#sort of. not much of a review
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
You may remember this post I made at the beginning of the year, about āThe Man Who Laughsā being public domain. Well, I looked after my bossā kids a couple of nights ago, and once I finally convinced them to go to bed, I started to watching it for the first time on their large movie projector! [mild spoilers ahead].

Unfortunately I only managed to watch half an hour of it, because the parents came home (and asked what Iād been watching š³ Had to explain my weirdness).
I finished it the next day on my own (considerably smaller) TV.

(The format didnāt work too well on my television, some of the picture was missing on both sides, annoyingly).
It was so good! It put me through a lot of stress, because while Iād read that Gwynplaine had a happy ending, I was still so worried something bad would happen to him, Dea, Urus or Homo.
It felt similar to āThe Hunchback of Notre Dameā and āThe Phantom of the Operaā, but also very different at the same time. Gwynplaine is the only Universal āmonsterā character to have been a leading man, and to have not been killed off at the end.
Look at them š
I couldnāt help but laugh every time this guy showed up. Look at his goofy face š¤£

It was nice not to feel emotionally destroyed after a tragic movie for once (well, I was a little bit scarred - Gwynplaine had so much inner pain š)
#a new favourite for sure#the man who laughs#the man who laughs 1928#conrad veidt#Gwynplaine#Dea#tmwl Dea#mary philbin#Brandon Hurst#Barkilphedro#tmwl barkilphedro#movies Iāve watched#movies#universal monsters#š Iām tagging it this because both Hunchback & Phantom count as Uni monsters & Gwynplaine is along the same lines#1920s#1920s movies#1928#silent movies#my posts#my movie reviews#sort of. not much of a review
10 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
In super exciting news, Iām going to be competing with Lil Hal in the Awesomecon Cosplay Competition!
In even BETTER news, that means I get to make a whole BOOK about how I made his cosplay.

Iāve already got my build book cover ready to go
#graphic design in my passion#I canāt wait to get peer reviewed for my favorite project#then I can get feedback for how to make it COOLER#win win scenario#i swear the contents of the build book are much more professional#sort of#homestuck#lil hal#hal strider#dirk strider#lil hal cosplay
55 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Yeah, sure, sex is great and all, but have y'all ever tried being lounged on by a guard dog who's stronger and meaner than you? Serving as a weighted blanket, casually pinning you down beneath them under the guise of cuddling whilst watching a show/video. Their hands roam wherever they please, just softly exploring your skin with their fingertips and nothing more. Their lips are even more explorative whenever they're not pressed firmly against your own: panting hot breaths into the crook of your neck, leaving bite marks and hickeys all over your throat and shoulders. They growl each time you shift, any attempt to move making them more handsy out of spite. Any whining only makes them chuckle at your helplessness and bite/claw at you harder. You're stuck there, helpless to move, and so deeply content to be dumb and teased and frot against another, bigger dog who loves to watch you squirm beneath them.
#maybe it leads to sex idk#point is I don't want that I sort of just want forced closeness#and A Lot of teasing#so much teasing#ugh don't even touch me let's just grind against each other for hours#Anyway#looking for a review..#for a friend.....#my post#sub posting#ftm puppy#puppy sub#dumb puppy#nsft puppy#ftm t4t#ftm sub#ftm nsft#ftm ns/fw#t4t#t4t nsft#t4t mlm#queer nsft#trans nsft#anyway š« forcibly dog-ifies you#š¤
117 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Macbeth, David Tennant - A very subjective, spoiler and emotion filled review
Just walking out of seing Macbeth at the Donmar and I have Feelings. Unsurprisingly, I primarily went to see it because David Tennant was in it. I love the play, big fan of Shakespeare but the trip to London was most certainly motivated by a very specific actor. Hence the highly subjective review. Fortunately, I also happen to quite like Macbeth. We studied it at school, and it holds a special place in my heart (back then, Hamlet was my favourite Shakespeare play but honestly, after tonight, Iām not so sure anymore. Anyway, I digress). It was my first time actually seeing an actor Iām a fan of in real life, so obviously the entire time my brain was just going oh my god thatās David Tennant oh my god thatās David Tennant like I actually could not comprehend it. The man Iāve spent hours staring at on a little screen is suddenly real, and right there. So yeah, that took me a hot second.

