#tma navigation
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Master List by year
2022 and 2023 Master list (mostly one piece content)
2024 Master list
Updated: 1/25/24
List of Up-and-coming works || Master list (here🔴) || Twitter
Support me on Kofi and Patreon
88 notes
·
View notes
Text
Wrt LRB sometimes I'm so baffled by what people bother to ask me because my charitable assumption will be an image in my mind of the results of a search query using keywords in that question and what failures may have occurred in the transfer of information and I'll start talking like "What did you search for this? When I used [keywords] the results seemed pretty self-explanatory." Or like idk. Baseline I'll assume they've read some Bullshit that comes up when u search something. There are multiple things in this world if you use the most self-evident english search queries for you will just get misinformation. So maybe then I'll start talking as to counter those points instead and they're sooo lost and I'm like ??? and they're like I didn't bother to look it up I didn't search for any texts on this subject. And I'm like. How the fuck can you expect me to have a conversation about this then? We have to like. Have a baseline of implicit assumptions of understanding to talk about this how do you not CARE about that???
#Or like I'll assume if someone is asking me something subjective it's coz they reasonably assumed searching would be futile#& they're ok w being subject to niche/personalized information like. That is their query when asking Me in a sense given the alternative.#AND THIS ASSUMPTION DOESN'T HOLD? WHY DOESN'T IT HOLD. WHY WOULD YOU ASK ME SOMETHING KNOWING WHO I AM AND HOW I PROCESS THINGS#SOMETHING WHICH CAN BE EASILY SYNTHESIZED FROM THE FIRST 3 SEARCH RESULTS IN A STANDARD QUERY#Like idk people treat me like such an idiot sometimes too coz I'll ask things that Can Be Searched but a lot of the times I did search it#And I just couldn't synthesize the information.#Which from a stranger is like ok you think I'm a garden variety idiot whatever there are so many ways to be assumed that that I rly can't#navigate at all like. It's so hard for me to conceptualize what is a given btwn strangers. But when people who KNOW ME treat me like an#idiot for that it's like AM I FUCKING CRAZY FOR ADJUSTING THE RESPONSES I GIVE TO HUMAN INTERACTION BASED ON WHO THE OTHER PERSON IS?#Also I'm still mad abt the interaction I had here on tumblr where someone was replying 'what does TMA mean' when like.#You should have the skill of getting the context clues to format a specific search query!! If you look up 'TMA transmisogyny'#then you do get people bullshitting and being chuds but they do explain what the acronym stands for. Plainly. So then you adjust the query#you use on the human. Like. A better question would be 'I looked up what TMA means and now I know the acronym. But these explanations seem#like shit. Do you have anything on hand that explains it better?'#and i tried to explain that in absence of this skill they're wasting ppls esp marginalized ppls time and energy n they standpoint#epistemology'd at me about it WHICH DOESN'T EVEN MAKE SENSE COZ THEY DIDN'T KNOW ENOUGH ABT THE SUBJECT TO HAVE A STANCE ANYWAY#AM I WEIRDO FREAK FOR SYSTEMIZING SHIT LIKE THIS IT SEEMS OBVIOUS TO ME#am i fucked up and weird for thinking it's a good idea to have texts on-hand that explain concepts that searches fail.#~
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
i will be honest. if you water down the whole concept of the terms TMA vs TME as 'penis havers vs vagina havers' all it shows is that you fundamentally misunderstand each of these terms.
#there are trans women with vaginas and both cis and trans TME folks with penises#it sounds to me like you are using your own marginalization to discredit the language transfems use to describe navigating transmisogyny.#like i understand how you could interpret it as another binary.#but saying that the terms TMA and TME are enforcing a gender binary is like saying that 'queer' and 'non-queer' are enforcing a binary.#no!!!! they are just used to describe how someone might navigate specific systems of discrimination!!!!!#turning off rbs bc i'm not trying to start an internet argument but. Good Lord.#cedar speaks#edit: rbs are on but if anyone says anything nasty i'm blocking em
28 notes
·
View notes
Text
Unsolicited horror prompt from my nightmare the other night: one of those time loops that resets when the main victim dies but instead of some sort of apocalypse or horrific accident it's a teen who's got a terminal illness or a heart attack that's about to happen or something. The amount of time after the loop starts before he dies varies from an hour to a week. There are a few other people (his best friend and his english teacher for some reason) who are also stuck in/aware of the loop and they're all trying to break it but how do you find a cure for cancer (or whatever it is) and save your friend with only three days on average before everything resets? And then there's the lingering question of whether his recovery will actually break the loop, or only prolong it until he dies from something else? And why are they the ones stuck in the loop and not others?
