ATEEZ Pairings in Fanfic at AO3 (2023)
Curious which romantic partnerships between members were underused, last year I decided to do a quick survey of pairings at AO3 because that data was easy to get compared to Tumblr. Wanting to see what has changed I revisited the data. The numbers reflect how many times a pairing occurs, not how many works are about that member as a character or how prominent they are in a story. For instance Jongho x Yeosang appears surprisingly often but more commonly as a couple when the whole group is partnered in a story along the typical breakdown of Hongjoong x Seonghwa, San x Wooyoung, and Mingi x Yunho.
The numbers I found really paint a picture of the dearth of reader inserts posted at Archive of Our Own versus Tumblr. Just writing for two years now, I have contributed between 5-10% of the reader x Mingi, x Jongho, and x Yunho categories there which is such a misrepresentation of what the whole of ATEEZ fanfic looks like. I encourage anyone to consider contributing their writing, especially reader pairings, to the library there to preserve more fandom history given how fast accounts can turn over on Tumblr when people deactivate. While reader inserts are not as popular at AO3, I think it is worth posting there both as a record and because cultures can change over time. When people are given more reader inserts to enjoy there a taste might develop and we all would benefit from more stories to read.
The following snapshot is roughly done (and corrections are welcome) but it is a fairly accurate look at the state of pairings in ATEEZ fanfiction present at AO3 on May 6, 2023. The numbers in parentheses are from the previous year.
Total works in the ATEEZ category: 18,348
Top ten ATEEZ pairings on AO3:
Hongjoong x Seonghwa 4,999 (3,782)
San x Wooyoung 4,009 (3,046)
Yunho x Mingi 2,058 (1,603)
Yeosang x Jongho 1,283 (950)
Yeosang x Wooyoung 1,066 (866)
Seonghwa x Yeosang 794 (773)
San x Yeosang 723 (539) up two positions from last year
San x Seonghwa 716 (574) down one position from last year
San x Yunho 650 (553) down one position from last year
Hongjoong x Wooyoung 519 (new this year replacing HJ x Yunho)
Pairings by member:
Hongjoong x
Seonghwa 4,999 (3,782)
Wooyoung 519 (256) up three positions from last year
Yunho 496 (427) down one position from last year
Mingi 446 (367) down one position from last year
San 355 (272) down one position from last year
Reader 316 (228) up one position from last year
Yeosang 311 (241) down one position from last year
Jongho 219 (193)
Female OC 48 (28)
Total: 7,709 (5,794)
Seonghwa x
Hongjoong 4,999 (3,782)
Yeosang 794 (773)
San 716 (574)
Wooyoung 493 (416)
Yunho 368 (292)
Reader 351 (230)
Mingi 233 (175)
Jongho 211 (172)
Female OC 61 (42)
Total: 8,226 (6,456)
Yunho x
Mingi 2,058 (1,603)
San 650 (553)
Hongjoong 496 (427)
Seonghwa 368 (292)
Reader 310 (218) up one position from last year
Yeosang 309 (264) down one position from last year
Wooyoung 290 (192)
Jongho 254 (183)
Female OC 71 (48)
Total: 4,806 (3,780)
Yeosang x
Jongho 1,283 (950)
Wooyoung 1,066 (866)
Seonghwa 794 (773)
San 723 (539)
Mingi 314 (239) up two positions from last year
Hongjoong 311 (241) up one position from last year
Yunho 309 (264) down two positions from last year
Reader 194 (131)
Female OC 35 (22)
Total: 5,029 (4,025)
San x
Wooyoung 4,009 (3,046)
Seonghwa 716 (574)
Yeosang 723 (539) up one position from last year
Yunho 650 (553) down one position from last year
Hongjoong 355 (272) up one position from last year
Reader 315 (224) up one position from last year
Mingi 312 (282) down two positions from last year
Jongho 217 (192)
Female OC 56 (37)
Total: 7,353 (5719)
Mingi x
Yunho 2,058 (1,603)
Hongjoong 446 (367)
Jongho 324 (258) up one position from last year
Yeosang 314 (239) up one position from last year
San 312 (282) down two positions from last year
Reader 275 (203)
Seonghwa 233 (175)
Wooyoung 207 (158)
Female OC 43 (31)
Total: 4,212 (3,316)
Wooyoung x
San 4,009 (3,046)
Yeosang 1,066 (866)
Hongjoong 519 (256) up one position from last year
Seonghwa 493 (416) down one position from last year
Yunho 290 (192)
Reader 248 (178) up one position from last year
Jongho 235 (191) down one position from last year
Mingi 207 (158)
Female OC 37 (23)
Total: 7,104 (5,326)
Jongho x
Yeosang 1,283 (950)
Mingi 324 (258)
Yunho 254 (183) up three positions from last year
Wooyoung 235 (191) up two positions from last year
Hongjoong 219 (193) down two positions from last year
San 217 (192) down two positions from last year
Seonghwa 211 (172)
Reader 176 (111)
Female OC 40 (18)
Total: 2,959 (2,268)
5 notes
·
View notes
I posted 1,137 times in 2022
That's 811 more posts than 2021!