(Excuse the piss poor image quality, I took this with shaky hands without looking or bothering to focus the cam)
The Staging
Still starstruck and a bit dazed, one thing really really stood out to me: the staging. It was so, so good. I knew it was going to be minimal from the pictures I had seen, and it was, but it was also so insanely real. There were barely any decorations, and half the cast and the musicians were hidden behind a glass screen doing background noises and gestures. From where I was sitting I could not see them much, but could definitely hear them which added to the overall atmosphere. The stage was also really tiny, and the play benefitted incredibly from it. All the action was happening in one tight space that had been put to use incredibly well, particularly the banquet scene but Iāll come back to that because it deserves its own paragraph.
The way they chose to do the soliloquies was so fitting - all the actors start to move in slow motion - everyone else slowing down and just the characters speaking moving was so good, it made sense.
The Headphones
Iām a bit mixed about the headphones. They were amazing for the vibes, we could hear whispers and they really heightened some of the emotional speeches in the play - because when someone is struggling with guilt and trauma it makes sense for them to be mumbling rather than yelling. So that was really great. However, especially in the scenes where the actors where yelling/ loud I preferred to take them off a bit cause it felt more real that way. Iām so used to hearing actors voice on recordings, it does hit different when you can hear them for real. But, as I said, personal preference and thatās whatās nice, you can take them on and off as much as you want.
Famous Speeches
There were three speeches I was quite interested to see how they were going to be adapted - scorpions and dagger for Macbeth, and out damned spot for Lady Macbeth. These are classic, everyone knows the words, the plot but they managed to make it feel real in a new and touching way. I think here the headphones were quite helpful because they allowed the actors to actually whisper parts of those lines. They were so subtle, so embedded in the text they felt so natural which imbued them with all their power. I saw in a review Cush Jumboās out damned spot speech be described as āhauntingā, and I wholeheartedly agree.
The Macbeths
I didnāt like Macbeth, the character, very much when I first learnt about him. His actions didnāt make sense to me, I couldnāt quite comprehend in my 21st century little brain how he went from Iām super loyal to the King to I will freely murder children for shits and giggles. But now, now I understand. It makes sense, itās believable. And thatās a mix of the acting choices and teh overall setting. Like the opening scene, instead of presenting Macbeth as a glorious hero, he is presented to us as a traumatised hero. He spends the first few minutes washing the blood of his clothes, haunted by noises from the battlefield. And that sets the themes quite nicely, not ambition, as Tennant specified in an interview, but guilt and trauma. There are so many ways to interpret Shakespeare, thatās the beauty of it, and I think this version of Macbeth just resonated more with me (maybe because ambition I donāt quite understand but guilt I am intimately familiar with? Or maybe because it was David Tennant? I donāt know, probably a bit of both). Tennant delivers a convincing Macbeth. Yes, you can see his ambitions play out, but also his fears, his guilt, and that makes him into a complex three dimensional character that you want to understand.
And I absolutely loved this version of Lady Macbeth. Not just a powerful woman who bullies her husband into become an evil murderer (because again, here we can see traces of that in Macbeth from the start), but an ambition woman in love, with her husband, with power, and not quite healed from the trauma of loosing her child. Again another review said she is more of an enabler than a manipulator and I quite liked that description.
My Favourite Scenes
God the banquet scene. The one with the ghost of Banquo. An absolute masterpiece. I did not expect that scene to hit that hard. It was raw, it was powerful and even if Tennant was facing away from where I was sitting, even without seeing his face I could feel the emotion, the whole audience could. In a video essay on Tennant, @davidtennantgenderenvy highlighted how in almost every role he played, there is it is the classic Tennant breakdown moment, and breakdown moment it was. Not with tears, not as expressive as he sometime is but just enough for a King trying to hold it together but fear and guilt breaking through. I was absolutely overwhelmed and it was beautiful. The set up for the scene was amazing too - there were ceilidh, celebrations, I adored the contrast between these fast pasted scenes and guilt ridden whispers of the couple. And the way everyone sat down around the stage and suddenly it looked like a banquet table ? Just perfect.
Another really cool moment, less on the emotional side but more on the visuals was when Macbeth goes to get the second prophecy from the witches. Almost the whole cast is there, running around, moving, almost dancing and it gives the whole thing a mystical atmosphere. Thereās smoke, Macbeth falls, is carried up high Jesus style, cowers, rises, itās so busy and insane all the while there are whispers and whispers in the headphones - it manages perfectly to feel like a mystical moment.