#TMA End entity type nightmare I tell you#ask to tag#tw death#nightmares#In the dream there was also something weirdly significant about the loop victims navigating a grocery store#The nature of what was killing the guy was unclear. He was coughing a lot but not like bed bound or in the hospital#(At least not at the loop's start)#clearing out my drafts
8 notes
·
View notes
Note
Hey sorry to ask, but am I tripping or is some of your Redbubble stuff removed?
(Also can I be wheat anon? )
i did private my tma stuff on redbubble! i dont use twitter or many other social media so i was unaware that they are apparently vehemently against people selling fanart for tma, i was just naively thinking well if they had an issue with an art piece theyd ask me to take it down (& i 100% would, of course) but if its something theyr outspoken about then I cant in good conscience continue selling it, even if it was my main seller on there 😔
(you absolutely can🌾)
#once again being a grandpa thats bad at social media has come to bite me in the ass 😭😭#i saw many other people listing tma art for sale & just naively assumed that meant it wasnt something they really cared abt ya know?#talked with several people lately abt the ethics of selling fanart & this came up#in regards to mech fanart#i will leave it up for now since coming from a bandmember we have a tacit ‘we just look the other way’ sort of approval#but knowing that i was going against something they care about so strongly didnt sit right so 😔#RIP to my paycheck but you gotta put ur money where your mouth is#selling fanart is always such a grey area it’s complicated to navigate#asks#sorry if i articulated this poorly
51 notes
·
View notes
Text
I mostly haven't been posting anything because I was on vacation (which was fun!!), but also ngl I think I'm getting burnt out by forcing myself to work on only longfics again...
I have A Stitch In Time (my in-progress TMA longfic), which I AM running out of prewritten chapters for much faster than I'm writing new ones, but at the same time nobody's going to be mad at me for going on hiatus?? like what am I actually worrying about dskkdh
and then there's also an ATLA fic I started in 2020 on my old ao3 account that I keep swearing I'm going to finish (and I AM going to, it's just taking. so long.)
anyways, my point is both of those are longfics, which is burning me out. what I need to do is write something else short and sweet... I have one more week of break before college restarts, and I'm determined to make the most of it!!!
#my post#help idk what to tag vague stuff like this dskjgkdshf#uhh#ramblings#a stitch in time#oh yeah I guess for current and future tag navigation within my own blog:#the magnus archives#tma#avatar the last airbender#atla#those last two tags are kind of useless to anyone else right now#considering the atla fic is currently almost completely unconnected to my current account fdkjgsfd#it will be when I finish writing it though#and then I'll thank past me for tagging this post as such haha
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
I can't be the only one who thinks S5 of TMA can best be told with "Navigating" by Twenty One Pilots, right???? Right????? Or even just have it be a Jonathan Sims, Head Archivist of the Magnus Institute song???
I spoiler because omg i'm gonna go rant mode and you should have a barrier.
Obvious spoilers for MAG 160 ~ MAG 200 (The Magnus Archives).
Like just give me a moment to cook. Jmart POV, starts with reflections of Martin in the Lonely ("the haze around my face / makes me feel so alone") OR its to show Jon's thoughts post-Door Open.
"I know you see me standing still / When our fingers touch, I feel my way back home"
This the most MAG 161 & MAG 162 coded shit in history. Martin being the one to act as 'home' as they move from the cabin.
First chorus is just them going through the first set of domains, with 'give me some advice' happening during the Not!Sasha smiting. Maybe there's some flashes of the real Sasha in there, who knows.
"Don't know how long it's been / My, oh my / How things change so rapidly / I find my self-esteem / Then turn so cold"
MAG 166 ~ MAG187 pipeline.
Chorus 2 is the ways to the other domains, eventually ending in the Panopticon.
"Don't know how long it's been / Since I responded to your question / If you really wanna know what I'm thinking"
Annabelle and Hill Top scene. I take my seat.
"Kind of feels like everybody leaves / Feeling the reality that everybody leaves / My dad just lost his mom, I think that everybody leaves / And I'm trying to hold onto you / 'Cause everybody leaves"
YOU CANNOT TELL ME THIS ISN'T THE PRE-JONAH STAB CONVO IN A NUTSHELL. YOU CANNOT DELUDE ME AWAY FROM THIS IM DYING ON THIS HILL-
Second-to-last chorus is the Jonah erasure stuff lol
AND THE FINAL LENGTH OF THE SONG, IS JUST MAG 200 TEARING US TO PIECES WITH INTERLACED FLASHBACKS ENDING WITH A BLACK SCREEN TO RUIN US EMOTIONALLY.
