You can’t shop your way out of a monopoly
I'm on tour with my new, nationally bestselling novel The Bezzle! Catch me in TUCSON (Mar 9-10), then SAN FRANCISCO (Mar 13), Anaheim, and more!
If you're running a business, you can either invest at being good at your business, or good at Google SEO. Choose the former and your customers will love you – but they won't be able to find you, thanks to the people who choose the latter. And if you're going to invest in top-notch SEO, why bother investing in quality at all?
For more than a decade, Google has promised that it would do something about "lead gens" – services that spoof Google into thinking that they are local businesses, pushing down legit firms on both regular search and Google Maps (these downranked businesses invested in quality, not SEO, remember). Search for a roofer, a plumber, an electrician, or a locksmith (especially a locksmith), and most or all of the results will be lead-gens. They'll take your call, pretend to be a local business, and then call up some half-qualified bozo to come out and charge you four times the going rate for substandard work:
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/31/business/fake-online-locksmiths-may-be-out-to-pick-your-pocket-too.html
Some of them just take your money and they "go back to the shop for a tool" and never return:
https://www.riverfronttimes.com/news/when-a-fake-business-used-a-real-st-louis-address-things-got-weird-32087998
Google has been promising to fix this since the late aughts, and to be fair, it's a little better. There was once a time when a map of Manhattan showed more locksmiths than taxis:
https://blumenthals.com/blog/2009/02/18/google-maps-proves-more-locksmiths-in-nyc-than-cabs/
But GMaps is trapped in the enshittification squeeze. On the one hand, the company wants to provide a good and reliable map. On the other hand, the company makes money selling "ads" that are actually payola, where a business can pay to get to the top of the listings or get displayed on the map itself. Zoom out of Google's map of central London and the highlighted landmarks are a hilarious mix of "organic" and paid listings: the British Museum, Buckingham Palace, the Barbican, the London Eye…and a random oral and maxillofacial clinic in the financial district:
https://twitter.com/dylanbeattie/status/1764711667663831455
Hell of a job "organizing the world's information and making it universally accessible and useful," Big G. Doubtless the average Londoner finds the presence of this clinic super helpful in orienting themselves relative to the map on their phone screens, and it's a real service to tourists hoping to hit all the major landmarks.
It's not just Maps users who'd noticed the rampant enshittification. Even the original design team is so horrified they're moved to speak out about the moral injury they experience seeing the product they worked so hard on turned into a giant pile of shit:
https://twitter.com/elizlaraki/status/1727351922254852182
Now, when it comes to locksmiths, I'm lucky. My neighborhood in Burbank includes the wonderful Golden State Lock and Safe, which has been in business since 1942:
https://www.goldenstatelock.com/
But you wouldn't know it from searching GMaps for a locksmith near me. That search turns up a long list of scams:
https://www.google.com/maps/search/locksmith/@34.1750451,-118.369948,14z/data=!3m1!4b1?entry=ttu
It also turns up plenty of Keyme machines – these are private-equity backed, self-serve key-cutting machines placed in grocery stores. Despite Keyme calling itself a "locksmith," it's just a badly secured, overcaptilized, enshittification-bound system for collecting and retaining shapefiles for the keys to millions of homes, cross-referenced with billing information that will make it easy for the eventual hackers to mass-produce keys for all those poor suckers' houses.
(Hilariously, Keyme claims to be an "AI" company):
https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200114005194/en/KeyMe-Raises-35-Million-to-Further-Its-Mission-of-Building-the-Premier-Locksmith-Services-Company-in-the-Nation
But despite the fact that you can literally see the Golden State storefront from Google Streetview, Google Maps claims to have no knowledge of it. Instead, Streetview labels Golden State "Keyme" – and displays a preview showing a locksmith using a tool to break into a jeep (I'd dearly love to know how the gadget next to the Slurpee machine at the 7-Eleven will drive itself to your jeep and unlock the door for you when you lose your keys):
https://www.google.com/maps/place/KeyMe+Locksmiths/@34.1752624,-118.3487531,3a,75y,350.19h,90.21t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1ssHrtqjqvgFir3NBauMy13Q!2e0!7i16384!8i8192!4m15!1m8!3m7!1s0x80c2959cd65dbb1b:0x4b3744cf87492a71!2sBurbank+Blvd+%26+N+Hollywood+Way,+Burbank,+CA+91505!3b1!8m2!3d34.1750025!4d-118.3493484!16s%2Fg%2F11f37_3lq8!3m5!1s0x80c2951cedbf4d39:0xe8ff9fd5872e66e9!8m2!3d34.1755176!4d-118.349!16s%2Fg%2F11mw7nr4fx?entry=ttu
It's pretty clear to me what's going on here. Keyme has hired some SEO creeps and/or paid off Google, flooding the zone with listings for its machines. Meanwhile, Golden State, being merely good at locksmithing, has lost the SEO wars. Perhaps Golden State could shift some of its emphasis from being good at locksmithing in order to get better at SEO, but this is a race that will always be won by the firm that puts the most into SEO, which will always be the firm that puts the least into quality.
