yourfavouritenpcandcats

[yourfavouritenpcandcats]

🧿 The Dark Side of Destiny: Villainous and Corrupted Chosen Ones

Chosen for Darkness

(Bonus Page: The Chosen One Project)

Not every Chosen One becomes a saviour.

While the trope traditionally celebrates figures destined to heal or redeem, many narratives explore a darker possibility: that those marked by prophecy, divine favour, or extraordinary power might fall into villainy instead.

These corrupted or villainous Chosen Ones add depth and danger to fantasy storytelling. They challenge the assumption that destiny equates to goodness, and they reveal how easily power can distort intention.

There are several key examples where the Chosen One turns toward destruction -and consider what these fallen figures teach us about fate, agency, and moral responsibility.

🌟 Destined for Ruin: Fallen Chosen Ones Across Fantasy🌟

Anakin Skywalker (Star Wars prequels) exemplifies the tragic Prophetic Archetype. Prophesied to bring balance to the Force, Anakin’s fear of loss and desperate need for control drive him into darkness. Rather than saving the galaxy, he becomes Darth Vader - the enforcer of tyranny he was meant to destroy. Or perhaps the perfect weapon of destiny who truly did bring balance to the Force.

Sephiroth (Final Fantasy VII) presents another chilling image of corrupted destiny. Elevated by Shinra as the “perfect solider,” or Divinely Selected Figure. He was initially a celebrated hero, Sephiroth’s discovery of his manufactured origins -and his supposed greater “purpose”- leads him to embrace apocalyptic destruction, reshaping his destiny into a quest for godhood.

Emperor Zarkon (Voltron: Legendary Defender, 2016) offers a subtler tragedy. Once a noble Paladin of the Black Lion -an Artifact Wielder chosen for leadership and balance- Zarkon’s obsession with power and immortality slowly warps his destiny. The very force that once marked him as a protector becomes the tool of his downfall, transforming him into a brutal conqueror.

Oryx, the Taken King (Destiny video game lore) similarly ascends to dark godhood by making a bloody pact with cosmic forces. By taking Manifest Incarnation through force, his “chosen” path is one of annihilation, a deliberate rejection of mortality and community in favour of dominion.

In each case, destiny does not protect against corruption.

It amplifies it.

🌟 Narrative Power: Why Fallen Chosen Ones Matter🌟

Villainous Chosen Ones are more than mere reversals of the heroic narrative.

They force readers and audiences to confront uncomfortable truths about power, privilege, and the fragility of moral intention.

They show that being “chosen” is not an absolution -it is a test.

Fallen Chosen Ones:

Reveal the neutrality of destiny. Prophecy and selection are not moral judgments.

Highlight the importance of choice. Greatness requires conscious, continuous ethical action -not just anointing.

Mirror the hero’s potential for failure. They act as dark reflections, showing what could happen if virtue gives way to fear, anger, or pride.

By corrupting the promise of the Chosen One, these stories deepen their emotional and philosophical stakes.

They remind us that the power to save and the power to destroy are often terrifyingly close.

🌟 Corruption as a New Kind of Destiny🌟

The fall of the Chosen One is not merely personal tragedy.

It critiques the very systems that elevate individuals above others, questioning the societal need for singular saviours.

When heroes fall:

It becomes clear that no prophecy is infallible.

It exposes the dangers of concentrating hope -or power- in one figure.

It calls for vigilance, humility, and shared responsibility rather than blind faith in destiny.

In a genre increasingly aware of systemic injustice and complexity, villainous Chosen Ones feel not just relevant -but necessary.

They invite us to ask: If destiny can create monsters as easily as heroes, how should we rethink what it means to be “chosen”?

The Choice Beneath the Crown

Ultimately, the most compelling Chosen One stories -heroic or villainous- hinge on a simple truth:

Being chosen is never enough.

The heroes we admire, and the villains we fear, are shaped not by the hand of fate alone, but by their decisions in the face of it.

