Between the Lines- Ep. 3
A/N: This one is pretty long, partially to make up for just how short the next one will be. Episode 4 comes at you pretty rapid fire by design, so it's harder to stretch out and still make it make sense.
Usual warnings apply, some no no words, innuendo/bad flirting. This one also features a bit more insecurity around body image than usual and discussions of mental illness, so if that's not your thing please keep that in mind.
Index
Episode 2
I was cursing at my phone and muttering about stupid 20-somethings getting involved in shit they shouldn’t— and ignoring the irony— when I finally managed to get a grip on myself and start thinking a bit more clearly.
Should I text the others? The Hacker seemed pretty sure one of them was the culprit, and while I wasn’t totally positive, the timing of the threatening call seemed to support that. It had been early on in my communications with the group that it would have been surprising if my number had leaked beyond them by then.
But if the Hacker was monitoring their phones, could the culprit be as well? I know he’d said he was putting protections on my devices, but if he hadn’t done theirs it was entirely possible someone could have gotten my number that way.
Not to mention, Thomas claimed the message with my number in the first place had come from Hannah’s phone. We’d been working under the assumption all this time that she’d sent it, but her phone had disappeared with her, and Thomas said the call he’d made had been answered by breathing. Despite what Joyce had claimed in Stranger Things, there was no good way to identify breathing.
What if it had been the kidnapper who sent them my number? The issue of “why me” remained, but it did make more objective sense that he would have access to the phone and use it for something other than calling the police (or their hacker friend).
Hell, maybe my number has actually been a diversion. A random string of numbers sent to confuse them that happened to be my contact info? The coincidence was huge, but possible. In fact, was it even that big of a coincidence? Maybe for me, the person with the number, it felt that way. But on the outside looking in, most combinations of numbers with the right amount of digits would probably call someone.
I wasn’t an investigator or police. I occasionally dabbled in writing mystery and did some escape rooms. I listened to true crime podcasts. But being that I was the core, stereotypical demographic for most of those things, that didn’t exactly make me uniquely qualified for any of this.
My mind raced round and round, trying to piece together who I could trust, how I could help, and what my place in this whole clusterfuck really was. I actually had something of a reputation of being good under pressure (but collapsing as soon as it was gone— as shown by the time I’d giggled for like ten minutes straight after rushing around to put out Annie’s kitchen fire as she screamed and didn’t use the phone in her hand to call for help) but this time, maybe because there really wasn’t anything I could actually do, I found myself totally useless.
I’d worked myself up into such a fit that by the time Cleo texted, I was tense enough to yelp at the buzzing phone in my hand.
Thomas? I mouthed silently. The kid takes off after finding out about the body, gets weirdly aggressive at Dan to set up some sketchy deal he refused to mention by name, and then breaks into his girlfriend’s apartment?
Cleo was clearly uncomfortable with it too, sounding more stilted and awkward than I’d ever heard her, even when confronting her about her newfound love of trespassing. Was he looking at her phone? Had he said something to her?
It wasn’t beyond the realm of possibility to think he had a key— Annie’s boyfriend had one to our place, much to my chagrin— and Cleo was just as guilty of going in as he was. But something about her reaction put me on edge, so I hoped she’d get somewhere she felt freer to talk soon.
Jessy’s rage provided a good distraction, though I really wasn’t surprised to see the way the paper had “reported” the body. It fit for a small town, whose identity partially stemmed from the idea of being safe and close. How many times in the past had I rolled my eyes at my grandma declaring that “this stuff didn’t happen in her town” when she watched the news for the city I’d grown up in? These were places where you never locked your doors, knew the mailman by name.
It became crucial to maintain that status quo at all costs, even if it meant relegating a murder to the back pages of a paper. Even if that meant the victim went unremembered.
Of course she was angry. Burying your head in the sand only felt good when it wasn’t your hurt being covered up.
Seeing her so upset brought back that feeling of helplessness I’d had with Cleo earlier. This time, there were things I could say, actions I could take. But nothing that would fix the situation or make her feel better at all. I could only let her vent. Even that felt so useless, it was only the tip of the iceberg.
Thomas’s return gave her something else to focus on, at least, even as I wondered whether it was planned or if his encounter with Cleo had forced his hand. I struggled to still see him as a devoted, grieving boyfriend after all this time.
The news that the body wasn’t Hannah’s perked everyone else up, but made me even more unsettled. As an outsider without any attachment to Hannah, a body appearing right after a kidnapping made things so much more complicated, and more dangerous.
One was unfortunate, two was a pattern.
There was no way I could say that to them, though, or even the Hacker, so I was left to stew on that on my own through the rest of Thomas’s return conversation.
Needing to process everything that had happened, I decided to go get some fresh air. I rarely took walks, I didn’t seem to get the cabin fever that others felt, and the pandemic had only made me even more comfortable hunkering down in one place. But suddenly I felt caged, like if I didn’t keep moving, I might collapse.
Something felt off to me, beyond the obvious. Why would the cops confirm anything to Thomas, who wasn’t Hannah’s husband and presumably had only a passing connection to the deceased woman? I knew that privacy in these cases wasn’t as strict as say, hospitals, and who knew what the laws in Germany looked like about that, but it still didn’t sit right with me. Maybe it was a small town thing?
Googling “how much can the police release to non-family in a missing person’s case” got me nowhere even before I added in the jurisdictional aspect, and I started to get frustrated at how little I knew about any of this.
I’d had dealings with cops before, a rebellious youth plus some impulse control issues had seen to that. I’d dated some questionable men, no doubt about that, made some bad choices. I knew the basics of the law in some areas, but nothing significant.
All of the recent happenings had me getting really frustrated with my ineptitude and getting pulled into this. I couldn’t say why I’d stuck around so far, really. It just seemed like everyone expected me to, and I didn’t want to disappoint them.
But hell, how was I not going to disappoint them?
My life had begun revolving around this case, even when it probably shouldn’t. Outside of the movie day and going out with Annie, one of which involved Jessy and the other I still felt guilty over, I’d taken very little time away from this, and it was starting to wear me down.
