#ability to consent to such a thing. but then...you gotta realize thats only a product of the principles being as they are so in a | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

dapperrokyuu · 2 years ago

Text

The whole crux of WHA is basically about healing magic and I still fail to understand why healing magic is banned, ngl, dalnbdalkfjn-

Like, I recall they say the whole experimental thing, but thats less about the magic and more about the lack of consent and suffering regarding those experiments-

#dee p thoughts #witch hat atelier #like consent and the concept of suffering is something regarded in REAL world healthcare advancements so you cant even say medicine in a #vacuum is done without those things. I mean we experiment on animals first then humans because we value the latter more but at the end of #they day beyond the suffering if a human were to go through the processes of consenting to such experiments theoretically it should be fine #I guess the question is about the ethical nature of magical experiments but a factor of that is that spells are apparently /reversible/#which honestly makes the argument AGAINST the magic usage even weaker actually albnfdajkln and I guess the difference between spells and #irl experiments is that you can reasonably estimate the results of the latter but spells are more spontaneous and unpredictable and #thats why its so unreliable and dangerous- so its a matter of you cant properly convey the potential suffering to a human subject without #experience BUT if theyre willing to consent to it despite the unpredictability would that be enough? I think we're basing the assumption #that no human would consent to being experiment on but im pretty certain their would be. and another aspect is that witches who've #experimented on humans likely did so with humans who had no knowledge or understanding of magic which would automatically inhibit their #ability to consent to such a thing. but then...you gotta realize thats only a product of the principles being as they are so in a #way its the principles fault for enabling such predatory behavior too AHHH #putting this in the tag actually intrigued about a conversation about this bare in mind Im only on chapter 51 adlkjfadl WHA IS ABOUT HOW #MUCH SOCIETAL SYSTEMS CAN BE PATERNALISTIC WHICH IS SOMETHING THATS BEEN IN HEALTHCARE FOR FOREVER TOO SLHDNBLSKJFBNLKSJFSL

5 notes · View notes