Dominating Love Pt. 2 (RDR2 Fanfic, Arthur Morgan x F!Reader, 18+)
Summary: Arthur continues to agitate you to the best of his ability, putting not only you but the whole camp on edge. When you finally snap, the resulting punishment is to the detriment of you both, pushing the two of you to a rage that is unexpected in its clarity.
Author’s Notes: This is part two. Click here for part one, and if you want me to keep writing about these two let me know!
Tags: Arthur Morgan x reader, smut, low honor Arthur Morgan, rough sex, oral sex, name-calling
AO3 Link
~
Dominating Love
Word count: 7931
Part Two
After three long days of self-hatred and regret, Arthur Morgan tucked tail and returned to his gang’s camp at Horseshoe Overlook. He didn’t feel like showing his face, especially not to you. You had every right to be angry with him, but he couldn’t face that—didn’t want to. He wanted to be with you again, to feel your skin on his, but he knew it wouldn’t happen. He had screwed up enough to know that to be fact.
As he rode nearer and nearer to camp, his nerves set in. It was an unfamiliar feeling. He almost never got nervous after years in his line of work, but there they were: bundled nerves so deep in the pit of his stomach that he thought about turning around and riding in the other direction. He didn’t though, gritting his teeth and riding on. The camp needed him, and he wouldn’t abandon the people who relied on him for longer than necessary because of a foolish mistake he made. It was his fault, and he would have to deal with it.
It was a little after noon when Arthur rode into camp. He hitched his horse and scanned the overlook, the tree line, and everywhere else for the sight of you. You were nowhere to be found. The thought of you in trouble somewhere all alone panicked him, but he quickly pushed the feeling away. You were too much of a minx to get yourself into any real trouble. It would likely be the other way around—an unlucky group of bastards having your wrath unleashed on them. Arthur chuckled at the thought as he made to start his usual camp chores.
You didn’t show up for the rest of the day, and as night fell, despite the fact that he knew you were probably fine, Arthur began to worry. He shouldn’t have listened to you, shouldn’t have let you run off alone just because you had guilted him into agreeing to it. There wasn’t much he could do about it now, though. You could be anywhere. Riding off to look for you was useless, and that left him with only one option: to wait on you—something he despised.
~
This was the most well-rested you had been since birth. As the sun rose and you woke beside the warm fire you had built the night before, you realized it would be your fifth day away from camp. More importantly, it would be your fourth day away from Arthur. Alleluia.
You sat up and stretched, looking around for your mare. She stood a good ways away down by the river that fed into the Upper Montana. You smiled at her. She was one of the better horses you had ever come across. The sun glinted off of her blood bay coat, turning her back blazing red. You sighed, wishing you didn’t have to go back. The thought surprised you. You loved the gang and the camp. Both provided you more shelter than you had ever known. You only didn’t want to see everyone because they always picked on you and Arthur after your days away from camp. You mainly didn’t want to face Arthur, the smug bastard. You picked at the grass beside you and shredded a piece, anger boiling over again at the thought of the man. It just wouldn’t do to stay away, though. You loved the gang more than you hated Arthur, and you sure as shit weren’t going to let him keep you from camp because of a childish spat the pair of you had. You sighed again, throwing the grass down. It was decided, then. You were going back today.
After eating and smothering the remaining embers of the fire, you saddled and packed up your mare and swung onto her, ready for the small journey that would take you back to Horseshoe Overlook. It would be a few hours, a last few peaceful hours full of nothing but beauty and a horse and the lack of Arthur Morgan. The thought made you smile.
After a much too short ride, the camp came into view as you plodded along the familiar path. It was still morning, and everyone was busy with their regular chores. It was true that you normally got to shirk some responsibilities with Grimshaw due to your talented marksmanship that had you winning scores with the men, but she would still be angry with you. Especially if Arthur beat you back and it looked like you had taken your sweet time returning to camp. Sure enough, upon arrival, you spotted his horse in the wood line. The sight of it made you frown. Your familiar anger set in like an old friend, and you decided from that point on you weren’t going to say one word to him today. Even if work called for it, you would keep your mouth glued shut with spite.
You hitched your horse and dismounted, feeding her and giving her a loving pat before walking off to find Grimshaw. A familiar voice rang out from your left, and your shoulders scrunched up to your neck from the sound of it. “Bout time you graced us with your presence.” You set your jaw and didn’t grant Arthur a response, looking straight ahead and continuing to walk instead. You didn’t let the smile reach your lips at the thought of how angry he would get over being ignored, but the satisfaction remained just beneath the surface. “Hey, I’m talking to you,” he said, closing the gap between you and spinning you around to face him. You stood your ground, flashing a wicked smile at him before turning back around to continue walking. “Oh, I see. The silent treatment. Real mature.” You gave him a very vulgar gesture without turning, off to find Grimshaw.
Sure enough, the leading woman in camp was not pleased at all by your absence. She had assigned you enough work to last all day, and you had been working for hours catching up on things you knew she only designated out of spite. It was enough work for three people. Your body ached. Hell, even your bones ached by the time she declared your work done for the day. You were about to find your bedroll and fall into it when Karen asked you to join her near the campfire. It was still early, and the fire would feel nice on your tensed muscles, at least for a little while. So, you joined her for a drink.