Still, how did I tell these grieving friends that I needed a break? How would I leave them up to their own devices, considering even with my help they were breaking in to crime scenes, buying illegal items, and having breakdowns over found bodies? They were suffering worse than I was, and even knowing that I would crash, I felt responsible for that.
Hannah had been missing for weeks, and all I’d done was find a cat picture, pry into her medical information, and discovered some emo poetry. Poirot, I was not. I couldn’t help but think that the others blamed me for that fact.
As if hearing my doubts, the Hacker appeared. I hugged my sweater closer to myself despite the day actually being fairly warm, and considered putting him off. But I wasn’t going to make any progress without him, and the sooner we solved this mystery, the sooner I could nurse my ego and return to my life.
I wasn’t at all surprised to hear he was reading in on my chat with Cleo, though I was a bit that he was watching my video chats. The insecure, dysmorphic part of me tried to remember how many chins I had while on screen, even knowing that he probably hadn’t looked at me once during the call. I knew it was silly, but I’d have to start considering my appearance a little more before turning on my camera.
I’d meant to come off more teasing when I’d questioned whether my opinion mattered to him, but I knew I sounded desperate for his approval. Still, I was pretty surprised when he answered in the affirmative, seemingly genuine. My face burned when I admitted to the same, but it kind of felt like I owed it to him at that moment.
Of course, he quickly moved the conversation back to the matter at hand, and I tried not to let that sting. Once he admitted to his “flaw”, though, I couldn’t help but question myself even further. Did it extend to not realizing how he came off over chat? Had he not even noticed the times I was flirting?
It seemed like everything had me off kilter today, and I was desperate to hide under my blankets and let myself mope, at least a little. It was so like me, to get feelings for a guy on the other side of the world that I didn’t even know the name of who had no idea I’d spent weeks flirting with him. I felt like a teenager again, pining over a boy who told me that I’d have an easier time finding a boyfriend if I lost weight.
Really, I thought I’d grown past this.
Massaging my temples as I walked back into my apartment, I let myself flop into bed despite how early it was. Maybe if I crawled into my safe space while texting, things wouldn’t bother me as much. Or I’d at least be less of an asshole and stop focusing on my own bullshit at a time like this.
I felt like I had to push back on his assertion that Hannah couldn’t have hurt herself. I clearly had more experience with depression than he had, and considering how he’d reacted to the SSRIs already, I worried it could break him. Besides, not all methods of hurting yourself came in the form that most people expected. Pretty much my entire early twenties was a testament to all of the ways you could hurt yourself without causing a single bit of physical harm.
I decided not to push that part.
We discussed the cloud entry (I resisted the urge to joke about my own shitty poetry, since I wasn’t making this about myself anymore) and I was surprised to discover that he’d never met Hannah. He was maybe more invested in finding her than some of the group.
I wasn’t making this about myself, so I didn’t worry that maybe they were romantic penpals or something. She had Thomas.
I had to admit I felt pretty good about getting to tease him about the legends, and was glad to see it made him laugh. Not because I wanted his approval, but just because he was usually so serious. Of course.
Finally, after exhausting all of the leads and updates either of us had— there was no movement on Poke’s number yet— he logged off suddenly and I sighed, taking the opportunity to wiggle deeper into my nest and think about nothing for a while.
___
I hadn’t intended to fall asleep, but I was shocked when I opened my eyes next to find that twelve hours had passed, and I suddenly found myself the topic of the group chat. Maybe I’d grilled Thomas too hard yesterday.
Dan: We don’t know anything about her, why should we trust her?
Seriously Dan? After facilitating some weird deal between Thomas and Poke, you want to start throwing stones? Maybe guilt and deflection, but annoying nonetheless.
I let myself get truly frustrated with them for the first time, reminding them of their responsibility for the fact that they knew nothing about me. Not like I’d been nothing but a vehicle to find Hannah or something to all of them but Jessy, right?
MC: I mean
MC: You could ask
Thomas: What?
MC: I don’t have a whole lot of reasons to lie to you
MC: Not beyond like “oh yeah I definitely do floss every day”, at least
MC: So don’t ask that one
MC: I will lie about that
Dan: We can’t even know if you’re telling the truth!
MC: Right
MC: But if we’re talking stranger danger, it’s kind of 5 against 1 already.
Dan: Fine, so tell us about yourself
MC: Well that’s super unhelpful
MC: I at least ask you guys questions
Dan: You mean interrogate?
MC: Sure
MC: Ask away
Jessy: What color is your hair?
MC: Ha!
I hit send while snorting before realizing that my amusement wouldn’t make sense to anyone in the group.
MC: Sorry, inside joke… not a very good one.
MC: Brown normally
MC: But I get bored with that a lot.
MC: So like, less brown right now? I guess?
Jessy: Oooh! What colors has it been?
I smiled a little, of course Jessy would show something of an actual interest while simultaneously asking questions that helped nothing.
MC: Well, I’ve done red streaks. Not like yours, Jessy, they called it “fire-engine red”. Red fades so fast, so I only did that once.
MC: High school was when I did most of it. It was pink for a while.
MC: Kept it bleached for a while, but I’m not a good blonde.
MC: Blue in college.
Thomas: Stop
Thomas: Why are you doing this?
MC: Because she asked? And because if you guys keep not trusting me, we won’t get anywhere?
Thomas: No. I mean, why are you here?
MC: Because you added me to the group.
Thomas: You know what I’m asking
I groaned. I did, but where do you even start? How do I even explain, when I don’t really know myself? I knew I was on thin ice, though. Jessy liked me, and Cleo was open to me. But Thomas was, at best, neutral, Richy had barely spoken to me, Lilly was totally absent, and Dan… well, Dan was Dan.
What do you tell a group of strangers when they ask why you’re putting all of your energy into snooping around their personal lives?
The hope that Thomas seemed to be fueled by, that I’d have some unknown connection and solution to everything seemed to have vanished. And that had really been my only connection to these people.
“Sorry, I might want to bone the hacker you all hate, so I do what he tells me,” was pathetic on so many levels, and would do nothing to help me.
