#WHATS HAPPENING I M JUST SO mINDBLOWN THE WHOLE TIME

[jiyaneru]

it was cool nothing fire nothing broke

[zonerz]

Discussing Pink Diamond Theories

So yall already know abt what direction I think Pink Diamond’s personality would be more likely to go, if we’ve learned ANYTHING abt how 3-dimensional the characters in this show are LMAO

So, with that in mind, lets talk theories, and continue with where I left off; Pink’s dilemma with Earth. 

Im sure she’d be sentimental about her first planet that she learned so much about, so it’s possible she might do what she could to save it, and taken her seemingly impulsive nature and obvious tendency to really FIGHT for what she wants, not afraid to stand up and argue with those higher than her, I feel her doing something drastic to get what she wants isn’t too far of a stretch, especially if she was truly attached to the planet. There’s also the fact that she was the creator of Rose Quartz soldiers, so our Rose could have possibly influenced her if she had been close enough or had gotten the opportunity. We can infer that Pink didn’t hold the same traditions that the other diamonds do, and it’s possible she spent a lot more time with her soldiers personally than the others, especially because of the fact that a lot of them were defective like herself. Hell, she might have even used that to her advantage to help motivate them, giving a whole “I was kicked down for being different but look at how I ended up! I’m here! I was able to climb and you can all do good too.” speech.

Also, with this intimacy with her court and army, she could’ve easily have been more aware of the seeds of rebellion that were growing. Again, this can split off into two branches, either she hates it and tries to shut it down (or merely never knew and thus was truly murdered by Rose/whoever framed Rose) or, and frankly more interestingly but also less likely, she could have seen a possible rebellion as an opportunity.

If anything were to get the other Diamonds off of Earth’s back, it would be a rebellion, a STRONG one too. 

So, and this is where we get into wild speculation here folks, but what if she had colluded with Rose??? Rose obviously loved Earth and if Pink Diamond had shown EQUAL support of the planet, then just imagine the possibilities of what these two could have planned. Pink’s supposed shattering of course is another story. Betrayal perhaps? Or a planned and unfortunate sacrifice for something Pink and Rose loved? Hell, maybe even it was staged. IK there’s a theory going around that Pink could possibly be bubbled (or have even escaped and gone into hiding) and while it’s probably not true, its fascinating to think of the possibilities of what could happen if she were still alive.

I mean, imagine it. The defective and oh so fragile Pink diamond seemingly being resurrected and then openly fighting on the side of the Crystal Gems, just for one planet. Imagine showing her true face and self for every other gem to see. Hell, imagine Jasper and so many gems like her’s reactions to finally seeing the legendary Pink Diamond and realizing that she’s defective. Imagine the kind of spark the idea of a defective diamond could spark in the rebellion. For characters like Amethyst who have always seen themselves as lesser for being short and coming out “wrong”! It’d be absolutely mind-boggling and would make even the most devoted homeworld gems question their oh-so perfect leaders!

Like I said, mad speculation that’s probably not gonna happen, but LET ME D R E A M–

EDIT: WE FORGOT ABT THE MURAL WHICH COULD MOST DEFINITELY SHOW US SOME MORE INFO!!

So the gem that Rose is fighting obviously doesnt look like Pink, that’s clear to say the least, especially with the diamond being on the chest rather than the lower stomach. Now, while this could be an idolization, it still doesnt add up. The coloration suggests that this gem Rose is fighting is instead White Diamond. But them again, the gem placement comes into question, but let me offer a solution!

Perhaps the diamond insignia on the chest is simply apart of a universal outfits the diamonds wear, after all we’ve seen all of the lower rank gems wearing outfits with that similar diamond on their chest. Ik I personally assumed it was just a yellow diamond thing but we’ve seen that everyone wears them because of the Amethysts in the Zoo and then Blue Agate herself, so why is it so far fetched that the diamonds themselves used to wear the same outfits and only Yellow from what we’ve seen, seeing as she’s the most militaristic, kept up the tradition? Pearl’s spacesuit even has Pink Diamond’s diamond on the chest!

So, this diamond is most likely White. So, what’s happening in the rest of the pic? Well, first off, it looks an awful lot like Rose is holding Pink Diamond.

So okay, let’s assume she IS. There’s two possibilities of what’s going on then. 

1) PD was only Poofed by Rose when stepping out of her palanquin and then was held as a sort of hostage by the rebellion as a hope to gain and advantage. PD’s freedom for The diamonds to leave Earth alone (although it’s unlikely they’d follow through) THEN furthermore, with the way White is standing, it’s possible that she’s literally denying it saying “No, you all have caused enough trouble for us, this ends now.” Which could’ve ended with Pink shattering in the midst of battle and then White blaming it on Rose

Or, and personally what I think if more likely

2) Pink was protecting Rose and the others. If we look at the way the mural is placed and how each character is standing, it looks more like Rose has her hands out in a “No, don’t!” type position as White seems to be launching an attack. And then of course, we see PD’s gem seemingly blocking and taking the blow of White’s shot if the lines going into the gem itself are anything to go off of. This exact moment could be what shattered Pink. As I looked at earlier, it’s extremely likely that a character like Pink got attached and wanted to protect her planet and her court. That dedication, appreciative and downright love could have been what saved them and Rose but also cost Pink her life.

And as Zircon said, it’s only possible for a Diamond to be shattered by another diamond! And of course White may not have intended to hit Pink, but if she did, she would most definitely try to cover it up. And who else is a known fugitive and rebel as well as being perfectly matched in the frame with WD?

Rose Quartz.

*Mindblown*