Descent Into Madness & other cool things
For Macbeth, having the kid running around scene after scene, haunting him, and then scene where he kills him - GOD itās powerful. Lady Macbethās descent into madness was so well characterised, I also loved the glass on the background that locked away some of the cast. Just wild. The actor that played Malcom actor was also really cool, and Macduff and Ross, big fan of all of them.
Overall I am overwhelmed with emotions. Tennant is truly one of my favourite actors - from Good Omens to Staged, Jessica Jones, even Harry Potter but also Mad to be Normal, Nativty, There She Goes, Around the World in 80 days, Doctor Who (god Iāve started a list, never start lists cause youāll forget people) and so, so many more, I was truly beside myself with excitement and expectations for tonight. And it did not disappoint. I do not want to leave the theatre and I pray they release a recording of this because I want it imprinted on my soul.
(Side note: I donāt know how to use tumblr very well, for some reason whenever I try to reply to ppl it posts from my other blog? Anyway @raquel-and-sergio is in fact me)
#david tennant#Macbeth#donmar macbeth#review#sort of#more like therapeutic ranting for me#because i love this Scottish man so much#and i dont want this moment to be over yet#or ever for that matter#good omens#tenth doctor#fourteenth doctor
118 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Merline DLC please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please
#cassette beasts#I am SHAKING with excitement this is so big#the pic looks like Kayleigh and the mc in some sort of warmly lit cave or tunnel system (possible an underground maze of some sorts?)#and the green is VERY reminiscent of a station entrance. TWO station entrances#I don't usually care for the caves very much but I will TAKE a plotline about exploring the deeper depths of the station system#maybe following up on the whole Here Comes the Sun debacle or that weird comment about how 'our worlds need us'#what does that mean Bytten. WHAT DOES THAT MEAN#these are all very off-the-cuff thoughts I need to review my notes (screenshots)
34 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
the thoughts are returning (making a comic adaptation of the actor au alongside the actual writing)
#I. DO NOT NEED MORE ON MY PLATE. THIS ACTOR AU IS GONNA TAKE ME YEARS TO WRITE LIKE I NEED TO PRAY EVERY NIGHT THAT PEOPLE WILL STILL CARE#ABOUT IT/THEM TO STICK ALONGSIDE ME I CANNOT BE ADDING MORE#ESPECIALLY WHEN IM SO BUSY AS ISSSSSSSS. UGH. BUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!#i mean the plus side is that i know i will never get tired of these guys and that au included. i will be in my seventies drawing these guys#I'M not going anywhere. but.......#my extremely lofty ambitions vs my compulsive deep rooted fear of time#but it's like. this au and these guys and everything on this blog has so much monumental importance to me#and even more monumental is that people get to feel the same Stuff i do about them. i need you all to hear 100% what i hear and see 100%#what i see................... okay wording it like that does not sound healthy LOL BUT#i grieve this a lot. that other people aren't able to feel the extent of the obsession that i do. and it's not because i'm like 'ONLY I KNO#THEM' or discrediting anyone else's passions absolutely not. but i'm just such an Extreme Case#these guys are everything everything on this blog is everything to me to the point that i did what i swore i'd never do and 'came out'#because i want people to experience it with me so bad..#and a comic is a good start. but also i've been saying for years i need to draw illustrations of what i've written and never have#but for reference i had started drawing a comic out of the first iteration of the actor au back in 2020 when that was a thing so this is#sort of picking back up on that#pros: motivation to draw. will help curate this vision i have. maybe more digestible to read. will help me be a better comic artist/#sequential artist/artist in general. maybe help me break out of my artistic paralysis#cons: I AM TOO BUSY. i am always starting and never finishing things. i would get stressed about non-existent deadlines just as i do with m#reviews and regular actor au chapter uploads. it's just so much to add on esp when we're at the beginning of the au as is and its taken me#years to write even that#yall it is genuinely too tough out here when you have too much passion and don't know what to do with it it's my best friend and my greates#enemy#somedays i'm like 'uuuugh everyone's gonna move past this it's just gonna be me again nobody will care about the actor au because i took to#long and also people are normal and cycle interests' i need to not worry about that!!!!!!!!!!#but i just have so many pig and duck thoughts and ideas but they're all mushed up into a bottleneck inside me and i struggle with getting#them out because there's just so much#i should maybe stick with my idea of doing fancy illustrations per chapter like i was gonna.. but UGHHHH#i don't know what i'm worried about. i love the pig and duck. i hope you do too#š
14 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
can i say something related to h/p that like. ok i donāt know how to word this exactly but i find itā¦disheartening. i think. that there are three incredibly popular dra/mione fanfics that are being traditionally published within the year, likely to major success. iām sure i should have a more complex take on it than that with more nuance butā¦.it feels. bad.