Destiny may light the path.

But it is choice -and the courage to choose wisely- that defines a life.

🧿 Project Navigation:

Start here: [The Chosen One: From Sacred Myth to Fantasy Staple (Part 1)]

➡️ [Typologies of the Chosen One (Part 2)]

➡️ [Psychological and Cultural Roots (Part 3)]

➡️ [Breaking Destiny (Part 4)]

[yourfavouritenpcandcats]

🧿 Breaking Destiny: Modern Subversions of the Chosen One

When Destiny Isn’t Enough

(Part 4 of 4: The Chosen One Project)

If early fantasy literature presented destiny as a promise, modern fantasy often treats it as a problem.

In a genre increasingly aware of systemic complexity, moral ambiguity, and the dangers of exceptionalism, the Chosen One trope no longer holds the easy answers it once seemed to offer.

Today’s writers are asking harder questions:

What happens when prophecy fails?

When destiny demands injustice?

When the weight of being “chosen” crushes rather than uplifts?

In this final section, we explore how contemporary storytellers are subverting, complicating, and reimagining the Chosen One -not to destroy its mythic power, but to reclaim it with greater honesty.

🌟 Challenging the Prophecy: Destiny as a Trap🌟

One of the most common subversions in modern fantasy is the idea that prophecy itself is flawed, weaponised, or false.

In His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman, prophecy becomes a tool of manipulation. Lyra is marked as a second Eve, but the adults around her seek to control, rather than empower, her destiny. The narrative questions whether foreknowledge is truly guidance -or simply another form of control.

Similarly, The Poppy War by R.F. Kuang frames divine selection not as a blessing, but as a curse. Protagonist Rin’s connection to godlike power isolates and destroys more than it saves, showing that divine favour can be indistinguishable from divine cruelty.

By destabilising the reliability of prophecy, these stories force readers -and heroes- to reckon with choice rather than inevitability.

🌟 The Reluctant or Refusing Hero🌟

Modern narratives increasingly depict heroes who reject or resent their supposed destinies.

Buffy Summers (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) famously wishes for a normal life, treating her Chosen One status as a burden that isolates her from friends, family, and happiness.

In The Broken Earth trilogy by N.K. Jemisin, no singular hero arises. Power is distributed, and characters resist any narrative that demands they suffer for the world’s supposed “greater good.”

These stories reveal that true heroism lies not in accepting destiny blindly, but in interrogating what that destiny demands -and whether it is worth pursuing at all.

🌟 Shifting from Singular to Collective Heroes🌟

Another major evolution of the trope is the decentring of the singular hero altogether.

Rather than one Chosen One bearing the weight of the world, many modern fantasies distribute agency among groups, communities, or even ecosystems.

In The Broken Earth, Essun’s story is deeply intertwined with the fates of others -her daughter, her communities, her oppressors- and no single act of salvation is enough.

Even in Avatar: The Legend of Korra, the sequel to The Last Airbender, the idea of the singular Avatar is complicated: Korra struggles with political realities that no lone saviour can fix, requiring coalition-building and systemic change.

These narratives reflect a cultural shift: the growing recognition that collective action, not isolated exceptionalism, drives meaningful transformation.

🌟 Destiny as a Choice, Not a Mandate🌟

At the heart of these subversions lies a powerful reimagining:

Destiny is no longer an absolute.

It is a possibility -one that must be consciously accepted, challenged, or reshaped.

Modern Chosen Ones are not simply reacting to fate.

They are negotiating with it.

They are asking: If I am chosen, what am I choosing in return?

This shift restores agency to characters, offering richer, more resonant stories. It also mirrors broader cultural anxieties about power, responsibility, and systemic injustice -issues that cannot be solved by a single figure, no matter how “chosen” they may be.

Choosing Ourselves

The Chosen One trope endures because it touches something ancient and vital in us: the desire to believe in transformation, purpose, and possibility.

