#mbav 'what if' scenarios

[agaypanic]

Can I request how the mbav characters would react id reader bit them and turned them? (with consent ofc)

Turning The MBAV Characters Headcanons

Masterlist

Request Something!

A/N: the scenario for these headcanons is that the characters asked to be turned, it’s not like a life or death situation like i did in that one rory fic. For their headcanons/scenarios, imagine that erica and rory got turned by you instead of jesse's cult

***

Benny

Would probably be so stoked about it

He’s a wizard and a vampire ???

Thinks he’s the coolest mf ever now

“This is so cool,” Benny said, staring in the mirror at his lack of reflection. He waved his hand around in front of him, but the mirror showed no evidence of him being there.

“Glad you think so.” You say, silently laughing at your boyfriend’s antics.

“Hey!” Benny exclaimed, whipping around to look at you. “Do you think if I got scratched by a werewolf, I’d become, like, the ultimate supernatural creature?”

“I dunno.” You answer. “And frankly, I don’t really wanna find out. I think being a vampire wizard is enough for you, Bens.”

Benny pouted, looking back at the mirror.

“You know what sucks?” He asked, and you started to panic internally. You hoped Benny wasn’t having reservations or regrets about this, because there was no going back.

“What?”

“I’m gonna be young and hot forever now, and I can’t even look at myself.”

Rory

If you thought Rory was excitable and hyperactive before, oh boy

Sometimes, you regret turning him because he’s not very secretive about his new identity and activities

But he’s so happy and optimistic that you forget all your worries

Teaching him how to feed at first was a bit funny

“You got your squirrel?” You ask, looking at your boyfriend.

“Yeah.” He responded, looking at the furry creature.

“Okay, now sink your teeth in and drink.” You instruct, doing it first as an example. Rory watched you with both fascination and disgust.

“Gnarly.” He muttered to himself. After taking a deep breath, he copied your actions. When you were both done feeding, he took his mouth off the blood source and started to spit. “Gross!”

“What?” You looked at him, confused. “Rory, the blood’s supposed to taste good.”

“It does, but now I have fur in my mouth!”

Ethan

Ethan being Ethan, I feel like he’d be having a crisis the entire time

Both before and after the turning

It takes a lot of thinking and convincing for him to agree to it

And then afterward, he doesn’t necessarily regret it, but it takes a while for him to calm down

“Oh my god,” Ethan muttered, feeling his fangs with his fingers. All of his senses were heightened; he felt so different. “Oh my god.”

“How are you feeling?” You asked worriedly, laying a gentle hand on your boyfriend’s shoulder in hopes of grounding him.

“Different.” He answered, still tracing the points of his teeth.

“Good different or bad different?”

“Well… on the one hand, I’m pretty much invincible now, which is cool. And we’ll never have to worry about me getting older than you, or me dying. I’ll live forever.” Ethan nodded along with his reasons, before his eyes widened in realization. “But on the other hand, I’m gonna live forever! That’s, like, a really long time!”

“Okay, okay, okay.” You grabbed Ethan by the shoulders, making him face you. “That may be true, but we can take it one day at a time.”

Ethan nodded, seeming to calm down a bit. But then another thought crossed his mind.

“What if blood is gross?!”

“Oh my god, Ethan.”

Erica

Being the biggest Dusk fan, she immediately said yes when you suggested it

After she turned and realized she didn’t need glasses and had gotten more attractive, she was ecstatic

Her ego and confidence went through the roof

But you’re the only one allowed to even think about her pre-vampire self

“What are you nerds doing?” Erica asked as you approached Benny and Rory, who were dressed like they were about to go on a safari.

“We’re gonna go hunt vampires,” Rory answered excitedly. He looked like he was about to elaborate, but Benny interrupted him.

“Don’t call us nerds.” He said to Erica, rolling his eyes. “Before you were a smoking hot vampire, you were a mega nerd, remember?”

Erica hissed and bared her fangs at Benny, making him jump back in his seat in surprise. But she grabbed his shoulder so he couldn’t get away.

“Remind anyone of that again, and you’re toast.”

