So I'm curious what oppression do asexual people face? I do understand there are some minor discrimination similar to homosexuality like being told it's a phase, but there have 0 laws against i, very few if any deaths because of it, few forced marriages. Maybe there have been cases of corrective rape?
sorry i took a few days to answer this -- i wanted time to give you a thoughtful response! this is kinda a version of an ask i answered last month, but i hope it helps answer your question!
here are some good posts that explain better than me:
https://livebloggingmydescentintomadness.tumblr.com/post/148453657895/the-aphobia-masterpost (This one goes into ace history, as well as many other topics – big recommend)
https://newt–x.tumblr.com/post/183606679191/a-spec-people-dont-experience-oppression (includes more comments/edits on the above)
So how are aces oppressed?
Let’s start with medical discrimmination: asexuality is classified as a mental disorder that you can get diagnosed with. Although the DSM-5 says that asexuality is a valid identity, it still lists hypoactive sexual disorder as – well, a disorder. This is basically defined as when someone is disinterested in sexual activity, and this disinterest causes them distress. This is the same boat that homosexuality was in until a few decades ago – and obviously, aphobia (and homophobia) are very likely to make people feel “distressed” about their sexual identity (I know that I do!) Imagine going to a psychiatrist and having them tell you that your orientation is a disorder that needs to be fixed: not great.
Even when ace people are not being explicitly diagnosed with Being an Asexual Disease, asexuals can often get into hostile medical situations, particularly in mental health settings. I have had several appointments with psychiatrists, counselors, and the like that were meant to be about unrelated topics, but when it came out that I was ace, the conversation turned to why this was a sign of isolation/pathology/other fuckedupedness. Other aces might be able to better speak about their experiences in this area, as I often avoid bringing up the topic in medical settings for this reason.
the discrimmination you’re talking about
Asexual people, particularly (but not only) female-identifying aces, have also long (long!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) been targets of corrective rape and sexual assault. Here’s a good (altho far from exhaustive) HuffPost article on the subject. Corrective rape is a huge issue. This is a very prevalent fear for a lot of ace people, who also face other types of violence. A really horrible and tragic example is the murder of ace teen Bianca Devins last year by a man that she refused to sleep with (I won’t post links because they’re pretty upsetting) -- a death that aphobes online are still making terrifying comments about.
So yes! Ace ppl do actually face violence and death!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Here’s a post that talks about why it’s hard to be an ace PoC (like me!)
Tl;dr, many people don’t know what asexuality is – it’s sometimes called an “invisible identity.” But that doesn’t mean ace people aren’t discrimminated against as aces.
Exclusion from the LGBTQIA+ community
As I’m sure you know, many fellow people in the queer community hate ace people. There’s a perception that ace people are being special snowflakes, that we are basically straight, that we are not oppressed enough to be part of the community, that we diminish the importance of other sexual orientations, and on and on. This is really hard for ace people, because we seek queer spaces, spaces that are supposed to be safe for marginalized identities, are often those that are most explicitly anti-ace.
In addition, some in the queer community used to identify as ace because they had internalized homophobia or other things, and view asexuality as a cover for those feelings based on their own experiences.
From queer tumblr bloggers I follow to comments by queer friends and acquaintances, I’ve personally had spaces that I thought were safe revealed to be aphobic. That’s a pretty upsetting experience – I don’t talk about being ace very often, but it’s devastating to know that people you encounter in your everyday life spend so much time thinking about how much they hate people like you.
All this leads to many ace people being scared and unhappy. In a UK government survey of LGBTQIA+ individuals, asexuals were the group least likely to be “open” about their identity (at 89% reporting that they were not open). Cis aces were the least comfortable being queer in the UK, and had the lowest life satisfaction scores, out of all cis responders (the survey did not break down the responses of trans responders into allo/ace).
(Side note – many ace people emphasize other parts of their identities in order to participate in queer spaces. For example, if pressed in a pride group or seminar or friendly gathering or etc., I might just say I’m bi. This sucks too! All parts of your identity are legitimate and that should go without saying?)
Personally, there are few environments where I am comfortable with people knowing that I am ace. I don’t wear obvious pride gear, and I don’t call myself ace when I’m in LGBT+ groups. I’ve never come out to a romantic or sexual partner as ace. My sexual experiences have been highly traumatizing in part because of my identity. Only a few of my closest friends know that I’m ace. The negative perceptions of ace people, particularly those in the queer community, are main causes of this.
Why do we need to be oppressed to be let in?
One of exclusionists’ favorite sticking points is that aces aren’t oppressed enough to be part of the queer community. We do face discrimination in major ways – see above. But this raises a question: why do we have to be oppressed to be welcomed into LGBTQIA+ spaces? What qualifies as oppression? Is societal oppression “enough,” or does every ace person have to be personally subjected to a hate crime? I’m not sure if this line of thought comes from a genuine belief that society has to personally take a shit in your bed every day for you to even think about feeling comfortable in queer spaces, or if it is just cover for an instinctive dislike of ace people. Regardless, it’s something to think about. To quote the first masterpost linked at top:
“Nobody is trying to say that asexuals have it “as bad” or worse than gay or trans people, but we don’t HAVE to “have it worse” to be included and for our experiences to have merit without being compared to anyone else’s. Let me say that again: our experiences have merit without being compared to anyone else’s. “
Anyway thanks for your question! I don’t know if this helps or changes your mind on the topic. Please reach out if you have any other questions about my experiences as an ace person!
2 notes
·
View notes