Of course, after only fifteen minutes, this drew Arthur’s attention like a shark to blood. You felt his presence ambling nearer before you saw him by the way everyone around the fire seemed to look to you in unison. You heaved a big sigh, making your annoyance known. You still vowed not to speak a word to him even though it was currently making camp relations a bit strained. No one wanted to be around the two of you when you were at each other’s throats, much less when you were making him so angry that his only choice was to take it out on everyone else for the day. You didn’t care. You hated him enough to keep it up.
“What’re you looking at?” he spat at them. Javier and Bill mumbled curses under their breath.
“I can’t quite tell,” Uncle responded, chuckling at Arthur.
“Real funny,” Arthur said as he stopped to stand beside you. You tensed so badly that your muscles protested, reminding you that you should be in bed instead of dealing with this. You waited for him to bait you with some nasty quip.
Instead, Karen faced him down. “Why are you giving us so much grief? It ain’t like we have to put up with it.”
Arthur opened his mouth in response, but before he could get a word in, Dutch placed a heavy hand on his shoulder. “I need to speak to you two.” He looked at everyone else around the fire. “Find somewhere else to be.” As they all mumbled and slowly scattered, your brows knitted together. Dutch usually liked to make an example out of everyone, a lesson out of everything, and you hadn’t the slightest clue what he didn’t want to say in front of the others. It rattled you a little. “Sit, Arthur,” he said, motioning to the log you sat on. Arthur sat beside you, and you swore you could feel the wrath rolling off of him in waves at having to obey like that. Dutch circled in front of you, standing over you both a few seconds before speaking. You recognized the danger in his expression, the look making the hair at the back of your neck stand on end. “I heard about what happened with Hosea.”
Now you understood. The pair of you had almost gotten him killed. Dutch was a very protective man, and that wouldn’t easily be forgiven.
You sat in silence, waiting for Dutch to speak first. “Well? What do you have to say for yourselves?”
“Ask her, it was her fault,” Arthur said. Where you usually would have given him a cutting response, you stayed as still and quiet as death.
Dutch gave Arthur a hateful look before locking those smoldering eyes on you. You made it clear you were speaking only to him, not Arthur, turning slightly. “We didn’t see the gun the farmer had until it was too late.”
Dutch closed his eyes and took a long breath like he was attempting to calm himself down with it. “That is precisely why you were there. To make sure something like that wouldn’t happen.”
Guilt riddled your gut and found a home there at his words. He was right. Arthur had been distracting you at the time, but Dutch was right. You should have been watching. “I know and I’m…it won’t happen again.”
“I am very close to saying there will be no ‘again.’” Dutch’s words surprised you, and the emotion found your face as you looked up at him open-mouthed. “And you,” Dutch said, turning his hard gaze on Arthur. “Don’t try and act innocent. I know she’s smart, and I know it wouldn’t have happened if anyone else had been with her.”
You had lost your voice, amazed that you had let your anger with Arthur cloud the fact that you had almost gotten Hosea killed. But Arthur hadn’t yet lost his will to argue. “Dutch, that ain’t fair-”
“It’s perfectly fair,” Dutch interrupted. He leaned forward toward the two of you, crouching down to your level. “Now, I don’t know what’s going on between you two, and believe me, I’m far from caring, but if you don’t find your heads and use them, you aren’t leaving this camp until you learn to put the safety of everyone else here before your own emotions. Do you understand?”
“Yes, Dutch,” you answered quickly.
You felt the hesitation from Arthur and knew what it meant—he would submit to Dutch’s wishes, but his reluctance proved how unwilling he truly was to do what he asked. “Sure,” he finally answered with his low drawl, like it killed him to say it.
“Good. Now stand up. Both of you.” Dutch stood back up, and you and Arthur reluctantly rose to your feet. “Shake hands.” Dutch crossed his arms, waiting, as you both turned to him with expressions of utter defiance. He held his hand up to silence you. “I don’t want to hear it. Shake hands so I know you’ll stop acting like children.”
You threw your hand out, and Arthur looked down at it a moment before reaching out his own with obvious discontent, shaking your hand in a too-tight grip. You let go quickly, turning and stomping off toward your bedroll before you were forced to be in his presence a second longer.
As morning came, your body ached from the work the day before had brought. You also pondered Dutch’s words with worry. You couldn’t afford to be screwing up jobs. It would only land you with Grimshaw permanently or worse: kicked out of the gang. That couldn’t happen. You wouldn’t let that happen. As much as you hated giving Arthur any sort of friendliness when he had caused all of this, it was your only option. You would have to at least try. You owed it to yourself.
When he attempted to get you to talk to him again, you answered him. It wasn’t the friendliest of responses, but it was at least something that would keep his anger at bay. He had said something about you finally deciding to help out this morning to which you responded with, “Mhm. Doing my part.” You didn’t think he caught the double-meaning, too upset with failing to rile you.
When he picked on you the second time, you again shot him down. “You know, you do work around camp well enough. I don’t blame Dutch for not wanting you out on jobs,” he said after Susan praised the hard work you were doing.
Before he could speak another word and dig himself into a deeper grave, you said “I don’t either, not after a messy score like that.” That one really stumped him, and as he grumbled and stalked off, you grinned.
The third time was different. He finally hit a nerve, and you couldn’t stop your anger from spilling out. You had finished your work for the day and stood near the cliff edge, pondering if this was how things would be from now on. Arthur sauntered over to you. You saw him out of the corner of your eye and braced yourself for whatever was making him so sure of himself. “So,” he said, coming to stand on the far side of you and resting his hands on his gun belt, looking out across the river. You didn’t immediately answer, so he continued. “I’ve been thinking.”
