#not wcth

[whencallstheheart]

[bellesdiaries]

when calls the heart 10x12

[dewofthesearosemarygrey]

Nathan And Elizabeth Vs Jack and Elizabeth

I've noticed a Lot of People saying Not another Mountie, Or that they don't want anyone Replacing Jack, or that Elizabeth Is just Jack projecting again on Nathan. I think there is some merit to that argument but a lot of the worry is Unfounded Lets look at some of the similarities and Differences and Why I think Nathan is a Good choice for Elizabeth and NOT a replacement.

Similarities.

Nathan is a Mountie

Nathan Loves Elizabeth

Nathan makes Elizabeth think deeply

Nathan is friends with Bill

Nathan has a dog

Nathan is not good at speechmaking

Nathan uses intuition

Differences

1.Nathan is Quieter than Jack

2. Nathan Has a daughter figure.

3. Nathan is a mountie by Job rather than Calling and would give it up for Elizabeth. His calling is more to be a family protector figure.

4. Nathan has only a few best friends, but loves and protects them intensely, wheras Jack was more generally friendly.

5. Nathan is a more awkwardly quiet dorky hero , Jack is more confident and bold hero

6. Nathan is more sensitive, Jack is more thick skinned.

7. Nathan is more small detail oriented, Jack is more big-picture.

8. Nathan is much less jealous than Jack he wants Elizabeth to be Happy even if its not with Him whereas Jack was more Annoyed/Angry at Elizabeth's other suitors such as Billy and Charles and Abigail had to tell him outright that he was Jealous and that the best way to Get Elizabeth Back would be to be nicer. "you catch more flies with Honey than Vinegar"!

When we first met Jack he was Bold confident and really annoyed at having to Look after Elizabeth. his relationship with Elizabeth was Hate-to-love dynamic and there was a lot of rough teasing banter and Jealousy.

With Nathan it is a Completely Different situation when he meets Elizabeth it is a shy but friendly meeting, and as we know from season 8 he had chosen by himself to come there to look after Elizabeth, The Exact Opposite of Jacks Situation. His whole goal was to protect her and leave it at that, Until he began slowly to make friends with her and find out what an amazing woman she was. then he didn't want to Love her becuase He felt Guilty about it, but slowly they overcame that and became really close Friends When she Chose Lucas he was the one to Go to Lucas WHY? Because he loved her so much he wanted her Happiness no matter what even Over his Own Happiness, Jack would never have done that for Elizabeth He Loved her a lot But not quite at the cost of his own Dreams, Goals and Happiness. Jack and Elizabeth had a healthy Balenced relationship where both could Express there own personalties and follow there callings, but I think Nathan Loves Elizabeth in a different and more Selfless way than Jack something which would be Amazing to see play out on screen, not to even get started on the mixed Family Dynamic! This difference Is why after saying Not another Mountie in season 6 I changed to Team Nathan in season 7

[bitchsince1976]

Just my opinion:

This is not Elizabeth seeing Jack in Nathan.

She is not projecting Jack onto Nathan. There is no Ghost Jack here.

She's not seeing just a Mountie uniform.

Elizabeth is finally seeing Nathan Grant!

I hate that the show is teasing Team Nathan with a 'Grant us a family' scene, or a possible Nathan/Elizabeth flip.

I'm strictly a Nathan fan, and I don't want to get my hopes up.

Easier said than done.

[lucabethforever]

If you have to tear down a much-beloved character and discredit years of storytelling and canon to make your new ship sail then that tells you all you need to know about that new relationship.

It is so obvious this whole season was written to be a TN fanfiction come to life and to clear Elizabeth and Nathan of any wrongdoing last season. Rosemary literally asked Elizabeth if the news about Jeanette made her feel less guilty about the way she ended things with Lucas. It's so obvious what the writers are doing. But it won't work. As far as we're concerned Elizabeth and Nathan are cheaters and liars and we loathe them.

This season also doesn't realistically validate any criticism of Elizabeth and Lucas’ relationship or Lucas himself since all of these issues have had no basis whatsoever previously in the show. If they had it would be legitimate and we would accept it as such.

