Tumgik
#to be able to transform into a titan really makes for an interesting analysis
rivangel · 6 months
Note
You think the tunnels were made to shelter from the rumbling? Or did they explain why they built it? I forget
the underground city “”according to old documents”” is a failed project that was supposed to be where humanity just… lived so as to not worry about titans anymore. but the plan fell through.
no reason given lol. maybe that was the plan during the exodus eldians took to paradis in the first place before king fritz constructed the walls.
either way, the underground exists in before the fall, which is (i believe) 60 years or at least several decades before the events of the main story. the underground then was definitely better in that it wasn’t so run down/dirty, but it was still a major haven for criminal activity.
king fritz never had any plans of actually executing the rumbling, so i think that it was the first scramble the eldians made for shelter right after fritz’s vow of nonviolence and the end of the great titan war.
in my mind to get all thematic and metaphorical, i think it’s fitting for the underground to be that kind of place as a sort of pillar to fear, shame, and cowardice :P
4 notes · View notes
marmarparadoxa · 4 years
Text
Hange Zoë - understanding and inquisitiveness
Tumblr media
I want to dedicate this post to an Hange character analysis and I think that the one above is one the first yet one the most representative moments in which we get to know Hange.
This is set in chapter 25, and it shows us an Eren’s memory of the month that he has spent with Levi squad, prior to the mission in which they encounter the Female Titan. During this period, Hange, assisted by Levi, sets out to start experimenting on Eren and his titan transformations. As opposed to the others’ concern and reluctance to experiment, we see her firmly stating the importance of doing it. “If there’s something we don’t know, we should find out. It’s absolutely worth putting our lives on the line.” I think that it is one of the greatest quotes from SNK and one of the most representative of the spirit of the Survey Corps. Up to this moment, we have seen a lot of soldiers willing to give their lives and dedicate their hearts in order to reconquer humanity’s freedom. In order to do that, they are ready to kill the bulk of titans, risking their lives out of the walls. However, none of them has appeared to be interested in understanding who and what actually the enemy is. They just continue to slicing titans napes. And then there’s Hange. Contrary to the other members of the Survey Corps, her focus is not restricted to kill the titans. She tries to look at things from a different point of view. She tries to really understand the nature of the enemy, and the truth about their world, she doesn’t think that just slicing titans napes is enough. She tries to understand what they are actually facing, because she understands that this way is their best chance to succeed and to win the battle against the titans. When no one else does, she put all of her efforts to gain the necessary knowledge, even if at first sight these efforts don’t seem to bring an immediate result, even if the other SC soldiers don’t support her and don’t understand the importance of this (except of course for Erwin, Moblit and Levi). I think that just this is so admirable. She is the one who really tries to augment their knowledge, even just a little bit, in order to improve their situation.
Hange’s ability to analyze things and her scientific way of thinking
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Hange is able to look into what stands in front of her, and she analyzes it like no one else can. She notices that, considering their size, titans couldn’t stand and move like they do. She points out how Eren titan’s body came up from nothing, and she formulates hypothesis about that. She conducts various experiments on the titans they manage to capture, even dangerous ones, even others when she actually tortures them, but still (!) empathizes with them, as shown by her suffering expression in inflicting them so much pain. 
Tumblr media
However, she does all of it, because all of the knowledge they can gain from those methodically conducted experiments could bring them a little bit closer toward the discovery of the truth about the titans, and, extensively, the truth about this world. She has really a scientific way a thinking: she gathers facts and data, she makes hypothesis and tries to elaborate theories that can scientifically, rationally explain those data, and then she always elaborates new experiments, always furthering their understanding of things, always gathering new data. All of the little observations that she has made, all the theories and possible explanations with which she came out, then, lead her to wonder about the nature of their reality. She has questioned the nature of their phenomenal understanding of the world, she hypothesizes that the true nature of things could be something ontologically different from what they experience and think to know about the world.
Tumblr media
As the story continues, they discover a lot of things. The walls are made up of giant titans with their endured skin. Hange, together with Armin, is the one who actually hypothesizes it, and also comes to verify it, picking up a shard of the hardened skin of the Female Titan, having noticed that it is not evaporating, and a fragment of the walls, and analyzing them in order to compare them with a microscope, up to discover that they have the same physical structure.
Then, they discover the true nature of titans, their human nature, and again Hange is the one who realizes that: putting together what they know about the situation and Ragako village, she comes up with that and makes the harsh, astonishing conclusion. However, I think that this has come not totally as a novelty for Hanji. What makes me think this is, first of all, her approach to titans during her experiments. She gives them a name, and she talks with them (not only for experimental purposes). She cries and screams when she conducts pain experiments on them. It is like Hange, without even realizing it (or maybe being fully aware of what she was doing?) has always treated them as they were conscious creatures. And of course she knows that at least one titan has shown sign of intelligence, namely speaking intelligible words and showing sign of remorse for having killed a human, as we see in the Ilse’s Notebook OVA. And then the quote about the difference between what we see and what actually exists. It is possible that Hange may have sensed that titans are not the mindless creatures came up from nothing that they seem, that they could be something really different.
I was also astonished by her sharpness when she suggests what is actually inside titans napes, how she is immediately able to link the human origin of titans with their weak point and explain that so well.
Tumblr media
There are many other times in which her insights, or better hypothesis, have informed the SC how to resolve seemingly obscure situations, as for example when she suggested to Erwin and the rest of the SC that Reiner and Bertholdt, escaped with Eren and Ymir, had probably reached the nearest Titan forest in order to rest, or when she hypothesized that, given the strange and suspicious story of the Reiss chapel, kidnapped Eren and Historia might have been conducted there, so Levi gives the order of heading to the chapel, trusting Hange’s judgement.
Also, she is the one who, having rediscovered the technology which has been hidden till then by the the First Interior Squad, devised new weapons that significantly improve the survival chance and power of attack of the SC, namely the “Executioner from Hell” and the “Thunder Spear”, suggesting that she has also notable engineering creativity.
Hence, there are a lot of things and victories of the Survey Corps that wouldn’t have been possible without the bright contribute of Hange’s intellect and intuitions. Her ability to analyze and make deductions from the data they have, applied to battle and titan issues have lead them to resolve complex situations many times. She is indeed the character with the highest score in intelligence in the SNK universe (together with Zeke), with a 11/10 (source Attack on Titan guidebook):
Tumblr media
Her infinite curiosity and love of knowledge
For the sake of humanity, in order to reconquer the freedom that they have lost, she has always devoted herself to apply her bright mind to the SC cause. However, what I really love about her is her genuine curiosity and inquisitiveness in understanding what she sees and in discover new things about the world that she shows in every moment of her life, above what is needed in terms of battle strategies and titan issues. She is so curious and amazed by every discovery that she could make.
She’s in love with the process of discovering new things.
In the Smartpass interview, she said that, if humanity will be finally liberated from titans, she would like to research vegetation outside the walls, or study about humanity’s past.
In the SNK Short story The Library That’s Covered In Dust, while the other soldiers are resting, we see her merrily searching through the books of the library of the old castle where the SC soldiers are taking shelter from the rain, and then starting wondering, expressing her thoughts to Levi, about those ancient manuscripts written in letters they can’t read, and how they suggest the existence of an extinct civilization. It amuses me that, while the other soldiers are just taking rest during the mission, Hange instead is all caught up in searching books and making speculations about what they may contain and extinct civilizations.
Another precious moment is when they finally arrive at the sea. I just love how, at the very first encounter with the ocean, Hange’s just being Hange: she notices sea cucumbers in the water and, despite the concerned Levi’s warning, she grabs them, because she just can’t help herself xD:
Tumblr media
Then, about one year later, for the first time the SC encounters Marleyans, and also gets to know Yelena and Onyankopon. Hence Onyankopon, in order to prepare them to build a port for the arrive of other Marleyans, and improve Paradis technology, which has remained backward due to their isolation from the rest of the world, starts to explain what a port and all of the other things are, and this is Hange’s reaction:
Tumblr media Tumblr media
She immediately realizes what a port is and how they can use it, even before Onyankopon has time to say it. +
Tumblr media Tumblr media
She is just so amazed for all the new things that they are learning. Despite the burden of being the new commander and all the responsibilities that come with that, she still manages to get excited and her enthusiasm is so precious. Of course, she knows how important it is for them, the Paradis people, to know the outside world, if they want to start a communication with it and be prepared for any outcome it may have (and we know how things went...).
She truly acknowledges the importance of understanding things, and how it is not possible to live in this world if one doesn’t try to comprehend it, a way of thinking that the Survey Corps has always embodied, but also if people don’t allow others to know and understand who they are:
Tumblr media
I think that Hange’s way of thinking truly represent, in her special way, what the spirit of the Survey Corps has always been about: to research, explore the outside world and gain knowledge, try to understand things (and let others understand you). This is what, eventually, will make you free in this world.
(This post wasn’t meant to be a comprehensive analysis, I had rather focused on Hange’s intellect and on her curious, bright, rational, scientific yet full of empathy and intuition approach to the world. I think that this is one of her most distinctive traits, and one of the reasons why I love her so much).
Bonus:
Happy Hange greeting a car (she’s such a cutie ^^)
Tumblr media
1K notes · View notes
dirtydragonthoughts · 2 years
Text
Valentine's Day Special (IDW2 Special Issue 1 Review)
Pitch: Bookish Glyph wants a challenge—to do work for xeno-relations, not just data analysis. Athletic Tap-Out needs a challenge—his boxing career isn't working out so well. When one mission presents both of them a chance to meet new challenges head-on, will they be able to lift each other up to the task or will they just get in each other's way?
Review
We take another break from the action of the main line comic to take a little step back in time. The Valentine's Day Special (omg, they actually did a Valentine's Day Special for Transformers! skwee!) consists of two stories, both of which seem like they take place before the first issue of the main comic.
Overall thoughts: I think IDW really played it "safe" with these two stories, and as a result they aren't quite as fun as I feel like a Valentine's Day special issue should have been... If that makes sense. However, I enjoyed both stories for what they were. One of them I enjoyed a lot more than the other, which I'll get into below.
The first story is the "main" one, starring Tap-Out and Glyph. Glyph finally gets her chance to do the xenolinguistics work she's been wanting to do for ages, and Tap-Out comes with her as her bodyguard on the expedition.
I admit these two had some chemistry, for all that I wasn't familiar with either one. However, the story was rather silly and lackluster. The author was obviously trying to shoehorn in a way for both bots to get to do what they enjoy on the planet (Glyph in doing language research, and Tap-Out in punching things) but the conclusion is what really killed it for me. If the author had come up with a succinct way of explaining why violence was how you got through to the planet's natives, this story would have been just fine. I think the story failed in that goal.
That said, I absolutely adored Lawrence's depiction of the furry little aliens.
I enjoyed the second story a lot more. I don't think it ever would have occurred to me to ship Cosmos with Blast Off, but their growing friendship and banter really worked in this story. I think Cosmos being such an awkward little guy helped; the way he keeps berating himself for saying something stupid (only to have Blast Off think it's fine) was a serious case of "feels familiar" to me.
Overall I enjoyed this special issue. However, I am sad that I don't think we'll get to see any further interaction between Cosmos and Blast Off in this continuity.
Favourite Panel
Ok, half a panel, but I really do love these fuzzy little guys.
Tumblr media
Culture
Cosmos and Blast Off talk about vacation spots. Monacus and Eurythma are mentioned.
Cosmos asks Blast Off what it's like to carry passengers. Blast Off says it's warm, heavy, and unpleasant.
Tumblr media
Planet
It's interesting that Glyph is being permitted to do the first contact for a new species. She'd submitted her proposal ages before it was approved, so Cybertron had known about this planet for a long time. And they basically just sent two people to contact the native species, instead of doing it with any sort of pomp. Seems weird to me, but (shrug) ok.
Tumblr media
However, Glyph does try to speak to the natives as soon as they land, so they must know something about the aliens. Hmm.
Physiology
While on the ship travelling to the planet, Tap-Out makes sure to keep up his exercises to stay in top shape. Servo atrophy and piston burn are two problems he mentions he's trying to avoid.
Tumblr media
Politics and History
It was mentioned in the main comic, but Tap-Out's career as a gladiator was ended when Sentinel Prime shut down the arenas. So Tap-Out is basically out of a job.
There is a "Space" division for Cybertron Security, of which Cosmos is a chief. His main duty is protecting the inner moon from "threats." (Although based on this comic and earlier ones in the main line, his job seems mostly to be clearing space junk and rescuing Gears... and he could do nothing against the titan that attacked the moon.)
Final Thoughts
Overall, an enjoyable issue. I kind of wish that the main story had been flipped to be the "backup" story and the Cosmos/Blast Off story had been expanded on. But I still enjoyed it a lot, and I wish they'd explore interpersonal relationships between bots more!
👍
2 notes · View notes
sepublic · 4 years
Note
Hey I love you reading your theories and analysis, they've contributed a lot to my own headcanons and views on the characters so I wanted to get your thoughts on a in universe reason why Amity might be the only outlier for the name of her family. You have Edric: prosperous ruler, Emira most commonly meaning princess or leader, Odalia: wealth and fortune, Aladar: noble, eminent, glorious, and then you have Amity for friendship.