#not pjo#chitter chatter#i really am struggling to word this#this is specifically about THESE FICS being published not the act of filing off the serial numbers or whatever as a whole#at this point im neutral to the concept and more on how the editing is done if at all due to the nature of how fanfic is often written#this is about THIS ship THIS fandom THIS ip THIS year#or i guess the last many years#I donāt like posting about books I donāt like anymore in fact Iāve been expressly told not to review books#but idk this one is bugging me so much I need to vent it somewhere#at least the biggest will be wildly successful im sure and it just makes me feel. bad.#I havenāt read it but im morbidly curious about it and it is giving all sorts of bad feelings#sorry to bring this up during pride month :///#I guess I should note here itās important that these arenāt āhey is this [ship] fanficā books#these were ON AO3#theyāve since been removed but they were explicitly fanfic#Im gonna like. eat a bagel now idk#Iāll lock and nuke this post if needed#ask to tag#i censored to not end up in the tags/search but lmk
14 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
drop the link on that fic of Zeus being a good dad?
Absolutely my friend!
As you can see, it's called Trials of Fatherhood by the lovely @z-eusie and in-between my agonies and right now, she's actually updated the fic and now the Apollo chapter is live!! Everyone should go read this fic, actually! It's a wonderful little compilation of moments that allow for showing both the ugliness and beauty of the gods when taken from a nuanced, compassionate perspective and it's always been one of my favourites to go back to every now and then just because of how fond I am of it. I'm especially fond of the Athena and Dionysus chapters myself but I hope everyone finds their favourite one. <33
#ginger answers asks#Writing#fanfic#Honestly I would do a series reviewing bomb ass ao3 greek myth fanfiction if I could#There's some genuine absolute bangers that deserve so much attention discussion and praise#One of my moots described greek myth tumblr as a symposium and if so I'm definitely the sort#who shows up each day with a new very annoying and longwinded opinion that ultimately must be discussed because it does - regrettably#have merit#Littlesparklight's portrayal of divine brotherhood and Zeus and Apollo's relationship#Is also really cool btw - if you guys haven't read littlesparklight's work you should do that also#Much more professional in flavour but the hidden subtleties are mmmmm SO tasty and good#omnomnom I eat that shit up#Okay yes this made me feel better ty for the ask anon!#ao3 link#zeus#apollo
32 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text


Feeling so thankful for this series of MAD! lyric videos today, because thanks to it I won't have to use the unimaginative names of "wild synth break 1" and "wild synth break 2" when refering to these parts of the song in my album review, but rather their true & official names: [unsettling synthesiser noises] and [heavenly choir + metallic chugging], respectively
#feeling so thankful for them also because they're so amazing and fun and awesome too and honestly the best lyric videos i've ever seen#i love how much they add to the whole feel of the album. i love the visual aesthetic of MAD! so much thank you galen johnson#i especially love the hotel 4 the fab vid the whole kinescopic (?) effect + the overlapping slowed down footage#go so well with the songs sinister vibe. and the scrolling list of the hotels services hell yesss. wonder if theres any easter eggs in ther#i also love knowing what color the songs are. bcs yes don't dog it is this exact shade of orangeish yellow so true#altough i see hit me baby as more of a red and pink song than blue (sky blue. or what i should maybe even call MAD! blue) but this works to#when i make that HMB-inspired comic page i think i'll go with red & dark pink & black in terms of colors mostly#but with some touches of that MAD! blue as well maybe. also speaking of the album review#i just hope to get to that before 14th june bcs if i don't then it won't exist until after it's my sparks show time#and i'd rather get that sorted out before all that big action time arrives. but now i'm still too busy enjoying MAD!#and losing it over how awesome this album is. but thats enough tags for one post i will continue this line of thought in another one later#goosepost
7 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
I am returned! Crazy things happened on hiatus, and here is a play-by-play:
Spent the bulk of September with our dogs at my great-aunt's lake cottage (which is a 15-hr drive from here), due to the abundance of birthdays this month.
