Tumgik
#this will be followed up by more content from the ivey family
ariparri · 2 years
Text
Carson Ivey - Reintroduction
I’m here to reintroduce my boy after a long time of not making any official content with him! For all my old and new mutuals and followers, meet Carson Ivey, my second MC for Hogwarts Mystery and Veruca McQuaid’s childhood best friend!
❌ NO REPOSTING ❌
○■○■○■○■○■○■○■○■○■○■○
Tumblr media
Carson Ivey is a halfblood Scottish wizard, born on August 4th 1972. His father, Hudson, is a wizard and his mother Norah-Raylene is a muggle. Carson loves his parents greatly, and his mother fondly addresses him by the nickname Carsy. A name that Carson would take offense to if someone else called him that as that is considered a sacred name only his mother can use.
Carson grew up with Veruca, knowing each other when they were both five years old. Despite his parents' protests to the McQuaids paying for Carson's enrollment to attend the same performing arts school with Veruca, Elroy and Wilhelmina insisted it would be a nice experience for Carson since he showed an interest in music. Eventually the Iveys gave in when Carson said he wanted to learn how to play an instrument so he can play for them.
Out of all the instruments, Carson grew to love the violin. Carson has always been extremely responsive to music. He would sometimes cry like a baby listening to a moving piece of music. The violin is one of the most moving instruments he's ever experienced. It also helps that he was really drawn to the power of orchestral music from classic plays and the theater.
Other than classical music, Carson loves 80s rock music. His favorite bands and artists are Twisted Sister, Bon Jovi, Quiet Riot, and REO Speedwagon. Despite Carson attending a performing arts school, he lacks skills in singing. His singing is a bad, high key, out of pitch tune that can be heard from another room or down the hall. His parents love him too much to ruin his fun. Even Veruca and her family let him have his singing moments, with Wilhelmina joking that if that boy ever learns to sing perfectly that is not the real Carson. He even humors them that he has no intentions of ever learning how to sing. His bad singing is part of his character.
Carson is also a lighthearted prankster. He isn't too fond of magic related pranks, thinking some of them can go a bit too far. His pranks and jokes are meant to be for fun where everyone can laugh. Sure, the glitter prank he is most known for can get very messy, but he's always sticking around to clean it up after having a good laugh. If someone ever got caught in a prank set up for someone else, Carson will make sure that they're okay and will compensate if anything of theirs gets ruined or accidentally destroyed. One of his more lighthearted pranks is to wear odd and mismatched outfits to annoy Andre and even switch out Andre's clothes for horribly designed ones.
In Hogwarts, Carson has become adept in charms. And while he is decent with potions, he still sometimes botches the concoctions. Something he's always confused about since he follows the recipe exactly. He's not fond of Care of Magical Creatures due to how active the creatures get around him. A few occasions, the puffskeins would get loose and chase him around Hogwarts, once even cornering him completely in a room. It took more than Veruca, Rowan and Professor Kettleburn to get him out of the swarm.
Carson's closest friends besides Veruca and Rowan are Jae, Diego, Tulip, Tonks and Andre. Jae has become the group's handler in contraband and oddities, something Carson takes advantage of with his pranks. Of course, he pays using Veruca's money. Diego, it took some time for them to be friends since the two always bickered about trivial things like who was the better gentleman of the two.
31 notes · View notes
tardytothepardy · 5 years
Text
Alrighty!
So a few days back, I did a CAS makeover of various families in Oasis Springs, and I didn't want to repeat what I did last time. And thus, picture splicing. Through Ibis Paint. It's fine, it worked. I first did Katrina Caliente as a bit of an experiment:
Tumblr media
With Katrina's outfits, I wasn't really sure what I was going for. I don't have much of a connection to Katrina, but I tried to use her traits as somewhat of a guide. Her partywear is a dress from Perfect Patio that I'd never used, so I figured I could use it for her, and I think she looks nice in it.
By the way, in my game I saw that MC gave Katrina a bit of a story! She went off and got married to a grand master vampire named Colby Wynn (so now she’s Katrina Wynn), but before that she had a kid with Don named Samuel. Scandalous? Maybe not. Very interesting though. Now she lives across the road from the freakin Landgraabs. She’s living the high life now.
Nina:
Tumblr media
One thing I thought was odd about Nina is that the chick got abs, even though if you have her clean a kitchen counter she's complaining due to her lazy trait. How and when did she get these abs?
At any rate, I decided with her athletic outfit that she would be dragged to the gym by Don or Dina (bc they're athletic or whatever) but all she would do is take pictures of herself in her leggings. Maybe make fun of someone falling on their face because she's like that. I do really like how she came out, though.
MC tried to make Nina a freelancer, but I didn’t think that suited her lifestyle, so I gave her a part time job in retail, which is probably perfect for her hot-headed and lazy traits. 
Dina:
Tumblr media
I also struggled with Dina a bit, but it was mainly because of her hair. I kept it short, but that meant that there weren't really a lot of options for her. I like to think about whether you could realistically have a hairstyle with a certain hair length, and since I very recently used to have hair that length, I knew that a bunch of hairstyles would be too long for how her hair is.
It would've been fine if I wasn't such a stickler for these kinds of things.
MC didn’t do anything with her, which was fine. I’m currently trying to have her pursue and complete her mixology aspiration. Right now she just needs to get a few more promotions and she’ll be fine. Except for that ‘make three drinks during a social event’ which I’m not so keen on. I rarely throw parties in The Sims (or at all really) because they’re so stressful and I’m too occupied with too many things. It’s not optimal. But I guess I’m gonna be doing that sometime soon.
Don:
Tumblr media
I'll admit that I do not generally like Don Lothario as a character. The fact that, in The Sims 2, he would pee in the shower and leave puddles that he would never clean up was like a personal insult. How dare he.
In The Sims 4 though, Don just comes off as a bit more... Chad? I'm not sure if that's quite right, but his og hair reminds me of when I was in 5th grade and all the boys had their hair like that and they thought they were the fucking shit. They were not.
I dressed him with the main thought of "Yeah, he would dress like that," and it was fine. I'm not 100% sure about his everyday though. I might end up changing that later, but for now I'll keep it.
Part of me wanted to give Don the athletic career, but then I remembered how I filled the house with toddlers, so someone had to be at home. I had already given Dina and Nina jobs, and I still have the ‘Don Lothario does medicine’ idea stuck in my head from the Sims 2, so I put him in the freelance programming career, because I’ve never done that before.
I really haven’t dabbled with many of the careers, if I’m being honest. It’s probably because I keep jumping from save to save, so I don’t get around to finishing things. Oh well. 
After that I just had to do the Landgraabs. I didn't include Nancy's athletic wear because it was basically the same as before- it was a white tracksuit, except now it doesn't have any orange on it. It's completely white except for her shoes.
Nancy:
Tumblr media
My thought process for dressing Nancy was really vague. I wanted to keep that bright, crisp color palette that she has, but still incorporate that “I am not fucking around here” energy that I get from her. Don’t ask about the hair though. I really don’t know what I was going with there. Sometimes I select hairs thinking ‘lol I never use these’ and then I end up having the Sim use it, and that’s what happened with Nancy. I’m not sure she really deserved it, but it’s gonna have to be fine.
I also kept out a picture of Geoffrey, but it was his sleepwear. I didn't have a problem with it, so I kept it.
Geoffrey:
Tumblr media
As far as Geoffrey's new outfits go, I feel like I was going for a very "grandpa" look for him, and it made me think about the dynamic that Geoffrey and Nancy would have. I used to think that Nancy was this powerhouse that would stop at nothing to get what she wants, including the law, and that Geoffrey would just be quietly standing by trying to raise Malcolm to be a respectable Sim (which he is not), but from looking at other people's stories, I feel like Geoffrey would be 100% aware of Nancy's criminal aspirations, and would mostly (with his experience as a Secret Agent) make sure that anything going on in his family would be kept on the down-low.
Because he married into the Landgraab family. It's not like he held the Landgraab legacy and Nancy's ambition and drive won him over and she married into it. He knowingly married into the family, for whatever reason. Did he want the financial stability? I mean, that always helps. I still think that he would want Malcolm to be successful, earn a degree in something (knowing Malcolm it'd probably be Villainy) and raise a family of his own, but Geoffrey isn't stupid.
I imagine that he would like it if him and Nancy had a better relationship with Johnny, seeing as he's their son too, but you can't have everything.
Malcolm:
Tumblr media
Finally, at the end of everything, we have Malcolm Landgraab. If his outfits don't scream "prep rich boy", then I did something wrong, because that was 100% what I was going for. He doesn't have enough muscle to be like a "frat boy" or something, but if you caught him in his athletic wear, you would just know that it's worth more money than you'll make in a year, and he has at least three of them that all look the same.
With his everyday, I was keeping in mind that story from Geoffrey wanting Malcolm to be successful and pursue uni. Clearly he would be in Foxbury, because to be in Britechester would be a deeper disgrace than Johnny straying from the Landgraab path. Do you really think Nancy can make another heir now? There's some pressure on Malcolm for sure.
3 notes · View notes
adamwatchesmovies · 3 years
Text
Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992)
Tumblr media
“We did it again!” Home Alone 2: Lost in New York is one of the most sequel-y sequels you’ll ever see. It’s preposterous and contrived - that's saying something considering the hoops the first adventure had to jump through. If you didn’t like the surprisingly successful 1990 family comedy, there’s nothing here for you. If you place Home Alone among your holiday classics, and you want to mix it up by seeing the Wet Bandits get hit in the head by different things… this could be a way to satisfy your craving without watching the exact-exact same movie… again.
One year after the events of Home Alone, the McCallister family are on their way to a vacation in Miami when Kevin (Macaulay Culkin) winds up on the wrong plane and lands in New York. With his father’s credit card, he treats himself to a personal vacation at the prestigious Plaza Hotel. Meanwhile, Harry (Daniel Stern) and Marv (Joe Pesci) have escaped from jail and bump into their young nemesis as they are preparing to rob Mr. Duncan’s toy store, whose namesake is getting ready to donate all of the till’s contents to a children’s hospital.
Like the previous movie, the bulk of the running time is dedicated to Kevin indulging in his fantasies. This time, he’s got "unlimited" cash to order violent movies (a sequel to Angels with Filthy Souls titled Angels with Even Filthier Souls, once again starring Ralph Foody), junk food, room service, and have the hotel’s pool all to himself. There’s a new “Boo Radley” in the form of a pigeon lady living in Central Park (Brenda Fricker) - her story is virtually identical to Old Man Marley’s - and a couple of new antagonists - stupid adults working at the hotel. Using the same kind of trickery as before, Kevin makes fools out of the Plaza Hotel’s concierge (Tim Curry), the bellhop (Rob Schneider), and the desk clerk (Dana Ivey). They’re good for a couple of laughs but you never believe any of their scenes.
And finally, we get to the trademark traps. Kevin tricks the Sticky Bandits (formerly Wet Bandits) into following him into a slapstick house of pain. Marv and Harry get roasted, electrocuted, skewered, clobbered, and pulverized. It’s the exact same thing as before but different because it’s in New York this time?
Home Alone 2: Lost in New York made me laugh. Tim Curry is quite enjoyable. There’s Christmas sentiment aplenty. Seeing the bad guys howl in exaggerated agony as a preteen lays waste to them through impossibly assembled pitfalls tickles the ribs once more. I still can’t give it a pass. This movie is lazy. It literally repeats what we saw before beat-for-beat and isn’t self-aware enough to justify its copy-paste plot. Between you and me, however, I own this on Blu-ray and watch it every couple of years around Christmas time. It’s a guilty pleasure. (On Blu-ray, December 21, 2019)
Tumblr media
3 notes · View notes
drooliasnott · 5 years
Text
Return To Dust, My Love
Tumblr media
Very recently, the last few evenings of my relaxation time have been spent languorously re-digesting my views as an adult on the Barry Sonnenfeld feature films, The Addams Family (1991) and The Addams Family Values (1993), based on the original characters by artist Charles Addams. Although there have been many adaptations over the years of the distinctly macabre and darkly wonderful family life of the Addams clan, no other cinematic versions grasp the mythology quite like these movies do. And in light of the brand spanking new trailer for the 2019 animated feature, which I admit had caught me completely off guard and a little alarmed, I thought no better time exists than now to delve back into exactly what kind of black magic it is that makes this source material just so enjoyable and unique. 
Though the Sonnenfeld films are nearly undeniably the jewel of the franchise, one cannot examine the Addams Family appropriately without appreciation for its origin. The energy and attitude generated at its inception by Charles (Chas) Addams for The New Yorker in the late 30′s feels unique even for the time. At 150 single panels, the original comic was a divisive satire on the modern 20th century family that was not only cheeky and clever, but also at times very beautifully rendered. Chas himself was an enthusiastic if not sometimes obsessive artist, often described as drawing with “a happy vengeance.” The through line of the story continues to this day to be positive relationships found within a family. All this plus a heavy splash of aristocratic dignity thrown into the mix, and The Addams Family has proven from the beginning to be a very distinct and sometimes even delightfully surprising blend of flavors. 
Tumblr media
 Despite the fact that Chas Addams had already well established his characters by the time he came in contact with writer Ray Bradbury, their connection is felt in every further adaptation of the title. While Addams continued to serialize his strip in The New Yorker, Bradbury separately had begun his own endeavor in creating a monster family of sorts, The Elliotts, beginning their narrative with the short story “Homecoming” in 1946. All tales concerning the Elliotts involve the clan slowly gathering together in a mysterious house at the top of a hill, while each short focuses more intimately on the powers of a different, particular family relative. All Elliot stories were later collected in a book, From The Dust Returned, published in 2001, but portions of it have existed in different publications long before then, most notably Bradbury’s famous The October Country. Finding a kinship between them, Addams and Bradbury discussed a potential long-format collaboration, though unfortunately this never came to fruition. However, Addams did supply an original illustration for Bradbury’s “Homecoming”, which is still in use as a dust cover today. The striking resemblance the Elliott House shares with the Addams house is but one of many aesthetic touch points which will last for the rest of the series.  
Tumblr media Tumblr media
The groundwork for the series was strong enough to launch several adaptations over the subsequent several decades, finding more palatable viewing content in the mostly forgettable and very safe 60′s television show, which was plain enough to get the Addams Family strip banned from The New Yorker for banal taste, until editor William Shawn’s retirement in 1987. Meanwhile, the 70′s offered an explosion of further efforts to market the title to children and average american joes, producing TV specials and animated crossovers to mixed results.  
It wasn’t until the 90′s when Orion, who by then had inherited the production rights, decided to begin work on a feature film. With a simple return to the story’s roots, the company assigned first timer Barry Sonnenfeld to direct 1991′s The Addams Family. The process was fraught with setbacks and pitfalls, and when the budget rose too high for the struggling company to justify continuing further, the decision was made to sell the film to Paramount, who finished the production and handled distribution. Though it was also met with mixed reviews, it was commercially successful enough to merit the stranger, longer, and bizarrely even brighter sequel, The Addams Family Values. 