193 posts created (17%)
944 posts reblogged (83%)
Blogs I reblogged the most:
@sorikkung
@jeongyunho99
@twancingyunhao
@absentcaryatid
@queerdo-mcjewface
I tagged 1,115 of my posts in 2022
Only 2% of my posts had no tags
#ateez - 350 posts
#fic rec - 252 posts
#gif - 236 posts
#yunho - 114 posts
#mingi - 114 posts
#video - 97 posts
#gender neutral reader - 96 posts
#seonghwa - 80 posts
#i love laughter - 77 posts
#kpop fanfic - 77 posts
Longest Tag: 140 characters
#i like this idea because i have a lot of things that are just a scrap of dialogue and probably won't go anywhere but can always be revisited
My Top Posts in 2022:
#5
Three Guys and Your Underwear
An ATEEZ fanfic by AbsentCaryatid
Yeosang is your boyfriend. Seonghwa is your roommate. Hongjoong is your best friend since preschool. One day you came home to find all three of them hovering over your dirty laundry basket inhaling the scent of your underwear. Can they explain what they were up to in a way that makes them completely innocent of doing exactly what they were caught doing?
2.5K words, Content note: gender neutral reader referred to with they/them pronouns, underwear sniffing, innuendo laden but still probably squeaks by for all tumblr using ages
~
There were three perverts standing around the laundry basket in your bedroom. Huddled together, your best friend Hongjoong, roommate Seonghwa, and boyfriend Yeosang had been sniffing away at a pair of your underwear. They were so engrossed that they apparently missed your greeting called from the front door on arrival. When you announced your presence in your bedroom doorway Hongjoong screamed and as a group they shot about six feet in the air being caught at their activity. Seonghwa looked guilty and Yeosang froze. You stared at them and they stared at you.
Bordering on yelling, nervously Yeosang claimed, “We can explain in a way that makes us completely innocent of exactly what it looks like we were doing.”
“Okay, try me. Please tell me this isn’t what it looks like.” The trio audibly relaxed a little until you narrowed your eyes and amended, “But make it believable.”
“It isn’t, I promise,” Seonghwa pleaded.
You snorted. “Isn't what it looks like, or isn't believable?”
There was laughter at your comment. Yeosang cut it off quickly at your look though. He could be bold sometimes, but was not a fool.
Ever the rules lawyer, Hongjoong hedged, “What does it look like?” His attempt at innocent doe eyes did nothing for you.
You took in a deep breath while pinching the bridge of your nose. “I’m going to say this nicely on the very slim chance there truly is a reasonable explanation for you three to be standing beside my dirty laundry and huffing my underpants, but what is going on, guys? You need to tell me, now.”
See the full post
51 notes - Posted July 15, 2022
#4
Looking for something else to read?
Here are the masterlists of some of the K-pop fanfic writers I enjoy on here. Search their name on my tumblr to bring up fic reviews for that author.
All Tumblr Using Ages:
Blossom-hwa Masterlist, ATEEZ, Golden Child, Stray Kids, The Boyz
Catboymingi Masterlist, ATEEZ
Mingtinys Masterlist, ATEEZ, BTS, NCT Dream, Super M
Sorryimananti-romantic Masterlist, ATEEZ, BTS, Red Velvet
Thexautisticxkpopper Masterlist, Block B, EXO, GOT7, NCT, VIXX
Theaufanartist (Flashing GIF) Masterlist, ATEEZ, BTS, SVT, Stray Kids
Twancingyunhao Masterlist, ATEEZ
Warmau Google spreadsheet Masterlist, ATEEZ, BTS, NCT, Svnt, +
Wooahaes Masterlist, Golden Child, Seventeen, Stray Kids, Treasure
Writersrealmbts Masterlist, BTS, GOT7, Monsta X, NCT, Stray Kids, TXT, VIXX
Masterlists with at least some 18+ Material:
See the full post
59 notes - Posted August 15, 2022
#3
The Quest to Fit Yunho
An ATEEZ fanfic by AbsentCaryatid
319 words, Content note: gender neutral reader, size references, hands
~
“My boyfriend, he's big,” you confessed in a whisper.
The woman you were speaking to encouraged you to tell more. “Go on, what else?”
Keeping your voice low, you added, “Well, Yunho's fingers, they are so large. It is a tough fit. Sometimes the stretch is too much.”
She gave a sympathetic nod, “I see.”
“I want to succeed where his previous partners have failed. He just wants to be able to slide his fingers in with ease. It seems like such a simple thing that would make him so happy but I need help.” A sad look crossed your face. Pleasing your boyfriend meant the world to you and this was something you had been trying to solve for quite a while now.
The lady was reassuring. “Maybe they gave up too soon. I believe I can be of assistance.” You smiled gratefully hoping there was a solution after so many attempts and false leads. “No matter his size, we do have models to fit in many colors,” she continued. “Let me bring you the extra-large range and you will be able to take something home for him today.”
