Undead Unluck Theory
Fengās Character Arc isnāt over - Possible Unfade Evolution
Iāve been thinking about this theory for a while and with chapter 191 partly confirming something for me I think itās time to write it down.
Basically: Start Investing in Feng Kowloon stocks.
Major Spoiler Warning all the way up to chapter 191 of the manga.Ā
This theory initially spawned after chapter 177 came out. More specifically, it spawned from the spread panel that showcased the current union members (minus Chikara, Sean, and Yusai who were shown to be in the operating room with Latla and Rip).
Here it was shown that Feng was not with the other union members. Earlier it was hinted that he didnāt join because he wasnāt with them when the group time skipped from 1999 to 2015.
At the time I had suspected that Feng simply hadnāt time traveled with everyone else and had used those 15 years to train (taking advantage of Unfade) and mightāve rejoined later, but no, turns out he hasnāt joined the Union at all.
Which made me ask this: why didnāt Feng join the union? It wouldāve been easy for Tozuka to write a little panel or two where Fuuko couldāve said, āok sorry I lied to you, I promise this time weāll fight monsters this time thoughā and Feng couldāve begrudgingly agreed to join at that point.
The thing with Undead Unluck is that Tozuka has a habit of constantly setting up minor plot details and then giving them major payoffs later on. Itās one of the best parts of the mangaās writing in my opinion. So I believe Feng not joining the union at this point of time was a very deliberate writing choice on the author's part.
So with that in mind, letās get started.
Current Quest Rounds
Currently, there are four quests active.
Letās take out āCapture of UMA Burnā. It's not relevant for this theory. What matters for this theory are the quests for Language, Beast, and Summer.
Language and Beast have relevance because of their rewards. Four extra seats added to the round table means four negators can participate on quests. But thatās all they can offer for this topic.
Summer, on the other hand, is extremely important. Because in loop 100, Summer was the exact quest Feng got his formal debut in.
My prediction is that in a direct parallel to loop 100, the 101 version of the Summer quest is where weāre going to get reintroduced to Feng, and probably get told that heās been up to for the last fifteen or so years.
What follows is that one of the union members will tell Feng about the Sick fight, to which he will be extremely disappointed to have missed out on. Itās at this point that upon learning thereās more of these extremely strong UMAs that heāll go, āFine, you win Fuuko Izumo, Iāll join your Union.ā
My guess is that, assuming that Fuuko successfully recruits the five negators Andy led her to, the open seats will go as following:
- Feng
- Top
- Tatiana
- Latla/Julia
This is because the first three are more suited to go straight into combat roles. As for Latla and Julia, I think the last seat could go to either one of them. It depends on whether Julia manifests Unjustice during this quest period but if she doesnāt, Latla can now fight directly due to being equipped with one half of Blade Runner.
This would leave Ichico, Nico, Kururu, Haruka, Bunny and Julia/Latla (aka the one who didnāt get the seat) as support members until new seats are rewarded.
Itās extremely important to note that at this point Feng isnāt part of the Union because he cares about protecting people or saving the world.
Despite him acknowledging Shen as his son, Feng still prioritizes his quest of being the strongest more.
Unfade Intermission (AKA Billy Would Kick Feng's Ass if they fought Right Now)
This is where I talk about my thoughts of Unfade because this is where it would flow best.
(I am also going to put a quick disclaimer that this isnāt an invitation for power scaling arguments as they donāt have any relevance here.)
Anyway, Unfade, Fengās negation ability. In Fengās character bio in the volume 8 extras Unfade is described as a self-targeting compulsory activation type. āAn ability that Negates aging after activation.ā
ā¦ aaaand thatās all Unfade can do, really.Ā
In fact, Unfade stands out from other negation powers because from what weāve been shown it has no viability in combat. I think the only negation that shares this trait is Unsleep. The reason Feng is such a threatening person has to do almost entirely with his years of cultivating his skills as a martial artist (granted, having an ageless, unfading body which is forever at peak condition probably does help a lot but I digress). Itās worth noting that if Unfade had been given to almost any other person, they wouldnāt nearly be as dangerous as Feng is.