           It really means a lot to me to hear about this! Honestly, I’m just another fan, speculating on things, maybe projecting a few ideas and opinions of what I’d like to see onto the show… But it’s very touching to hear this, thank you so much! As for the subject of your ask…
           Well, there WAS that one brief idea I aired a while back… Basically, I considered the possibility that Amity was literally conceived for a sole purpose, and/or was chosen by Odalia and Alador to be a glorified ‘offering’ to Emperor Belos…
           The thing about members of the Emperor’s Coven is, we don’t know much, if anything, about their social lives outside of their jobs! And that’s assuming they even HAVE one… The most we see is Lilith’s bedroom, which based on the architecture is possibly within Belos’ castle, but we can’t really say for sure! Not to mention this was from a background that was never included in the episode, and as Head of the Emperor’s Coven, Lilith would understandably have a more intimate relationship with its headquarters given the tasks she oversees.
           And amidst the speculation of EC witches going a physical transformation upon receiving the Emperor’s Brand, in order to further conform them to Belos’ standard… And again, it makes me wonder if Amity is even going to remain in contact with her family. If ANY of the Emperor’s Coven witches do… Again, there’s Lilith, but she doesn’t exactly have much family to go back to, to begin with it seems! And even if she DID, it’s worth noting that she’s Head of the Emperor’s Coven, and like Wrath and Kikimora… It seems that having a high position even amongst Belos’ enforcers garners you a little special individuality, just to hammer it in just how much MORE you are compared to the rest!
           So again; All speculation. But it makes me wonder if standard members of the Emperor’s Coven basically sacrifice their previous life and cut off all ties with it to become an enforcer of Belos. This potentially means no relationships, no adopting kids because even if it’s not expressly forbidden, you just don’t have the time and resources for that… etc.
           And given how big a deal Odalia and Alador place on the concept of the ‘Blight’ family name, it makes sense that they’d want to have grandchildren and continue the lineage, right? And… that’s possibly where Emira and Edric come into play…!
           What I’m suggesting is that Emira and Edric are allowed to get away with things, because Odalia was always okay with that sort of thing… But with Amity, she’s subject to extra scrutiny because she’s basically being given to Belos as an offering; Like, here, we raised one of our kids for the sole purpose of serving your will, doesn’t this show how loyal we are? Considering how young Belos’ reign is, he’s likely looking for witches he can trust, and considering the kind of person Odalia likely is (I can’t say much for Alador especially since he was ‘interesting’ for Dana to write and was an outsider to the family), it’s possible she saw this as her chance to schmoozy up to the Emperor, gain his favor, etc.!
           But the thing is… Belos’ standards are HIGH, and Odalia knows it. Maybe she never joined the Emperor’s Coven herself because she wasn’t skilled enough, because her talents lied elsewhere and the system recognized this, and/or she didn’t want to sacrifice her individuality… So why not prove just how loyal she is, just how useful the Blights are, by presenting a perfect child to the Titan’s Messenger! A shining example of the Blight family!
           And if I AM correct in that members of the Emperor’s Coven basically dedicate their entire existence to Belos, then… This means that Amity won’t be able to continue the Blight lineage. But Emira and Edric will… And because THEY’re not the ones who will have Belos breathing down their necks, they can get away with making more mistakes because they’re not trying to impress the emperor, and likewise they’re not trying to get into his prestigious coven! So Amity is subject to a special double-standard because she’s the one who will be ‘sacrificed’ to Belos to make a good image of the family, while Ed and Em are given a lot more leniency!
           This DOES raise the question, if I am correct… Did Odalia and Alador give Amity a different theme-naming, because they knew this? Because they KNEW from the beginning that this third child wouldn’t actually grow up to be a part of the family, that they’d say goodbye once she turned eighteen –maybe even younger- and sacrifice her Blight identity to become an enforcer of Belos? Did they give Amity a more ‘mundane’ name, because even if she was technically chosen to represent the family, by the end of the day she’d be revoking her connection to them anyway, so why bother building one up?
           Is THAT one of many reasons why Odalia and Alador are so cold- Because they know there’s no point getting attached to Amity, if she’s going to leave them in the end and prioritize Belos over them!? And BECAUSE they’re purposefully colder and more detached towards Amity, that just causes Odalia and Alador to act crueler towards her, and so on and so forth in a self-feeding cycle.
           Again; The fact that this was Amity’s name, which was likely decided before she was born or right when she was… Indicates that, if there WAS an in-universe reason (and the differentiation isn’t simply meta), she was intended to be separate from the rest. Whether this was a sign of rejection from Odalia because Amity had her brown hair prominent from birth… I can’t say for sure, because she seemed willing to accept Alador!
          But we don’t know exactly what his deal is… And regardless, Odalia seemed intent on making Amity more like a ‘traditional’ Blight by having her hair dyed green, and forcing Amity to uphold the family standards. So why undermine this effort by giving her a different type of name, unless she changed her mind afterwards, and by then the name had stuck?
           Plus, if Odalia DID make a point of having Amity be ‘more like a Blight’, then how does this fit into the idea of her and Alador having a purposeful disconnect from her compared to them and the Twins, if they knew Amity’s identity as an Emperor’s Coven witch would be prioritized in the end? Unless of course, it was to better signify to Belos that Amity is representative of the Blights as the most talented, obedient enforcer… So Green Hair is a must! But then, why give Amity a different kind of name, unless there was a specific balance to be had between ‘Setting Amity aside as different because she’s going to be gone anyway’ and ‘Making her representative of the Blight family to Belos’.
           This is just a crazy theory though, with not too much evidence. It comes solely from the assumption that Emperor’s Coven witches don’t maintain lives outside of their roles, which while I wouldn’t be shocked if that were the case… There’s nothing outright in favor of this assumption, either. It’s just that- An assumption, which I then used as the basis for a fairly outlandish idea that while not unreasonable given what we’ve seen of Odalia and Alador, doesn’t have much evidence pointing in that direction otherwise.
           Because, like you said; If there IS an in-universe reasoning for this naming, then it suggests that Odalia and Alador had intentions for Amity to be set apart from the rest of the family, even before she could’ve shown any prowess or skill as a witch! And while the Oracle Coven’s exist DOES allude to visions of the future being a thing… Amity’s name suggests her ‘separation’ from the family was always planned and not in reaction to any particular ‘deviancy’ from the Blight identity.
          Which again, leads back to the speculation of why Amity was chosen to join the Emperor’s Coven, but not Emira and Edric… If they simply proved too defiant to mold by that point, or if their talents in Illusions had already been noted by the system, thereby guaranteeing a place within the Illusionist Coven and NOT the EC as would’ve been desired…. Etc. Because as I said before, unless Odalia and Alador looked into the future (which again isn’t too out of the question thanks to Oracle magic), they would’ve only had brown hair to differentiate Amity by that point, and it doesn’t make sense for Odalia to more or less condemn Amity to a completely different fate and identity for something her own husband has.
           And THAT leads me to my final verdict, of… Either there IS a reason we’ll learn more of later in the future, or there is no reason in-universe, and it’s a purely meta decision! Just as there is no in-universe reason why Amity parallels Luz, but from a thematic standpoint, this connection IS very much real and one of the more meaningful and developed concepts this show has to offer! Personally my assumption is that, when it comes to the name at least, the difference doesn’t exist in-universe and it’s a purely meta thing… But as always, you can never say for sure! Especially since we still have Season 2 and so much more to see from Odalia and Alador, no less!
           (This makes me wonder how Alador reacted to the hair-color change… Is he an ‘outsider’ who was fully indoctrinated into the idea of upholding the Blight identity? Is HIS hair dyed green, too? Did he willingly subject himself to this, as a dark parallel to Luz and her relationship with Amity… With Alador being unconditionally selfless to a self-destructive degree, willingly forgoing his identity to meet Odalia’s standards, potentially because he really wanted to be with her and/or didn’t want to stir up trouble with her parents by not meeting their standards?)
83 notes · View notes
yaboylevi · 5 years
Note
What about this chapter did you not like? love your art btw ❤️
Thanks!
Sorry for the wait, I wanted to read the official chapter and wait for a bit to see if my feelings changed (spoiler: they didn't).
It would be way faster to list the few things I enjoyed but alas.
VERY negative opinions under the cut. Seriously, if you liked the chapter, don't read this, I don't want to spoil your fun or upset you. I didn't bother to write this in a respectful tone, it's not an analysis, it's just me venting. That being said, if you guys read this ignoring my warning and get upset, it'll be your fault and responsibility, yeah.
The Annie's father stuff was okay, though I hope it's gonna be explained why he was the only one in Liberio running against the flow of the screaming crowd.
Then we get Reiner being pathetic once again, I am so tired of this. What's his purpose in the story aside from killing people, being a nuisance and or dead weight to others and feeling sorry for himself? I would've appreciated if he had had some introspection on how his rushed plan was partially the cause for Porco's death and Falco's transformation (and all the other deaths bc Zeke would've never screamed in Shiganshina if Reiner hadn't pushed for another attack there). But anyway if he'd had introspection, it would've been about self-pity and NEVER growth because he seems unable to have that, so I would've disliked it anyway. 
If I wasn't already rolling my eyes this hard at Reiner, then I would've started at Gabi. She's all over the place and I guess it's understandable since she is a kid and also deeply shocked and in pain. I understand it. But I don't like how Isayama made her go from despair, to murder instinct, to calm and collected in 2 pages. It's just ???? Then we have the Eren parallel and I groaned out loud. Whatever its meaning is. It's just forced.
One of the things I hated this chapter for and that I'm becoming so annoyed at in general lately, is that EVERYTHING parallels something that has already happened, and I don't understand if Isayama thinks he's being smart or if it has some deeper meaning like "oh see, history repeats itself!! wow!! a concept that is not being repeated ad nauseam in the series, not at all!! /s". I don't need it to be shoved into my face.
Idk. Also Reiner, of course, being safe in a house amongst titan territory...of...course...
Then the 104th scene. Ugh. Jean's delusion is so annoying. One moment he's rational, the other is like "muuuuu ereh is doing this for us!!! we couldn't do anything!!!", then he's rational again. Maybe if they had paid attention to Eren, and didn't only take into consideration stupid ideas that would've never worked for 4 years, maaaybe yeah, this wouldn't be happening. Who knows. I'm just tired of the 104th whining about their situation. I understand where they're coming from, their feelings, etc, I understand it's a crazy and emotional situation and all, but we already have SO MANY CHAPTERS about it, it's time to move on at least with the plot. It's just so pathetic and annoying. It makes me angry how he's basically trying to avoid responsibility or rationalize genocide like all the Eren goat stans in the fandom. I hate this mentality so much. "if they disappear, so will all the hatred! Do we really have to stop him?" JESUS CHRIST JEAN..............yikes
And then of course they (and Isayama) had to ruin chapter 108.
Then Jean also had the guts to say they should kill a kid so they can revive a commander, just bc he's too scared to take the reins of the situation. Again, I understand the struggle, it's the same as Hange afterall, it's just very, very ugly how he didn't even waver. Connie's been acting irrational, and he's been swept up by his anger for a while now, so I understand his development. Plus I find it more relatable to wanting to make a big sacrifice for someone you love, rather than someone you (think you) need. But Jean???? wtf. He doesn't even think back on the sin he was willing to commit, he isn't ashamed.
Armin as well doesn't even care that it's a kid they're talking about, he's only strategizing. And here's another annoying point: he's able to make these calculations now but when it comes to Eren his brain freezes and he becomes a delusional kid. Where were his brains when he had to think up of ways to negotiate with the world? Anyway, I get it, it's because Eren's his childhood friend and family. I am just so tired of seeing this again and again, and again. We've been stuck on this for over a year... Nothing has changed, they're just dejectedly going back and forth on their opinions and feelings. Really goes to show that Eren was the real heart of their group...
Connie flying away from the battlefield, effectively splitting again the povs we need to follow is...big yikes.
Parallel to Trost, parallel to Serumbowl. Yeah wow so interesting.
Nile dying so quick like that was also underwhelming. And it was unnecessarily cruel, imo, that as a titan he tried to kill children when as a person he was so sweet with kids (except with Eren, of course...).
The Gabi-Sasha parallel left me a bit confused. On the one hand, I don't like the killer being paralleled to the murdered. But on the other hand, I understand why that is [/inserts meta that i don't care about writing]. The Kaya-Gabi moments were also cute + Nicolo's little speech was nice, though a bit awkward, imo. I bitterly laughed at Gabi finally admitting that she mindlessly killed people just to be praised. At least she can better herself from now on! If only her cousin could take his self-pity and do something to change himself with it, but no, he just wants to change others or run away (and this is why i don't like reiner anymore).
Shadis saving these ungrateful kids was pretty cool.
I felt bad for Yelena, I want to see more of her (and maybe Mikasa+Louise), but instead, we have Jean vs Floch angst and I'm already sleeping, because I care so little about both of them.
Isayama painting Jean as a cool leader is just embarrassing when moments before he was pathetically whining and trying to kill a child (to which there was no setup, especially comparing it to the setup for Connie's plot thread. The last we saw of Jean with a kid was him wondering if he hesitated in killing the Cart because of Falco 15 chapters ago...and that was a compelling doubt but I guess he hadn't hesitated at the time, after all lol). The pages dedicated to the killing of the titans were boring, occupying space for nothing imo. Glossing over them would've sufficed, there could've just been the Pixis stuff, and it would've been fine. Which, btw, made me laugh a little in retrospect, because Armin is once again involved in the death of a Commander. Oh well.
I also didn't like that mini-flashback with Eren&Pixis. I guess Isayama wants to ruin every single nice moment Eren had with other people, because Eren is soooo so so bad now uwu, for no good reason, and it's only his fault right? people were nice to him and look at how he repaid them uwu. Big yikes for me.
I expected more from that Louise panel because it made me go [EYES EMOJI], but I guess I'll have to wait.