But in a world where easy narratives no longer suffice, the Chosen One must evolve. Today’s most powerful fantasy stories remind us that true heroism does not lie in being chosen. It lies in choosing -choosing to act, to question, to resist, to build.

As readers and writers, perhaps we are no longer waiting to be anointed by prophecy. Perhaps we are learning to choose ourselves.

🧿 Project Navigation:

Start here:➡️ [The Chosen One: From Sacred Myth to Fantasy Staple (Part 1)]

➡️ [Typologies of the Chosen One (Part 2)]

➡️ [Psychological and Cultural Roots (Part 3)]

➡️ [Bonus: The Dark Side of Destiny]

[yourfavouritenpcandcats]

🧿 Why We Crave Chosen Ones: Psychological and Cultural Roots

The Enduring Appeal of Being “Chosen”

(Part 3 of 4: The Chosen One Project)

In a world often marked by uncertainty, chaos, and injustice, the idea that one individual could be destined to set things right is irresistibly comforting.

Despite its predictability -or perhaps because of it- the Chosen One trope endures. Across books, films, games, and myths, audiences return again and again to stories of heroes marked by fate.

But why?

What deeper psychological and cultural forces draw us to these narratives? And what happens when the fantasy of destiny begins to work against the stories themselves?

🌟 The Mythic Need for Meaning🌟

Joseph Campbell’s The Hero with a Thousand Faces (1949) argues that myths across cultures share a common structure because they address universal human needs: the need for purpose, transformation, and reconciliation with mortality.

The Chosen One, in this framework, becomes a vessel for hope.

Their journey reassures us that suffering has meaning, that trials lead to growth, and that the individual can triumph over chaos.

In an era increasingly shaped by disenchantment -the erosion of religious, communal, and mythic frameworks- the Chosen One offers a modern substitute for ancient sacred narratives. They provide a way for readers to experience transcendence through fiction.

When we read about a Chosen One, we are not merely entertained.

We are invited to believe, however briefly, that destiny itself has a plan.

🌟 Psychological Comfort in Narrative Coherence🌟

Beyond mythic resonance, the Chosen One also fulfils psychological needs for coherence and agency.

Research in narrative psychology suggests that individuals are drawn to stories that offer clear beginnings, middles, and endings.

Stories that affirm that actions have consequences and that lives have arc and meaning.

The Chosen One trope creates a powerful narrative coherence:

The world is broken.

A figure rises.

Change is inevitable.

In a reality often defined by randomness and systemic complexity, this structure provides catharsis.

It reassures readers that even in the face of overwhelming odds, individuals can matter -and that destiny can intervene when human will alone seems insufficient.

Especially for younger readers, narratives of exceptionalism offer a potent emotional anchor during periods of identity formation and uncertainty.

🌟 The Danger of Narcissistic Fantasy🌟

However, the same features that make the Chosen One trope comforting can also make it dangerously hollow.

As Anthony Rella critiques, the myth of the Chosen One can encourage a narcissistic fantasy: the belief that one’s mere existence, rather than one’s choices or efforts, guarantees significance.

When poorly handled, Chosen One narratives:

Strip agency from protagonists (they succeed because they must, not because they earn it).

Flatten character development (external destiny replaces internal growth).

Create unrealistic expectations in audiences about individuality and “specialness.”

In these cases, destiny becomes an excuse, not a challenge.

The hero succeeds because the narrative demands it -not because they struggled, learned, or sacrificed in meaningful ways.

Worse, when every hero is “chosen,” narratives risk implying that those who are not exceptional by birth or fate are simply irrelevant -an idea at odds with the humanistic ideals many of these stories aim to affirm.

🌟 A Tension Between Fate and Choice🌟

At its best, the Chosen One trope dramatizes the tension between fate and free will.

The most enduring Chosen Ones -from Frodo Baggins to Buffy Summers- are not defined by their prophecies alone.

They are defined by what they choose to do with their burden.