Returning to the core of what made the original content special, both 90′s films focused heavily, if not borderline exclusively on matters of familial struggle. However, unlike many of the earlier adaptations, the 90′s films also took great care to place special emphasis on elements of the family which do function well, something which is delightfully counter-intuitive overall. A particular portion of that credit goes to the fantastic casting of the films, the warm and vivacious Raul Julia as the erratic, sensual, and often charmingly innocent Gomez, Anjelica Houston as the ageless, witchy, white-marbled Morticia, Christina Ricci as the irreverent, sharp-witted outlier Wednesday, and Christopher Loyd as the bug-eyed, emotionally un-tethered uncle Fester all make for a very difficult call on whose performance is best above all. Dana Ivey is a delight to hate as Margaret, and Judith Malina is a joy to laugh at as Grandma, but it is really the core cast that shines beyond any previous actors, and it is because of this chemistry that the family relationships can really resonate. Two dynamics in particular stand out as specifically exceptional;
Tumblr media
GOMEZ AND MORTICIA ADDAMS
Opposite most long term monogamous relationships portrayed in media, Gomez and Morticia have a sustained romance which continues to burn more and more fiercely as time goes on. However, what makes their marriage unique as a film element is not necessarily their passion (and subsequently very active sex life,) but the equality found present within the marriage. They not only share common interests, (and possibly distant relatives?) but also take into consideration the same moral and social obligations. They value each other’s opinions, and both seek to create situations where the other can live as their best possible self. They are uninhibited in their public declarations of affection, and are adamantly devoted to their children, the family as a whole, and preserving the generations-long Addams way of doing things. They strongly adhere to old traditions, but as a couple they also are surprisingly malleable, attempting to navigate difficulties as a unit, though admittedly Gomez is occasionally a bit less good at doing this.
Gomez and Morticia consistently present a unified front to the Addams clan, and serve as the centerpiece in any scene they inhabit together, even in the very Ray Bradbury-esque gathering of Addamses for Uncle Fester’s surprise party during the finale of The Addams Family. The party is in celebration of Fester, but it is really Gomez and Morticia who serve as the jewels of the scene. It is the strength of their affection on which the emotional crux of the finale swings. What further enhances the succor of this particular relationship again falls to the actors, as time and time again Raul Julia shows a rending vulnerability in the way he portrays Gomez. It seems Gomez is still half-stuck in childhood, or maybe he lives in some tumultuous place inbetween as his innocent heart tet-a-tets with the passionate desires of a man. Morticia in turn seems ageless and timeless, a solid rock on which Gomez can throw his emotions again and again, and it is their intense and unique personality peculiarities that in the end fit them together in perfect harmony.  For a family as bizarre as the Addamses, their relationship is healthier than any other relationship found in canon, or in general just in film at large. 
Tumblr media
   WEDNESDAY ADDAMS 
An interesting blend of sociopathy, pragmatism, nihilism, isolationism, and just plain attitude exists in tandem inside Wednesday Addams. It would be too basic to call her an outsider, because though she is aware of her differences, she makes no effort to enhance, emphasize, or change them in any way. She differs even from the Addamses in her nuclear family, citing specifically in The Addams Family Values to her dorky crush Joel that if a man were to ever love her unconditionally, to devote his life completely to her, that she would pity him. This seems a direct call-out of her father Gomez, the coldness of which is both cutting and fitting. She follows up by rebuffing Joel’s clumsy advances with saying she would murder that same, loving man. A literal death threat is as true to her character as much as it is a dime-turn from her behavior towards Joel in the film leading up to that moment. As a young woman, she has already begun to clearly define herself as free and independent, even within the context of the family.
 Wednesday’s views on the relationship her parents share is one of cautious distance, while she also still has her own loving, healthy relationships with both parents individually. Though they love one another, in almost every case Wednesday tends to slant slightly darker, taking the more macabre path of her own accord in a family already well-suited to that kind of thinking. She is both sharper and wittier than her father, and crueler than her mother, and often interacts with Pugsley as if he were a sort of accessory at worst, or sidekick at best. She shows him solidarity as an Addams, but also constantly tries to expunge him so she can be the only child, which is a vendetta she furthers at the birth of Pubert in The Addams Family Values. Many comparisons have been drawn to similar characters of the time, of Lydia from Beetlejuice and Nancy from The Craft, but I would argue Wesnesday’s alignment falls closer to the Daria camp, as she is already firmly established in her thoughts about the neutral impact of family, the trouble with idiot boys, and the negative experience of outside society. Wednesday is purely independent, and resonates a sense of deep internal knowledge and self-worth that extends beyond the parameters of her identity as merely an Addams, and in that way she makes a strangely excellent role model. 
Following the success of both The Addams Family and The Addams Family Values, the series moved on to a saturday morning cartoon of parallel quality with the animated Beetlejuice cartoon. A following additional live TV series, The New Addams Family, also made it to broadcast, but the opinion of most viewers is that the entirety of it should be thrown in a river and destroyed forever. A cancelled Tim Burton adaptation also briefly existed, counteracting the 90′s film aesthetic which seemed pretty much already to be a restrained version of his personal flavor of set design. This leads to today, and the beginning of this meta, when this afternoon I saw the trailer for the 2019 CG animated reboot of the franchise, inexplicably also titled The Addams Family.
Though I respect the nature of some reboots, stylistic updates for one thing seeming somewhat necessary to keep old content fresh, the new trailer immediately had me skeptical. Though the new designs very closely resemble Chas Addam’s orginal designs from The New Yorker strip, something vital seems to be missing, and there is a strange liberty taken with some of the new character models which feels disharmonious, and even borderline disrespectful. And though The Addams Family has a rich and storied history of zany one-liners and satirical cheekiness, the lines delivered in the trailer seem to fall flat. Though many series in this franchise in past have been saltine cracker level boring, one would expect a reboot this late in the game in the popular Pixar-launched CG style would be an opportunity to inject new life back into the old series. But something seems off, and this in turn brings me at last finally back around to the 90′s films. 
The reason the Sonnenfeld 90′s films were good is easy; they have a subterranean classiness. Pulling Bradbury back into it, the earliest and best iteration of the series is infused with a rich, sensual, and genuine darkness. Bradbury's stink is all over the films, from the set design to the Addams Family reunion ball, to the serious performances given to obscene, ludicrous roles and a questionably weak script, by very talented actors. The suburbs seem more ridiculous when the pastel, unfeeling beastliness of uniformity is stood up next to dark, dank, meaty, loving weirdness of oddballs. To make satire work, one has to play a game of balance. Without salty, sweet will never taste quite right, but balance in storytelling has many levels. Visual balance is one thing, but one must also have careful emotional balance. The 90′s films maintain an underlying level of sincerity and integrity, which is what is required to counter the punchy, often goofy scripts and scenarios. The films were good because they had just as much heart as the Addamses themselves, and without heart, a movie will never have any true substance. 
The track record this franchise has with creatively successful projects is pretty poor, but one can hope the example of cult excellence set by the 90′s movies will infuse into some part of the future film, and maybe into further projects later down the line. Voicing your opinion on pop culture subject material is something I believe in as a means to guide new content created in the future, so if you have thoughts on the new movie after it airs, let the world know! Help create the kind of content you want to see in the world by building a healthy, respectful discourse. Only time will tell if the 2019 Addams Family will be any good, but I’ll keep watching till then.
Tumblr media
If you enjoyed reading this, drop me a line and let me know! I’m considering writing more meta for other films, and have dabbled up until this point with TV meta, so if you’d like more content in this vein I’d be glad to hear it. Suggestions welcome, though no timetable is attached. Thanks for reading!
98 notes · View notes
cover2covermom · 5 years
Text
*Books included in this batch of mini book reviews: Book Girl: A Journey Through the Treasures and Transforming Power of a Reading Life by Sarah Clarkson, Gods of Jade and Shadow by Silvia Moreno-Garcia, The Dragon Republic (The Poppy War #2) by R.F. Kuang, and The Great Alone by Kristin Hannah
#gallery-0-4 { margin: auto; } #gallery-0-4 .gallery-item { float: left; margin-top: 10px; text-align: center; width: 25%; } #gallery-0-4 img { border: 2px solid #cfcfcf; } #gallery-0-4 .gallery-caption { margin-left: 0; } /* see gallery_shortcode() in wp-includes/media.php */
» Book Girl: A Journey Through the Treasures and Transforming Power of a Reading Life by Sarah Clarkson
Book Girl is what I like to refer to as a “reading memoir.”  I love reading books by people who are passionate about reading & share their experiences with reading and the books that have shaped their lives.
I loved learning about Sarah’s journey & her connection to books.  We learn how Sarah & her siblings were encouraged by their parents to read, and how reading was a big part of their family dynamics growing up.  I think Sarah has excellent reading tastes, and will probably borrow the physical copy from the library to copy down all the reading recommendation lists.   *Spoiler alert: Sarah is a BIG fan of C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkein.*
Sarah is a beautiful writer and you can tell that she is a very educated woman.  Some reviewers found her a bit pretentious, but I did not get that feeling while reading Book Girl…. I’m wondering if this is due to the fact that I listened to this book via audiobook that was narrated by the author herself… Her tone in the audiobook did not come across as pretentious.
I gave it 3.5 stars because it was too heavily focused on religion & faith for my tastes.  Now, this rating should definitely be taken with a grain of salt.  Had I known this book was classified as “christian fiction,” I probably would have passed on reading it.  I am not one for books that are overly religious or faith centered as they tend to feel pushy & preachy to me.  Another criticism is that her book recommendation lists are lacking in diversity in regards to authors & content.  If you are looking for classic books by white men & women, you’ll find a plethora of them here.
> Recommended to: fans of christian fiction & bookworms
> Book Recommendations if you enjoyed Book Girl: I’d Rather Be Reading the Delights and Dilemmas of a Reading Life by Anne Bogel
» Gods of Jade and Shadow by Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Gods of Jade and Shadow was one of my most anticipated books of 2019.  When I heard that it was a Mexican folklore inspired fantasy set in Mexico during the 1920s, I could not wait to get my hands on it.  Historical fiction & fantasy mash ups are some of my favorite types of reads!  Did it live up to expectations?  Unfortunately it ended up being a bit of a disappointment for me…
Set in the 1920s, Gods of Jade and Shadow is about Casiopeia, a young girl that aspires to more than her current station in life.  Casiopeia is treated as a servant by her Grandfather & other male family members, but years for more.  After a series of events, Casiopeia must set off on a journey to help the former Lord of Mayan underworld, Hun-Kamé, reclaim various belongings in order to be restored to his former glory and defeat his traitorous brother.
With the fantastical elements & quest style plot, Gods of Jade and Shadow reads very much like a fairy tale.  As a reader I felt like I was listening to a story that had been passed down from generation to generation.  My favorite aspect of this book was that it was brimming with Mexican culture & folklore.
Casiopeia was a stereotypical Cinderella-type of character.  She waits on her Grandfather & cousin hand & foot while enduring their emotional abuse.  On one hand, Casiopeia was spunky & brave, but on the other hand she was impulsive & proud…  I had a hard time connecting with Casiopeia, thus having a hard time feeling invested in her plight.  
Despite Hun-Kamé being one of the main characters in the story, I do not feel like he was well fleshed out.  It was hard to feel the urgency of his dilemma when I knew little about him or his back story.  
I did not feel the romance in the story was believable or necessary.  I actually think the story would have worked much better without the romance sub-plot.
While I did enjoy the concept for the story, this book was lacking substance & development.  Gods of Jade and Shadow is a very plot driven story, but the focus was almost too plot heavy, which did not allow for enough character development.  The story line felt very jarring as we watch the characters bounce around from place to place.  I typically adore stories that include a journey/quest, but only if I get a strong sense of the setting, the characters, and the actions of the characters.  That did not happen for me in Gods of Jade and Shadow.  If I am being honest, this book felt very surface level.
> Recommended to: fans of fairy tale style novels; those interested in Mexican folklore
> Trigger/content warning: psychological abuse 
» The Dragon Republic (The Poppy War #2) by R.F. Kuang
After reading The Poppy War earlier this year, The Dragon Republic was another one of my most anticipated releases of 2019.  The Poppy War set the tone of the series with excellent world building, a unique magic system, an awesome school setting, and a gruesome war.  The Dragon Republic follows Rin post Third Poppy War as she must deal with the consequences of her decisions.  Not only is Rin racked with guilt, but she is also battling an addiction & struggling to control her powers.
I’m happy to report that there was no second book syndrome for this epic series! The Dragon Republic was an excellent follow up to The Poppy War.
If I had to classify this series, I’d consider it fantasy with a heavy military fiction feel to it.  While the bulk of The Poppy War is a military school setting & revolves around Rin’s education, the bulk of The Dragon Republic centers around Rin joining up with the Dragon Warlord with the intent of overthrowing the Empress & establishing a republic.  The Dragon Republic is full of military strategy, gruesome battles, political intrigue, brutality, and back stabbing.  While TPW was a dark novel, TDR is even darker.  Kuang really explores the effects of war on her characters.  You may find that many characters from the first book are not the same in this book. 
This series is just so damn good.  Highly recommend.
> Recommend to: fans of military fiction
> Trigger/content warnings: drug addiction, suicidal thoughts, & graphic violence
> Book recommendations if you enjoy The Poppy War series: Book of the Ancestor series; A Song of Fire and Ice series
» The Great Alone by Kristin Hannah
*4.5 Stars*
The Great Alone is about a a family’s journey to escape a father’s torment by relocating to Alaska.
Set in the harsh wild of Alaska in the 70s, The Great Alone was an excellent frontier/survival type of story.   I’ve always been fascinated by frontier style novels in which the characters must endure great hardship & show resilience in order to survive the land where they live.  I was engrossed watching Leni & her family grow and adapt.   The Alaskan setting of this book was my favorite aspect about this story.  Hannah paints a vivid picture of the Alaskan landscape in all its beauty and treachery.  Winter time would be the perfect time to pick this book up.
Themes included in The Great Alone include survival, coming of age, PTSD, domestic violence, family, & resilience.  This book was a roller coaster of emotion & heavy topics.  While reading I thought Hannah was going to go the cliche route a few times, but she kept on surprising me.  My only criticism of this book would be one particular portion of the ending.  It just didn’t feel believable, and felt too convenient.
> Recommended to: fans of survival/frontier stories; fans of dark family dramas; book clubs
> Trigger/content warnings: PTSD, domestic violence, & alcoholism
Book recommendations if you enjoyed The Great Alone: The Snow Child by Eowyn Ivey
Have you read any of these books?  If so, what did you think?
Comment below & let me know 🙂
      Mini Book Reviews: September 2019 - Part 2 #BookReview #BookBlog #BookBlogger #Books #Reading #BookTalk *Books included in this batch of mini book reviews: Book Girl: A Journey Through the Treasures and Transforming Power of a Reading Life…
0 notes
ywarsamebrock-blog · 6 years
Text
Audience Studies (3P18) Blog Post #2
    As a consumer of media, I have witnessed how the convergence of media technologies and the digitization of content has transformed the way in which audiences consume media in the 21st century. I have noticed that there has been a power shift in the media landscape as audiences are no longer simply consumers of content, but instead are active producers and consumers. The sports media industry embodies the nature of digital media as its unpredictable and disruptive nature filled with trade rumors and speculation has provided digital media with endless content. This blog will examine how sports media has been affected, an increase in audience power due to changes in viewing habits, the power of fandom as a driving force in content creation and the interactive nature of online media. In this ever-changing media landscape audiences are becoming producers of media and therefore disrupting the traditional media giants such as ESPN and ABC which relied on the production of mass media that relied on dominant hegemonies that are no longer enforced. This blog will examine my audience experience as an avid consumer of sports media online and highlight how audiences have become the major voice of the sports industry.