So anyway have fun with this torture :3
#twenty øne piløts#twenty one pilots#the magnus archives#tma#tma season 5#the eye lady is sobbing with her eyes#i refuse to believe Navigating isn't a Jon song#It just suits him so well
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Magnus Archives
Song of the Hive: regressor!Jane Prentiss horror story general magnus archives regression headcanons regressor!sasha headcanons regressor!michael shelley headcanons w caregiver!distortion caregiver!annabelle headcanonsBONUS: Entities and Age Regression brief cg!elias headcanons from ask game
regressor!jon art (and again!) regressor!nikola moodboard regressor!julia montauk being feral art regressors!jon and martin art regressor!martin art regressor!jon moodboard: first moodboard ever made for this blog! caregiver!elias moodboard
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
Late 2022 and 2023 Master List archive
I'm going to do it month by month, hopefully it won't break at a later date.
November 2022
December 2022
January 2023
February 2023
March 2023 (was on hiatus)
April 2023
May 2023
June 2023
July 2023
August 2023
September 2023
October 2023
November 2023
December 2023 (no posts, I got sad)
Updated: 1/25/24
List of Up-and-coming works || Master list || Twitter
Support me on Kofi and Patreon
#tma original#tma master list#tma masterlist#tma navigation#2022 master list archive#2023 master list archive
100 notes
·
View notes
Text
I just discovered that I can log in to my spotify account in browser on PC. Furthermore, I discovered that once there, I can drag-and-drop episodes from podcasts straight to playlists, instead of tap-tap-tap-tap-tap-tap-tap-tap-tap-tap-ing two thousand times like in the phone app. Long story short, I have some playlists now.
#the magnus archives#and protocol too I guess#Spotify#can't be a pain to use#being able to use a mouse to navigate it helps a lot#and now I have a way to find episode I want without slogging through nearly 300 entries in TMA podcast list#:D#happy little discoveries#playlists#are friends#(not food)
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Magnus Archives Masterlist

✰ Daisy Tonner
Dreams of the Hunt
↪ Summary: Violence follows your love like a hunting dog, nipping at her heels
↪ Tags: monsters in love, established relationship, gender neutral reader, canon-typical horror
✰ Jane Prentiss
Swear I'm Better (Miss Parasite Possessor)
↪ Summary: There is a woman outside your door.
↪ Tags: canon-typical corruption content, horror, self-mutilation, not really romantic but not not romantic, gender neutral reader

0 notes
Note
how scary is the silt verses? i want to get into it bc you're saying so much good stuff about it, but i had to stop listening to the magnus archives because it was keeping me up at night :(
hmmmmmmmmmmm I have to think about this a little bit, because scariness in podcasts doesn't bother me much so it's entirely possible for there to be Some Great Horror I'm just not thinking of.
Relative to TMA! I'd say The Silt Verses horror elements are less frequent than TMA, considering the TMA format is to tell One Fucked Up Story every single episode. The Silt Verses does not have that format so it can go episodes at a time digging through the narrative.
But it does have horrific things that pop up which could belong to a TMA episode. A Deer That's Wrong, fishermen sewn together into a fucked-up boat thing, whatever body-horror Val does to people. I do think the flavor is different from TMA. A lot of those TMA horrors are from the perspective of normal civilians, unwillingly subjected to A Horror. In TSV, most everyone encountering The Horrors is ready to start punching. But still like... The Horrors ARE very much there, and part of it.
Though, there is a flavor of horror in TSV which I don't think is very prevalent in TMA, which is this "you're about to be killed and everyone in society is okay with this, actually" style of horror. There's a plot point where a company which is, essentially, going through lay-offs, is allowed to kill the people they're letting go as part of a sacrifice. And the POV character (who is not being laid off) is experiencing this whole thing going "this surely can't be right. they surely can't?" But they do, and she's complicit.
