#casey's parents putting up missing posters and still not knowing what happened to their son

[phddyke]

damn casey hartley really like...haunts the narrative huh

[whitefanggurl]

“Why?” 2012 Donatello x Reader; Raphael x Reader

Warnings: Hurt, Angst, Cheating, Sadness

And you end up with Raphael in the end, but start out dating Donnie. Also, if you like April, this is not the fanfic for you.

(Please don't kill me!!!)

Glancing down at the screen, you frowned.

It was your birthday today and Don still hadn't called like he said he would.

The day hadn’t started off so well, what with the rain ruining the outdoor party decorations your family had set up for you. Luckily, they saved the cake and presents in time.

Then, your aunt and uncle hadn’t been able to come because of the storm that had increasingly gotten worse.

And lastly, your (brother/sister) had gotten the stomach bug at school and puked on the brand new carpet.

You snatched your hoodie and headed out the window down the fire escape to head to the lair.

The rain was relentless in its mission to absolutely drench you with all of heaven’s tears.

(foreshadooooooooooooooow. Alright, back to the depressing fanfic from hell’s fiery depths)

You stopped and looked up at the sky, “DO YOU HATE ME?” You screamed and shook your fist towards the clouds.

They responded with a streak of lightning and thunderclap lighting up the sky.

“Wonderful,” You muttered and lifted up a sewer cap.

Heading down, you took off your hood and shook out your hair.

‘Maybe he forgot...’

The turtles could be heard before you even saw them. Mikey and Raph were yelling (well, really just Raph) and Leo was fanboying over Space Heroes.

“Hey guys,” You squeezed the water out of your hair and grinned at the three mutant teens.

Their eyes all widened, “(Y/N), aren't you supposed to be celebrating your birthday today?” Leo asked, puzzled.

You shrugged, “Well, it hasn't been the best of days, and I was just wondering why Don hasn't called like he promised.”

The boys frowned, “He hasn't called yet?” Raph questioned suspiciously.

You shook your head and made your way towards the lab, Raph following to make sure what was happening wasn't what he was thinking.

But it was.

Donnie was sitting at his desk, kissing April.

Tears filled your eyes and you subconsciously gripped onto Raphael’s arm as his stance became rigid.

“Don,” he growled and hid you behind the door.

Donnie and April leapt away from each other and attempted to straighten their appearances, “H-Hey Raph!” He squeaked nervously, suddenly finding his posters more interesting.

“Please tell me that you, of all people, aren't cheating on sweet (Y/N),” he slowly stalked forward, his gaze darkening with every step.

You felt tears roll down your cheeks while you stood out of sight.

“W-What? Of course not! April and I were just... c-conducting an experiment is all!” Donatello gave a fake laugh.

“Oh, an experiment. With your lips evidently,” Raph raised his hand and pointed at April, “And you,” he growled, “I cannot believe you! I knew that you were bad news but seriously? Helping him cheat on his girlfriend all because you like boy attention? You aren't coming back here ever!!”

April’s face reddened and she opened her mouth but was cut off.

“It’s my birthday.”

Everyone snapped their heads towards you.

You stepped out of the hall and into the lab, “And... I was waiting for your call, Don. I thought you would make this day all better,” You closed your eyes and bit your lip, taking a deep breath, “But now, I can finally see through those lies you always told. All those excuses for the missed dates, unreturned phone calls, weird times when you would try to prove your ‘love’,” Anger sparked behind your eyes and deep in the pit of your stomach, “And here I find you, lies finally gone. You’re what my parents warned me about, the unfaithful playboy,” The spark grew louder and brighter as you turned to April, “And you...” You growled, “The girl I thought was my ‘best friend’. Did that even mean anything to you? My friendship is not a rag that can be thrown away you idiot. It’s a trophy you have to work and push yourself to earn. I trusted you!!” Your voice grew in pitch, becoming a scream of rage.

You grabbed a smoke bomb from your pocket and threw it onto the ground, running from the room.

Raph’s eyes narrowed and he punched his fist, “Now to take care of you, Don.”

You ran out of the lair, despite Leo and Mikey’s shouted inquiries of what was wrong.

Not even caring where you were heading, you ran, feet pounding along the concrete.

But your subconscious guided you from the sewers and towards Karai and Shinigami’s hideout. (well, not really hiding. The place used to be Shredder’s, so it’s kinda conspicuous)

Finally, you stopped, breath ragged and lungs heaving, and glanced around the street to see where the besties were staying.

You dragged yourself to the door guarded by Foot soldiers. They saw you and let you through, remembering who you were.

Making your way to the main room where the girls probably were hanging out, you felt the tears burn behind your eyes.

The girls looked up when you entered and their eyes widened.

“(Y/N)!!” Shini cried and rushed over to you, taking your muddy hoodie and clothes in with concern.

Karai hissed, “Who do I have to kill? Just say the name.”

The tears made their way down your face as the emotional dam broke, “D-Donnie cheated on m-me....” You whimpered.