You thought about saying something along the lines of that being surprising, but you kept your thoughts to yourself. “Mhm.”
He moved in close, his bicep touching your shoulder, his head leaning down toward yours but remaining looking out as he whispered. “I think there’s something going on between you and Dutch.”
“Excuse me?” you asked, stepping away to look him in the eye. You were somewhat offended by the statement but mainly confused by it.
“That has to be it,” he said with a gleam in his eye. As he leaned in toward you, you knew whatever was about to come out of his mouth was going to be idiotic, but you certainly didn’t expect his next words: “How else would he get a little bitch like you to mind him so well?” Your face dropped. No feeling, no anger escaped it, but white-hot rage pooled in your stomach all the same. “I’ll have to ask him for some pointers-”
Before he could utter another word, you were on him like a hellcat, using his close proximity to your advantage as you punched, slapped, clawed, and kicked. He was on the ground in seconds, cowering. All he protected was his face and upper body, so you used that to your advantage and kicked him in the balls. Hard. He recoiled, his hands shooting downward to his crotch as he cried out in pain. You used the opportunity to reach down, yanking his head up by his hair to make him look you in the eyes. “You say shit like that again and I’ll gut you,” you growled. You shoved his head back down before looking up to see what a grand mistake you had made. A few of the gang members had run over to see what the commotion was, and Dutch hovered just beyond them, his smoldering gaze set on you.
After what felt like hours trapped within a moment, he pushed through the crowd and stalked toward you. Just as you began to find your words to apologize, he pushed past you and moved to Arthur’s side. He crouched down, asking him if he was all right. You felt ashamed, stupid for thinking you could handle your temper around Arthur, for thinking you meant nearly as much to this gang as Arthur did. You heard Dutch’s voice grow louder. “Good, then get up.”
He yanked Arthur to his feet and Arthur winced, walking curled in on himself with every step. Dutch yanked his arm along like a child in trouble, and when they made to pass you, Dutch sidestepped and grabbed you too. The sudden feeling of being manhandled along with your anger that hadn’t yet simmered down had you fighting him, yanking away with every step. “Let go of me!” you yelled, but his grip was iron. It was no use.
The whole gang watched as Dutch dragged the pair of you all the way across camp to the hitching posts. Once there, he let go and shoved you both, sending you shuffling a few steps past him. “I tried telling you, both of you. Now go on and leave,” Dutch said loud enough for everyone to hear as his voice cracked on the last word.
“Dutch?” Arthur pleaded, the hurt in his voice not a result of the pain in his body but rather for the threat of being told to leave for good.
Dutch held up his hand to silence him. “You may join us when you’ve sorted this out. Until then, even if it takes weeks, even if it takes months, I don’t want to see your faces in this camp again. Do I make myself clear?”
You just stared, open-mouthed. The coldness had reached your eyes, but you didn’t care to hide it, even if it was Dutch on the receiving end. This was your home, and Arthur had just taken it away from you. Dutch hadn’t given you a choice either, had grouped you in with the bastard. Tears began to form at the corners of your eyes, and before you let them show, you turned and stormed to your bedroll to pack your things and leave.
You made quick work of it and were on your mount headed out of camp when you heard Arthur behind you. “Hey, wait up a minute,” he yelled out, sounding out of breath, whether from trying to catch up to you or from shock you couldn’t tell.
You seethed, anger pouring out of every place it could find daylight. “Don’t you dare say a word to me,” you threatened once he had ridden to your side.
“Y/N-”
“Arthur, I swear to god,” you interrupted. You locked eyes with him, hate rushing out of you and toward him with so much force it was nearly a physical thing. That shut him up. Finally, you thought.
You didn’t know where you were going, just that it was habit that took you down the path toward Valentine. Arthur rode beside you in silence. You wanted him to be on the opposite side of the world but knew that his silence was better, a precious thing that you didn’t want him to waste on someone else. By the time you hitched in front of the saloon in town, your anger had subsided again, leaving a hollowness in its wake that made you feel dead inside. Alcohol would help. It would burn up the pain that was trying to eat you alive.
You stepped inside and up to the bar, not caring whether Arthur was there or not, blocking everything out in an attempt not to think about Dutch’s words. Weeks and months kept flashing across your mind. That was too damn long. “Whiskey,” you told the bartender, sliding your money across the bar.
You heard another coin scrape across the bar top beside you, but you ignored its owner. “Same here,” followed his gruff voice. You leaned over the bar, searching your hands like they would give you some sort of answer. They wouldn’t, and you knew the alcohol wouldn’t either, but you couldn’t help it. You couldn’t remember feeling this broken since the gang had found you and taken you in.
After too much whiskey and very little memory of the remaining day’s occurrences, you had fallen asleep in the hotel. You awoke the next morning with a pounding head and moaned in pain and regret before immediately tensing from the warmth of a body next to yours. You looked over to find Arthur, but he was clothed. You were clothed.
His eyes opened slowly from the sound you had made. He assessed the situation and ran a hand down his face, moaning with the same pain. “Shit. What the hell happened?”
“You tell me,” you said. Arthur had a tendency to get rowdy and violent when drunk, so you surmised that he remembered more than he was letting on, sentient enough the day before to get you both to the hotel in one piece.