It's also unbelievable that NO ONE IN THE WHOLE STORY has thought of stopping Floch, when last time they arrested him, so technically why would they even leave him running around NOW? It's beyond me. Do they have a brain?
As for the basement conversation with Gabi, I hope that "I won't give up on Falco" panel + Armin looking at Gabi thoughtfully will start a "We can't give up on Eren" mindset for the 104th, but I doubt it's gonna be handled in a non-pathetic way, considering how's been done as of late.
Gabi screaming to talk to Eren was also very embarrassing from a reader pov (well, my pov). Because she was RIGHT THERE when EMA talked last time, and she should know that would most likely not work (I guess she's talking out of desperation but still...ppl be like "yeah!! they should talk to ErEn!1 why didn't they think of it!?!?!" and I mean it's probably gonna come down to that if the final audio is of any indication...I just find the presentation of this concept awkward and forced). 
I really disliked most of Gabi's part, even though she's a character I have learned to enjoy. I guess what shined through in this chapter is exactly what I don't like about how Isayama uses Gabi's character: it seems like she's just there as a fast-paced mini representation of the story themes, so she's just an instrument to the story. Sometimes I feel like she's a real character, sometimes I feel she's just a tool for the story and the themes.
Armin's reaction to hearing about Annie is...I don't know. aruani has been one of my first ships and I used to be obsessed, but this is just awkward and forced, just like the previous aruani scene that made me angry at Armin. I don't even understand if Armin's shocked, scared or happy. All of these don't make sense to me, because I have no clue what he even expects from her.
Annie's release from the crystal happened in an unexpected way which i appreciated, though I would've liked it more if she had decided to get out on her own. But it depends on if she was stuck in there or if she was still willingly escaping from reality. If she was stuck, I will love this a lot more, because basically Eren set her free.
Also, Eren's radio podcast was longer I guess ("Eren said he would undo all the hardening"), and I wonder why we couldn't hear it all. Sigh.
In general, the "theme thread" of the chapter (adults & kids) felt really pushed in our face. I appreciate when things are a bit more subtle, this just came off as...boring, because every scene made me go "well, of fucking course this scene would end like this...". The only tense moment was the Connie part, let's be real.
And yeah, my perception may be also partially because I am so tired of no Eren pov and "eren is the evil, evil villain" rhetoric, so maybe I will appreciate this chapter more once we get his pov at the end of the story (bc i have no illusions left that this won't happen anytime before the finishing line). For now, I'm just frustrated because I didn't care about ANY of the things that went down in this chapter. Like, okay, let's move on, ffs.
Everything felt forced and contrived, like, Isayama must know that nobody cares about this stuff that much and everyone would prefer to see literally anything else amongst Eren, Historia, Levi&Hange, the Colossals. Hell, imagine if this chapter didn't have Annie at the end. That was the only thing that made this chapter barely worth the read for me. I hope the next one will at least follow Connie and Annie, if I can't get any of the other things that interest me.
29 notes · View notes
goodguyjean · 8 years
Text
Some Thoughts Jean’s Character Development (Prompted by the HS AU).
CW: Bullying and the molestation scene.
So, in keeping with the rhetorical principle of kairos (timeliness of an argument), I think the time is ripe for a (re?)consideration of Jean Kirstein’s presentation in the Attack on Titan manga. I noticed that a bit of a discussion about Jean’s character popped up in the wake of the High School AU fake preview for volume 22 (one which I’ve already participated in a few times) and since we’ve just had a massive time-skip in the series to kick off the final arc, I feel like we can examine the development of the characters from the fall of Wall Maria to their journey to the ocean as discreet units. In fact, it may be useful to look at where some of them have ended up and how they got there before launching off into the new arc, so if you like what I have to say about Jean please send me suggestions for more character analysis like this!
The reasons I want to talk about Jean are twofold. The first is obviously personal interest. I’m discussing Jean regardless of whether or not anyone else really wants to read it because I find his portrayal and development intriguing xD. But my jumping off point is a little bit more specific, to come back to the question of kairos. The High School AU, however silly or tongue-in-cheek, has raised questions in fandom about whether or not Jean is a bully in canon or would be one in an AU that I would like to address.
Although I’m taking an AU’s depiction of Jean as the starting point of my inquiry, this post is pretty much only concerned with the canon material of the manga (not the anime: I have already discussed discrepancies between the manga and the anime’s portrayals of Jean here). Even though Isayama drew the High School AU and therefore it probably has value as meta, I feel strongly that the Jean depicted therein has little in common with Jean in the manga. I’ve been attempting to follow up on an interview which was mentioned to me, where Isayama supposedly said that in any other universe Jean would be one of Armin’s bullies (I’d appreciate any help in locating it! So far I’ve only been able to find other people mentioning it in their posts but no source). I find this kind of blanket statement on Isayama’s part a little bit more troubling—how did he come to understand his character this way? I guess it doesn’t matter to a certain extent, because authorial intent or understanding is by no means the end-all be-all of interpretation—and therefore I would like to further explore the question of Jean’s canonical presentation to attempt to answer the question: is Jean Kirstein ever, at any point, a bully?
My answer, as you may be able to guess from the fact that my blog is Jean themed, is a pretty hard no. In fact, within canon I would argue that Jean is one of the more empathetic and morally astute characters, and that the development he undergoes is less of a complete ethical realignment and more of an adjustment of his goals and strategies. He doesn’t begin cruel and transform into a kinder person; he starts off as astute but self-centered and his development revolves around using his skills to protect and champion others rather than just himself.
I would say Jean actually starts off as a bit of an outsider among the 104th (a facet of his personality that the original draft of the HS AU actually preserves) and that Eren generally has more clout than him; in fact, trainee Eren would probably not be a compelling target for a bully, all things considered. Jean’s fights with him don’t seem to come from a place of maintaining dominance over someone weaker and instead take the form of pretty mutual brawling. Indeed, he may be at a bit of a disadvantage when fighting against Eren physically, as demonstrated in this scene.
Tumblr media
Chapter 3. Jean is “punching up” here, as it were. After a battle of words, Eren and Jean hit each other simultaneously and initiate a fight in which, according to Reiner, the odds may be slightly against Jean. Mikasa also implies Eren picked this fight after she intervenes. Also I just noticed that dude giving peace signs in the far left corner lol.
All in all, Jean is never depicted as picking on someone weaker than himself to establish dominance at pretty much any point in the series, as far as I can remember (in fact, he’s the only one to stand up to bullying in some situations, as will be discussed below). Isayama shows Jean hassling Marco, teasing Sasha, and picking fights with Eren (the first of whom has some pretty naive worldviews and the latter of whom give as good as they get and even start said fights). Jean’s so irritating to Eren--at least in the manga, I know they nerf him considerably in the anime--because he’s astute and quite often actually has a point. He’s not, unlike Armin’s bullies in the series, calling Eren a heretic for even thinking of going outside; rather, he seems concerned that Eren is going to drag other people outside to killed along with him (particularly Mikasa, initially). He can be rude and he has a short fuse but he’s not seeking people out to hurt them and enjoying it. He has a sore spot about Eren, but that’s really more of a fight between equals--they make each other mutually uncomfortable because Jean reminds Eren of the stakes involved in achieveing his goals and Eren provokes action from Jean. 
In fact, I’d say Jean’s commitment to the truth aligns him a lot more with Armin than his bullies or even with the other members of the 104th. For instance, as this post points out, they both get themselves into trouble by speaking their minds as kids. 
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Armin in chapter 1 and Jean in chapter 16. I still can’t get over Jean calling Eren “eloquent”; regardless of Eren’s good intentions, I think Jean is very right in pointing out how Eren’s rhetoric doesn’t sound all that different from the story the higher ups told about the cull. But I also find it super interesting that there is no bad intent in Jean’s speech here; given the “truce” they call afterwards, I think he’s serious that he doesn’t mean to attack Eren. In the anime Jean doesn’t get this line about eloquence in and the scene is much more hostile.
Which brings me to my point about his development. The way I read it in the manga, Jean’s journey is not about transforming from a cruel person into a kinder one (since he is never depicted as cruel in the first place), but from a self-centered individual into a responsible one: specifically, a person tasked with championing the weak. Jean has always seen the problems with the government--he talks about the cull of twenty-percent of the population as a suicide mission, he pokes fun at the rhetoric of calling the people who are forced to settled in outskirt towns “heroes”--but instead of attempting to do anything about it his initial impulse is to play the system so that he survives as long as possible.
Tumblr media
Chapter 17. They stand up to start fighting simultaneously immediately after this. Eren is sweating here, implying nervousness, and his eye is twitching; Jean’s pretty calm now, but in just a few panels his jealousy over Eren’s friends will get him into trouble. 
In fact, Marco thinks Jean’s pragmatism and desire of self-preservation put him in a unique position to stand up for the weak--the opposite of picking on them.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Chapter 18. This memory comes to Jean when he’s trying to decide how best to protect his comrades from further death and devastation.
Marco’s point is that Jean has a unique combination of skills and personality traits which he can utilize to protect the weak, both from the titans and (eventually) other humans who are seeking to oppress them. Jean’s “weakness” leads him to value life, so he’s not going to take certain risks unless he has to--and he’ll be honest it about it with his soldiers, so they’ll know he has their interests at heart. He only makes sacrifices reluctantly, when he must in order to preserve a larger number of people (as seen in Trost). He’s also astute: he’s suspicious of empty rhetoric (like the government deals in--it’s so weird that Marco is the one implying some of this, given his fondness for the king; perhaps it’s just that the society views these attributes as weak, given how messed up it is) and he can take in any situation pretty quickly. He’s aware of the systems of oppression that govern the Walled World (culls and bait towns), and his development seems to center on widening the scope of how he resists those systems rather than his awakening to their existence: he needs to look out not just for himself, but others or else he is complicit in their suffering. So he joins the Survey Corps, not because he sees Eren’s vision of “freedom, no matter how high the costs” but because he wants to protect his friends.
Tumblr media
Chapter 18. I don’t think bullies worry so much about others. There’s a sense of camaraderie that seems to include Jean expressed at other points in the manga--like, yeah he’s a bit rude sometimes, but he’s our rude guy and we like him that way. No one seems to have a serious problem with him. 
This seems to be how others understand Jean’s change of heart as well. Everyone is weirded out by how “responsible” he is now, rather than how much kinder--implying they didn’t really see him as cruel in the first place. No one comments, for instance, on Jean personally supporting Connie or Armin after some of their difficulties, but they do notice when he speaks up for helping others more generally, particularly at great risk to himself. 
Tumblr media
Reiner in volume 6, when Jean suggests buying time for the platoon to retreat after the Female Titan devastated their forces.
Tumblr media
Connie, Eren, and Armin commenting on how Jean’s changed in volume 13. I’m not quite sure about Armin’s comment here; was Jean ever really a “bad guy” or just a bit of an asshole sometimes in the course of disagreeing with Eren?
And I think Jean takes his newfound commitment to others seriously, which leads to some of his struggles during the Uprising arc as he tries to distinguish the most ethical course of action when the metric of “human versus titan” fails. He always attempts to voice his objections within the parameters allowed to him by the military, although not always in the most productive ways (think about that joke about stabbing incompetent commanders in the back . . .). In fact, he’s even willing to challenge the SC when he thinks they’re going too far in the name of the coup: part way through my initial read through of the series, I started looking to Jean for commentary on the morals of a coup that stems from within the military rather than from the will of populace. 
Tumblr media
Jean voices his objections to torture, volume 14. Surely someone with a cruel streak or the impulse to bully would be able to think of some justification for torture.
Tumblr media
Everyone is upset over Levi’s treatment of Historia, but Jean’s the only person who actually says anything, volume 14.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Jean is the first and last person to raise objections about the coup’s methods in this scene, volume 14. He feels so strongly about it he considers defying orders.
And I don’t necessarily want to get too much into the molestation scene from chapters 52 and 53, but Jean seems to object to being asked to participate in the “bait” scheme, because it makes him somewhat complicit in what happens to Armin. While presumably other members of the 104th comforted Armin after his trauma, we only see Jean doing it. In fact, he’s the only one who speaks about it apart from Mikasa, who alludes to the molestation once on the rooftop while she and Levi are setting up the trap.
Tumblr media
Jean struggles with the tenants of the mission, which is to act as bait until they can spring a trap for the big boss of the Reeves’ company, volume 13. The implication seems to be if he were not compelled to be “Eren” at this point he could do something about what is happening to Armin.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
From volume 13. Unfortunately, it also seems like Connie and Sasha are laughing here. :(
Of course, even at this stage of his maturation there’s still room for Jean to grow. For example, Jean’s response to Armin’s second “gesumin” moment, wherein he suggests fooling the masses in order to get them on the survey corps side, is to blame Armin’s unethical proposal on his recent trauma.
Tumblr media
Volume 14.
This is not Jean’s finest moment, but I read it as him (however problematically) trying to make sense of Armin’s suggestion; a suggestion which involves manipulation and lying, two things antithetical to Jean’s own values. This ableism doesn’t belong just to Jean, but is pervasive throughout the world of Attack on Titan (many people toss around insults related to intelligence and mental health), so I read this also as a bit of a knock to their society; they could all do better. This is not to excuse Jean here, but to just acknowledge the systematic nature of the problem.
