Chapter 2: Lost in Sacrificial Fate ~Trial~
Wooo! The trial is finally done, this is a pretty long one so hopefully you guys don’t mind that. Hope ya’ll enjoy
Bold are blue statements
Bold and italic are yellow statements
“Now, let’s begin with a simple explanation of the class trial! You’re votes will determine the outcome of this, you will debate on a variety of topics regarding the murder and then try to identify ‘whodunit’. If you can correctly guess the culprit, then the culprit alone will be punished…but if you guess the wrong one. I’ll punish everyone besides the culprit! Now…where will this trial go? I hope it’s good!”
“There’s not really much to discuss though, is there? It’s kinda obvious who the killer is in this case.” Shinko-san started off.
“It’s obvious? But I still don’t have any idea, even after the investigation.” Yokozawa-san said.
“No need to worry, that’s why I’m here to show you all how this case went down. Simply put, Irunami died because of a freak accident when the lighting rig fell. Everyone in the audience is a witness to that. So, whoever was working the lighting must be the one that’s accountable. So, it has to be Okanaya that’s the culprit of the case!” Shinko-san declared.
“E-eh?! Me again?!”
“Did you seriously not even put that together? Of course, if the lighting rig was what killed Irunami-chan, then the one working the lighting rig would be the most suspicious.” Kurosaki-san sighed with a smirk.
“Bullshit! You can’t just say I’m the killer because of that! B-besides, surely that wouldn’t be reason enough for me to be responsible! M-Monokuma?!”
“Weeeeeell…even if its an accident, the one who ultimate caused the accident is still gonna be the culprit for that death.” It was an ambiguous answer that didn’t say Okanaya-san was the culprit.
“Aren’t we moving a little quickly?” Ishikawa-san interrupted. “To simply decide Okanaya-sama as the culprit at the start of the trial would be foolish. Shinko-sama, please keep your rash accusations to yourself, I would prefer it if you didn’t hurt our chances passing the trial.”
“Huh?! The fuck did you say to me?! Do you know who you’re talking to, bitch?!” Shinko-san growled.
“Save your breaths for the discussion, would you?” Amaterasu-san stepped in. “The problem here is if this case is an accident or not, and if it is an accident, does that necessarily mean it was Kobo-chan’s fault.”
“It definitely wasn’t me! I’m telling you all now!” Okanaya-san said again. Was Irunami-san’s death an accident…? We need to figure that out first.
-Non-Stop Debate 1-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets:
Broken Spotlight/Undamaged Spotlight
Okanaya-san’s Account/Okanaya-san’s Mistake
Lighting Rig/Metal Pole
Amaterasu: If you guys don’t decide whether this case is an accident or not, we can’t progress…
Toson: Obviously…The murder happened on accident….and Okanaya is responsible.
Kobo: Don’t just say that! This could’ve been on purpose!
Karma: You do realise that if it was on purpose then you’d have to be the killer, right…? You were the only one working the lighting rig
Kobo: N-no way! It ain’t that easy! The killer…could’ve sabotaged the lighting rig!
Karma: Oh! I guess that’s true! Then maybe the case is a real homicide!
Ryuu: (We first need to decide if this case is a homicide or an accident…how am I supposed to prove that?)
“No, that’s wrong!”
-
“Shinko-san, I don’t think Irunami-san died from an accident. When I was talking to Okanaya-san during the investigation, he told me that he made sure that the lighting rig was secured last night. So, if it really was secure, I doubt it would’ve just fell on accident at just the right time to kill Irunami-san.”
“Okanaya told you that…? Hmm…usually I wouldn’t believe the words of a suspect-“
“Didn’t we do that for you the last trial?” Kurohiko-san pointed out.
“-but I checked the lighting rig as well, just to make sure Okanaya didn’t fuck it up…and yeah, it was secure. Totally forgot about that.”
“How convenient of you to forget that.” Okanaya-san snarled.
“However, that doesn’t mean the killer isn’t Okanaya. It just means the murder was on purpose. With his own testimony, we know the lighting was secure the night before and that means the lighting rig needed to be released by someone. Namely, the only person working the lighting rig.” Shinko-san said.
“Huh…? Well, maybe it was sabotaged or something the night before and it had nothing to do with Okanaya-kun.” Yokozawa-san suggested.
“We all finished at 9 every night, so it’s not impossible to say that someone just snuck into the auditorium after we all left.” Ram-san said. No…simply getting would be pretty difficult because…
-
My logic follows!
-
“Shinko-san, you locked door at night after rehearsals, right? Then the door wouldn’t be unlocked until we started again in the morning.”
“Yeah, that’s right. I didn’t want anyone going in and messing with stuff without supervision. And because of that, nobody could’ve gotten into the auditorium outside of any rehearsal times.” Shinko-san confirmed.
“Could someone sabotage the lighting rig before the performances began that morning? We did not start the show until 12:30 or so.” Asano-san suggested.
“No, that’s not possible either. I was by the ropes for the lighting rig as soon as we got in that morning and didn’t leave until the murder happened, nobody had the chance to fuck around with the lighting rig.” Okanaya-san shook as head.
“I feel like you’re too honest for your own good.” Graves-san laughed.
“The honesty is appreciated though. Makes our job a lot easier.” Sly-san said.
