I know you dont watch GoT anymore. And that Braime and Sansa are your favorites. But I know you've read the books and are obviously really interested in the story. And I was just wondering what your thoughts are on the whole Jon killing Dany thing? Is that something you can see happening in the books? And if it is do you think it'd be in the same context as the show did it?
Ahaha, welp. Just jumping right in there.
(Also, you never have to apologise for asking GOT/ASOIAF questions. I obviously have been a fan for 16 years and wrote fuckinâ TNR with its half-million-plus words, so I clearly do have Thoughts on the story/characters, especially with the bag of lukewarm cat vomit that was s8 of the show.)
I already answered this ask discussing how much I hated the Mad Queen Dany thing, both because a) it was horrifically badly handled and b) these mediocre misogynist douchegobblers have managed to outdo themselves in terms of the gross messages theyâve sent about women, after 8 seasons of that. (These are the same people who made Sansa say that she was grateful for her rapes and who claimed that Danyâs turn into madness was foreshadowed by her having a âchillyâ reaction to the death of her abuser, Viserys, in s1, soâŠ. make of that what you will.) Iâm not saying that it was narratively impossible, especially since GRRM has been toying with the same thing in the books and has more than his own share of Male Author Syndrome. But at the start of 8x04, Dany is in Winterfell, perfectly sane, toasting Arya as hero of the battle. By the end of 8x06, sheâs crazy, a war criminal, and dead, murdered by her boyfriend, because⊠well, something something plot reasons. Even if you didnât like Dany or were rooting for her to go mad or whatever, that was wildly badly handled.
I personally think it would be pretty gross for GRRM to also go down the Mad Queen route, though at least if he does, we will have had Danyâs POV chapters beforehand and presumably something resembling a justification and a building narrative momentum toward it. But she also got stuck in Meereen for so long because by his own admission he didnât know what to do with her there or how to get her out of the situation and moved onto Westeros, which remains, theoretically, her outstanding goal in the books. It would obviously not be outside the realm of possibility for this to happen, given GRRMâs focus on âgrittinessâ that the show took to max factor 5000. I would still find it reductive and trying to make a Clever Postmodern Point and etc if it happened in the books, because literally why invest us in a character this long, especially one who has tried so hard to overcome the circumstances of her past/to not be her father, and then just do exactly that? Obviously there would be elements of Shakespearean tragedy to it, and if done well it could be compelling, but I personally just have a different approach to fiction and what people want out of a story (especially one now as famous as GOT/ASOIAF and how universally betrayed everyone seems to feel by the ending). Iâm not saying Danyâs ultimate ending needs to be sunshine and roses and getting what she wants, because often character arcs and resolutions become all the more powerful for being subverted and thwarted (think the âI said I wanted [x] but [y] was there insteadâ sort of endings). But whatever it is, it needs to beâŠ. not that.
Also, Jon in both books and especially show has been the epitome of Mediocre White Man. I stopped watching in s4, but Kit Haringtonâs acting was so wooden and the writing for him was very much Standard Misunderstood Brooding Fantasy Hero that I could barely pay attention to his scenes. I find him somewhat more interesting in the books, though ADWD dragged for everyone and it was obvious GRRM was writing in circles. But everyone has noticed that especially in the show, Jon does absolutely bupkis. His ass is constantly saved by the women in his life, he makes an absolute hash of any power that he is given and doesnât want it anyway, and his ultimate ending wasâŠ. going back to the Nightâs Watch (as their idea of satisfying narrative storytelling is to literally put everyone back where they were in the very first episode, apparently). Never mind the fact that thereâs no need for the Nightâs Watch, but the point is, even the fact that Jon is Rhaegar and Lyannaâs son ended up being relevant for like half an episode. That has been one of the major plot points/secrets of the books (although not so much anymore) and it justâŠ. fizzled out like a damp squib. Dany actually TRIED for multiple seasons to be a good ruler and to learn how to handle power and become a queen, so for her to have to be the one to die for Jon to once again do diddlysquat is⊠well, as I have said before, the misogyny leaps out. They ended up wasting so much potential and so many other things that were also foreshadowed (and far more convincingly than âwah wah she was gonna go evil!â). For this? So Jon can just go brood in the snow again? Cool.
