#carly carmine x reader | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

gracev0609 · 9 months

Text

Keys a Josh Kiszka X Queer Plus Size Reader X Danny Wagner story

Trigger Warnings: MINORS DNI, 18+, Adult themes, pure porn, f/f, m/m, m/f.

Word Count: 3k+

You have been seeing Josh for at least six months now, and things are wonderful. The two of you agreed to have a relationship that was somewhat open, you both were free to entertain another person as long as you checked in with one another at the end of the night. He was your piece of solid ground, your rock, and you liked it that way. Although, neither one of you had been with anyone else yet, until tonight. A friend of Josh's decided to host a key party and you both were invited. You and Josh were both excited to get a taste of something new for the evening.

" How does a key party work exactly?" Josh asked as he straightened up the clean and dirty laundry in his bedroom.

You were sprawled out on his bed enjoying the sunshine and breeze blowing in through the window," All the men, or masc presenting people, put their car keys in a bowl and at the end of the night all the women, or fem presenting people, pick a key and whomever it belongs to is the person they go home with."

Putting a stack of white t-shirts away in his dresser he asked," Have you been to one before?"

" Yeah, I went to one when I was in college. It was a lot of fun. Have you?"

" No, never something as organized as that." Josh chuckled.

" You're going to have a great time babe!"

Before you knew it, the sun was setting and it was time to get ready for the party. After getting dressed in a black floral mini skirt and a black tank top you brushed up your hair into a high ponytail with some pieces out around your face. Putting in some dangling earrings and a necklace on you spritzed yourself with your favorite perfume.

" Y/N, I'm ready when you are," Josh called, stepping into the bathroom where you were getting ready." You look incredible!"

Turning to take in his outfit you fought back a chuckle. He was wearing his standard issue uniform of a white t-shirt and khaki colored pants and his white vans that have seen better days. He spiced it up with a long pendant necklace that hung to his stomach.

He wrapped his arms around your waist and nuzzled into your neck," I'm getting a little jealous that I don't get to go home with you looking like that tonight."

You laughed and unwrapped his arms from your frame," Come on let's go, I don't want to be late!"

A little while later you stepped into a home that you hadn't been to before, following Josh closely with your fingers intertwined with his.

"Let's get some drinks and loosen up!" He yelled to you over his shoulder. The music was cranked decently high but not too high that you couldn't have a conversation.

Josh led you into the kitchen where the counters were lined with food and alcohol. He found plastic shot glasses and a bottle of tequila. The two of you shared a nervous smile and clinked your shots together before downing the liquor.

"Josh!" You heard a man yell while barreling over to give him a hug.

"Carmine!" You recognized him as the host of the party.

" Add your keys to the bag buddy!" He held up a black velvet drawstring bag. It almost looked like it was purchased for the intent of this party.

Josh grabbed his Jeep key fob from his pocket and dropped it into the waiting satchel. Carmine pulled the strings tightly and shook it up.

After a few more shots you were approached by a beautiful blonde couple.

"Hi! I'm Carly and this is my boyfriend Michael. We saw you two walk in together, and we were hoping that we'd pick each other's keys."

You were taken back slightly by her forwardness, but what else were you supposed to do at a sex party.

" Oh yeah, hopefully! I can try my best to find them." You said taking in her eye candy of a boyfriend.

"Great! Ours have a triangle keychain. What do yours have?" Carly asked.

" A peace sign." Josh answered her. He was also taking in the handsome man at her side.

"Let's sit together until it's time to pick keys!" Carly said taking both your hand and Josh's leading you to a couch in the living room.

As you sat down next to Josh you noticed how swimmy your head had gotten from the tequila and you were certain that tonight was going to be extraordinary. Carly sat on your other side as Michael flanked Josh.

She started running her hand up and down your thigh, getting a read on you. Looking into her eyes you subtly nodded, and she brought her lips to yours. It had been a little while since you had kissed a woman. Her lips were so smooth and soft, and you could smell her candy scented perfume. You gently put your hand to her chest, cupping her breast and thumbing her nipple through the shirt.

