#ThirStu Readers

[voxmortuus]

Silly Crush | Chapter 6 - How?

Stu Macher x F!Reader

Scream (Movie) FanFic

TW: Language | Talk of Murder | Smut | Unprotected Quickie Sex | Vaginal Penetration | Body Fluids | Choking

Sorry, this one is really dialog-heavy.

Words: 997

Chapter 1 Silly Crush | Chapter 2 Movie Date | Chapter 3 Dinner Date | Chapter 4 Joy Ride | Chapter 5 First Fight

You had so many questions running through your mind. You didn't even know where to start asking. Let alone what questions to ask. You bit on your nail and looked at Stu, observing him, wondering how this creature could do such a thing, and the more you thought about it, the more it started to gnaw at you. Licking your lips, you let out a soft breath and leaned against the table.

"What are you thinking?" He asked you.

Taking a moment, you let out a soft breath. "Okay, so you do these things, with or without Billy... and you enjoy them?"

Nodding quickly and without hesitation, he answers. "Yes."

"What goes through your mind?" you bite the corner of your bottom lip, you keep your fingers on your lips, waiting for the good stuff.

"Well, it depends on the situation." He states

Tilting your head, you think of a situation. "Okay, your last one. What were you thinking then?" You ask.

"Well, I was thinking how annoying she was, my rage for her, the deep knowing feeling of her cheating, the deep knowing feeling that I was her prisoner, her accessory, How she used me, just a pawn in her game." He states, looking down at his hands, and back up at you, his eyes went dark, and your toes curled looking at his hands and back at him.

"Okay, what was it like?" You ask.

"Honestly, it was the best feeling. This rush of adrenalin washes over you. You feel invincible. Powerful." He smirks.

"What did your first time feel like?" You ask as you start to fiddle with your hair.

"Well, at first I was sick, I was disgusted, not with what I was doing but with the smell. I had this sinking feeling that I was going to get caught my first time, but here I sit." He smirks.

"Yes, here you sit." Tilting your head, you nibble on your lip a moment.

Thinking about a few more questions, you readjust in your seat, letting out a soft breath as your legs pressed together, tilting your head, looking at him, and smile. He smiles back and looks down at his hands again and back at you.

"Stu, how do you do it?" You ask him.

"Well, do you want the bland version or the detailed version?" He asked you.

"Detailed."

"Well, It starts with a phone call..."

"Skip that. How do you murder them, Stu?"

"Oh, okay. Well, these people always try and run, or throw something at me, so I have to figure, am I running or am I countering something thrown? When I get to them, Personally, I like to go for the neck, choking them, my hands wrapped around their throats, squeezing the last breath from them. Feeling the throat collapse in your hands, the bones crushing, feeling them take their last breath. I'm partial to a good deep throat slit or even for the dramatic, but I'm more of a hands-on kinda killer, makes me glad we wear gloves." He looks over you.

Your heartbeat has picked up. You lick your lips, leaning in, wanting more as your legs slowly press together again, rubbing together the friction, and the thought of Stu doing this was something you wouldn't think you would ever be into. Your breathing is jagged, you reach over and touch his hands, and you stand up, walking around the table and sit in his lap straddling him, and you look into his eyes, letting out a small breath.

"Fuck me." you tell him.

Without any hesitations, he looks over your face and reaches his hand between your legs, leaning you back slightly to lean against the table as he feels how wet you are a smug smirk creeps across his lips as his fingers work you and he readies himself. His cock in his hand as he shoves his fingers into you, you let out a soft whimper and feel him rub his cock against your pussy before he pulls you down onto him, feeling him harden a little more before you let out a gasp.

He grips your hips and helps guide you up and down on him, your hands on the table behind you as you bounce in his lap, feeling him deep inside you. You let out a soft whimper before you feel his hands digging into your hips. You take a hand moves to him and you place them on your throat.

"Choke me." You demand.

He wasn't going to question. His fingers wrap around your throat, lacing together in the back and he squeezes in just the right way to not hurt you, but to give you exactly what you're looking for.

"Such a dirty girl." He smirks.

Biting your lip you grow wetter as he squeezes tighter around your throat. Your moans become strained as you bounce on his hard throbbing cock as he guides you up and down by your throat. Your hands move to his chest as you rock back and forth, he picks you up by your throat and places you on the table, and starts thrusting into you harder.