“Thank you so much,” you gushed, “Yunho will be very happy when he opens his present. He has always spoken of wanting driving gloves but nothing at the market stalls ever fit. Driving gives him so much pleasure but in these colder months he complains. As often as he praises the seat warmer, he wishes the steering wheel had the same feature.”
The saleswoman beamed behind her counter, pleased to have helped. “It is a good thing you came to this department store then, isn't it? Once you decide on a pair I will wrap them for you.”
Purchase complete, you headed home smiling to yourself knowing how thrilled Yunho would be slipping on the first pair of gloves that actually might fit since reaching adulthood.
~
Masterlist
62 notes - Posted January 18, 2022
#2
A Birthday to Remember
An ATEEZ Seonghwa x Reader fanfic by AbsentCaryatid
Seonghwa has purchased an adult toy for your birthday and is eager to help put it to use. If the night goes as he hopes, he will be playing with you for a long time.
1.4K words, Content note: Gender neutral reader, humor
~
Seonghwa knows what you want, knows how to please you. For weeks he has been keeping it secret but tonight he will reveal all. You have been dating almost a year now and he wanted to mark the occasion with something really special in honor of your birthday and he had just what you had been longing for. He understood you were curious if you were up to the challenge. The thought of getting to be the man who provided this first in your life left him restless and eager to get on with the evening.
He could see the excitement when he whispered in your ear what his plans were once he took you home. Tonight you would go all out and try something new. It was difficult not to speed through the rest of the meal in anticipation over what was to come. Your face displayed such open desire and Seonghwa could not help but feel an equal interest.
Abandoning plans for dessert, the bill was paid quickly and you rushed to his car. Looking for all the world like two young people in love, for that’s what you were, you kept glancing at each other and grinning. Once home, he escorted you to the bedroom where he presented you with the gift. From his hints at the restaurant you already knew what you would be getting up to and it had you salivating. Kissing him passionately before unwrapping, you marveled once you saw it in person. “I had no idea it was so big.”
“You flatter me,” Seonghwa laughed, “it is not like it is The Titanic.”
“It practically is.” Tracing the outline you couldn’t help but gasp as you took in all the details. “And so hard!” Although you had not opened the large box yet the picture on the outside told you a long-held dream was about to come true. Tonight you would enjoy an 18+ toy you had your eye on from that special shop you liked to browse together. “Seonghwa, I can't believe you. You spent a fortune on me!”
See the full post
67 notes - Posted January 13, 2022
My #1 post of 2022
ATEEZ Reaction to Your Chest Being Uneven
A gender neutral fanfic by AbsentCaryatid
The reader has been hiding from their romantic partner the fact that their chest is more developed on one side than the other. I present one way the members of ATEEZ might react. This is not smut but instead written to be reassuring from someone who has the experience of visible asymmetry and it has never been an issue.
432 words, Content note: some are lightly suggestive but still rated safe for all tumblr using ages
~
Hongjoong would deliver a chaste kiss above each side when you confess your anxiety about being uneven to him. Hongjoong then would promptly fall asleep on your chest and much later wake up, happy to be there no matter how great your disparity.
Seonghwa would insist he is not with you for your body but for your personality. “No matter what, I still I think you are perfect just as you are.” As you stare into his flawless eyes, you understand completely.
Yunho would respect your emotional impact from being lopsided. “I am not going to tell you how to feel about your chest and will support you if you wish to have cosmetic reduction on one side or enlargement on the other. Please know though, that I find your appearance charming. You don't love me any less for my uneven smile and I feel exactly the same way about you.”
Yeosang would be over the moon and have a lot to say. “You are warning me because you are going to let me see your chest? How could I have any complaints about that step in our relationship?” Ever the scientist, Yeosang would also be a researcher and come back to you with facts. “Now that I have read up on the subject, I learned it is common to be asymmetrical. Estimates vary, but one doctor cited 90% of people with developed breasts have at least a 15-20% difference in volume, and truly if your measurement is precise enough nobody is actually identical. A mismatch can happen to any gender if muscles get a regular workout on one side more than the other. The difference may be more noticeable on you than others, but it is very normal and nothing to feel bad about.”
San would pointedly tell you some of his stuffed animals are small and others are large, but they are all equally loved and worth cuddling.
Mingi would have nothing to say if you draw it to his attention, merely joyfully diving back in to shower you with snuggly affection. Despite wanting to be supportive, Mingi would probably never even notice the size difference between sides of your chest.
Woooyoung's delighted and overly loud proclamation that a variety pack is a plus would be overheard by the whole dorm. Then comes the shared laughter as he discovers, “Look at this. I can make my hand look big or small depending which side I hold it over!”
Jongho would be warmly reassuring with the confirmation, “I love everything about you. How could I not love your chest as well?”
~
Masterlist of stories
85 notes - Posted June 14, 2022
Get your Tumblr 2022 Year in Review →
My stats from 2021 Tumblr Year in Review
2 notes
·
View notes