Carly broke the kiss first, her tongue licking a stripe down your neck that made a flush of arousal rewet your already soaked panties. " I think they're also getting along," she whispered. You both looked over to see Josh kissing and sucking on Michaels neck.

Watching your partner be somewhat intimate with another person lit a primal need in your core. You wanted to experience more with Josh, you wanted to watch him experience more.

"Hey y'all, sorry to interrupt but it's pickin' time!" Carmine interjected, rattling the bag of keys in front of your faces.

You looked over at the boys as Carly reached her hand in the bag, they had matching lust filled gazes eager to continue this elsewhere. After what felt like an eternity she pulled her hand out of the bag holding a rectangular key fob. The word Jeep embossed on the side. A few keys hung from the keychain along with a little metal peace sign charm. She had successfully found Josh's keys. Your stomach tingles with anticipation.

"Remember, triangle keychain." Carly whispered into your ear.

You reached your hand into the bag feeling around for the pointy keychain. Finally finding one that felt like a triangle you picked it up feeling triumphant. You pulled it out and showed it to her," Is this it?!"

You watched Carlys face fall," that's not it."

You stared at the keys in your hand, a Jeep key fob that resembled Josh's, a few house key type keys, and a keychain that was a triangle shape. It looked to be one of the flags that they have at the holes on golf courses.

*Josh POV*

You stared at the keys in Y/Ns hand and you felt your blood run ice cold. You know who's keys they are. You helped him pick out the Jeep. And before you two left the dealer lot you watched him attach that damn keychain. They belong to Danny.

He was your oldest friend, and you trusted him completely. You knew your girlfriend would be in excellent hands. The dilemma you were facing was that as much as you wanted to play with Carly, you wanted to play with Danny. He was your first crush that was a boy, he helped you realize your queerness. Over the years you and Danny have shared suggestive glances and some touches that held more meaning behind them than what initially appeared. You just never got the courage to do anything about it, you didn't want to jeopardize your friendship or the band. Tonight was different though, everyone had come here with the promise of sex. You exchanged phone numbers with Michael and Carly while promising them a fun time another night, and got up to find your girlfriend who was currently searching for the man who owned the keys she was holding. You found her and Daniel having a shot of tequila in the kitchen. Standing in the doorway you watched their interaction. Recognizing the mischievous glint in her eyes, you saw him reach out and cup her chin in his large hand.

"Come on babe, you know I can throw you around better than he can," Danny said smoothly.

Watching as she bit her lip and subtly clenched her thighs. She wanted him, and so did you.

Saying his name you called for their attention," Daniel. Would you be opposed to me joining your evening?" Silently you willed him to say yes.

"I wouldn't be opposed at all Joshua."

A large smile appears on all three of your faces.

Danny grabs Y/Ns hand and places his other low on your back guiding you both to the door.

"Let's go back to my place, yeah? Don't need Jakey knowing about any of the sinful things I plan on doing to you two," Danny cooed.

You locked eyes with your girlfriend who looked just as turned on as you were.

Watching in the backseat of his Jeep as Danny drove you saw her running her hand up the length of his muscular thigh getting closer and closer to the obvious tent in his jeans. Once Danny put the car in park he grabbed her wrist with one hand holding it still on his bulge,and brought her face to his with the other. Her soft jaw contrasting with his sharp one as they heatedly made out. The car was silent apart from the lewd sucking sounds,breathy moans, and your heavy breathing. Watching your partner kiss your childhood crush was doing something to you, feeling blood rush to your groin effectively making your cock hard. Your hand snaked its way to the crotch of your pants as you desperately palmed your erection. A small whine escaped your lips, and Danny broke the kiss turning his attention to you.

"Feeling a little left out Joshy?" Danny asked," come here."

Leaning forward in between the two front seats you felt his hot spit slicked lips capture your own. You couldn't help but tangle your fingers in his mane and tug gently, it was all you had wanted to do since he started that damn curl routine. Danny groaned into your mouth, the sound making your own cock twitch.

"Can we go inside now?" You heard your girlfriend ask. "I am so fucking turned on right now, I don't know how much more I can watch without taking my clothes off."

