#the character work and development is amazing
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Okay, but I actually adore the romantic arc in KPop Demon Hunters. There's so little time to tell this story and to focus on all its nuances, but the way the movie gets us there is absolutely amazing and doesn't feel cheap at all. And I think part of the reason why is the fact that Rumi and Jinu never really develop past what technically counts as just a crush.
It doesn't try to convince us that what they shared was something unbeliavably deep or like some kind of soulmate bond. It doesn't act like they were perfect for each other and how their love could make it through everything. It works precisely because it shows the tragedy of how little time they had together and how they never got to explore that on their own terms.
And we can all relate to that feeling of loss of something that could have been more. All of the elements of a great romance are technically there but all these other outside elements are working against them and all we get to see at the end of the day is the unexplored potential.
Rumi and Jinu connected on a very human level, that's true, but the tragedy of their relationship is that it couldn't really become more and what we end up mourning is the potential they had, the fact that they could have been so much more if given a chance.
So often stories try to convince us of these stronger-than-anything romantic arcs, but since a lot of the time romance is the B-plot at best and there's no time to develop it properly, we end up with the characters basically skipping all the stages from attraction and straight to pure and unadulterated love.
KPop Demon Hunters doesn't do that.
Instead, it focuses on the connection that was broken too fast and that's precisely why it resonates with us. It doesn't try to pretend that their romance is something that it isn't and that fact, more than anything else, makes it feel authentic.
I feel like a different ending would have cheapened the story somehow. We got a happy ending, yes, but it doesn't make it all good. It doesn't erase all the pain that we had to go through to get there.
And at the end of the day, it's not some grand love story.
No.
Instead, it's two broken people who connect, who feel attraction and who never get to explore what it means. The romance itself isn't some kind of be-all and end-all kind of thing.
It still matters, though.
Why? Well... because they still got to meet each other. They still got to heal, in their own ways. And that matters, too. Even if it wasn't meant to be the way we wish it was. Sometimes, that's just how it is.
#kpop demon hunters#netflix kpop demon hunters#rumi kpdh#jinu kpdh#rumi x jinu#kpdh#netflix kpdh#rujinu#kpdh meta#kpdh analysis#jinu x rumi#kpdh spoilers
873 notes
·
View notes
Text
This was one of the real beauties of 22-25 episode seasons. There wasn't a need to make every single moment count. We got bottle episodes which are some of the most character-enriching episodes of a lot of series. We got clip shows which reminded us of scenes we loved (this is back before you could just rewatch an episode online so we lived for re-runs or, with great dedication, recorded episodes to tape each week). Longer seasons allowed time for characters to develop more naturally. Does high-stakes character development work well? Absolutely. But for a lot of fans, especially shippers, there's so much magic in the moments in between. I think this is one of the real reasons that there was so much amazing fan content even before streaming allowed us to micro analyze media by watching it over and over and over. We got to *talk* about it for a week (or an entire summer) before there was more to consume. Shows got to explore so many facets of things without having to make every moment count because they only have 10 hours to tell the story. I love streaming. And there are some truly amazing shows making every moment count with ultra-compelling 10 hour blocks of television. But there was something magical, especially in science fiction, when you gave the universe—and the characters in it—room to breathe.
I don't know what those '90s sci Fi TV writers were putting in their shows but I wish they'd start doing it again
50K notes
·
View notes
Text
hi guys, i played your game (expedition 33) now pls play mine (kingdom come deliverance 2)
#wdym it doesn’t work like that#i still think people should give kcd2 a chance it’s so good!!#good story/amazing and funny dialogues/interesting and well developed characters/made you want to explore the world/good and fun sidequests#*make#like there’s so much more that just hansry being canon#(i mean that itself is amazing but kcd is just an amazing game in general for everything it has to offer)
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
Watch "Kpop Demon Hunters"

Watched the movie one day after it came out and i have to say that this movie was amazing, from the trailer i knew i would enjoy this movie but watching the movie made it so much better.
So let me just gush about the movie for a minute
First: characters - i really like the main trio, They are all well written and their interactions are both funny but still have some meaning, Zoey is probably my favourite between the three because her expressions are dumb and hilarious and she is a mood lol.