MC: Look
MC: I’m an asshole, okay? My jokes are bad, I suck at people, and I’m just generally something of an acquired taste at best
MC: But like, how do you walk away from people who want you to help find a missing person?
MC: I don’t know her. It’s crazy I care this much. But Thomas, you sent me all those pictures
MC: And you’ve all talked about her so much
MC: And I read the articles about it online and that made it so real too
MC: I don’t know if I’ll be useful. Frankly, I’m usually not even at the best of times
MC: But on the tiniest chance I can be, and I don’t try? I don’t think I’m prepared to be that much of a shit person.
The silence after I wrote all of that stretched on long enough to make me sweat. Being genuine wasn’t something I practiced much, and I was mostly just glad I hadn’t had to say all of that out loud because I would have stumbled over it and messed it up somehow. However un-charismatic I was online, it was nothing compared to how I was in person.
After what felt like several minutes of nothing, I began frantically thinking of ways to take it all back. Despite the miles and miles between us, something about my words made me feel like I was standing in front of them all naked, so the lack of reply had me fighting not to claw my eyes out.
Finally, around the time I’d hunted down the dusty bottle of vodka I’d gotten as a gift for last Christmas and poured myself a glass with little enough juice that it did more for color than taste, there was movement in the chat.
Dan is typing…
Dan: Fine
Dan: Stay
Dan is offline.
Cleo: Right, well… Welcome to the team.
I was a bit surprised to see the hesitation from Cleo, since she’d already called me at Hannah’s and admitted to several crimes, one of which I was complicit in. Maybe she’d only included me before since I was online and couldn’t stop her? Who knows.
Thomas is offline.
Cleo is offline.
Richy is offline.
Only Jessy and I remained, which I guess I could have predicted at that point. Considering her line of questioning, and our active personal chat, it made sense that she’d be the one least likely to need to mull over my outburst. Which is why, when I saw a notification pop up seconds later, I didn’t hesitate to press it without looking at the name.
As it turned out, It wasn’t from Jessy. Instead, the notification led me back to my chat with the Hacker.
???: You did surprisingly well.
Despite the fact that I’d normally bask a little bit in the compliment (however backhanded the qualifier made it feel), I only felt irritated. My frustration, insecurity and helplessness bubbled over, and even knowing how little he’d get those emotions from my words, he was the only one here to direct it at.
MC: Thanks? I think?
MC: Or are you just surprised they didn’t boot me out of the chat?
MC: Look, I want to help, but you saw how that just went.
MC: I don’t do this, okay? I don’t know how to get people to like me, or trust me, or want to talk to me. Everyone who puts up with me in real life are either people who met me when we were young enough that being edgy and bitchy seemed cool, liked my mom enough to feel like they have to make sure I’m alive, or are getting paid in one way or the other.
???: I believe it went well, MC. You were quite convincing.
MC: Pf. Hardly. For Hannah, you need to find someone else. I can still do the cloud stuff if you want, but there’s got to be someone better to talk to the group.
The moment I hit send, a notification from the person I’d been expecting earlier appeared at the top of my screen.
Jessy: MC! I’m so sorry they acted so mean
Jessy: They’re not usually like that, they’re scared. But that’s no excuse.
Jessy: You almost made me cry!
MC: I’m sorry!
Jessy: No no, it was so nice! 🥰
MC: Mmh, Jessy, I made everyone run away.
Jessy: Trust me, they just didn’t know what to say. They hate being wrong!
While I wracked my brain trying to formulate a response, another notification popped up that I didn’t even bother to click this time.
???: ;)
Smug bastard.
___
After that, things were a little less tense in the group chat. The majority still weren’t particularly friendly, but they’d at least seem to accept my presence. Dan was still kind of an asshole, but in a kind of way that I was used to, so I didn’t let it bother me. He seemed like the sort that people just kind of ignored most of the time, and I knew what that was like.
The chat wasn’t what I’d consider active, but they checked in on each other occasionally, tried to cheer each other up and touched base with platitudes and support.
Jessy: MC
Jessy: …
Jessy: You there?
Jessy: MCCCCC
Huh. It was strange for me to be addressed directly at the start of a conversation, but the fact that it was Jessy made it make a little more sense. I suspected she was trying to include me more and humanize me to the rest, a mission she’d kind of taken up recently.
MC: Hi! Sorry, I got a call.
Jessy: Aren’t you popular?
MC: No, no, never. Work. 😩
Jessy: Oh! You know, I don’t think we’ve ever talked about your job.
MC: Well, yeah, it’s not really been important.
Other than my chats with Jessy, and the time Thomas had grilled me about my intentions, discussing me had been pretty low priority. I’d chime in here and there when the group chat dipped into the easy flow that happened in messages between old friends. And I never missed a chance to make a sassy comment or comment, which they’d quickly learned to ignore or roll their eyes at.
But it was true that in their eyes, I was still just a stranger. Even as I slowly started forming pictures of their lives and getting pulled deeper into Hannah’s world, the group as a whole still didn’t even know my last name. I hadn’t offered it, but they didn’t ask either.
After my hidden meltdown when the body was discovered not to be Hannah’s, I’d probably put up some barriers trying not to totally lose myself in their lives. It was wearing on my mental health in a pretty serious way, so while Jessy and I were continuing to bond, and Cleo had started talking to me more, I felt a bit detached overall.
Jessy: Still!
Jessy: You’re always on your phone
Jessy: Every time I’m on
I snorted at that, mainly because it wasn’t totally true. I wasn’t a morning person, and she was bright and sunny enough to be way too much until I’d gotten at least two cups of coffee in me. But after that, I did give my phone nearly my full attention.
MC: That’s what my boss just said on our call, haha. 🙃
MC: I work remotely, so I’ve got some flexibility
MC: But I’ve been pushing that lately
MC: And unlike someone, I’m not cute enough to get away with it
Richy: 😳
For all Jessy tried to hide when she texted non-stop at work, it was actually the worst kept secret. Especially since Richy was on nearly as much during the day. They didn’t acknowledge each other over chat all that much, but there was no way they didn’t notice they were both on.