They remind us that destiny may open the door, but it is choice that walks through it.

This tension creates the emotional and philosophical stakes that elevate Chosen One narratives beyond mere wish-fulfilment.

As modern fantasy continues to evolve, this tension becomes even more crucial. Readers increasingly demand stories where characters shape their fates -not where fate shapes the characters.

Why Destiny Still Matters (Carefully)

The Chosen One endures because it offers us hope:

Hope that order can emerge from chaos.

Hope that meaning can arise from suffering.

Hope that individuals can still shape history, even when the world feels immovable.

But when destiny replaces agency, that hope turns hollow.

Understanding the psychological and cultural roots of the Chosen One prepares us to see where the trope can grow -and where it must be challenged.

🧿 Project Navigation:

In the next and final section, we explore how modern Fantasy writers are breaking, reimagining, and reshaping the Chosen One narrative for a new era of storytelling.

Start here: ➡️ [The Chosen One: From Sacred Myth to Fantasy Staple (Part 1)]

➡️ [Typologies of the Chosen One (Part 2)]

➡️ [Breaking Destiny (Part 4)]

[yourfavouritenpcandcats]

🧿 The Many Faces of Destiny: Typologies of the Chosen One

More Than One Way to Be “Chosen”

(Part 2 of 4: The Chosen One Project)

Not all Chosen Ones are created equal.

While the overarching idea remains the same -an individual burdened or blessed by destiny- the way that destiny manifests varies greatly across stories. Some heroes are prophesied, some are anointed by divine beings, some stumble across sacred relics, and others are born as living embodiments of cosmic necessity.

By examining these variations, we can better understand how Fantasy stories use the Chosen One trope to explore different questions about power, agency, and fate.

These are the five major types of Chosen Ones that dominate Fantasy literature, film, and games, with examples that reveal both the richness and the risks of each category.

🌟1. The Prophetic Archetype🌟

“The boy who lived... destined to vanquish the Dark Lord.”

The Prophetic Archetype centres around a figure foretold long before their birth, marked by ancient omens or cryptic predictions.

Their journey is framed by the need to fulfil -or sometimes escape- the prophecy that defines their existence.

Examples:

Harry Potter (Harry Potter series) - marked by prophecy to defeat Voldemort.

Rand al’Thor (The Wheel of Time) - fated to battle the Dark One at the end of the world.

Neo (The Matrix) - “The One” prophesied to liberate humanity from the machines.

The Prophetic Archetype often carries an inherent tragedy: the character’s life is not their own. Their choices, struggles, and sacrifices are weighed against the pull of fate -and readers are invited to question whether destiny uplifts or imprisons them.

🌟 2. The Divinely Selected Figure🌟

“Into every generation, a Slayer is born…”

Here, the Chosen One is not merely predicted but actively selected by a god, cosmic force, or metaphysical entity. Their role often carries a sacred or spiritual weight, and their powers are granted, not inherent.

Examples:

Buffy Summers (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) - chosen by mystical forces to fight evil.

Moses (Biblical narratives) - selected by God to lead his people out of Egypt.

Percy Jackson (Percy Jackson and the Olympians) - son of a god, called into divine conflicts.

The Divinely Selected Figure embodies questions of duty, faith, and burden. They often struggle not with accepting their abilities, but with accepting the moral or emotional cost of being “chosen” by powers beyond their understanding.

🌟 3. The Artifact Wielder 🌟

“It chose me. I didn’t choose it.”

In this variation, the character becomes significant because they inherit or wield an ancient artifact of immense power. Unlike the Prophetic or Divine types, these heroes may stumble into destiny through accident, circumstance, or inheritance.

Examples:

Frodo Baggins (The Lord of the Rings) - bearer of the One Ring.

King Arthur (Arthurian legends) - wielder of Excalibur, the sword of kingship.

Aladdin (Aladdin) - accidental master of a genie through the magic lamp.