“Did you do it though Okanaya-kun…? Did you kill Irunami-kun…?” Hachi-san’s voice trembled with a mix of anger and anguish.
“Hell no! Now that I know it wasn’t an accident, I’m gonna prove I didn’t have anything to do with this! Don’t worry Hachi, we’ll find out who did this and sent them straight to hell!” I believe him. I really don’t think Okanaya-san is the killer, so I need to prove that either there was a way to sabotage the lighting rig, or that the lighting rig didn’t need to be sabotaged.
-Non-Stop Debate 2-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets
Cables/Razor Wire
Shinko-san’s Account/Shinko-san’s Mistake
Lighting Rig/Metal Rod
Vent System/Bolted Vent Grates
Kobo: I’m not the killer…! I’m gonna prove it to you all!
Doi: Since Irunami’s death was on purpose…doesn’t that mean the killer had to be near the lighting rig?
Kobo: Yeah, but somebody else could’ve done that!
Ram: The door was locked…
Tsukiko: Could there be another way into the auditorium?
Tomoe: Maybe the killer used a set-up!
Kobo: Or the lighting rig didn’t need to be sabotaged!
Ryuu: (Something someone said…I think that might be the key to this.)
I agree with that!
-
“Ishikawa-san may be right. Even if the door was locked, there should’ve been another way to get into the auditorium. During the investigation, Graves-san decided to check the vent system and found that it went throughout the whole building. ‘Every floor, every room’ were her words.”
“It’s true! Look at all the dust on me!” Graves-san spread her arms to show off her dirty outfit.
“I wasn’t gonna mention it…but if there was another way to get into the auditorium…” Yokozawa-san nodded understandingly.
“Yeah. Then it’s way too early to say that Okanaya-san is the killer!”
“God, fine!” Shinko-san conceded defeat.
“So, at some point the killer went into the auditorium after we all finished up for rehearsals and messed around with the lighting rig. That’s good and all but where do we go from there…?” Graves-san asked.
“Well…I don’t know if this is worth out time or not, but…I wasn’t there for the moment that Irunami-san was killed, so I don’t fully get what happened. Could we maybe go over what happened?” Kurohiko-san asked.
“Same for me. I was backstage when it all happened, so I want a clarification too.” Amaterasu-san second.
“It’s important we all stay on the same page, so we should go over it.” Ram-san agreed.
-Non-Stop Debate 3-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets
Lighting rig/Metal Rod
Fog Machines/Dry Ice Buckets
Broken Spotlight/Undamaged stagelight
Kurosaki-san’s Set/Kurohiko-san’s Set
Shinko-san’s Filiming/Shinko-san’s Absence
Shinko-san’s Account/Shinko-san’s Mistake
Ram: When the show started…everything seemed normal…
Doi: I know that Kurosaki-san and I went on first…but after that I didn’t come back….
Tomoe: Shinko-kun’s movie played fine as well…There was nothing wrong with the movie.
Amaterasu: And afterwards was Sadao-chan.
Tomoe: Yeah, Irunami-kun came on stage…but when he called Shinko-kun to the stage…that’s when the lighting rig fell and struck him over the head…!
Yuuki: There was a broken stage light on the ground too. It must have broken off on impact.
Ryuu: (…this is just supposed to be a recollection of what happened…so why does something feel off?)
No, that’s wrong!
-
“…um…” Even though I objected, I don’t really know where I’m supposed to go with this. Everyone’s staring at me, so I need to at least raise the concern. “K…Kurosaki-san, about what you said…you said the stage light broke off of the lighting rig when it hit Irunami-san, right?”
“Is there something wrong with that? You’re not gonna suggest the lighting rig wasn’t the murder weapon, are you?” Sly-san asked.
“It’s not that. The spotlight had blood on it, so I don’t that it’s the murder weapon…it’s just…the part of the spotlight that attaches to the lighting rig…it isn’t damaged.”
“Huh? What do you mean it’s not damaged, does that matter?” Yokozawa-san said.
“Yeah, it’s definitely weird. The lights have this kind of metal hoop that goes right around the lighting rig’s pole. Makes it fuckin’ difficult to position then right. There’s no way one could fall off without that hoop being broken off.” Okanaya-san explained.
“Oh! Then it’s like a condom!” Graves-san nodded.
“It is definitely not like a condom.” Yokozawa-san said with disgust.
“Eh…? So, you’ve used one before?” Graves-san tilted her head.
“I see. It is good you are enjoying life, Yokozawa-sama.” Ishikawa-san smiled and giggled.
“Th-that isn’t it! M-more importantly, why isn’t that spotlight’s attachment broken off?!” Yokozawa-san threw us back into the discussion. It’s suspicious. Really suspicious.
“Ah~ Maybe we should take a step back!” Kurosaki-san suddenly chimed up.
“Oh great. I almost forgot about you and now my headache is back.” Shinko-san complained.
“Ehhhh!? Shinko-chan, don’t be mean to me!”
“Wh-who the hell are you being so informal with?! Die, will you?!” Shinko-san’s face flushed.
“Kurosaki, what do you mean by taking a step back?” Sly-san interrupted.
“Well, it’s pretty easy to tell why the spotlight’s attachment isn’t broken, right? There’s no need to discuss it at full length.” There’s no reason to discuss it at full length…then is the reason the spotlight’s attachment isn’t broken something simple…?
