#french revoluton

[publius-library]

Why do you think Hamilton supported the Alien and Seduction acts as an immigrant himself?

This is a common discussion I see, and it becomes quite easy to understand when you take into account the current events, what prompted the Alien and Sedition Acts (which is what I will assume you meant instead of Seduction, since I think it would be pretty self explanatory why Hamilton would support Seduction acts), who John Adams was, and Hamilton's beliefs.

Firstly, the most prominent international event occurring at the time was the French Revolution. When the Revolutionary government replaced that of the Ancien Regime, it dissolved it's alliances with foreign nations, especially after they cut their king's head off. This resulted in a war and a dude you might have heard of named Napoleon, but we don't need to get into that to understand that Britain and France had major beef, even more so than before. As a result, a lot of the French people who did not approve of their government's actions, but still did not want to live under a monarchy, immigrated to the United States. Much like today's current debate over immigration, some people believed that the United States were not obligated to give refuge to these immigrants, that they would take American jobs, and posed a risk to American citizens. Hence, the Alien portion of the Alien and Sedition Acts.

As for the Sedition part, this was a personal gift from John Adams to himself. He was a very egotistical, sensitive man who could not take criticism of his policies from the newspapers. As stated by the National Archives, "The Sedition Act made it a crime for American citizens to "print, utter, or publish...any false, scandalous, and malicious writing" about the government."

John Adams, a Federalist, believed that in putting restrictions on citizenship and free speech, he was preventing American people from sympathizing with the French in the potential war that was brewing between America and France, since France was currently raging and ruining everything and making everything difficult for everyone.

Now, where does Hamilton come in? Hamilton was a Federalist, and while he didn't agree with Adams on almost anything, he was fiercely against any kind of violent rebellion. This is exhibited in the many times he attempted to stop a mob, the earliest one being at King's College, when he stood before a mob and lectured them, buying time for the president of the college to escape being tarred and feathered. This is repeated during the Cadaver Riots in 1788. This belief of his can be traced back to his childhood in the Caribbean, in which there was a constant fear that the overwhelming enslaved population (80% of the island's inhabitants were enslaved Africans) would revolt.

Hamilton was also a fan of Thomas Hobbes, who believed in a cynical idea of human nature, in which every individual is self-serving to their own wants and needs. Hobbes wrote in The Leviathan, "And from hence it comes to pass that, where an invader hath no more to fear than another man's single power, if one plant, sow, build, or possess, a convenient seat others may probably be expected to come prepared with forces united to dispossess and deprive him not only of the fruit of his labor but also of his life or liberty." The key differences between the philosophies of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke also resemble the distinction between Federalists and Democratic Republicans.

All this to say, Hamilton's beliefs were shared with Adams- the French immigrants were possibly dangerous, being a threat to the stable revolution that was surviving in America. Additionally, he followed the principles of Hobbes in his belief that the government was responsible for keeping the people in check, and preventing them from entering into their natural state, which made life "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." The goal of the Alien and Sedition Acts was to prevent individuals aiming to bring a French-style rebellion to the United States, and to discourage similar sentiments from circulating in the press.

Clearly, this didn't work. The United States never went to war with France, this violation of the right to the press was not tolerated, Adams never served another term as president, and Hamilton never convinced a mob to disperse. The Alien and Sedition Acts weren't entirely anti-immigrant, as they were mainly targeted by the French, and if you're asking me personally, I believe Hamilton was able to disregard this as the law for citizenship (changing the residency requirements from 5 to 14 years) wouldn't apply to him anymore, and he could further hide the fact that he was an immigrant. He was ashamed of his origins, as the Caribbean was used at the time as, essentially, a large prison, and he didn't have the best reputation while he was there. I do think it is ironic that Adams was responsible for the Alien and Sedition Acts, and he was the one who tormented Hamilton for this birthplace. But, you know, I wasn't in that crazy ass redhead's mind.

I know this is long, but I've thought about this before, and I love getting into the reasoning behind Hamilton's politics. He was one of those cases where you can really see how his personal life influenced his political beliefs, and I think that's really interesting. Anyway, I hope this helps, and thank you for the ask <3

[sebsketchs]

you already know what i want

one french minor character coming up, hot off the barricades!

[worldhistoryfacts]

A counter-revolutionary cartoon published during the French Revolution showing two revolutionaries hanging from the gallows. the one on the left is literally two-faced and wearing revolutionary colors. The movement of the hanging men is called a “Pas de Deux” between the Jacobins and Feuillants, two of the major radical groups during the revolution.

[tecumsehtemple-blog]

Historical Whiplash

In my French Revolution class today we discussed the National Convention and the more radical and violent phase of the Revolution. At that point there was a lot of counter-revolutionary activity within France itself, (including a full scale civil war in the province of Vendee) a foreign invasion in eastern France and an economy in the shitter. In order to deal with this, the Convention created the Committee of Public Safety and starting getting much more violent and defensive. So this one kid decides to raise his hand to contribute to the discussion and says: "The radicals in the Convention remind me of Nancy Pelosi. How she expects everyone to be on board with what she does and if they don't she wants their head on a steak."

Dude, WHAT?

I hate Pelosi as much as the next guy but holy shit. I was so disturbed I stood up for her in class by replying: "Nancy Pelosi's never killed anybody."

The whole class had a good lol and my professor said one of the greatest things ever.

"I was really expecting you to compare them to Joe Stalin and when you said Nancy Pelosi I got historical whiplash."

[publius-library]

okay, just a question: I've heard somewhere on the internet (I know, very trustable lmao) that Jefferson was scared shitless of the Haitian Revolution and that his own slaves would try to pull off the same thing and kill him, and that he almost fucked up the U.S. financially 'cause of it. So, do you know if any of it is true? Istg I know nothing on this man lmao

Yes, that is true, though I would think of it slightly differently.

Jefferson, as a slave-owner, was constantly afraid of slave rebellions. This was an attitude shared by both Democratic Republicans and Federalists because both parties were, in fact, racist. So, when Haiti declared independence, Jefferson refused to acknowledge this, and it wasn't until 1862 that the United States would recognize Haitian independence.

I don't know how exactly that would affect the US finances, but it did ruin relations between the US and Haiti until 1862. This occurred around the same time as the French Revolution, and it did reflect negatively on Jefferson that he supported one and not the other.

But yes, Thomas Jefferson was scared shitless of slave revolts, and the fact that one was successful in forming a country terrified him. Thanks for the ask.

[bunniesandbeheadings]

Pending the extermination of the terrorists, he [deputy Gerente] insisted on the institution of a festival commemorating the 9th of Thermidor, evidently to serve as an antidote to that of January 21. In spite of Legendre's opposition to the motion as giving too much importance to Robespierre, who was no more than "the apprentice of crime," the festival was established, after Tallien had extolled the day in which he had played a leading part.

Albert Mathiez, After Robespierre: The Thermidorian Reaction