With that Danny opened his car door signally to us that it was indeed time to go inside.

The three of you beelined it to his bedroom, you and Y/N stood as Danny made himself comfortable on the mattress having already discarded his shirt. His eyes raked over the both of you, they were hungry and he looked intimidating. Very unlike his usual harmless teddy bear demeanor .

"Take your clothes off Josh." Danny commanded. Slowly you took off your necklace and t-shirt, folding them and setting them aside before unbuttoning your pants and sliding them and your underwear down your legs. Standing before him your cock bobbed and twitched sensitive to the cool air of his bedroom. Feeling oh so nervous you decided to try to take back a bit of your confidence. Strutting over to the bed, swinging your hips a bit in show, you went to grasp Danny's chin mirroring what he did to Y/N earlier.

" Baby boy, if you think you're going to have any control over me tonight you're going to be vastly mistaken." Danny scolded you before you could even open your mouth.

"Now sit down on the bed and play with that pretty cock of yours while I watch Y/N get undressed for me."

Quickly you got comfortable on his bed and wrapped a loose fist around yourself, slowly pumping. You were already wound so tight, so eager to get off. You knew tonight was going to be a battle of willpower to stave off your impending orgasm. Your eyes found your girlfriend taking her top off letting her breasts bounce, the metal bars through her nipples glinting in the low light made you squeeze your fist around your too hard member.

"Ahh, I remember those, I could see your cheeky little piercings through your bathing suit top the first day I met you. I remember being jealous of you,Josh." Danny retold," now Y/N sit up on the bed next to Josh. I want to have a taste of you both."

She got comfortable at your side, and intertwined your fingers together. She brought your hand up to her face and kissed it. You were busy looking at the excitement in her features as you felt bodyweight settle in between your legs. Turning your gaze down you thought you could cum right there just from witnessing your point of view. Hovering right above your red angry cock was Danny.

He crudely spit on two of his fingers before slipping them between your cheeks, rubbing your most sensitive orifice. Subconsciously you thrust your hips in the air, your cock begging for relief.

"Please Danny, I need it, I'm so hard. Please." Begging the beautiful boy above you.

Danny opened his mouth and brought it down on you. Groaning as you felt the warm wetness of his tongue swirling down your shaft. Shamelessly you whine and moan, toes curling as he sucked on your sensitive skin. Throbbing intensely as he timed his fingers with his tongue. He was hurtling you towards your orgasm.

"Danny, stop! I'm going to cum already if you don't stop."

Danny popped his lips off of your cock," If I let you cum now, do you think you can give me another one?"

Harshly swallowing you thought about it.

Y/N spoke up answering for you," He can. He will, right baby? You'll give Danny two orgasms."

Nodding your head furiously you agreed with her. Danny reattached himself to your cock, sucking you down greedily. You noticed he was rutting his own cock into the mattress as he worked you, turning your head you found your beautiful girlfriend with her fingers furiously shoved into her wet pussy. The wet squelching of her arousal as she finger fucked herself along with the wet sucking sounds Danny was making was becoming the tipping point of your orgasm.

" I - I'm cumming. Fuck, I'm cumming. Don't stop, God Danny don't stop."

Violently twitching your cock exploded down Danny's throat. He sucked you dry, as his tongue coaxed the entirety of your release into his mouth.

Cum drunk, he pulled off of you and your penis flopped onto your thigh with a wet thud.

"Your turn sweetie." Danny growled moving in between Y/Ns thick thighs.

*Y/N POV*

Leaning down you captured Danny's lips in your own. You could taste Josh's release on his tongue, it fueled your desire, turning you on even more. He ripped away from your kiss and pushed you back down onto the bed.

"I need to taste your pussy. Fuck you're so wet." Danny muttered from in between your thighs.

He licked a hot stripe from your anus to your clit before swirling the tip of his tongue around your sensitive bud. He pushed his large hands between your thighs, opening your legs wider for him to thoroughly eat you out. Ecstasy clouded your mind as he thrashed his mouth from side to side, licking everywhere as his nose nudged your clit.