“Got it,” Benny said with an even but stiff tone. Erica grinned.

“Good.” When she let go of Benny and turned back to you, her fangs and yellow eyes were gone. “Come on, Y/n.”

You walked away from Benny and Rory, hand in hand. Out of earshot of anyone around, you looked up at Erica with a fond smile.

“I remember when you were a mega nerd,” you said, giggling as she huffed. “You were a cute nerd.”

“Shut up,” Erica said, rolling her eyes. But you managed to catch a glimpse of her small smile.

***

Benny Weir Taglist: @batmandallyboy

[bubblegumvolcano]

barbie sleepover ♡ everyone is welcome!

anon-safe! join if you can, i'd love to have you here ♡ (yes, i did this already but im bringing it back!)

CLOSED! Sorry if I didn't get to you!

(💎) explain your style & personality to me and i’ll assign you a barbie doll, character & movie!

(🎀) give me an album and i’ll rank the songs from worst to best

(🍥) give me a short scenario w/ a character and i’ll give you five songs to think about it to

(🧁) ships! just tell me what movie/show, your sexual preference, and some of your main traits (personality & looks both count) ! (check below the post to see shows/movies I can do!)

(🧊)  tell me your personality and i’ll tell you what movie in general you should watch!

(🌷)  tell me your personality and i’ll assign you a celebrity/character!

(🍨) give me a character and/or scenario and i’ll assign a good specific chunk of a song to it.

( 🐬 ) blurbs! give me a character and a prompt/scenario and I'll write something short about it! pls keep in mind I cannot do all of these but I'll do my best. :)

*please check under this text to see which shows/movies I can ship you within and/or write about*;

╰┈➤ barbie!

╰┈➤ harry potter (all eras)

╰┈➤ stranger things

╰┈➤ marvel in general

╰┈➤ mbav

╰┈➤ victorious

╰┈➤ bullet train

╰┈➤ gilmore girls

╰┈➤ twilight

╰┈➤ ahs

╰┈➤ monster high

[mysticmoondancer]

What if Ethan had developed a really bad fear of Jesse due to being so traumatized after what happened at the dance that he can’t stand to be in the same room as him or starts to freak out at the sight of him? Which isn’t easy considering now Jesse wants to be a good guy (or at least a somewhat better version of himself), so he starts hanging out with the gang (who have all forgiven him for his past evil deeds). You know, as friends. But it’s like...hard on Jesse every time he sees Ethan so terrified of him now, all because of what happened at the dance. And like...he really wants to make amends with Ethan and be friends.

And maybe later on, Ethan eventually is able to get over his trauma of that night and actually start to warm up to Jesse just a bit and the two start to become friends.

[bookworm-called-bear]

Okay like 0 people interact with me but can one(1) person tell me if they want to hear more about Ocs from books I’m writing(I.e. Elvi Romania, The dead family, the ghost hunters, the assasian crew) or Ocs from media ( ie. Eris Ruewen, Alice Quinzel, Juliet Winchester, Rylee Hood, Nylia Adams). Also, what do you want to hear about them (interests, backstory, scenarios, relationships, what their life is like, chaotic moments, headcannons/little things?)

Fandoms with Ocs

KOTLC

DC

Marvel

Supernatural

Teen wolf

Monster high

Ever after high

H2O just add water

The gifted(marvel)

Marvel runaways

Harry Potter

TVD

Twilight

The Darkest Minds

ATLA

MBAV

Ect

Original books

Shadows still living

Don’t get blood in my dress

Chasing stories

Graveyard Housing

Love Letters and Tiny Fortune tellers

Dancing in the dark

Margaritas and knives

Find me on the dark side

Tower Bound

Queen of sapphire seas

Bandaged bulletholes

What is truly evil?

Memoirs of a looser.

[readbyred]

Do I have a ton of matchups in drafts? Yes. But I'm feeling sick and am wrapped in two blankets while everyone is outside enjoying the sun so guess what, gang?