He looked over at you and yawned, still waking up. “I remember…you wanting to come here. So I took you.”
You sat in silence a moment before laying back down. The room still spun slightly. Arthur shifted to rest on his side and looked at you, waiting. “Didn’t think to get two beds?” you hissed.
“They were all out.” So he did remember.
“Hmm,” you said. You weren’t really up for arguing with him but couldn’t resist saying it. “So, what was going through your filthy little mind last night when you crawled into this bed with me?”
“Nothing,” he responded, surprising you. “I wasn’t thinking at all.” You turned your head and met his gaze, those pretty eyes of his dangerously close, honest and searching yours.
You didn’t let your filter catch the question before it left your mouth. “Why haven’t you given up on me?”
“What?” he said on an exhale.
“Why haven’t you left me somewhere to fend for myself already? It’s not like I don’t deserve it.”
He pondered this a while, blue eyes shielded in thought. Then, “Why haven’t you dropped me?”
“Trust me, I’ve tried,” you quipped, turning your head to look at the ceiling. That earned you a low chuckle from him.
“Yeah, you ain’t kidding.” The pair of you sat in silence a few moments before he spoke. “Listen, I’m…sorry. For what I did up in the mountains. For acting a fool in camp.”
You didn’t move a muscle to look at him or speak. Deep down you appreciated it, but it made even more guilt build up inside your gut, knowing he had just been doing what he always did that day, and you had snapped at him over something minuscule, causing all of this. This was your fault. The pair of your were banned from camp because of your temper, not his. Given, he wasn’t completely innocent, but he wasn’t the cause either. You were. This was all you. And suddenly, your anger was hard to hold down any longer. It was all you knew. The one thing causing all your grief was the one tether you could hold onto, the one thing keeping you from drowning. So you let it out. “You should be. Sorry sack of shit.”
You knew your words cut him deep when he didn’t immediately answer. He was trying, really trying, to throw you a lifeline. Reaching out his hand. And you had chopped it clean through the bone. It riled him. “For god’s sake,” he breathed out.
“What,” you spat, a statement more than a question.
He turned, sitting up to look at you. “You’re really that wrong in the head, are you? Thinking you’re all alone, that you don’t deserve anything good.”
“I don’t know what the hell you’re talking about,” you spat, throwing the sheets off of you and getting up.
“I see it, Dutch and Hosea see it. Hell, everyone in that goddamn camp sees it. You’re broken. And you think pushing us all away and hating the world is gonna fix that? Trust me, it ain’t.”
His words were lined with honesty, like he had gone through the same thing. You turned on him. “Don’t act like you know me. Like you know what this feels like.” He had risen to sit on the edge of the bed and just stayed there, shaking his head. “You’re wrong, wrong about me. I don’t hate it all, I love it all, everyone, too much. And it just gets me hurt, crushes me over and over again. I’m clinging to that camp like a lifeline, knowing full well I just ruined what little bit of good I had there.”
He met your gaze. “You didn’t ruin it.”
“Yeah, I did. It’s what I do. You think they won’t remember me almost getting Hosea killed, me beating you to the ground, their golden boy?”
His eyes hardened. “I ain’t their golden boy. Far from it.” You rolled your eyes, and he went on. “I’ve pulled the same shit you have my whole life with them. They ain’t gonna abandon you. I won’t…abandon you.”
Realization dawned on you. This was about him. He was making it about him. He had been hurt the same way his whole life, and now that he saw it happening to someone else, he was protecting you for his own sake. “Leave me the hell alone,” you spat, getting up and grabbing your boots, stomping toward the door.
He was up in a heartbeat, slamming the door shut as you opened it. “Why can’t you see,” he said, grabbing your arms and spinning you, forcing your back into the door as you dropped your boots. “Why can’t I make you see,” he spoke through gritted teeth. You felt the anger coming off of him and matched it.
“Get off of me you piece of shit,” you muttered, trying to fight him off. To no avail. “This makes you feel big, doesn’t it? Trapping me? Saving me?” You spat the word in his face, and his gaze turned feral.
“This ain’t about me you little-”
“Oh, it sure as hell is. Tell me, does your dick get hard at night thinking of coming to my rescue?”
“Shut the hell up,” he growled.
“No, you know it’s true. You know I’m just a means to an end. I’m you, Arthur-”
He slammed you against the door. “No you ain’t!”
You winced but pushed on. “I am. I’m you, and I’m seeing it now, why you always want to fuck me so bad. It’s the closest thing to saving me, saving yourself. Isn’t that right?”
He pushed hard, and you began to lose your breath at the weight. “You’re wrong,” he growled.
“Am I?”
“You’re wrong,” he repeated.
“Tell me then. Enlighten me,” you said, almost at a whisper from how much force he was using to push you against the door. You worried your bones would crack.
“Fuck you,” he spat.
“Tell me, you bastard,” you said through gritted teeth.
The anger was swallowing him whole. You were glad it wasn’t you for once. “No.”
“Tell me.”
“No,” he repeated, his lips pulled back over his teeth in a snarl.
“Tell me!” you screamed, and he let go with one hand, slamming it into the door beside your face.
“Because I fucking love you!”
It suddenly made sense. All of it. His refusing to let up on you for one damn second. You could see it all as clear as day. But that didn’t keep you from being floored by his words, from letting the weight of them hit you harder than any anger, than any pain.