It is my belief that within the current negators, you take out their powers and make them fight purely hand to hand as normal humans? Feng comes out the strongest, if not pretty damn close to it.
However, the second that negation powers are added into the fray, Feng would lose his title as the strongest, and he would lose that title very quickly. In a negator fight with, say, Billy, he wipes the floor with Feng, easily. Feng having no idea how negator powers work is how Fuuko was able to keep him in check for so long in loop 101.
In UU, negation powers donāt get stronger via traditional training. In order to level up, the negator in question has to expand their interpretation of their powers.
By expanding their interpretation, this typically leads to the negator having a journey of self discovery about themselves. Inherently due to this system, a lot of times this means that negators evolving their powers tend to be directly tied into character development. Itās a neat system! One of my favorite power systems in SJ because of how naturally it ties together with the narrative.
But for Feng? This is the literal worst thing for him. Because even though heās a legendary martial artist, Feng has a terrible understanding of people. Heās the least emotionally intelligent person among the negators, and itās not even close. Shen, who was raised by Feng for around twenty years, notes that Fengās unending pursuit of strength hasnāt brought him any sense of fulfillment and that Feng himself isnāt even self aware of that fact.
Feng didnāt even realize he even had a negation tragedy until 150 years after his ability manifested. Even then, Shen (who, for the record, only found out about negations likeā¦ 15Ā minutes prior), had to spell it out to Feng.
Throughout loops 100 and 101, weāve seen how differently negation abilities can evolve. Negation abilities so far have tend to have fallen in three ways:
It has direct ties into character development and how they evolve as people (Unluck, Unchange, Unseen)
It has manifested differently due to the wildly different circumstances between loops (Unfair)
The negator have found ways to work around what would be entirely detrimental abilities to make them useable to get through day to day life (Unsleep, Untell)
The idea that Unfade has never evolved since manifestation ties pretty well with how stagnant Feng has been as a person throughout most of his life. In fact, while the circumstances of manifestation are different, Feng 100 getting UF as an old man vs Feng 101 getting UF when he was around his twenties, the ability itself hasnāt changed at all. Which definitely isnāt unique but it is worth noting, I feel.
Master Rule VII
Remember at the beginning of this post that stated chapter 191 partly confirmed something to me? Yeah thatās relevant now. This was the big clincher that inspired me to write this giant theory.Ā
Right now we donāt know exactly what Master Rule VII represents exactly (itās possible āTime Defenseā is just an attack name just like how Andy uses āCrimson Bullet"), however he is absolutely heavily time based if not outright time. My top prediction for him is that heās UMA Time or Fade. (For simplicityās sake, this theory will use āVIIā when it comes to referring to him.)
Anyway, assuming that weāre going in order of counting down, then naturally VII is next in the line up. Feng's first round as a union member means heās conveniently part of the quest period where, chances are, he might be a hard counter to the UMA that represents time in some capacity, as Unfade negates the passage of time affecting his body. Everyone in the Roundtable comes to this conclusion as well and thus Feng is signed up for the quest for the neutralization of VII. In this scenario, Shen would also be one of the negators in this quest, this is going to be extremely important.Ā
However as the actual fight begins, Feng turns out to not be a perfect counter to VII for one reason or another. This fight would end up being a struggle for everyone involved because VII would presumably use his time abilities to avoid hits and disorient everyone by time lagging them like how he did to Andy in 191.
During this fight, Shen is going to be in danger, and possibly get hit with a fatal injury before he can even react. Feng, witnessing this, is going to have one thought in his head, āShen is going to die.ā
āMy son is about to die.ā
And at that moment Feng recalls what Fuuko believes the meaning of being the strongest:
āThose who care for others with an unwavering heart have always been the strongest people around.ā
And Feng, after decades of not knowing what she meant, finally realizes what Fuuko was trying to tell him. And this, in turn, causes Unfade to evolve.Ā
Interestingly, Feng back in loop 100 is stated to figure out how souls worked, but this hasnāt come up since.Ā
And I think this would be a great opportunity to fire that Chekhovās Gun, because my friend (who also reads the manga) gave a really cool possibility on how Unfade could evolve into a combat viable ability by combining the idea of Feng mastering using his soul in combat.