  When examining audience reception studies, it is always important to begin with context in which we consume media. This involves examining the spatial context, which the textbook describes as “the physical location” and the social context which is the people and relationships that are involved (Sullivan, 2013, p.63). As a long time consumer of traditional media, television has always been a staple of my family’s domestic life. I have many fond memories of the large analog television in my living room, which was often always displaying basketball games, that my family and I eagerly watched and discussed. I have noticed that traditional sports media thrived on selling the idea of media rituals which can be described as “a regular habitual activity, to ensure that audience was able to tune in to their sports coverage” (Sullivan, 2013 p.178). Looking back, it was interesting how sports media producers had conditioned me when it came to how they packaged their content as a media event, which was somewhat as symbolically important as a religious ritual. During the first week of June every year, the NBA finals was broadcasted and it involved the convergence of the basketball and celebrity world, which truly made it a media spectacle. I would eagerly anticipate and follow every game while shrouded in my religious attire that consisted of my favourite basketball jerseys and prayed to the basketball god’s that my team would prevail. Media rituals indoctrinated me and were responsible for all my opinions regarding my basketball knowledge. I agree with the textbook’s argument that media rituals are narrative focus with intense claims (Sullivan, 2013, p.252). At that time my fandom mainly consisted of my obsession with Michael Jordan as I was unknowingly being indoctrinated by sports media relentless promotion of Michael Jordan as he dominated the traditional news cycle. I felt a deep psychological connection with him as I remember begging my parents to let me visit the United center where the bulls often dominated other teams. However, a few years later, the rise of the internet would occur and my knowledge of sports media would ultimately transform as I would awaken from my indoctrination.
  The article from week 2 by Sundar and Limperos titled “Uses and Grats 2.0” brought up an interesting point on how the rise of the internet has allowed audiences to gain power as both producers and consumers of media. It argues that “While the role of gate keeping has historically been the domain of a privileged few, now anybody can serve as a gatekeeper of content on the Internet” (Sundar & Limperos, 2013). This is a very relevant quote in regards to my audience experience as during the ancient times before the internet, television was my main source of news regarding basketball. Therefore, it had the ability to serve as a gatekeeper of information which led me to naturalize its dominant ideologies that promoted Michael Jordan’s greatness. The rapid rise in media technologies has allowed me to control my viewing behaviors as I am now no longer relying on a media platform. When I think about how the internet has changed the content in which audiences consume media, I realize that I freed me from biased media agendas of traditional media outlets a I can now seek different perspectives.  The textbook introduced the concept of privatized spaces and the beliefs of Mackay and Ivey who argued that media technologies create privatized spaces where individuals retreat to their own spaces (Sullivan, 2013, p.242). I find myself agreeing with this argument as I often enjoy consuming my media when I am alone and in my room. However, it is interesting that the Article from week 8 titled by Kim, Cheong & Kim “The Influence of Sports Viewing provided an interesting contrast when it explained that audiences still enjoy consuming sports media in traditional settings, regardless of modern developments in technology. This means that although sports can be viewed privately on any mobile device, people are still enjoying the social aspect of sporting events which was a staple of traditional television.
  As a passionate NBA fan, I have spent many hours heavily involved in interpreting the sports media I consume. I have found that technology has freed audiences from being as mindless masses that do not have a voice. This is a stark contrast from the days of traditional television where, media giants controlled the narratives surrounding sports and audiences had no choice but to accept the messages that were presented. When it comes to fandom the textbook explains that theorist have agreed upon it consisting of two elements: the social aspect and the interpretive aspect (Sullivan, 2013, p.272-273). I can remember when my fandom was frowned upon as many people I knew considered my love for the NBA a bizarre subculture that existed under the shadow of the largely polarizing and more culturally relevant NFL. However, with the rise of the internet, the NBA is quickly overtaking the NFL in popularity as fans across the world have mobilized to bring NBA fandom to the forefront of the sports media and popular culture. Fandom is not only limited to the enjoyment and sharing of original text, the rise of the internet has allowed for audiences to take an active role in the interpretation of texts. As a frequent social media user, I have formed online communities with many other users who share the same level of fandom when it comes to the NBA.  I agree with the textbooks argument that fans can mobilize to demand change from content producers because I have been involved in a situation where I demanded change from the NBA. As an audience member I often do not enjoy when I see players exaggerating contact in order to have a foul called by the referee. Therefore, in order to have this unethical practice stopped, I took part in a guerrilla social media campaign in which my online community harassed many NBA players that feigned excessive contact. In the end it the guerrilla campaign was successful as many media members began to demand a response from the athletes, and ultimately led to the league office creating harsher fines for excessive contact. It could be then said that I had an active role in the creation of sports media content, as I helped create a new rule that has the potential to alter the text in a positive way.
  During the days of traditional sports media, the audience experience consisted of simply watching a televised game along with a broadcast that did not allow for any audience participation. With the rise of the internet, the audience experience has become broader as I find that the creation of fan fiction often supersedes the original text itself. The textbook described fan fiction as “short stories that are written in the creative universe of the original text” (Sullivan, 2013, p.205).  When examining the narrative styles of fan fiction, the two types of narrative fan fiction styles I use are refocalization, and genre shifting. I use refocalization because I often enjoy creating stories on basketball forums that focus on players that traditional media tends to overlook. This includes players that statistically underperform or play for smaller market teams that do not receive media attention. I find that a writer of fan fiction I also practice genre shifting because traditional sports media often only focus on the live event aspect of sports. However, it becomes obvious when one becomes undergoes the transformation from casual fan to fandom that the NBA holds great potential as a reality show due to the never-ending gossip and rumors that create an atmosphere of drama.
  The article from week 9 by Navar-Gill titled “Fandom as Symbolic Patronage” brings up an interesting point on how crowdfunding allows for fans to gain a special social position within their respective communities centered around their fandom. An interesting example of crowdfunding within the world of sports would be how Chicago Bulls fans recently crowdfunded a billboard in downtown Chicago demanding the firing of the general manager of the bulls. This highlights how fans can exert power when it comes to producing their own media texts because the billboard served as a paratext that also became part of the original text as the Chicago bulls acknowledged the billboard during their televised coverage. This was a show of political resistance towards the original text as it aligns with the argument that theorist John Fisk presented in the textbook that stated fans resist negative characterizations of fandom by establishing ownership through interpretive play with texts (Sullivan, 2013, p.270.
  The sports media world has been greatly affected by the digitization of content as audiences are now able to enjoy sporting events and any sports related media throughout a variety of online platforms such as YouTube and Instagram. This has resulted in audience fragmentation as viewers are able to time-shift their consumption and no longer rely on traditional television habits. However, the greatest advantage of digitization has been the ability for audiences to publish user generated content. The power to create user content has always existed but the rise of the internet allows for it to easily be dispersed to audiences. I often partake in the publishing of my own sports media content which involves my views on my favourite teams and my analysis on issues that dominate the traditional news cycle.  Although digitization and the online media landscape offer many benefits to consumers, traditional media outlets can exploit audience content and threaten intellectual property through labour exploitation. As a consumer of sports media, I have seen many instances where media companies such as ESPN routinely steal and publish user generated content without even crediting the interpretive communities that created them. An example of this would be the many original and thoughtful blog posts created by some of my favourite amateur sports enthusiasts that offer a unique perspective, which are then posted on traditional media platforms. I find this ironic because corporations are often quick to threaten legal action when it comes to their intellectual property. Ironically, when certain original texts such as photographs are reworked into memes and gain popularity, corporations are quick to incorporate them into their own content without giving credit. This has many audience members unsure regarding the issue of media ownership on digital platforms as it remains unclear whether digital media is simply a platform for distribution or a platform where audiences can retain ownership of content.
  In conclusion the rise of digital media platforms has transformed the way in which audiences consume media as it has allowed audiences greater power and a sense of agency.  As a social science researcher, the sports media industry has presented itself as an interesting case study when examining online media landscapes because its unpredictable and exciting nature has allowed for it to seamlessly transition from traditional to digital platforms. The rise in digital technologies has allowed for viewers to have greater access to sports media content, which in turn has strengthened their fandom and has transformed the audience experience into that of a participatory culture. The barriers that surrounded traditional sports media are slowly being eradicated as mainstream sports media is beginning to incorporate user generated content.  As an avid prosumer sports media, I urge my fellow audience members to make sure to self-credit any text you produce on digital media… it might just end up on the front page of ESPN.
0 notes
Text
Pasture Management 101: Starting a New Pasture from Scratch
New Post has been published on http://lovehorses.net/pasture-management-101-starting-a-new-pasture-from-scratch/
Pasture Management 101: Starting a New Pasture from Scratch
In general, the recommended stocking rate is one mature horse per 2 to 3 acres of land.
Photo: Adam Spradling/The Horse
In the first two installments of our pasture management series we talked about renovating established pastures. However, occasionally horse owners will find that it’s ultimately a better option to start the process from scratch. Factors to consider when doing so include facility design, rotational grazing, recommended seeding practices, and toxic weeds.
Plan Your Paddocks and Pastures
When designing a pasture for your facility, keep in mind the total number of horses your land can support.
“Many horse owners want to have pasture provide a majority of their horse’s nutrition, but often overstock the land,” said Jennie Ivey, MS, PhD, assistant professor and extension equine specialist at the University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture. Thus, they “use turnout time strictly for exercise while providing additional hay” for nutrition, she said.
In general, the recommended stocking rate—which allows for a horse to graze pasture without stressing the grass stand and prevents overgrazing—is one mature horse per 2 to 3 acres of land. While pastures in some areas might be able to maintain horses on less land, keep in mind that varying weather patterns, soil fertility, manure presence, and weeds will impact how much forage is available for the horse to consume.
“Consider implementing a rotational grazing system with a heavy-use area,” Ivey said. “Divide the total acreage for pasture use into one- to two-acre plots, with access to a central heavy use or ‘sacrifice area.’ ”
This system allows owners to let horses graze one plot until the grass is about 3 inches in height, then move to another pasture to allow the first plot to rest. Owners can continue rotating horses through the remainder of the plots (if available) until the first pasture reaches 8 inches in height, at which point the cycle can begin again.
Horses should always have access to the heavy-use area, making it a good place to provide water and shelter. As a bonus, this heavy-use area gives owners a turnout paddock if horses need to be kept off pasture, for instance, after heavy rain to prevent grass from being torn up or to limit grazing time.
Plant Your Pasture
Once you’ve designed your pasture layouts, conduct a soil test to help you select the ideal forage species for your region and soil type.
Then, you’ll need to decide how you’ll go about planting the new stand of forage: through conventional or no-till seeding practices.
“Conventional seeding requires preparation of the seedbed by plowing and disking the field to mechanically kill plants that may compete with new seedlings,” Ivey explained. “Once the seedbed has been prepared, then seed can be broadcast or drilled and cultipacked for optimal growth results.
“Alternatively, no-till seeding uses herbicides to remove any competition within the pasture,” she continued. “Then, a no-till drill is used to place the seed in contact with the soil at the appropriate depth.”
Ensure you plant (or have your pastures planted) at the proper time for the species of grass or legume you’ve selected. This is usually during spring or fall.
Other factors to consider include planting the right amount of seed, planting when moisture is available, and planting seed at the proper depth to ensure establishment of a good stand and plant survival. Your county extension agent or district conservationist can provide you with information on appropriate seeding dates, rates, and depths for your area.
Give the New Pasture Time to Grow, and Check for Weeds
Once you’ve planted your pastures, don’t let your horses enjoy them just yet, said Dewitt Simerly, a district conservationist with the United States Department of Agriculture’s Natural Resources and Conservation Service.
“When establishing pastures be certain to keep horses off the pasture area until the grasses can become established then control competition from weeds or undesirable vegetation,” he said.
Finally, inspect your pastures regularly for presence of weeds and plants that are toxic to horses and other hazards, such as broken fences, and have a plan in place for correcting the situation. Ivey advised owners to keep and special eye out to the following toxic weeds:
Buttercup (Ranunculus species, widespread across the country);
Jimsonweed (Datura stamonium, widespread across the country);
Nightshade family (Solanum species, across northeast, mid-west, southwest and southeast regions of the United States);
Pokeweed (Phytolacca americana, eastern United States); and
Poison hemlock and water hemlock (Conium maculatum and Cicuta species, widespread across the country).
Herbicides can be used to kill weeds but caution should be used to spray weeds at the right time and with the correct product and amount to be most effective.
But, “the most effective means to prevent weed presence is the establishment and maintenance of a good pasture stand,” Ivey said.
About the Author
Hope Ellis-Ashburn, MS
Hope Ellis-Ashburn, MS, lives with her husband and daughter near Chattanooga, Tennessee, where the family raises Black Angus cattle and hay on her husband’s family’s farm, which has been in operation for over a century. She is a former Extension agent, a current high school teacher, and has owned horses for more than 30 years. She currently owns a half-Arabian mare named Sally. She began writing freelance articles three years ago, authored The Story of Kimbrook Arabians, and posts a range of horse-related content weekly on her blog, Red Horse on a Red Hill.
0 notes
freewhispersmaker · 7 years
Text
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
"The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics" Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant…
View On WordPress
0 notes
artsvark · 7 years
Text
Sell-out musical RENT comes to Johannesburg
After sell-out shows in Cape Town, the award-winning Rock Musical, RENT, is coming to Johannesburg in a vibrant 20th anniversary production at Joburg Theatre from 28 April – 07 May. The original rock musical, composed by Jonathan Larson in 1996, was a Pulitzer Prize and Tony-Award winning masterpiece that changed the landscape of musical theatre. Previously featuring well-known actors such as Neil Patrick Harris, Rosario Dawson and Taye Diggs in various Broadway adaptations, including the 2005 feature film, the show has enjoyed on-going success with diehard fans being dubbed ‘RENT-heads.’ Inspired by Puccini’s classic opera La bohème, RENT tackles issues of homelessness, homosexuality, drug addiction and HIV and Aids.
RENT 
Directed by Byron Bure Choreography by Shona Brabant
CAST LIST:
MARK COHEN (Played by Dean de Klerk- 21): A filmmaker. Left behind his affluent Jewish upbringing to pursue his craft. Narrator: would rather tell the story than be the story. Hides behind his camera.
ROGER DAVIS (Played by Nicky Rossouw ): Former frontman for a rock band. Discovers he has AIDS in a note his girlfriend left when she committed suicide. Tortured artist – brooding and aggressive with a gentle side. Recovering drug addict. Searches for meaning through his song writing.
TOM COLLINS (Played by Arlin Bantam- 21): Philosopher, professor and AIDS activist. Former roommate of Mark, Roger, and Benny. Angel’s lover. The patriarch. Strong, yet warm presence.