The Saja boys were also a cool way to make the villains interesting for the movie, while sometimes it did feel like it was basically jinu and the rest, it makes sense since you can't develop all of the characters in a 1:30 hour movie
Next - The songs - Overall the OST is a banger, "How its done" is no doubt my favourite original track from the movie, as it felt like KDA on crack and is already on loop for me, "Soda Pop" and "Takedown" were neat songs, the latter being performed by TWICE's Jeongyeon, Chaeyoung and Jihyo which is a very interesting trio for a song.
"How it sounds like" and "Golden" were less my style but were not bad, considering they were pretty much songs for plot
The songs from existing groups were also well chosen with "Strategy" by twice, "Love me Right" by EXO, "Love, maybe" by melomance and more giving the movie's soundtrack more personality.
Now: The looks - wow, everything looks amazing, the artstyle was vibrant, the animations were superb (not surprising since its the same studio behind the spiderverse movies), the fights were well choreographed and the character designs are just *chef kiss*, nothing else to say.
Lastly: the Plot (Will try to prevent spoilers) - it was good, the premise was interesting and the way Kpop was incorporated to the whole demon hunter was good, feeling as if the trio are basically a bunch of DnD bards who multiclassed into fighters.
the climax of the movie actually gave me the shivers and all of the interactions between the characters were plot important and not just there for being there, especially the Rumi and Jinu ones which were pretty much the leading duo when it cames to their interaction, bit Zoey and Mira were also a funny and good duo.
=================================
Overall? Yes, watch this movie. As a kpop fan it felt like everything was made with intention without anything that was in the movie for the sake of being in the movie (ehm ehm Minecraft movie), for me its a 10/10 movie and if you haven't watched it yet, give it a shot
Thats all for me, see you next time Leafies, i promise i am working on my next draft lol
24 notes
·
View notes
Note
Howdy hey Habs!
I am wanting to learn character drawing. I realized very quickly that I needed a solid understanding of the human form, so I've been practicing life drawing and feel I have an intermediate understanding of the human form (I still need to learn advanced anatomy -- and am working through the Morpho anatomy books/attending life drawing sessions, but I can solidly draw a person head to toe).
I am really struggling with abstraction and drawing without reference. And I'm having a hard time finding a resource that focuses on abstraction specifically.
A few questions for my favorite BKDK artist 🫶
Does my lack of understanding of abstraction indicate I just need to keep studying the fundamentals/advanced anatomy before I start trying to tackle character drawing?
If I need to just start character drawing, do you recommend a specific resource or exercise to start?
Do you have any other general resources that helped you develop your character drawing skills?
Thank you so much for all of your art tips! I love your tumblr so much and I think it's amazing that you are helping newer artists. ❤️
Hi! If you think you’ve built up a solid understanding of fundamentals, there’s no reason not to try expanding your skills into character art!
I don’t know if there’s any specific resources I can give you, but for me I learnt how to simplify characters by observing from other artists and referencing shows I liked, so my suggestion for you is to try drawing from sources that inspire you! I personally keep comics and manga around me when I draw, and I save art and that I find interesting, basically building up a library to help inspire me while I work!
23 notes
·
View notes
Note
what's your opinion on hadestown? i'm a newer theatre kid and I like orpheus and eurydice's story but don't know much about the musical as a whole
:OOO thank you so much for asking!! It’s wonderful!!!
Hands down my favourite musical of all time!!! (It also explores Persephone and Hades’s story, if you like that too!!) I HIGHLY recommend watching it (especially as a newer theatre kid!)
There’s a few full recordings on YouTube :3!! orrr the official cast album is really good too!!