The Artifact Wielder often explores questions of worthiness and corruption. The object may amplify the hero’s best or worst traits, making the story less about predetermined fate and more about how power is wielded once granted.

🌟 4. The Manifest Incarnation🌟

“When the world needed him most, he vanished…”

Some Chosen Ones are not called or chosen -they are born as the living embodiment of cosmic necessity. They are avatars, reincarnations, or natural phenomena given human form.

Examples:

Aang (Avatar: The Last Airbender) - the Avatar, reincarnated to maintain balance.

Krishna (Hindu mythology) - an avatar of Vishnu sent to restore dharma.

The Doctor (Doctor Who, depending on interpretation) - a timeless being embodying hope and defiance.

Manifest Incarnations dramatize the tension between individuality and cosmic role. These characters often face identity crises, torn between their human desires and their larger, often impersonal, purpose.

🌟 5. The Legitimate Monarch🌟

“The hands of the king are the hands of a healer.”

In this iteration, the Chosen One is revealed to be the rightful heir to a throne, a lineage hidden or forgotten. Their destiny is tied not just to saving the world, but to restoring a rightful order or repairing a broken kingdom.

Examples:

Aragorn (The Lord of the Rings) - heir of Isildur, destined to reunite the kingdoms of Men.

Daenerys Targaryen (A Song of Ice and Fire) - claiming the lost Targaryen dynasty.

Simba (The Lion King) - born to reclaim his kingdom from a usurper.

The Legitimate Monarch type often navigates questions of governance, responsibility, and legacy. These stories ask not just whether the hero can claim the throne, but whether they deserve to rule at all.

Many Paths, One Destiny?

Each type of Chosen One offers a different way to explore power, fate, and identity.

Yet across these variations, one persistent question lingers: Is destiny a gift - or a cage?

🧿 Project Navigation:

In the next section, we will dive deeper into the cultural and psychological appeal of the Chosen One, exploring why this trope continues to captivate readers even as it evolves, fractures, and falters.

Start here: ➡️ [The Chosen One: From Sacred Myth to Fantasy Staple (Part 1)]

➡️ [Psychological and Cultural Roots (Part 3)]

➡️ [Breaking Destiny (Part 4)]

[yourfavouritenpcandcats]

🧿 The Chosen One: From Sacred Myth to Fantasy Staple

The Familiar Weight of Destiny

(Part 1 of 4: The Chosen One Project)

We know this story. A hidden heir. A lost prophecy. A reluctant saviour called forth to change the world.

The Chosen One trope has become one of the most recognisable narrative devices in Fantasy storytelling. Yet its roots run far deeper than recent bestselling novels or blockbuster films. Long before Harry Potter, Luke Skywalker, or even King Arthur, stories of exceptional individuals marked by fate shaped human imagination across cultures and centuries.

By exploring how the Chosen One trope evolved from sacred myth to genre fixture, we can see how it continues to shape Fantasy narratives and why modern audiences are increasingly questioning its power.

Before we can understand the ways in which the trope succeeds, falters, or transforms, we must first trace its long, complicated history.

From Myth to Modernity: A Brief History of the Chosen One

🌟Ancient Origins: Divine Favor and Cosmic Struggle🌟

The Chosen One narrative predates the Fantasy genre by millennia.

In ancient epics like the Epic of Gilgamesh, The Odyssey, and the stories of Moses in religious texts, individuals marked by divine favour, prophecy, or unique birth were tasked with changing the fate of their people. These early Chosen Ones reflected profound cultural anxieties: survival against chaos, the fragility of civilisation, the desire for a guiding force in an uncertain world.

Joseph Campbell’s study The Hero with a Thousand Faces (1949) synthesised these global myths into the “monomyth” -a common narrative pattern where a seemingly ordinary figure is called to adventure, undergoes trials, and emerges transformed. The Chosen One embodies this journey, serving as a bridge between the human and the mythic, the mortal and the divine.