But since it was just as obvious that Richy wanted to date Jessy…
Jessy: 😤
Jessy: But what do you do?
Of course neither would acknowledge it. They both knew, even if they wanted to pretend they didn’t. I was surprised the group didn’t heckle them for it more. Yet another way they differed from mine, I guess. I’d never live it down with them.
MC: Nothing very exciting. I’m called a “Customer Communication Quality Assurance Analyst”
Jessy: Right…
Yep, that was the usual reaction alright.
MC: Told you 🤣
MC: You know how when you call customer service, that message plays?
MC: About your call being recorded?
MC: Some companies review those in-house, but others contract out to a firm
MC: So I work for one of those
Dan: You’re joking
He didn’t usually get involved when I was talking. He’d respond to the others, of course, but for the most part he preferred to ignore me completely. This would be interesting.
MC: No… why would I be?
Dan: You spend all day spying on people’s calls
Dan: Just to open your phone
Dan: And interrogate us
I actually was a little more offended than I should have been, which probably gave his point more credence. Still, it felt like there was a note of teasing to it that maybe could work in my favor if I played it right.
MC: Okay
MC: Well when you put it that way
MC: My life just sounds sad
MC: And kind of creepy 😒
Dan: I mean, isn’t it?
MC: Hey 😤
MC: But actually
MC: I wanted to be a teacher when I was younger
Jessy: Really?? That’s so cool
I hadn’t meant to prolong this conversation, but since Jessy had definitely become the one that both liked me best and I’d been most open with, maybe it would be useful to let them in a little.
And it was definitely for Hannah and not because I wanted the acceptance of these people. Of course.
MC: Mmh, no, not really.
MC: Could have saved myself a lot of time and money if I’d remembered I don’t like dealing with people that much
Jessy: What do you mean?
Jessy: You’re so friendly!
Friendly? Jessy, I’m a raging bitch, covering up for the self-esteem of a goldfish with sarcasm and fake arrogance, the mouth of a sailor, and the gutter-mind of a 16 year old boy. Was that friendly?
MC: Sure, to people I like
MC: But I made the mistake of being a TA in undergrad
MC: Turns out, people can be really dumb and I have no patience 🤓
Cleo: MC!
Yeah. That would be a bit far for Cleo. She was nice enough, of course, but probably the one that struggled the most with my more insulting quips. Well, Thomas and Lilly hadn’t been much involved with me either, so maybe they’d have been yelling at me even more. Who knows?
MC: Yes, yes. I’ll be nice
MC: I just get frustrated easily, I guess.
MC: Having to explain something over and over
Dan: Mmh, I’m trying to picture you as a teacher. It’s kind of funny.
I felt a surge of pride in realizing I’d kept Dan at least marginally engaged. Though actually, in other circumstances he might have actually been the one I was the most similar to. He seemed to also lack a filter and the capability to recognize when running his mouth was okay.
MC: Funny isn’t the word I’d have used
Jessy: Poor you 😫
MC: If I’m being honest, probably poor them
Jessy: Oh no
MC: 😉
MC: It was better for everyone that I got out of that line of work
MC: But it was too late to change my degree unless I wanted to spend way too much time backtracking
MC: So I just found a job that would take a degree, no matter what it was.
MC: So now, here I am
MC: Both professional and amatuer spy
MC: Apparently
Jessy: That suits you somehow
MC: I don’t know what to say to that
MC: Should I be insulted or…?
Again, realizing my role in this group was still barely above the Hacker’s as far as my motives made my heart sink. They were right. My job here was to investigate, spy and uncover. But since I hadn’t really made them aware of just how creepy I was being, I was surprised to see that they considered me a “spy”, or even investigator.
Jessy: No no! I just meant that you see things others miss
Jessy: So it works for you
MC: Oh okay
Dan: Yeah, you’re a regular Sherlock Holmes
MC: Nah, he at least had cocaine to keep him awake.
MC: I’m probably more like Harriet the Spy, tbh. 😂
The conversation didn’t continue after that, but I almost felt like I’d earned Dan’s respect even just the tiniest bit with that one.
___
I was somewhat caught off-guard when Richy added me after discussing the Man Without a Face in the legends chat that Jessy had made for us. I agreed with him that Jessy seemed more eager to latch onto the legend than most people would, but it made sense that she’d want to seize any chance she saw to step back from the idea that the killer could be human.
For my part, the more I thought on the idea that someone would be masquerading as this mythical avenger, the more I saw it as a viable concept. Killers, especially ones that consider themselves righteous, love to glom onto characters that get across the message they want to embody.
My true crime podcasts taught me that much at least.
I teased him about Jessy more to get him off balance than to confirm he liked her— that much was already obvious. I wasn’t crazy about the power dynamics at play there, with him being her boss, but that seemed kind of like a thing that just happened in small towns. There were only so many people to start with.
I considered lightly flirting with him to see if that was a better tactic, but frankly I couldn’t bring myself to. Jessy was a friend, and she seemed to like him too. I didn’t think he’d ever get up the nerve to ask her, but there was only so much playing in their lives I could justify before it felt icky.
Besides that, there was the question of my shadow.
Ruminating on that led me back to decrypting, a habit I’d taken up while trying to avoid thinking too much on him, his motives, and how much he even noticed about me. Ironically, decryption was the thing that should remind me the most of him, but I could generally focus on Hannah while doing the most annoying parts, since it was to benefit her.
Sometimes I wondered how she would feel once she was safe. I couldn’t imagine she’d be interested in much to do with me— I was still pretty convinced she hadn’t sent my number— as I’d be mostly a reminder about this horrible time in her life. But would she resent me for the intrusions I’d made into her private life?
As if sensing my guilt, the next file I opened was clearly another diary entry, once again filled with emotional conflict. It as much more straightforward than the last, written with a bit more clarity and thought rather than vomiting words up as they appeared in her head.
