comp titles challenge: practical magic meets the old west, suggested by @youareiron-andyouarestrong
two very different sisters living with their elderly aunts are their small town's local witches. they provide insight, charms, and a hex or two if you need. when one of the sisters gets involved with a man who treats her wrong, well, things have to be dealt with.
the town's new sheriff is awful interested not only the missing man, but those tonics the locals have. when he shows up at their door, one witch may find her heart black heart still beats.