critical-espurr - Tumblr blog

[critical-espurr]

Forgive me if this seems insensitive, but I have a habit of noticing patterns.

Is it me, or has Lily not once, but twice now, claimed that someone has raped her, only AFTER they stopped being silent and came out about her?

Because the whole Courtney situation is giving me serious Lizzy slander vibes.

It's so sus to me.

that's literally all she does for everything she's accused off. everything everyone else accuses her of being is a confession, but when she accuses someone else of the same, oh, that is when you are meant to take it seriously.

indeed, LO only ever claimed that Lizzy SA her after Lizzy talked about how LO would cheat on her and ignore her boundaries regarding NSFW works.

[critical-espurr]

"The way people treat Lily Orchard is weird" they say about a woman who continues to beautify the sexual incestuous abuse she's guilty of 💀🤮

I don't goddamn know how or why people can still defend Lily but for my own sanity it's an immediate block from me.

many don't know about the incestuous abuse allegations or the mountains of other allegations against LO. they only know her like that youtuber who made that SU video years ago and how we keep talking about her, so of course for those people it will come out as weird. if someone does know about the allegations, sees LO constantly talking about incest and romanticizing every chance she has, and still chooses to defend her? now that is a different story and i have no sympathy for those people.

[critical-espurr]

"I won't take asks unless for work" lasted less than a day.

just give it a few more days and she'll start accepting anons again, but only in very brief windows that nobody can catch. we should keep a counter for how long it will take for sucky boy to appear too.

[critical-espurr]

Lily about fan art (mostly about her incest OCS): of course I have that saved! I treasure that shit!

Lily about the comic her wife quite literally invented for her and spent years drawing for free, out of love: yeah, I could get that back, but it's so bothersome, too much work.

You can't make this shit up....

like i said, only LO can be so casually callous about the labor of her wife. just like she's so callous about everything to do with that woman. it's sad.

[critical-espurr]

Check the lily tags. It looks like a certain somebody has made a new account and claimed Courtney is "dishonest" - and I don't think it's a parody or troll

Why tf can't she stay gone

i do think this is LO. the sad thing is, i do think that mostly because only LO would be so casually callous about the webcomic that her wife made her for free the last four years. she cared much more about recuperating her awful incest OC stories than her art, even though it could be recuperated, and if that isn't the quintessential experience of being married to this woman i don't know what it is. above everything else, the just not caring about MO is so LO coded and something a troll wouldn't bother with that it has to be her.

[critical-espurr]

Who is Lily Orchard, and why the f🚨ck did you call this blog "Broken Glass of Water"?

🚨 Before I start, do NOT dox, harass, or engage with Lily Orchard in any way, okay? Leave Lily alone and those who have made the choice to stay within her good graces. This blog is aimed more at Lily's behavior, those who have questions, and/or the genuinely curious.

Okay, so the darkly humorous answer to this question is, "Lily is like a broken glass of water: you can still drink out of it, but good look having anything but a painful experience."

Any time Lily and/or her fans have told people like us to "eat glass" (or any kind of petty insult for that matter), this is usually what I think of. You don't need to tell me to "eat glass" - I'm more or less doing that when you talk shit.

In what little Lily actually gets right (you know, that shit about a stopped clock being right twice a day) is undermined by many, many things... to put it nicely.

---

Now for the more serious answer: Lily Orchard was one of many YouTubers that did video essays during the height of My Little Pony's golden days, becoming popular through two mediums: In A Minute and Glass of Water. The later of the two got its name from one of the songs of the same name. You might recognize its piano, instrumental version as the intro song to Lily's earlier works of Glass of Water.

This was coined again by yours truly as a way to express my frustration with Lily's lack of morals and consistency between YouTube and other social media platforms, such as Tumblr and (for a time) Twitter.

It was during Lily's time in the MLP fandom that she first began to transition, so there's a chance some of you might know her by various dead-names, such as Bhaalspawn, Jerry Peet and/or Lily Peet.

🚨 Please refrain from using dead-names when referring to Lily: she's an asshole to be sure, but that's not a good reason to engage in bigotry.

Every blog that I watch is usually for archiving, insight, and/or interaction of some kind that relates back to Lily Orchard in some way, preferably in a constructive manner.

