Delicious multifandom mess. Currently obsessing over FE:3H, Hadestown and Avatar:The Last Airbender (always!), among other old fandoms. [Warning: prompt me and I'll write]
So, first off I have to say I tend to like them all, or at the very least find them interesting... Especially the regulars - Rose, Martha, Donna, Clara, River... Even Amy and Rory - but I guess this does kind of answer my question, right?
Itâs not that I donât like her character, or in general - I guess I just donât appreciate how her entire life was dominated by the Doctor from start to finish. She had this remarkable experience with him when she was just a child - he was late, and she waited years for them - but I feel like itâs a bit tiresome to see how little of Amy remains if you take away the Doctor.Â
As much as travelling with the Doctor brings a lot to everyoneâs lives - how Donnaâs personality developed, how Rose had her life turned around - they all had their own thing going on before it all started. Not Amelia. She went to child psychologists because she believed in a man in a blue box. She waited around. She has vague jobs, lives in a nondescript house during her âdown timeâ... It only goes to show how the Doctor is ultimately responsible for what happens to her, and how recklessly he acted just getting into a childâs life like that. Of course, it was just after regenerating, so a bit of insanity can be excused. But even so, it feels like the character of Amy was too much defined by the Doctor (the same happens to River, in some extent, and it keeps getting worse the more bakstory we have from her) for me to be completely comfortable with...
(Please donât kill me, itâs not that I donât like her, I just wish she could have a chance to develop in her own terms a bit more.)
This being said, I really liked the way she and the Doctor parted ways - and this is mainly because Amy, for the first time, actively chose to get the Doctor out of her life because she found something that was more important to her than being with her âraggedy manâ, and thatâs some character growth.
So not the favourite Doctor, but the favourite regeneration scene? Hmm, this is interesting.Â
So hereâs a music video of all regenerations so far, so we can all refresh our minds.Â
The most touching, of course, is Tenâs regeneration into Eleven because, well...
But Iâm still very fond of Nineâs regeneration into Ten, with his delightful final speech:Â
But when it comes to the idea of the regeneration, my favourite is still of the Second into the Third Doctor, because the circumstances are so remarkable: heâs actually being sentenced to death and exile (at the same time, lol) by the hands of the Time Lords because of taking an active role in fighting against injustices in the world... Look at you, Doctor, quite the political prisoner.Â
Ok, Iâm using the plural very liberally here, because there are SO many sad moments on Doctor Who, which have made me tear up (and some still do, every time I watch it). So maybe one per season, so I donât spend the whole day crying about Doctor Who?
1x06 - Dalek - the Dalek asks Rose for permission to die.
Itâs not in this moment precisely, but this episode is filled with so many FEELS that itâs hard to pick a moment. Maybe when the case opens up and the changed dalek just wants to enjoy the sun, and asks Rose permission to die... Jeez, everything in this episode is heartbreaking.Â
2x13 - Doomsday - THAT scene on the wall + their goodbye in Bad Wolf Bay.
FFS, this sad moment even has its own heartbreaking theme to go with it.Â
Yes, you know the moment Iâm talking about. Not so much of Rose almost falling into the void, but how they act after the breach closes...
Now Iâve watched it again on youtube and I almost teared up. Thanks, challenge, for messing with my feels.
The differences in their reactions is what makes it so sad. Rose is angry, crying, while the Doctor just grows cold and still, but you can hear his heart breaking, his very soul shattering at what happened... And their unfulfilling goodbye, oh Gods, donât even get me started on that. Itâs sad. SO SAD!
3x13 - Last of the Time Lords - the Master dies in the Doctorâs arms.
youtube
No matter if you watch it with or without your shipping goggles, this scene just breaks my heart. The Master, who avoided death so much he subjected himself to horrible things to get another body, choosing to die because he wonât be the Doctorâs prisoner... You can see the Doctor having glimpses of a future together with an equal, living in the TARDIS with him, and suddenly itâs taken away... His childhood friend and nemesis, dying in his arms. Of course they come back ( the Master always comes back!) but this scene... Sigh. And one again, the music! âThis is Gallifreyâ is my favourite music from the whole Doctor Who soundtrack, and itâs a perfect place to play it.Â
Basically the entire 4th season
Oh, the fourth season - itâs especially hard, considering all the feels that Donna brings us. We have the âsong of captivityâ scene with the Oods, Donna kicking the Doctorâs ass in The Fires of Pompeii for not wanting to invervene, Jenny dying in âThe Doctorâs Daughterâ, Riverâs first appearance (and death) in the Library, oh god, the whole chain of events leading to the finale!  The Doctorâs suicide in âTurn Leftâ, Donnaâs death, the Doctor trying to escape his death throughout the season in a constantly more desperate way...