"Fuck Danny, god I need to be fucked." You pleaded with him.

He got up on all fours," God, I am going to split you in two." Crawling over your frame you peered at his heavy cock. He was girthy and lengthy, and you had no doubts that he would split you in half.

He pulled your wide hips into his lap before slapping his hard cock on your clit teasing her.

Danny slowly pushed his way inside of you, aware that he was bigger than the cock you usually took.

Somewhat recovered from his orgasm Josh moved his way to kiss and lick at your chest while you got situated. As Josh lapped at your nipples you clenched around Danny letting him know it was time to start fucking you.

Rocking his hips into you it took him barely any effort to bottom out.

With the tip of his cock tapping your cervix you felt your orgasm start to overtake. Babbling incoherently with one hand gripped on Danny's forearm and the other gripped into Josh's hair you cried out as a squirt of liquid drenched Dannys stomach as he fucked you through your orgasm.

"Fuck, I knew you were going to be fun." Danny exclaimed, pulling out of you. He leaned over to whisper softly into Josh's ear as you recovered from your orgasm.

Josh came into your line of sight," You're doing so good baby. Are you ready for me?"

Looking down you saw his cock hard once again. Josh pulled a small stack of pillows down and told you to sit your ass down on them and lay back. With your hips elevated he grabbed his length and slid his tip through your wetness. Immediately you moaned at the feeling of his hot flesh slipping through your folds. Josh lined himself up with your entrance and pushed in, the angle he had your hips at made you feel gloriously full.

You knew Danny was somewhere behind Josh, from your limited view you could see a flash of dark curls now and again.

A pathetic sounding whine passed through Josh's lips, and you heard wet lapping noises. Feeling his cock twitching inside you,you realized that Danny was licking at Josh's hole while he was inside of you. A flush of arousal coated his length as you somehow got even more turned on. You heard the click of the top of a cap, and you watched from below as Josh's eyes screwed shut. His mouth hung slack and his cheeks were flushed red from the evening's activities. You felt Josh's hips gently press into your own, pumping into you, but it felt different than usual. You realized that Josh wasn't moving but Danny was. Danny was prepping him, finger fucking his hole.

"Do you feel good baby?" You asked him softly as your hand came up to caress his cheek.

"Incredible." He whispered back.

You saw Danny appear over his shoulder, kissing and sucking on his neck, "Do you think you're ready for me yet?"

"Yeah- yeah I'm ready."

Danny gently pushed on Josh's back so he was laying atop of your body.

As he nuzzled into your neck you locked eyes with Danny and a wicked grin formed on your face.

You watched Danny clench his jaw as he pushed into him.

"Relax baby." He said softly, running his hand down his back.

Josh's breath grew ragged and he took the massive intrusion.

"Please move." He whimpered into your neck. Pulling himself up off of your chest he repeated himself more surely," Danny, please move. I'm ready."

You felt Danny's hips push into his, effectively sliding his cock deeper into you.

"Fuck" you muttered.

After a few pumps the three of you found a rhythm. Sounds of skin slapping skin filled the room. You couldn't hold back; you were the personification of euphoria.

Your whole body was aflame, instinct, arousal,and pure sex courses through your veins.

"Fuck I'm cumming." You moaned out to the two men. Your pussy pulsed around Josh's cock before he groaned, filling you with hot sticky cum.

After a few more pumps Danny cried out that he was cumming as he filled Josh with his hot load.

Danny hissed as he pulled out of his tight heat, flopping onto the bed at your side. Josh mustered the last bit of strength he had remaining to pull out of you and lay down on your other side.

Comfortable silence filled the air as the three of you laid there blissed out. You felt love and comfort flowing through the room and you knew in that instant that it had to be replicated.

"We're doing this again right?" You spoke to both men.

"I'd be down for that. What about you Josh?" Danny asked.

"Oh, I'm so down to do that again." He replied sleepily from the crook of his arm.

Fin.

#gvf #danny gvf #jake gvf #josh gvf #josh kiszka #sam gvf #iced chai universe

39 notes · View notes