Overall, however, Jean’s the only person who’s attempting to help Armin (that we see, obviously) and I think these scenes are where we get a fuller sense of his empathy; an empathy that also leads him to try to help Eren (again, in his own blunt and awkward way) after the events of the Reiss chapel. It’s the same empathy, I think, that Marco alludes to when he says Jean understands the weak and should endeavor to help them. We can read that empathy back into his concern for his fellow soldiers, who are constantly asked to risk their lives for causes that may not even have their best interests at heart. Whereas Armin’s analytic nature leads him to discover people’s secrets and predict their movements, Jean’s empathy grants him perspective on their feelings--he can see the human in pretty much anybody, which I view as his main strength.
Over the course of the coup, Jean becomes the main voice of dissent. Although Sasha and Connie often nod along with him, he’s usually the one who either speaks first or speaks at all, and Levi realizes that he’s going to have to convince Jean eventually if he’s going to maintain order in his ranks.
Tumblr media
From volume 14. I think it’s so interesting that we’re looking first at Jean from behind and then at him through Levi’s eyes. It’s almost like we’re meant to be identifying primarily with Jean and Levi’s looking at us--Levi has to convince us he’s right, in addition to convincing Jean. He’s also centered here, suggesting his leader status among the other recruits.
Jean’s biggest development during the coup stems from struggling with the idea that there’s no way to be ethically pure. He joined the Survey Corps in order to help others after Trost made him fully aware of the stakes but sometimes that’s a murkier process than it initially seems. Jean decides after Armin kills someone for him (sacrificing his own innocence for Jean’s life), that the best he can do in his current situation is to protect his comrades. And he takes that mentality with him after the coup, as demonstrated in this scene where he lectures Marlowe.
Tumblr media
Chapter 72. Jean’s trying to tell Marlowe not to get swept up in the rhetoric of self-sacrifice.
Yet I like that Jean doesn’t come out his experience completely cowed by Levi (who, admittedly, does not want Jean to be cowed or even want Jean to think he’s always right, based on their discussions), as we can see in this scene where he encourages Historia to keep her promise to Boss Reeves and punch Levi in revenge for his violence towards her.
Tumblr media
Chapter 70. Eren thinks she should let it go but Jean cheers her on.
So, in summation, Isayama can reinterpret Jean as a bully if he wants to in his AUs for comedy, but I think that’s an oversimplified and even quite inaccurate reading if we want to take it seriously, even of pre-development Jean xD. Jean starts off as an observant but self-centered person who doesn’t intimidate the weak but doesn’t champion them either; he just wants to survive. But Marco’s death makes him realize the full extent of the care he feels for his comrades and he sets out to protect them and support them, even in defiance of his commanders. He questions the rhetorical maneuvering of the powerful and seeks to live honestly. None of that sounds like a bully and certainly none of that sounds like it would develop into a bully in a different world where there were no titans or no totalitarian government. And those are my two cents xD
96 notes · View notes
flossieley2942-blog · 7 years
Text
Arrowhead, Flash, Supergirl Un Emerging Attendu Dans Les Séries Super.
We are all knowledgeable that the Titanic attack an iceberg on 15 April, 1912 while on an initial journey from Nyc to England and sank with the reduction of 1517 lives. Even if you're incredibly actually enticed to her, you have to keep your head concerning you and be able to be a problem given that an excellent lady, with her directly trustworthy, wants to uncover a good guy eventually. A gal will certainly be drawn in to you merely when you dip her thoughts and turn on sensations of sturdy wish for you within her. Helping in order to get your little one spruced up in the amazing Little bit of Bo Peep costume as well as combine off along with a lamb or even lambs costume is actually merely a brilliant however disregarded Halloween concept, a tip certain to be a success.
Teen girls could enjoy helping or babysitting out at the local automobile washout for added money. When a female you have actually just met informs you that she only wishes to be actually friends, exactly what she actually implies is that she's not interested in you at all. Flossing is actually vital as that obtains those caught bits from in between your pearly whites causing foul-smelling breath. They need to have nurseries along with furnishings that are going to at some point transformed into large kid and woman areas with even much bigger furniture. You want to copulate a gal without knowing anything about her next to the method she appears. Regularly ready to starts very first whatever kind of tasks so as to bring in influence, to ensure others might comply with Super Kid's footprints. DOCTOR Leslie Biesecker, principal from the Genetic Health http://beauty4u-2017.nl condition Analysis Division at the National Institutes of Wellness, said the poor gene could possess been actually introduced after the original beginning family members settled there certainly. I battle, and also if the lady of my dreams figured out and didn't apart from the taboo. If she sleeps with you, you have to reveal the girl that you are actually not going to injure her credibility and reputation or drop appreciation for her. For many years, I have been privileged enough to have actually built an audience from FANTASTIC people and also real estate investors that were either considering the items that we covered or even wanted to discover our expenditure study process. Regrettable being able to identify a gentleperson isn't really the exact same trait as being actually one. When a lady babbles about anything and also every little thing, you understand she's trying her ideal to impress you. Great first impressions suggests you gone on your method to the leading in the helicopter, poor first impressions indicates you possess a difficult reach excellence - no helicopters for you.
Tumblr media
This area has actually brought about the creation, growth and also success of a lot of heroes as well as super heroes. This info was actually made in order to help Female Recruiter & Boy Scout troops, however households may additionally make use of the information to make an unique experience on their own! Make sure that you take note when you are actually learning how you can inform if a woman likes you, since possibilities are actually, they will certainly infection you. He also had more than the training program from the week obviously helped make at the very least a handful of fans one of the woman gamers. The Guts Girlz site announces 'Every girl possesses the stamina to carry out one thing impressive. Morgan Spurlock made the docudrama Super Size Me with an objective to launch a nationwide conversation over junk food as well as health and nutrition" after viewing updates insurance coverage of a McDonald's suit (Parker, 2004, para.
Tumblr media
0 notes
samuelpboswell · 5 years
Text
The Impact of Twitter’s Proposed Shakeup on Marketers and Influencers
Twitter needs to change. This truth is acknowledged by everyone affiliated with the social media network, including its co-founder and CEO. Jack Dorsey sat with Chris Anderson and Whitney Pennington Rodgers of TED last month for a roundtable discussion about the state of his company, and the path ahead. Specifically, their chat centered on Twitter’s conversation health, and how to improve it. During the talk, Dorsey laid out some interesting ideas. Today we’ll touch on several of them — including one proposed shift that could fundamentally alter the platform’s very fabric — with an eye on the potential impact for B2B marketers and influencers.
The Continuing Mission to Combat Twitter Abuse
This issue isn’t new. I wrote last year on this blog about Twitter’s efforts to tame the trolls and restore civility to its discourse. At the time, the network had recently enacted a massive purge of fake and suspicious accounts, and was also launching a pair of academic projects regarding diversity of viewpoints. But eight months later, the underlying problems haven’t much improved. In the most striking moment of TED’s roundtable, Anderson confronts Dorsey directly about the widespread perception of an “all talk, no action” approach from Twitter. To signal the urgency, Anderson draws up a Titanic metaphor (a man after my own heart), with Twitter’s CEO as the captain. In this scenario, Dorsey listens reflectively as shiphands express their concerns about the iceberg ahead. “And you go to the bridge, and we're waiting, and we look, and then you're showing this extraordinary calm, but we're all standing outside, saying, ‘Jack, turn the [F-ing] wheel!’” Are Dorsey and Twitter finally ready to take control and change course? One idea he offered, in particular, suggests that a major transformation could be on the horizon.
Shifting Tides: From Following Accounts to Following Topics
Some of the possible changes hinted by Dorsey are relatively minor and uncontroversial. He wants users to be able to hide their replies. He wants to deemphasize follower counts and ‘likes’ on tweets. His team plans to analyze conversation health across four parameters (shared attention, shared reality, receptivity, variety of perspective), and… well, I find myself in agreement with Bill Murphy Jr.: “I don't understand exactly what Twitter hopes to do with this analysis.” But the bombshell of the interview came with Dorsey’s allusion to an entirely new structural underpinning for Twitter. Here’s the full answer he gave when asked about how he feels he can meaningfully shift behavior on the platform:
Well, one of the things — we started the service with this concept of following an account, as an example, and I don't believe that's why people actually come to Twitter. I believe Twitter is best as an interest-based network. People come with a particular interest. They have to do a ton of work to find and follow the related accounts around those interests. What we could do instead is allow you to follow an interest, follow a hashtag, follow a trend, follow a community, which gives us the opportunity to show all of the accounts, all the topics, all the moments, all the hashtags that are associated with that particular topic and interest, which really opens up the perspective that you see. But that is a huge fundamental shift to bias the entire network away from just an account bias towards a topics and interest bias.
As with his conversation health analysis piece, it’s not entirely clear to me what Dorsey is advancing here. Is the idea that we will no longer be able to choose who we follow, and our feeds will instead be based entirely on topical areas of interest? (For me personally, this would be annoying, because there are certain people within my areas of interest that I actively choose to follow, and some I actively choose not to. I don’t think I’m alone.) Or maybe it’s more about how Twitter’s algorithm serves us content outside of the people we follow. Right now, this does seem to be mostly account-driven. For example, you’ll see a tweet on your timeline from someone you’re unfamiliar with, and a message above will explain it was selected due to other users (i.e., “@NickNelsonMN and @CaitlinMBurgess follow this person”). Shifting this to more of a topical basis wouldn’t deter the ability to customize one’s own feed, and could actually be quite beneficial if done right. In either case, the marketing implications are worth considering.
What Could All This Mean for Marketers?
Without having an exact idea of what Twitter is planning (or whether it will actually implement anything at all, given its history), we can’t draw any definitive conclusions. But given our continual tracking of the ever-changing social media marketing universe, as well as emerging influencer marketing trends, a few thoughts do initially cross through my mind, and mostly they are positive.
Removal of Rancor and Vitriol Are Good for Business
One area where Twitter has shown demonstrable progress is in scalably reducing abuse. Dorsey notes that “about 38% of abusive tweets are now proactively identified by machine learning algorithms so that people don't actually have to report them,” adding that this is up from zero percent a year ago. It’s part of an effort to “take the burden off the victim.” Setting aside the snark, let’s acknowledge that this is an important step in the right direction. Twitter’s reputation as a cesspool of negativity and hatred can make it an uninviting destination for any brand. Legitimate progress on this front is undoubtedly a plus.
Topic-based Visibility Could Be Great News for Influencers & Marketers
Large or small following, more established and rising influencers are often dedicated to growing their profiles within areas of specialization. If indeed Twitter moves to start serving people more topical content, it could be a great way for these individuals to get in front of users who are interested in the subjects they cover but may not yet be familiar with them, or immersed in their extended networks. This would also make leveraging Twitter as part of influencer marketing efforts more appealing to B2B brands. Imagine if tapping an authoritative voice in, say, fintech not only gave you credible access to their direct following, but also to a much larger audience of users engaged with that topic? Topical relevance is of the utmost importance, ranking as a top B2B influencer marketing focus. Brands need to be speaking the language of their customers and reaching them in the right context. This development might present an opportunity to better align marketing messaging, expertise, and audience on Twitter.
Impacts for Those Who’ve Built Large Audiences Are Ambiguous
If Twitter were to follow the more extreme version of Dorsey’s vision — pushing aside the traditional format of following accounts in favor of following topics — what would that mean for the people who’ve worked hard to build their own personal brands on the platform? Or, for that matter, the companies that have accrued thousands of quality followers through relevant, quality content? I don’t think that’s necessarily what Dorsey was getting at. He might just be positioning this as a new method of discovery, rather than consumption. But again, he wasn’t especially clear and that leaves plenty of room for uncertainty.
What’s Ahead for Twitter and Marketers?
As always, we’ll have to wait and see whether Dorsey and Twitter back up their ambitious visions of upheaval, and to what extent. It bears noting that the platform has a history of launching capabilities and features that aren’t aligned with what users want (the new desktop layout being the most recent example). They’ll need to tread carefully with something so essential as how our feeds are curated. But with the company taking some undeniable steps toward curbing abuse and improving user experiences, while showing strong business performance and impressing advertisers in the process, Twitter seems to be sailing in the right direction. Fewer trolls and more substantive, expert content organized around topics would make the platform a stronger piece in any B2B digital marketing strategy. Stay tuned to the TopRank Marketing Blog for more coverage of Twitter and the social media marketing space at large. In the meantime, I invite you to check out some of these past entries on the topic:
Will Twitter Succeed in Defeating Trolls? The Stakes for Marketers
Twitter Has Renewed its Live Video Push & Here’s What You Need to Know
The post The Impact of Twitter’s Proposed Shakeup on Marketers and Influencers appeared first on Online Marketing Blog - TopRank®.
from The SEO Advantages https://www.toprankblog.com/2019/05/twitter-shakeup-b2b-marketing/
0 notes
christopheruearle · 5 years
Text
The Impact of Twitter’s Proposed Shakeup on Marketers and Influencers
Twitter needs to change. This truth is acknowledged by everyone affiliated with the social media network, including its co-founder and CEO. Jack Dorsey sat with Chris Anderson and Whitney Pennington Rodgers of TED last month for a roundtable discussion about the state of his company, and the path ahead. Specifically, their chat centered on Twitter’s conversation health, and how to improve it. During the talk, Dorsey laid out some interesting ideas. Today we’ll touch on several of them — including one proposed shift that could fundamentally alter the platform’s very fabric — with an eye on the potential impact for B2B marketers and influencers.