In these ancient narratives, destiny was not merely a tool of storytelling. It was an articulation of cosmic order itself.

🌟The 19th Century: Proto-Fantasy and the Return to Myth🌟

The Romantic and Victorian periods saw a revival of mythic storytelling in Western literature. Writers like George MacDonald (Phantastes, 1858) and William Morris (The Well at the World’s End, 1896) wove elements of prophecy, sacred quests, and otherworldly trials into their works.

While these early fantasy experiments did not always feature a singular “Chosen One” as we recognise today, they reintroduced key components: the idea of the worthy hero, the sacred quest, and the unseen forces guiding mortal hands.

This era laid the groundwork for the Chosen One’s transition from religious symbol to literary figure.

🌟Mid-20th Century: Codifying the Trope in High Fantasy🌟

The Chosen One truly became central to Fantasy literature in the mid-20th century.

J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings (1954–1955) and C.S. Lewis’s The Chronicles of Narnia (1950–1956) codified many of the structures that now define the trope. Tolkien gave us Aragorn, the Legitimate Monarch whose hidden lineage made him the rightful king, and Frodo Baggins, the reluctant Artifact Wielder burdened with destroying the One Ring.

Meanwhile, Lewis’s Pevensie children were summoned by prophecy to liberate Narnia, a clear example of Prophetic Archetypes fulfilling ancient foretelling.

Importantly, these mid-century narratives, though mythic in scale, emphasised moral complexity, sacrifice, and internal conflict. The Chosen One was not simply a vessel of destiny; they had to choose to fulfil it, often at great personal cost.

At this stage, the trope was vibrant, resonant, and intricately tied to ideas of free will versus divine orchestration.

🌟Late 20th Century: Mass Popularisation and Commercial Expansion🌟

The late 20th century witnessed the Chosen One’s leap from literary tradition into global pop culture.

George Lucas’s Star Wars (1977) explicitly borrowed from Campbell’s Hero’s Journey, placing Luke Skywalker at the centre of a galactic prophecy.

Robert Jordan’s The Wheel of Time series (1990–2013) built a world around the Dragon Reborn, a hero bound by fate to both save and destroy.

J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter (1997–2007) brought the Chosen One into the mainstream consciousness of an entire generation: a boy marked at birth, guided by prophecy, burdened with the fate of the wizarding world.

During this era, the Chosen One trope became nearly synonymous with Fantasy itself. It provided instant stakes, easy emotional investment, and clear thematic resonance. However, the sheer volume of such narratives also began to expose the trope’s vulnerabilities -particularly its tendency toward passivity, predictability, and unearned exceptionalism.

🌟21st Century: Deconstruction, Subversion, and Evolution🌟

Contemporary Fantasy increasingly interrogates the Chosen One narrative.

Stories like His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman question the very validity of prophecy.

In Buffy the Vampire Slayer, the Chosen One mantle is portrayed as an unwanted burden, isolating and traumatising the bearer.

Authors like N.K. Jemisin in The Broken Earth trilogy fracture the idea of a single saviour, dispersing agency across multiple characters and communities.

As Anthony Rella critiques, the myth of the Chosen One risks reinforcing narcissistic fantasies of exceptionalism -fantasies that can alienate rather than empower. Meanwhile, psychological studies suggest readers are drawn to these narratives because they offer coherence and personal significance in an increasingly chaotic world.

Today, the Chosen One is no longer an unquestioned narrative anchor. It has become a site of tension: between fate and free will, individuality and community, tradition and reinvention.

🧿 Project Navigation:

Understanding the Chosen One’s history allows us to recognise its power -and its pitfalls. But not every Chosen One is the same.

In the next section, we explore the five major types of Chosen Ones that dominate Fantasy storytelling -and how each reflects a different relationship between hero, destiny, and agency.

➡️ [Typologies of the Chosen One (Part 2)]

➡️ [Psychological and Cultural Roots (Part 3)]

➡️ [Breaking Destiny (Part 4)]