So... yes...! TSV is scary! But it's a kind of scary which is more baked into the society the characters are navigating, vs. the TMA-style "spend every episode one a different Horror Incident that happened"
152 notes
·
View notes
Text
jon: ultimately i think the impact of colonialism on the subcontinent stretches beyond merely the material aspect of pillaging wealth but we do nevertheless have to accept responsibility for the actions of our people since 1950 with regards to the construction of a national image built upon the bones of minorities
basira: youre only saying that because youre hooking up with a white boy you can’t separate the current trend of nationalism in south asian politics from the colonial mechanism of keeping pro-western elites in power by subjugating the masses ultimately that evil in our society is still the fault of colonialism
jon: and youre a cop whos hooking up with a white girl whose also a cop i never said those two werent linked. also i know everything like youre literally wrong
basira: youre only saying that because i’m muslim and you disagree with my vision of a postcolonial south asia that can find peace through the return of our traditional ways of life
jon: well i’m christian by that logic i don’t fit in to any image of south asia whether historic or modern so surely my call for accountability is worth more than your call for tradition
basira: youre christian and so the colonial era power structure inherently benefitted you and youre calling for accountability from people who werent able to abuse it as much as you were
jon: youre simplifying the entire history of the subcontinent to suit your own agenda and avoid blame for issues that you’ve contributed to
basira: you’re avoiding accountability for abuses of power that you were complicit in by shifting the blame on the groups of people you profited off of
he throws a tape recorder at her. they were both born and raised in england and have been to india and bangladesh respectively a collective four times in their entire lives
i’m probably overthinking this because i’m incredibly ill right now but i do genuinely think slapping the ‘south asian’ lens over jon and basira in particular does a lot to enrich their characters and experiences throughout the podcast especially when one considers the inherently voyeuristic nature of asian culture (log kya kahenge etc) and why jon might succumb to it versus basira staying immune to et cetera et cetera it but its also just really funny because south asians are already the most hypocritical insufferable pendantic self-hating group of people on the planet imagine the infighting coupled with eldritch know it all powers. jon makes dosa and calls it dosa and basira says actually its not dosa dosa is stuffed and jon throws it at her and they have to physically be separated for the rest of the week
#tma#im so ill this makes no sense but do u see my vision#yes this is also a thinly veiled analogy for how the two of them actually go about navigating accountability and power in the podcast itsel#its worse when tim and melanie get locked in sger hker wasian beef btw
39 notes
·
View notes
Text
⋆˚࿔⋆。 ゚ ☁︎。 ⋆。little navigation post!! ฅᨐฅ✧。 ⋆。 ゚ ☾ ゚ 。 ⋆
°⋆.ೃ࿔*''knee-deep in the water" comic tags! ⋆౨ৎ˚⟡˖ ࣪
comic pages and aaaall of the art + sketches!
salamath - "mother said im allowed to have this 2 knives"
shas-hara - big bird with a reputation of hunting people for sport
narine - keeps dodging bullets but would prefer to catch them with a head a couple of times
kuyan - avoided responsibilities by pretending to be dead (surprise, it works)
ayasha - can successfully sell winter jacket in +40C
sino - emo boi who couldnt be fixed
ketla - "bi" in "bipolar"
tiisha - "please lord im only 7" (1/2 main character!)
yata - winks at you but only when you cant notice (2/2 main character!)
°⋆.ೃ࿔*:little faq + about the blog + fanart tags! °❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:
₍⑅ᐢ..ᐢ₎ so, what im doing here?
im working on the ࣪ ִֶָ☾. knee-deep in the water˚ ೀ⋆。˚ comic!!
oc characters you can find in this blog are mostly all from there, and if not - they are tagged by related fandom!
₍ ᐢ. ̫ .ᐢ ₎ how's the drawing process for comic going?
by now i finished half of chapter one, and finished the intro! as soon as it is done i'll start to post pages here and on the dedicated site once-twice a week! script is already almost finished too!
₍ ᐢ. ̫ .⑅ᐢ ₎ do i still make fanart?
yes of course, just less often than before!
i was most active in bg3, tes, elden ring, dishonored and tma fandoms, but now im head and shoulders deep in datv!!
₍ᐢ › ̫ ‹ ᐢ₎ do i take commissions?
almost throughout the whole year! so feel free to send an email on [email protected] - there's 100% chance i'll be free and able to work with you!
₍ᐢ. ̫.ᐢ₎ where can you see commission information?
on my carrrd!
૮₍'˶· . • ⑅ ₎ა am i open to work on an art trade?
yes!!
♡꒰ᵕ༚ᵕ⑅꒱ can i do drawings from ask-prompts?
very rarely, when im in the mood!
₍ᐢ. ༝ .ᐢ₎ do i make speedpaints?
even more rarely than prompts, but you can find some in the tags!
₍ᵔ.˛.ᵔ₎ what software do i use? which brushes?
photoshop 2020 + kyle t. webster dry media brushes!