#:DDD#I’ve never ever not cried while watching/listening to it#the character work and development is amazing#the main message is Humanity’s unwavering hope no matter what#a tragedy that is a tragedy because Orpheus’s love is so so so strong that he CANT not look back#but we watch and hope it’ll be different this time anyway#like he does again and again :)#and tries anyway#how despite all odds we keep trying<3#and dare to hope for a better world. despite the world we live in now#BSKSJS I LOVE IT SO MUCHHH
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
it was only a matter of time, unfortunately
doodles regarding my tadc oc. sorry for falling back into the oc x canon mines 😔
i like to think that hassel befriends caine simply bc hes so fascinated and wants to know the inner workings of the circus and also just how advanced caine is as an AI. sure the friendship started out as one-sided and an attempt to get information n maybe to find an exploit of some sort but it soon becomes a real, genuine friendship.
gif unrelated
#the amazing digital circus#tadc#tadc oc#tadc caine#oc x canon#my art#doodle#oc: hassel (tadc)#tadc zooble#tadc pomni#tadc gangle#tadc ragatha#tadc kinger#tadc bubble#as ive said before i am a sucker for robots developing sentience and experiencing emotions for the first time#decided to make hassel less like myself n more like his own character n ive been havin more fun with that :]#guy who REALLY likes computer viruses winding up in the circus is just a funny concept to me#>works in cyber security#>ignores the warning signs and opens a dubious program#>mfw im now stuck in digital purgatory#“i am cringe but i am free” ect ect
161 notes
·
View notes
Note
*sigh* thoughts on Nintendo's botw/totk timeline shenanigans and tomfoolery?
tbh. my maybe-unpopular opinion is that the timeline is only important when a game's place on the timeline seriously informs the way their narrative progresses. the problem is that before botw we almost NEVER got games where it didn't matter. it matters for skyward sword because it's the beginning, and it matters for tp/ww/alttp (and their respective sequels) because the choices the hero of time makes explicitly inform the narrative of those games in one way or another. it matters which timeline we're in for those games because these cycles we're seeing are close enough to oot's cycle that they're still feeling the effects of his choices. botw, however, takes place at minimum 10 thousand years after oot, so its place on the timeline actually functionally means nothing. botw is completely divorced from the hero of time & his story, so what he does is a nonissue in the context of botw link and zelda's story. thus, which timeline botw happens in is a nonissue. honestly I kind of liked the idea that it happened in all of them. i think there's a cool idea of inevitability that can be played with there. but the point is that the timeline exists to enhance and fill in the lore of games that need it, and botw/totk don't really need it because the devs finally realized they could make a game without the hero of time in it.
#i really do have a love-hate relationship with this timeline#because it's FASCINATING lore. genuinely. and i think it carries over the themes of certain games REALLY well#but i also think it's indicative of a trend in loz's writing that has REALLY annoyed me for a long time#which is this intense need to cling to oot#and on a certain level i get it. that was your most successful game probably ever. and it was an AMAZING game.#and i think there's definitely some corporate profit maximization tied up in this too--oot was an insane commercial success therefore you'r#not allowed to make new games we need you to just remake oot forever and ever#and that really annoys me because it makes certain games feel disjointed at best and barely-coherent at worst.#i think the best zelda games on the market are the ones where the devs were allowed to really push what they were working with#oot. majora. botw. hell i'd even put minish cap in there#these are games that don't quite follow what was the standard zelda gameplay at their time of release. they were experimental in some way#whether that be with graphics or puzzle mechanics or open-world or the gameplay premise in its entirety. there's something NEW there#and because the devs of those games were given that level of freedom the gameplay really enforces the narrative. everything feels complete#and designed to work together. as opposed to gameplay that feels disjointed or fights against story beats. you know??#so I think that the willingness to allow botw and totk to exist independently from the timeline is good at the very least from a developmen#standpoint because it implies a willingness to. stop making shitty oot remakes and let developers do something interesting.#and yes i do very much fear that the next 20 years of zelda will be shitty BOTW remakes now#in which botw link appears and undergoes the most insane character assassination youve ever seen in your life#but im trying to be optimistic here. if botw/totk can exist outside the timeline then we may no longer be stuck in the remake death loop#and i'm taking eow as a good sign (so far) that we're out of the death loop!! because that game looks NOTHING like botw or oot.#fingers crossed!!#anyway sorry for the game dev rant but tldr timeline good except when it's bad#asks#zelda analysis
169 notes
·
View notes
Text
I am liking Jujutsu Kaisen, way more than I imagined I would, but I foresee it will let me down and it's keeping me from enjoying this as much as I could haha
I think the characters and dynamics are well set, and I think many of them have an incredibly good and deep potential, but I would be willing to bet they'll not get a proper development, enough for them to really hit. A well assembled set of gears is not enough to make the movement go, you have to wind the clockwork.