BENNY COFFIN III (Played by Matthew Kriel): Went to college with Mark. Lived with Roger, Collins, Maureen and Mark. Married into a wealthy family. Hopes to fulfil dream of building an arts studio for his friends, while making money for his father-in-law.
ANGEL SCHUNARD (Played by Anzio September- 23): Drag Queen. Living with AIDS. Warm, lovable, nurturing, and honest. The mother hen of the group.
MIMI MARQUEZ (Played by Nadine Suliaman- 22): Fragile drug addict. HIV/AIDS positive. Puerto-Rican descent.  Exotic dancer at the cat scratch club. Sexy, sassy and street smart.
MAUREEN JOHNSON (Played by Emily Adair- 21): A performance artist. Not as good as she leads on. Lover of Joanne, Mark’s ex-girlfriend. Young, spunky, quirky and fun. Selfish and enjoys the drama of life.
JOANNE JEFFERSON (Played by Namisa Mdlalose- 22): Harvard grad, lawyer. Affluent upbringing. Comfortable with her artistic liberal way of life and conservative upbringing. Insecure in her relationship with Maureen. Politically connected. Dry wit.
FEMALE ENSEMBLE:
Bonolo Makhele
Jessica Kohler
Maya Spector
Robyn Ivey
Tammy de Klerk
Tara Macpherson
MALE ENSEMBLE:
Jaydon Farao
Keegan van Zyl
Leagen Phillips-Laws
Director, Byron Bure, highlights the significance of these issues, particularly in a South African context, as they are still very relevant today “Every day we see the divisive effects of nativism and intolerance which ends up in violent conflict between different communities. The story of RENT may be specific to the artists in New York`s Bohemian East Village in the early 1990s, but the theme of a community in crises and how they struggle to deal with it still resonates today.”  Bure stresses the importance of addressing these issues through art and performance wherever possible. “As South-Africans we often see the impulse to turn against one another when threatened by these external forces.  RENT challenges us to turn towards one another to weather a storm and to choose love and respect. In our fractured society, this is a message that desperately needs to be heard.”
While setting the bohemian scene, much like in the original, Bure’s production focuses on the group dynamics of the characters. “We spent a great deal of time analysing the characters and their needs within the piece, which informed how we were going to construct a production that best serves Jonathan Larson’s vision.  We set about finding actors that could embody the characters both physically and vocally.”
Having played to full houses in Cape Town and receiving rave reviews, RENT producer, Stephan Fourie, who is making his debut with The Stephan Fourie Theatre Company, believes the success of the first run is due to the vibrancy and relevance of the production.  “The feedback we received from Cape Town audiences was incredible. We had tons of comments on the energy of the cast, the fantastic choreography, the set, and significance of the shows themes. I am particularly excited to bring this sell-out sensation to a Johannesburg stage as the story holds its relevance today more than ever. RENT brings on a unified sense of community, making difficult themes and conversations more palatable, and we are now working hard to bring an even more spectacular production to Johannesburg this April. “
The cast members include award-winning theatre and performance artists from around the country, technically trained across musical theatre, acting, singing, dance and choreography.  Anzio September (23), who plays drag-queen ‘Angel’ has not only the challenge of performing dynamic dance moves in 4-inch platforms, but to also bring to life the true essence of one of the show’s most complex and lovable characters. “The role of Angel has made me realise that fear is the only thing that keeps us alive in this life. We are caged by normative thinking and what is deemed ‘socially acceptable’. If love and respect was at the core of humanity, peace would prevail and wars would be an unknown entity. One has to be true to themselves even if the world says no.”
Classical and contemporary singer and recipient of an invitation to audition for Juilliard Performing Arts School in 2012, Namisa Mdlalose (22) who plays the role of the brooding ‘Joanne’ echoes September’s sentiments. “RENT tells a story of a community of broken people begging to be loved, to be forgiven, to be seen, to be healed. Ultimately, we find, love wins.”
The Ultimate Rock Opera Taking on the task of the music itself is no small feat. RENT set the bar for rock musicals 20 years ago, quickly becoming the best-selling cast album of the decade. The musical score is technically a challenging one since it is a completely sung-through production.  Rooted in rebellion and protest, the show is a blend of soulful gospel, grungy rock and pop. Bure explains that the music is well- written but that it’s the place of the lyrics in the narrative that imbues them with relevance. He describes the real magic of the show as the hybrid of 80’s and 90’s rock combined with the unique sounds of contemporary musical theatre.
“My hope for this production is that audiences will leave with a sense of compassion for the characters, and a broader view of different communities.  Without the support of fellow beings, issues that should be easily resolved, are made incredibly difficult to overcome. We need to approach differences with love and understanding to create a consciousness for change, and that’s what RENT is all about” says Bure.
Bookings through Webtickets or visit http://www.joburgtheatre.com/rent/
Follow The Stephan Fourie Theatre Company Facebook page for show updates @stephanfourietheatreco
Sell-out musical RENT comes to Johannesburg was originally published on Artsvark
0 notes
Recommended Resources from Tracey Hecht for Middle-Grade Read Aloud
The benefits of reading aloud to children who are well past the age when they can independently read, include, but are not limited to, educational, emotional and social growth. Below are supportive resources.
1.    Kids and Family Reading report by Scholastic: 6th Edition: http://www.scholastic.com/readingreport/reading-aloud.htm
This comprehensive study found that 51% of kids ages 6-11 said the reason they like be read aloud to is so they can enjoy books that may be too difficult for them to read on their own. It also found that 78% of kids say school librarians are the top people in the lives who encourage them to read books for fun.
2.    The Core Knowledge Blog entry, Why Is There So Much Listening in the Core Knowledge’s Reading Program? explains that “Thomas Sticht discovered the important fact that reading does not catch up with listening until late middle school or early high school. (Hirsch, Jr., E. D. Blog. Core Knowledge, 2013. http://blog.coreknowledge.org.)
3.    Lettie K. Albright and Mary Ariail: “A Survey of Teachers' Read-Aloud Practices in Middle Schools.”
Two university researchers conducted a survey of middle school teachers' read aloud practices at a large state conference for middle-level educators. Results of this survey provide a beginning step toward evaluating the ways in which middle school teachers use read-alouds in the classroom. This paper shares the results of the survey and offers insight into the extent and nature of teacher read-aloud practices in middle grades.
(Albright, Lettie K. and Ariail, Mary. “Middle School Teachers' Read-Aloud Practices 69.” Reading Research and Instruction, Volume 45, No. 2 * Winter 2006)
4.    Gay Ivey “Reading and Writing in the Content Areas”
Reading aloud, like other teacher demonstrations with text, helps student comprehension. Language arts teachers across the grade levels commonly read aloud, but content-area teachers have not fully explored the value of this practice. When teachers read aloud to students, they give a voice and meaning to text that students often cannot give to the reading themselves, most often because they lack knowledge about the subject.
(Ivey, Gay.  “Reading and Writing in the Content Areas.” Educational Leadership, Gay Ivey    60, no. 3 (2002): 20-23.)
5.   Why Listening and Learning is Critical
Acquisition of both language and knowledge will also be enhanced if, following each read-aloud, children participate in rich, structured conversations with an adult in response to the written text that has been read aloud. In this way, they can begin to orally practice comparing, analyzing, and synthesizing ideas in written text in much the same way as they will be expected to do as independent readers in the later grades.
(Core Knowledge Foundation, 2013, coreknowledge.org )
6.    Jim Trelease, The Read-Aloud Handbook
Recommended by, The New York Times and The Washington Post, for three decades, millions of parents and educators have turned to Jim Trelease's classic to help countless children become avid readers through awakening their imaginations and improving their language skills. This edition of The Read-Aloud Handbook imparts the benefits, rewards, and importance of reading aloud to children of a new generation. Supported by anecdotes as well as the latest research, The Read-Aloud Handbook offers proven techniques and strategies—and the reasoning behind them—for helping children discover the pleasures of reading and setting them on the road to becoming lifelong readers.
(Trelease, Jim. The Read-Aloud Handbook: Sixth Edition. New York: Penguin Books, 2007.)
 Why Read Aloud? From the Editors at Fabled Films Press
Reading aloud promotes reading skills as well as memory, comprehension, vocabulary, writing skills, and language fluency. But did you know it also builds confidence? According to the American Library Association, the security children experience when a parent reads aloud with them increases their self-esteem.
So, how can you create read aloud sessions that foster all of these benefits, and still make it fun for kids?
To begin, let kids pick out what they want to read. Even if they can’t understand the words, (we’ll cover that below), allow them to steer the experience. They’re more likely to develop their love of reading if it’s an activity that speaks to their interests, rather than having their reading material prescribed to them. And, keep different levels of books on hand in your classroom or home.Children can still extract meaning while looking at pictures, or working with the words they know. When choosing a book, what do kids look most for? According to Scholastic, 60% of kids surveyed in the U.S. want to read something funny!
Next, a read-aloud session should include children being read to, as well as children reading aloud themselves. Both methods offer different kinds of benefits, but many of the techniques can be applied when either you or the child is reading.
One of the benefits of reading to children is that they can understand something read to them at a higher language level than they can read by themselves. Being read to exposes them to more complex language than they would choose to read on their own. Words and sentence structures in written language also are more complex than what we hear on a daily basis, and this helps increase vocabulary.
When you’re ready for a break, have the child read a few pages aloud. Reading aloud forces children to slow their pace and spend time on words and concepts with which they aren’t familiar. Otherwise, they tend to zip past words they may not know if they are reading to themselves silently. By reading aloud and slowing down, this not only helps children pay attention to the words they don’t know, but also helps them break the word down verbally. Sounding it out enables them to pick out the letters and sounds they recognize, and learn the ones that they don’t.
When they do pause over a word, offer a brief explanation. Given in the context of the reading, this brief explanation can be enough for children to make the connection between new words and their meanings. Repeated readings of the same text improve vocabulary as words go from never seen before, to recognized, to understood as they’ve seen the word several times along with context.
One of the great things read alouds do that passive reading can’t develop communication skills. When you invite discussion of the text, you’re stimulating language development and at the same time increasing vocabulary. They use expressive language to respond to questions about the story they’re reading. Expressive language is important for children to be able to describe their wants and needs and convey their thoughts. Their ability to relay what’s happening in the story taps into this kind of language.
Reading also improves memory! Memory pathways in the brain are created by seeing and hearing the words, as when you’re reading to a child who is following along with the text. But, when children say the words themselves, they create additional memory pathways by forming auditory links to what is being read. When a child reads aloud, they are using three ways to remember what they’ve read: seeing it, hearing it, and saying it.
Math skills probably aren’t the first thing you associate with reading aloud, but reading builds those, too! Structuring a read aloud in a way that models problem-solving shows children how to approach new texts the same way experienced readers do, and builds analytical habits. Asking questions facilitate problem-solving as they read, and helps children get into the habit of applying these skills as part of their reading experience.
By pausing, asking questions, and encouraging readers to connect with the text by telling their own related stories, they actively interact with literature. Take their lead – when they ask a question, allow for the interruption and use the pause as an opportunity to invite their own problem solving. Ask the group to answer the question. Build on the student responses and create a conversation between yourself, the young readers, and the text itself.
Start by setting aside just a few minutes each day to read together. Let your young readers pick their own reading material (help them choose something funny!), and they’ll be having so much fun they won’t even realize how many skills they’re developing! Finally, don’t stop reading aloud with them just because they can read themselves: Scholastic’s Kids and Family Reading Report showed that most parents stop reading to children after age 6, but 40% of kids in the U.S. still want to read aloud to up to age 11 because they value the special time with their parents.  
Why Read Aloud? From the Editors at Fabled Films Press, Works Cited:
http://www.ala.org/aasl/parents/reading
http://www.educationworld.com/a_curr/curr213.shtml
http://www.scholastic.com/readingreport/KFRR-GetKidsReading.pdf
http://www.readingrockets.org/article/vocabulary-development-during-read-alouds-primary-practices
http://www.readingrockets.org/article/reading-aloud-build-comprehension
http://www.teach-nology.com/themes/lang_arts/reading/aloud.html
http://www.teach-nology.com/themes/lang_arts/reading/aloud.html
https://www.communication.northwestern.edu/clinics/speech_language/expressive_language
https://www.brainscape.com/blog/2011/10/reading-out-loud-remember/
http://www.scholastic.com/readingreport/KFRR-GetKidsReading.pdf
0 notes
mrs-hollandstan · 5 years
Text
Make Me Love You || Frat Boy!Tom [twelve]
Tumblr media
Warnings: Smut (18+), male & female receiving oral, Valentine’s Day sex ya know, I guess minor bdsm??, tying up, dom!Tom themes, blindfolding, toy use, alcohol & its use ;) , talk of sex with the roomies, teasing of Harrison & Cole if you blink, language, minor mentions of family issues, more fantasizing of family life
Word Count: 5,977
Author’s Note: Happy Valentine’s Day!! I hope you enjoy. Just let me say that the next few parts may or may not hurt, but I ask you to stay with me cause it is needed haha. Lemme know what you think though. :)
Series Masterlist || Add yourself to one of my taglists here
"Happy Valentine's Day to my absolute favorite women." Phoebe remarks, setting different colored sparkly heart shaped baskets in front of you, Ivey, and Scarlett at the kitchen table. Ivey gasps as you smile and Scarlett coos,
"Aww Phoebs these are so cute." Scarlett remarks. You nod, glancing up at her,
"They are, they're really adorable." You tell her. She smiles,
"Only the best for my loves." She remarks, leaning against your chair with a shrug. You smile, leaning into her. She sighs,
"Any idea what the boys got you girls?" She asks in general to the group. There's a collective shake of the head as you, Ivey, and Scarlett look between each other to see if anyone knows. You smile,
"Tom did demand I buy him new roses if anything ‘cause his died."
"You should try buying him carnations. Those last a lot longer." Ivey pipes up. You shrug, looking over the contents of Phoebe's basket,
"Any idea what we're all doing tonight?" Phoebe poses instead. Scarlett hums,
"Cole's making dinner and dessert and then we're gonna watch cheesy rom coms and make fun of them." She says with a smile. You giggle, looking to Ivey who shrugs,
"The only thing I know is Harrison and I are going to dinner." She remarks. The three of you nod before all eyes land on you. Your cheeks burn, eyes downcast,
"Uhm, I- Tom didn't really... give me much. He just told me to wear... something nice." You mutter,
"He'll probably just take you to dinner-"
"No not... not that kind of nice, uhm, he told me to wear a nice bra and panty set." You add. There's a silent a gasp,
"Ooh shit." Phoebe mumbles. Scarlett snorts,
"Look at you exploring that fuckin typical sex fiend Tom. How has it been?" She asks. You shrug,
"I don't really have much to base him off of. I was with like one guy before him and we were both in high school." You admit, picking at a string on your sweater. She hums,
"But... can he make you cum without touching you? Like, just sex, no clit rubbing?" You nod,
"Yeah, depends on what position he puts me in. He's really good in doggystyle."