I bit the inside of my cheek as I read over it a second time. I knew I had to send this to the Hacker, but Hannah’s distress had really been the only thing to faze him since that first, frantic call to her friends. I worried that this one, likely even direct enough for him to grasp the emotion behind, would cause him even more grief.
But he’d also be furious if he found out I kept something from him, even—or maybe especially— if it was out of a desire to protect him. Sighing guiltily, I sent it to him to discuss.
The conversation went a bit unexpectedly, though. Maybe he’d come to terms with our previous findings enough to prepare himself for this one, or maybe he was glad to have something a bit less hard to understand. He probably didn’t read much poetry with his flaw.
I wasn’t prepared for the fucking praise, though. Or really, my reaction to it was the problem. Instead of feeling patronized, it sent a bit of a jolt through me. So damn stupid, getting worked up over some guy telling you that you did a good job. I knew I had a bit of a submissive side but Jesus, really?
Wait. Could he have found that particular… interest… of mine when reading through my chats? Jessy and I got a bit detailed at times when discussing our preferences, after she got used to me it seemed like she enjoyed having someone to discuss things with.
What else had he seen on my phone and devices? He admitted to having full access but said he only looked at case-related things. Still, there was a lot of bullshit to wade through in order to find those case-related items. After he’d said not to worry about offending him, I’d mostly tried to forget he was there whenever I messaged people or screwed around on the internet.
But all it would take was one poorly timed screen-mirror and…
I scrambled to try to remember my recent activities and felt my face burn when I considered all of the possibilities. I wasn’t one to watch risqué videos, being more into reading and writing to alleviate my frustrations.
Cool. Great. Awesome. He probably knew everything about my kinks and I didn’t know his name.
As freaked out as I was, the fact that I still didn’t know his name was starting to bother me. Especially in light of this recent realization. I could do it, right? Just ask his name? I mean, we’d been talking a while, he said he trusted me. I got the feeling I’d never see his face or talk to him without the distortion, but his name was innocent enough.
Before I could chicken out, I typed it out, as a request rather than a question, and hit send.
Of course he’d ask why I cared. Of course it seemed ridiculous to him, I’d already suspected he had no idea what signals I’d tried to throw out.
Would it hurt to try to be more obvious? I wondered. I was cringing at my screen now, trying to both type and shut my eyes to what I was saying as I admitted to liking him. I tried to make a joke of it, using the damn smilies Jessy had gotten me addicted to, but even someone who couldn’t read had to be able to just smell the pheromones and insecurity dripping off of every word.
Jake.
The emotional high of learning that, of being able to greet him properly for the first time, dampened a bit from the clear regret he immediately expressed. Still, he hadn’t left yet, so I I tried to salvage things a little.
Are you dating someone?
How could I not have melted at that? It was the most overt he’d ever been by far. So even when he fled again, I couldn’t keep the stupid grin off of my face.
___
I was pretty ashamed to only realize that Cleo had never gotten back to me about the situation with Thomas until she reached out again, saying that she needed to clear her head before we talked. Still, I should have checked in about it long before now, so the guilt of making it about me, again, pushed away the good feelings from earlier.
Learning that Thomas and Hannah had been arguing, that he no longer had a key to her apartment despite clearly having a way to access it, just solidified my need to check further into him.
Goddamn it folks, stop being shady and stop not telling me things. How is it this fucking hard?
I pinched my nose, attempting to slow my breathing. But learning that he took something from the apartment just shot my blood pressure back up through the roof.
I’d drank as much during this investigation— even ignoring my night out with Annie at the start— as I normally did in a year but I still couldn’t escape the urge for a shot. It was barely mid-afternoon so I resisted the urge, but barely.
___
After getting the book number for Jessy, Jake (that still felt weird) let me know he’d found Poke’s number. I got nervous when he revealed I’d have to call rather than text— I was a millennial, that’s my actual nightmare— and a little frustrated when he seemed to minimize the risk to me again. At this point, he should know I’d stick around even when I’m scared. But it would be really nice to whine and be comforted for five minutes before handing my number over to a suspected criminal.
Still, I suspected that being comforting wasn’t particularly his style, and that even if he wanted to, he’d have very little reference for how to do it.
And there was no denying that of the two of us, I was the better choice for handling the people part. I mean, we were still screwed, but I kind of suspected I was the only person he’d managed to charm recently and I still wasn’t totally possible how he’s done that.
So I groaned, put on my big girl panties, and called.
___
A locksmith. All of this cloak and dagger bullshit over a locksmith. A clearly unethical one, but why the hell would they not just pretend like Thomas had lost his own key or something instead of acting like the sketchiest fucking losers alive?
I wasn’t proud of my past associations, but I’d seen drug deals discussed with more grace than these folks were handling an exchange with a perfectly legal business and an obvious cover story.
Not to mention, why the hell did Thomas not know where her spare key was if Cleo did? I wasn’t sure how long they’d been dating, but it was probably long enough for him to know where her spare key was.
For some reason, I started to suspect less that the culprit was either Dan or Thomas, mainly because they apparently made the stupidest damn criminals I’d ever met.
Hannah, your friends are going to be the death of me, I swear.
___
As the group chat exploded into drama over Phil, I groaned out loud. A fight was a long time coming, especially between Cleo and Jessy, but did it have to be now?
I was working when it started, trying to clear my inbox that I was sorely behind on dealing with. Several of the calls I’d reviewed today had serious violations and one of the clients took the negative feedback really poorly. I’d had enough yelling for this week, thank you.
Annie popped open a can of coke behind me and leaned over to look beyond my shoulder at my phone. I tried to casually block her from seeing, but she was tall enough to catch sight of it anyway.
“Hey is that Jessy? How is she?”
“Fine,” I muttered, locking my phone screen and trying to ignore the rapid-fire buzzing.
“What crawled up your ass?” She snarked, eying up my tense posture and tight expression.
“Nothing, Annie, I’m just trying to work and no one will leave me alone!” I snapped, pushing my keyboard away from me in frustration.
She threw her hands up in surrender. “Jeez, sorry, I was just trying to help.” She turned away from me, toward her room, and took a loud slurp of her coke as she walked. “Let me know when you’re less of a bitch.”