Ok, this season was pretty dark.Â
But if youâre expecting Iâll talk about the end of Journeyâs End, bout what he did to Donna - no, that doesnât make me sad. It makes me angry and a bit sick.
But the afterneath, oh gods...
youtube
Yes, maybe itâs sad, but in a whole different way. Oh Gods, Donna...
Specials - 3 The Waters of Mars - Adelaideâs suicide.
The Time Lord Victorious is wrong, and that darkness is heartbreaking as soon as he realises exactly what heâs done.
youtube
Bonus scene because I canât help myself:
Vale Decem!(Farewell Ten - the Doctor regenerates.)Â
OK, I canât even with this episode... The Master broken and wounded, but still dangerous. The Doctor and the Master wondering what their lives would be without each other. The Masterâs sacrifice. Tenâs moment of weakness right before he does the right thing and saves Wilf. His last chance to see and help his friends. His last visit to Rose. The ood singing him to sleep. I didnât even watch any videos and Iâm already crying. help!Â
youtube
Ok, now that Iâve cried all over season 4, letâs get on quickly with the other seasons, at least for fairnessâ sake.
Now, I donât really remember all that many plotlines from Elevenâs era, so Iâll just enumerate them:
5 x-02 - The Beast Below - when we find out that the ship is being powered by a tortured gigant space whale.Â
6 x 04 - The Doctorâs wife - when the TARDIS gets the chance to talk to her thief briefly before she loses human shape.
7 x 01 - Asylum of the Daleks - when we find out Claraâs double in the future is a Dalek.
Of course, thereâs âThe Angels take Manhattanâ and Amyâs letter goodbye, which is also a touching moment, but at least she lived an interesting, full life with Rory...
8th season - the feels are back.Â
Twelve sounds a bit darker overall, and the eight season had some interesting moment of shredding our heartstrings, like:
8 x 01 - Deep Breath - Elevenâs message to Clara right before he regenerates, about her accepting the new him.
8 x 02 - Into the Dalek - the Doctor wonderin whether heâs a good man, and the Dalek being transformed by having seen beauty...
8 x 04 - Listen - Scared Time Tot Doctor crying himself to sleep. That was harsh.Â
9th Season - the feels are here to stay.
9 x 10 - Face the Raven - let me be brave. Let me be brave...
9 x 11 - Heaven sent - the entire. Freaking. Episode.Â
9 x 12 - Hell Bent - the end of the universe with Ashildr; seeing the Doctor go to extremes and cross his limit again.
And, to finish this already HUGE list, the one scene that tears me up when it really isnât that much of a big deal:
The Husbands of River Song - when River talks about how the Doctor would never love her, and he reveals himself to her.
youtube
Because in this moment, we get a glimpse from behind the scenes, when sheâs not all bad-ass and impressing the Doctor. The lonely years, making her way through time and space, in love with an alien who sees everything in a bigger perspective. If anything, itâs so  relatable of how it is to love someone so deeply and know that they might even be incapable of loving you back. Sigh. Ok, better stop here before it gets too personal.Â
And now here are some kittens, because even I need some cheering up at this point:
This one is so difficult! What does the âship that could never beâ even mean? Is it a ship I donât like? Is it some ship I wish that was canon, but isnât? Is it something I ship, but would be a total trainwreck? Oh well... I guess Iâll have to interpret it myself, then.Â
One ship that I find fascinating, but would never  wish upon my darlings in Doctor Who, is actually the endgame of Ten x Rose - more specifically, Time Lord Victorious!Ten x Rose.