I think Gojo and Megumi have a fascinating and very complex dynamic, but I doubt it will be given the time and care that imo it needs to actually work. And it is going well enough for now! One could see the intimacy between them was deeper than the one Gojo had with, say, Yuji and Nobara ever since the very first few episodes despite the fact Fushiguro too was a first year. But the pieces forming what they have are extremely complex, and it just wouldn't be realistic if it doesn't show, even if in a not showing way, or if it doesn't have consequences or implications.
It's one of those dynamics that shape one's life, the way one regards the world, the way one establishes or not relationships with other people. It's one of those dynamics that could be full of fondness, gratitude, resentment, admiration, trust, and that imply intimacy, the good kind or the bad, even if in just the knowledge of someone who's been a constant through your life. It could, and would, imply a myriad of feelings, and probably in such a mix it could imply contradictory feelings too. Even the nothingness would weight, even the nothingness would be significant and meaningful.
Gojo took Megumi and his sister under his wing, the son of a man who murdered him, because of both selfish and selfless reasons. Megumi looks like Toji. What does Gojo feel about this? How does Gojo deal with this? How does Gojo go about taking care of Megumi? Would he walk him to school? Make him breakfast? Celebrate his birthdays making him blow candles? Did he take him to the zoo? Does the relationship between them feel professional or is it something more? Gojo appreciates his students, but is Megumi to him just another student? When Gojo faces Sukuna in Megumi's body, did he see the kid he raised, or does he just see Sukuna in one of his students' body? Did he have one faint wavering instant? And how does Megumi feel about this? Is he resentful of him? Resentful of the situation? Of the selfishness behind his actions? Does he feel like a pawn? Is he grateful? Does he resent feeling grateful? Would he rather not? Does he love Gojo? Does he feel nothing about him other than what he could feel about a teacher that sort of annoys him but knows he's reliable in his strength? Does he think it unfair, cruel or unfeeling that Gojo is close, closer perhaps, with Yuuji or Yuta, considering their story? When Sukuna slices Gojo in two, does the remnants of Megumi's soul tremble?
And not just Megumi and Gojo. Yuuji and Nanami, Gojo and Nanami, Yuuji and Fushiguro, Nobara and the boys, or Nobara and Maki, Todo and Yuuji or Yuta, Gojo and Yuta, Megumi and his sister. Gojo and Geto, even! If the pieces are well set, the dynamics are intriguing, interesting, and have potential to be deep, but then the characters have like two plot relevant scenes that punch you hard, but little more, it's not nearly enough. Especially not nearly enough for the enormity that is shonen dynamics and situations. And the potential existing at all, and then not delivering, makes it all the more frustrating when you're left with something mediocre that could have been so good.
The development of dynamics through not only a few plot relevant gut wrenching moving scenes, but also the smallness of life, is important. The friend who recommended this to me said that those things were just unnecessary filler, but I disagree. I think there's a big difference between a large amount of anime-only filler episodes whose existence is based on the fact they had run out of manga chapters to animate, and moments of quietness. The low stakes character-driven moments of quietness can be so telling and so insightful, and they are so satisfactory when brought back later in higher stakes situations. My friend teased me there was no scene of Gojo making breakfast to Megumi, that it would be an idiotic idea, but it would be so telling. How he makes breakfast, what they eat, if he tries hard or if it's all mechanised, if they have personal bowls or if they use whatever, if he just buys them some pastry on the way to school, if the way they have breakfast changes through the years, or if he doesn't make them breakfast at all! All that would be very insightful on their dynamic and its evolution. All that would give a glimpse on how they regard each other and why, even in the present. All that could become meaningful in tense situations and high stakes scenes.
These moments also let the plot breath; if a lot is happening all the time, if every character is always experiencing trauma after trauma, the entire story is so emotionally draining that at some point you don't even care all that much. Besides, these nothing moments or low stakes plot arcs, besides deepening and developing dynamics, also let some in-world time pass, which would make the intimacy and bond between characters more believable imo; between Yuuji eating Sukuna's finger and their last confrontation in December how much time has passed? A few months? Am I truly to believe these characters are so everything to each other in only a few months?