The Continuing Mission to Combat Twitter Abuse
This issue isn’t new. I wrote last year on this blog about Twitter’s efforts to tame the trolls and restore civility to its discourse. At the time, the network had recently enacted a massive purge of fake and suspicious accounts, and was also launching a pair of academic projects regarding diversity of viewpoints. But eight months later, the underlying problems haven’t much improved. In the most striking moment of TED’s roundtable, Anderson confronts Dorsey directly about the widespread perception of an “all talk, no action” approach from Twitter. To signal the urgency, Anderson draws up a Titanic metaphor (a man after my own heart), with Twitter’s CEO as the captain. In this scenario, Dorsey listens reflectively as shiphands express their concerns about the iceberg ahead. “And you go to the bridge, and we're waiting, and we look, and then you're showing this extraordinary calm, but we're all standing outside, saying, ‘Jack, turn the [F-ing] wheel!’” Are Dorsey and Twitter finally ready to take control and change course? One idea he offered, in particular, suggests that a major transformation could be on the horizon.
Shifting Tides: From Following Accounts to Following Topics
Some of the possible changes hinted by Dorsey are relatively minor and uncontroversial. He wants users to be able to hide their replies. He wants to deemphasize follower counts and ‘likes’ on tweets. His team plans to analyze conversation health across four parameters (shared attention, shared reality, receptivity, variety of perspective), and… well, I find myself in agreement with Bill Murphy Jr.: “I don't understand exactly what Twitter hopes to do with this analysis.” But the bombshell of the interview came with Dorsey’s allusion to an entirely new structural underpinning for Twitter. Here’s the full answer he gave when asked about how he feels he can meaningfully shift behavior on the platform:
Well, one of the things — we started the service with this concept of following an account, as an example, and I don't believe that's why people actually come to Twitter. I believe Twitter is best as an interest-based network. People come with a particular interest. They have to do a ton of work to find and follow the related accounts around those interests. What we could do instead is allow you to follow an interest, follow a hashtag, follow a trend, follow a community, which gives us the opportunity to show all of the accounts, all the topics, all the moments, all the hashtags that are associated with that particular topic and interest, which really opens up the perspective that you see. But that is a huge fundamental shift to bias the entire network away from just an account bias towards a topics and interest bias.
As with his conversation health analysis piece, it’s not entirely clear to me what Dorsey is advancing here. Is the idea that we will no longer be able to choose who we follow, and our feeds will instead be based entirely on topical areas of interest? (For me personally, this would be annoying, because there are certain people within my areas of interest that I actively choose to follow, and some I actively choose not to. I don’t think I’m alone.) Or maybe it’s more about how Twitter’s algorithm serves us content outside of the people we follow. Right now, this does seem to be mostly account-driven. For example, you’ll see a tweet on your timeline from someone you’re unfamiliar with, and a message above will explain it was selected due to other users (i.e., “@NickNelsonMN and @CaitlinMBurgess follow this person”). Shifting this to more of a topical basis wouldn’t deter the ability to customize one’s own feed, and could actually be quite beneficial if done right. In either case, the marketing implications are worth considering.
What Could All This Mean for Marketers?
Without having an exact idea of what Twitter is planning (or whether it will actually implement anything at all, given its history), we can’t draw any definitive conclusions. But given our continual tracking of the ever-changing social media marketing universe, as well as emerging influencer marketing trends, a few thoughts do initially cross through my mind, and mostly they are positive.
Removal of Rancor and Vitriol Are Good for Business
One area where Twitter has shown demonstrable progress is in scalably reducing abuse. Dorsey notes that “about 38% of abusive tweets are now proactively identified by machine learning algorithms so that people don't actually have to report them,” adding that this is up from zero percent a year ago. It’s part of an effort to “take the burden off the victim.” Setting aside the snark, let’s acknowledge that this is an important step in the right direction. Twitter’s reputation as a cesspool of negativity and hatred can make it an uninviting destination for any brand. Legitimate progress on this front is undoubtedly a plus.
Topic-based Visibility Could Be Great News for Influencers & Marketers
Large or small following, more established and rising influencers are often dedicated to growing their profiles within areas of specialization. If indeed Twitter moves to start serving people more topical content, it could be a great way for these individuals to get in front of users who are interested in the subjects they cover but may not yet be familiar with them, or immersed in their extended networks. This would also make leveraging Twitter as part of influencer marketing efforts more appealing to B2B brands. Imagine if tapping an authoritative voice in, say, fintech not only gave you credible access to their direct following, but also to a much larger audience of users engaged with that topic? Topical relevance is of the utmost importance, ranking as a top B2B influencer marketing focus. Brands need to be speaking the language of their customers and reaching them in the right context. This development might present an opportunity to better align marketing messaging, expertise, and audience on Twitter.
Impacts for Those Who’ve Built Large Audiences Are Ambiguous
If Twitter were to follow the more extreme version of Dorsey’s vision — pushing aside the traditional format of following accounts in favor of following topics — what would that mean for the people who’ve worked hard to build their own personal brands on the platform? Or, for that matter, the companies that have accrued thousands of quality followers through relevant, quality content? I don’t think that’s necessarily what Dorsey was getting at. He might just be positioning this as a new method of discovery, rather than consumption. But again, he wasn’t especially clear and that leaves plenty of room for uncertainty.
What’s Ahead for Twitter and Marketers?
As always, we’ll have to wait and see whether Dorsey and Twitter back up their ambitious visions of upheaval, and to what extent. It bears noting that the platform has a history of launching capabilities and features that aren’t aligned with what users want (the new desktop layout being the most recent example). They’ll need to tread carefully with something so essential as how our feeds are curated. But with the company taking some undeniable steps toward curbing abuse and improving user experiences, while showing strong business performance and impressing advertisers in the process, Twitter seems to be sailing in the right direction. Fewer trolls and more substantive, expert content organized around topics would make the platform a stronger piece in any B2B digital marketing strategy. Stay tuned to the TopRank Marketing Blog for more coverage of Twitter and the social media marketing space at large. In the meantime, I invite you to check out some of these past entries on the topic:
Will Twitter Succeed in Defeating Trolls? The Stakes for Marketers
Twitter Has Renewed its Live Video Push & Here’s What You Need to Know
The post The Impact of Twitter’s Proposed Shakeup on Marketers and Influencers appeared first on Online Marketing Blog - TopRank®.
0 notes
smartecky · 6 years
Text
Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but lidar has proven transformative. The latest accomplishment using laser-based imaging maps thousands of square kilometers of an ancient Mayan city once millions strong, but the researchers make it clear that there’s no technological substitute for experience and a good eye.
The Pacunam Lidar Initiative began two years ago, bringing together a group of scholars and local authorities to undertake the largest-yet survey of a protected and long-studied region in Guatemala. Some 2,144 square kilometers of the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Petén were scanned, inclusive of and around areas known to be settled, developed or otherwise of importance.
Preliminary imagery and data illustrating the success of the project were announced earlier this year, but the researchers have now performed their actual analyses on the data, and the resulting paper summarizing their wide-ranging results has been published in the journal Science.
The areas covered by the initiative, as you can see, spread over perhaps a fifth of the country.
“We’ve never been able to see an ancient landscape at this scale all at once. We’ve never had a data set like this. But in February really we hadn’t done any analysis, really, in a quantitative sense,” co-author Francisco Estrada-Belli, of Tulane University, told me. He worked on the project with numerous others, including Tulane colleague Marcello Canuto. “Basically we announced we had found a huge urban sprawl, that we had found agricultural features on a grand scale. After another nine months of work we were able to quantify all that and to get some numerical confirmations for the impressions we’d gotten.”
“It’s nice to be able to confirm all our claims,” he said. “They may have seemed exaggerated to some.”
The lidar data was collected not by self-driving cars, which seem to be the only vehicles bearing lidar we ever hear about, nor even by drones, but by traditional airplane. That may sound cumbersome, but the distances and landscapes involved permitted nothing else.
“A drone would never have worked — it could never have covered that area,” Estrada-Belli explained. “In our case it was actually a twin-engine plane flown down from Texas.”
The plane made dozens of passes over a given area, a chosen “polygon” perhaps 30 kilometers long and 20 wide. Mounted underneath was “a Teledyne Optech Titan MultiWave multichannel, multi-spectral, narrow-pulse width lidar system,” which pretty much says it all: this is a heavy-duty instrument, the size of a refrigerator. But you need that kind of system to pierce the canopy and image the underlying landscape.
The many overlapping passes were then collated and calibrated into a single digital landscape of remarkable detail.
“It identified features that I had walked over — a hundred times!” he laughed. “Like a major causeway, I walked over it, but it was so subtle, and it was covered by huge vegetation, underbrush, trees, you know, jungle — I’m sure that in another 20 years I wouldn’t have noticed it.”
But these structures don’t identify themselves. There’s no computer labeling system that looks at the 3D model and says, “this is a pyramid, this is a wall,” and so on. That’s a job that only archaeologists can do.
“It actually begins with manipulating the surface data,” Estrada-Belli said. “We get these surface models of the natural landscape; each pixel in the image is basically the elevation. Then we do a series of filters to simulate light being projected on it from various angles to enhance the relief, and we combine these visualizations with transparencies and different ways of sharpening or enhancing them. After all this process, basically looking at the computer screen for a long time, then we can start digitizing it.”
“The first step is to visually identify features. Of course, pyramids are easy, but there are subtler features that, even once you identify them, it’s hard to figure out what they are.”
The lidar imagery revealed, for example, lots of low linear features that could be man-made or natural. It’s not always easy to tell the difference, but context and existing scholarship fill in the gaps.
“Then we proceeded to digitize all these features… there were 61,000 structures, and everything had to be done manually,” Estrada-Belli said — in case you were wondering why it took nine months. “There’s really no automation because the digitizing has to be done based on experience. We looked into AI, and we hope that maybe in the near future we’ll be able to apply that, but for now an experienced archaeologist’s eye can discern the features better than a computer.”
You can see the density of the annotations on the maps. It should be noted that many of these features had by this point been verified by field expeditions. By consulting existing maps and getting ground truth in person, they had made sure that these weren’t phantom structures or wishful thinking. “We’re confident that they’re all there,” he told me.
“Next is the quantitative step,” he continued. “You measure the length and the areas and you put it all together, and you start analyzing them like you’d analyze other data set: the structure density of some area, the size of urban sprawl or agricultural fields. Finally we even figured a way to quantify the potential production of agriculture.”
This is the point where the imagery starts to go from point cloud to academic study. After all, it’s well known that the Maya had a large city in this area; it’s been intensely studied for decades. But the Pacunam (which stands for Patrimonio Cultural y Natural Maya) study was meant to advance beyond the traditional methods employed previously.
“It’s a huge data set. It’s a huge cross-section of the Maya lowlands,” Estrada-Belli said. “Big data is the buzzword now, right? You truly can see things that you would never see if you only looked at one site at a time. We could never have put together these grand patterns without lidar.”
“For example, in my area, I was able to map 47 square kilometers over the course of 15 years,” he said, slightly wistfully. “And in two weeks the lidar produced 308 square kilometers, to a level of detail that I could never match.”
As a result the paper includes all kinds of new theories and conclusions, from population and economy estimates, to cultural and engineering knowledge, to the timing and nature of conflicts with neighbors.
The resulting report doesn’t just advance the knowledge of Mayan culture and technology, but the science of archaeology itself. It’s iterative, of course, like everything else — Estrada-Belli noted that they were inspired by work done by colleagues in Belize and Cambodia; their contribution, however, exemplifies new approaches to handling large areas and large data sets.
The more experiments and field work, the more established these methods will become, and the greater they will be accepted and replicated. Already they have proven themselves invaluable, and this study is perhaps the best example of lidar’s potential in the field.
WTF is lidar?
“We simply would not have seen these massive fortifications. Even on the ground, many of their details remain unclear. Lidar makes most human-made features clear, coherent, understandable,” explained co-author Stephen Houston, of Brown University, in an email. “AI and pattern recognition may help to refine the detection of features, and drones may, we hope, bring down the cost of this technology.”
“These technologies are important not only for discovery, but also for conservation,” pointed out co-author, Ithaca College’s Thomas Garrison, in an email. “3D scanning of monuments and artifacts provide detailed records and also allow for the creation of replicas via 3D printing.”
Lidar imagery can also show the extent of looting, he wrote, and help cultural authorities provide against it by being aware of relics and sites before the looters are.
The researchers are already planning a second, even larger set of flyovers, founded on the success of the first experiment. Perhaps by the time the initial physical work is done the trendier tools of the last few years will make themselves applicable.
“I doubt the airplanes are going to get less expensive but the instruments will be more powerful,” Estrada-Belli suggested. “The other line is the development of artificial intelligence that can speed up the project; at least it can rule out areas, so we don’t waste any time, and we can zero in on the areas with the greatest potential.”
He’s also excited by the idea of putting the data online so citizen archaeologists can help pore over it. “Maybe they don’t have the same experience we do, but like artificial intelligence they can certainly generate a lot of good data in a short time,” he said.
But as his colleagues point out, even years in this line of work are necessarily preliminary.
“We have to emphasize: it’s a first step, leading to innumerable ideas to test. Dozens of doctoral dissertations,” wrote Houston. “Yet there must always be excavation to look under the surface and to extract clear dates from the ruins.”
“Like many disciplines in the social sciences and humanities, archaeology is embracing digital technologies. Lidar is just one example,” wrote Garrison. “At the same time, we need to be conscious of issues in digital archiving (particularly the problem of obsolete file formatting) and be sure to use technology as a complement to, and not a replacement for methods of documentation that have proven tried and true for over a century.”
The researchers’ paper was published today in Science; you can learn about their conclusions (which are of more interest to the archaeologists and anthropologists among our readers) there, and follow other work being undertaken by the Fundación Pacunam at its website.
