#mr.shue

[cherrysfanfics-ily]

hi would you maybe write a jesse st. james reader fanfic where the reader is finn's sister and she's a really good singer, like better than rachel!

Here is your request! I hope you enjoy it, I had lots of fun writing it! It may be a more friendly type one-shot with some romantic aspects here and there, but if people want one I can do a part 2 with a more romantic take!! Genre: Fluff

Pairing: Jesse St. James x Fem! Reader

Word Count: 1825

(___’s POV)

I was sat in the choir room with the rest of the glee club the day after Rachel showed her ‘Run Joey Run’ film, with Finn on my left and, surprisingly, Jesse on my right and Rachel looking at the two of them with sad eyes on the opposite side of the room. “ Mom says she’s making alfredo with chicken tonight for dinner,” Finn spoke looking over at me, with a small smile. “ That is the best news to hear, I love her alfredo and chicken.” I smile back. “ Alright glee clubbers, does anyone else have a bad reputation song to share after Rachel’s yesterday?” Mr.Shue asked with a clap of his hands looking around at the rest of us hopefully. I quickly look around, seeing no one else wanting to go, so I raise my hand with a proud smile, “___! Come on up!” Mr.Shue said with a smile waving me up.

I stood from my chair and headed to the front, when I got there I turned to look at everyone seeing everyone watching me, and Rachel glaring at me crossing her arms. “ I’ll be honest I think a bad reputation does not equal a good reputation, I think it just means you’ll never truly have fans but haters,” I spoke looking around at everyone matching Rachel’s glare when I met her eyes, “ But I chose a song that may have a bad reputation but you just can’t help but get up and dance and sing along to.” I finished before I nodded at the band to start the music, and they started playing the instrumental to ‘Girlfriend’ by Avril Lavinge.

“ Hey, hey, you, you, I don't like your girlfriend. No way, no way, I think you need a new one. Hey, hey, you, you, I could be your girlfriend,” I sang starting to rock out to the drums and guitar, ” Hey, hey, you, you, I know that you like me. No way, no way, you know it's not a secret. Hey, hey, you, you, I want to be your girlfriend.” I sang a smirk on my face started to dance a bit, and watched as a few others recognized the song and started to dance in their seats a bit. 

“ You're so fine, I want you mine, you're so delicious, I think about you all the time, you're so addictive. Don't you know what I can do to make you feel alright?” I sang as I started to walk through everyone’s chairs circling Santana’s chair and doing a small shimmy back and forth with her before moving on. “ Don't pretend, I think you know I'm damn precious, and hell yeah, I'm the motherfuckin' princess. I can tell you like me too and you know I'm right.” I continued playfully leaning onto Kurt as he smiled at my antics. 

“ She's like so whatever, you could do so much better. I think we should get together now, and that's what everyone's talkin' about.” I sang standing back up properly before heading and playfully sitting on Mercedes's lap acting as if I was talking about someone with her, before heading back to the front and repeating the chorus. 

“ I can see the way, I see the way you look at me. and even when you look away, I know you think of me.  I know you talk about me all the time again and again.” I sang going and messing with Brittany’s head as if she might have thought of me, “ So come over here and tell me what I wanna hear. Better yet, make your girlfriend disappear, I don't wanna hear you say her name ever again.” I skipped over to Jesse and sat in his lap with a smile on my face, with him smiling back, just having lots of fun before getting up and heading back to the front again to sing the pre-chorus and chorus again. 

“ In a second, you'll be wrapped around my finger. 'Cause I can, 'cause I can do it better. There's no other, so when's it gonna sink in? She's so stupid, what the hell were you thinkin'?” I sang clapping to the beat, with the girls, excluding Rachel, joining me, standing to come to dance with me. “ In a second, you'll be wrapped around my finger. 'Cause I can, 'cause I can do it better. There's no other, so when's it gonna sink in? She's so stupid, what the hell were you thinkin'?” I continued with the guys joining the girls and me up at the front.