The pair of you stood there, breathless, staring. “Prove it,” you whispered before you could stop yourself. His lips crashed into yours. The force of his strength against you let up, instead pushing into your mouth. He kissed you so hard you thought your head would break through the door. His tongue pushed past your teeth, running along the top of your mouth, your teeth, your tongue. It earned him a groan from you filled with frustration and lust that only spurred him on. He pushed harder and harder, devouring you, until he took your arms in his hands again and spun you, shoving himself against the door with you in front of him. You hesitated for less than a heartbeat before understanding—he wanted you in control. The thought ate you alive. You wanted him then and there.
You pushed forward and kissed him, the pair of you tearing at each other like animals. You pulled his suspenders off his shoulders, unbuttoned his shirt and his union suit, ripping them down to reveal that broad chest. He heaved in breaths, each one a holy sight for your devouring. You couldn’t resist and reached for his throat, shoving his head back into the door to hold him there as you ducked your head and latched your mouth onto one of his nipples. He growled at the contact, no doubt humiliated by it, but he let you continue. He let you. The thought fueled the fire that began to burn within you.
You flicked your tongue over the small nub enough to make him squirm before releasing him. You shoved him once against the door, backing off of him slightly. “Don’t move,” you said. He just looked at you with hardened eyes, trying very hard to listen. You could see it was killing him. You rushed forward again and untucked his shirt, yanking it up and throwing it behind you. You unbuttoned his pants and the remaining buttons on his union suit, sliding your hands around to cup his ass and slowly bringing his clothes down with them. You ran your hands around his hips and to his front, flicking your eyes up at him as you did. The gaze that looked down at you was damning. Your core tightened in response, flexing for those eyes. You looked back down so as to keep your patience, and just before you touched his length, you stopped. He let out a harsh breath of frustration. He was rock hard, and the sight made the corners of your mouth tug upward. You silently wondered if his arousal was from your touching him like this or from your obvious acceptance of his confession. You settled on both as you took his length in your hand.
He winced, his hips bucking forward slightly. “Easy,” you purred, grinning at his eagerness. You kept one hand on him and used the other to pull his pants and union suit all the way down. He stepped out of them, and you threw them both behind you as well, leaving him bare.
“What about you,” he breathed, motioning to your clothes with his eyes.
“Patience,” was all you uttered before using both of your hands on him. His body tightened, like a coil being forced downward only to inevitably spring back. His hands clenched and unclenched, wanting so badly to touch you, to make you his. But this time, he was yours. You put your mouth just below his belly button, sucking the skin and hardened muscle there while you hands worked his shaft just below. The noises that started to come out of him were sinful.
You teased him, flicking your tongue close enough to his length for him to imagine what you could do with your mouth on him, but just out of reach. You sucked his skin as you ran the pad of your thumb around his tip, spreading his precome along it. Your other hand barely brushed the underside of his cock, causing no friction but no release either. Just a tease. He began to squirm. You moved your hand to his balls and cupped them, making him groan. The sound sent more heat between your legs. You didn’t squeeze in the slightest, your small way of apologizing for being so rough with him last time, not to mention kicking him there yesterday. You ran your thumb from his tip slowly downward, all the way to his base. You heard a thump and released your mouth from his abdomen to look up. He had tilted his head back against the door with his eyes closed tight. You chuckled, unable to resist. His movement left you with no choice but to surprise him. Still cupping his balls and moving your hand back and forth very softly, you grasped his base and took him into your mouth.
“Christ,” he hissed, squirming in your grasp. You began to move, slow and erotic, using your tongue like you knew how. Only, when you considered it, you hadn’t gotten to do this to him before. He had fucked your mouth before, but this was very different. His arousal pooling in your hands, his body reacting to every flick of your tongue on his shaft so delightfully. It was a pleasure to watch, to do it to him. And you would get your due. That you were sure of.
You kept your movements light, your touch unfocused enough to keep him at bay and drive him mad all the same. After a few minutes, you took him out of your mouth with a loud pop and rose to your feet, meeting his eyes. He huffed out breaths like each one was precious. You could tell he was frustrated. Unfortunately for him, it was only going to get worse. You smirked at him before walking to the bed and sitting, leaving him staring after you. “Come undress me,” you taunted.
His gaze was blown wide with lust, his thoughts and judgement no doubt clouded as he moved to you quickly, starting with your shirt. He undid each button but didn’t peel the shirt away before he moved to your pants. You stood up. “Kneel.” He stopped and looked at you with surprise, like he was too distracted to understand your words. When they clicked, he grimaced but folded his lumbering form to the ground, kneeling before you to resume unbuttoning your pants. “Ah ah,” you tisked. He closed his eyes in frustration but moved his hands away, looking to you for what to do next. You made him watch as you took your shirt off, peeling each sleeve off your skin slowly. You weren’t wearing your usual short chemise and were instead bare. He swallowed, taking in the sight of your breasts just above him. “Now,” you said, motioning for him to resume. He did but lingered on the sight of your upper body, blue eyes brushing over the raised skin. He finished unbuttoning your pants and saw that you wore nothing under them as well. You thought you heard a small groan escape him. “Go ahead,” you told him. He pulled your pants down slowly, running his warm fingers down your sides, your skin lighting on fire with his touch. You wanted him so badly, his submission, his beautiful body, him. You were running out of patience.