Without some smallness, some repetition, some daily life, some low stakes not plot-centric development, the dynamics don't hit, they don't truly feel fleshed out, and dynamics as complex as the ones Megumi and Gojo have, or as supposedly meaningful as the one Megumi has with Yuuji or his sister, should be fleshed out if they're going to exist at all. Otherwise they'd risk making the writing feel awkward and fake. Besides, if the dynamics felt well fleshed out and realistic, they would shape the way the characters interact and act, and how they deal with situations, thus being plot relevant.
The shonen genre has so much happening all the time, the stakes are so high, the dynamics are so rooted in big events and the relationships carry enormous weight and implications. Yet they barely get developed, and it feels so stupid, so plain, the absence of something so important noticeable like a constant void, a shapeless nothingness present in every scene. It makes the characters feel like cardboard figures. Jujutsu Kaisen is already getting a better job than many, but I doubt it will do enough for what I've heard, and I fear I am bound to feel let down, and bound to feel unmoved.
After all, if not enough time and care has been given to develop a dynamic, I am not going to feel pressured by the high stakes; if not enough time and care has been given to develop the dynamic between Megumi and Yuuji, as good potential as it has I am bound to feel little for this last confrontation between Sukuna and Itadori, and his effort in getting Megumi back.
#It's not that I think everything has to be character driven or take a lot of care about dynamics#Death Note for instance works well without it. There's juice in the dynamic between Light and his father and the role of Matsuda there#and it works well with Light's views and their evolution and the whole Kira situation. It isn't much. It doesn't need more#But Death Note doesn't truly drop something as big as Gojo and Megumi to then do barely nothing about it#('But L and Watari' not the same at all. That was deepened in the anime and besides Watari is not one of the main characters)#Or Megumi and his sister. If we see barely nothing of Megumi and his sister other than shiny flashbacks of her#how am I to feel moved by it all beyond superficial emotions? I don't know. It just feels so like cardboard to me#And it annoys me! It annoys me a lot! Because Jujutsu Kaisen has amazing potential! The dynamics and characters could be amazing!#But I don't trust they'll live to their full potential and the potential existing for nothing is ruining this for me xD#Jujutsu Kaisen#Sorry this time I'm tagging it. I want to find this and see if I was right when I'm finished. I think I'll read the manga too#The condescending filler breakfast comment by my friend was ironic considering the Kramer vs. Kramer breakfast scenes exist#Breakfast can be so telling. And besides he loves the Chainsaw Man coffee scene so I don't get why not breakfast#But truly some small daily life moments can tell us a lot about a character that we could recognise later on in high stakes scenes#such as how they deal in tense situations‚ what makes them snap#how they go about dealing with a problem.#Sometimes it could be smaller moments or conversations what makes characters reconsider things‚ not just having Sukuna rip their heart out#In Pandora Hearts the conversation between Elliot and Oz about the book series they love and their favourite characters becomes key#Oz's development and how he regards things‚ his own person‚ and how he deals with situations will be shaped later on by this conversation#till the very end. The entire main character's development is shaped by a 'filler' conversation.It's not filler. It's just not a fight scen#Shonen manga readers find everything filler except for fights which is ironic considering that many fights in shonen feel unnecessary#Breakfast is unnecessary. Just filler. Fighting thirty seven secondary monsters or chapter after chapter of physical training is not. Okay#Things can be small but plot relevant. If it shapes and fleshes out and deepens a character or a relationship it is not filler#And mainly MAINLY for the love of everything good if you're going to make a fucked up or Meaningful Beyond Everything dynamic#give it time and care. Actually write it. Don't give me two panels and one conversation after some life and death situation. It's not enoug#Especially if I'm to believe they are important. Make me believe they actually are#I don't know... This issue with not trusting the development of very well set potential in Jujutsu Kaisen#has not only been keeping me from thoroughly enjoying the series‚ but actively keeping me from watching for weeks#It makes me doubt if I want to spend my time in this at all since after all time is limited and we can but spend it in a handful of things#A pity. I really love some things and I really think Megumi and Gojo could be everything to me haha the Heathcliff/Hareton vibe gets me
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
hi i've noticed how incredibly difficult it is to write threads with people so i think the best approach might be to stick to one thread per person and go from there instead of juggling like 20 asks that are all single instances. if you want to thread with me please give this a like and i will slink over for discussion !
