#pllos theories

[mysoulisnotugly]

where are noa’s, tabby’s and imogen’s fathers? we didn’t get an explanation for them right? how come all five of their mom’s had kids at the same time? we probably won’t get an answer to that but it’s pretty weird to me

[disneydeb1928]

Crazy PLL Original Sin Theory #2

So, one of my biggest questions going into this show was how they were going to explain this villain going be "A". Like, it's not as if Millwood is on the complete other side of the country. It's literally 30 minutes down the road from Rosewood. Yes, I understand it's probably supposed to stand for Angela. But, you expect me to believe that not a single person will think it's strange that when this all comes out into the open that this Masked Man who has been terrorizing this young group of girls is using the same exact moniker as hooded/coated/uber variety from down the road, that no one is going to find that strange?

So. I wanted there to be some type of explanation, though I didn't want to get my hopes up.

Angela Water's mom, Rose was in Radley Sanitorium from very early 2000 to when it closed down (around 2012) before being released. Girl was there for the entire saga: Cece/Charles, Bethany Young, Marion Cavenaugh's death, the 10,000 breakouts, Jessica DiLaurentis's visits, Mona's stay after the first "A" reveal, Spencer's psychotic break after Toby's supposed death, Aria's stint as a candy striper, Mona going back after confessing to shooting Wilden.

Goodness.

If she's still alive and well, she literally got an entire play by play on masterpiecing gaslighting, gatekeeping and girlbossing from the queen of the alphabet herself, Mona Vanderwaal. I wouldn't be displeased if this was how they chose to explain this part of the story.

[sparklinpixiedust]

There's something up with Madame Giry.

Could she be Rose waters? Her character is so... different? Odd? Like idk, there's something off about her.

Also she was weirdly calm giving Faran that part back again.

She's hated (?) Faran from the start , but once Faran got those medical reports and had turned against her mother she was suddenly sorta okay?

I don't think she's A, but there's definitely more to her.

[tabbyadams]

the way mouse had a burner phone and texted her mom like A??!!!!! are we supposed to ignore that or is it a trick to get us to think she’s A

OH. I did not ignore that. Mouse is on my suspect list. I love her, but I just can't figure out some of her motivations - for example, connecting with a random (was it?) strange man whose child was taken from him to what end?

May I also point out, she may have gotten that burner from Steve's work place, which makes me also wonder if she didn't pick Steve for his access to electronic devices, such as burner phones and surveillance equipment...

[vicontheinternet]

FYI in terms of years pllos takes place in 2021. They jump from 1999 and present day and the jump between there is 22 years. Also the girls are 15 mouse said she’s 15 so assuming they are all in the same grade they are all 15 meaning they were born in 2006 presumably and they are sophomores.

[mydearmanda]

So for some reason I feel like Archie Waters is Imogen’s dad. The way Rose Waters looked at Imogen at the soup kitchen was weird. If I’m right it would make The Season One finale more f*cked up.

[unmasking-a-theories]

'Minnie Mouse is the Mastermind Theory '

This crazy theory has been stirring around in my mind .. so we know so far this show loves referencing movies and playing homage to a lot of them so what if they decided to do an orphan twist and by that I'm talking about the Movie Orphan ,now if any one has seen that movie you know in that movie the girl being the orphan is actually a grown woman who looks like a kid.. So my theory is what if Mouse is actually much older than she really is but looks like a teenager .. who actually was the girlfriend of Angela Waters and is now going back to Millwood to get revenge on the mothers /daughters but the one doing the killing is her true love Angela Waters .. this dynamic duo could be revealed as the A team ... now to make this theory work , the moms probably knew Angela liked girls but never met the girl Angela was dating .. I mean it would be an awesome twist !!!! what do you guys think ???

[superduperkas]

God damnit. Pretty Little Liars Original Sin got me and pulled me in after I promised never again

Anyway

I think Kelly is dead and not Karen. I think Imogen was right when she called "Kelly" Karen at the dance. They switched spots so Karen could have a front row seat to Imogen being humiliated. And of course Imogen would know the difference between Karen and Kelly because Karen was her best friend

[comeplayandgoaway]

PLL OS Theory - Kelly and Mouse are the killers

Kelly - she wanted to get out of her sisters spotlight, and she also wants to be top of the social ladder so the other girls need to back off

Mouse - she is really 30 (born 1992) but she just looks young (genetic disease ala Orphan (2009), so allowed her to pass as a young teen and be adopted by her moms. Her older sister was Angela, who was killed by the mothers. She's seeking revenge ala Prom Night (1980), so she's killing the daughters.

[marieevestudies]

ok i know this blog has not been a pll blog in years but i have literally not seen anyone address the fact that eddie lamb is going to be in pll: original sin ??? i cannot be the only one freaking out about this

[darkjosie]

pll fans!!

chandler is doing in person AND virtual m&gs!!

[veronikaa2]

When Angela takes blame for the weed, the janitor takes her to his service building or sth like that.. Could it be, that he raped her, she gave birth to the child on that party and thats why A has his/her secret layer on school property? Because the janitor took angela, who survived the fall, in with the child and now they all work together?

[disneydeb1928]

Crazy PLL Original Sin Theory #1

All of the boyfriends are working with "A" and the Masked Man.

Pay attention, because most of the time, "A" only uses a piece of information to mess with the Liars and their mothers after one of the boys (Ash/Henry/Chip/Shawn) has learned it first.

This is in deep contrast to the original PLL where most of the time we would learn the liars secrets from "A" themselves and then have to wait for the character's to explain in more details what exactly that secret means in context.

[sparklinpixiedust]

So what was up with crazy Joe? If he wasn't A, then why was he acting so weird?

And was that really Angela's corpse or someone else's?

[tabbyadams]

If you’re right and there’s henchman older A and leader younger A that makes me question even more if A killed Tyler out of some weird protection for the girls OR if it’s literally just to frame them for murder

why not both? @wandering-astral-spirit suggested that older -A/younger -A could be a mother/daughter team, and that just blew my mind cause it would be absolutely brilliant.

it would play into the generational trauma theme of the show, and it would explain why sometimes masked -A seems protective of the girls in their own twisted way. masked -A interrupted a very uncomfortable moment between Tabby and creepo Wes, killed both Karen and Tyler, and stopped Marjorie from continuing to ruin her own daughter's life by pinning her drug abuse on Noa.

it doesn't mean mastermind -A can't use all of this to control the girls, keep them quiet and finish their team's mission.

[vicontheinternet]

The fifth signature in the visitor log is a guy. Eddie said he recognized the four girls their moms but their was a fifth signature and he didn’t say anything abt it. Was it because it wasn’t a girl and they were talking specifically abt their mom’s?