The basic idea follows that by unleashing his soul in his impacts he would be able to make strikes that donāt fade away. Tying into the idea of how he only unlocks Unfadeās true potential when he opens himself up to the more metaphorical version of āthe impact he has on othersā and vice versa.
(Of course this is just one idea of how Unfade could evolve, I just really like this idea because it ties with UUās constant video game analogies, with Unfadeās evolution being akin to a damage multiplier like when you get a really good combo in a fighting game. Basically Tozuka would acknowledge Fengās a giant Tekken reference).
I know that negation abilities are classified with external or self targeting, but Sean alone proves that if you bend the rules enough, you can get away with not following those classifications to the letter.
Either way, this upgrade leads Feng to turn the tides against VII and complete the quest in a way that leads to the Union getting away without casualties. Maybe as a bonus we get Feng making a Shen-esq joke (like "Your rules are outdated, you old coot" or smth) to tie how much influence both of them have had on each other.
Also ideally Feng stops having the emotional intelligence of a goldfish and trying to fight Fuuko at a drop of a hat but that might be asking for too much, honestly.Ā
After the fight Feng would finally drop his tsundere bullshit and admits out loud (and to himself) that yes, he cares for Mei and Shen not just because theyāre his disciples but because he genuinely loves them as family.
This would also be the point heās marked as a true member of the Union because he now wants to protect his family.
57 notes
Ā·
View notes
alright now for the clover patch au portion of the poll-voted rambling!! this is gonna be a longer post but itās going to be an overview of how each clover feels towards the other (and a certain flower too :3)
(for reference, gold = genocide clover, soul = neutral route clover, and just clover is pacifist route/the main clover of this run. also, soul will be colored when referring to the character, while it will be the default color when referring to a regular human soul.)
cloverās thoughts:
clover -> gold
clover is Very Confused by gold. one of the first things they did was point a gun at their soul, but then they proceeded to teach them how to survive in the underground. peacefully, despite the clear signs of wear and tear on their clothes that clover is fairly certain would not just appear from traveling. sure, they can be bluntā¦ most of the times, but clover doesnāt have any reason to not trust them. theyāll justā¦ keep an eye on them for now. (though they doubt they could do anything against a real gun.)
clover -> soul
if clover was confused by gold, then clover feels that way about soul multiplied by about ten. they barely know how their soul works in general, then it just. suddenly contorts into their image. they find soul to be very spooky, even barring the lack of facial expressions and their inability to communicate without sign language orā¦ text boxes? clover is confident that they are pretty good at reading people, yet soul is quite literally a blank slate. the only emotion clover can manage to parse from them is anxiousness, if their jumpiness is anything to go by.
clover -> flowey
clover never got the chance to actually talk to the flower. although he seemed nice enough, goldās attitude towards him suggests that something isnāt as it seemsā¦ they would ask him about it, if gold and soul didnāt try to shoot him on sight every time heās attempted conversation.
goldās thoughts:
gold -> clover
ānaive. i canāt let them repeat my mistakes.ā
gold -> soul
āā¦a victim to this cycle. just like all of us, i suppose. at least they could break free in some way.ā
gold -> flowey
āheās planning something, i know he is. the underground isnāt right, and if iāve noticed that then he has too. i wonāt let him put our mission in jeopardy.ā
soulās thoughts:
soul -> clover
* a sign of hope. maybe theyāll be the one to break free. maybe they will never be trapped in the first place.
soul -> gold
* strange. the dust on them isā¦ worrying, though. just what did they do?
soul -> flowey
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO
* ā¦
* soulās finger seems to be glowing with energyā¦
15 notes
Ā·
View notes