Shortly after arriving, I got a cold from my sister, which as per usual, turned into bronchitis, which lasted the entirety of the vacation (I still have the cough).
Around midnight on the eve of our departure, I had a gallbladder attack (first one since early spring).
Except it was way worse. Like, I couldn't breathe, couldn't speak, couldn't even cry.
Called 911, got in the ambulance, and the pain suddenly vanished in the space of a minute.
The wee mountain hospital didn't have imaging equipment beyond a CT scan and the Dr. was like "If the pain is gone, you shouldn't expose yourself to that much radiation" (which I appreciated)
My labs were normal, so we conclude this must've been the passing of the gallstone. Big, if true.
I take hydrocodone and we all go to sleep.
In the morning, my mom and sister pack my stuff for me and my parents and I drive the 15 hours back home so that dad can make it to a job interview the next day.
During the last 45 minutes of the journey, my mom's very very old & frail chihuahua experiences a sharp decline in his already poor constitution.
I'm knocked out on hydrocodone, but my dad is up all night with the dog, and in the morning, he takes him to the vet to be put down.
My mom is devastated, this dog was adopted to be her bedside companion during chemo twelve years ago.
My dad's interview goes well.
I still have bronchitis.
Two days later, my sister (who stayed longer at the lake house to clean up) drives back to her home in Southern GA, but for hurricane Helene reasons, the highway is closed and she gets lost.
She finally makes it home to find her power is out, for hurricane Helene reasons (it's still out)
Three days later (last night), I have another brutally painful attack (clearly I'd NOT passed the stone), so my parents drive me to the ER.
Am able to get an ultrasound there, which confirms I still have either many gallstones or one huge one, but my labs are still normal.
Unfortunately, this makes sense because I underwent some rapid drastic weight loss after my attack in the spring.
ER Dr. thinks my pain is instead being caused by gastritis for genetic reasons (which reminded my mom that as a teenager she passed out at work from gastritis).
He prescribes me a trio of gastritis drugs.
I'll be going to a trusted functional medicine doctor next month because my dad got the job (an amazingly good job, praise God) and we can afford it at last. My hope is that this Dr. can point to causes beyond genetics for the gastritis and also get rid of the stones once and for all, even if that means going on Ursodiol.
My dad's new job requires him to move to the Middle East in three weeks.
Oh, and my personal Instagram account (which was about to become the cornerstone of my small business) was inexplicably terminated during my hiatus and I have no means of getting it back besides writing to the state Attorney General.
#I'm treating the gastritis diagnosis as a second opinion#half of it checks out and the other half of it feels sus#I'm really banking on the outstanding reviews of this functional doctor that our church friend gave us#she said he listened to her for 2 hours which sounds fake but ok#tl;dr my vacation was not really a vacation and my whole torso feels like a bus ran over it#but I'm so happy for my dad. this is a job that appreciates him for his military experience rather than treating it as a defect#he loves the Middle East and the company will pay for him to visit us whenever and we can go stay with him for 3 months at a time#(I likely will not until these health issues are sorted but even so. it's so much better than a deployment)#(and the pay is vastly improved lol--so thank y'all for your prayers on the job front)#x
23 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text

2025 reads / storygraph
This Love
contemporary fiction, set over a decade
a stubborn butch lesbian who breaks a lot of hearts and wants to do something important with her life, and a pan guy whoās moved from New York with his mother to escape his abusive father and a bad relationship with a professor - meet in their final year of university and quickly become close friends
they both dream of settling down and having kids - and decide that if they donāt find partners (or even if they do), theyāll do it together
over the years they navigate their relationships with their parents, new relationships, diverging life paths and media careers, and while their lives donāt go to plan, an unconventional family develops out of their strong friendship
#this love#lotte jeffs#aroaessidhe 2025 reads#oughh this was a lot#Iām always searching for more stories centering platonic relationships (esp m/f ones) that give them as much#development and complexity and messiness as romance stories get. this definitely delivers on that!#theyāre messy complicated characters with a messy complicated relationship thatās not always easy#but itās worth it#(I didnāt enjoy reading the parts where they grew apart :( but also I so appreciate a story giving that sort of complex narrative to a frie#It explores a lot of queer experiences and unconventional families.#as someone with very opposite feelings about wanting kids I definitely didnāt relate to that aspect of the narrative so much#but it was interesting to read that perspective.#the sort of. nonlinear bits and twist ending could have been expanded upon a bit more imo#āSince when do you not care about labels; you're obsessed with them. look at your spice rack. you have a label makerā lmao#sapphic books#this is not a very good summary or review LOL
12 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text









tyyy beloved @ash-and-starlight for the tag here r some books im excited to read next year !!!