Imagine if he decided to break laws of Time to save Rose? Imagine what would have happened if he left his Metacrisis alone in Peteâs world and Rose saw what the Doctor did to Donna right after? If the Doctor acted selfishly regarding his feelings, would he still be Roseâs Doctor? Would she be horrified, angry? Would she want to leave him after a while? Would he let her?
So yes, itâs a fascinating ship and I love reading stories about it, but poor Rose and poor Doctor, they donât deserve to be like this...
I have the feeling that Iâll keep repeating characters and creatures during this challenge... Because really, many of them overlap.Â
So, it all depends on how we interpret the word âmonsterâ. If itâs a crude word for non-human creature, then if you listened to my ramblings yesterday you know about my love for all things Ood...
However, oods are not monsters! Apart from being non-human and having some scary tentacles, theyâre just an oppressed species who has been mutilated and had their psychic defences lowered...Â
So if the question is about monster or villain, then it implies that weâre looking for evil rather than strangeness, which brings me to another favourite who has already been featured in this challege:
Behold, Lils obsesses over the Master again!Â
So why do I love them as a villain? Probably because of their unpredictability. You know a Dalek will go âEXTERMINATE!â, that a cyberman will go âDELETE!â and that Davros will spurt something about the species he created, but what will the Master do?Â
Sing?
Will they help the Doctor and then betray him? Will they want to take over the world just to spite the Doctor? Will they create overly elaborate traps for the Doctor?Â
Or will he be genuinely be desperate for help, even from the Doctor, or team up with him to save the world from something even more terrible than our adorable schemer?
Fourth Season showed us that the reason for the Masterâs actions were the result of manipulation from the Time Lords, who planted the drumbeat as a signal into his mind when he was a child, but I donât buy the whole mental manipulation = evil thing. This might have lead to his insanity, but not to his maliciousness...
(sorry, kiddo, youâll be insane and evil from now on)
But either way, I love them as a villain and I would love to see more of them, be it in the past or the future, especially if heâs having flirty or deeply touching moments with the Doctor
My favourite episode of all, which one day will be the basis for a paper about international law (I kid you not):
4x03 - Planet of the Ood
Seriously, what a great episode. Itâs Donna and the Doctor at their best, and it brings complex and interesting issues. And the music! Donât get me started on the music!Â
youtube
In this episode, Donna and the Doctor go to the planet of the Oods. These tentacled darlings had been introduced earlier, when he was still with Rose - a slave species with a hive mind, especially susceptible to mind control.Â
At the time, Rose commented on how strange it was, but neither her nor the Doctor went deeper into that matter (maybe because they had a huge black hole and Satan itself to worry about), but all the oods ended up dying in the end.
So now the Doctor and Donna get to the bottom of things, discovering the planet where they are born and enslaved, and confront many unpleasant truths. Donna is righteously appalled at their situation, but the Doctor points out that humanity isnât so much better where they come from (âYou donât have slaves? Tell me, who made your clothes?â), and Donna canât initially face to hear the pain the Oods are in: she asks the Doctor to hear their song of captivity, but itâs too much for her. Just watch that beautiful scene:Â
youtube
To me, thatâs Ten and Donna at their best: some serious character growth for Donna, whoâs growing into this strong, compassionate person but who isnât ready to face all the heaviness of the world, and the Doctor who feels so much of other peopleâs pain to the point that he might even become desensitised...
But the most interesting thing, in my opinion, is how they handle the Ood liberation: of course, Doctor and Donna save the day and help them, but they donât do everything by themselves: the Ood were already rebelling in their non-violent, beautiful way, and their ultimate act of rebellion was turning their captor (and mutilator and torturer) into one of their own. THE BAD GUY TURNED INTO AN OOD, and now the other oods would take care of him and treat him well. Iâm tearing up here, people. The ood are beautiful and I love them. And theyâre great dancers.Â
So there it is - character development, great music, interesting themes, beautiful creatures, struggle against oppression, and the ominous foreboding of Tenâs death:Â
The worst part of Pride each year is riding the subway late at night and seeing the gay guys, mostly the ones riding by themselves, slowly take off their rainbow stickers and beads and what-not in preparation for their walk alone in their neighborhood, doing their best to prevent the off-chance of being jumped. I saw one guy with a flag in his bag turn it upside down so it wouldnât poke out.