You held your resolve nonetheless as you stepped out of your pants. He moved them for you and sat back, his eyes slowly moving upward until they stopped right between your thighs. “All yours,” you said through a wicked smile. “Come return the favor.” You sat on the bed, laying back, and he huffed in frustration. This teasing was getting to him.
He rose to his knees and ran those sinful hands along your legs anyway, moving up and up, tracing lazy circles as he did so. He pulled you slowly toward the edge of the bed, toward his face. You thought you would explode with wanting. When his thick fingers finally touched your folds, you let out a gasp. A sound rumbled through him in response. He began running one finger along you, nearing your entrance but continuing, making you squirm like you had done to him. Without warning, he slipped a finger inside of you, and you bit down to keep from moaning. “Want to hear you,” he said, the arousal in his voice making you clench around him.
It was a command but a reasonable one, so you allowed it. He began pumping in and out of you slowly. You thanked the heavens for giving him such broad fingers as he worked you over, inserting a second. Your body reacted to it, your muscles tightening with desire. He still moved slowly, building you up, but you knew you wouldn’t come like this. You were growing impatient. “Arthur-” you chided before he interrupted you by placing the pad of his thumb on your clit. You gasped. He hummed his pleased response. Then he began to move.
His thumb flicked circles, making you move into his touch. His two fingers from his other hand picked up their pace, and he curled them. It was pure bliss on your body that melted into every touch, every caress. He went faster and faster, his thumb erratic on that bundle of nerves. You climbed and climbed, wanting to clench around him and come for him, for how well he was doing.
You felt the sudden absence of his thumb and almost squealed in protest until his mouth replaced it, his tongue finding that rhythm instead, the heat of his mouth surrounding you. “Arthur,” you moaned, unable to stop yourself. For the first time, you didn’t care. He was yours and he knew it, and it didn’t matter that you were moaning his name. That erotic movement against your clit warranted it.
He hummed his approval, and the vibration sent a shock through your body. You were going to come. As if he knew it, he switched, moving his tongue down to your core and his hand to your clit. He began to devour you, rubbing such erratic patterns with his thumb that you huffed out each breath. His tongue lapped at your heat, pressing into you with a familiar warmth that you craved more of. He split you wide open, building and building and building you up until you were bound to crash. The constant pleasure from his thumb became faster, became urgent. Demanding. Your body finally submitted to it, and you came hard at the thought of the taste of your release in his mouth. You yelled your pleasure and didn’t care if the whole world heard it.
He was slow at stopping, taking his time to clean you up with his mouth. The feeling of it drove you mad as you came down. His tongue finally slipped out of you, and you looked down at him as he wiped his face and crawled up, bracing his arms around your head and smiling down with a shit-eating grin. “You wipe that grin right off your face before I do it for you,” you said with a matching one.
He had never done that to you before, had never had the patience or restraint to, but god had someone taught him well. You silently thanked whoever that was as he said “So good for me.” You flipped him off, still with a smile, and looked down at his length, thinking about how you wanted to take him. His cock was leaking, no doubt aching at this point. You loved him behind you, but you had gotten enough of that to last you a lifetime. This was different. This was special, even if you hated to admit it. His muscled form remained over you, waiting on your command. You relished the sight. You met his eyes and found fire there, surprising you. You were pure bliss, pure contentment. The desire within him rattled you. You moved, asking him to lay on the bed. He obliged, pressing his back down against the sheets and looking up at you as you moved over him. You had no idea where this sudden restraint was coming from, but you were more than grateful. He was more than proving his earlier statement.
You wrapped your hand around his length and lined yourself up with him. He hissed at your touch, at the anticipation, before you slid onto him, sitting down so that you were flush with his body, split to his hilt. He let out a loud sound, one that made you blush, but he continued to hold your gaze with that sinful mouth open in pleasure. Then you moved.
Whether it was from your previous climax or from his thickness inside you, you couldn’t be sure, but you clenched and sputtered around him mere seconds into moving on him, holding another orgasm back so as to build it up. He let out a weak groan as a result that made you speak up. “You come when I tell you.” A statement, not a request. He gritted his teeth as you ground down on him, his head tilting back and hitting the bed.
You were fairly unfamiliar with this as well, only doing it once before with him when getting the upper hand late one night. You remembered how he had begun to fight back before realizing how good it felt, fucking up into you while holding you down with a bruising grip. In the end, though, he had grown impatient and flipped you over and around, fucking you from behind until you were drooling into the blankets and screaming each other’s pleasure.
This time was becoming not much different as your pace picked up and his hands found your hips. You began to pant and he did too, his cock splitting you wide with pleasure over and over again. His fingers dug deep—you were sure of the marks that would form there. Marks that would make you smile and would make you wet with the thought of their origin. He lost some of his resolve, his restraint, as he began to match your rhythm and fuck up into your heat. He slammed your hips down on him with every thrust, and you snapped them forward to make him hit you deep each time. You were both grunting messes within seconds, and through the sweat and haze of pleasure, he found his words. “I think I like you riding me, little whore.”
He couldn’t resist the words, and you couldn’t resist the smile that reached you face when you said “Don’t come. My turn.” The most evil form of punishment. You slammed down on him one last time, spasming around his hard length as you came, yelling again. You stopped suddenly, utterly, leaving him sheathed inside you, and he lost it, growling in anger. “Don’t worry. I haven’t forgotten,” you said, a little bitterness in the last word for the last time the pair of you were together.