₍ᐢ._.ᐢ₎♡༘ do i sell prints?
nope! im that boring zero-waste person + i live in a country where most related us/european sites are blocked or simply not working without paypal!
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・a little about the artist thingy! °❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・
if you'd want to support my work - i have boosty (and soon hopefully gonna have a patreon!) where i post speedpaints, early access to pages, sketches and all that!
thank you so much for reading and please dont hesitate to ask stuff if you'll have any questions! ♡
337 notes
·
View notes
Text
"Reflections unto a Mirror"
I'm gonna be brave and do an Oc reveal for my TMA AUs. This OC hasn't appeared or been mentioned in any of my AO3 fics (and probably won't for a bit), but she's extremely relevant to it all.
Introducing... "Ani", the Memory-Impaired (Interim) Head Archivist of the Magnus Institute (as of 2016)!
Introduction
"Ani" (the only name she remembers) quite literally appears in the Dalton household out of nowhere one sunny January, just a week after the People's Church of the Divine Host tried to complete their Extinguished Sun ritual. Despite this, she only has a marking of The End from her exposure to the Dalton stronghold, and an unknown Marking that not even Simone can decipher.
Very few things are gleaned from trying to Compel her, amongst those being that she's Australian, she thinks she's either 21 or 23 and, of course, her assumed name. Everything else she is forced to discover over her year-and-a-half apprenticeship under Archivist Quinn, and afterwards when she is forced to assume the Interim position due to lack of willingness from her co-workers.
(More info under the read more, I get my message is big lol)
Paths
"Ani" falls to The Eye as a result of her persistent internal voice nagging her that she has forgotten something extremely important, and her fears that the reason she has no memories now is because someone entrusted her with a dangerous piece of knowledge. It also triggers due to [Spoilers], but we're focusing on the main reason. Her abilities are mostly focused around finding the truth to a situation or to expand her understanding, giving her...
Statement Syncing/Taking (typical)
Compulsion
Knowing (+Translation)
Telekinesis/Levitation (learnt)
Dream Walking (learnt).
Her Spiral sub-path - the only one not granted via a weapon or Leitner - comes to her as naturally as breathing once she meets and makes a few deals with The Distortion (wearing the face of Emma Harvey), granting her...
Impossible Navigation (cannot get lost in domains lmao)
Short-Range Teleportation (learnt)
"Song of the Soul"
A term coined by Edalyn Gleave prior to her death, it stands for 'a song that you would live and die to, a song that fuels your every move when you cannot move anymore'. Hunters trained under Edalyn were typically ones posed this question, but the Institute begun taking up the idea too when the Thundering Strings started getting too confident.
"Ani" claimed her song was "Navigating" by Twenty One Pilots, but the song does not exist (yet). Thus, she hunts for a new song, and eventually finds herself resonating close enough with "What My Scene?" by Hoodoo Gurus due to her unfamiliarity with her place in the world, and her desperation to clutch to her homeland and its music.
"Try" by P!nk does seem familiarly powerful to her, but she can never bring herself to call it her "Song of the Soul"... more 'the old tune to a life I used to lead' (no one prompted her so she forgot that line afterwards lol)
Other
Jesus I yap alot...
If you wish to see more of her or of others in her era of the Archives, please let me know! I do plan to do more eyes, but I also want to draw the people in my AO3 fics... maybe. We're trying. Simone's a high priority.
#tma au#tma aus#digital art#tma ocs#tma sona#(not really but she's close enough as the mc)#tma the eye#tma oc#tma oc art#tma the spiral#the spiral#the eye#Nikola and the Circus are punching the air because amnesiac with a deep fear of never knowing herself is such a pull#unfortunately the Daltons intervened#she kinda goes neutral with The Stranger tbh#Beholding is a very jealous lil guy tho all through it#Poor Martin (who exists in this as the Beholding's favourite) gets all the Beholdings vents about it#the eye lady is very nervous about this please be nice with any criticisms ty i shy#rip Navigating you didn't exist in 2015 ~ 2018#Mag-Ruin AU
6 notes
·
View notes
Note
Well in that case we can also argue that ''trans woman" fonctions as an umbrella gender characterized by a particular adversarial and oppositional relationship to patriarchy: transmisogyny produces trans womanhood, and afab trans women are certainly this.
''Trans woman'' is also an essentialist archetype that some trans women fail to met (e.g those born with a vulva, those who can bear children).