"Cum on my cock. Now." He demands.

Without any second-guessing, you do just that. your body shakes and you let out a scream. When you let out your scream Stu feels your tighten around him almost pulling him in as he finishes inside you, not thinking, so caught up in this moment. He slowly lets go of your throat and looks over your face. "I'll talk about murder more often..." He chuckles

"Or you take me with you and I'll fuck you in the car after I watch..."

"Or I can fuck you after you do it and I watch."

"Either or." you chuckle.

You stand up and fix yourself feeling his cum roll down your leg, you look down and back up at him and he shakes his head.

"Leave it. Just a reminder." He smirks.

Scream Tag Squad: @luciferslittleastre, @ms-ghostface, @ginger-called-beth

[voxmortuus]

Silly Crush | Chapter 2 - Movie Date

Stu Macher x F!Reader

Scream (Movie) FanFic

TW: Language and Fluff

Forgive my writing. It’s been a while.

Chapter 1 Silly Crush

GIF created by @2026

"Y/N! DOOR!" Your mother called out.

"Who is it?" You call back checking the time it was far too early for Stu to come and pick you up. Before an answer could find its way to you a knock came at your door. Getting up you make your way to the door and open it to find Tatum standing there, your nerves get the best of you, and your heart and stomach sink.

"H-Hello Tatum, what's up?" You ask with a small shake to your voice.

"Stu, Stu broke up with me, that fuckin asshole!" She began to cry and barged her way into your room. You panic, the big blue dog on the bed, you look at her, but she moves the dog not really thinking much of it and falls backward on your bed.

"Stu broke up with you? I'm sorry, did he tell you why?" you ask.

"He said he needed something else, something different, he said I was being bitchy and that I needed to get a grip on myself. That I needed to not be so uptight." She began to sob. Thinking mentally about how spot on he was you didn't want to say anything you hand her a tissue.

"I'm sorry Tatum, that sucks. I'm sorry I am not good at this kind of thing, I tend to keep to myself." You give her a sweet consoling face. She sits up wipes her tears and shakes her head.

"No, it's okay, you're smart for staying single. Men are assholes." She states bluntly shaking. Arching your brow you almost chuckle.

"Yeah, I guess so huh?" You think a moment. "Umm, listen, Tatum as much as I'd love to help you through this tragic time, I've got to get ready, my dad is coming to get me we're going to see Bordello of Blood. I don't get to see him often since the divorce. I'll get with you later." You give a kind smile. Sniffling she nods.

"Thank you Y/N for listening... You're a great friend." She hugs you and heads out.

Letting out a heavy breath you close your eyes a moment and take a seat in the chair in front of your desk and you put your head in your hands and chuckle a moment. Looking over at your closet you decide to go with a jersey cotton black dress with a black sweater that hung off your shoulder and a pair of Chuck Taylor Converse shoes. Throwing your hair up in a messy bun and neutral-toned makeup, you spray yourself with a soft scented cucumber melon spray and head downstairs.

Your mother was in the kitchen and you lean against the island counter. "Hi mom." You smile. "I'm going out tonight, I'll be back around 11." You tell her.

"No later okay? Is Tatum okay? She seemed upset." She added.

"Of course. No later. She's alright, her and Stu broke up."

"Well, that's nice of you to go out and cheer up your friend, make it midnight okay? Tell Sidney hi for me okay?" She adds to her assumption.

Simply nodding your head you head to the front porch and wait, looking at the clock through the window he's right on time. Making your way to the car you slide in and lean in and kiss his cheek. "Hiya Stu."

He looks over at you. "Hey Y/N, you look nice." He smiled. "Off to Bordello of Blood!" He stated with an excited tone to his voice. Putting the car in drive he takes off down the road toward town. Going around some turns and curves he looks over at you. "I broke up with Tatum today." He states.

"I know, she came to my house to tell me, apparently you called her a bitch, and that she was uptight and you needed something different." You loosely quote.

He laughed and looked at you. "I told her she was a cunt, not a bitch, maybe that she bitched a lot, and was pushy, clingy and overly needy. Materialistic and demanding." He stated. "She gave you the nice version." He added as you drove into town you look at him and blink a few times.