You sat a moment longer before turning on him, sitting back down on his cock with your back facing him. You peeked over your shoulder to find him exasperatedly staring at your ass, open-mouthed, hands frozen in the air like he didn’t know where to place his focus. You didn’t blame him, though. The angle really felt that good. Then you moved. After two orgasms, you were becoming a little overly sensitive. It was pleasure mixed with pain as his shaft pushed into you again and again, the angle touching that spot deep within you Arthur had discovered the last time you were together. It had you moaning, humming around him. “You don’t stop that and I’m gonna come,” he mumbled, his hands again finding your hips as he snapped his own into you. You smiled and bit the inside of your cheek, trying to stop the pleasure from escaping your mouth. Instead, you reached for his balls. The second you touched them, you could feel his body writhe beneath you, and he rose behind you, wrapping a strong arm around you to keep you pinned down on his cock. He went impossibly deeper with the new angle, and you couldn’t stop yourself. “Arthur,” you sighed, uncaring that he had earned a kernel of control back, unconcerned about anything but the painful pleasure that rolled through you every time he fucked into you from below. His pace became erratic. You knew he wouldn’t last long.
He suddenly moved his fingers back to your clit with the arm he had wrapped around you, and you felt fire, actual fire, burning you from within. It was too much. “Wanna f-feel you,” he managed, grinding into you so harshly and running his finger around so ruthlessly that tears pricked your eyes from overuse.
Your body yielded to his request, and you came again, screaming his name this time. You didn’t think you would ever come down as he let out a pained whimper, wanting to come but remembering he had to have your permission. You relented quickly. “Come, Arthur.” He obeyed. His come painted your walls as he yelled out his pleasure.
After pure stillness for a few moments, he leaned back and hit the bed, and you followed, slipping off of him in the process.
“Fucking hellfire,” he murmured.
“You got that right,” you said as you both heaved in breath after breath. You looked over to him, his face inches from yours. His eyes were closed. “You love me,” you stated. His eyes opened and found yours.
He also found the grin waiting beneath them. “Shut up,” he said in his familiar drawl, pushing you off of him and moving to rest beside you.
You chuckled at him, high on something you were entirely unfamiliar with—contentment. “Hard not to,” you said, the grin pushing through into your words.
“Oh, god,” he sighed. “I’ve made a monster.”
You laughed out loud. The morning pushed in through the windows around you, the sounds of Valentine reaching your ears. Despite your sleep-filled night, you were tired. Your head still throbbed, whether from being hungover or being fucked relentlessly, you weren’t sure. You didn’t care. You turned on your side and curled into Arthur, leaving the sheets beneath you. The sheen of sweat on your body made it too hot for them anyway. Within minutes, you were asleep.
That was what your day consisted of—sex and sleep. Arthur fell asleep beside you, but you were pleasantly awoken by his fingers exploring the space between your legs a few hours later. You couldn’t resist him—he was intoxicating before but downright overwhelming now that he was letting you have your way with him. For the second time that day, you had sex with him, but you let him fuck you from behind for good measure. He deserved it. You once again dozed after, but when you woke, the third time was different. The third time was caring. The third time consisted of him on top of you, tenderly pushing into you, holding your gaze. The third time, he made love to you. And it was all that you had been needing, all of the reassurance in the world that what he had spoken earlier was true—that he wouldn’t abandon you. And it wasn’t for his own conscience, but for you, for a love that he gave to you willingly, not expecting anything in return. But return it you did that very evening as the pair of you ate together in the saloon. As he looked to his plate oblivious to the world around him, you saw him for who he was and loved him for it, for not giving up on you.
“Arthur,” you said, making him look up at you with those breathtaking eyes. “I love you too.” And he smiled.
83 notes
·
View notes
Dust and Dirt
Here in Dust and Dirt!
In 2006, John Dominic Crossan and Marcus Borg published The Last Week. The book begins with an unforgettable image:
“Two processions entered Jerusalem on a spring day in the year 30. . . One was a peasant procession, the other an imperial procession. From the east, Jesus rode a donkey down the Mouth of Olives, cheered by his followers. . . On the opposite side of the city, from the west, Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor of Idumea, Judea, and Samaria, entered Jerusalem at the head of a column of imperial calvary and soldiers.
Jesus’s procession proclaimed the kingdom of God; Pilate’s proclaimed the power of empire.”
I’ve no idea how many thousands of sermons have been preached on this passage in the years since. In the last fifteen years, I’ve never not heard a Palm Sunday sermon allude to it, borrow the image, or quote it directly. The “two processions” have become nearly a commonplace in liturgical and liberal churches.
This year, I’ve wondered about the crowds watching the processions. Matthew depicts the throng cheering, waving branches, and singing hosanna. The author interlaced the Jesus procession with a prophecy from Zechariah. In the Hebrew scriptures, Zechariah envisioned a humble king who arrives in Jerusalem on a donkey and a colt. That king will end all war. No more chariots, warhorses, or battle-bows. This king commands peace.
Of course, Pontius Pilate wasn’t a king of peace. He commanded an army on behalf of Caesar. But he and that legion were there to keep the peace during the holy days of Passover — making sure the Jews caused no trouble for their Roman rulers. As his procession made its way to the city gate, most likely no one cheered him. The crowds hated and feared him.