Just looking at the Jeanette storyline, Lucas never referred to her as an old poor widow. It's also unrealistic for her to rely on seeing a newspaper article to track Lucas down when he was in direct contact with her and told her how Hope Valley was perfect. When Lucas saw her in this episode it was like he saw a ghost. He couldn't wait for her to be out of town. So why would he freely contact her without hesitation in previous seasons? If he doesn't trust that she's gone straight and is associating with the right people why did he enlist her help to bring down Wyman Walden? The answer is a RETCON. This show and the characters are Linday Sturman’s version. LS and her team are revisiting resolved storylines and writing them the way they would have had they been at the helm. This season is season 2 of WCTH: a different version.

[bell-gryffin]

Well, it was a good run but it’s time to move on from the show.

[a-beautiful-heart-wf001]

I’m not going to lie, I dropped WCTH for about two years because I was so upset with E choosing L. Then last spring, my mom asked me if I’ve kept up, and I told her I didn’t and explained why. Then she said, “You REALLY need to catch up.”

So I took her advice and spent the next few days watching the episodes I missed on Peacock.

I am SO GLAD I did.

Super excited to see what this new season brings.

[whencallstheheart4ever]

The way they look at each other >>>>>>

[unhingedhearties]

A Story Told In 4 Acts

[romancemedia]

Although the show won't be coming back until next month, I just want to clarify one simple thing... I QUIT When Calls the Heart.

Last season was BEYOND disappointing because the writers really screwed things up for the characters, but their biggest mistake was breaking up Lucas and Elizabeth and they're going to get her together with Nathan!!! They Have NO Chemistry. Zero. Nada. Zippo. Zlich! And Worst of All, they are getting her together with the man responsible for her husband's DEATH! HOW SCREWED UP IS THAT!

The only thing about last season I enjoyed was the birth of Rosemary and Lee's daughter, but aside from that WCTH made one too many mistakes and enough is enough! I am done with WCTH unless they start making some changes!!! Until then, I QUIT!

[whencallstheheart]

[bellesdiaries]

I'm asking you to be honest with yourself. Is this what you want? What other choice do I have?

[dewofthesearosemarygrey]

When calls the Heart Season 8 season 10 parallel Scene

This scene from season 8 Nathan Tells Elizabeth "Let me know when You're ready"

In season 10 on the same spot on the steps He tells Elizabeth when talking about sharing things with their childeren "They'll let you know when they're ready"

Cute Parallel that shows Lindsey Sturman really did her homework!

Hopefully Elizabeth will let Nathan know when she's ready.

[coolcatkerr]

Elizabeth + Nathan || "I don't think I was listening to my heart..."

I am READY for season 11 - that promo poster (internally screaming).

I was always a Nathan fan, don't get me wrong I didn't dislike Lucas but I saw Lucas as her old life; safety in the comfort of it from the beginning. Whereas Nathan was the unhappy ending with Jack/ unsafe path. I felt like Lucas could offer all these different possibilities (trips away to the city, literature etc) and comforts to Elizabeth which in the end would take her back to the world she left in season 1 and it was always going to be about if she wanted that for her future. So season 10 made sense to me (But I can understand why with season 9 giving no hint to this why Lucas fans feel let down in this writing - maybe it wasn't the initial plan - who knows)

It always interested me how when the triangle was happening Lucas did the grand gestures and "grand ideas" - love through gifts bought, making for beautiful scenes and visual "luxuries", spoiling Elizabeth as every woman should experience. However, Nathan could only offer his words and his actions, handmade gifts; in the end his honesty as a friend in wanting her to be happy.

I really can't wait to see how this relationship unfolds, this blended family dynamic will be great to see. I am curious to see if Allie will be happy or apprehensive as she was upset when Elizabeth chose Lucas so maybe she won't be so quick to soften.

To be continued - waiting for new material this time next month to continue with this couple with edits!

[rosemarygrey]

Nathan and Elizabeth Parallel Scenes Aesthetic

[lucabethforever]

His heart was completely hers

Her heart belonged to another

He wanted a life with her

She dreamt of a life with another

All he wanted was to stay

He left to save the place she adored