"Harsh Stu." You chuckle shaking your head, laughing he pulls you closer, thank goodness for a bench front seat. Resting your head on his chest you watch as he drives and finds the theater and finds a spot to park and gets out and runs around to open your door.

"Your door M'Lady." He offers you a hand and you smile taking his hand as you two walk inside to get tickets, walking to the counter. "Two for Bordello of Blood." He states and pulls out his wallet to pay. The host gives him two tickets and he looks at the concession stand and walks to it. "Super Popcorn and a Super Soda." He states and hands you the large cup. "You can pick." With a large grin, you take the cup and fill it to the top, and with both hands carry it back. Looking at you he chuckled and you two make your way to Room A2 and sit in the way back.

Taking a seat you place the cup in the holder and look at the other people in the theater. People were coming in but not many, you look over at Stu and smile. "Thank you for this, it's nice getting out." You smile.

Shaking his head he smiled. "Don't thank me till the end, what time is curfew?" He asks

"Well, my mom thinks I'm out with Sid and Tatum, so she set it for Midnight." You smile.

"Midnight it is, I'll have you home by then, you can thank me then." He smirked. He looked at the screen and the others coming into the theater and looked back at the screen taking a few pieces of popcorn and a sip of soda and the lights start to dim and he lets out a manic laugh and pulls his foot to the chair and rests his arm on his knee and leans over to you and kisses the side of your head and stretches and places his arm on your shoulders. Smiling you bite your lip and watch the screen. You feel this burning in your chest, fluttering in your gut, and you want to burst into giggles.

"Contain yourself you heathen." You tell yourself as the movie beings.

A little over halfway through the movie there was a scene that was supposed to be scary, faking you jump a bit and he pulls you closer and you pretend to hide your face in his chest as he looks over at you smiling and back at the screen. "The scary part is over." he tells you. Looking up you kiss his cheek, being sure not to disturb him, he was way into this movie. Smiling he pulls you closer and leans in and kisses your lips and runs a thumb over your cheek and finishes the movie.

Upon finishing the movie the shared popcorn and the shared soda you two head out, he takes you to a place, a place that only Stu knows about, parking his car he moves to the hood and looks at you from the window. "Come watch the stars with me." He tells you. You smile nodding your head, getting out of the car you hop on the hood and lean back on your elbows looking over the stars.

"It's beautiful Stu. Where are we?" You ask.

"I can't tell you, but I can tell you that it's not as beautiful as you are." He smiles looking over your face and checking the time, one hour until midnight. He leans down and kisses you softly, cupping your face in his hands, he lays on the hood of the car and pulls you to his side. Resting your arm and head on his chest you listen to his heartbeat, and you close your eyes wanting to lay here like this forever. "I want to do things with you, but I want to try something different, maybe take things a little slow... I don't want to run you off." He admits.

"You're not going to run me off Stu, but I like the idea of slow. I'll tell you when I'm ready."

"Promise?" He asks.

"Cross my heart Stu." You smile looking over his face kissing him sweetly he holds you tightly.

"You're what I need." He whispers against your lips. "Time to get you home. Need to make an impression for mother dearest, who thinks I'm Tatum and Sid." He chuckles.

Pulling up to your house he looks over your face leaning in he kisses you and smiles. "Dinner tomorrow?" He asks.

Nodding early "My treat." You add.

"Shaking his head he looks at you. "I pay, you pay me by looking pretty." He chuckles and pats your butt on the way out after landing a kiss on your lips and drives off.

Watching with a giggle you make your way inside and your mother is in the living room watching a movie she looks over her shoulder. "You look happy, Oh, I saw Sid and Tatum, you weren't with them. Where were you Y/N?" You close your eyes and let out a slow breath.

"Mom, I was out with... Stu... I can explain everything." You tell her.

Your mother chuckles at the story and smiles hugging you. "Just don't catch yourself in a web okay? Besides, I never was a fan of Tatum. As long as he is good to you, I'm okay, and he made sure you were home before curfew." She smiled kissing your head. "Good night honey."

"Good night mom."

—————————————————————————————————

If you want to be tagged let me know. This is the first of many stories! I am also taking requests!