-
My logic follows!
-
“You’re saying that the spotlight that hit Irunami-san was never attached to the lighting rig, right? That’s why it’s attachment was never broken.”
“Perfecto! Nagata-kyun, we think so much alike!” I definitely don’t want to hear that from you…
“Wait, if the spotlight was never attached to the lighting rig then how did it manage to get onto the stage? Furthermore, how on earth was it able to strike Irunami-sama?” Ishikawa-san asked. That’s the new question, huh…seems we’ll need to figure that out next.
-Non-Stop Debate 4-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets
Fog Machines/Dry Ice Buckets
Broken Spotlight/Undamaged Spotlight
Kurosaki-san’s Set/Kurohiko-san’s Set
Air Cannon/Fog Vacuum
Trap Door/Regular Floor
Kurohiko-san’s Clothes/Irunami-san’s Clothes
Tsukiko: There must’ve been a chance for the spotlight to make its way onto the stage.
Kobo: Maybe it was always on stage…? But we just couldn’t tell.
Tomoe: Or maybe Irunami-kun brought it on with him?
Amaterasu: Or there was some kind of fancy trick used…like balancing the spotlight on the lighting rig…and it fell onto Sadao-chan.
Doi: Talk about suspension of belief…
Tomoe: Are we overthinking it…?
Ryuu: (How did the spotlight get onto the stage…? We need to figure that next…)
I agree with that!
-
“I think Amaterasu-san said. There was a trick used to get the spotlight onto the stage. When I was investigating underneath the stage, I found that there was a trap door that worked by alternating two different wooden panels between the stage and underneath the stage.”
“Ah! If that trap door was used, then the killer could get the spotlight onto the stage!” Ram-san concluded.
“Exactly. I think that’s exactly what the killer did!”
“That can’t be real!”
-
“Hold on now Nagata-kun, there’s a massive problem with that! Sure, I can understand the killer using the trap door to get the spotlight onto the stage, but if that’s the case then now did, they manage to hit Irunami-kun with the stage light and kill him?!” Hachi-san objected.
-Rebuttal Showdown Vs. Tomoe Hachi-
Truth Blades:
Broken Spotlight
Trap Door
Ram-san’s Account
Kurohiko-san’s Clothes
Kurohiko-san’s Account
Tomoe: Sure, the trap door could have used to get the spotlight onto the stage, but that doesn’t tell us how it struck Irunami-kun! Irunami-kun died right there on stage so how could the spotlight have hit him when it was underneath the stage?
Ryuu: Isn’t it possible that we’re missing something? There could’ve been some sort of set up used!
Tomoe: Some sort of set up…? There’s no kind of set up that would work! And there’s no way Irunami-kun hit himself so if there was no way for it to happen…then the spotlight wasn’t brought to the stage by the trap door!
Ryuu: (I can feel something in the back of my mind…some kind of new possibility with the evidence we have…)
I’ll cut through that argument!
-
“Actually…Irunami-san might’ve not died on stage like we originally thought.”
“H-huh?!” Hachi-san frowned.
“When I was investigating Irunami-san’s dressing room I found Kurohiko-san’s regular clothes in a bag-“
“You found my clothes and didn’t tell me?!”
“You wouldn’t have wanted to wear them. When Nagata-kun looked at those clothes there was blood found on them, if I remember.” Yokozawa-san recalled.
“B-blood on my clothes…?” Kurohiko-san paled. “H-hold on, y-you aren’t gonna accuse me, right?!”
“Doi-chan isn’t the killer.” Amaterasu-san said.
“I agree! I cannot see Kurohiko-kun being the killer!” Asano-san added.
“N-no, I’m not saying that. Kurohiko-san was in his stage clothing ever since his set with Kurosaki-san…after all somebody should’ve seen him enough times to prove that…”
-
It’s you!
-
“Kurohiko-san told me that he saw Amaterasu-san a lot whilst searching for his clothes. I’m sure she can confirm that Kurohiko-san was in his stage outfit the whole time after Kurosaki-san’s set.”
“Yeah, he was.” Amaterasu-san stated.
“Though how exactly does this all mean that Kurohiko isn’t the killer?” Sly-san asked.
“Th…that’s not really the point I was trying to make. Rather than proving Kurohiko-san can’t be the killer…his clothes actually prove that Irunami-san didn’t die on stage in front of us like we originally thought. Nobody would’ve been close enough to Irunami-san when that lighting rig fell for blood to get on those clothes…”
“So…you’re saying that Sadao died somewhere else?” Graves-san thought for a moment. “It makes sense…between that blood and the broken spotlight, it’s obvious that Sadao never made onto the stage.” Never made it onto the stage…come to think of it…someone mentioned something else that points to the fact that Irunami-san never made it to the stage.
-
Here’s my proof!
-
“Ram-san pointed out that Irunami-san died in his regular outfit despite the fact that she and Asano-san made a stage outfit for him.”
“Are you saying that…Irunami-kun was in his normal clothing because he was dead before he got on stage…? But, if that’s the case then what did we see on the stage?” Ram-san asked.
“Yeah, I’ve been thinking for a while that we kind of believed all this way too easily. I mean…we all saw Irunami-kun from the audience. So, that must’ve been him.” Hachi-san said.