#* ✦ 𝐈. ❮ ooc ❯ ⸻ ❝#i was talking to the besties about this issue i face with falling short in character dynamic developments#because my approach so far has literally just been answering asks and prompts which is great but that takes away from the development#i do discuss in dms which does give substance but it would be amazing if i could stick to a thread with more than 4 notes for once#i might make a spreadsheet to help keep track since i like to sprinkle my responses to different people so everyone gets a fair share#but yes i am going to move away from prompts unless i feel like i can juggle some extra replies since i want to flesh out interactions#also by one person i mean like since i have multiple muses it would be great if you could pick one and just stay with that pls#until i get a break from my busy work life anyway#thank you for understanding !
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
Something seriously lacking in my art is the ability to tell a story in a single illustration.
I've gotten so used to drawing my characters standing around doing random things that I've never practiced telling a full tale/putting implications into my pieces that require more thinking/looking.
It also comes from a lower amount of details in my works by default [since I like to get pieces done fast], but I'm tired of using that as an excuse.
#vent#kinda#sorry I'm just having a rough one tonight but I'll recover lmao#I think the AI art thing is really getting to me cuz like.#Anyone can make pretty images if they study and practice hard enough#[not to detract from people who don't tell stories with their images!]#but something in my brain wants to fight back because AI will never be able to Tell a Story through its images.#It can't make narrative choices through its regurgitation of random elements. It will never tell a cohesive and interesting tale through#detail choice#the worst it can do is create surface-level 'pretty' images by smashing together a bunch of mushed up information#but storytelling? that's human touch#that's intention. Thought. Choices.#and idk it's really bothering me lately that my images almost never... 'say' anything about a character.#this does not apply to anyone else's art I look at#it's just a standard I'm starting to feel my head apply to my own work and nobody else's.#which I'm taking as a sign that this is something I'm unsatisfied with#but the thought of starting to develop a completely new skill like that? terrifyingly daunting.#Sorry for the wall of tags I'm havin' some hella moodswings tonight#happens a lot when I get inspired by art I see#which I'm trying to work on but yaknow#it's a long process#anyways how's your night goin#I'm gonna cheer myself up by eating some amazing asparagus casserole
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
fighting with my demons (wanting to be supportive of all kaito vocaloid portrayals but finding six packs on him so weird, off putting and out of character (at least to how i see him be commonly portrayed and with my own personal vision) on him that i can't wrap my head around it)
#Bean Text#if you ever see me draw kaito with a shrink-wrapped six pack thats not me. or its a cry for help#i can see him as thin / fat (hell! i wouldn't be opposed to muscular kaitos if they were realistic!)#maybe its just my hatred for abs in general idk#but (and this is delving to how i personally see him) i feel like he wouldn't have the drive to develop one even if it were a easy goal#imo even in my personal idol au kaito's the type of guy to take it easy and only work out to maintain the ability to dance and be flexible#meanwhile the main kaito from my other au (mittens vocabytes ily) is a fat guy! and he wouldn't have it any other way!#i want to make a statement that you can still make fat characters cool and amazing and badass !!#not every damn male character needs to have a fucking six pack!#shocker! people come in all different shapes and sizes ! ! !#shoutout to women with muscles though. especially if they're realistic instead of them looking like they're just for show#shrugs. its what its
7 notes
·
View notes
Note
No no I knew you weren’t talking bad about him! I was just baffled that people were talking shit when he legitimately said nothing bad about Taylor or their previous relationship…
he was very kind and very eloquent and succinct and i think this is the best response possible (and it once again discredits all those tabloid articles people thought came from him 🙄) but people will always be mad when someone they perceive has wronged taylor doesn't bend over backwards apologising and sanctifying her putting all the blame on them thus he continues to be a villain for answering the way he did (it's a catch-22, nothing he does will ever be the right thing in their eyes)
i was honestly more interested in the bit where he talks about how he's more interested in continue being a character actor even if it's only in supporting roles instead of empty leads that don't fulfill him artistically rather than the breakup questions
#like i already knew that because i knew he turned down several big offers in mainstream franchises and whatnot#but having him spelling it out was nice too#he's an incredible actor and i enjoy seeing him do amazing work in supporting roles he clearly loves rather than a lead in a blockbuster#tho i will continue to advocate for him to play any targaryen character in one of the many game of thrones spin-offs hbo is developing
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
@eglerieth replied to your post: Hello! I am here to ask about your Dior headcanons…
What’s your Galadriel headcanon?