Karai nodded and started sharpening her knives, “Well, his funeral is going to be slightly.... early.” She grabbed them all and put them each in her pockets, heading out to end the turtle mutant’s life.

Shini led you to the guest bedroom and grabbed some sweats and chocolate for you, “I swear,” she growled, “That boy will surely die. If not by Karai’s hand, then by mine.”

Don had so far been beat up by Raph, Leo, and Karai, while Mikey somehow duct taped him to the wall and threw water balloons at him.

Everyone hated him. Even Sensei was even more upset than normal.

Master Splinter circled around him in the dojo, “So, Donatello... Do you know why you are here?”

“Because,” he whimpered, “I cheated on (Y/N) with April.”

He nodded and started to also circle around April, “And April. Why are you here?”

(I’m not the biggest fan of April AT ALL, but I can see her doing this actually. She plays hard-to-get with Don and Casey and it angers me to no end because I hate when anyone does that. Playing with people’s feelings isn't okay, guys. It’s possibly one of the worst things you can do because it will scar them mentally and emotionally.)

She stopped her lip from quivering, giving up the ‘innocent’ act, “Because I knew that Donatello and (Y/N) were dating, but I started to date Don anyway.”

Splinter again nodded and he glared at the two teens, “April, you are never allowed here again. Not until you change. I will no longer instruct you in the ways of the kunoich. You are dismissed.”

Her jaw dropped, but Splinter’s glare silenced her. She stood and bowed, “Hai Sensei.” And she left.

“Now, as for you, Donatello. No more experiments. The lab is off limits for you. No more patrols, missions, or going onto the surface unless you are desperately needed. Am I clear?”

Donnie’s face paled but he nodded, “Hai Sensei.”

“I am disappointed in you. I know that I did not raise you this way, Donatello. You have not only disrespected (Y/N), but your family name. You have hurt her in a way that will take much time to heal. She will possibly never forgive you, and for what you have done, I do not blame her. I am ashamed of your actions, my son. And I hope you are as well.”

(”You may look like a bride, but you will never bring your family HONOR!!!” Alright, never mind me, just quoting Mulan over here....

But, just one more.....

“DISHONOR ON YOU! DISHONOR ON YOUR FAMILY! DISHONOR ON YOUR COW!!!!” Ok, I’m done.)

“You are dismissed, Donatello.”

Don stood and bowed, then left the dojo.

Raphael stood in the doorway and glared at his back as he left.

You wiped the tears from your eyes as Shinigami and Karai made popcorn and put on (Fav movie).

Taking another bite from your chocolate bar, you froze when you saw a turtle silhouette in the window.

But his form was shorter and more muscular than Donatello’s, and there was no bo staff strapped to his back.

You slumped back against the couch with a relieved sigh, “Hey Raph.”

He opened the window and hopped down onto the floor, “Hey Tiger, how you holding up?” He plopped down next to you.

You gave a flat chuckle and motioned to the chocolate wrappers, “Not as bad as I could be, I guess.”

He hesitated, but then opened his arms.

You pretty much flew into his arms.

Raph buried his face in your hair and rubbed your back.

“I’m so sorry you had to go through all this crud, (Y/N),” He murmured softly.

“It’s not your fault, Raph,” You pulled away slightly and pecked his cheek, “But thank you for being here.”

(Le time skip) One year later.....

Surprisingly, you had forgiven Don after a while. He kept his distance though, and April and you never spoke again. Evidently, she didn’t want to ever come back to the lair if you were there, so... Yeah. No one heard from her or Casey again.

Which was good because you were scared Karai would have a murder on her record from how she was talking about disposing of that redhead.

By now, you were a full kunoich. The turtles had already held the ceremony earlier in the year.

You smiled softly at the black titanium tanto you held in your hands, remembering the night the ceremony was held.

Raph came up behind you and tapped your shoulder, “Hey (Y/N)? You ok?”

You jumped slightly but grinned at him, “Yeah, just remembering when I got this thing.”

He smiled, “You deserve it, especially after how hard you've trained for it,” he suddenly became nervous, “Um, there was, uh, something I wanted to ask you....”

You raised an eyebrow and motioned for him to continue.

“Ah, well, I was wondering if you would like to, ahem, go out sometime?” He voice got quieter, “M-Maybe as a boyfriend and girlfriend thing or something?...”

You don’t know what came over you in that moment, but you launched yourself at Raph and wrapped your arms around him while laughing and squeaking out a weird “YES!!!” over and over again.

He had a stupid grin on his face and pumped his fist in the air.

___________________ Hey guys!!!!!!! I hope you liked this oneshot!!!!

And, um, if you wanted to be with Don, *sweats nervously* I’m sorry that it probably wasn't what you wanted.

if you guys ever want a part 2, just ask!!

My next one is with you and Don though, so I hope it makes up for this!!!

Alright, well, signing off.

LOVE YOU GUYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!