@luciferslittleastre @ms-ghostface

[voxmortuus]

Silly Crush | Chapter 3 - Dinner Date

Stu Macher x F!Reader

Scream (Movie) FanFic

TW: Language and Fluff, fingering in public so some smut...

Chapter 1 Silly Crush | Chapter 2 Movie Date

GIF created by @netesu

It was like clockwork. He picked you up from the driveway and you slid in. He smirked looking at you and kissed your cheek you two took off.

"So how was your day?" he asked you.

"Oh, it was great... spent the day with my dad, fuckin bastard." You grumble.

"Don't like your pops much?" He asked.

"Try at all. He left me alone while my mother was working, and he had packed all his shit and fuckin left. I was 4, home alone from 9am to about 8pm. Let me tell you, uncooked cake batter isn't good in powder form." You shake your head.

"Damn, cold piece. I'm surprised your mums even lets him come around." he gave you a concerned look.

"She does because that's the only way he'd agree to pay for what I need. He thinks buying me off with money will make it all better. That's not the case. Like ever. I didn't want the money, I never wanted the money. I wanted a father ya know?" You let out a sigh. "But whatever, enough about me. What about you? how was your day?" you ask him with a smile on your face placing your hand on his leg as he drives.

"Spent it with Billy and Sid. Tatum's kinda fallen off the face of the earth... from what I hear she had a psychotic moment on her mother and she was admitted... you should come hang out with us sometime... I'm sure Sid won't care." He added.

It wasn't that Sid would care, you knew she wouldn't, what got you waiting about it was on if she would say anything to Tatum, and then it would blow up on you like it did her mother. Biting your lip you look up at him and nod. "Sure."

"Oh good, because ummm, they're joining us for dinner." your heart sank, you felt sick to your stomach, and you grew nervous. You begin biting at your nail and he looks over at you and reaches for your hand bringing it away from your mouth kissing your hand. "Trust me, babe, it'll be okay. If not, you can punch me in the gut. Deal?" He reassures you.

Nodding your head you let out a heavy breath. "Deal." You begin playing with the hem of your skirt and bite at your lip. When he pulls into a local diner you spot Sid and Billy sitting in a booth with his arm around her shoulders and you look at Stu worried but he smiles takes your hand and drags you inside, almost proud.

Walking in you look at them and Sid smiles. "Oh hey! I haven't seen you in what feels like a long time. You doing good?" She asks you.

You smile and nod. "Yeah, I'm doing good."

Billy nods at you and looks at Stu. "You coming over tomorrow? We have a few things to-- Discuss." He states.

Stu pulls you closer and nods your head. "Yeah, I'll be there, Y/N has to go out of town for a small thing with her mom so yeah, I'll be there." He grins.

"Stu so you're like, serious with Y/N?" Sid asks. Your heart begins to pound.

Stu looks down at you and kisses you in front of the two and you flush, and feel the fluttering in your stomach and hide a bit. "Very." He grins. Offering you to slide in first. You slide in and Stu slides in next to you putting his arm around you as you begin to play with the napkin out of nerves.

"Well, this new Stu suits you, happiness suits you Stu. I'm happy." Sid replies looking at you. "And you, you seem so happy. Truly, own it." She tells you, and you can tell her sincerity when she grabs your hands looking at you. It was this gut feeling. "Don't let anyone take that from you... and I mean anyone." She states.

Looking at her you smile nodding your head. "Thanks Sid."

The waitress comes over and asks what everyone wants, Sid and Billy order, and Stu, he orders for both of you, looking over at him you smile and kiss his cheek and take a sip of the water that was poured.

After a little bit, your dinner comes and he even went as far as ordering you a chocolate milkshake, with a small mental squeal and a bite of your lip your hand reaches to his leg to give him a thanks squeeze on his thigh and dig into your chicken fingers and house-made fries. The boys start talking about some project they're working on but it's so deep in the context that you and Sid zone out mowing down on dinner and shakes.

Meanwhile, while Stu is eating and talking his hand makes its way to your leg and you bite your lip while playing with your fries, you scoot a little closer as his hand moves further up your thigh under the hem of your skirt, you clear your throat and smile looking at Sidney. "So Sid, have you heard from Tatum at all?" You ask her genuinely curious.