Whenever I write about this stuff, people inevitably ask me which search engine they should use, if not Google?
And there's the rub.
Google used predatory pricing and anticompetitive mergers to acquire a 90% search market-share. The company spends more than $26b/year buying default position in every place where you might possibly encounter a new search engine. This created the "kill zone" – the VC's term of art for businesses that no one will invest in, because Google makes sure that no one will ever find out it exists:
https://www.theverge.com/23802382/search-engine-google-neeva-android
That's why the only serious competitor to Google is Bing, another Big Tech company (Bing is also the primary source of results on Duckduckgo, which is why DDG sometimes makes exceptions for Microsoft's privacy-invading tracking):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DuckDuckGo#Controversies
Google tells us that the quid-pro-quo of search monopolization is search excellence. The hundreds of billions it makes every year through monopoly control gives it the resources it needs to fight spammers and maintain search result quality. Anyone who's paid attention recently knows that this is bullshit: Google search quality is in free-fall, across all its products:
https://downloads.webis.de/publications/papers/bevendorff_2024a.pdf
But Google doesn't seem to think it has a problem. Rather than devoting all its available resources to fighting botshit, spam and scams, the company set $80 billion dollars alight last year with a stock buyback that was swiftly followed with 12,000 layoffs, followed by multiple subsequent rounds of layoffs:
https://pluralistic.net/2024/02/21/im-feeling-unlucky/#not-up-to-the-task
The scams that slip through Google's cracks are sometimes nefarious, but just as often they're decidedly amateurish, the kind of thing that Google could fix by throwing money at the problem, say, to validate that new ads for confirmed Google merchants come from the merchant's registered email addresses and go to the merchant's registered website:
https://pluralistic.net/2023/02/24/passive-income/#swiss-cheese-security
Search is a capital intensive business, and there are real returns to scale, as the UK Competition and Market Authority's excellent 2020 study describes:
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5fe4957c8fa8f56aeff87c12/Appendix_I_-_search_quality_v.3_WEB_.pdf
But Google doesn't seem to think that its search needs that $80 billion to fight the spamwars. That's the thing about monopolists, they get complacent. As Lily Tomlin's "Ernestine the AT&T operator" used to say, "We don't care, we don't have to, we're the phone company."
That's why I'm so excited about the DOJ Antitrust Division monopolization case against Google. Trusting one company to "organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful," was a failure:
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-google-monopolizing-digital-advertising-technologies
I understand why people want to know which search engine they should use instead of Google, and I get why, "There aren't any good search engines" is such an unsatisfactory answer. I understand why each fresh round of printer-company fuckery prompts people to ask "which printer should I get?" and I understand why "There are only six major printer companies and they're all suffering from end-stage enshittification" isn't what anyone wants to hear.
We want to be able to vote with our wallets, because it's so much faster and more convenient than voting with our ballots. But the vote-with-your-wallet election is rigged for the people with the thickest wallets. Try as hard as you'd like, you just can't shop your way out of a monopoly – that's like trying to recycle your way out of the climate emergency. Systemic problems need systemic solutions – not individual ones.
That's why the new antitrust matters so much. The answer to monopolies is to break up companies, block and unwind mergers, ban deceptive and unfair conduct. "Caveat emptor" is the scammer's motto. You shouldn't have to be an expert on lead gen scams to hire a locksmith without getting ripped off.
There are good products and services out there. Earlier this year, we decided to install a (non-networked) programmable pushbutton lock. I asked Deviant Ollam – whom I know from Defcon's Lockpicking Village – for a recommendation and he suggested the Schlage FE595:
https://www.schlage.com/en/home/products/FE595PLYFFFFLA.html
I liked it so much I bought another one for my office door. Eric from Golden State Lock and Safe installed it while I wrote this blog-post. It's great. I recommend both of 'em – 10/10, would do business again.
Name your price for 18 of my DRM-free ebooks and support the Electronic Frontier Foundation with the Humble Cory Doctorow Bundle.
If you'd like an essay-formatted version of this post to read or share, here's a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free, tracker-free blog:
https://pluralistic.net/2024/03/05/the-map-is-not-the-territory/#vapor-locksmith
Image:
alicia rae (modified)
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Kehole_Red.jpg
CC BY 2.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/deed.en
--
Budhiargomiko (modified)
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Wasteland.jpg
CC BY-SA 4.0
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en
243 notes
·
View notes
Electrical and Roofing Contractor Data Scraping
If you’re looking for an electrical and roofing contractor online, it’s about to be much simpler. That’s because many of these contractors usually have information on their websites about the services they provide. It’s important to find a Contractor Data Scraping Service or software that can help you get everything you’re looking for in one place.
Electrical and Roofing Contractor Data Scraping Services
This offer is perfect for any contractors looking to collect data from local businesses. We will provide you with the most up-to-date information about your industry and save you time in the process. Updates come out weekly, and we make it easy to order custom reports. Moreover, this offer provides an automated system that scrapes data from Home Advisor's directory, so it's easier than ever to get accurate information.