"Must be nice. Sometimes Harrison just... forgets." Ivey speaks up. You smile, listening to Scarlett scoff and jokingly brush her hair over her shoulder,
"That's what you get for dating a boy Ivey. At least mine's a man." She boasts. You snort,
"Yeah, your man wore Spongebob boxers until he was nineteen." You tell her. The room breaks out into laughter, Scarlett leaning back in her chair,
"Hey, there's nothing wrong with liking Spongebob into your twenties. That's when you understand most of the jokes anyways." She defends. You giggle as she purses her lips, trying to contain her laughter,
"Besides, he is so fucking good. God that boy is so fucking sexy. His voice afterwards when he knows I still can't breathe-"
"Ew, ew, ew, that's alright, we don't have to. I'm related to that and I do not need to know." You tell her, shivering and moving your hands between you. She laughs, eyes casting up to Phoebe who holds her fingers out at a measurable distance. Scarlett reads her, holding her fingers up with a little added length,
"Balls too."
"Scarlett!" You squeal, your friends bursting out into laughter again. She holds her hands up,
"What?! How is that fair that you can talk your sex life but I can't talk mine?"
"Because yours happens to occur with my older brother and I do not need grimy details about an idiot I grew up with." You screech over the laughter. Once the laughing subsides, Scarlett sighs,
"He is good though." She mutters. You roll your eyes as a knock on the door sounds through the room. You silently thank the gods for whoever is on the other side, face brightening further when the three boys in question walk through the door. Tom rounds the corner in sweats and a tee, hat on backwards as he beelines straight for you, hands shoved in his pockets. You smile, laying your head back against his stomach as he leans in to kiss your cheek,
"Happy first Valentine's babe." He whispers to you. You smile, kissing his cheek back,
"Happy Valentine's Day love." You mutter. He glances up, watching his best friend and Cole retreat to their respective girlfriends. Phoebe drapes her arms around his shoulders,
"So I heard you requested that our sweet Y/N wear her best undies." She tells Tom who smiles, glancing down at you,
"Good thing I don't tell you my secrets darling." He jokes. You giggle and shrug,
"We're a family here. I tell them everything." You tell him. He hums, looking back up to Phoebe,
"Yeah, I got somethin good planned for her. Should be great." Is all he comes up with. Laying your head back against his arm, he nods at her. She nods in return as he purses his lips,
"But uhh, what are you doin?" He asks her. She shrugs,
"Probably sitting around here. Maybe I'll look for a hookup, who knows." She says with a shrug. You giggle as Tom smiles at her,
"Well shit, when you put it like that, there's room on my bed for the both of you." You gasp, reaching up to swat at his chest,
"Tom!" You screech. He chuckles,
"What? She's gonna spend Valentine's Day alone looking for a hookup. I could take you both on." He remarks. You pout as he stares down at you with a cheesy smile. He clicks his tongue,
"I'm kidding love. Damn I thought you'd put up more of a fight." He jokes. Phoebe smiles down at you,
"It's fine Y/N, wouldn't wanna steal your picture perfect moment." She remarks. Tom wraps his arms around you, lifting you and sitting in your spot. He pulls you into his lap, his arms wrapped tight around your waist.  He sighs, leaning into your ear,
"Just for that though, you'll have to be punished." He jokes. You smile, leaning your back against his chest, hands placed over his arms.
                                                     ---
Each of your steps are accentuated by the clicks of the heels you wear as Tom walks you up the stairs to the frat house,
"Ya know, I really, really want our own place so we can do whatever we want." He reminds you. You smile and nod, holding his hand tight,
"Well it's not like I'm quiet if there's people around. At your friend's house back in London I was pretty loud and Cole's friend definitely has neighbors and I wasn't exactly quiet." You remind. He gives a cocky smirk as he glances back at you,
“I like that about you. You don’t hide it like some girls try to.” He tells you. You hum, releasing his hand as he shoulders the front door open. It’s nearly empty, just a few of the boys standing spread through the house. Some greet you, others continue what they’re doing like you aren’t there. Tom leads you through the kitchen first, grabbing some alcohol before he leads you up the stairs and into his room. He sighs as he closes the door and you settle on the bed, laying back and kicking your heels off. You cross your hands over your stomach, watching as Tom walks forward to run the tip of his finger over the hill of one of your breasts,
“I like this dress. It shows off your goodies perfectly.” You smile,
“Thought you just cared what was underneath tonight.” He hums, not answering you at first as he pours some of the bourbon he’d brought into a glass and handing it to you. You sip from it, cringing softly. Tom smiles,
“Well I do, but ‘m just sayin, you’re pretty fuckin sexy in this little dress.” He remarks. You nod, allowing him to crawl over you. You hum as he brushes your hands up above your head, leaning in to kiss your throat,
“You know what though, I think it’ll look better on my floor.” He whispers, reaching up to slide the strap of your dress down your arm, repeating the process with the other as he slides it down your body. When your bra is exposed to him, he lets out another hum, continuing the trail down past your underwear which he blinks down at, dropping your dress on the floor beside him,
"Damn..."
"This set was just bought for this occasion." You tell him with a smile. He eyes the frilly red lace set,
"Its beautiful baby girl. You really know how to spoil me then huh?" He teases. You giggle and nod, eyes following his hand as he reaches for the bottle of bourbon, turning it upside down to drizzle some down the valley of your breasts, quickly leaning in to lap it up as it begins to run. You smile, watching him stand, kicking his shoes off and shimmying from his socks. He sheds his top and pants, watching as you sit up and lean in to kiss across his abdomen. He reaches up to run his fingers through your hair. He gives a sharp tug after a moment, bringing a choked whimper from your throat. He smiled down at you,
"I've got something for you. But you have to be a good girl for me to see it." He purrs. You smile up at him, body coursing in excitement at his tone. He wants to be domineering and you'll let him. You nod, chewing your bottom lip. He gives one curt nod, releasing your hair and walking to his closet. He pulls out a shoebox, placing it on the bed beside you and opening it. Your eyes widen at the contents: silk ties, handcuffs, a few varieties of dildos and vibrators, and nipple clamps,
"The craziest thing in this box is the clamps. But most of it's pretty mild. I just figured I mentioned toys and you didn't say no so maybe I could've bought some and then I had a little extra money. So I kinda went all out. We can try all of them in time but... I only got like three dildos cause I don't really want to use them on you when I've got a perfectly good dick in my pants but... figured maybe we'd see. But if you'd like, we could sample out a vibrator of your choice. And these are definitely being used." He rambles, dragging the ties out. You meet eyes and he gives you a cocky smirk. You cock your head and click your tongue,
"See that's not fair. I wore this for you to dominate me?" You pose, gesturing to the lingerie set you wear. Tom shrugs, looking you over, but he strokes the ties smooth as he does so,
"You did date night a few weeks ago. It's my turn to actually spoil you."
"But I wanna be on top. You always do the work." You pout, shoulders slouching. Tom presses his lips together, staring up at you without blinking for a moment,
"Fine. But I've got conditions. You're to let me tie you up to eat you out and when I'm done I'll let you do the same. But we need to establish a safe word. We aren't gonna be too crazy but," he grabs your hips and leans in to kiss your stomach, "I want us to be safe. If something doesn't feel right, we can use it and we'll stop." You nod, hands rested on his shoulders,
"What about... ooh, what about curtain call?" You pose. One of his eyebrows arches and you purse your lips,
"Ya know... at the end of a performance. Y-you were talking about stage directions the other day. I do listen." You murmur, seeming somewhat embarrassed. Tom chuckles,
"I know you do, I'm just... surprised. Yeah, curtain call is good." He tells you through a chuckle, squeezing your hips. You nod, letting him guide you back to lay on the bed, dragging you up to have you hold the posts of his headboard before he binds a silk tie around your wrists and the post. You watch, leaning up to kiss his stomach again, which moves as he laughs,
"Gonna be a good girl for me darling?" He purrs again, leaning in to kiss along your jaw. You nod,
"Yes sir."
"Now that's just wrong. You don't want me to dominate you, but you're gonna call me sir. Naughty girl." You giggle as he lifts your bottom half from the bed, pulling your panties down and swatting your butt in one sitting. You press your eyes closed for a moment, opening them as he spread your thighs to kneel between. He drags another piece of silk from the nightstand, showing it to you before leaning in to fasten it around your eyes. You gasp,
"Oh come on. That's not fair."
"You blindfolded me the other night. It's my turn. Besides... your orgasm'll be better if you're compromised." He mutters, kissing down your body. He disappears from the bed, his weight around you nonexistent anymore as he toys with your remaining senses. You gasp again, tugging at your restraints when something brushes over your stomach. Tom cackles,
"Those were my boxers by the way. And your body liked that." He purrs once more, leaning in to kiss around your belly button which draws a guttural whine from your throat,
"Tommy... please do something." You cry out. He chuckles again, humming to himself as he rounds the end of the bed, running his hands up your legs from ankle to thigh to spread them,
"What do we say pretty girl? Repeat it."
"Please." You pant, holding the wooden headboard post,
"Good girl." He gently mumbles. Closing your eyes tight, you give a shaky breath, feeling his breath across your hips before he leans in, instantly sucking your clit into his mouth. You cry out arching your back as his hands find purchase on your thighs, holding them apart while he works on you. He hums, your toes curling and you're on the verge of tears with how good it feels. Tom always makes it feel good. Sex is always the best, but the way he uses his mouth- which he hasn't since the night at the club because all of your sex has been too rushed for foreplay- is exceptional. You grasp the restraints, moaning and whimpering as you focus on the tingling and straight pleasure Tom provides, tracing his tongue around your clit and lapping at you in figure eights. You whine as he pulls up,
"Tommy... Tommy, please..." He chuckles,
"Tell me what you want baby girl." He demands. You arch your back,
"Please just don't stop. Want your tongue." You whine. He chuckles again,
"Good thing I hadn't intended on stopping then huh?" He poses, your senses dialed to eleven as he leans in, sucking your clit into his mouth and pumping his fingers inside of you once he slips them inside. Your nails claw at the bedpost, eyes squeezed shut tight beneath your blindfold,
"Fuck Tom." You gasp. He chuckles darkly,
"You like that pretty girl. So wet for me." He mutters, kissing your thigh. You can feel him shift, but think nothing of it as you focus on getting to your first high of the night. Your body craves it, wanting to feel that molten lava take over your body. You hum, gasping and shuddering as a strong vibrating sound rings through the air and cool metal is pressed to your clit. Your body lurches, tugging against the restraints at the new, overwhelming, foreign feeling and the milliseconds of uncertainty as to what it is nearly has you calling out your safe word.. He chuckles again,
"You like that darling?" You nod, panting as you seek out more pleasure from not only his fingers pumping in and out of you, but the bullet vibrator pressed firmly to your clit. You move your hips down into him, letting him slip his fingers out of you and replace it with his tongue. Your back arches again, head buried in the pillows,
"Fuck me Tommy. That feels so good." You moan, feeling your high build further and further,
"Can tell... you're soaked darling." He mutters back. You grasp the ties, toes curling and eyes squeezing shut,
"Fuck, fuck, fuck I'm gonna cum." You squeal. Tom hums, his tongue leaving you before he takes hold of your hips and flips you over onto your knees, twisting your wrists in the ties snugly, but not uncomfortably. He presses his fingers back inside of you, thrusting them quickly as he holds the overpowering vibrator firm to your clit. You whine, leaning down to bury your face in his sultry smelling pillow as he fights to bring you to climax,
"Come on love, cum for me." He directs into your ear. You let out a moan, back arching into his chest as he leans over you, stiff cock jabbing you in the side. Your body convulses after a few more seconds and you squeal, toes curled as you cum finally. You let out a whimper as he works your through it, turning the vibrator off as he draws his fingers out and licks them clean. You hold the post above you tight in your hands,
"Are you... are you gonna untie me?" You ask. He chuckles,
"Eager are we? I don't think I will just yet love. I like you like this." You whimper again as he lays you on your back, pulling the tie on your blindfold lose and tossing it aside,
"I will do that though. You look beautiful all flushed like this." He says with a smile. You return it, leaning your head up to kiss him, tasting yourself on his tongue as he slides it into your mouth. You hum,
"I do quite like the dominating stature you take. It's pretty sexy." He smiles, running his hands up the inside of your thighs,
"That's good. That's kinda... my style of stuff. I like dominating my girls." He admits. You crane your head to watch him sort through the things in front of him. His smile widens,
"You sure liked that vibrator." He remarks. You click your tongue,
"That's like telling me that starving me will result in me wanting to eat. No shit Sherlock." You chide. He chuckles,
"Didn't you though? I mean obviously your body involuntarily likes it but... it's good huh?" You nod, relaxing back against the bed,
"It was good. Intense. I've never used toys before." You admit. He returns your nod, reaching for a condom as he removes the lube in the box and walks to the closet to deposit it back. He hums as he returns, standing beside you with his hands on his hips,
"I'm not ready to untie you love." He remarks. You lick your lips, raising your head,
"Come closer then loser." You bite, watching him walk forward before you lean in to take his cock into your mouth. He hums. You smile around him, shifting until you're laying on your side, bobbing your head softly. You hum as he reaches up to untie you, pulling your legs off the bed and putting you on your knees,
"Hands behind your back darling." You do as you're told, letting him tie your hands behind your back, gathering your hair in his hand,
"You're beautiful baby girl." He purrs. You glance up at him through your lashes, his lips pressing in a tight line as he stares down at you. You hum, moving forward until you're gagging. Tom curses under his breath, holding you far too lightly. You pull back,
"Tommy..."
