#rather than pulling random characterization out of thin air | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

dashiellqvverty · 6 months ago

Text

at the end of the day the stage version of newsies is just a more fun experience because the dancing is so BIG the singing is better the songs themselves are better (the difference in Once and For All…. oh my god) but i am definitely coming around on the movie having its merits! watching it again so soon after the last time i saw it i’m especially thinking about how much more fully realized so many of the characters are (except sarah but. well.) and ultimately i think that’s just the nature of the kind of show that newsies is, but in paticular i’m really starting to prefer how crutchie (or i guess crutchy) is done in the movie. don’t get me wrong i love that he has a more significant role in the musical and i am jackcrutchie shipper #1 but he feels like much more of an individual person and overall rascal in the movie as opposed to a sweet and sympathetic prop for jack’s story 😬

#like truly i just think. this isn’t a thing with ALL musicals but what i mean about the kind of show that newsies is #like it’s all about the big numbers and the dancing and i LOVE that #there’s simply not time to have the little details that expand on these characters #all of that goes into jack and i DO prefer stage!jack as a character #but like obviously katherine is. more of a character than sarah but only slightly #and like you would need so much more time of just dialogue scenes to have fuller development for characters like crutchie and even davey #there’s stuff there to work with especially with davey like there’s a clear intention in his character #but it’s small moments and you really have to pay attention and work with that #there is just not time to have all the songs and dancing i love AND do all of that for every character id want to see it for #it’s a big disney family musical that’s not what the point is #however i DO think they could’ve done more with katherine #write a romantic duet that is more fitting to what we know about her so far. and expands on that even #rather than pulling random characterization out of thin air #just as an example <3 #r.txt

4 notes · View notes