“Right,” I mumbled to myself, getting myself more settled into my chair. “Focus.”
The incessant vibration wouldn’t let me, though, and I realized that I wasn’t going to get anything done until it stopped. Sighing louder than necessary, I once again got involved in something that had no good reason to be my business.
I felt bad for being relieved when Jessy stormed off and things cooled down relatively quickly after that. I reminded myself to reach out to her later, even though I knew she wasn’t the sort who liked to be left alone while she was emotional.
The information about Phil was interesting, though. It wasn’t particularly a side of Hannah I’d heard anything about. But then, I’d only heard about her from people who loved her, and it already seemed like no one knew about her depression.
And boy didn’t I know the kind of questionable decisions depression could lead to. Not to mention, having learned that Thomas returned his key during a fight made me wonder exactly what their relationship was at the time of her disappearance. If they were broken up, maybe she’d been acting out her heartbreak in a way that would raise eyebrows in a small town.
I suppose she could have been taken by a partner after all. Just not the one we knew about.
At the same time, Phil’s comments bordered on the Nice Guy style bullshit I and my friends had heard so often after turning a guy down. Men love to call women sluts for not sleeping with them.
No, I was supposed to be focusing on work. Work. It was bad enough to put off responsibilities for a kidnapping case, it was another to instead speculate on a woman’s sex life when I’d never met her.
Yet I was glad Richy was going to talk to Phil.
I managed to get through about half a day’s work before my phone started again. Spy mode was getting old fast, I have no idea why Jake liked this shit. I just don’t care about other people’s crap this much. I don’t even want to deal with my own social life!
Though it did catch my eye to see that Jessy and Dan were going on a date. Hadn’t seen that one coming, she’d never shown much of a soft spot for him and Dan didn’t strike me as particularly romantic.
But maybe I was just bitter considering “are you single” was the hottest my current relationship had gotten so far.
So much for doing work, I griped and started logging out for the day. Once I started brooding over things with Jake, I was never going to get back on track. I’d learned that the hard way.
Pretending it wasn’t at all to talk to him, I made my way out to the garden and curled up next to a bush to start decrypting in the sun.
___
The sun had set by the time I managed to get anything, but for the first time the picture made me pause.
A Raven.
To be honest, a large part of me figured it was stupid kids. If this legend was as well known in the city as Jessy and Richy had implied, then it made sense for jagoff teenagers to run around marking things up with it. It was at least more creative than just doing penises like most of the graffiti I saw.
But it wouldn’t do to just dismiss it outright either.
In fact, the more I thought about it, the more intriguing it was. Because it didn’t matter if it was just graffiti. The how or why of it being there might be totally irrelevant.
But what made it important was that Hannah thought it was important.
I suppose she could have just thought it was cool, or maybe she was interested in the legend or wanted to show Jessy, who clearly had a strong interest in the macabre. But not long after she’d taken it, she’d supposedly been dragged into the woods by the man this symbol was meant to represent.
Had she been pursuing him rather than the other way round?
Trying to get around explaining to Richy and Jessy where I’d gotten the picture was a bit awkward. They seemed to know I was investigating on some level, and they knew I was in touch with Jake. But they hadn’t really put those things together or realized how deep I was digging, and I was pretty grateful for that. They would have to be offended on her behalf. I was offended on her behalf sometimes.
But like, the police would be doing it too, right? Going through her personal life and putting it under a microscope, analyzing every word she said and who she said it to. At least I wasn’t her neighbor, her pastor, or anyone she had to deal with regularly. That had to be a comfort, I hoped.
But I appreciated Jessy keeping Richy from asking more, either way. Her trust touched me, and made things much simpler for now. And processing this with someone other than Jake was strangely nice, despite how much I enjoyed talking to him.
Of course, then Richy had to get in a parting shot about where I got the picture. And the worst part is, he wasn’t even wrong.
|___
The guilt of all— the hiding, the lying, the half-ignored responsibilities— it started weighing on me after that. Too much was at stake to back down now, but I could feel the suspicion pointed at me, and it was deserved.
I wasn’t above half-truths or even the occasional lie, really. Sometimes it was just easier and better for everyone if the truth went unsaid. But this was snowballing out of control and I didn’t know how to stop it.
So I confessed the only thing I could think of that might not ruin everything.
MC: Jake?
Jake is online.
Jake: Hello, MC.
Jake: Is everything alright?
MC: I lied before.
MC: And cheated.
I paused, trying to think of how to say it. Which I knew I should have considered before I even started the conversation, but planning wasn’t my strong suit when my emotions got the better of me.
Jake is typing…
Jake: To what are you referring?
Right. I’d gotten so used to him reading things and knowing what I meant before I said it that I just kind of assumed he knew what was going on in my head.
MC: The bet.
MC: I’m sending your credits back.
After hitting enter, I quickly opened the app he’d sent me my winnings through and sent them all back. I hadn’t done anything with them, it felt kind of gross.
Jake: I appreciate your honesty, but I’m not sure I understand. You found the information more quickly than I could.
MC: Right, well. That’s because I already knew what SSRIs were for. I’ve been on them for years.
MC: I’ve been depressed since I was a teenager. I don’t even know why I pretended.
MC: I was just surprised you didn’t know already and then you were SO shocked and uncomfortable about Hannah and I got worried you’d think differently of me too so I just went with it.
He typed and erased several times, and my mind became a whirlwind of regret. Why was I doing this? He didn’t ask to hear all about my problems. It wasn’t like I’d conned him out of a huge prize. But I was so tired of lying, and lying to him felt especially wrong after he’d been letting me in.
Jake: MC, I never thought less of Hannah for her depression. I was upset to find out that she was suffering.
MC: It seemed like you were, I don’t know, struggling with your perception of her.
Jake: Not in a negative way, not toward her. And I am sorry that it made you feel like you had to hide or be ashamed in any way.
MC: I’m usually not like this with it, you know? I mean in high school I was, but that went super poorly so I made myself talk about it.
Jake: You do not have to talk about it if you’re not comfortable.
