hi! i was wondering how you felt about that "one" scene in winx club that was banned? did the scene go differently in the original italian version?
as a black girl who loves winx, it was sad for me to see </3 im just curious how the reception in other places was
Hi there! First of all, I have the banned episode from this ancient Mondo DVD, since it's been taken down from youtube and other streaming services, even in italian. I will sub this ep regardless of the infamous scene, since I don't think there's anything controversial outside of that
In short, TLDR, in my humble opinion, the scene is racially insensitive and overly meanspirited from the heroines we should root for. The average italian kid didn't think much of it when it aired and re-ran, Italian adults lack the cultural context of black hair outside the country so most didn't understand the complaints and non-white italians did not seem to make any noise about this online. If anybody can prove me wrong is welcome to provide sources that I missed.
More under the cut!
There was some disco resurgence in the early 2000s around, in Italy and Japan, so that's what inspired the scene, likely.
A frog! With an afro!
Bucatini dance!
Is there a history of discrimination over textured and curly hair in Italy? As far as I know, no. You see white people with dreads and braids all the time and for historical reasons, curly and textured hair is common in people's genes. From what I've seen from italian forums and social media, I have read no complaints from black italians about the scene, so it definitely didn't move the italian black community or anything to stir any controversy.
Alright. With that out of the way... As a kid, I didn't think too much of the scene. I didn't think "wow, that hair is bad/ugly/something mean", or anything of the sort, and this seems to be the general sentiment from other italian watchers. I didn't think anything of the poor black girl being mocked. Being from a filler episode, the scene is rather forgettable to the average euro person.
I thought the hair wasn't even normal afro hair. And so did many others, according to italian social media posts...
I thought it had become JELLO! The hair is shiny and makes a strange noise when Bloom touches it. I'm still sure it's jello.
Bloom touching the hair unprovoked is also kind of nasty.
Some don't believe it's jello at all and I can't fault them for it, since the poor girl doesn't say any details. Just that her straight hair turned into "this thing".
The language used in this scene is meanspirited.
"What did she put on her head?" is a bit too much from Stella. You see a girl crying and you mock her?
The Winx don't even do anything for her, just standing back and watching. The Trix mocking her is one thing, but the Winx could have tried to help, only for them to give up as the girl has a breakdown, I dunno, better than nothing or Bloom's terrible attempt. The whole scene isn't easy to save and I don't think anybody should bother, not even the 4Kids edit improves it much. Just cut it out.
The joke was likely at afro hair looking funny itself, rather than make the black girl seem undesiderable for having an afro, as I've read from some interpretations. All italians I've read and asked agree that they didn't think maliciously of the scene as kids nor now. At least there's that.
A surprising amount of people thought the scene wasn't racist at all though, and couldn't understand why would this be offensive, while those who agreed it was bad still argued that banning the episode was too much.
The italian side has been very focused on the whitewashing discourse, though. Not since Magical Adventure as some have noted, but ever since the fairy couture dropped.
These are from 2022! What have they done to Aisha!
Anyway, thanks for reading all the way there. I'd like to hear more opinions, provided they're brought in a civil manner. Because I've seen a lot of nastyness on this argument and I'd rather not deal with trolls.
These poor girls!
18 notes
·
View notes
Luca Laurenti e Paolo Bonolis ~ Bucatini Disco Dance Daje! " Er barcarolo va Contro corente E quanno canta L'eco sa risente Tanto pe' canta' Tanto pe' sogna' Tanto pe' canta' Tanto pe' sogna' Roma nun fa' La stupida stasera Damme 'na mano A faje di' de sì Tanto pe' canta' Tanto pe' sogna' S'annamo a diverti' Na ni na ni na ni E noi je dimo (yeah) E noi je famo (yeah) C'hai messo l'acqua (yeah) Nun te pagamo (yeah) Tanto pe' canta' Tanto pe' sogna' Tanto pe' canta' Tanto pe' sogna' "
57 notes
·
View notes