…they have a point. I’m positive that Irunami-san wasn’t alive when he was on stage, so who was it that came on during his set...? “Let’s think of it this way then. If Irunami-chan being in his normal clothes proves he didn’t make it to the stage, then whatever had his stage clothes would be what appeared during his set.” Kurosaki-san said. Whatever…was in Irunami-san’s stage clothes?
-
Here’s my proof!
-
“There was a stunt dummy underneath the stage that was wearing Irunami-san’s clothing. Kurosaki-san, are you suggesting that what we saw on stage was that dummy…?”
“Oui! Very well done, Nagata-kyun~! If the killer utilized that dummy, then it becomes easy to act as if Irunami-chan is on stage!” Kurosaki-san explained.
“No, it doesn’t.” Hachi-san disagreed. “It explains the silhouette. But it’s not that simple…but there’s two other problems. One, why didn’t we notice? Second, how did the dummy move around the stage?”
“Okanaya-kun was right next to the stage, shouldn’t he have noticed if the figure on the stage was Irunami-kun or not…?” Yokozawa-san said. Not necessarily…if the killer used that thing then they could’ve stopped anyone from realising that it was actually a dummy.
-
Here’s my proof!
-
“Couldn’t the killer have disguised the dummy with the fog machines? There was a lot of fog on the stage that we could barely see who it was on the stage. Because of that, we just assumed that Irunami-san was on stage because it was his set.”
“And it explains why Okanaya-kun wouldn’t have realised despite being so close to the stage.” Ram-san continued.
“Okay…that takes care of problem one, but what about how the dummy was moved around the stage…? That still hasn’t been explained.” Kurohiko-san said.
“We’ve come too far to be wrong here! I’m sure if put our heads together we can figure this out as well!” Ram-san smiled. Yeah, she’s right…the solution is somewhere, we just need to find it.
-Non-stop Debate 5-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets
Kurosaki-san’s Set/Kurohiko-san’s Set
Remote Control Car/Broken Toy
Cables/Razor Wire
Air Cannons/Fog Vacuums
Dummy/Undamaged Dummy
Ram: The killer must have had a way to move the body around the stage! I’m sure we can find it!
Kobo: Should we just guess…? Maybe the killer used wires? They could’ve controlled the dummy like a puppet!
Tomoe: Did they use magic?! They could’ve done it with a trick!
Sly: Also, possible they carried the dummy around.
Karma: Or the dummy is haunted…and levitated around the stage by itself!
Doi: D-don’t say it’s a ghost!
Ryuu: (Someone brought up an idea that might be possible given what I know…)
I agree with you!
-
“Sly-san might be onto something. There might have been a method of carrying the dummy around the stage. When I was investigating underneath the stage, there was a remote-control car sitting there. The same car that Amaterasu-san was looking for to use in her performance.”
“Amaterasu was gonna use a remote-control car…? For singing…?” Sly-san raised an eyebrow.
“Not just any kind of remote-control car. This car was specially equipped and suitable for someone like the Ultimate Thief. This car was modified with a claw that would be used to pickpocket people.” I explained.
“I was gonna distract everyone when I was singing and use the car to steal stuff. Had it all planned out.” Amaterasu-san said.
“Right. If the killer used the claw on the remote-control car then it’s possible to transport the dummy around.”
“He’s right…the arm the claw is attached to is super long and I made sure the car wouldn’t tip over despite any weight on it. It totally should’ve been able to carry around the dummy.” Amaterasu-san confirmed.
“Then it’s settled. There are no more problems with Irunami-san not dying on stage like we originally thought-“
“I see your flaws!”
-
“Don’t fuck around now, Nagata-kun! There’s still a massive problem that you haven’t answered!” Yokozawa-san interrupted.
“H-huh…? There’s still more?”
“Geez, you didn’t even realise it…? Guess I have no choice but to explain…”
-Rebuttal Showdown Vs Junpei Yokozawa-
Truth Blades:
Asano-san’s Account
Kurohiko-san’s Account
Shinko-san’s Account
Okanaya-san’s Account
Ram-san’s Account
Junpei: You’re saying that everything has been proven but that’s not the case. You still haven’t explained Irunami-kun’s voice when he came on stage to do his set. If you can’t explain the voice then you haven’t really explained anything!
Ryuu: Are you really saying that after all the evidence presented that Irunami-san was still killed on stage?
Junpei: We all heard Irunami-kun’s voice, that’s undeniable! It was clear as day, he even called up Shinko-kun to the stage! There wasn’t anything unusual about his set until that moment, aside from the fog machines!
Ryuu: (I get Yokozawa-san’s point, but even so…)
I’ll cut through that argument!
-
“No, there was something unusual about Irunami-san’s set. When I was talking to Shinko-san about the performance he said it was strange. It was like Irunami-san was repeating everything he was saying during the rehearsal stages word-for-word.”
“Now that you mention it…” Amaterasu-san murmured.
“But that’s not all. Hachi-san, you and Irunami-san recorded your sets so you could watch them back, right? Would it not have been possible to use Irunami-san’s set from there when they sent the dummy out on stage?”
“P-probably…there are speakers underneath the stage. If you plugged the recorder in there, you could play it out over the speakers.” Hachi-san nodded.
“So…Irunami-kun seriously didn’t die on the stage…? And all of that stuff we talked about is seriously what the killer did…?” Yokozawa-san said in disbelief. “How…? How the hell did someone even come up with a plan like that?”