MC: No, I want you to know. It’s a part of my life. And really so much about me makes way more sense when you realize my brain doesn’t really do what it’s supposed to.
MC: Sorry, dark humor is my main coping mechanism.
Jake: I had noticed.
MC: Yeah, it’s not particularly subtle.
MC: And just so you know, I’m stable. The meds help, and I do therapy as needed. There are still bad days and stuff but that’s always going to be true.
MC: That’s part of why I kept pushing about you realizing it was possible that Hannah had hurt herself, too.
MC: Like you said, that’s not the case here since you saw it. But it does happen. And I know my friends and family were even more upset when something would happen because it caught them off guard.
Jake: Is that something
Jake is typing…
MC: Let’s save that conversation for another day, maybe?
Jake: Of course.
MC: But the good news is that maybe it means I can provide some different perspectives on things, right? Like that first cloud entry.
MC: Really, I just have to hope that if I get kidnapped no one gives enough of a shit to sort through my stuff like this because there’s nothing good to be found in my sad folder.
Jake: “Sad folder”?
MC: Don’t even try, it’s super old and on a flash drive somewhere that hopefully fell out of whatever box I put it in when I moved here and got crushed by several cars.
Jake: How oddly specific.
MC: Fantasies are what keep a girl going, right?
MC: Jake?
MC: Thank you for listening.
Jake: :)
Jake: Thank you for your trust.
Jake is offline.
Later, after the third or so time that I re-read our conversation, I tried to work out exactly what it was that made trust so important to him. In our particular situation, we did need to trust each other to a point, but somehow it seemed bigger than that. It was like my trust was some precious trinket to him that he was grateful for each reminder of.
Admittedly, at times that trust felt a little bit more like blind faith, even toeing the line on being foolish. But my instincts told me that he was involved for the right reasons, even if sometimes his methods were at times a bit cold.
___
Somehow, maybe the drink I’d mixed while getting ready for my date with Jessy, it hadn’t occurred to me to think that Jake might have been reading along. I’d gotten used to it by that point, hell, sometimes it even felt reassuring. But it wasn’t until it had started winding down and he messaged me that I realized.
Jake: Hello, MC.
MC: Hello, Jake
He always greeted me so formally, it made me think of a handshake and firm eye contact. I chuckled, picturing us meeting for the first time with a handshake.
Shaking my head at myself, I looked down at my phone.
Jake is typing…
Here, he erased, paused, and started again.
Jake is typing…
After a few minutes of waiting, I started to get concerned.
MC: Is everything okay?
Jake: Did you enjoy your evening?
MC: So you were reading along again 😆
Jake: Yes, it seemed interesting that she chose to cancel her date to speak to you. I wanted to see if there was any information that could be useful to us.
MC: Well, did you see anything interesting?
Jake: Why do you believe that she made the decision to stay home and speak to you?
I wondered for a second if it bothered him. We’d never explicitly discussed my sexuality, and Jessy and my rapport sometimes played hopscotch with the line between bubbly and flirty in that way that every bisexual woman has been confused by at some point in their lives.
MC: Because I’m great 😎
MC: But also Dan kind of sucks
Jake: Regardless, I imagine she would have had a more enjoyable time going out rather than making small talk over orange juice.
MC: Depends on the company I guess 🤷🏻♀️
Jake is typing…
Jake is typing…
MC: Did I make it weird again?
Jake: No.
Jake: Of course not.
Jake: A virtual date was simply a concept I was previously unaware of.
Jake never really spoke informally, but at least lately he’d seemed a little less… stiff. I groaned, suspecting that, despite his denial, I’d made it weird.
MC: Well
MC: I think the voice distortion and hidden face might make it a bit more difficult for you
MC: My mom did tell me not to talk to strange men online 😂
Jake is offline.
And there it is. Not surprising, that could easily have been viewed as an insult. Especially after we’d been seemingly getting closer lately. But my life had totally been taken over by strange men on the internet lately, so I considered it somewhat fair to at least acknowledge that it was weird.
MC: Look, sorry, I didn’t mean anything by it. My mom WOULD be rather annoyed if she saw me now. But it’s not like this is even the worst thing I’ve done.
MC: Really I think I’m mostly surprised that you haven’t had a virtual date before.
MC: It seems like that’d be right up your alley. Computers and girls at the same time.
His status didn’t change after my messages, so after a few minutes I let myself bonelessly sprawl across the couch and sigh. I read through a few bullshit articles online, shared some memes on Facebook, and waited to see if he’d log back on. That had happened a few times, after he’d done whatever he needed to in order to get over the embarrassment, annoyance, or brain breaking I’d subjected him to. He did need me, to a degree, and as inconvenient as my personality was for him, it was more to his benefit to keep me sweet.
Which probably made me a bad person for taking advantage of that for my own amusement just a little. But he could well be using me to find his friend so at least we both got something out of it.
It took longer than usual for him to come back this time, maybe I’d really pissed him off. But around the time I’d started scrolling through some cat pictures on Reddit, he came back.
Jake is online.
Jake: My apologies, something needed my immediate attention.
Jake: I don’t know how my small talk abilities didn’t make it abundantly clear, but I haven’t had the time or opportunity for many dates in the recent past, virtual or not.
My eyes widened a tiny bit. Personal information AND multiple contractions? The language was still very stiff, of course, but there was a tiny bit less formality than earlier. Maybe he wasn’t reading as closely before he hit send. Trying not to chicken out?
Pure speculation, but I liked the thought.
MC: Shame. They can be fun, even without the orange juice.
MC: What with the pandemic and all, it was that or nothing, so I tried my hand at it a few times.
MC: Nothing came of it but you know. It passes the time.
Jake: Is that where your ability to connect with the group without meeting came from?
Interesting question, even feeling a bit loaded. I’d already confirmed I was single, of course, and I’d said I liked him more than once by now. But that still left a lot of room between “hermit” and “almost having a partner”, and I wondered if he was trying to suss that out.
MC: Not entirely. Most of my friendships are online ever since I moved a few years ago. I’m not the greatest at initiating conversation so I’ve mostly stuck with keeping in touch with them.