Not to mention, I find it gross on principle that Danyâs boyfriend had to be the one to kill her, especially after rape/sexual violence/loss of agency was such a big part of her early-season storylines (and how horrifyingly and grossly that has been handled on the show overall). Weâre obviously supposed to sympathize with Jon in this scenario and to feel that it is justified to âstop a tyrantâ or whatever. Also, if the episode was going to be called âQueenslayer,â why the fuck wasnât it Jaime fulfilling the valonqar prophecy, another thing they forgot about, and killing Cersei, at great personal grief/cost, to once more stop an insane monarch from burning down Kingâs Landing? But that, of course, would be actual character development/overall arc, and they preferred to also trash that by having Jaime âkilled Aerys Targaryen literally to save half a million innocent people and lived with his reputation being destroyed ever afterâ Lannister unironically claim that he never cared about the lives of the innocent and only wanted Cersei. After she again tried to kill him and Tyrion like three days ago, not even to mention what they did to Brienne and with that whole arc, but I will have a ragestroke if I think about it too much.Â
Basically, the ending wasnât âbittersweet.â It was tragic, reductionist, ham-handed, hugely disappointing for everyone who put years of investment into these characters, and ended up in the amusing position of making Bran Stark the younger and more beautiful queen who comes to cast Cersei down. He became king because⊠reasons? Whatever? And he knows literally everything about everyone thanks to being the Three-Eyed Raven, so thereâs no way that can go horribly wrong. He has basically done nothing except sit in a wheelchair and look creepy for several years now, his arc has never been remotely about being king, and Isaac Hempstead-Wright himself is apparently on record as saying he genuinely thought it was a joke script when he read it. This after both Emilia Clarke and Kit Harington broke down over learning what happened to their characters/Kit apparently realized it for the first time at the read-through and was horrified. Emilia already talked about wandering for five hours and having a crisis and calling her mom and asking to be talked off the ledge likeâŠ.. fictional choices/characters completely aside, thatâs a gross thing to do to your actors. I know theyâre all proud of their work and they have apparently and understandably been defensive about the existence of the petition to rewrite s8, but theyâve all been pretty clear, while still being professional and supportive, that there is stuff that theyâre just as much WTF about as we are.
Basically, as everyone keeps saying, the acting, cinematography, visual effects, music, etc was clearly up to as high a standard as ever, but was betrayed fundamentally and comprehensively by this god-awfully shit writing by a couple of hacks who clearly rushed the final season to get on to ruining working on Star Wars. They have also been on record about saying âyou canât do what the audience expects or itâll get boring blah blah blah,â which is a profoundly flawed storytelling strategy if youâre paranoid and trying to outsmart your audience and do something that nobody has ever thought of because youâre an Intellectual Postmodern Commentator On Our Violent Society. If your audience can guess where a story is going, but are still surprised by major twists along the way that then make sense in hindsight, youâve done your job. If youâre relying on grimdark and cramming in gimmicky plot twists and deus ex machinas and Shocking Moments rather than authentically developing your story, itâs going to bite you in the ass in a big way, as was just proven.Â
Nobody expected a completely happy ending from GoT. But the fact that they went to such lengths, especially in s8, to build up characters/ships (Jonerys, Braime, Gendrya were all torched after major canon moments completely unexpected by fans, especially the latter two â why even include it unless to just be more Tragique, and Gendrya is the only one that has even a chance in the future since half of it didnât end up idiotically dead) and then just wrecked all of itâŠ. as Iâve said, good endings donât need to be rainbows and unicorns and kittens. But if youâve asked eight years of audience investment, there has to be something that makes it worth it and that doesnât make everyone feel like they were duped and stupid to get involved in the first place. They have been beating the âitâs a hard world and bad things happen to the charactersâ drum for all theyâre worth, but⊠itâs just bad. You can analyse and ask why the hell they did things and so forth, but itâs bad. At this rate, the show should have either ended after 8x03, or they should have taken the money HBO offered and done the proper 10 episodes and let Bryan Cogman write all of them. He was the only one who appeared to remotely give a shit about the characters, and since D&D wrote the last four episodes themselves, yeah, this disaster is on them.
Fortunately, I left the show years ago and have TNR and am used to ignoring their version of things. And I knew all along that they never really got the characters or the story. But I feel really bad for everyone who has had this thrown back in their face, and it seems like a communal disenchantment with this ending is going to enter the pop-culture consciousness on a possibly unprecedented level. So if GRRM does do the Mad Queen Dany killed by Jon in the books (though he has apparently called the showâs ending âtraumaticâ), Iâll probably still not like it. He has a chance to sell me it on/justify it to me narratively, which the show categorically failed to do. I donât think I will, just because as I said, I donât like anything about it, but yes.
Anyway. This is a long post already, and I probably have more to say still, but itâs pretty obvious I think itâs just really, really bad, and thatâs about the essence of it.
53 notes
·
View notes