Oh man, I didn’t see this!! Thank you for asking, i fully did not expect anyone to actually get far enough into the Dior post to see that let alone actually want to know. Sorry I’m two days late!
So! What we know about Galadriel in the Silmarillion:
She hated Fëanor but thought being a queen sounded pretty sweet/desired power
She’s named as one of the leaders of the Noldor across the Helcaraxë
Instead of founding her own kingdom (like she’d explicitly originally wanted) or moving in with her brother she got married and stayed in Doriath and learned a lot from Melian
Eventually Melian was like “hey so you should explain the weird ominous evil metaphysical cloud i can see hanging over the Noldor so i can explain about it to my husband bc he should really learn about whatever happened before it blows up in everybody’s faces” and Galadriel was like “yeah he probably should but i’m not telling”
At some point Galadriel asked Finrod why he wasn’t married yet
One time Melian casually foreshadowed Beren’s existence to Galadriel, who has no recorded response
That’s it. That’s literally all we know about what she was up to. She was super jazzed about the prospect of Ruling A Kingdom and then made friends with a queen and learned a bunch from her and… was still alive after the War of Wrath, and in between we have nothing.
We don’t know how she survived the Second Kinslaying, we can assume she made it to the Havens of Sirion but don’t know how she survived the Third Kinslaying let alone what she did/where she went after that… we don’t know what her reaction was to the death of her only remaining family member in Middle-earth, for which her cousins and the great-uncle in whose kingdom she lived were both partially responsible…
Like, that's weird, right? Galadriel is firmly established as someone bold and interested in being a ruler and stubborn as all get out, and then she… does nothing and everybody seems to forget she exists for several hundred years and some major political upheavals that should have personally affected her? It's not just me? That's really weird?
So, my Galadriel headcanon is that she’s inexplicably absent for most of the Quenta Silmarillion because she was deliberately erased/left out by the scribes writing things down because there was no way to acknowledge her presence in Doriath during and after Beren & Lúthien’s whole everything without getting into the messiest bit of Sindar-Noldor political tension that didn’t involve the Fëanorioni, because (again, headcanon) Galadriel Did Not Respond Well to her uncle getting her brother killed as a side effect of trying to get her cousin’s boyfriend killed and there was A Lot Of Tension for a while there (when you’ve got that kind of interpersonal tension between people who are both essentially Political Figures, i figure it’s probably going to turn into political tension unless they’re both trying very very hard to avoid that and potentially even then)
…and then after Thingol’s death a few years later, I think one of the primary contenders for Next Ruler of Doriath was Galadriel “Well I Came Here For A Kingdom In The First Place” Granddaughter-of-Olwë and also her husband is related to Thingol* and Lúthien’s clearly removed herself from contention so if the Sindar want a monarch who’s actually related to the last one they both qualify, it’s perfect and obviously Galadriel should be the next queen of Doriath (it is not obvious to everyone)
* on a side note, Celeborn is mentioned twice in the Quenta Silm: #1, Galadriel stays in Doriath because she’s marrying a “kinsman of Thingol,” while #2, shortly after Thingol’s death, Celeborn is referred to as a “prince of Doriath.” Not actual evidence, but it sure fits in nicely!