tagging (v optionally) @wakingstone @jumping-jackalope @legofbicuriosity @lesbianboyfriend šš»šš»š
#rn iām most excited abt the sophie lewis#3rd in line on libby š¤#ash iām š¤š¤ abt priory ppl keep reccing it to me for so long now. something about lesbians? anyway š«”#alsoooo putting baru on here as a contract bc i rlly have been meaning to read it since we talked abt it!! [redacted amount of time] ago š#a bunch of these i uncovered when sorting/moving stuff out of my room n remembered they existed#you exist too much and freshwater and the rilke mainly#tryinggg to read more physical books again#also imagine all of the locked tomb series is here i just couldnāt fit em all#but feel like thatās my duty as a lesbian asw š«”š«”š«”#exit west iāve heard is v cool#histories of the transgender child iāve had on my list since i read excerpts a whileee ago#and decolonizing methodologies i saw in the reviews for braiding sweetgrass which was v good#anywayyy hehe feel free to drop more recs !!#i like that weāre all like. this is my tbr for 2025. dont worry abt the book(s) that were on my tbr for 2024. or 2023. or-
11 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Maeve Fly is,,,,, something
#im enjoying it don't get me wrong#but youve really gotta meet this book where it's at#and there's still something about it that's just falling sort of.. flat#i think the marketing does it a BIG disservice#its pitched as like. a female american psycho. a splatterfest gory serial killer book#but for the Girls(TM)#which honestly made me wary as much as it did intrigue me a little dhdDNDA#but its more.... idk. its got a slow build and a romance that i *think* it wants me to root for? based on how reviews felt on it anyway#and I think pitching this book as an American Psycho sets the wrong expectations for Maeve as a character#q reads maeve fly
4 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
looking for fragrances that really smell like sex. not "sexy" and when people call something sexy its always either a violently putridly sweet floral or a smoky leather dive bar smell no i mean like carnal...an erotic aphrodisiac kind of a scent. and god no not something that smells like actual bodily fluids please. idk what i want thats why i'm saying all this
#watching videos reading reviews trying samples where i can maybe i'll find something#suggestions welcome lol#the musk in delina is sort of there thats why people love to say it smells kind of like pussy...but i dont like og delina that much#i do wear la rosee but its so cutesy idk like thats not always the vibe#so what am i even talking about
4 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
When The Moon Hatched is an insane book. It is a fae romantasy but this author went whole hog into building a world that works completely unlike our own, and I can tell she is determined to make it consistent and make sense within her own internal set of rules. I really respect her for trying to do something new, even if the prose is the brightest shade of eggplant I've come across in a while. It's not Good -- the weakness of the prose, especially when she tries a "High Fantasy" tone, holy shit, and the stodgy romantasy beats [even with the twist you can see from a mile away] make this a squarely mediocre read -- but she was definitely ambitious and trying something that puts her work apart from the gazillion other fae romances (there's like, no humans at all in this book, which I respect a lot). She definitely has a Vision, and there's nothing I love more than works produced by self made arteurs with only middling technical skill that are obviously passion projects. Yeah, the story itself is mid and the characters pretty stock when you get down to it, but the world is genuinely interesting and probably the least derivative I've read in any contemporary romantasy. You can tell that she probably read things like Discworld and was like, "I want to do this too! I want to create my own unique planet and then set a sexy faerie romance on it and it'll be my magnum opus."