Perhaps a few paid supporters were sent out to shout Ave Pilate — Hail Pilate — as he entered — to soothe his imperial ego. Maybe a few powerful people in Jerusalem actually approved of him, or wanted something from him, and shouted their praise. Chances are, however, the road to the west gate was relatively deserted as the Romans approached. The only sounds were the dreaded clomp, clomp of armored horses and chariot wheels traversing the cobblestones. Pilate, in regal splendor, probably wanted to be home in his seaside villa instead of here, with the unruly Jews.
Meanwhile, at the eastern gate, Jesus’ noisy supporters were crying out Hosanna! Save us! Please save us now! They weren’t asking for some sort of spiritual salvation, for a place in heaven, or for eternal life. They wanted to be saved from Pilate, from the legion entering the other gate, from Caesar, and that faux peace of Roman swords. They knew there was no Pax Romana, it was nothing but misery and death.
Hosanna Jesus! Free us, we pray you! Deliver us! Save us from Pilate and Caesar and the misery of Rome! Hosanna, hey sanna, sanna sanna ho! Now, Jesus, now!
There isn’t an ave or an alleluia to be heard. These branch-waving protesters were begging to be rescued from oppression and injustice, shouting for liberation from the forces of violence and death.
Palm Sunday has always confused me. When depicted as a jubilant crowd, it doesn’t make a lot of sense. But, if the crowd is understood as desperate subjects of a bloody empire, Palm Sunday comes into better focus. Why do they later turn on Jesus? Well, once the Roman soldiers enter the fray, and once their hoped-for savior is arrested, the reality of their situation sets in. No amount of hosannas can free Jesus from his Roman fate. But they could still save their own hides and hope for better when the next promising savior arrived. They didn’t really betray him. They did what fearful subjects of a brutal regime usually do — they capitulated to their overlords who had thousands of chariots, warhorses, and battle-bows at their command. The Romans essentially forced them into the imperial procession. By Friday, they weren’t begging Jesus for salvation; they were praying they could avoid being crucified with him.
We are frail people after all.
But Jesus will save them from violence and death — although not as anyone hoped or expected — by drinking Rome’s bloody cup. The journey to the anti-imperial kingdom will be marked by a cross. Palm Sunday is the first step along a way that will end with a stunning event in a cemetery garden.
And yet, even after the tomb: hosanna still sounds. In a week, we may shout our Easter Alleluias, but the truth is that our days cry out hosanna. Children and teachers die in pools of blood at school, homeless people lay in the dirt on the street, lies pervade and divide a desperate people, the rich steal everyone’s share, courts unwind decades of justice, and even a poisoned earth and sky rage against us. Pax Americana? We may have believed that once, subject to its deceptive promises. But the mask comes off and a faux peace makes itself known. A peace enforced by fear and violence, a peace of privilege and guns. Hosanna, Jesus, hosanna! Save us, NOW!
Honestly, I’m stricken by the bodies and blood, the price of empire. I’ve got no alleluias left. But I can wave my palm in protest, and I can still shout: Hosanna, hey hosanna, hosanna hosanna ho / Sanna, hey, sanna hosanna!
And that chorus is needed now more than ever. The road to the eastern gate beckons, opening to the commonwealth of God. Sing with me.
Two processions entered Jerusalem on that day. The same question, the same alternative, faces those who would be faithful to Jesus today.
"Which procession are we in? Which procession do we want to be in?
This is the question of Palm Sunday and of the week that is about to unfold."
— John Dominic Crossan and Marcus Borg, The Last Week.
We all are in the dust and dirt! Shed Your Fears! Hosanna in the Highest! See your brothers or sisters before you in the dirt, remember the day is coming for each of us to be dirt!
Let us talk to God, or anything with which we find union! Let us let go, feel the pain and exhaustion and take a chance on being loved, and in so doing remember the words of Dorothy Day: "In each person I find the Christ." Deo Gratias! Thanks be to God!
.
Fr. River Damien Sims sfw, D.Min, D.S.T,
P.O. Box 642656
San Francisco, CA 94164
www.temenos.org
415-305-2124
The Twenty Second Annual Stations of the Cross
"Our Haunting!"
April 7, 2023
Civic Center
Noon-2 p.m.
Food Provided By:
AUNT BARBARA’S KITCHEN
GOOD FRIDAY IRISH SODA BREAD BLITZ ON POLK STREET
in alliance with Fr. River Damien Sims of Temenos
https://www.temenos.org/
Please help support a Good Friday initiative. Fr. River Sims aims to serve 200 folks with Irish Soda
Bread, the food that supported many Irish during hard times. It’s in the spirit of community and
nurturing.
There’s a legend that when a cross is made in each loaf before baking, all the good fairies are released. We like to believe in that.
$15/loaf payable through www.temenos.org , pay pal, or Aunt Barbara’s Kitchen/Temenos Catholic Worker, P.O. Box 642656, San Francisco, CA 94164
Aunt Barbara’s Kitchen is a Cottage Food Operation from a home kitchen in Marin County.
The business started with $10 and Aunt Barbara’s great grandfather iron skillet with the intention to build
a business model that feeds the hungry and revenue that goes to youth in college. The owner volunteers
her time to this endeavor and takes no revenue for herself, at this time. She hopes to reshape the model
of what businesses can create for communities, especially our youth, to cultivate and showcase the
power of human investment. 415 717 0151 https://barbaramcveigh.com/aunt-barbaras-kitchen/
1 note
·
View note