I went on to sing the rest of the song dancing with a few different people until Jesse and I started dancing with each other for the rest of the song. “ Hey, hey!” I finish with a huge smile on my face, as the others erupt into cheers having had lots of fun dancing and singing along. 

“ Great job ___! You gave a great example of the assignment, and got everyone up and moving along with you!” Mr.Shue said excitedly giving me a high five as we all returned to our seats, “ Alright. We have a couple of days left of the week, so if you have a song with a bad reputation then you are welcome to share it. I will see you all tomorrow.” Mr.Shue smiled at us heading to wipe off the whiteboard, and out of the corner of my eye I saw Rachel pop up and head over to Mr.Shue. I start to gather my things, putting them in my backpack. “ You ready to go?” I hear Finn ask as I grab my keys out of my bag. “ You go without me, I’m planning on heading into town for a while,” I told him hugging him, while he nodded and waved goodbye as he left. 

I finally finished putting my things in my bag and headed out of the room to my locker to drop off the books I didn’t need tonight and grab the ones I did need. I hear footsteps coming up to me before they stop and clear their throat causing me to turn to look who it is, only to see Jesse. “ Hey ___, that was a great song choice in there.” He complimented me with a smirk, causing me to smile and let out a small laugh turning back to my locker to finish what I was doing. “ Thank you, It’s a song I have on my playlist so it was an easy pick,” I told him, with a smile putting the last book away shutting my locker door, and turning back to look at him.

“ Well either way your voice was perfect for the song, and I enjoyed dancing with you.” Jesse smiled at me starting to lean on a nearby locker. “ I enjoyed dancing with you as well.” I smile back before I notice Rachel down the hallway watching Jesse and me, and I just roll my eyes and lean on my locker, “ Are you and Rachel still together? Or what happened after yesterday?” I ask him curiously. He turned his head to see Rachel watching us as well making her turn away from us and go, before turning back to look at me. “ No, I told her last night that what she did hurt me, with how she lied and used me.” He spoke shaking her head. 

“ I’m sorry you had to deal with that, should’ve warned you that she’s kind of selfish when it comes to glee club. She’s at least lucky that I haven’t talked to her about it yet.” I spoke leaning back against my locker a bit with a cross of my arms glaring at where Rachel just was. “ Yeah?” He questions raising one of his eyebrows. “ Yeah. She does these things to get her way, and not only did she use you and Puck, she used my brother.” I ranted a bit rolling my eyes. “ Well, you don’t have to worry about that since everyone has called her out for it,” Jesse stated with a small laugh.

I watched as he smiled and laughed, which brought a smile to my face, “ I’m heading into town to get some coffee and do a bit of shopping. Just have a fun time after the last few days, do you want to join me?” I ask standing straight again and adjusting my backpack. “ I’d love that honestly, it would be good to take a break.” He spoke, which made me smile a bit more. We both head to the front of the school and head towards my car. I unlock the doors as we get closer and head over to the driver seat, as Jess goes over to the passenger side. We both hop in and put our bags in the back seat so we have enough room up front before buckling in. I put the key in the ignition starting it up as I grabbed a CD case I had in the back, put it into the CD player, and started to play it. As I pull out the song I was left on last time starts to play, “ Great CD choice, and such a great song.” Jesse spoke looking over at me. 

“ I mean you can never go wrong with Gaga, and Judas is an amazing song of hers,” I responded looking over at him quickly before I looked back at the road stopping at a red light. I hear him laugh as I glance over at him to see his head thrown back against the seat before watching the lights. As the light turns green I continue down the road before I’m able to pull into the parking lot of Lima Bean, quickly finding a parking space to park in. After parking I turn the car off, Jesse and I both unbuckle and get out. I make sure to lock the door as we go to head in, with Jesse opening the door for me as I smile at him in thanks. We were quick to the counter ordering our drinks and paying before moving over out of the pay of other people. 