And you know what??? Good for her. I love that. Friggin large popcorn dammit because reading this feels exactly like watching one of those one-off mid-budget fantasy/sci fi movies from the mid 00s - mid 10s that are firmly mediocre, but still live in your psyche forever. This is truly the Mortal Engines or Chronicles of Riddick -- or, actually JUPITER ASCENDING!!!! -- of the faerie romance genre. I'm only about halfway through, but I'm pretty sure at the rate this is going my opinion isnt going to change much.
Also. People complain that there's tons of made up jargon and they need to consistently refer to the glossary, which I personally don't see because to me it's really quite easy to infer what things mean based on context clues ??????? Like the book never goes out of its way to overly explain what anything is since the POV character has lived in this world for her entire life, so it's all just normal to her, and I very much respect that choice not to exposit more than absolutely necessary. Like idk those 70s pulp sci fi books must have really done a number on my pattern recognition and contextual reading skills, because I'm not having any difficulty at all following and inferring the meanings of the jargon. Like. I really need some of these people who complain about fantasy slang and jargon to try picking up A Clockwork Orange one day. That book is nigh impenetrable with made up slang LOL.
#rene's impromptu book reviews#this is my new tag for these kinds of posts#also i love how fae aging and longevity is implied through the way time is measured in this one#A year is about 1000 in universe days and fae can apparently live for hundreds of years#like theyre i think considered mature at the same number of years as humans but the length of those years are much longer than ours#and we have no clue how long those days are -- theyre at least as long as ours though they could be longer#but thats a moot speculation because there are no humans in this one so everyones on the same playing field#also the way that they use scent as a primary sense differently from us is genuinely handled so subtly im actually a little impressed#like i know its a stock trait in contemporary faerie books for fae to be able to smell things a/b/o style#but i do like that it was included the way it is. not super in your face but still There#readswithrachel blasted a line because the pov character described someone as smelling like a 'freshly split stone' and went on a rant abou#how that doesnt smell like anything and im just like. hm sure but first of all these people arent human and use smell as a primary sense#(which is supported by the fact that someone asked another person what a stranger smelled like in order to get an identifying description)#so like. how do you know if they cant smell what split stone smells like. also it's just an evocative description. it could be literal but#it also could be metaphor. if scents tell you what sort of person a character is then that is an evocative description.#it is a little purple and silly sure. but this is also a fae romance book.#like idk i think a skill you need to have as an effective critic is to be able to engage with a work on its own level -- to analyze it from#both the perspective of your own tastes and from the perspective of its target audience. theres layers to it. like an onion#anyway.
5 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Not people making a whole hashtag(#sick of the smut) against smut on social media and a publisher jumping in on it:

More of people talking about the hashtag:
Video 1
Video 2
And on the smut in YA discourse thatās been talked about along with this hashtag, Iām a fresh 20 years old(birthday was last month) meaning Iāve been(and still am) reading YA for a good portion of my life. Yes, I know YA is for 12-18 year olds. But, 12-18 is a large developmental gap within itself. This shouldnāt really need to be said, but not every book in the YA genre is going to be able to cater to the age range thatās included in the range for reading YA. The singular or few smut chapters in YA thatās everyoneās having discourse about isnāt for 12-14 year old YA readers, no debate about that.
The singular or few smut chapters are for the 16-18 year old readers, because thatās what lines up with the developmental experiences of someone within that age range. Especially the 17-18 year old readers considering theyāre either in college or about to be going to college. Sex and dating normally starts to be more relevant or interconnected topics or things people are going through at that point in life. This shouldnāt need to be said(again) but 16-18 year olds(speaking as a former 16-18 year old) arenāt going to really relate to the level of romance that would be appropriate for a 12-14 year old. Theyāre on different ends of the puberty spectrum and in different environments(mainly 17-18 year olds).
More in the tags
#Instagram#sick of the smut#ya genre#book discourse#to finish this up#for the people complaining about not knowing whether or not thereās smut in a book#number one Google it and read reviews#number two: the proposal of the putting some sort of warning that the book does contain smut is a pretty nuanced and fair idea to try#number three: the sick of the smut people would hate ao3 because they seem like the same type of people who couldnāt figure out the filters#bookblr#discourse#book smut#and all the people on social media being like oh my god ya is saturated with smut#it isnāt#it really isnt#thereās plenty of cute romance or fantasy books without smut in them#I would know because I read them all the time#in all honesty it doesnāt take much to google a review of the book before reading said ya book
3 notes
Ā·
View notes