MC: Keeping and forming connections aren’t the exact same, but since this lot seems to keep me close because Hannah sent my number, it helps.
Jake: I refuse to believe that you aren’t good at initiating.
Jake: Conversation.
Oh, that made me laugh. I wanted desperately to push a little harder on that one, but he’d already logged off once and I was really enjoying talking to him. I got up and poured myself another glass to help me relax a bit further, since the one from my date with Jessy had started to wear off.
MC: I’m actually very shy at first, believe it or not. It’s only once I get comfortable with someone that I become the giant pain in the ass you see before you.
Jake: Does that mean you feel comfortable with me?
MC: Clearly. That’s how transitive property works, right?
Jake: Are you sure that’s the transitive property?
MC: Nope, but it is now.
Jake: Haha.
Jake: You are quite intriguing.
MC: Boy, you know how to charm a girl. I guess “intriguing” certainly isn’t the worst I’ve been called though.
Jake is typing…
He stopped. I again waited for him to log off, but after several long beats, he hadn’t. I decided to put him out of his misery a little.
MC: So how much were you able to dig up on me? I’ve been curious.
MC: I can only assume by this point that you know more about me than I do.
If he was surprised or unnerved by the change in topic, he didn’t show it.
Jake: I looked, of course, before I gave you access to Hannah’s information and the spy mode.
Jake: It was possible that the reason she had your number was because you were the culprit.
MC: Guess being across the world helped reassure you.
Jake: That was part of it.
Jake: Additionally, everything I saw pointed towards you being a perfectly normal woman.
MC: Normal? You must be bad at your job, sir.
MC: But you didn’t actually answer what you dug up.
Jake: No, I did not.
Jake: But I suppose you deserve to know.
Jake: As you’ve mentioned, I have access to your phone. That allowed me to find your social media profiles and email very quickly.
Jake: You don’t list your job on social media, interestingly. Nor the last several.
MC: No way I’m making it easier for them to find the shit I say.
MC: I’m not sure I’d get fired faster for the nerdy bullshit or the liberal rants.
Jake: It’s a good idea to keep those separate, of course.
Jake: It still would not be impossible to find.
Jake: But you also use a nickname on social media and your legal name for work.
Jake: And separate emails.
Jake: That helps as well.
MC: My, are you this thorough with everything you do?
MC: But the analysis is good. Though I’m sure you still found more.
I grinned into my glass a little. There was a chance he wouldn’t pick up on the suggestion behind my comment, but I wouldn’t mind letting him stew on it just the tiniest bit if he managed to.
Jake: Of course. Being thorough is required in my line of work, so it’s part of my nature.
Damn. Just enough that he could still be talking about hacking. Or he could be volleying it back. And in order to know, I’d have to be more obvious. But I couldn’t let him win like that, so I decided to let it go for now.
MC: I’m not that easily deterred. If you found my work email, you found my LinkedIn.
Jake: Yes, of course.
MC: And knowing my email means you know the username for just about everything.
Jake: Yes.
MC: So, anything interesting?
Jake: Well, to be honest, once I’d found your socials and work information, I had enough to determine you were safe to contact.
MC: And I totally believe that someone we’ve established as being painstakingly thorough stopped there.
Jake: After some of our conversations where I revealed more details to you, I did look a bit further. I connected you to an old username it doesn’t seem you use any longer.
Oh, damn. I should have expected that, but suddenly realized just how many old profiles I had under that name. Everything from dating profiles, to forums, to fanfiction. It went back as far as middle school.
Jake: I stopped after finding an old Xanga and LiveJournal. At that point, it no longer felt appropriate.
Okay, maybe he didn’t find my RPG posts. I hoped.
MC: I would have thought you’d find those entertaining. I was pretty angsty and faux-deep. Almost as bad as my sad folder.
MC: Loved me some sparkly HTML backgrounds.
MC: I got them all from a source of course, we can’t all be geniuses, and I considered myself something of a writer at the time. Coding was never my thing.
Hopefully, leaning into the embarrassment would get rid of the blush on my face. Plus, the second glass of wine was certainly helping to loosen my lips, er, fingers.
Jake: To be totally honest, I was far too busy remembering my own teenage angst to focus too heavily on yours.
Jake: I scrubbed my own profiles years ago.
I smirked.
MC: Hm, now I’m curious what you used.
MC: You can’t be too much younger than me if Xanga and LJ brought you back.
MC: But I guess you could still be a late MySpace, early Facebook user and still remember those.
MC: I’d bet good money you got your hands on a computer young, and probably had even less oversight than I did.
Jake: Mmh, but I thought your mom told you to be afraid of internet strangers.
MC: But she also believed I’d listen. It’s like she didn’t even know me. 🤭
MC: You’re probably not even the worst stranger danger I’ve let myself get involved with.
Another pause, but this one felt a little more comfortable. Maybe he was curious and wondering if he should ask. Or maybe he was pondering the meaning of “get involved with”. Maybe he just didn’t know how to reply.
Still, this time felt rather friendly, like the last hour or so had relaxed something in us both. I had no idea if he was flirting back or just clueless, but I didn’t sense any discomfort beyond maybe uncertainty.
Jake: MC, I have to go.
Jake: But thank you, I enjoyed this time.
MC: Hopefully it made good practice for your next virtual date. 😝
Why would I say that? And why did that thought bother me that badly? Of him taking our conversation and using it to charm someone else?
That’s not good.
Jake: We shall see.
Jake: :)
Well, fuck.
Honestly, I probably could have dwelled on that for the rest of the night. But nothing sobers a girl up and jerks her out of daydreaming about men quite like a rapid fire confession of lawbreaking from someone who you thought hated you, discovery of a lead on a kidnapping case, and realizing that the initials on that same lead may well match the initials of the guy you were just daydreaming about.
After a nearly sleepless night, I would come to realize that nothing cleared up exhaustion quite like a threatening call and learning that someone you knew was barely clinging to life, either.
NEXT
16 notes
·
View notes