Like I said in the Dior post, I don’t think anything ever came to outright surface-level conflict; a civil war in Doriath is not getting left out of the Silmarillion. Tension between Galadriel and Thingol, though? and then between Galadriel and [various other contenders for the throne after Thingol, potentially including Dior himself when he arrived] that had everyone a little nervous? when she didn’t become queen and did (however begrudgingly) accept that Dior was the closest thing to a consensus pick and did survive the next several thousand years only to finally wind up as functional queen of most of the remaining Sindar despite eschewing the actual title? That I can see getting diplomatically left out of the histories, and explaining why she’s completely during the parts of the story where you’d think she’d be most involved.
#eglerieth#replies#lotr#character: galadriel#the silmarillion#listen i love galadriel more than words can express but so much of what's interesting about her is her character development#we know her best from LOTR as one of the oldest wisest most powerful most respected people in all of middle-earth#and she started as this stubborn willful power-hungry kid?#it's been a long time since i first read the silmarillion but i still remember discovering that and how it blew my mind#so while i do think all of this makes sense as An explanation for her disappearance from the text#part of why it's *my* explanation of choice is that i love that that's where she started and i think it's a shame we don't get to see more#of first age galadriel being this complicated messy figure who makes her third age self look all the more amazing#bc how the hell did she get there from here#so it works out so nicely if part of the reason we don't know more about early galadriel being Complicated™...#is just how Complicated™ early galadriel was#anyway the main thing i have realized in writing this & the dior post is holy shit i think about the silmarillion too much#i have. so many thoughts and opinions that i have never discussed with anyone and i don't even know what i actually need to explain#/what facts & opinions i need to establish as context for the stuff i'm actually trying to talk about#guessing the answer is "a whole bunch that i didn't‚ but not like half the things i *do*'' but i genuinely do not know!
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
whelp. just finished the fall of the house of usher and i can now finally say with absolute certainty that it wasn't his best work
#mike flanagan#the fall of the house of usher#it just-#eh#half of the deaths just straight Missed#which like with my favorite actress (whose character i actually really liked and whose death i was really excited for)#was kind of disappointing#the other deaths were good but the follow through sucked#the only amazing one was the first one and it set my standards unreasonably high apparently#second favorite was the glass just because that was fucking bonkers and i loved it. and that actress was WHOOF in that role#but the story beats were off and the flashbacks were not nearly as well incorporated as his other shows#the character development was mid and honestly it just didn't cement the characters nearly enough for their deaths to be impactful#even in a way where the lack of impact itself could've been significant lol#also the message didn't really come off that well man idk :/#some of the scenes fucked but not enough to save it tbh#like it wasn't bad but his other works certainly delivered much better#just felt like a lot of the things required for a moving story were missing
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
watching mash s11ep4 the joker is wild for the first time and...boy howdy do i have thoughts on bj's trapper complex
#mostly i think its absolutely fascinating for the writers to make trap's absence such a big part of bj's character and character development#and i dont mean character development in a good way i mean it in an actively bad way actually#but like how many shows do you watch where a character is “replaced” because an actor leaves that show#and we actually see the negative implications to that character replacing them#like it would be so easy for the writers to kind of hand wave over bj replacing trapper - just another cog in the army machine etc etc#but to make the choice that being a “replacement” to trapper would impact bj's state of mind so greatly#so LATE in the show too??#is fucking incredible storytelling actually#like bj had spent so long actually *trying* to be the replacement trapper#working on the still riffing off of hawk's jokes causing shenanigans#until he hits this spiral and breaking point in seasons 10/11 and seeing him almost...lash out? chafe? against that comparison#that building tension and exhaustion to always being in someones shadow#the writers sat on that for like SEVEN YEARS#and i just think thats fucking insane and amazing actually#its also hard as a viewer because like#i love bj#but he *is* trapper's replacement#and that makes this all the harder to watch because on the one hand im like “bj's right to feel this way”#but im also like “...trap would never”#so i am in fact falling into the conceit that everyone in the 4077 is#which makes the writing and storytelling#all the better#sorry not sorry for the insane tags on this whoops#em starts mashposting#m*a*s*h#mashposting#bj's trapper complex#bj hunnicutt#trapper john mcintyre#im also v new to the mash fandom and mash discourse so i have no idea if this is interesting or obvious oh well
3 notes
·
View notes