“It’s obvious, right? The killer’s just one crafty bastard.” Okanaya-san said.
“If that’s the case we can finally rule out Kobo-chan.” Amaterasu-san said.
“Oi!”
“But even though we’ve established the method, are we actually any closer to finding the killer…?” Ram-san asked.
“Hmm…well, the Monokuma File doesn’t mention the time of death, right? Maybe we should try and figure out when Irunami-kun died?” Yokozawa-san suggested.
“Check everybody’s alibis, right…? Yeah! We can do that! Let’s figure it out ASAP!” Hachi-san said with determination. The time of death…I wonder, do we have anything to show when it could’ve been?
-Non-Stop Debate 6-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets:
Monokuma File 2/Monokuma’s Mistake 2
Kurohiko-san’s Account/Kurohiko-san’s Mistake
Talent Show Line-up/Scraped Line-up Plan
Rehearsal Schedule/Night-Time Announcement
Shinko-san’s Filming/Shinko-san’s Absence
Kurosaki-san’s Set/Kurohiko-san’s Set
Junpei: Since the Monokuma File doesn’t include the time of death…do we have any way to pinpoint when Irunami-san died?
Mami: Irunami-kun must have died during the talent show
Kobo: During it…? How do you figure that?
Tomoe: It’s not impossible…did someone see him?
Mami: I do not believe anybody saw him…however, something could have happened…something that could have only happened during the murder. That would give us the time of death.
Yuuki: Was Senorita Asano always so cryptic?
Ryuu: (We can’t determine alibis without figuring out the time of death…so how do we go about figuring that out…?)
I agree with that!
-
“Yeah…something did happen. Something that could have only happened during the murder. Remember how I mentioned earlier that Kurohiko-san’s clothes had blood on them? Well, Kurohiko-san’s clothes could have only went missing during the set with Kurosaki-san. That must have been around the time of the murder!”
“That’s not necessarily true. Couldn’t Kurohiko have killed Irunami before the talent show and then simply changed into his stage outfit…?” Shinko-san asked.
“Nope! I can disprove that theory right now!” Kurosaki-san chimed. “You see, Monsieur Kurohiko and I shared a changing room and we were in there the whole time getting prepared for our set-in various ways, so he had no opportunity to kill Irunami-chan in his regular clothing. Not to mention that, even if he did, I would’ve noticed the blood.”
“V…various ways…?” Shinko-san repeated.
“Wh-why the hell are you saying weird things?!” Kurohiko-san protested.
“So that is the kind of man you are, Kurohiko-kun.” Asano-san nodded understandingly.
“And there wasn’t a chance for Doi-chan to kill Sadao-chan after his set either. I saw him too often backstage while I was searching for my car and not once did, I see him in his regular clothing.” Amaterasu-san joined.
“And in turn, I saw Amaterasu-san way too often for her to have a chance to sneak underneath the stage and set up all that stuff with Irunami-san’s body. In fact, I saw Amaterasu-san only a few seconds before the lighting rig fell and she should’ve had the remote for the toy car with her, but she didn’t.” Kurohiko-san said.
“So, you two are each other’s alibis. At least that sorts them out.” Yokozawa-san said. “So we know there’s about half an hour of time where the killer could’ve killed Irunami-kun whilst Kurosaki-kun and Kurohiko-kun were on stage.”
“A whole half an hour of knife tossing…” Kurohiko-san shivered from the memory.
“And majority of the others were in the audience at the time, right? So, they obviously have alibis.” Sly-san said. That actually brings our suspect list down…huh?
“Wait…is there anybody left then…? Wasn’t everyone either on stage or in someone’s sights in that time frame…?” I asked.
“Okanaya was working the lights in the wings. Would anybody see him…?” Sly-san asked.
“I was standing with Okanaya during Kurosaki’s set waiting for my turn, so he has an alibi for that time. We saw Amaterasu a lot as well, she was really pacing back and forth around backstage.” Shinko-san said. Then…who’s even left at this point…?
“One person.” Kurosaki-san said. Huh? “One person is left. Out of our whole group, only one person standing here doesn’t have an alibi for when me and Kurohiko-san were on stage. One person who nobody saw until the murder.”
“…w-wait…” It suddenly dawned on me. Out of everybody here, the only person that wasn’t seen until the murder…that was…
…that person is the culprit? That can’t be right though…
-
The culprit…is you!
-
“…Hachi-san?”
“Huh? What’s up?” Hachi-san asked, not quite realising it yet.
“If we go by everybody’s accounts, the only person left without an alibi for Kurosaki-san’s set would be you…” But can that be right…?
“Hold on, there’s clearly a problem with that! A big one!” Ram-san cried. “H-Hachi-san and Irunami-kun were best friends! It just doesn’t make sense for Hachi-san to be the killer, don’t you think?!”
“Friends?” Kurosaki-san repeated slowly. “Sorry, but if you start saying lines like that then I’ll start laughing. Laughing so hard I might piss myself, so please don’t start joking around.” It was quick. It’s always quick when Kurosaki-san’s malicious expression reveals itself that I can’t help getting caught off guard. “Friends don’t exist in the class trial, only victims and killers. Those are our only relationships to each other…”
“That’s not true!” Ram-san yelled, surprising everyone in the room. “…a-ah, what I mean to say is…I want to believe in the friends I made here, if I can’t believe in them then there’s nothing I can believe in…s-so, I want to believe in the friendship Irunami-kun and Hachi-san had…”
“R-Ram-chan…” Hachi-san murmured. They let out a breath and looked at me. “Okay…if you’re gonna try and point to me as the killer then I want some serious proof because not having an alibi by itself doesn’t mean anything.”