Contractor Data Scraping
The DataScrapingServices team employs a variety of techniques in data scraping, including web scraping, third-party services, and APIs. Our top priority is customer success, and with this in mind, you’ll find affordable rates for every budget. You can also rely on us for support when it comes to gathering key contact information about those in your network or for individual use. We know that accuracy is important when recording key contacts, so we utilize our data-scraping expertise to collect this information quickly.
List of Data Fields
DataScrapingServices is an expert in scraping data from various websites using contractor data scraping services.
Contractor Name
Contact Name
Street Address
City
State
Zip
Phone
Fax
Email
Website
Business Category
Review
Business Ratings
Popular Contractor Directories List
We extract contractor data from the following list of directories:
Angi.com
Buildzoom.com
Contractorleadshq.com
Everycontractor.com
Easyleadz.com
Fountain.com
Homeadvisor.com
Homestars.com
Houzz.com
Manta.com
Merchantcircle.com
Superpages.com
Thumbtack.com
Yelp.com
Popular Contractor Service Category
Architect
Contractors
Dentists
Doctors
Electricians
General Contractors
Home Builder
HVAC Repair
Physicians
Plumbers
Real Estate Agent
Repair Solar Panels
Roof Cleaning
Roofing Contractors
Wedding Vendors
Why choose us?
With our Contractor Data Scraping Services, you’ll be able to obtain the latest Contractor data from any website or directory, regardless of whether it’s on a mobile or desktop device.
Using our Contractor data scraping services, you can collect information on potential contractors.
With our Contractor data scraping services, you can collect home contractor, local contractor, and roofing contractor data for your real estate market conditions.
Best Contractor Data Scraping Services in USA: New York, Los Angeles, California, Chicago, Illinois, Houston, Texas, Phoenix, Arizona, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, San Diego, Dallas, San Jose, Austin, Jacksonville, Ohio, Indianapolis, Indiana, Charlotte, North Carolina, San Francisco, Seattle, Washington, Denver, Colorado, DC, Oklahoma, El Paso, Boston, Massachusetts, Detroit, Michigan, Memphis, Louisville-Jefferson County, Kentucky, Baltimore, Maryland, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, Albuquerque, Tucson, Fresno, Sacramento, Kansas City, Missouri, Mesa, Atlanta, Georgia, Omaha, Nebraska, Colorado Springs, Colored, Raleigh, Long Beach, Virginia Beach, Miami, Oakland, Minneapolis, Tulsa, Bakersfield, Wichita, Arlington, Texas, Nashville-Davidson, Tennessee, Oklahoma City, Fort Worth, Columbus, Portland, Oregon, Las Vegas, Nevada.
If you are looking for Contractor Data Scraping Services and Electrical and Roofing Contractor Data Scraping then email us at
[email protected].
Website: datascrapingservices.com.
Skype: nprojectshub
1 note
·
View note
Tucson Plumber
Today’s author with https://tucsonazplumber.com/ will introduce your premiere plumbing service for any outdoor plumbing, indoor plumbing and emergency plumbing needs Introducing for any Local, Plumbing Service in Tucson.
A.S.G. Plumbing Enterprises Inc. L.L.C., https://tucsonazplumber.com/plumbing-services/ a Tucson local plumber offer affordable plumbing repair and service for all of Tucson AZ and surrounding communities. Anthony your local plumber has over 25 years plus plumbing experience.
We guarantee to deliver excellence with every plumbing job.
ASG plumbing is located on the Eastside of Tucson. We service East Tucson, Northeast Tucson, South Tucson and the Southeast Tucson areas Including the following Tucson zip codes 85710, 85715, 85718, 85730, 85747, 85748, 85749, 85750, 85712 and more...
We are A family business and keep customers happy with a (5) year warranty on all plumbing repair and services to include however, not limited to the following:
Irrigation, Water Filtration, Emergency Plumbing, Garbage Disposals, Kitchen Faucets, Bathroom Faucets, Sinks, Tubs, Showers, Toilets, Irrigation Systems, Vacuum Breakers, Timers, Valves, Leaky Shower, Leaky Faucets, Toilet Replacement, Outdoor Plumbing, Hose Bibs, PRV Valves, Pipes Wrapped & Insulated, Water Filters, Misting Systems, Drip Systems, Sprinkler Systems, Water Softeners, Water Conditioners, Water Drinking Filters, Whole House Water Filters, Aquasana Installation, A.S.G. Quatro Plus Water Filtration Systems and Much More...
Call Anthony For Your Free Tucson Plumbing Estimate with ASG Plumbing.
All Work Comes With A Warranty, Receipt, And Is Performed By The Owner.
All Plumbing Work Is Guaranteed In Writing To Your Liking And Satisfaction.
All Plumbing Repair And Service Comes With 3-5 Year Warranties.
Remember: Estimates are always 100% Free.
http://www.TucsonAzPlumber.Com
(520)-351-2787
ASG Plumbing
- Anthony
0 notes