Her brows arch a moment, "No, last I heard she flipped shit on her mom and was put up somewhere. I'm sure she'll be back, calm I hope... but word has it her mom is moving with the family and heading out of town." She added. "The change could be good for her anyway." She added as she ate her fry and Stu's fingers started to play with the fabric of your panties.

Biting your lip and scoot a little closer to him as he pops a fry into his mouth talking to Billy about something, you've lost your focus as his fingers maneuver their way rubbing your swollen bud. Your hips naturally spread a bit as he continues to toy with you, feeling as he applies pressure, and makes his way under your panties feeling his fingers toy with your flesh you do all you can to be inconspicuous and casual while inside you are moaning and screaming. you feel like he is testing you, and you are going to do just as you're expected to do.

As he works at your flesh sliding a finger in slightly you take a sip of your drink and close your eyes. "Dinner is really good... this place is fantastic. I can't believe I've never been here." You chuckle.

"This place has been around since my grandparents were kids." Sidney chuckles taking a bite of her burger.

"For a long while." Billy adds.

"Kind of a landmark here." He states looking at you with a shit-eating grin, as his fingers work their wonderful magic. Letting out a breath you cough a bit with a chuckle as he feels how wet you are and takes advantage of that as his fingers work faster, your breathing slightly picks up as you breathe into a napkin pretending that the chicken strip was hot as you finish on his fingers. With a smile and a chuckle to his voice he looks at Billy. "Plans for the night?" He asked him taking his hand you just finished on and taking a fry and eating it licking his fingers clean and smirks.

You flush red while Billy looks at him. "I was thinking maybe going for a joy ride. You?" He asked.

"Maybe the same." He smirked looking at you.

Flushing you grin, "A joy ride sounds great."

—————————————————————————————————If you want to be tagged let me know. This is the first of many stories! I am also taking requests!

@luciferslittleastre @ms-ghostface

[voxmortuus]

Silly Crush | Chapter 5 - First Fight

Stu Macher x F!Reader

Scream (Movie) FanFic

TW: Language | Angst This is your first fight with Stu | Fluff | Smut

Chapter 1 Silly Crush | Chapter 2 Movie Date | Chapter 3 Dinner Date | Chapter 4 Joy Ride

GIF Found on Pinterest

After your night with Sidney you had gone home, not seeing Stu for a few days, he had called you, you talked, but there was something Sidney had said that really hurt, it kind of hit hard and you trusted her, she would never steer you wrong. Stu had invited you out for a drive. You had agreed, as long as it was just a drive and no one else was involved. He had agreed, promised even. With some reserve about it, you agree to the promise. Sitting on the edge of your bed you look out the window and let out a heavy breath. Your stomach hurt, and you hoped it was just some sort of accusation, like a game of telephone, just the ending message was all twisted. The thing is, what you were told you didn't honestly surprisingly have a problem with, it was the fact that he never told you about it.

Your mom calls up. "Stu's here honey."

"Okay mom, thanks!" You respond looking out the window you notice that it was just him. Letting out a small breath you grab your jacket and head down the stairs.

"Have fun, Honey. I'm pulling a double shift so I won't be home until tomorrow night." Your mom calls out to you.

"Thanks, Mom." You give a faux smile and head out the door. Getting in the vehicle you look at Stu and then look out the window.

"What's wrong?" He asks you, genuinely worried.

You close your eyes and look at Stu. "Why didn't you tell me about the bad things you do Stu?" you ask him.

He furrows his brow. "What bad things?" He asks.

"Well word has it you're involved in some really bad dark shit Stu, like you were involved with a few murders? The fuck is that?" you state.

Stu lets out a chuckle. "Are you kidding me?"

"No."

"I would ne--" You stop him.

"Stu, it all makes sense, your late nights with Billy, you vanishing at times, your coincidence in times with when bad things have happened. I'm not mad that you're doing them. I'm mad that you didn't come to me." You tell him.

Stu stays quiet, not quite sure how to process this. He goes to your favorite spot. You keep quiet, fidgeting with the fabric of your jeans, the rip in the thigh, the loose strings, rolling them between your fingers. You lean your head against the window, the rain starting to pick up. He pulls into the abandoned lot and shuts off the car and looks at you.