“ Listen ___, I want to thank you for being kind to me even if I didn’t truly deserve it. I also really appreciate you inviting me to hang out with you today. It means a lot more than you know.” Jesse spoke looking down at me with a smile. “ Of course, even if you were on the opposing team that doesn’t warrant being rude to you, and I can’t imagine how it felt for your girlfriend to triple-cast you for her wants and desires,” I told him with a smile, softly putting my hand on his shoulder. He smiles as he wraps an arm around my shoulder as our drinks are called. We go and grab them before heading out to continue with what we planned for the rest of the day.

[mauradersdaughter]

One of the biggest reasons why New Directions didn’t win more awards was because Mr.Shue sucked. He kept making the same structures in their performances (s1-s3): duet (mostly slow songs) + big number (that would have everybody singing, but have the main focus on Rachel and Finn, having Mercedes belt at the end). Their best performance that was built this way was ‘Sectionals’ from season 2, where other people got the spotlight, having the duet being Sam and Quinn and the big ending being sung by Santana.

New Directions had so much talent, but all of it was kept in the background, ‘cause Mr.Shue kept doing the same performances and having the same singers without any diversity. He could’ve done a performance where Santana, Rachel and Mercedes sung, but he was so stuck in the same boring performances that he chose. No wonder the girls left, who would want, with a talent like theirs, to be stuck in the back? Also, it shouldn’t have come to surprise to anyone that ND didn’t win ‘Regionals’ in s1, their performance was ‘Sectionals’ worthy. They could’ve been an insanely good show choir, even ranking higher at ‘Nationals’ in s2, if Mr.Shue was a better organizer, choreographer and treated kids the same, giving them fair opportunities. There was space for everyone to have a moment in their performances. (also they could’ve ranked higher if Rachel and Finn could’ve waited 5 freaking minutes; you just know that if any other kid had done what they did, they’d be getting a earful).

[kayla6]

I don’t hate any character in glee (except mr.shue, I’m his SECOND biggest hater) mainly because I’ve just decided that a lot of the characters are written poorly(Quinn, Blaine, Tina, Jake, even Ryder, and even ones I don’t particularly like i.e Finn, Puck,Artie) so I don’t take canon way too serious, but since all we have is that it’s just nice to talk about. However the people on the clock app are having the interesting conversation of glee not being a parody show and analyzing everything every character does that’s “morally wrong” i.e anything that comes out of sues mouth, Blaine, Quinn, and Rachel cheating, Santana bullying, Finn bring homophobic, etc. All of these are great conversations but I just feel we have to remember that the real enemy is Ryan Murphy and Mr. Shue

[randomestfandoms-ocs]

What’s Kath’s (and Oz) reaction to “Mr.Shue is he your son?”

Kath is very silent while she watches, once Mr Schue starts to look concerned she just gets up and walks out very very calmly (Oz follows), has more of a freak out about it once they’re alone while she processes what that actually means and that his lack of response means that, at the very least, he did cheat on Terri and Jesse could be his son

[occasional-ghost]

🌾 + Bonnie? <3

Nature 3

Send me 🌾 + an OC and I’ll tell you:

If they were given the chance to change their first name, what they would change it to: she wouldn’t!

Their favourite scent in shampoo or body wash:

Peony

How they like their coffee/tea, if they drink either: prefers both iced, also likes both to be really sweet.

What nonsensical profession (wizard, unicorn, etc.) they wanted to have as a kid:

Fairy

Their biggest insecurity: weight (Blame being a cheerleader + Sue + some gymnastics and dance coachesteachers)

The most common way they get injured: cheer stunts gone wrong.

Does their personality change when they’re alone versus they’re with people? How so?: n/a

Their romantic orientation, sexual orientation, and gender identity:

Gender identity: cis-female

Sexual orientation: bisexual

Romantic orientation: biromantic

Are they naturally more obedient or compliant towards authority?: compliant - specifically, calling out Mr.Shue on a lot of his bullshit in glee club.

(Especially when it involves Shue bringing in Holly for glee at the end of The Substitute and in Sexy with her not supposed to be being around Hayden.)