"What?" He asks, eyes softening at your whine. You pout,
"We established a safe word and we aren't even gonna get our worth out of it." His eyes twinkle as he stares down at you,
"I don't follow darling." He remarks with a lopsided smirk. You click your tongue,
"You wanna be dominating, you gotta gag me." His smile widens as he comes to the realization,
"You want my cock down your throat darling?" He poses softly. You smile and nod, winking up at him,
"You've got me all tied up, why not play with me?" You purr. He chuckles darkly,
"Oh darling, you don't know what you're getting yourself into." He mutters as you take him back into your mouth. He hums, watching you and running his fingers up the side of your face before he gives a solid tug on your neck and you gag. He hisses,
"Fuck darling. You're very good with that pretty little mouth." You hollow your cheeks as he speaks, giggling around him as his knees threaten to give out. He tugs on you harder, hand wrapping in your hair again before he presses, gagging you effectively over and over again. After another moment, he tugs you off of him, breathing hard,
"Alright... fuck... that's enough." He pants, bringing you to your feet and turning you around. Pressing a hand to your back, he bends you over the bed, swatting at your bottom. You squeal, giggling after as he picks at the knots at your back, untying the ties and letting you lay back on the bed, rolling onto your back. He stands between your knees,
"Wanna tie me up now?" He poses. You smile and nod, taking the tie from him and sitting up. He lays back on the bed, letting you move his hands until they're grasping the same post you were. He watches you clamber over him to tie the silk around his wrists, leaning up to kiss your tummy. He hums as you crawl back down, sitting just above his bobbing cock,
"You ever not used a condom with a girl?" You ask him, raising an eyebrow. He smiles, shrugging,
"Maybe one or two." He admits. You click your tongue,
"Such a whore you are Mr. Holland." He chuckles as you lean in to kiss across his chest, rolling your tongue around his nipples. He closes his eyes, grasping at his restraints as you creep down his body. Crouching between his legs, you find the condom and lube amongst the sheets. He sighs as he waits for you to add lube to the tip of the condom after you've opened it and slide it down over him,
"I actually can't wait for the day you let me not use a condom." He remarks. You smile,
"Shoulda said something before I put it on." He raises his head, staring up at you,
"Well fuck then, take it off, what’s one condom?" He practically squeals. You giggle, shaking your head at him,
"Too late." Climbing over him, he watches you turn the lube upside down and drip it over him, setting the bottle aside and settle above him. You reach down, guiding him with two fingers to your entrance before you slide down onto him. He hums, holding the ties in his hands,
"Fuck... that's good." He mutters, eyes closing again as you settle yourself above him, hands on his chest. He presses his lips in a line, raising his head to glance down where you're connected. He sighs,
"Fuck you're good." He adds. You smile, rubbing your hands across his chest before slowly raising your hips and dropping them down again. He hums, holding the restraints around his wrists in a bruising grip. You slowly bounce on top of him, trying to stretch yourself out as he licks his lips and curses under his breath. He watches you reach down once you start to pick up speed, stroking your clit in quick circles, your body quivering from the previous orgasm you'd had. Tom gives a somewhat feminine whine,
"Fuck darling." He tugs at the restraints around his wrist. You tut,
"Don't tell me I'm gonna have to blindfold you for being a bad boy." You tease. He stares up at you with wide, lust blown eyes, laying his head back against his pillow with his eyes never leaving you,
"You're mean." He mutters. You smile down at him, back arching softly as you rub yourself, bursts of pleasure bursting throughout you. You hum, coming down harder around him. After another moment of dull pleasure from Tom, you press a foot to his bed, leaning back on his thighs to bounce softly. He watches, eyes widening again,
"Baby, untie me." He desperately begs. You giggle, pausing as you stare down at him,
"You're such a pussy. I was tied up for like five minutes and you can't even last two." He groans,
"But this is different. I can give you more, come on, untie me." You shake your head, continuing to bounce atop him,
"No way. You stay tied up until I can make you cum." He rotates his wrist in a circle,
"Then c'mon. Hurry it along then darling, I can feel it." He rushes, laying his head back against the pillow below him with a small grunt as you pick up speed. His toes curl, eyes closing as his back arches,
"Fuck..." He groans, holding his ties, focusing on you instead of the bed creaking. He desperately wants to bring his knees up to give him some leverage to thrust up into you, but he can't. You're leaning back on his legs so he just has to enjoy the ride for now. One of your hands comes down between your own legs, rubbing your clit and releasing quiet but high pitched moans. Tom chews his lip, watching you as he chases his high, loving the way your body looks. He whines, tugging at his restraints and he wants nothing more than to reach up and play with your perfect, full, beautiful breasts. His eyes are locked on them, he's captivated by your sheer beauty as your head falls back,
"Fuck Tom... that feels so good." You moan, digging your nails into his thigh. He chuckles,
"Gonna cum before me?" You hum,
"You're hitting the right spot perfectly." You tell him, heart pounding from your chest. Your head falls back again, lips pressed in a tight line as you process the pleasure coursing through your veins. Its molten lava, burning your body. You bite your lip, Tom's eyes wandering up your body. He's nearly there,
"Fuck babe. God I'm so close." He growls. A thought strikes you, a wicked smirk which Tom doesn't catch crossing your face, his eyes closed. But they pop open and he gasps as he feels your hand that's drifted down between his legs to fondle his balls. You laugh wickedly as the headboard jolts and Tom tugs his restraints,
"Babe... ah fuck darling." He spits out, starting to squirm after a moment,
"Fuck, fuck, fuck." He curses, his hips involuntarily bucking up into yours as he struggles to contain himself. He lets out a loud groan as he cums, wrists red and burning as he tugs against his confines,
"Fuck." He grunts, giving one more thrust before he relaxes. You giggle, leaning over him and kissing him softly,
"Good baby?" He nods rather tiredly, glancing up as he feels you picking at the knots in his ties,
"No changing position." You demand. He nods, hands instantly rising to press over your breasts. You lean up just a little, finding the perfect spot to work back against. His hands slide down to your hips and then one slides down between them, pressing on your clit. You gasp, back arching as he circles the bud,
"That's it baby. Cum for me." He mutters, wrapping his free arm around your shoulders as you lay chest to chest against him, goosebumps erupting across your skin as the new angle allows him to press into that pleasure button. As you pick up speed, his fingers circle your clit faster, pushing you closer and closer to your high.
Each move of your hips draws a dull cry from your lips pressed to Tom's shoulder before he presses his feet to the bed, thrusting up into you. You squeal, biting into his shoulder which draws a growl from his own lips. He kisses your cheek, coaxing you along until you shudder, nuzzling your face in his chest and give a lighthearted scream as you cum for the second time. You pause, kissing his chest as his arms bind around you, legs sliding like butter down amongst the sheets as he struggles to breath below you. You hum as you rise slowly, brain clouded in a blissful haze, Tom's hands resting on your thighs as he waits for you to climb from him. You're panting as you do so, collapsing at his side, draping yourself over his arm. You pull the comforter up across your body, holding it in the crooks of your arms while Tom, just as out of breath, peels the condom from himself and tosses it into the bin beside his bed. He hums, placing his hand over your arm as he drapes the blanket across his waist, turning his head to look at you,
"Well shit." He pants out with a cheesy smile. You nod, letting out a small, breathless laugh, snuggling up into him. He runs his fingertips up your arm, tucking his other arm behind his head. You sigh, placing your hand over his chest,
"I think that was our best yet." You in part joke. He nods,
"I feel that." He mutters. Reaching up, he closed his eyes as you brush through his slightly sweat dampened hair. You lean in to kiss the corner of his mouth as his hand rests on your back, smiling and leaning in to kiss him farther after a moment. Your eyes drift to the top of his dresser where half dead roses lie,
“Wow, you weren’t kidding about your roses.” He glances up and chuckles,
“What, you think I’d lie to you about something so serious?” He jokes. You share a giggle as you lay your head against his shoulder, staring up at them for a moment longer. You raise your head again to look down into his face, heart fluttering,
"I love you. You're my everything." You tell him. He smiles, not opening his eyes for a moment. When he does open them, you watch the brown swirl, a golden speck dancing in them,
"I love you too. You're more than anything. I dunno where I'd be without you." He admits. Tracing his collarbone, he twirls a strand of your hair around his finger. Leaning back, you lay across his arm,
"Let's fantasize more. About our future. About us." You request. He hums, staring up at the ceiling as he thinks. You watch his lashes flutter,
"'Right, I want our house to be like... like warm but not like heater or natural heat warm. I want like... oven warm and I want it to smell like baked goods. And I'm," he looks at you then, eyes widening gently in worry, "I'm not like... saying I want you to sit at home and bake. I just want it to smell like baked goods just in general." You nod, staring up at him. He nods in return, glancing up at the ceiling. You hum,
"I always revert back to you with kids. I’ve always wanted to be a mom." He glances down at you again,
"You'd be a real good one, I know that much." He remarks. You smile up at him,
"Is it creepy that I always imagine you as the father of my kids? We've been together like... six months and I’ve already like… planned out their names and thought about what they’ll look like." You tell him. He chuckles and shrugs,
"I don't find it creepy, I think it's cute. You're like the only girl I've ever actually wanted to fantasize about it with." He admits. You hum, rubbing his chest,
"Fine, then I'll tell you what I think of. I think of you coming home from work and being bombarded with like... well I don't know how many but I see you being bombarded by our babies and then you sit at the table with the boys and help them with their homework as your daughter is questioning me about every little thing associated with dinner and helping me do that. She's too young to go to school of course so... she has to be distracted somehow." He nods with a smile,
"And then you teach them how to clean. Like how to do laundry and dishes and vacuum. But our baby girl will be scared of the vacuum for a few years and everytime you're trying to teach them you have to hold her." You add. He chuckles as your eyes sting in unshed tears,
“Very active imagination. That’s cute, I like it.” He remarks, unaware for a moment until he glances down. After another moment, he glances down,
"Hey. What's the matter?" He asks at the look of you, worriedly moving to brush your tears away. You shake your head and sniffle a little,
"Nothing I just... I just didn't get that growing up. I don't want what I had for our kids. This whole split family shit that I went through. I want more for them." You admit. He hums,
"And you'll get there. You're gonna be an amazing mum and hopefully I'm the dad to watch you be that. You're perfect and I couldn't ask for anything better. Our kids are going to be so fucking loved because the love I have for their mum is unreal." He rambles. You smile and nod, pressing your hand over his on your cheek,
"I know. I just... I feel like my parents said the same thing and then they fell out of love and shit. I just don't wanna go through any of that." You mutter. He nods, letting you lay your head over his shoulder,
"What do you dream about when it comes to kids?" You ask, trying to change the subject. He hums,
"Dunno. Uhm, how many kids are we talkin here?" He poses. You shrug,
"I guess if we're being serious, like... three or four." You tell him. He nods,
"I like the idea of being bombarded by little babies. I dunno if I could hold all of them though. But... I like the idea of you being pregnant and giving birth to babies that have your eyes." He jokes, leaning in to poke your nose. You smile,
"I like your eyes though." You murmur. He hums again,
"Well we'll see who our kids side with on that one." You click your tongue,
"Guess so. I like the idea of having little boys that look like me and little girls that look like you though." He purses his lips,
"Little mumma's boys and little daddy's girls. I could fuck with that." He mumbles. You smile, relaxing against him. He runs his fingers up along your spine, your brain going fuzzy as you close your eyes. You sigh, binding your arms around him. He returns the sigh,
"Why don't you get some sleep and dream some more fantasies up for me." You smile, snuggling down into his side,
"I love you." You tell him. He runs his fingers through your hair,
"Love you too darling. Get some rest." With his fingers in your hair and across your back, it isn't hard to fall asleep, your chest pressed to his. Tom glances down at you when he hears your breathing shallow, smiling down at you and pressing a kiss to your forehead,
"And happy first Valentine's my love." He whispers, kissing your temple before his own eyes close and like always with you around, he falls asleep faster than ever. Peacefully.
Permanent Taglist: @embrace-themagic @t-holland @spiderman-n @winters-beauty @smexylemony @lolabean1998 @musiclover1263 @xxtomxo @chillinjules @sincerelyfan @justkeepdreaminganddreaming @spnobsessedmemes @hazmyheart @saltysebastianstan @petty-geminii @motherhyuckerdude @counting-eyerolls @princezzariel @martinimendes @happytappy02 @lilya-petrichor @20coldhearts @random-fandomer @kalliria @im-tajah @celinelopez3 @itsjusttor @popluckbih @obsidianspidey @takemetooneverlanddd @marshyrebelcloud @zabdisamor  @marvelismylifffe @loveylangdon @inlovewithmobtom @tsh-darling @bangtan-serendipity @peterbeterbarker @bonfirelohve @meg-holland @localfangirlx @turtlee-says-rawr @sadbitchfangirl @th0ttie4tommy @w-jhxk-yj @thatweirdominic @mytonycinematicuniverse @chances-and-miracles @averyfosterthoughts @liberty01 @hatterripper31 @agirlwithpointlessideas @cassiopeiaskies @iam-thevillain-of-thisstory @deviilsangel @peterspideysense @mariejulianposts @hannahholland1811 @jackiehollanderr @peterparkerbabyyy @artsyle @unbelievableholland @hollandjmc @lmao-whats-up @getmebieber @biebsmylife95 @iamyourdaddi
Series Taglist: @maybemona @spideyyeet @princess-chocolate-drop @andreuskystuff​ @cxptain-capsicle​ @motherhyuckerdude @kthemarsian @heavenspidey​ @thenoddingbunny-blog​ @likeit-or-leaveit​ @packsforu​ @chaos-rising​ @gioandreolli​ @aiianovna​ @ohfxxkitsme​ @thehappygrungelife​ @littleros-es​ @oh-mymendes​ @no-no-notorious-writes​ @peteysbaby​ @000nova000​ @myheartismilesaway​ @stxfxniexreads​ @shutuppeter​ @dangerousluv1​ @popluckbih​ @gyllen-holland @hollywoodundeadgirl2​ @i-cant-hangout-im-drumming​ @celinelopez3​ @kingjvngins​ @lavender-writer​ @im-fandom-trash​ @loveylangdon​ @complete-trash-101​ @thenerdiverse​ @gwsparker​ @averyfosterthoughts​ @i-fellinahole​ @tragic4ngel​ @imdrunkisuposse @mariemrose​ @pcterstingle​ @thatharrystyleskid​ @mytonycinematicuniverse​ @peterwhoreparker @itsrainingguppies @morbiddanvers​ @blindedbyyourgrace17​ @the-professional-procrastinator @prettymessygurl​ @runawaywithme-xo​ @coupsniel​ @iam-thevillain-of-thisstory​ @drown-me-before-dema-does​ @heartofholland​ @tomhollandthing​ @mariejulianposts​ @unicorn-princess-1999​ @sle8293 @hon3y-baby​ @applenter​ @hollandjmc​ @spideyth​ @lmao-whats-up​
508 notes · View notes
freewhispersmaker · 7 years
Link
"The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics" Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings... • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A - Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B - Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C - Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D - Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A - Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B - Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C - A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D - GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
Source: © AcademicWritersBay.com
>> CLICK HERE TO ORDER 100% ORIGINAL PAPERS FROM AcademicWritersBay.com
The post “The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip appeared first on Academic Writers BAy.
0 notes
freewhispersmaker · 7 years
Text
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
"The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics" Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings... • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes
youtube
Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A - Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B - Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C - Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D - Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A - Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B - Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C - A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D - GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
Source: © AcademicWritersBay.com
>> CLICK HERE TO ORDER 100% ORIGINAL PAPERS FROM AcademicWritersBay.com
The post “The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip appeared first on Academic Writers BAy.
