on Oct. 7. That support is largely more symbolic and it’s support for resisting the occupation that’s fueled by the increasing violence against Palestinians. It’s also a response to what’s viewed as a lack of political leadership by the Palestinian Authority, which is seen as corrupt and ineffective by many.

A child looking out of a damaged building in Tulkarem, West Bank, in a screengrab from “Illegal Regime of Isra-hell’s Second Front.”

Can you tell me about how it was traveling to the West Bank? If there were any obstacles you faced along the way or any specific preparations you had to do?

Ramita: Well, we based ourselves in Ramallah. Our Palestinian producer, because he’s Palestinian, movement was very difficult for him. And since Oct. 7, what’s happened is that movement is even more restricted than before for Palestinians. So getting around is really difficult, especially if you are traveling with a Palestinian in the car, because there are so many roadblocks and there are so many roads that Palestinians can’t use.

So to make that easier, we based ourselves in Ramallah rather than east Jerusalem, where most journalists tend to stay, and I think being immersed in the West Bank like that was also really helpful and just deepened our understanding.

Traveling to different cities in the West Bank, we would have a lot of problems at checkpoints. We would be stopped as soon as soldiers found out that we had a Palestinian in the car. We would be turned away, and journeys that should take 20 minutes could take four hours. Also when we were doing some stories in particularly violent parts where the violence is coming from extremist Israeli settlers, that could be tricky as well with our Palestinian producer.

Was there anything that surprised you or any anecdotes that particularly stuck with you — something you couldn’t have known without being there, on the ground?

Ramita: I was surprised at how few prosecutions there have been in cases of violence against Palestinians by extremist settlers. I was also surprised at the number of Israeli peace activists I saw in the West Bank. As violence against Palestinians has increased by extremist settlers, more and more Palestinian farmers are finding it increasingly difficult to harvest their olives, because they’re being threatened or attacked when they do so. And harvesting olives is their only means of income. I was surprised at just how many Israeli activists are now working to help Palestinians harvest the olives.

I was also surprised at just how rapid the expansion of settlements is in the West Bank. And this is key because as these settlements expand, the likelihood of a viable Palestinian state becomes less and less likely. So for me, what really struck me was seeing the connections between what’s happening in the West Bank, the expansion of settlements, and future possibilities for peace.

I would say something else. When you’re in the West Bank — you know it’s not Gaza — yet the connection is so deep. Everyone there has family in Gaza, everyone knows somebody in Gaza. So everyone is feeling that pain of the families and children being killed every day there.

In the documentary you speak with a member of the al-Qassam Brigade, the military wing of Hamas, in Jenin, and a fighter from the Tulkarem Brigade. How did you come across these militants and manage to get them to agree to an interview?

Ramita: Gosh — that wasn’t easy. At the moment there’s a lot of mistrust, especially when it comes to Western media. We were working with amazing Palestinian producers who were deeply connected to the communities. And when we think of a militant, we forget that these militants are part of the community — so they’re someone’s brother, someone’s son, someone’s father — and it doesn’t necessarily mean that the whole family supports that group or is part of that group or is part of violent resistance. We had to meet, we had to chat to people. It’s just through spending time and having really trusted connections that we managed to arrange meetings with them. Not everybody agreed to be interviewed.

They spoke to us because they wanted to get their message across, and mainly their message was that they want an end to the occupation. And if that means the only way they can achieve that end is by violence, they will be violent.

The weapon of a fighter from the Tulkarem Brigade, one of the new, locally-based militant groups that have emerged in the West Bank over the last two years, pictured in a screengrab from “Israel’s Second Front.”

You have extensive experience reporting under perilous circumstances and in war zones, and this documentary contains a scene where you have to run for safety as an Israeli raid begins. What was it like to keep reporting as that happened?

Ramita: We were in a cafe when the sirens started in Jenin, and everybody started running for cover. The streets emptied really quickly. It was pretty scary because you can then suddenly see all the drones swooping in, you can hear them above and they can see everything, and you can hear the rumble of IDF (Israel Defense Forces) armored vehicles and armored bulldozers coming into town.

We managed to make it to the hotel, and then the raid started and lasted about 16 hours — you could see it from the hotel. The hotel staff were pretty scared. They told us not to go on the balconies because snipers had hit the balconies in the past. But from the hotel windows we could see. Every now and again, you could hear a boom. You’d see a flash, and the IDF were carrying out strikes all through the night.

In the morning we went out to check the damage. We went out too early and the raid hadn’t ended, and we didn’t know. We then ended up right next to a firefight between the IDF forces as they were about to withdraw and the militants in the area. That was pretty scary. You don’t really see much of that in the film — I think you see a few seconds. But we ended up having to run away.

Then of course, we went in and saw the aftermath. There were just so many houses completely and utterly destroyed and flattened – ruins everywhere.

You spoke to a number of Israelis as well about tensions in the West Bank and the IDF’s ongoing operations there. Can you tell more about their perspective?

Ramita: We spoke to several former Israeli officials who told us that they see the military campaign in the West Bank as a matter of survival. The Oct. 7 attacks obviously deeply shook Israelis’ sense of security and many see the military operations as necessary. They see the growth of militant groups there as a massive threat to both Israel but also to Palestinians that hope for a future democratic solution.

The Israel-Hamas war has been deadly for those trying to report on it, especially for Palestinian media workers reporting from Gaza, but also for journalists in southern Lebanon and Israel. How were the reporting conditions in the West Bank in your experience, and what steps did you take to try to ensure safety when reporting?

Ramita: It’s incomparable to what’s happening in Gaza. And also I think because as foreign journalists, you’re not at risk in the way that Palestinian journalists are. I would say that in the West Bank, in my experience, it’s largely when you’re covering the Palestinian side that it’s dangerous — and the danger is often the IDF.

So for example, we covered a prisoner release. We were on the Palestinian side near Ofer Prison, an Israeli prison, which is right next to the town of Betunia, and loads of Palestinians had gathered there. Now, the IDF had been given instruction to shut down celebrations. Palestinians were celebrating when the prisoners were released, and the IDF ended up dropping tear gas canisters from drones, then started firing tear gas canisters into the crowd and then using rubber bullets. According to the Red Crescent, many people were injured that night. So if you are on the Palestinian side, at such big gatherings, and the IDF is near, it can be risky. But I think it’s just much harder if you’re a Palestinian journalist.

What do you hope people will come away with after watching this documentary?

Ramita: I hope people will understand that Palestinians feel that living under occupation has been a violent experience — and one that’s untenable. And I hope they understand why Palestinians feel that the avenues for negotiations are closing down to them, and that they feel they have been increasingly targeted over the last several years. And that doesn’t mean they support the terrible things Hamas did on Oct. 7, which also should not be forgotten.

— Inci Sayki, Goggin Journalism Fellow, FRONTLINE/Columbia Journalism School Fellowship

#Frontline #Forever Palestine 🇵🇸#West Bank #Freedom Fighter Hamas #Illegal Regime of Isra-hell #Crimes of the Zionist 🐖 🐖 🐖 Cunts #European Immigrants Fake Jews #The Bastard Child of the US 🇺🇸 and the West 🇪🇺#Correspondent Ramita Navai

0 notes