“If that’s the case, where were you during Kurosaki’s set?” Sly-san asked.
“I was preparing for my tricks and stuff. Irunami-kun and I had a switching places acting at the end of his set, so I had to set up for that, but I also had to set up for my own tricks. I didn’t have any time to go and kill Irunami-kun.” Hachi-san explained.
“So pathetic…” Kurosaki-san sighed. “I don’t even want to get into a debate because this is so pathetic…you were killing Irunami-chan and setting up all your tricks for the murder. Not the show.”
“Th-that’s not true…!” Hachi-san said.
“Kurosaki, can you just shut up…?” Okanaya-san growled. Kurosaki-san looked at him for a moment and smiled with a nod. “Let’s actually talk about this shit properly. Hachi, you’re saying there ain’t any evidence saying you’re the killer, but you actually got anything specific…?”
“S…specific…?” Hachi-san thought for a second. “…ah! I got it! The lighting rig! The killer obviously had to make the lighting rig fall somehow, but it’s not been established how that was done! If you can’t prove I could’ve knocked the lighting rig down, then I can’t be the killer!”
“They’ve got a point. The lighting rig was part of the killer’s cover-up so if Hachi-san didn’t knock it down, they can’t be the killer.” Kurohiko-san frowned. The method of knocking down the lighting rig…it’s true we didn’t decide on what it was, but will that really prove who the killer is?
-Non-stop Debate 7-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets
Okanaya-san’s Account/Okanaya-san’s Mistake
Lighting Rig/Metal Rod
Hachi-san’s Magic Classes/Irunami-san’s Hypnosis Classes
Rehearsal Schedule/Absence List
Air Cannons/Fog Vacuums
Tomoe: If you can’t connect the lighting rig falling to me…then I can’t be the killer!
Kobo: So, the issue is how the lighting rig fell.
Tsukiko: Perhaps the cables were severed?
Kobo: It’s stupid to say, but…maybe the wind knocked it down?
Toson: Dumbass, we were inside…there was no wind!
Amaterasu: Couldn’t Tomoe-chan have climbed up and released them?
Toson: You’re just acting to be voted for, aren’t you? Nobody could’ve climbed all the way up there!
Ryuu: (Let’s think carefully about this. The answer might be a little ludicrous, but if it’s the only answer…)
No, that’s wrong!
-
“No, Shinko-san…I think Okanaya-san may be onto something by saying it was the wind. When I was talking to Yokozawa-san, he started talking about these air cannons that Irunami-san was planning to use during his performance. Pretty powerful ones.”
“Powerful is an understatement, they could send a person flying from the other side of the stage.” Kurohiko-san said.
“Urp!” Hachi-san went pale. So…that really might be it.
“Who was in charge of setting up the air cannons for Irunami-san’s act?” I asked.
“That was…Hachi. Hachi and Irunami were helping each other set up their sets.” Shinko-san spoke, realising what everything meant. “H…hold the fuck up! Are you really gonna say that Hachi set up an air cannon to knock the lighting rig down?!”
“E-e-easy now! That doesn’t mean anything! S-sure, I set the air cannons, but someone could’ve changed their positions! Amaterasu-chan was walking back and forth between the wings and backstage, right?!” Hachi-san argued.
“Can you prove that Amaterasu touched the air cannons?” Sly-san asked.
“Can you prove she didn’t?! B-besides, if that’s all you got then I don’t have anything else to say! Those air cannons don’t tie to me at all! You can’t tie the air cannons to me!” Did I not already do that…? So, Hachi-san wants something more than what I already showed…something that might link to the air cannons…
-
Here’s my proof!
-
“Hachi-san, I have just one question. How do you do your wind trick?”
“…huh?” Hachi-san somehow went paler.
“You told me about those magic classes you gave to some of the group, and a wind trick. How did you do that magic trick…? Did you maybe use the air cannons?”
“I…I…”
“Not to mention that everybody who was at those magic classes has an alibi for the murder…! So even though some of us knew how to do that trick, none of us could’ve actually killed Irunami-kun!” Yokozawa-san said.
“So…it’s really true, huh…? Hachi-san really killed Irunami-kun…!” Ram-san covered her mouth.
“HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLD ON!!!!” Hachi-san bellowed. “It’s all…circumstantial! Because…because…you still haven’t established where Irunami-kun died! Where did Irunami-kun die?!”
Irunami-san…the most likely place he died would be…
-
My logic follows!
-
“It would’ve been to risky to kill him underneath the stage. Kurohiko-san had left his clothes there, so he was definitely going to go there at some point. The only place I can think of…is Irunami-san’s dressing room.”
“But, other than on Kurohiko-kun’s clothing, there was no blood in there, correct?” Asano-san said.
“Irunami-sama had thick, curly hair, when he was hit, a lot of the blood would’ve been soaked in by his hair, so a lack of blood isn’t so strange.” Ishikawa-san said.