The social reality of the afab transfem can be similar to the one of (conventional) transfemininity if the afab person is perceived (and thus treated) as a transfem..so what about those people ? Aren't they functionally transfem ? Their lived material experience isn't transfem? However similarity can also arises from interesections between racialization, misogyny, or lesbianism, intersexuality, detransition etc, creating experiences that are functionally like or adjacent to trans womanhood. Some afabs can also be ''women by dint of being less than women'' and thus are transfems, this is not exclusive to amab transfems.
the crux of your problem is this sentence: "the social reality of the afab transfem can be similar to the one of (conventional) transfemininity if the afab person is perceived (and thus treated) as a trans fem"
this is the main justification I see being used for claims of transfemininity/trans womanhood/being tma by people who were cafab: people keep mistaking me for a tranny, and that makes me a tranny! this rests on a complete misunderstanding of the systemic nature of transmisogyny. being mistaken for a trans woman, even on the regular, does not put someone in the same totalizing relationship to hegemonic gender, for the simple reason that (as I have now said multiple times) the logic of transmisogyny operates thru birth assignment. the corrective violence of transmisogyny is applied specifically because betraying coercive assignment as male puts a person in a unique degenerate position as far as cisheteropatriarchy is concerned. someone who was cafab will always have their birth assignment as a shield against this, even if there are instances of mistaken identity where it cannot be used in time.
you may retort that sometimes the violence against someone who was cafab proceeds apace despite disclosure of this assignment—perhaps in the case of the cafab butch lesbian facing street violence (thinking of nearby versions of hannah gadsby's story in nannette), or the working class transmasc on T running up against discrimination at the workplace, or, famously, the case of woman athletes, generally Black and sometimes intersex as in the case of Caster Semenya, being banned from sports competitions (I imagine this is one of the examples you're alluding to when you mention intersections). but to equivocate this to transfemininity is itself violent erasure. you would be neglecting that in every case there is a difference between the person under discussion and someone against whom transmisogyny has set its whole machinery.
there are tma masc lesbians, there are working class transfems on T, there are Black trans women for whom participation in sport is yet more complicated. the realities of navigating the legal-medical-social apparatus of gender is multiplied in impossibility for all of them, because birth assignment is the charge laid by transmisogyny to condemn the trans woman. whatever intersection your "afab transfem" sits at, there will always be this difference between them and transfemininity. this is a difference that will be leveraged against the latter, not the former.
if you think you can reskin my argument as you have in this ask and maintain its fit to reality, then you understand neither misogyny nor transmisogyny. transmisogyny against the "afab transfem" is a mistake by the lights of hegemonic gender itself, to be amended (not necessarily into something harmless, but certainly into something different) upon the revelation of birth assignment. meanwhile the misogyny experienced by trans women (including closeted trans women, including the trans girl who does not even know why she is being treated thus!) does not happen by accident, but as part of the logic of (trans)misogyny itself, because trans women fail to be men despite their birth assignment and this demands punishment. there is not an escape-by-disclosure here. in other words, misogyny deliberately makes trans women women! there is no defense the trans woman can mount on the basis of birth assignment, because that is the very event against which her existence is measured.
this is not true of your imagined afab transfem, nor is any further punishment systemically levelled against the "afab transfem" because of their failing to meet the "essentialist archetype" of trans womanhood. on the contrary, the "afab transfem" remains asymmetrically empowered to use transmisogyny against the transfeminine. yes, cafab ppl are not exempt from violent transphobia, but this is not a violence predicated on the same gender-betrayal the transfeminine person embodies. the political distinction between these experiences remains.
a final point: you are correct that some cafabs can be "woman by dint of being less than woman" but I never claimed that this was a unique trait of transfemininity! in fact I made it clear that this is a common condition for many women (ableism, fatphobia, classism, etc. can all degender a woman). what is unique is the role the logic of transmisogyny plays in defining transfemininity, and the specific manner in which it underclasses the transfeminine subject—makes her the kind of person for whom only a certain, highly peripheralized form of existence is permissible.
if you are interested in describing the way the world is (hopefully with intent to change it) then this is not the way to go about that. any careful analysis of the power relations that cisheteropatriarchy uses to facilitate gender-classing in service of the division of labour will make this clear. you can argue whatever you want! you can also be wrong.
#ask answer#why cant i get fun asks instead of this#im answering these bc i think jt would be helpful to have like a library of resposnes dor the inevitable next time#but pls#if i wasnt so deprived of stimulation rn i would probably not be bothering yo answer#hopefully by the end of tomorrow my thumbs will haveba spacebarand moise to caress again
249 notes
·
View notes