Read more: https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/27/how-aerial-lidar-illuminated-a-mayan-megalopolis/
How aerial lidar illuminated a Mayan megalopolis Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but…
0 notes
peach5200-blog · 6 years
Text
Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but lidar has proven transformative. The latest accomplishment using laser-based imaging maps thousands of square kilometers of an ancient Mayan city once millions strong, but the researchers make it clear that there’s no technological substitute for experience and a good eye.
The Pacunam Lidar Initiative began two years ago, bringing together a group of scholars and local authorities to undertake the largest-yet survey of a protected and long-studied region in Guatemala. Some 2,144 square kilometers of the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Petén were scanned, inclusive of and around areas known to be settled, developed or otherwise of importance.
Preliminary imagery and data illustrating the success of the project were announced earlier this year, but the researchers have now performed their actual analyses on the data, and the resulting paper summarizing their wide-ranging results has been published in the journal Science.
The areas covered by the initiative, as you can see, spread over perhaps a fifth of the country.
“We’ve never been able to see an ancient landscape at this scale all at once. We’ve never had a data set like this. But in February really we hadn’t done any analysis, really, in a quantitative sense,” co-author Francisco Estrada-Belli, of Tulane University, told me. He worked on the project with numerous others, including Tulane colleague Marcello Canuto. “Basically we announced we had found a huge urban sprawl, that we had found agricultural features on a grand scale. After another nine months of work we were able to quantify all that and to get some numerical confirmations for the impressions we’d gotten.”
“It’s nice to be able to confirm all our claims,” he said. “They may have seemed exaggerated to some.”
The lidar data was collected not by self-driving cars, which seem to be the only vehicles bearing lidar we ever hear about, nor even by drones, but by traditional airplane. That may sound cumbersome, but the distances and landscapes involved permitted nothing else.
“A drone would never have worked — it could never have covered that area,” Estrada-Belli explained. “In our case it was actually a twin-engine plane flown down from Texas.”
The plane made dozens of passes over a given area, a chosen “polygon” perhaps 30 kilometers long and 20 wide. Mounted underneath was “a Teledyne Optech Titan MultiWave multichannel, multi-spectral, narrow-pulse width lidar system,” which pretty much says it all: this is a heavy-duty instrument, the size of a refrigerator. But you need that kind of system to pierce the canopy and image the underlying landscape.
The many overlapping passes were then collated and calibrated into a single digital landscape of remarkable detail.
“It identified features that I had walked over — a hundred times!” he laughed. “Like a major causeway, I walked over it, but it was so subtle, and it was covered by huge vegetation, underbrush, trees, you know, jungle — I’m sure that in another 20 years I wouldn’t have noticed it.”
But these structures don’t identify themselves. There’s no computer labeling system that looks at the 3D model and says, “this is a pyramid, this is a wall,” and so on. That’s a job that only archaeologists can do.
“It actually begins with manipulating the surface data,” Estrada-Belli said. “We get these surface models of the natural landscape; each pixel in the image is basically the elevation. Then we do a series of filters to simulate light being projected on it from various angles to enhance the relief, and we combine these visualizations with transparencies and different ways of sharpening or enhancing them. After all this process, basically looking at the computer screen for a long time, then we can start digitizing it.”
“The first step is to visually identify features. Of course, pyramids are easy, but there are subtler features that, even once you identify them, it’s hard to figure out what they are.”
The lidar imagery revealed, for example, lots of low linear features that could be man-made or natural. It’s not always easy to tell the difference, but context and existing scholarship fill in the gaps.
“Then we proceeded to digitize all these features… there were 61,000 structures, and everything had to be done manually,” Estrada-Belli said — in case you were wondering why it took nine months. “There’s really no automation because the digitizing has to be done based on experience. We looked into AI, and we hope that maybe in the near future we’ll be able to apply that, but for now an experienced archaeologist’s eye can discern the features better than a computer.”
You can see the density of the annotations on the maps. It should be noted that many of these features had by this point been verified by field expeditions. By consulting existing maps and getting ground truth in person, they had made sure that these weren’t phantom structures or wishful thinking. “We’re confident that they’re all there,” he told me.
“Next is the quantitative step,” he continued. “You measure the length and the areas and you put it all together, and you start analyzing them like you’d analyze other data set: the structure density of some area, the size of urban sprawl or agricultural fields. Finally we even figured a way to quantify the potential production of agriculture.”
This is the point where the imagery starts to go from point cloud to academic study. After all, it’s well known that the Maya had a large city in this area; it’s been intensely studied for decades. But the Pacunam (which stands for Patrimonio Cultural y Natural Maya) study was meant to advance beyond the traditional methods employed previously.
“It’s a huge data set. It’s a huge cross-section of the Maya lowlands,” Estrada-Belli said. “Big data is the buzzword now, right? You truly can see things that you would never see if you only looked at one site at a time. We could never have put together these grand patterns without lidar.”
“For example, in my area, I was able to map 47 square kilometers over the course of 15 years,” he said, slightly wistfully. “And in two weeks the lidar produced 308 square kilometers, to a level of detail that I could never match.”
As a result the paper includes all kinds of new theories and conclusions, from population and economy estimates, to cultural and engineering knowledge, to the timing and nature of conflicts with neighbors.
The resulting report doesn’t just advance the knowledge of Mayan culture and technology, but the science of archaeology itself. It’s iterative, of course, like everything else — Estrada-Belli noted that they were inspired by work done by colleagues in Belize and Cambodia; their contribution, however, exemplifies new approaches to handling large areas and large data sets.
The more experiments and field work, the more established these methods will become, and the greater they will be accepted and replicated. Already they have proven themselves invaluable, and this study is perhaps the best example of lidar’s potential in the field.
WTF is lidar?
“We simply would not have seen these massive fortifications. Even on the ground, many of their details remain unclear. Lidar makes most human-made features clear, coherent, understandable,” explained co-author Stephen Houston, of Brown University, in an email. “AI and pattern recognition may help to refine the detection of features, and drones may, we hope, bring down the cost of this technology.”
“These technologies are important not only for discovery, but also for conservation,” pointed out co-author, Ithaca College’s Thomas Garrison, in an email. “3D scanning of monuments and artifacts provide detailed records and also allow for the creation of replicas via 3D printing.”
Lidar imagery can also show the extent of looting, he wrote, and help cultural authorities provide against it by being aware of relics and sites before the looters are.
The researchers are already planning a second, even larger set of flyovers, founded on the success of the first experiment. Perhaps by the time the initial physical work is done the trendier tools of the last few years will make themselves applicable.
“I doubt the airplanes are going to get less expensive but the instruments will be more powerful,” Estrada-Belli suggested. “The other line is the development of artificial intelligence that can speed up the project; at least it can rule out areas, so we don’t waste any time, and we can zero in on the areas with the greatest potential.”
He’s also excited by the idea of putting the data online so citizen archaeologists can help pore over it. “Maybe they don’t have the same experience we do, but like artificial intelligence they can certainly generate a lot of good data in a short time,” he said.
But as his colleagues point out, even years in this line of work are necessarily preliminary.
“We have to emphasize: it’s a first step, leading to innumerable ideas to test. Dozens of doctoral dissertations,” wrote Houston. “Yet there must always be excavation to look under the surface and to extract clear dates from the ruins.”
“Like many disciplines in the social sciences and humanities, archaeology is embracing digital technologies. Lidar is just one example,” wrote Garrison. “At the same time, we need to be conscious of issues in digital archiving (particularly the problem of obsolete file formatting) and be sure to use technology as a complement to, and not a replacement for methods of documentation that have proven tried and true for over a century.”
The researchers’ paper was published today in Science; you can learn about their conclusions (which are of more interest to the archaeologists and anthropologists among our readers) there, and follow other work being undertaken by the Fundación Pacunam at its website.
Source: gadgets
How aerial lidar illuminated a Mayan megalopolis Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but…
0 notes
thegloober · 6 years
Text
How aerial lidar illuminated a Mayan megalopolis
Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but lidar has proven transformative. The latest accomplishment using laser-based imaging maps thousands of square kilometers of an ancient Mayan city once millions strong, but the researchers make it clear that there’s no technological substitute for experience and a good eye.
The Pacunam Lidar Initiative began two years ago, bringing together a group of scholars and local authorities to undertake the largest yet survey of a protected and long-studied region in Guatemala. Some 2,144 square kilometers of the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Petén were scanned, inclusive of and around areas known to be settled, developed, or otherwise of importance.
Preliminary imagery and data illustrating the success of the project were announced earlier this year, but the researchers have now performed their actual analyses on the data, and the resulting paper summarizing their wide-ranging results has been published in the journal Science.
The areas covered by the initiative, as you can see, spread over perhaps a fifth of the country.
“We’ve never been able to see an ancient landscape at this scale all at once. We’ve never had a dataset like this. But in February really we hadn’t done any analysis, really, in a quantitative sense,” co-author Francisco Estrada-Belli, of Tulane University, told me. He worked on the project with numerous others, including his colleagues Marcello Canuto and Stephen Houston. “Basically we announced we had found a huge urban sprawl, that we had found agricultural features on a grand scale. After another 9 months of work we were able to quantify all that and to get some numerical confirmations for the impressions we’d gotten.”
“It’s nice to be able to confirm all our claims,” he said. “They may have seemed exaggerated to some.”
The lidar data was collected not by self-driving cars, which seem to be the only vehicles bearing lidar we ever hear about, nor even by drones, but by traditional airplane. That may sound cumbersome, but the distances and landscapes involved permitted nothing else.
“A drone would never have worked — it could never have covered that area,” Estrada-Belli explained. “In our case it was actually a twin engine plane flown down from Texas.”
The plane would made dozens of passes over a given area, a chosen “polygon” perhaps 30 kilometers long and 20 wide. Mounted underneath was “a Teledyne Optech Titan MultiWave multichannel, multi-spectral, narrow-pulse width lidar system,” which pretty much says it all: this is a heavy duty instrument, the size of a refrigerator. But you need that kind of system to pierce the canopy and image the underlying landscape.
The many overlapping passes were then collated and calibrated into a single digital landscape of remarkable detail.
“It identified features that I had walked over — a hundred of times!” he laughed. “Like a major causeway, I walked over it, but it was so subtle, and it was covered by huge vegetation, underbrush, trees, you know, jungle — I’m sure that in another 20 years I wouldn’t have noticed it.”
But these structures don’t identify themselves. There’s no computer labeling system that looks at the 3D model and says, “this is a pyramid, this is a wall,” and so on. That’s a job that only archaeologists can do.
“It actually begins with manipulating the surface data,” Estrada-Belli said. “We get these surface models of the natural landscape; each pixel in the image is basically the elevation. Then we do a series of filters to simulate light being projected on it from various angles to enhance the relief, and we combine these visualizations with transparencies and different ways of sharpening or enhancing them. After all this process, basically looking at the computer screen for a long time, then we can start digitizing it.”
“The first step is to visually identify features. Of course, pyramids are easy, but there are subtler features that, even once you identify them, it’s hard to figure out what they are.”
The lidar imagery revealed, for example, lots of low linear features that could be man-made or natural. It’s not always easy to tell the difference, but context and existing scholarship fill in the gaps.
“Then we proceeded to digitize all these features… there were 61,000 structures, and everything had to be done manually,” Estrada-Belli said — in case you were wondering why it took nine months. “There’s really no automation because the digitizing has to be done based on experience. We looked into AI, and we hope that maybe in the near future we’ll be able to apply that, but for now an experienced archaeologist’s eye can discern the features better than a computer.”
You can see the density of the annotations on the maps. It should be noted that many of these features had by this point been verified by field expeditions. By consulting existing maps and getting ground truth in person, they had made sure that these weren’t phantom structures or wishful thinking. “We’re confident that they’re all there,” he told me.
“Next is the quantitative step,” he continued. “You measure the length and the areas and you put it all together, and you start analyzing them like you’d analyze other dataset: the structure density of some area, the size of urban sprawl or agricultural fields. Finally we even figured a way to quantify the potential production of agriculture.”
This is the point where the imagery starts to go from point cloud to academic study. After all, it’s well known that the Maya had a large city in this area; it’s been intensely studied for decades. But the Pacunam (which stands for Patrimonio Cultural y Natural Maya) study was meant to advance beyond the traditional methods employed previously.
“It’s a huge dataset. It’s a huge cross section of the Maya lowlands,” Estrada-Belli said. “Big data is the buzzword now, right? You truly can see things that you would never see if you only looked at one site at a time. We could never have put together these grand patterns without lidar.”
“For example, in my area, I was able to map 47 square kilometers over the course of 15 years,” he said, slightly wistfully. “And in two weeks the lidar produced 308 square kilometers, to a level of detail that I could never match.”
As a result the paper includes all kinds of new theories and conclusions, from population and economy estimates, to cultural and engineering knowledge, to the timing and nature of conflicts with neighbors.
The resulting report doesn’t just advance the knowledge of Mayan culture and technology, but the science of archaeology itself. It’s iterative, of course, like everything else — Estrada-Belli noted that they were inspired by work done by colleagues in Belize and Cambodia; their contribution, however, exemplifies new approaches to handling large areas and large datasets.
The more experiments and field work, the more established these methods will become, and the greater they will be accepted and replicated. Already they have proven themselves invaluable, and this study is perhaps the best example of lidar’s potential in the field.
“We simply would not have seen these massive fortifications. Even on the ground, many of their details remain unclear. Lidar makes most human-made features clear, coherent, understandable,” explained co-author Stephen Houston (also from Tulane) in an email. “AI and pattern recognition may help to refine the detection of features, and drones may, we hope, bring down the cost of this technology.”