0 notes
freewhispersmaker · 7 years
Text
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
"The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics" Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant…
View On WordPress
0 notes
freewhispersmaker · 7 years
Text
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
"The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics" Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant…
View On WordPress
0 notes
freewhispersmaker · 7 years
Text
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
“The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics” Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant components of a social media campaign according to the level of influence each could have on the new product launch. Examine both the social media tools that will provide the highest return on investment (ROI), and two (2) key performance indicators (KPIs) that one could use to measure success. Provide a rationale for your response. Welcome Student | Help | Sign Out Library CoursePack Contents Font Search this article Edit Notes Edit Settings Actions SALINABEAR: MONETIZING A YOUTUBE PROFILE Karen Robson prepared this case study under the supervision of Professors Michael Parent and Anjali Bal solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmission without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail [email protected]. As the eight millionth view started on her YouTube channel, Salina Siu put her scissors down and reflected on the amazing events of the past year. It was September 2012, and what had begun as a hobby a little over two years earlier had grown into a successful small business. Siu had started a YouTube channel, joined YouTube’s partner program, graduated from university and obtained an internship in social media in her hometown of Vancouver, Canada. All this from tutorials on how to creatively cut T-shirts! Siu’s YouTube channel, SalinaBear (http://www.youtube.com/salinabear), provided instructional videos on how to transform plain T-shirts into fashionable garments by carefully cutting them using only scissors — an apparently popular practice among teenage women. The high number of views led to Siu being accepted into YouTube’s Partner Program, whereby ads were placed next to her videos, and Siu shared in revenues resulting from either exposure to these ads or click-throughs on these ads. Siu was making good money, but not enough to replace a full-time job. Siu picked up her scissors and continued carefully cutting the neck seam on her latest project — transforming a man’s extra-large T-shirt into a trim woman’s tank top. As the blades moved effortlessly through the fabric, she thought about her options to transform the site into a bigger business that would provide enough income to warrant full-time employment. BACKGROUND Salina Siu Salina Siu, 23 years old, was part of a creative, artistic family. Her father, who enjoyed photography as a hobby, had first piqued her interested in drawing. Her mother had been a seamstress her whole life and sewed clothes part-time at home. When Siu was a young girl, her mother would ask her what new outfit she’d like her to make for her. At an early age, Siu had already started thinking like a fashion designer. She had also developed a taste for unique and custom garments. By her own admission, she had always been interested in arts and crafts: drawing, painting, photography and graphic design. Siu also pursued these interests professionally. She graduated with her bachelor’s degree in Business Administration in 2012 from the Beedie School of Business at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada, with concentrations in entrepreneurship and innovation and in marketing and a minor in publishing. Throughout her coursework, she also took electives from Simon Fraser’s School of Interactive Arts and Technology, including digital image design, graphic design and drawing as inquiry. In May 2010, she bought a T-shirt at the local mall that had been cut up in the back. It was the first time she had ever seen such a thing, and she was enthralled. She immediately tried to figure out how it had been done, even searching on YouTube for videos that might show her. She commented: The videos were OK, but they really didn’t show it clearly. The production quality was poor, and the instructions were incomplete and confusing. I felt frustrated, and never really got a clear understanding of how to cut T-shirts into these neat patterns. So, I just decided to do it myself. Through trial-and-error, and with some help from my Mom, I got the hang of it really fast! It’s actually pretty easy and straightforward once you get it! This epiphany motivated her to want to make better videos than the ones currently on YouTube. She saw an opportunity to help others, while also developing valuable video-creation and -editing skills and learning about YouTube — a fast-growing medium for her generation. As a marketing graduate, she also knew the value of research, so she started watching a large number of craft tutorial videos, not only for T-shirt cutting but for all sorts of arts and crafts. Siu said: I was especially inspired by Erica Domesek and her website “P.S. I Made This” (http://psimadethis.com). Erica created a blog that taught people how to reproduce brand-name styles. She went on to publish her own book and made numerous television appearances on shows like Martha Stewart’s. She had been featured in magazines like Teen Vogue, Glamour, Lucky and InStyle, and had partnered with big brands to style and design campaigns for the likes of Coke, Ford and Roxy. She had even hosted events with big brands like Kate Spade and Gap. She was a real inspiration to me, and I sought to reproduce her success in my own way. This research led Siu to conclude that clear, accessible content was the most critical success factor for tutorial videos. Specifically, she felt that an effective instructional video should include the following: • Clearly numbered steps throughout the video so that viewers could fast-forward and rewind easily • Showing of the end product at the beginning of the video so viewers can decide right away whether the tutorial is what they’re looking for. • Clear and appropriate camera angles that show the work being performed, as it was being performed (in other words, providing an overhead view of the cutting without using cutaways that revealed a miraculously perfect product) • Proper lighting • Clear and concise instructions • Showing of all the steps • A playful, fun atmosphere that made the task look easy and approachable Siu also decided that she would not only demonstrate but also act as the model in her videos (see Salina’s website at http://www.youtube.com/salinabear for examples of her videos). She believed doing so was important to establish her credibility and provided an opportunity to showcase her personality. As far as the name for her channel, she said: I chose SalinaBear for a few reasons. First of all, I wanted the channel to have my name in it so that viewers would know who I am, and how to spell my name, as it has an unusual spelling, with an a in the first syllable, not the usual e. I also wanted to create a brand that would be unique, easy to find on the Internet, playful and fun. Finally, the thought of a cute bear in the logo appealed to me, and I thought it’d appeal to other young women. Siu uploaded her first video to YouTube in June 2010. It showed viewers how to cut strips into a “V” shape on the back of a T-shirt using only scissors — no sewing or taping required (you can view the video on her website at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbhC7hPFaLA&list=UUCYATxMpYZ4ayXG5NPxqQw&index=23). The 4-minute, 45-second video took her four hours to film and another four hours to edit before it was ready for posting. To promote the video, she shared it on craft and do-it-yourself (DIY) websites. A major boost in viewership occurred after one of these sites, CutOutAndKeep (http://ift.tt/MXhDtU) featured her video on its landing page. In fact, it remained on the landing page for one week and eventually was moved to CutOutAndKeep’s featured products page. It became SalinaBear’s most popular video, at more than 2.2 million views. In addition, some organizations and clubs gave Siu branded T-shirts for her to cut up in return for mentions in her videos. These organizations, in turn, promoted her work by distributing these videos to their networks. YouTube Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim, all former employees of PayPal, founded YouTube in 2005. The site went live in Beta in May 2005, before the full-featured site was launched online later that year, in December. YouTube’s vision is “to give everyone a voice, to evolve video, and to make our partners and advertisers successful.”1 In October 2006, Google acquired YouTube for US$1.65 billion2. By January 2008, 10 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube every minute; in October 2009, this rate increased to 15 hours of video per minute, and in March 2010, the rate had increased to 24 hours of video per minute. In 2012, YouTube was the world’s largest online video site, with roughly 72 hours of video being uploaded every minute, of which three hours per minute were being uploaded from mobile devices. YouTube began its Partner Program in December 2007. YouTube partners were content creators, and many of them were large media companies, such as Sony or Universal. Partners were able to upload videos of any length (i.e., they were not limited to 15 minutes) and were able to monetize their videos through ads or by making their videos available for rent. Partners were also offered more analytical tools to manage their sites. YouTube gave partners about 50 per cent of the revenue generated by ads on their sites, based on either cost per impressions (CPM) or cost per clicks (CPC), depending on the advertiser’s choice. Ads were placed in numerous spots on the partner’s website, at the top of the video, on the bottom of the video window or at the side. Up to three ads appeared on any one page. To become a partner, the site owners first needed to create an original video suitable for online streaming, and they needed to either own or have permission to use and monetize the video and audio content. Potential partners also needed to apply to YouTube to join the partnership program. YouTube considered how often videos were uploaded, how big their audience was and how many videos were in the potential partner’s library. YouTube had more than one million partners, with top-performing partners reputed to be making well over $100,000 per year. YouTube’s partnership agreement included a clause prohibiting partners from disclosing how much they actually earned from the partnership program, owing to the variety of factors that went into calculating compensation. However, an oft-cited estimate was $2 in earnings for every 1,000 views and $0.05 for every subscriber.3 HOW TO GET MORE THAN EIGHT MILLION VIEWS AND 47,000 SUBSCRIBERS As of September 2012, SalinaBear had 47,753 subscribers and 8,234,081 video views (an average of 10,000 unique views daily). Siu had created and posted 24 videos, and her work had received more than 5,000 comments, 28,000 likes and 1,300 dislikes. The website Social Blade tracked YouTube metrics, including those for Salina’s site (see http://ift.tt/2xqJEtA). Siu posted her first video on June 5, 2010, and she applied to be a YouTube Partner on June 15, 2010. As of June 28, she had 100 subscribers, and on June 29, YouTube approved her partnership application (see Exhibit 1). She received her first royalty cheque on November 24, 2010 (YouTube sent cheques when an account had amassed more than $100). Siu’s videos became increasingly sophisticated, while continuing to retain a light, whimsical tone. Siu also became more adept and efficient at creating the videos. They now took her about three hours to film and another three hours to edit. The videos all began with the SalinaBear logo. They then moved on to the tutorial. Some videos depicted very basic steps (e.g., how to cut a neck), while others were more complex. In some videos, she referred to earlier videos depicting these basic steps. Siu felt that three keys had led to her success: quality content, the building and nurturing of an audience and findability. Quality Content It was important for Siu to avoid mistakes that other videos had made, which is why she wanted to number the steps and explain and illustrate them clearly, using good lighting and a top view. She also believed it was important to show the finished product at the beginning of the video to give viewers an idea of what they were working toward. Finally, she believed she established her credibility by acting as both the model and creator in the videos. The response from viewers was enthusiastically positive, as attested to by the following comment, one of many on the website: oh my god. i’ve seen a ton of tutorials on weaving and this is by far the best i’ve ever seen lol. usually you can’t see what the hell the people are doing with what strings because they like to pick a black shirt or the camera is a weird angle or too far away. but i love how clean and simple your drawings are :). every step is shown and explained thoroughly :D. thank you so much! – MikoSubaru (February, 2012) Building and Nurturing an Audience “I feel a great deal of loyalty to my viewers,” Siu maintained. “They got me to where I am today, and their ongoing support has been crucial to SalinaBear’s success.” Siu kept close tabs on her viewership using YouTube’s extensive analytics (see Exhibit 2 for sample viewership data). It came as no surprise to her that the majority of the site’s views were from young women (90.2 per cent of her overall views were from women), mainly in the United States. However, it surprised her that a considerable number of views were from Mexico, the United Kingdom and the Philippines. During the first four months, she felt it was important to reply to all comments on the channel. However, it became too repetitive to thank everyone, so she limited her replies to more complicated questions. She also created an FAQ (frequently asked questions) video addressing popular topics. In April 2011, after hitting one million views, she created a special “thank you” video for her fans and followers. The growth in the site’s views was, at first, mainly organic, with very little effort on Siu’s part. In addition to having posted the videos on DIY sites, Siu had also posted them to her personal Facebook profile. She used the biography of her Twitter account (@salinasiu) to refer to SalinaBear. She created a Flickr account that displayed her T-shirts and encouraged fans to subscribe to her YouTube channel (http://ift.tt/2gWYXiH). She also used Pinterest (http://ift.tt/2xqfmHg). Out of her 20 boards on Pinterest, the board that had attracted the most engagement showed photos of her own designs and YouTube videos and T-shirts that others had cut up. Including designs by others on her Pinterest boards reflected Siu’s underlying belief that reciprocity was a big part of success in social media marketing efforts. She was also pleased that every time she logged into Pinterest, her recent repins and likes were mostly from strangers who had discovered her “Cut T-Shirt” pinboard. Findability Siu devoted considerable attention and energy to ensuring that interested viewers could find her site: she knew that it was not enough to have an interesting topic and well-made videos. After all, many good videos on the Internet were never discovered. Luckily for Siu, when she started her channel, only a handful of users were making T-shirt-cutting tutorials. Siu considered this topic to have little competition. Siu believed the other key findability factor was search engine optimization (SEO), which was improved through the use of keywords. She used targeted keywords in the videos’ titles. She used Google AdWords’ Keyword Tool to determine which keywords were most popular. The title of the video was especially important: Siu strived for a balance between being descriptive and enticing viewers. By responding to Comments, she created buzz around her videos, thus increasing the videos’ rating on the search results. CHALLENGES Imitation, far from being the sincerest form of flattery, was endemic on the web, especially on YouTube. Paradoxically, by helping people, Siu was also empowering them. Nothing prevented anyone else from either imitating or even bettering her. As such, her competition was essentially unbounded. Moreover, she believed that viewers expected instructional and informational videos to be free. After all, she herself had turned to YouTube after buying her first cut T-shirt! Consumers’ reluctance to pay for content constrained her options for the future of the site. In some ways, Siu wanted to transform SalinaBear into a full-time job and career. However, she felt she needed at least a tenfold increase in revenues to do so. She did have several options worth pursuing: she could charge for her videos via another platform; charge rent on her videos on YouTube; sell DIY kits; create a physical shop, and conduct in-person group or individual tutorials; and/or expand her brand, in much the way Erica Domesek had done, by developing a new line of tutorials focusing on nail art, jewellery or other crafts. Charging for Videos In early 2010, YouTube began experimenting with paid content — that is, having users pay for access to certain content; in this case, YouTube offered some select films from the Sundance Film Festival.4 This experiment eventually morphed into a product YouTube called YouTube Rentals,5 in Beta form, as of September 2012. More traditional sites, such as Blockbuster, Redbox and Netflix, also rented movies and television shows, as did Apple’s iTunes. However, these sites did not host instructional videos. Instructional video sites, such as TeacherTube, EduTube and Mylearningtube, hosted similar videos, but they were more school-focused, not hobby-focused. Finally, numerous arts and crafts sites, such as Martha Stewart’s and SimpleKidsCrafts, hosted DIY videos, but they were not paying sites. If Siu chose this path, she faced the challenge of either finding a suitable paying distribution channel for her videos or the daunting task of creating a pay channel of her own. DIY Kits Siu had also considered creating and selling DIY (do-it-yourself) kits. She pictured these kits to contain scissors, a ruler and a couple of T-shirts with dotted lines printed on them to instruct people where to cut. These kits would pair well with her existing videos, and promoting them on her videos would be easy, but she wondered whether people would buy them. One option was to sell them online, perhaps via Amazon.com, although yet another option was to develop a relationship with an existing retail chain. Such kits were popular with arts and crafts retailers, including the arts and crafts retail giant Michaels. She could also develop a tutorial book or a book of patterns, which she could sell in addition to or packaged with the DIY kits. Physical Shop Many viewers had asked Siu whether she gave in-person workshops or tutorials. So far, she had demurred. If these workshops and tutorials weren’t free, she felt that not enough people would be interested to make this option financially viable. She would also face the challenge of scaling the operation. However, she realized that could open a physical retail store, where she could both conduct tutorials and sell some of her creations. She’d been inspired by Hamburger Disco, a brand run by two of her friends, which had only sold products online until opening a pop-up store in Vancouver. Her friends had asked Siu to cut one of their T-shirts to promote their pop-up store; in return, Hamburger Disco cross-promoted the video she had created. Based on their experience, and on advice from others, she believed she’d need at least $10,000 to open a small store, buy inventory and run it for six months without a profit. Aside from the time and energy needed to establish a retail presence, she knew that the majority of her viewers and fans were located in the United States, and she wondered whether marketing her brand in her hometown would work. In addition, Siu also realized that running a physical retail store was vastly different from maintaining the online presence she had created. The skills required to run a store were not the skills she had developed as a video producer and on-air personality. Although the store option didn’t play to current her skills, interests and competencies, she acknowledged that it could be a necessary step in growing her brand. Brand Extension The last option was to branch out into other types of crafts, such as nail art or jewellery. Siu believed that she had created a strong brand presence on YouTube. Moreover, the SalinaBear brand name was sufficiently vague to allow for many other types of products, not just crafts. Siu wondered whether she could start small by choosing one or two categories to pursue, produce a few videos and then load them onto the SalinaBear site, or whether she should, instead, segment her products through separate YouTube channels (e.g., SalinaBear T’s for T-shirts and SalinaBear Jewels for jewellery. She wondered whether her audience would follow her and whether her personality was appealing enough to distinguish her from all the others on YouTube. Next Steps As her latest creation took shape, Siu reflected on her future and on her options. Life had suddenly become very busy, and she’d found herself posting a video apologizing to her subscribers for being away so long. She wondered whether SalinaBear was more than just a short-term experiment, and whether devoting her energy to growing the business would be a wise and profitable long-term move. Exhibit 1 TIMELINE TO FIRST YOUTUBE ROYALTY CHEQUE AND VIEWERSHIP NUMBERS Source: Salina Siu Exhibit 2 SELECTED YOUTUBE ANALYTICS DATA FOR SALINABEAR (JULY 2012) Source: Salina Siu 1 YouTube, “Frequently Asked Questions,” http://www.youtube.com/t/faq, accessed July 1, 2012. 