Under different circumstances, having this kind of traction would be really neat, so what's the problem? What the fuck has Lily done that's lead to multiple people making critical blogs about her? Well, to put it simply, she's done a lot.

Courtney (Lily's sister) was on Zena and Poppy's live-stream a while ago, but due to Poppy's violation of Courtney's privacy and Poppy's reaction after the fact, that live-stream is no longer available... well, not for free anyway. Should you choose to pay the $24.99 a month for the membership required to watch it, allow me to warn you that the live-stream in question engages in some seriously dark shit.

Thankfully, Courtney has a video out talking about these very experiences. Again, the warning about dark shit is still up for this video.

Despite Poppy's actions, there is further evidence of Lily's misconduct (sometimes even outright confessing), including (but not limited to) the master-post made by lily-orchard-gossip-blog (here's the archived version of the post) who was on a hiatus as of July 17, 2023, but came back for a week.

Then there's Britt's evidence bank of some seriously nasty shit... just an F.Y.I. alleged grooming is a constant theme in a lot of the gross shit Lily has done.

Oh, and then there's that time Lily allowed Ginger to flirt with her, and Ginger was a minor at the time (part 1/part 2), so let's add pedophilia into the mix...

Let's also not forget that time Lily tried grooming Lolo into a harem (I mean polycule), most notably through her sock puppet account, sucky-boi.

Then there's the allegation of fundraising fraud regarding Mikalia's immigration to Canada, who has yet to immigrate to Lily's residence despite the time that has elapsed at this point, making some of the donators wonder where that money actually went. This is particularly note-worthly because Lily got on the case of an anon by sharing pictures of Mikalia's living situation.

And not saying anything when Sparky (a known predator) was lurking around her, and by extension the children who still adore Lily...

And there's Astrid, another, openly confessed predator, whom Lily also did nothing about...

Yeah, the most you can get out of Lily is either weak-handed sympathy when it suits her narrative or insistence that they get a lawyer, or the rare chance that she'll demand evidence, there's no consistency beyond Lily's selfish interests.

The most recent bullshit is sucky-boi being used to ask about inappropriate advancements in connection to Sketchy, one of Lily's long-time friends, suggesting that not even Lily's male friends are safe from her inappropriate behavior.

Obviously, there's more evidence out there, but this is the tip of the iceberg.

Lily's behavior and reactions doesn't help her either, which include (but not limited to), advocacy (of death, violence, and suicide), submitting anonymous anons to suit her narrative, etc.

Lily doesn't believe archived evidence. Nevertheless, it's something I try to do anyway (along with the original link and a screenshot), least the original source is destroyed.

At the end of the day, I believe Lily is a victim to some degree, and what helped me realize that is the Poppy and Zena video that's no longer available to the public. However, being a victim of abuse does not entitle you to be abusive to other people, which is exactly what Lily has been doing.

Lily Orchard needs attention, but not the social media kind: Lily needs professional help, coupled with the genuine desire to improve, and until Lily is de-platformed (at minimum), preferably with signs of getting real help, I intend to stay here.

Questions are welcome, yes, even anon questions.

[critical-espurr]

To add a little bit of happiness to what must be a stressful day, here's a picture of the family Christmas present Twinkle.

Sweet baby...thank you. I admit I'm a bit heated about this today.

Tired of being told I have "no proof" when I've been sharing the same proof for years. Tired of being told I need to just get over it when I've literally watched somene who ADMITTED TO ME that she's a pedophile and a predator abuse, use, and harm others via her youtube platform. Tired of seeing people act like that's not a big fucking deal when I know those same people would carry pitchforks against people like Shane Dawson for comparatively less than what we've seen Lily Orchard get away with.

Just tells me these people don't actually care about protecting people or getting predators off the internet. Especially when it's someone they're a fan of.

[critical-espurr]

remember that lily is attempting to rebrand. continue to tag Lily orchard but also tag lilianvorchard lilian-v-orchard

I don't believe her story of tumblr nuking it. I think she nuked her blog on purpose to get rid of the mountain of evidence and rebrand on tumblr.

She's trying to get away from the evidence.