“These technologies are important not only for discovery, but also for conservation,” pointed out co-author Thomas Garrison in an email. “3D scanning of monuments and artifacts provide detailed records and also allow for the creation of replicas via 3D printing.”
Lidar imagery can also show the extent of looting, he wrote, and help cultural authorities provide against it by being aware of relics and sites before the looters are.
The researchers are already planning a second, even larger set of flyovers, founded on the success of the first experiment. Perhaps by the time the initial physical work is done the trendier tools of the last few years will make themselves applicable.
“I doubt the airplanes are going to get less expensive but the instruments will be more powerful,” Estrada-Belli suggested. “The other line is the development of artificial intelligence that can speed up the project; at least it can rule out areas, so we don’t waste any time, and we can zero in on the areas with the greatest potential.”
He’s also excited by the idea of putting the data online so citizen archaeologists can help pore over it. “Maybe they don’t have the same experience we do, but like artificial intelligence they can certainly generate a lot of good data in a short time,” he said.
But as his colleagues point out, even years in this line of work are necessarily preliminary.
“We have to emphasize: it’s a first step, leading to innumerable ideas to test. Dozens of doctoral dissertations,” wrote Houston. “Yet there must always be excavation to look under the surface and to extract clear dates from the ruins.”
“Like many disciplines in the social sciences and humanities, archaeology is embracing digital technologies. Lidar is just one example,” wrote Garrison. “At the same time, we need to be conscious of issues in digital archiving (particularly the problem of obsolete file formatting) and be sure to use technology as a complement to, and not a replacement for methods of documentation that have proven tried and true for over a century.”
The researchers’ paper was published today in Science; you can learn about their conclusions (which are of more interest to the archaeologists and anthropologists among our readers) there, and follow other work being undertaken by the Fundación Pacunam at its website.
Source: https://bloghyped.com/how-aerial-lidar-illuminated-a-mayan-megalopolis/
0 notes
roberttbertton · 6 years
Text
Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but lidar has proven transformative. The latest accomplishment using laser-based imaging maps thousands of square kilometers of an ancient Mayan city once millions strong, but the researchers make it clear that there’s no technological substitute for experience and a good eye.
The Pacunam Lidar Initiative began two years ago, bringing together a group of scholars and local authorities to undertake the largest yet survey of a protected and long-studied region in Guatemala. Some 2,144 square kilometers of the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Petén were scanned, inclusive of and around areas known to be settled, developed, or otherwise of importance.
Preliminary imagery and data illustrating the success of the project were announced earlier this year, but the researchers have now performed their actual analyses on the data, and the resulting paper summarizing their wide-ranging results has been published in the journal Science.
The areas covered by the initiative, as you can see, spread over perhaps a fifth of the country.
“We’ve never been able to see an ancient landscape at this scale all at once. We’ve never had a dataset like this. But in February really we hadn’t done any analysis, really, in a quantitative sense,” co-author Francisco Estrada-Belli, of Tulane University, told me. He worked on the project with numerous others, including his colleagues Marcello Canuto and Stephen Houston. “Basically we announced we had found a huge urban sprawl, that we had found agricultural features on a grand scale. After another 9 months of work we were able to quantify all that and to get some numerical confirmations for the impressions we’d gotten.”
“It’s nice to be able to confirm all our claims,” he said. “They may have seemed exaggerated to some.”
The lidar data was collected not by self-driving cars, which seem to be the only vehicles bearing lidar we ever hear about, nor even by drones, but by traditional airplane. That may sound cumbersome, but the distances and landscapes involved permitted nothing else.
“A drone would never have worked — it could never have covered that area,” Estrada-Belli explained. “In our case it was actually a twin engine plane flown down from Texas.”
The plane would made dozens of passes over a given area, a chosen “polygon” perhaps 30 kilometers long and 20 wide. Mounted underneath was “a Teledyne Optech Titan MultiWave multichannel, multi-spectral, narrow-pulse width lidar system,” which pretty much says it all: this is a heavy duty instrument, the size of a refrigerator. But you need that kind of system to pierce the canopy and image the underlying landscape.
The many overlapping passes were then collated and calibrated into a single digital landscape of remarkable detail.
“It identified features that I had walked over — a hundred of times!” he laughed. “Like a major causeway, I walked over it, but it was so subtle, and it was covered by huge vegetation, underbrush, trees, you know, jungle — I’m sure that in another 20 years I wouldn’t have noticed it.”
But these structures don’t identify themselves. There’s no computer labeling system that looks at the 3D model and says, “this is a pyramid, this is a wall,” and so on. That’s a job that only archaeologists can do.
“It actually begins with manipulating the surface data,” Estrada-Belli said. “We get these surface models of the natural landscape; each pixel in the image is basically the elevation. Then we do a series of filters to simulate light being projected on it from various angles to enhance the relief, and we combine these visualizations with transparencies and different ways of sharpening or enhancing them. After all this process, basically looking at the computer screen for a long time, then we can start digitizing it.”
“The first step is to visually identify features. Of course, pyramids are easy, but there are subtler features that, even once you identify them, it’s hard to figure out what they are.”
The lidar imagery revealed, for example, lots of low linear features that could be man-made or natural. It’s not always easy to tell the difference, but context and existing scholarship fill in the gaps.
“Then we proceeded to digitize all these features… there were 61,000 structures, and everything had to be done manually,” Estrada-Belli said — in case you were wondering why it took nine months. “There’s really no automation because the digitizing has to be done based on experience. We looked into AI, and we hope that maybe in the near future we’ll be able to apply that, but for now an experienced archaeologist’s eye can discern the features better than a computer.”
You can see the density of the annotations on the maps. It should be noted that many of these features had by this point been verified by field expeditions. By consulting existing maps and getting ground truth in person, they had made sure that these weren’t phantom structures or wishful thinking. “We’re confident that they’re all there,” he told me.
“Next is the quantitative step,” he continued. “You measure the length and the areas and you put it all together, and you start analyzing them like you’d analyze other dataset: the structure density of some area, the size of urban sprawl or agricultural fields. Finally we even figured a way to quantify the potential production of agriculture.”
This is the point where the imagery starts to go from point cloud to academic study. After all, it’s well known that the Maya had a large city in this area; it’s been intensely studied for decades. But the Pacunam (which stands for Patrimonio Cultural y Natural Maya) study was meant to advance beyond the traditional methods employed previously.
“It’s a huge dataset. It’s a huge cross section of the Maya lowlands,” Estrada-Belli said. “Big data is the buzzword now, right? You truly can see things that you would never see if you only looked at one site at a time. We could never have put together these grand patterns without lidar.”
“For example, in my area, I was able to map 47 square kilometers over the course of 15 years,” he said, slightly wistfully. “And in two weeks the lidar produced 308 square kilometers, to a level of detail that I could never match.”
As a result the paper includes all kinds of new theories and conclusions, from population and economy estimates, to cultural and engineering knowledge, to the timing and nature of conflicts with neighbors.
The resulting report doesn’t just advance the knowledge of Mayan culture and technology, but the science of archaeology itself. It’s iterative, of course, like everything else — Estrada-Belli noted that they were inspired by work done by colleagues in Belize and Cambodia; their contribution, however, exemplifies new approaches to handling large areas and large datasets.
The more experiments and field work, the more established these methods will become, and the greater they will be accepted and replicated. Already they have proven themselves invaluable, and this study is perhaps the best example of lidar’s potential in the field.
WTF is lidar?
“We simply would not have seen these massive fortifications. Even on the ground, many of their details remain unclear. Lidar makes most human-made features clear, coherent, understandable,” explained co-author Stephen Houston (also from Tulane) in an email. “AI and pattern recognition may help to refine the detection of features, and drones may, we hope, bring down the cost of this technology.”
“These technologies are important not only for discovery, but also for conservation,” pointed out co-author Thomas Garrison in an email. “3D scanning of monuments and artifacts provide detailed records and also allow for the creation of replicas via 3D printing.”
Lidar imagery can also show the extent of looting, he wrote, and help cultural authorities provide against it by being aware of relics and sites before the looters are.
The researchers are already planning a second, even larger set of flyovers, founded on the success of the first experiment. Perhaps by the time the initial physical work is done the trendier tools of the last few years will make themselves applicable.
“I doubt the airplanes are going to get less expensive but the instruments will be more powerful,” Estrada-Belli suggested. “The other line is the development of artificial intelligence that can speed up the project; at least it can rule out areas, so we don’t waste any time, and we can zero in on the areas with the greatest potential.”
He’s also excited by the idea of putting the data online so citizen archaeologists can help pore over it. “Maybe they don’t have the same experience we do, but like artificial intelligence they can certainly generate a lot of good data in a short time,” he said.
But as his colleagues point out, even years in this line of work are necessarily preliminary.
“We have to emphasize: it’s a first step, leading to innumerable ideas to test. Dozens of doctoral dissertations,” wrote Houston. “Yet there must always be excavation to look under the surface and to extract clear dates from the ruins.”
“Like many disciplines in the social sciences and humanities, archaeology is embracing digital technologies. Lidar is just one example,” wrote Garrison. “At the same time, we need to be conscious of issues in digital archiving (particularly the problem of obsolete file formatting) and be sure to use technology as a complement to, and not a replacement for methods of documentation that have proven tried and true for over a century.”
The researchers’ paper was published today in Science; you can learn about their conclusions (which are of more interest to the archaeologists and anthropologists among our readers) there, and follow other work being undertaken by the Fundación Pacunam at its website.
Source TechCrunch https://ift.tt/2OYGQsR
How aerial lidar illuminated a Mayan megalopolis – BerTTon Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but…
0 notes
fmservers · 6 years
Text
How aerial lidar illuminated a Mayan megalopolis
Archaeology may not be the most likely place to find the latest in technology — AI and robots are of dubious utility in the painstaking fieldwork involved — but lidar has proven transformative. The latest accomplishment using laser-based imaging maps thousands of square kilometers of an ancient Mayan city once millions strong, but the researchers make it clear that there’s no technological substitute for experience and a good eye.
The Pacunam Lidar Initiative began two years ago, bringing together a group of scholars and local authorities to undertake the largest yet survey of a protected and long-studied region in Guatemala. Some 2,144 square kilometers of the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Petén were scanned, inclusive of and around areas known to be settled, developed, or otherwise of importance.
Preliminary imagery and data illustrating the success of the project were announced earlier this year, but the researchers have now performed their actual analyses on the data, and the resulting paper summarizing their wide-ranging results has been published in the journal Science.
The areas covered by the initiative, as you can see, spread over perhaps a fifth of the country.
“We’ve never been able to see an ancient landscape at this scale all at once. We’ve never had a dataset like this. But in February really we hadn’t done any analysis, really, in a quantitative sense,” co-author Francisco Estrada-Belli, of Tulane University, told me. He worked on the project with numerous others, including his colleagues Marcello Canuto and Stephen Houston. “Basically we announced we had found a huge urban sprawl, that we had found agricultural features on a grand scale. After another 9 months of work we were able to quantify all that and to get some numerical confirmations for the impressions we’d gotten.”
“It’s nice to be able to confirm all our claims,” he said. “They may have seemed exaggerated to some.”
The lidar data was collected not by self-driving cars, which seem to be the only vehicles bearing lidar we ever hear about, nor even by drones, but by traditional airplane. That may sound cumbersome, but the distances and landscapes involved permitted nothing else.
“A drone would never have worked — it could never have covered that area,” Estrada-Belli explained. “In our case it was actually a twin engine plane flown down from Texas.”
The plane would made dozens of passes over a given area, a chosen “polygon” perhaps 30 kilometers long and 20 wide. Mounted underneath was “a Teledyne Optech Titan MultiWave multichannel, multi-spectral, narrow-pulse width lidar system,” which pretty much says it all: this is a heavy duty instrument, the size of a refrigerator. But you need that kind of system to pierce the canopy and image the underlying landscape.
The many overlapping passes were then collated and calibrated into a single digital landscape of remarkable detail.
“It identified features that I had walked over — a hundred of times!” he laughed. “Like a major causeway, I walked over it, but it was so subtle, and it was covered by huge vegetation, underbrush, trees, you know, jungle — I’m sure that in another 20 years I wouldn’t have noticed it.”
But these structures don’t identify themselves. There’s no computer labeling system that looks at the 3D model and says, “this is a pyramid, this is a wall,” and so on. That’s a job that only archaeologists can do.
“It actually begins with manipulating the surface data,” Estrada-Belli said. “We get these surface models of the natural landscape; each pixel in the image is basically the elevation. Then we do a series of filters to simulate light being projected on it from various angles to enhance the relief, and we combine these visualizations with transparencies and different ways of sharpening or enhancing them. After all this process, basically looking at the computer screen for a long time, then we can start digitizing it.”
“The first step is to visually identify features. Of course, pyramids are easy, but there are subtler features that, even once you identify them, it’s hard to figure out what they are.”
The lidar imagery revealed, for example, lots of low linear features that could be man-made or natural. It’s not always easy to tell the difference, but context and existing scholarship fill in the gaps.
“Then we proceeded to digitize all these features… there were 61,000 structures, and everything had to be done manually,” Estrada-Belli said — in case you were wondering why it took nine months. “There’s really no automation because the digitizing has to be done based on experience. We looked into AI, and we hope that maybe in the near future we’ll be able to apply that, but for now an experienced archaeologist’s eye can discern the features better than a computer.”
You can see the density of the annotations on the maps. It should be noted that many of these features had by this point been verified by field expeditions. By consulting existing maps and getting ground truth in person, they had made sure that these weren’t phantom structures or wishful thinking. “We’re confident that they’re all there,” he told me.