“So, you’re saying Tomoe-chan killed Sadao-chan and then took his body underneath the stage and set it up for the switch when the lighting rig fell.” Amaterasu-san clarified, “Then…isn’t there another problem, isn’t there…?”
“Another problem? What do you mean?” Kurohiko-san raised an eyebrow.
-Non-stop Debate 8-
Truth Bullets/Lie Bullets
Vent System/Bolted Vent Grates
Costume Rack/Empty Rack
Trap Door/Regular Floor
Hachi-san’s Account/Hachi-san’s Mistake
Amaterasu: The killer must’ve had a way to get Sadao-chan underneath the stage…the problem is that Tomoe-chan would’ve had to pass through the backstage area to get underneath the stage…wouldn’t that have been impossible…?
Toson: Right…Amaterasu was going back and forth around backstage…but she didn’t see Hachi at all….
Tomoe: Yeah…! Yeah! See? I’m not the killer then! Thanks Amaterasu-chan, you’re the best!
Ryuu: (I don’t doubt that Irunami-san was killed in his dressing room…was there a method of getting Irunami-san’s body underneath the stage without being seen?)
No, that’s wrong!
-
“That wouldn’t be a problem at all. Remember earlier how I mentioned the vent system? It’s possible for Hachi-san to move Irunami-san’s body through there, right? That way they could’ve gotten Irunami-san’s body underneath the stage without being seen.”
“Oh yeah! The vents are huge, it would be super easy to push a body through there or drag it!” Graves-san said.
“Nononononononono!!” Hachi-san pleaded. “It’s all wrong! This is all wrong I’m telling you!”
“With this…all the mysteries have been solved. Hachi-san killed Irunami-san, took his body to underneath the stage then set up the switcheroo trick to make it seem like he died on stage, then joined us in the audience.”
“…huh?” Hachi-san thought for a second. “…yeah! That’s not possible, Nagata-kun! Not possible at all…! Because if I was in the audience at the moment of the lighting rig falling, then how could I have pulled the lever to activate the trap door?!”
“A-ah…!” Th-they still have more in them…but I can feel it. This has to be the final hurdle before Hachi-san confesses…okay, I’ll break through this and end this trial!
-Argument Armament Vs. Tomoe Hachi-
Tomoe: There’s no way I could have been in two places at once, so I couldn’t have pulled the lever for the switcheroo trick! Your whole basis is wrong because I’m not the killer, I could never be the killer!
Tomoe: Stop it already…I just want to find Irunami-kun’s killer! I want to find the truth more than anyone, so why are you accusing me?! I’m innocent I tell you, I’m innocent, I won’t let you say I killed my friend!
Tomoe: Just leave me alone! It’s all a trick by the true killer, you’re being tricked! I won’t allow this killer to get away, so just stop it already! It’s impossible, completely impossible for me to be the killer!
Ryuu: This is the end!
Tomoe: How could I have done the switcheroo from the audience?
Remote Control!
-
“You could have easily activated the trap door from the audience, as long as you had its remote control.”
“R-r-remote?!” Hachi-san repeated.
“Kurohiko-san told me about it when he was explaining the trap door to me. He said that practically everything in the auditorium was remote controlled. Kurohiko-san, that includes the trap door, right?”
“Y…yeah. Trap door, speakers, fog machines, lights…everything.” Kurohiko-san confirmed.
“And if you were using remote controls, you wouldn’t have had a moment where you could safely dispose of them, right? After all, Hachi appeared right after the lighting rig fell…so, if we searched you, would we find the remotes?” Sly-san asked.
“Gh!”
“You clearly blundered when you volunteered to watch over Irunami-sama’s body, but if you did not it may have been suspicious that you did not wish to be with Irunami-sama after his passing. A conundrum you clearly had not prepared for…” Ishikawa-san theorised.
“And that’s that…any more objections, Hachi-san?” I asked. Hachi-san simply let their mouth hang open, unable to form any kind of coherent words or phrases.
“Hey, I’m still kind of fucked here…this was really complicated, so can we go over it all from the start?” Okanaya-san asked. Yeah…I’ll summarise these events and end this case once and for all.
“This is the truth of the incident!”
-
Act 1
This case is a pretty complicated one, so I'll try my best to explain it all thoroughly since it relied heavily on a certain trick. First the killer needed to prepare beforehand for the actual murder so they decided, with the work of Irunami-san and Shinko-san, that they would all work to put on a talent show as a cover for the murder. They were going to use their set time in the talent show as their alibi and as a way to frame Okanaya-san.
Act 2
First the killer prepared a dummy and dressed it up as Irunami-san. Then rigged the lighting bar for the actual talent show by setting up some of the air cannons to hit the lighting rig at full blast. They did this all the night before the talent show, knowing that nobody else from the stage crew would be around so they were free to do what they needed to.
Act 3
Next was the actual day of the murder, the first few acts went on as normal. However, at this moment, the killer went backstage to Irunami-san's dressing room and used a spare stage light to bludgeon him to death, dressed in Kurohiko-san's clothes to avoid the blood getting on their clothes. Next the killer got changed out of Kurohiko-san's clothes and into their own.