So yeah, fuck that heterosexual pride day nonsense.
There was never much levity at the Academy. All leisure time was given up to a quite conscious development of mental and physical skills, from telepathic meditation to learning the traditional waltzes (days of studying the steps in yellowing, dusty old tomes â theyâd called them the âFoxtrots of Rassilonâ) and swimming
I donât really have a huge NOTP in Doctor Who - Iâm very easy-going when it comes to my own ships (as youâve seen yesterday), and Iâm always open to new possibilities. Really, if itâs well written, basically anything goes...Â
But if you put a gun to my head and said âchoose a ship that you donât like much in this fandom, Iâd say
- Ten x Donna (theyâre my BROTP and the great thing about them is that theyâre friends, no sexual tension there)
But if thereâs one thing that makes me very uncomfortable (no matter if in Doctor Who or any other fandom) is RPF.
I mean, fictional characters depend on us to be brought to life, but real people have their own lives, their wants and needs.Someone who is in the public eye because of acting, performing for an audience or anything like that might be exposed to us in many ways, but we donât really know them. I can tell a close friend that his current choice of partner might not be ideal, or that theyâd be super cute with someone, but doing this with people whom I donât know, and that didnât give me permission to do so makes me cringe (unless itâs that super cracky spoofy pieces who are clearly sattirical and mostly involve Donald Trump).
âYeah, Wilson played first table on the chess team, Chester used to start crying every time he heard a sad song, Dan can really rock a cocktail dress and six-inch heels, and I wasnât going to let anyone give them any shit for any of that. Â So I had to learn to beat up people bigger than me pretty early on.â
I remember when I thought people in their 20âs were adults. Now all of my friends are in their 20âs and everybody is just kind of fumbling around bumping into each other, trying to figure out where the free food is
Yes, I am a tortured being who has their soul split in two, because Iâm incapable of having a single OTP - but since even the Doctor could have a biological metacrisis and get a human version of himself, so can I split my attention between Ten and Tentoo and consider it my OTP. So the first one, and the one that I write fanfic for is
Tentoo x Rose
Now, when I first watched Journeyâs end, I mindlessly hated the ending: give Rose a human version of the Doctor and leave her? How dismissive is that?!? But then it got me thinking, and, in the end, this is the one scenario where Rose and the Doctor have a chance of a relationship in more equal terms, and the unseen dynamics of Rose and the Doctor in Peteâs world has the potential to be really beautiful.Â
Because now Rose isnât some wide-eyed ingenue, but a dimension-traveller in her own right, who had Torchwood training and probably acquired some engineering knowledge on the way. And the Doctor, apart from the matching lifespan and biology, is in a completely new universe - so his centuries of knowledge might only apply partially to Peteâs universe.Â
So now thereâs no âlast-of-the-time-lordsâ or âyouâll-leave-me-in-the-endâ or even âcentury-long-age-gapâ: they still get what made them fall for each other, but with loads of baggage and angst to make it all interesting. (And then thereâs the bonus that thereâs no way Moffat or any future showrunner can ruin them, so itâs a pretty safe zone for fanfic writers)
That doesnât mean that I donât appreciate the sweet dynamics of Nine x Rose or the tragic longing of Ten x Rose, but when it comes to Ten (and the other Doctors as well, letâs face it) thereâs someone else I ship them with...
Doctor x Master
Yes, I went there.Â
No, itâs not a lovely, potentially healthy relationship like Tentoo x Rose, but itâs a beautiful train wreck and I canât look away.
Imagine that: theyâre childhood friends (and sweethearts!), go through school together, survive stifling Time Lord society, make plans to travel the Universe together, and then something goes so terribly wrong that they end up chasing each other across Time and Space as bitter enemies...
Except when theyâre not.
Which happens quite often, all things considered. In the end, I think they might even want the same thing, but with a crucial difference:Â
So itâs tragic and quite possibly toxic, and itâs such a shame that it has only been made canon when the Master regenerated as a woman...
But regardless of gender, era or body, these two are a beautiful mess and I canât get enough of them.Â