"You assume." He states.

"Yes, I assume, and it adds up. I'm not blind Stu." you retort.

"If I was doing bad things do you really think I would want to expose that? I'm not stupid!" He kind of snaps.

"I never said you were stupid Stu, don't snap at me." you let out a low growl and get out of the car and go sit on the hood of the car. You look down at your boots as they start getting wet from the rain, your jeans speckled, turning darker black, your jacket sounding with the pitter-pat of the rain. He gets out of the car.

"Don't do that!" He yells.

"Do what?!" You yell back standing up looking over at him.

"Get out! Walk away!" He stated. "You didn't talk to me for a whole week! Don't treat me like I've done wrong! I haven't wronged you Y/N! I never would!" He adds.

"Then be honest with me!" You demand. You're to the point of tears.

"I am being honest!" He snapped.

"Take me home Stu. If you're not going to be honest with me than this just isn't going to work out." you tell him, your jaw clenched. But he refuses to get in the car, shaking his head.

"No." He stated.

"Then I'm walking." You state it wouldn't be the first time you've walked it. You start to walk past him and he growls as you pass.

"Stop!" He demands but you keep walking. You weren't going to tolerate the lies. He looks at you as you walk away, watching your hips sway. He growls at himself again shaking his head. "I've killed 3 people. I liked it, I liked it a lot. There! Now you know the truth."

You stop walking and let out a soft breath. Looking down you turn around and look at Stu. "Why didn't you tell me?!" You demand the answer.

"I was afraid. I was scared you wouldn't love me anymore! I was afraid you'd go to the police, and chances are you will." He starts walking to you. "I was afraid to lose you, I love you. I don't want to lose you. You're the only one who seems to truly understand me. You don't judge me... you don't question me." He states as he approaches you cupping your face. "I love you Y/N, losing you would break me." He tells you.

Looking over his face you start to cry, and here's the kicker, you don't know why, you're angry because he lied to you, he wasn't honest and he didn't tell you from the beginning. You're hurt because he was scared, and you're madly in love and don't like the fact that he was afraid. You look at him. "I love you. I don't care what you've done, next time, take me with you." You tell him. "I'm not joking." You tell him.

Leaning down he kisses you deeply. You wrap your arms around him. "My mom's not home. Let's go back to my place, she won't be there until tomorrow night." You tell him.

He takes your hand and brings you back to the car, both of you soaking wet. He drives back. By the time you arrive at your house, your mother is gone. She left you a note with 50 on the fridge telling you that she loves you to order out that she won't be home for a few days because of having something to do at the hospital but she will try and stop home tomorrow night to check on you. You and Stu kick off your boots leaving them at the door.

You take Stu's hand and bring him to your room and he looks at you and then looks at the blue dog and the goldfish and smiles. Leaning in he kisses you deeply picking you up he places you on the bed and climbs on top of you kissing you more. You flip him over and straddle him taking your shirt off. His hands move up your sides, over your curves as he undoes your pants. Looking over your face he smiles. "You're so beautiful." He smiles.

You smile back looking at him. "Shut up." You chuckle as he grabs at you and turns you over back on your back and takes off your pants and slides off your panties disrobing himself he climbs on top of you and looks over your face. You reach into your top drawer and hand him a rubber. Smirking he unwraps it slipping it on before he climbs back on top of you and leans in teasing you with the tip before he gives you a soft thrust and kisses you. Moaning into his mouth you let out a soft gasp aching into him slightly your hips meeting his. Though it doesn't take long before you are on top of him riding him.

The grunts, groans, moans, and smells all hit you not holding back your hips move and buck like riding a bull and your nails dig into his chest as you hit you peek. "Come on my cock baby, come on." He beckons you. Without any hesitation, you slam your hips down and let out a heavy moan and you keep going, waiting for him to finish, only to finish again.

After a few hours and a couple rounds, you look at him and smile. "Pizza and movies?" You ask him. Nodding his head.

"I think that sounds like a wonderful idea. Maybe we'll talk about the next victim..." He smirks.

Nodding your head. "Okay." You grin and wrap in your top sheet and head downstairs to call in dinner.

Taglist: @luciferslittleastre @ms-ghostface @ginger-called-beth