Their most painful memory: n/a

[analvolcano]

Guess what celebrity moved to town and now frequents the grocery store I work at, FUCKING MATTHEW MORRISON, I NOW MUST LIVE WITH THE THREAT OF MATTHEW MORRISON APPEARING, A REAL THREAT I MUST NOW LIVE WITH

[iamapixy]

Glee pt4

Puck: You know, what eats a large amount of the day are naps. You go to sleep it's light out, you wake up it's dark. That's the whole day. Where did that day go? I have no idea.

mr.shue: You mean on a weekend.

Puck:

Puck: Yes?

[xaeydnquartz]

Rachel's Broadway premiere episode

The saved seat for Finn. The memory of Finn empowering her performance. Mr.Shues son's middle name being Finn.

I honestly wish that was it so I could be put out of my misery from anymore pain but it's not and it hurts.

Seriously, I have begun to just skim through episodes unless it pertains to something that is important or Finn related because it all just seems so empty without Corey.

[justice4harwin]

Would it really have been SO HARD for Mr.Shue to wait for Finn OUTSIDE the locker room on the pilot episode?

Like, it's not that difficult. He waits outside and when Finn comes out he asks him: hey were you the one singing in there? I wanna invite you to join my club

[elle-smells]

im not answering that

you're jsut as much of a coward as carmen is sam i thought you were better than that

[vorepred223311]

Mr.Shue gobbling up Captain America?

Mr shue screamed in pkeasure as he came on his huge gut he'd been humping as America fought for his life inside as he melted

[screamslikeaman]

Haunted by the idea if Glee was still running, they’d have songs that blew up on Tiktok episode. Biggest jump-scare in the episode is Mr.Shue singing Mitski.

[quinnfebrey]

i will never forgive glee for trying to convince us mr.shue was sexy

*mr shue voice* baby likes his soup

[randomestfandoms-ocs]

👗 May during the “Mr.Shue is he your Son” meeting?

[occasional-ghost]

🌟 + Henry, specific to Kath (& Oz) crossovers

1) Henry is an absolute disaster in the kitchen, Kath banned him from cooking they even moved out of the Shuester apartment.

2) In Henry’s verse, the Shuester apartment is a three-bedroom. Henry and Kath share the second largest room. (Terri disapproved of the two of them sharing at first but Henry - age 6 - pointed out if she let them share, she could have Kath’s room be her craft room.)

3) Finding out the twins also have strawberry allergies is what gets Jesse to take a DNA test after being in denial fallowing the mess of Britney’s “Mr.Shue is he your son.”

4) Speaking of Jesse, both twins think he can do better than Rachel before he breaks it off. (Henry doesn’t get mad often but he’s so pissed on Jesse’s behalf after Run, Joey, Run.)

5) In verses where they date, Kath is very supportive of Oz & Henry and defends then when/if anyone (Rachel) tries to make it seem like a bad thing?

6) Since Oz never wanted to be home when Rachel was and before moving into the St.James apartment/house Henry and Kath never wanted Oz dealing with Will and Terri, more often then not they found other places around Lima to hangout outside of school.

7) Henry, Oz, Kath, & Sam all get an apartment together in New York once they graduate, Josh gets Roman to help them find a place with a landlord that won’t screw them over. (Sometimes if Henry is dating Carla/Sadie/etc & Blaine is Oz’s boyfriend, Blaine and whoever is dating Henry also move in with them.)

8) To go with that - instead of Jesse going back to LA he moves to New York but gets his own place close to the kids? (Either trying for NYADA one more time or going to NYU with Henry?)

8) Henry eventually starts thinking of Josh as more of his dad then will ever was. 🥺

9) Henry and Kath and Oz never miss eachother’s events. (Side note, Sue definitely tries to get Henry to join the Cheerio’s so she can piss Will off even more.)

10) In dating verses when they eventually get engaged, Henry and Oz’s biggest argument with their wedding is whose side Kath should be on.

[gleeincorrectquotes]

Ooohh(sorry to ask) but can you do the gunshot meme with Mr.Shue as the guy, doesnt know spanish as the gun and his career as the guy getting shot.

Then: "how could Santana do this"

Here ya go anon!