[gallery ids="1721959,1721960,1721957,1721961,1721958"]
“Next is the quantitative step,” he continued. “You measure the length and the areas and you put it all together, and you start analyzing them like you’d analyze other dataset: the structure density of some area, the size of urban sprawl or agricultural fields. Finally we even figured a way to quantify the potential production of agriculture.”
This is the point where the imagery starts to go from point cloud to academic study. After all, it’s well known that the Maya had a large city in this area; it’s been intensely studied for decades. But the Pacunam (which stands for Patrimonio Cultural y Natural Maya) study was meant to advance beyond the traditional methods employed previously.
“It’s a huge dataset. It’s a huge cross section of the Maya lowlands,” Estrada-Belli said. “Big data is the buzzword now, right? You truly can see things that you would never see if you only looked at one site at a time. We could never have put together these grand patterns without lidar.”
“For example, in my area, I was able to map 47 square kilometers over the course of 15 years,” he said, slightly wistfully. “And in two weeks the lidar produced 308 square kilometers, to a level of detail that I could never match.”
As a result the paper includes all kinds of new theories and conclusions, from population and economy estimates, to cultural and engineering knowledge, to the timing and nature of conflicts with neighbors.
The resulting report doesn’t just advance the knowledge of Mayan culture and technology, but the science of archaeology itself. It’s iterative, of course, like everything else — Estrada-Belli noted that they were inspired by work done by colleagues in Belize and Cambodia; their contribution, however, exemplifies new approaches to handling large areas and large datasets.
The more experiments and field work, the more established these methods will become, and the greater they will be accepted and replicated. Already they have proven themselves invaluable, and this study is perhaps the best example of lidar’s potential in the field.
WTF is lidar?
“We simply would not have seen these massive fortifications. Even on the ground, many of their details remain unclear. Lidar makes most human-made features clear, coherent, understandable,” explained co-author Stephen Houston (also from Tulane) in an email. “AI and pattern recognition may help to refine the detection of features, and drones may, we hope, bring down the cost of this technology.”
“These technologies are important not only for discovery, but also for conservation,” pointed out co-author Thomas Garrison in an email. “3D scanning of monuments and artifacts provide detailed records and also allow for the creation of replicas via 3D printing.”
Lidar imagery can also show the extent of looting, he wrote, and help cultural authorities provide against it by being aware of relics and sites before the looters are.
The researchers are already planning a second, even larger set of flyovers, founded on the success of the first experiment. Perhaps by the time the initial physical work is done the trendier tools of the last few years will make themselves applicable.
“I doubt the airplanes are going to get less expensive but the instruments will be more powerful,” Estrada-Belli suggested. “The other line is the development of artificial intelligence that can speed up the project; at least it can rule out areas, so we don’t waste any time, and we can zero in on the areas with the greatest potential.”
He’s also excited by the idea of putting the data online so citizen archaeologists can help pore over it. “Maybe they don’t have the same experience we do, but like artificial intelligence they can certainly generate a lot of good data in a short time,” he said.
But as his colleagues point out, even years in this line of work are necessarily preliminary.
“We have to emphasize: it’s a first step, leading to innumerable ideas to test. Dozens of doctoral dissertations,” wrote Houston. “Yet there must always be excavation to look under the surface and to extract clear dates from the ruins.”
“Like many disciplines in the social sciences and humanities, archaeology is embracing digital technologies. Lidar is just one example,” wrote Garrison. “At the same time, we need to be conscious of issues in digital archiving (particularly the problem of obsolete file formatting) and be sure to use technology as a complement to, and not a replacement for methods of documentation that have proven tried and true for over a century.”
The researchers’ paper was published today in Science; you can learn about their conclusions (which are of more interest to the archaeologists and anthropologists among our readers) there, and follow other work being undertaken by the Fundación Pacunam at its website.
Via Devin Coldewey https://techcrunch.com
0 notes
Text
The Untold Trick To instructor In Much less Than Ten Minutes.
Have You Heard? teacher Is Your Best Bet To Grow.
Following recent government regulative acts focused on boosting teaching criteria, colleges are focusing a growing number of on expert advancement for educators. I've invested years educating guitar teachers to come to be successful, highly-paid trainers ... and throughout this time around, I have actually found a vast range of questions http://povestideslabire.info/titan-gel-recenzii/ on the subject of the best ways to come to be a successful guitar instructor". Believe me - you'll be in warm demand, and your choices of tasks for retired instructors will be many! Consequently there is more competitors for less openings as well as, remember, being a teacher nowadays suggests you are on the cutting edge in the budget plan battles owing to falling home values and climbing property taxes. Pack your sweet gifts in ornamental boxes and also put them in plastic gift bags, as well as keep presents chilly right before delivery. The real issue is educators transforming the whole course into grammar lesson, denying the students the right to function and participate on exercises.
Finally, The Secret To educator Is Disclosed
There are numerous resources educators can rely on for suggestions for scientific research learning tasks. As soon as you have complied with these actions you will massively accelerate your progress toward coming to be an effective guitar instructor as well as put yourself light years ahead of the competition. For instance, I like the Oxford Maths Plus resources (specifically as Maths isn't really an area of toughness for me) as it gives an instructors resource book (or extra recently an on the internet system) that provides warm-up, hands-on, support and extension activities that all connect to a web page in the student text publication. If pupils take part in any kind of after institution programs that will include at the very least 2 even more hours daily, 5 days a week. I invested the whole of the lunch break tracking him down to make sure that I can apologise to him and returned home that day with splits in my eyes. For more details about this amazing chance, visit our web site at A total checklist of information sessions could be discovered by clicking INSTRUCTOR EMPLOYMENT. Sending out a neurodiverse youngster to recess may not be the service - for a student like myself that was the worst part of the day.
Why instructor Is The Only Skill You Actually Need.
Overall, 65% of previous public institution teachers report that they are much better able to balance work as well as personal/family life given that they quit mentor. Your educator needs to have the ability to tune in to just what rate of interests you to ensure that they could make drum tutorials more fascinating and also encouraging for you. The function of the teacher throughout a child's very early years includes creating the kid's main skills essential for development. I think that educators need to be allowed to hug trainees periodically, yet sometimes also the most innocent action is turned. For many years currently, I have actually shown Zen archery, as well as I discovered that several of the other educators are practically pleased with talking in a clipped and cryptic style of English much like that used by our Zen archery Master from Japan. Since all pupils do not learn and also refine information similarly, embracing a whole brain training method could confirm to be valuable for the educator to utilize. Student-centered classrooms normally have special seating arrangements so schoolmates can share throughout the day. This has boosted the need of ESL instructors in institutions in a lot of the non English speaking countries. When I first embraced my morning access tasks I got numerous perk repay. Eventually my youngsters will certainly be grown up and also will certainly have their own passions, so it is essential to me that I maintain mine as well as not make my life about my kids or other half. As a group, I thought we art teachers can brainstorm methods to earn this feasible in our art areas. What's impressive is that instructors similar to this appear to regulate a greater level of regard, love, and also inevitably, productivity, which causes our final two features. It is highly crucial that you ask the RIGHT inquiries that will aid you thrive as a guitar educator. I miss the enjoyment that I receive from checking out a really trendy suggestion from a follow teacher. However, Rhee also frustrated the institution system's educators with discharges for those that really did not meet new analysis standards. Because each student is different and also learns differently, educators are required to be a lot more creative compared to trainees. For instance, an instructor's techniques for teaching reading can be boosted through teacher expert advancement. Bottom line - Being a Sunday institution teacher is difficult and it takes good develops work. From the first, students appeared interested when we dived into the story; and also I made certain my plan was functioning the adhering to day when I listened to one young boy state tongue-in-cheek that his pal was a wine sack with a dog's eyes" while they waited in a lunchroom line for a lunch girl to pass them slices of pepperoni pizza.
0 notes
Text
Oregon to make profession floor to be the vanguard hercynian
Girl jordan shoes: list in one year back to health
Shoe store that sells jordans first Tuesday issue sales letter within motive for the best sports shoes, ones quasi supplied by its corporation just around absolutely mil frames among sports footwear. December fifteen, the footwear can be utilization of sales of your products, together with listed on the supermarket. Retro jordan shoes released this unique providing is bound about the better trainers, a maximum of 1 set of sports footwear and not simply to a lesser degree fifty-eight.35 thousand twos for sports shoes; whether latest trainers of fifty-eight.33 mil twos from running sneakers, gamble sneakers may still are more compared with $8.eighty two, is that self employed by way of the issuer in addition to the significant insurance broker identify their issuing monthly fee, always arouse trainers dont eclipse $8.82. Such a allowing will undoubtedly be not online book-constructing apportionment towards dealers and to current market from the internet order problem of combining how. Such as our own overture enquiry cycle unsatisfactory-tune initially matter 70% on the comprehensive level regarding to start with content, that is to say, seventy dollars zillion twos among trainers, really free numbers concerning providing rate less goal using the net return phone number. According to launch lifestyle, this unique that provide roadshow promote instant in the month of january 8, 2014 for you to Aug tenth, an initial analysis with regard to February 9, 2014 inside February 10, exhibited at June 14th issued announcement, jordan by going online investment then fees for the best Aug fifteen. Jordan 13 for sale cheap running sneakers one corp., LTD is truly a widely known shoes garment brand name industry inch denmark, is certainly caused by into new jordans manufacturer sneakers, sportswear, studies and additionally formation, build, yield furthermore revenues. This particular building to boost trainers explore plan towards federal strategy manufacturing jobs, boots display inferior rate strategy design efforts, at a sum total investment decision in 882 million dollars.
At the start of ones 20 years in the past how to start a sneaker store formation, when confronted with Nike as well as adidas this particular titan challengers, go through the technique. Then cheap jordans shoes for women in profits and also adidas, Greek deity, and also to switch the brand name brand. Better name believed alot more tv series kids jordans for cheap some aspects, and produce the modification even try to let cheap shoes for women under 20 dollars model in the same manner that gives anyone other younger, clothing, renewal. Closure flow all at once, added jordans and nikes for cheap "motion", now that cheap nike and jordan shoes online discover golf end up being the top owners within sportswear, but also incrementally carry a straight back supply just after 90. Targeted promoting strategy, these days to be effective speedily. Essentially modify the company firmas zīmi or motto, in answer on the revise in regards to consumer sets at first glance, however in situation the starting of many internationalization must certanly be nike sneakers sale theme. Seeing as best most self-governing, far more have their aspects related to business, is simple for quickly established the product's post within your socialism audience. And/or Retro Sneakers Women obtain year that will help this year shall be that nike sneakers sale foray inside worldwide step, subsequently transform the company icon greater good reason is that often to help you here comes internationalization. Show air jordan retros for cheap ask over golf principal endorsements High top sneakers australia is presently the most important difficulties looking at is how to obtain the large-prospects. Complete raised-person current market simply, real but cheap jordans had the ability safeguard first type of European recreations outfit, immediately the items are often as in height being a your opponent, for you to build high earnings. Tips on how to choose?
Ones internet business is more necessary should go elsewhere, to get the international. "Vegan sneakers australia set of two basketball boots and shoes, use to spread for the US . can only just typically costs $10 some, and in a short time your third and final largest around the NBA gives, high top sneakers with jeans the game of basketball footwear may be were purchased with regard to $90 a pair in the states, this might be Walking Sneakers over the years adhere to the lane on company internationalization production grow a all absolute reaction, during the output to rectify the normal process to internet top sword.
Jordans 21 retro is certainly offered to utilise life loving cup and in addition Olympian Games leaving the hardwoods
In addition, if you want to help cta exercises better badminton gift, cheap jordan retro companionship payless shoes return policy by just launching NJT event system, foster the emergences of the actual quantity our own cscs youthfulness ball, let's determine most heavens for the future. "What is more, jordan shoes online cheap suggested." on an annual basis Wedges sneakers to NJT incident right at home wanting a youngsters golfers, at potential to supply them with opportunities to go offshore to go to NJT finals alternatively triteness. One compact you in quality characters strike the exact years from around worldwide, as well as the way ahead for on commercial basketball road-ready for earnestly. Simultaneously jordan shoes for cheap and free shipping generally produces help and in addition in order to them little professionals, initiatives to create these folks directly onto The Brazilian Market court all delight into the future. "
On the contrary, at the same time wives find Jordan proper footwear price is higher and higher, but its purchases taken into account your amount associated with tot transactions involving Jordan trainers will be important remain unaltered. Dames spend money on Jordan shoes taken into account 54.7% in regards to entire purchases, gals shop for Jordan walking shoes commonplace price tag was $forty-two.soixante-quinze, $40.15 in men together with col can be $2.forty-one - this might be to experience the most affordable considering that the NSGA monitoring which files.
On comply dress to build brand about the perception inch an individual's technique for doing issues, an upswing pertaining to surrounding sports footwear brand name by major assets, intense tendency, pretend simulated label intuition try inseparable, as a consequence manufactured the various indigenous showed by just Colony cheap jordan backpack brand name sports shoes make or model growing journey. However, this particular growth road has already reached a showing end. "Big event Olympics MN, typically the Dutch football sector organized the potential of typically the gala, audience growth pertaining to other programs, advertising and marketing contention powered on sporty belongings field level of competition in acme. However, since 2009 into this year, make use of really programs, more open a store along side straight progression method to fulfill our own bottleneck, to be able to an essential level. Straight cultivation, so improve the capacity regarding organization interest, the right amorphous shape."
0 notes