2 All currency amounts shown are in U.S. dollars unless specified otherwise. 3 http://ift.tt/2gWP7xp, accessed July 1, 2012. 4 Jolie O’Dell,” YouTube Will Start Charging for Some Videos,” ReadWrite, January 20, 2010, http://ift.tt/2xqfoim, accessed July 1, 2012. 5 YouTube, “YouTube Rentals Beta,” http://www.youtube.com/t/youtube_rentals, accessed July 1, 2012. Copyright © 2012, Richard Ivey School of Business Foundation Version: 2012-12-19 Scroll down for the next article • Copy • Highlighting Toolbar Settings… • CoursePack Contents Page • Back (to article beginning) • Next Article • Last Article • Back • Forward • Reload • Stop MKT 500 Week 8 Scenario: Developing Social Media Campaigns for the New Product Launch Slide # Scene # Narration Slide 1 Scene 1 [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] Ed and Samantha meet in the morning to discuss the next steps in the tablet PC launch. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-1: Good morning, Ed. How are you doing today? MKT500_8_1_Ed-1: Good morning, I’m doing quite well. What about yourself? MKT500_8_1_Samantha-2: Good, thanks. I’m really proud of the progress we’ve been making with our tablet launch, and I’m excited for the next steps. MKT500_8_1_Ed-2: I love your enthusiasm, Samantha! I spoke with Carl earlier. He said now that we have selected our advertising media and budget, we need to take a deeper look into social media. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Yes, the enormity of today’s media choices—the Internet alone—makes it a wonderful time to be alive. Social media is at the cutting edge of this trend. MKT500_8_1_Ed-3: As we discussed, we can use social media as one of our main media outlets for advertising the new tablets. However, mobile marketing is growing because our cell phones are particularly convenient; they contain our identities and those of the people we talk to frequently. They are our portals to email, social media and networking sites, which are many people’s primary means of sharing information and entertainment. Interestingly enough, at the same time that electronic and information technologies are becoming more accessible and pervasive, traditional media are experiencing their own changes. Slide 2 Interaction Hover your mouse over each media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. Newspaper Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. Radio The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. TV Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is a facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4: Hover your mouse over each type of media to discover more information about the changes they are undergoing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab A: Newspaper circulations are declining, and while optimists continue to launch new magazines every year, their overall sales and circulations are down as well. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab B: The number of radio stations has grown, boosted by satellite servers, but listeners are tuned in for less time each day than just a few years ago. MKT500_8_1_Ed-4_Tab C: Television channels also continue to grow. The bad news about this fragmentation is that with more TV channels, the audience for any given show is typically smaller. The good news is that targeting is facilitated when the segments of viewers are somewhat more homogeneous. Slide 3 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] (Display social media graphic) MKT500_8_1_Samantha-3: Very interesting, Ed. I hadn’t realized the effects of social media on more traditional media types. MKT500_8_1_Ed-5: The other part of the “social media” story is its social, or human, element. Belonging to different communities and interacting with different people in our social roles is part of our identity. The most fundamental means of interaction is dialogue. In social media, customers have become participants in a dialogue with marketers or brands. Traditionally, customers had been mere recipients of one-way messages that had been shot out by marketers, but now customers have a means of talking back. For example, customers post positive endorsements about brands, and they also use the web to vent. I often vent on Facebook about restaurants where I have had a bad experience. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-4: (pointing to graphic of different types of social media) This is very true. Are there certain types of social media that you had in mind for our tablet launch? I have a Facebook account and use Twitter and Pinterest frequently, but I feel that using all of these might be overkill for our new tablet launch. MKT500_8_1_Ed-6: Well, there are a few sites that I believe will provide Golds Reling with very strong exposure during our initial launch. Let me show you this short video that discusses the advantages of using social media in our marketing campaign. Slide 4 Social Media Marketing in 3 Minutes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gza8dvN8Hkc Slide 5 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-5: Thanks for sharing that video, Ed. I understand better how social media helps connect companies to customers, and helps customers get to know, like, and trust companies better. MKT500_8_1_Ed-7: Yes. The key to a successful social media campaign is selecting a social media that creates good W.O.M. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-6: What is W.O.M.? MKT500_8_1_Ed-8: W.O.M. is Word-of-mouth. Word-of-mouth works on inherently exciting products like Golds Reling’s new tablet, and it also works where the notion of buzz marketing makes sense. Yet creative brand managers have launched clever ad campaigns that get talked about even for pretty mundane products, too; the key being that the product and the message are meaningful to the customer. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-7: Okay. You know, I learned in my classes at Strayer University that different social media combined create social networks. In social networks, there are some members that are more connected and influential than others. We need to leverage these interpersonal group dynamics, ideally locating the highly connected influential members, to induce their trial of our tablet, in turn initiating and propelling the diffusion process. MKT500_8_1_Ed-9: You’re right. To locate these influential members and get the word out about our tablet, we need to study how these potential consumers, or actors, are embedded in these networks to locate those that are relatively central. Centrality indices are computed for each actor in the network to describe the position of that actor relative to others in the network. The easiest and most common way to compute centrality is to count the number of connections each actor has with the others in the network. An index of degree centrality is derived for each actor—those with many links are said to be relatively central, and those with fewer links are more peripheral. In order to determine the degree of centrality for these consumers, we need to create several different accounts on various social media forums for Golds Reling. Strong centrality will be useful in creating buzz for our new tablets. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-8: Okay. We can start working on this right away. MKT500_8_1_Ed-10: First, though, let’s begin with answering the return of investments, or ROI, issues. As you know, Carl is always focused on the bottom line. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-9: What should we focus on in terms of ROI? MKT500_8_1_Ed-11: As with traditional media, we can begin to answer return on investment questions only if we know the goal that the marketing action was initially intended to achieve. Based on our goals, selecting the media and ROI measures are rather straightforward. When estimating ROI, which is really the efficiency of investments, the primary expenditures might not be media buys or explicit budgetary contributions so much as salary equivalents of people’s time allocations. We also need to consider KPIs. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-10: I know that KPIs are key performance indicators, but how do we identify KPIs for social media? MKT500_8_1_Ed-12: KPI’s for social media are analogous to traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. Specifically, marketers are always interested in quantifying reach, frequency, monetary value of customers, customers’ behaviors, attitudes, and memory, including recall and recognition. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-11: So, how can we determine the ROI and KPIs for our tablet? MKT500_8_1_Ed-13: I’m glad you asked this question, Samantha. A common way to determine ROI for social media is through conversation rate. This term refers to the true engagement for conversations in your social media communities. Conversations will be different depending on the network. For example, Facebook, YouTube, and blogs are focused on comments; however, Twitter is measured with mentions and hashtags. We, therefore, calculate the figures for each network, and calculate how many conversations took place about our company and products per post, tweet, or video submission. Another method we can use is viewability rate. This metric is a little harder to find on Twitter. However, for other networks and mediums such as Facebook, YouTube, and our blog, it is the total number of views or impressions per post. This is not as important as the conversation rate, but it is always satisfying to see how often your content is being looked at, and if no one is seeing it, then you better find a way to get users to view it! MKT500_8_1_Samantha-12: I see. Thank you for that explanation. Before we move on, let me check to make sure I understand what you are saying about KPIs. Slide 6 Check Your Understanding KPIs for social media are _________ traditional measures for advertising effectiveness. A) very different from B) analogous to C) opposite of D) inconsistent with Feedback: Incorrect A – very different from: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Correct B – analogous: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect C – opposite of: KPI’s are very similar to traditional media. Incorrect D – inconsistent with: KPI’s are very consistent with traditional media measurements. Slide 7 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-13: Great information, Ed, but can we go back to the word-of-mouth concept? How do we know consumers are talking about our new tablets on social media? How can we capture this and make it work for Golds Reling? MKT500_8_1_Ed-14: Word-of-mouth conversations and other customer-to-customer information flows have become a rich new source of consumer insights. There are two main categories for the ways in which consumers receive information about companies and their products: passive listening and active intervention. Slide 8 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, or web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: Tab A – Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. Tab B – Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. Tab C – Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. Tab D – Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. MKT500_8_1_Ed-15: Click the tabs to learn more about passive listening in marketing. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16: Passive Listening Research shows that a lot is learned from lurking, web crawling, and scraping, all of which are examples of passive listening: MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab A: Tweets, blogs, and discussion forums are monitored to make predictions about new product launches more accurate. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab B: Companies use text analyses on Facebook to get a read on customer opinions about their brands. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16¬_Tab C: Beyond the brand itself, content analysis has been useful in detecting developing consumer trends. MKT500_8_1_Ed-16_Tab D: Brand managers check websites for misinformation to try to nip bad, grassroots PR in the bud. Slide 9 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Samantha-14: Great information, Ed. What can you tell me about active interventions? Slide 10 Interaction Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions Tab A – Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. Tab B – Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, new product description, etc. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. Tab C – A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation, as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. Tab D – GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17: Click the tabs to learn more about active interventions. Active Interventions MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab A: Marketers enter online communities and ask for paid volunteers to be user groups to test beta products and offer feedback. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab B: Marketers conduct experiments. In the so-called A / B split tests, one group is exposed to one ad, new product description, or whatever element of the marketing mix the marketer is testing. The other group is either a control group, or they see a different version of an ad, featuring a new product description. The marketer then compares brand attitudes or subsequent sales in test markets to detect some lift due to the marketing intervention. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab C: A company may wish to measure comparative click-through rates, member sign-up rates, or purchase valuation as a function of whether the ad appeal is more rational or emotional, whether video or script endorsements are featured, which price is posted and whether a discount is available. MKT500_8_1_Ed-17_Tab D: GPS data function much like live cookies, storing information for your convenience upon return while still protecting your privacy. The purpose of GPS units in phones was originally consumer service for mapping. GPS units are becoming geo-retailing units, and they will soon offer extremely timely opportunities for marketers, though some may consider this more intrusive than timely. A motivated company will know where its customers are at all times. Slide 11 Scene 1, cont. [Ed, Samantha – Ed’s Office] MKT500_8_1_Ed-18: In general, social media pundits advise that any corporate postings or representations have to start by being interesting – otherwise, consumers won’t even read them! The content needs to be honest, not defensive, and not too “corporate”. There needs to be transparency to customers, employees, and stakeholders. Being transparent usually means being honest, building trust, and creating the opportunity for two-way dialog. Social media have sufficient variety and prevalence that they can be a tremendous marketing tool—if we can offer something that provides value to those customers, and reaches them in a way that matters to them. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-15: You’ve given me a lot of valuable information about social media, Ed. MKT500_8_1_Ed-19: I’m glad that you feel that way. Next, we can start by creating Golds Reling accounts for each of these social media applications. MKT500_8_1_Samantha-16: Well, since we already have a Facebook account, I can create a Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest account for Golds Reling. MKT500_8_1_Ed-20: Excellent. Let’s break for now, and then we can organize our information for Carl. Slide 12 Scene 2 [Ed, Samantha, Carl – Conference Room] Ed, Samantha, and Carl meet in the conference room to discuss the social media aspects of the product launch. MKT500_8_2_Carl-1: Good afternoon, Ed and Samantha. I saw you both looking very busy in Ed’s office earlier. I’m looking forward to hearing the information that you two have put together concerning social media marketing for our new tablets. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-1: Yes, Ed and I have been very busy. We have analyzed and concluded some basic concepts. MKT500_8_2_Carl-2: And what would these be? MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-2: Social media are an abundant opportunity for Golds Reling. Social media provides a web-based means for customers to interact with friends and strangers by posting opinions, pictures, and videos. Social networks are the structures of interconnections among customers that propagate word-of-mouth. Networks can be drawn and analyzed, and the actors measured on indices of centrality to assist Golds Reling in finding opinion leaders and influential consumers. Our campaign would identify these actors within two months of launch and create great buzz for our new tablets. A great feature of social media is the measurement methods; these are ROI and KPIs, and they can be computed with the help of online analytics, as for any marketing effort. MKT500_8_2_Carl-3: Good points! Why do you believe that investing in advertising through social media would be the right decision for Golds Reling and our new tablet? MKT500_8_2_ Ed-1: Social media is a great way to generate repeat business and to attract new customers. Furthermore, the target market we have selected are big users of social media. Golds Reling already has a Facebook account, but we believe that creating accounts for Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest will really help boost the conversation rate, and, thereby, the word-of-mouth, for both our company as a whole as well as our new tablet. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-3: Carl, by utilizing social media, we feel that Golds Reling is spending our advertising money wisely. MKT500_8_2_Carl-4: Ok, sounds like a good investment. Explain how we are going to measure this investment. MKT500_8_2_ Samantha-4: The key is to communicate the different features of our new tablet and to have consistency in the message we choose for social media. Measuring effectiveness will occur through KPI’s, recall, attitudes, click rates, and conversation and viewability rates from social media communications. MKT500_8_2_Carl-5: Excellent. I like what I’m hearing. Social media sounds perfect for generating buzz and word-of-mouth about our new tablet. I agree that Twitter, Google Plus, and Pinterest accounts for Golds Reling will be excellent additions to our existing Facebook account. Very nice work, both of you. Slide 13 Check Your Understanding What social media term refers to a set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them? A) Team B) Group C) Network D) Forum Incorrect A – Team: This is not the terminology used to describe relationships in social media. Incorrect B – Group: Although a group includes two or more people, this is not a part of the relational ties. Correct C – Social Network: A network is defined as the set of actors (or nodes) and the relational ties that link them. Actors may be customers, firms, brands, concepts, countries, etc. The connections between the actors are relational ties (or links). Ties can be symmetric or directional, and they can be binary or vary in strength. Incorrect D – Forum: Although this is a close description, it doesn’t explain the interaction experienced in social media. Slide 14 Scene 3 [Ed, Samantha – Hallway] MKT500_8_3_Samantha-1: Today was a highly informative day. Using social media for marketing can help us generate word-of-mouth about our tablet, especially if we are able to connect with the most influential members of social networks. MKT500_8_3_Ed-1: Absolutely. It will also help customers identify Golds Reling as a company they know, like and trust. Don’t forget to complete the e-Activity and particip
"The Importance of Social Media and Web Analytics" Please respond to the following: From the case study, assess the degree to which Salina Siu effectively used YouTube to develop customer loyalty. Appraise the success potential of at least two (2) other social media methods that Salina could use to promote her business. Justify your response. * From the scenario, prioritize the most significant…
View On WordPress
0 notes