Act 4
Then they took the stage light and Irunami-san's body and placed them on the lift for the trapdoor underneath the stage by transporting them through the vents and swapped their bloody clothes out for the stage outfit on the rack, then hiding the bloody clothes in a bag in Irunami-san’s dressing room. Then they took the dummy dressed as Irunami-san and used Amaterasu-san’s remote control car to hold it up. Now it was ready to go on stage.
Act 5
The dummy went on as Irunami-san and the killer joined the audience through the vent, saying it was part of the trick Irunami-san was planning and waited until the dummy was hovering over the trap door and released the lighting bar by using an air cannon, letting it crash onto the stage. They then used the button for the trap door to switch the dummy with Irunami-san's actual body and feigned innocence, thinking we'd all believe the tech crew was to blame for Irunami-san's 'accidental' death and we didn’t even realise Irunami-san never made it to the stage because of the fog machines.
And this was the trick you used to fool us all...it’s curtains for you: Tomoe Hachi, the Ultimate Illusionist!
-
“And that’s all…did I get anything wrong…?”
“I…” Hachi-san was quiet for a moment before letting out a sigh. They then flashed a smile. “Wow, Nagata-kun! You really did it! You figured out all of my tricks and saw past my illusions!”
“H…Hachi-san…” Ram-san murmured.
“Oh? Is that it? Have you all decided now…? Well, if that’s the case, let’s all proceed to the voting tim-“
“Can we hold off for a moment?” Ishikawa-san interrupted. “I apologise, but before we proceed to the voting…how do we wish to handle this matter?”
“What do you mean?” Amaterasu-san asked.
“Do you not recall…? The motive for this particular trial?” Huh…? The motive…the motive, if I remember…
-
My logic follows!
-
“A wish…if the killer wins the class trial, they get a wish granted. Any wish they want.”
“Y-you’re not gonna suggest we let Hachi win the class trial, are you?!” Shinko-san growled.
“Why not…? If we allow Hachi-sama to win then we may be able to end this killing game. I fail to see any problem with this idea.” Ishikawa-san smiled.
“Th-that true…” Shinko-san murmured.
“Hold on now, we can’t trust someone like Hachi-san! They killed Irunami-san after all!” Kurohiko-san argued.
“Nagata…what do you think…?” Okanaya-san looked at me. What did I think…? I can see it from both sides…if I’m honest, my gut is telling me…
“…I don’t think we should let Hachi-san use their wish.”
“N-Nagata-kun?!” Ram-san squeaked.
“I’m sorry! I know it sounds cruel but…there’s no way this killing game would end that easily! There’s a trick to Monokuma’s motive, I know it! We just can’t take the risk! Please…Ram-san, I know it’s hard but you have to believe in me…I don’t like it either…”
Ram-san looked to the ground, tugging at her hair so much that her hairband was shifting out of place. “…alright then…I’ll…I’ll trust you.” She said with determination.
“No way! We can end this once and for all! We can’t let this opportunity pass us up!”
“It’s too risky! We can’t!”
“I sense the discord!”
-
“Ah…I suppose it’s pretty late in the trial, but if seems you’re all at an impasse. This is a very important topic, so I think it’s time for the morphing trial grounds…!” Monokuma announced, pulling out the key from before and causing the trial podiums to change formation.
-Scrum Debate, begin!-
"Should we let Tomoe use their wish?"
"We shouldn't!" - Ryuu, Kobo, Ram, Mami, Sly, Amaterasu, Yuuki
"We should!" - Tomoe, Toson, Karma, Doi, Junpei, Tsukiko
Junpei: We should let Hachi-san use their wish to end this killing game!
(Okanaya-san!)
Kobo: It’s way too risky! We don’t know if Hachi will use their wish the way we want them too!
Toson: We’ve already trusted a killer in our group, so what’s the difference here?
(Sly-san!)
Sly: I may be a killer, but I’m not the culprit in this case. These are two different matters.
Karma: We can prevent anyone from having to be executed. Isn’t that a good thing?
(I’ll deal with this!)
Ryuu: There’s no way Monokuma would let us fail a class trial without anyone being executed!
Tsukiko: Can we not trust Hachi-sama to do the right thing in the end?
(Asano-san!)
Mami: Hachi-san sacrificed their best friend in the group. Are we expected to trust them even after that?
Tomoe: Please, let me end this killing game once and for all! I can do it, I promise!
(Ram-san!)
Ram: Even if you say that…we can’t guarantee the killing game will end because of the wish!
“This is our answer!”
-
“I’m sorry everyone…I’m sorry…Hachi-san…but if we don’t vote correctly, who knows what might happen?! Our lives are on the line, can we really afford to be taking risks right now?!”
“You…you are right…” Ishikawa-san conceded. “Even though I do not wish the endless slumber upon anyone…what am I to do when there are so many other lives in front of me that could be jeopardised?”
“Shit…shit! Fuck this! Fuck this whole class trial, why can’t we just have it be easy?!” Yokozawa-san slammed his fists onto the podium.
“Then…you’re done…? We can proceed with the vote…?” Monokuma asked. “Great! Then please select who you believe is the culprit from the screen in front of you! Will you pick the right choice…? Or the dreadfully wrong one…? What’s it gonna be? What’s it gonna be…?”
We watched as the Monokuma roulette wheel spun around, out faces each passing the needle before it eventually stopped on Hachi-san’s icon. Bouquets of flowers popped from the sides of the roulette wheel…we had voted. And the class trial was over.
2 notes
·
View notes