🍰𝐌𝐈𝐍𝐈 𝐌𝐀𝐓𝐂𝐇𝐔𝐏𝐒

🍰𝐒𝐄𝐍𝐃 𝐌𝐄

🥄one thing to make someone fall in love with you

🥄one thing to make someone hate you

🥄some pictures that have your vibe [optional]

🥄[🍰] if romantic

🥄[🥄] if platonic

🍰𝐘𝐎𝐔‘𝐋𝐋 𝐆𝐄𝐓

🥄One character from a chosen fandom

🥄A short explanation why I chose them and/or a few cute scenarios together

🍰𝐖𝐇𝐄𝐍 𝐑𝐄𝐐𝐔𝐄𝐒𝐓𝐈𝐍𝐆

->𝐬𝐞𝐧𝐝 𝐭𝐨

🥄my inbox

🥄private chat [if you want to be anonymous when sending photos]

->𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐤 𝐚 𝐟𝐚𝐧𝐝𝐨𝐦

🥄dps

🥄lsoh

🥄hp

🥄it

🥄random books I read [mystery matchup]

🥄starkid shows

🥄mbav

[taosaf]

what do you think happened to after the lucifractor exploded? and how would you set up the beginning of s3 for mbav?

i have many theories but i’m not sure which one i think most so here a vague list

-benny stops the blast, killing himself in the process

-sarah and jesse run ethan and benny as far away as possible, and die in the process

-ethan convinces sarah and jesse to run, and they all end up safe (though with some bumps and bruises)

-the lucifractor somehow doesn’t kill everyone but stern was working for someone and that’s what season three is about

-they don’t do anything and all die in the blast

in all of these scenarios i’d start it with a funeral, for whoever died in whichever theory, in the case of no one dying it’s some random old guy and benny makes some joke about death bcs he was old and ethan reprimands him in a throwaway scene before the season actually starts

[bubblegumvolcano]

sleepover ♡ everyone is welcome!

CLOSED!

anon-safe! join if you can, i'd love to have you here ♡

(💎) explain your style & personality to me and i’ll assign you a barbie doll, character & movie!

(🎀) give me an album and i’ll rank the songs from worst to best

(🍥) give me a short scenario w/ a character and i’ll give you five songs to think about it to

(🧁) ships! just tell me what movie/show, your sexual preference, and some of your main traits (personality & looks both count) ! (check below the post to see shows/movies I can do!)

(🧊)  tell me your personality and i’ll tell you what movie in general you should watch!

(🌷)  tell me your personality and i’ll assign you a celebrity/character!

(🍨) give me a character and/or scenario and i’ll assign a good specific chunk of a song to it.

( 🐬 ) blurbs! give me a character and a prompt/scenario and I'll write something short about it! pls keep in mind I cannot do all of these but I'll do my best. :)

*please check under this text to see which shows/movies I can ship you within and/or write about*;

╰┈➤ harry potter (all eras)

╰┈➤ stranger things

╰┈➤ marvel in general

╰┈➤ mbav

╰┈➤ victorious

╰┈➤ bullet train

╰┈➤ gilmore girls

╰┈➤ twilight

╰┈➤ ahs

╰┈➤ monster high

[mysticmoondancer]

What if right after the events of Smells Like Trouble happen that Erica realizes that maybe she actually DOES have feelings for Benny, after all?! Which is why she went after him while under the love potion’s effect and not Ethan. Of course, that doesn’t explain why some of the other girls in school went all goo-goo eyes for him as well rather than Ethan, though. But we’ll just ignore that little detail for now, though. *giggles* 🤭😜 But I mean, come on! Sarah was immediately drawn and attracted to Ethan when she was under the love potion’s effect and yet later on in season two we actually start to see that she really does have some feelings for Ethan, after all. So, why not the same with Erica with Benny?! 🤷‍♀️😊

Can you imagine?! Erica starting to freak out over this major revelation in her life and not knowing what to do about it, either?! She’d have a panic attack followed by denial, grief, and confusion until finally she accepts it. Lol! 😂

[mysticmoondancer]

What if instead of using his magic to turn Ethan back into a human again after being turned into a frog/toad by his mom in “Halloweird”, Benny just kissed him to break the spell?

(Benny)😚 + (Ethan)🐸 = (Bethan)👨‍❤️‍👨