#pirate poll

[tidesreach]

"black sails fans are so mean" "this is a reign of censorship and fear" yeah well everyone is a monster to someone since you are so convinced that i am yours i will be it

[thatlittlesentientfox]

Time for some chaos

(couple more pics ‘cause both outfits are fire)

[jaskierx]

ofmd related disaster polls 🏴‍☠️💥 grand finale

[chocolatepot]

Friends. A poll.

You know what you must do.

[demisilver]

this is what queer infighting leads to

[v333nus-demilo]

pirate poll🏴‍☠️

this is a poll designed to cause a civil war in the black sails fandom inspired by another textpost i saw. choose between flint and silver. i am not providing any criteria. i expect bloodshed and will not do anything to stop it. go have fun🗡️🗡️🗡️

[dracothelizard]

For the sake of convenience, you're US-American if you identify as one, regardless of where you live now.

(Also yes it hurts me a bit too to lump all of us non-US people together but again, convenience.)

[howlerbat]

Time for a hyper-specific pirate poll

[enderspawn]

DO YOUR CIVIC DUTY!

[tidesreach]

absolutely love that the pirate poll drama has inadvertently caused a black sails renaissance of sorts like there are now a bunch of people watching it for the first time so truly tumblr user pirate-battle

[runawaymarbles]

truly it’s inspiring to see the black sails fandom come together again... temporarily setting aside old grudges (the Flint/Anne Gay vs Bi schism, Silver v. Flint [2017],) to agree that at the end of the day and despite all that divided us six years ago that we’ve mostly forgotten about except for when we realize someone still has us blocked on tumblr dot com, Flint is still thee character of all time.

[jaskierx]

‘ofmd fans are so cringe and annoying’ i type after writing a short essay in the tags about how everyone who voted against stucky in the poll should die immediately (i’m allergic to self awareness and i’ve never been outside before)

[chocolatepot]

Since the beginning?!?! For a ship from the 2010s?

[jellybeanium124]

Stede, Ed, and Jim have been left off this poll due to having their backstories explained in season 1 (although I would love more!)

[pirate-deathmatch]

Round 2 Starboard: Anne Bonny (Black Sails) vs Charles Vane (Black Sails)

We never saw them fight in canon, but they probably considered it at least four or five times. Both solve problems with murder. Anne once killed a man with a broken piece of glass. Vane once killed a man with a pointy stick. Anne's got a cool hat. Vane's belt is truly impractical.

The pirates MAY use any special skills or equipment they possess. They may NOT call on any friends or creatures to assist them. For the sake of this tournament, all pirates CAN be killed and cannot come back to life during the fight. Reblog to throw a vegetable at the opponent. Deathmatch masterpost here.