[critical-espurr]

said the woman who put a genocidal violent dictator who plays slavery apologia to her wife, who she keeps dirty to fuel her own fetish, as better autism representation. you want to talk about questionable choices, that one is questionable to me. not to mention the randomly also claiming the abusive violent sister of a incest game as part of the same group.

[critical-espurr]

The fact that Ethel seems incapable of accepting any wrongdoing on her part to any meaningful degree and instead twists things to always be the innocent party really should be a red flag to more people.

That's a red flag in ANYONE.

[critical-espurr]

said the woman who put a genocidal violent dictator who plays slavery apologia to her wife, who she keeps dirty to fuel her own fetish, as better autism representation. you want to talk about questionable choices, that one is questionable to me. not to mention the randomly also claiming the abusive violent sister of a incest game as part of the same group.

[critical-espurr]

Cameron really thinks he's doing something, between this and the other comments he's left. He's really making himself look more guilty, in actuality.

He speaks in a skin-crawling, condescending way that feels like someone desperately trying to keep power they feel slipping from their fingers. Lily does too, mind, but the specific way Cameron does it... it's a specific sort of way that I'm all too familiar with. I've never met a single person who speaks like that who was safe to be around, and maybe that's an obvious statement on my part given he's speaking to and about his victim, but hopefully what I mean by this is clear enough.

Can we talk about the C Hank Dopler guy ( aka Courtney's rapist) by the handle of @doplerc1 on YouTube?

This guy is just calling himself out. Sounds like he took some lessons from Lily.

😁

laughing emojis... the best weapon against CSA allegations. whatever could Courtney do now that cameron has used the best card in the entire game. i guess that Courtney is over now. the emojis have spoken. you can't argue against laughing emojis.

[critical-espurr]

So in terms of me covering Lily on youtube ive made a few decisions

I will not be speaking for anybody. Ill talk about Lily grooming her auidence, trying to normalize incest and the multiple times shes written CSEM

But I wont be putting other peoples stories in my mouth. Not unless im expressly asked to and given a script outline by the person themselves.

Im not "using" anybodys testimony, story, name, status or what have you.

Ill be speaking about what i know and whats been found online Given everything thats happened, im not going to assume the right to speak someone else's story.

[critical-espurr]

Ethel slowing down her vids to bait people into calling her boring so she can say "that's how my autism presents itself, you're just ableist" kind of reminds me of lily using her trauma or whatever diagnosis to get away with being a shit. Yes, mocking someone's flat affectation is ableist, but that alone doesn't stop her videos from being as entertaining as stubbing a toe. Public speaking isn't for everyone, and if documenting lily's shit is so harmful to her mental health as she says, then why on God's earth has she put herself at the head of it all

attention

[critical-espurr]

Didn't lily write a post somewhere warning people to stay away from cameron? That and the fact that the nicest thing I've seen her say about him was "at least he doesn't misgender in front of his kids (and he let's me have access to them)" it makes any sort of "alliance" they have with each other look very sus and like worse people

Lily put him on The Dirty.com

Which for anyone who doesnt know, is a site that was used to trash and or warn people about other people. Usually used for sex pests, grifters, women beaters and cheaters

although its usually someones ex that puts them on The Dirty, not a sibling

I find it really funny that they're stories are word for word the same "Courtney never faced any abuse until she got addicted to drugs and was groomed by a 40 year old"

cuz everyone expects the person accused of rape to say "i didnt do it" but a blanket statement like "Courtney has never faced any SA whatsoever by anyone anywhere ever untill she left the house" Thats implying that i couldnt have possibly faced assault or abuse outside my family, by someone who left my life when he was 12 and never came back into it. Its unreasonably wide statements like that that sound sus as fuck.

"i didnt rape her" would make sense for cameron to say "shes never faced abuse ever" thats a general statement that you dont get to make there golden boy.

He also calls lily my "brother" underneath my video so the misgendering sure as shit happend where the kids could see it =/

its fine, they're angy cuz i wont shut up. People are starting to talk so they need to try to cover their asses

[critical-espurr]

Is this a joke trying to make a bad jab at your audience (which doesn't work) or a confession of your own lack of creativity?